# Sentencing Letters Submitted on Behalf of Nishad Singh (Exhibit A to the Sentencing Submission), part 14 of 19 (ECF pages 145 to 150) [Index](index.html) · [Whole document](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1.html) · [Web page](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-14.html) · Part 14 of 19. Parts: [1](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-1.html) [2](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-2.html) [3](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-3.html) [4](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-4.html) [5](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-5.html) [6](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-6.html) [7](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-7.html) [8](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-8.html) [9](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-9.html) [10](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-10.html) [11](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-11.html) [12](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-12.html) [13](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-13.html) 14 [15](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-15.html) [16](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-16.html) [17](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-17.html) [18](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-18.html) [19](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-19.html) · About this text version: at the end of this page **Contents** (added for navigation; not part of the document) - [Letter from Peter Buckley (High School Friend)] (ECF p. 145) - [Letter from Baylor Odabashian (Middle School Friend)] (ECF p. 147) - [Letter from Greg Etzbach (Elementary School Friend)] (ECF p. 150) --- [ECF p. 145] ### [Letter from Peter Buckley (High School Friend)] April 27, 2024 Dear Judge Kaplan, Thank you for the opportunity to write on behalf of Nishad. He’s been a good friend since high school, and I’m grateful for the chance to vouch for his character. I wholeheartedly believe that if you knew Nishad well you would know that he is worthy of compassion. No one who knows him would say any differently. With that in mind, here are some things that I think might help someone understand Nishad. There are some people for whom anyone who knows them, even acquaintances, will jump at the chance to say good things. Everyone knows one or two people like this. Nishad is one of those people. Nishad is notoriously humble. He will never be the one to play up his own accomplishments -- you will have to ask his friends and colleagues to find out he has some exceptional talents. He is an excellent drummer, and can frequently be found conducting intricate finger drumming performances on tables and desks. If you listen closely you may also hear him playing an imagined double bass drum on the floor. He is extremely kind towards animals and feels a personal responsibility to prevent their mistreatment. This comes from a deep instinct to be concerned for those who cannot voice their own concerns. He has been a vegetarian since middle school. When someone has particularly impressive deadpan humor I’ll often describe it as “almost Nishad-like” in delivery. Almost. Nobody else can get away with saying something as ridiculous as he can while I nod along for one beat, two beats, three beats – before clocking the joke as he finally cracks a smile. Nishad has on many occasions been the one to pull me aside and ask how I’m doing when I’m having a particularly bad day. He pays attention to the people around him and when he notices something is wrong he will feel it’s his responsibility to do something about it. I once went to briefly keep Nishad company while he ran a 100 mile race. After not very many miles, I was losing steam and told him to go on as I was beginning to slow him down. (At this point he had “only” been going for 30-odd miles.) He insisted on accompanying me to the next rest stop another mile ahead, chatting away while making sure I was at a comfortable pace. He dropped me off and with a wave accelerated to his normal speed. In the middle of one of the most physically challenging experiences I can imagine, his priority was making sure I felt welcome. I happened to be visiting Nishad and other friends in the Bahamas for vacation the week FTX declared bankruptcy. Finding myself in spaces with many of the employees, I saw dozens of different reactions: fear, anger, sadness, outright disbelief. From what I saw the person who took the situation the hardest was, by far, Nishad. He was deeply devastated, and clearly not because he had lost personal wealth or the fact that he might be in legal trouble. He felt terrible that all of the effort he had put into building a company that was meant to improve the world would instead cause pain, disappointment, and devastation. [ECF p. 146] *[This page of the PDF is an image. Its text was typed out from the image. The line in square brackets near the end is the letter’s own.]