# Sentencing Letters Submitted on Behalf of Nishad Singh (Exhibit A to the Sentencing Submission), part 6 of 19 (ECF pages 49 to 55) [Index](index.html) · [Whole document](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1.html) · [Web page](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-6.html) · Part 6 of 19. Parts: [1](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-1.html) [2](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-2.html) [3](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-3.html) [4](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-4.html) [5](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-5.html) 6 [7](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-7.html) [8](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-8.html) [9](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-9.html) [10](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-10.html) [11](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-11.html) [12](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-12.html) [13](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-13.html) [14](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-14.html) [15](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-15.html) [16](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-16.html) [17](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-17.html) [18](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-18.html) [19](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-19.html) · About this text version: at the end of this page **Contents** (added for navigation; not part of the document) - [Letter from Rajeev Patel (Stepfather)] (ECF p. 49) - [Letter from Malhar Singh (Brother)] (ECF p. 52) --- [ECF p. 49] ### [Letter from Rajeev Patel (Stepfather)] September 10, 2024 Dear Judge Kaplan, My name is Rajeev Patel and I am Nishad’s step father. In the early 2000s, I began coaching marathons for a non-profit organization, Asha for Education, which raises money to educate underprivileged children in India. Over the last 22 years, I’ve coached over 1,000 athletes. I first met Nishad when he was seven years old and later became his running coach before becoming his stepfather. Over the years, I’ve had the privilege of watching him grow into a compassionate, selfless, and driven young man. Growing up, Nishad wasn’t the most athletic child, as his asthma often made physical activity challenging. But he approached every challenge with remarkable determination. In 2004, when he was nine, I took him on his first run. Though it was difficult for him, the pride on his face at the finish was infectious. In 2006, when he was eleven, he completed his first half marathon, and the following year, we ran one together. I watched in admiration as he took the time to personally thank all the volunteers at the aid stations. Nishad’s gratitude has always been one of his defining traits. By the time Nishad was thirteen, I had developed a passion for ultramarathons, which are races longer than the marathon distance of 26.2 miles, along with his mother. He asked me if I thought he could run a 100-mile race one day. He was embarrassed for dreaming so big, but I could already see that he had the will and determination to make it happen. I told him it would take at least two years of dedicated training, but I would be with him every step of the way. His training over the next two years involved ramping up to longer-distance ultramarathons. He was an eager student, always respectful of my guidance. He listened carefully, asked questions to clarify, and followed every piece of advice I gave him. He never took shortcuts, and I knew I could trust him to put in the work. Unlike some runners who might stretch the truth about their training, Nishad was always honest—if anything he would underreport his speeds and distances. I distinctly remember a 2011 incident where he stood up to me for the first time. It was during a very hilly, dusty, and hot 31-mile race that he and I ran. The conditions were not ideal for a fifteen-year old asthmatic kid, but he had been talking about this race for months and had a specific finish time goal in mind. At around 28 miles we came across an older runner who was sitting down beside the trail on a steep, exposed climb and who looked to be in bad shape. We had no cell phone coverage in those hills. I suggested we get to the next Aid Station and ask them to come back to help this runner. In a rare moment for him, Nishad disagreed and insisted on not leaving the runner alone. He asked if I would get help and he would stay. When I came back, I happened upon a scene of Nishad lying beside the older man and giving him riddles to take his mind off the stressful health incident. Nishad went on to finish the event, missed his goal time, and never thought twice about it. [ECF p. 50] A few months later in his first 50-mile race, Nishad finished a few minutes behind the winner for his age group. The other boy’s father approached Nishad, shook his hand, and said something to the effect of, “You both did well, but my son doesn’t shoot for second place.” Nishad just beamed and said “The race was awesome, he really did well, didn’t he?” I felt Nishad was gracious in overlooking the slight, and, in typical Nishad fashion, shone the light on the other person. There was something special brewing in this young man. It was quickly becoming apparent that Nishad’s inner fire did not manifest itself as a zero-sum, competitive drive. It was instead always community-focused. He took joy in his victories, but also took real pride in those of others. It made him a uniquely loved figure in the Bay Area ultramarathoning community. Several months later in August 2011, he completed his first ever 100-mile race at the age of 15, becoming the second person in the US to do so at that age. He raised quite a bit of money for scholarships at his high school while doing so. Ten or so of his friends excitedly cheered him on and took turns pacing him throughout, and together formed a cherished memory they all hold dear to this day. As Nishad grew older, he naturally gravitated toward helping others experience the same joy he found in running. Here are a few people whose lives were changed. There was a socially isolated, young girl with developmental challenges who was inspired by Nishad and had expressed to her parents her desire to run. When Nishad learned of this from me, he invited her to do her first ever run with him. He took her under his wing. Even though he was in school and very busy with studies, he would wake up very early at 5:00 a.m. and take her out for a run around the neighborhood before leaving for school at 7:30 a.m. His kindness and patience with her were so beautiful to watch, as he treated her like he would anyone else, though perhaps with a touch more encouragement. She went on to complete a few 50K and 50-mile races. The transformation that we all saw in her self-confidence was so profound that not only her parents but others in the community noticed it. He would often run from his home to his younger cousin’s after school, encourage them to join him for a few miles, drop them off, and then go to another cousin’s house. He would ask some of his high school friends to join him at the Sawyer Camp trail