* I have no doubt that, then and now, he would give anything to undo what happened. I imagine you are reading many similar letters and ultimately I can only say: I too believe Nishad to be an unusually kind, caring person who would never intend to cause harm. It’s not who he is. Thank you for your consideration, Peter Buckley [Please redact the below from anything ending up in public record] For further information - [REDACTED] [ECF p. 147] ### [Letter from Baylor Odabashian (Middle School Friend)] **July 28th, 2024** Dear Judge Kaplan, I have known Nishad Singh since he was 13 years old. We have been Model United Nations delegates, bandmates, and close friends. I believe I have about as long a perspective on his personal development as anyone outside of his immediate family. Nishad is a patient, thoughtful, and kind young man—traits recognized by his FTX coworkers, who nicknamed him "the king of kindness." He's one of the last people I'd have expected to be involved in any kind of scandal, and I truly believe that, whether or not he’s offered any leniency, he will never again commit a crime. From the ages of 13-18, Nishad and I went to the same schools and attended Model United Nations conferences together, spending most lunches, and 3-4 long weekends away from home together in a paradise of minimal adult supervision. While other high schoolers were using their newfound freedom for the predictable wildness, Nishad and I were thrilled just to be able to stay up until 2 or 3 AM laughing and talking. In our state of exhaustion, we poured out our hearts to one another. This is what I saw of the young Nishad’s inner life and emerging worldview. Nishad had serious and practical concern not so much with how to appear virtuous as with how to actually be good. This extended beyond the ordinary scope of adolescent thoughtfulness—genuine laughter, a sympathetic ear, or an insightful mirroring of another teen’s woes (although these were offered generously)—and beyond the limits of teenage utopian thought. He empathized deeply with the suffering of our classmates, and people in war-torn countries around the world, and with animals living on factory farms. Tellingly, he cared enough about this last group to change his behavior three times a day – forever. He was a sincere and committed vegetarian—the only one in his family or circle of friends. Though he never resorted to shame or blame towards others, his passionate defense of voiceless creatures moved me. His arguments were convincing enough that I also became vegetarian for several years. And these dietary choices reflected the multitude of humane perspectives Nishad held. Whether discussing a war between states or a petty dispute between classmates, Nishad always argued for nonviolence and non-harm. Perhaps this was why he won so many awards for best delegate at these Model United Nations conferences, or perhaps it was because of the patient sympathy with which he listened to other people’s needs, and because of his earnest efforts to change his own proposals to accommodate the needs of others. The teenage Nishad was also the only person I knew who was as passionate about music as I was. In the 10th grade, we formed an ill-fated but surprisingly good band called The L33tles. While I (inveterate attention hog) played screaming lead guitar, and howled [ECF p. 148] about my angst into the microphone, Nishad supported me, deftly navigating my extreme dynamic choices with percussion that was by turns furious and sensitive—and always, of course, exactly what the song needed. He was incredibly encouraging of my singing and songwriting at a moment when no one else in my life really cared. I am a professional musician and teacher today. I might have given up if I hadn’t had Nishad’s generous, perceptive, and supportive presence at my side at that young age. Nishad and I were close friends when he started training for an ultra-marathon to raise money for the scholarship fund at our high school. He was only 16 and suffered from asthma, so it must have been exceptionally hard. Nonetheless, after 23 hours of running, he succeeded at running 100 miles. Though this was a remarkable feat written about in various newspapers, it was even more remarkable that I never once heard him brag about it. In fact, I barely heard him talk about it at all. Nishad never seemed to be motivated by external praise. He always just tried to do what was right as he saw it, quietly, without focusing on external rewards. Imagine my surprise then when I learned in October of 2022 that Nishad had become incredibly wealthy. This was doubly shocking because, though we had seen less of each other as adults than we had as teenagers, it wasn’t as if we had become strangers. Throughout our early and mid-20s, we’d annually hop on the phone or meet at a diner for an extended catching up. During these meetings, we’d mention our careers in passing (Nishad would usually say something like “I’m working crazy hours in crypto, but it’s raising money for causes I really believe in, so I am happy to do it”) and then get down to discussing what we always had—international relations, our old classmates, moral philosophy, and music. I witnessed no external change whatsoever in his character during this time. He did not become a petty tyrant to waiters or impatient in line, or too important to talk to a broke musician like me. He never made me feel unworthy to be his friend—quite the opposite, always. I think that the very qualities which make Nishad a good member of society under ordinary circumstances—his extremely hard work, his receptiveness to other people's ideas, his serious commitment to protecting the lives of others—became his Achilles' heel in the unique and unprecedented context of a multi-billion-dollar cryptocurrency exchange run by a nonviolent psychopath. In November 2022, FTX collapsed. Nishad became suicidal and disappeared into a legal labyrinth. When he finally got back in touch with me two years later, I was immensely relieved to know that he was alright, and happy to hear that he had found some contentment in a much slower, quieter life after his conviction. He tells me now of the happiness he feels writing code for a low-income housing project, going on long walks with his dogs in San Francisco, and of how he is deeply in love with his fiancée Claire. He also tells me that the hardest part of coming to terms with his [ECF p. 149] mistakes has been his guilt at the damage his actions have done. This is not the behavior, and these are not the thoughts of a hardened criminal or of a man who is a danger to society. Indeed, this is the profile of a man who is ready to return to a quiet life with a job and a family. Nishad is not even 30 years old. He has deep and meaningful relationships with his brother, parents, and fiancée, friends who love him, and now has a healthy relationship with a job again. He made great mistakes, but the person I know so well did not do so out of greed or malice. He is not someone who ever wants to hurt other people—he only wants to help. And if he is imprisoned, his friends, his family, and my own world would be the worse for it. Please consider this perspective when determining your sentence. Sincerely, **Baylor Odabashian**, Schoolmate, bandmate, and old friend of Nishad Singh *[A photograph appears here in the original. Its caption follows.]* *Baylor and Nishad, 2008* [ECF p. 150] ### [Letter from Greg Etzbach (Elementary School Friend)] July 2, 2024 Dear Judge Kaplan, I’ve known Nishad since I was 5 years old. He is the older brother of one of my closest friends, and we went to the same schools together for 11 years across elementary, middle, and high school. We were in the same Model UN organization for another 7 years. Though I imagine that many older brothers come off this way, I’ve generally regarded Nishad as someone with an extreme sense of responsibility to those other than himself. Being older is a good test of patience, as your kid siblings and their friends are usually more interested in playing with older kids than vice versa. When I was in elementary school, Nishad found out that his younger brother's grade no longer participated in a tag game which had been ‘passed down’ through the grades at our middle school for years. He then gathered up his too-old-for-this group of friends and convinced almost 20 8th graders to teach us this tag game during recess. In 2020 I spoke to an old teacher who confirmed that the game is still being passed down grade-to-grade like it was for us. I first spent time alone with Nishad on a Model UN trip in middle school. On this trip I was by far the youngest student, and everyone else invited was already in high school. We were renting a tiny house which consisted of two connected cottages. One cottage was big enough to house all the students except for two, and the other one would house our chaperones and one group of two students. Initially, Nishad and his roommate were going to be in the ‘fun’ cottage with the other kids, and myself and the second youngest would have been in the not-so-fun teachers cottage. Nishad could tell I was bummed out by this, and not only did he offer to switch with me, but he convinced his roommate Eliott to switch with him so I could be in the fun cottage with a roommate I was most comfortable with. This is a young high schooler giving up precious unmonitored time to a middle schooler just so that he’d feel more comfortable away from home, and it is a darn perfect example of the kind of person I have always known Nishad to be. I have many memories of Nishad that speak to his kindness and generosity. There were times Nishad helped me with my position papers on that trip and times he would go-over entire years of high school experiences to answer questions like: ‘how do I choose Junior year classes at Crystal?’. I didn’t choose to focus on those examples because recounting moments where it cost Nishad nothing to be kind are not enough to reveal the character I’ve known much of my life. Instead, I am hoping to illustrate that Nishad is the kind of person who takes care of others even when it *does* cost him something. Nishad is someone with a remarkable sense of duty, and you can see that sense of duty inform everything in his life from his career choices to his cruelty-free eco-friendly salad toppings. I would confidently say that Nishad puts more thought and effort into facilitating human happiness than anything which could benefit him. We need people like that in our world as much as possible. Sincerely, Gregory Etzbach --- **About this text version** This is a text version of Exhibit A to the [sentencing submission](singh-sentencing-submission-ecf-523.html) filed for Nishad Singh on October 16, 2024 in *United States v. Nishad Singh*, No. 22-cr-673 (LAK), in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York. The exhibit’s cover page calls it “Sentencing Letters Submitted On Behalf of Nishad Singh”. It holds an index of letters and the 105 letters that the index lists, in the index’s groups: former Alameda and FTX employees, immediate family, teachers and professionals, the volunteering community, extended family, and friends. It is docket entry 523-1 (“ECF No. 523-1”) and runs 210 pages. The public filing is redacted in places. **Note by this site, not part of the document:** Letters to the judge from family, friends, former colleagues and others, among them eighteen former employees of FTX and Alameda (ECF No. 523 at 2). - This is part 14 of 19 of the text version, covering ECF pages 145 to 150. The document is divided so that software which reads only the beginning of a long page can still read all of it. Other parts: [part 1](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-1.html), [part 2](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-2.html), [part 3](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-3.html), [part 4](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-4.html), [part 5](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-5.html), [part 6](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-6.html), [part 7](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-7.html), [part 8](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-8.html), [part 9](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-9.html), [part 10](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-10.html), [part 11](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-11.html), [part 12](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-12.html), [part 13](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-13.html), [part 15](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-15.html), [part 16](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-16.html), [part 17](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-17.html), [part 18](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-18.html), [part 19](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-19.html). The whole document on one page: [exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1.html](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1.html). No copy of this exhibit’s PDF is held here. The exhibit is ECF No. 523-1 on the court’s docket, which is available through PACER, and The New York Times hosts [a PDF of the sentencing submission together with its exhibits](https://static01.nyt.com/newsgraphics/documenttools/02780b6d3f9a0f08/dd12bbcd-full.pdf). The PDF as filed shows the contact details that this text leaves out. This part as plain text: [exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-14.txt](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-14.txt). The other documents from the case: [index](index.html). - It was converted by software from a PDF copy of the exhibit that carries the court’s filing stamp on every page, and every page that holds text was then compared by machine with a separate extraction of the same PDF. Ten pages are images of pages, and the PDF holds none of their wording as text: the index on pages 2 and 3, and the letters on pages 17, 18, 26, 95, 101, 102, 103 and 146. They were typed out from the page images and read against the images again; a note in the text marks each. The letter on page 101 is handwritten, and words that are crossed out in it are left out. If this text and the PDF ever differ, the PDF controls. - `[ECF p. 122]` marks the start of page 122 of the exhibit, counted by the page numbers the court stamps at the top of each page (“Page 122 of 210”). The sentencing submission cites the exhibit by those numbers, as in “Ex. A at 122”. - The heading in square brackets above each letter, such as “[Letter from Adam Yedidia (Former FTX Engineer)]”, was added by this site so that a letter can be found. It gives the author and the title or relationship in the words of the exhibit’s own index of letters (pages 2 to 4). The name in the index is not always the name as the letter gives it: the two may differ, for example, in spelling, by a middle name or initial, by a second surname, by a name that the index adds in brackets, by a short form of a first name or by initials, and the letter on page 101 is signed with another given name. The index gives page 121 for a letter that begins on page 122, and page 187 for a letter that begins on page 186; the headings stand where the letters begin. The headings without brackets (“Index of Letters”, “Letters from Immediate Family” and the like) are the exhibit’s own. - `[REDACTED]` marks what is blacked out in the public filing. The redactions are the filing’s own. One mark may stand for a single word or for many lines, so the marks do not show how much is covered. Pages 62 and 63 are blacked out in full, and each is given as a single `[REDACTED]`. - This site leaves out contact details that the public filing shows: 41 email addresses, 40 telephone numbers, 1 fax number and 7 street addresses. They are those of the people who wrote the letters and of their offices, except for one telephone number that stands at the top of each of the four screenshots of text messages on page 43 and is counted four times. Each place is marked, for example `[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]`. The court’s own address is kept, and so are the names of towns and states, ZIP codes, and the names of firms, organisations and buildings. Apart from these details and what the other notes here list, no word was left out. - Signatures written by hand and a photograph on page 149 are not reproduced. On page 13 the signature is a picture of the writer’s name in a script typeface; a note there gives the name. The image on page 43, four screenshots of text messages, was typed out, except for the small symbols at the top of each screenshot and the grey words in the empty entry field at its foot; notes in the text say where the image begins and ends. - Bold and italic type are shown with asterisks. Where the original itself has an asterisk, begins a line with a dash or with a number and a full stop, or sets a row of underscores on a line of its own (page 8), this plain-text version puts a backslash before it (`\*`, `\-`, `1\.`, `\_`) so that it is not read as formatting. The backslash is not in the original. Line breaks inside paragraphs and the spacing of the original are not reproduced. Neither are the court’s stamp at the top of each page, the page number printed at the foot of each page (“Page 122 of 210”), the page numbers 1 to 6 that one letter prints on its own pages (pages 35 to 40), underlining, ruled lines and the colour of type. A ligature (one character that joins two or three letters, as in “fi”) is written as its letters. On the typed pages, straight and curly quotation marks may differ from the original. Errors in the original are left as they are, except that the reading of the handwritten letter on page 101 gives words in their usual spelling, as the note there says. - On page 60 a signature block is set in two columns side by side. The left column is given first, then the right. - Where a page ends at the end of a sentence, this text starts a new paragraph on the next page. The original often does not show whether a new paragraph begins there. In a few places a letter starts a sentence on a new line with no space or indent before it, although the line above ends well short of the right margin; this text starts a new paragraph there. In some other places the original leaves the division into paragraphs open.