before school, where they’d get an early morning run in and look for wildlife in the process. Through Nishad’s encouragement, all three groups – the young girl, his cousins, and his high school friends – would go on to complete ultramarathons of their own over following two years. Nishad was perhaps proudest of a young boy named Miguel that he met through another runner. Miguel was just twelve. He, too, wanted to run a 100-miler. Nishad mentored him, picking him up from [ECF p. 51] home and taking him on runs in the same park that would host the 100-miler they’d both go on to attempt. That summer in 2012, Nishad ran the 100-mile race again, setting a then world record for the fastest 100-mile race for someone under the age of 17: just under 24 hours. Miguel did not finish that year. But he did the next year, at thirteen years of age. Where others might have felt a pang of jealousy at being overtaken, Nishad's heart swelled with pride. He celebrated Miguel's achievement as if it were his own. We talked often while he was in college. The sweetest kid, he would never fail to thank me for all the formative lessons our running together had imparted. Through the grueling races, Nishad had discovered his unusual capacity for effort and dedication, seeing firsthand how persistence could overcome large obstacles. It became his modus operandi, guiding his approach to college, during which he transformed into a consistent A student, and later, professional life. Years later, when we visited Nishad in the Bahamas, I saw that same sense of pride and humility in his work. He had built a community there, much like the one he had created in ultramarathoning. He introduced us to the Customer Support section of the office. I saw that same sense of pride and humility as he introduced us to engineers on his team, singing praises of each of them. Some of the older members – the lawyers, accountants, and others – treated him like a nephew, and he even babysat their children. Truthfully, a small part of me was jealous because we all missed Nishad and wanted him back home. When he did finally return to California, I regretted having ever wished for his return. He was broken. He’s worked tirelessly to make a dent in the harm he has caused and I do not think he will ever forgive himself. But he has found a way to put one foot in front of the other and walk a safe, good path. Just a few weeks ago (August 2024), at 28 years old, Nishad joined the same race in which he ran his hundred-mile runs. He brought along a new friend he has been training with. They completed a 50-kilometer race: the friend’s first ultramarathon ever, and Nishad’s first in years. I have hoped and prayed that he would return home in every sense of the word, and I feel that he has. I pray that Nishad is given the opportunity to continue on this path and rebuild his life. Respectfully yours, Rajeev Patel [ECF p. 52] ### [Letter from Malhar Singh (Brother)] The Honorable Judge Lewis A. Kaplan United States District Judge Southern District of New York September 8, 2024 Dear Judge Kaplan, I’m Nishad Singh’s younger brother, Malhar, and I’m now 27 years old. It's a strange experience to reflect on my older brother when he was younger than I am now. My brother Nishad is the most caring and loving person I know. This may sound like an empty phrase, but it’s not – his kindness truly defines him. He’s always been someone who thinks deeply about how others feel, giving people the benefit of the doubt and showing good faith. He’s the peacemaker, the cheerleader, and the mediator. I’m grateful to have the opportunity to share with you my understanding of Nishad’s hopes and dreams and the motivations behind his actions since he graduated from college in 2017. But most importantly, I’d like to share why I admire him so much for what he has done since FTX’s collapse in 2022. **Our childhood, and how Nishad’s love manifested at an early age** We grew up in a shared home with our cousins, aunt, uncle, and two other family friends, learning early the importance of community and sharing what we had. Nishad had a deep sensitivity to the suffering of the people around him, especially after our trips to India as young children where we witnessed poverty up close. It stuck with him in a way that I think it didn’t with the rest of us. He would be the first of us kids to ask our parents to get food for an unhoused person he saw in San Francisco. When Nishad was in middle school, we learned more about our parents’ upbringings. They had humble beginnings and their paths to the US seemed so unlikely and fortuitous. Nishad appreciates the opportunities he and I enjoy because we were born in this country, along with the responsibilities we have to give back as a result. In high school, Nishad and I participated in Model UN together. While most other students wanted to debate in prestigious mock committees like the Security Council, Nishad always opted to join the humanitarian-focused committees – it’s where his heart was. During this time, Nishad read Jonathan Safran Foer’s *Eating Animals*. I remember one afternoon after school watching him slowly flip through a multi-page visual section of the book, where each page was filled with dots, each representing a factory-farmed animal that the average person would eat in their lifetime. The book made a profound impact on Nishad. After reading it, he changed his diet and became a vegetarian. I eat meat to this day and never worry about his judgment. I know that Nishad’s decision to change his diet came from a deeply sincere and personal place. **College and beyond: navigating adult life** [ECF p. 53] Nishad’s work ethic wasn’t always something to write home about, but a flip switched in him after he started running ultramarathons. It was as if he finally realized how much more he could accomplish if he applied himself and worked hard. Over time, I’ve come to see this characteristic as the second most remarkable thing about him (after his kindness). Nishad is extraordinarily dedicated and can put everything into achieving a goal once he sets his mind to it. Nishad had never coded in high school. At one point, he was even discouraged from taking the high school computer science class because he wasn’t on the advanced math track. So it was unexpected when in college, through his hard work, he found a home in one of the school’s most demanding majors, computer science and electrical engineering. Nishad often told me how beautiful he found computer science and, ultimately, he inspired me to major in it when I was in college, too. He graduated with “highest honors,” which earned him a spot in a special part of the graduation ceremony. However, he proactively opted out because he preferred to hang out with his “study friends,” to whom he credits much of his college success. In reality, I’m certain it was because he didn't want to place himself above his friends in any way. **Life at Alameda and FTX** During his time at Alameda and FTX, Nishad was logging 14 to 16 hour days and, much of the time, he slept in the office under his desk. In 2018, I visited Nishad in the Berkeley office. I remember being both impressed and intimidated by everyone’s multi-screen setups and the fast-paced trading action in the office. We had lunch together that day and he told me that he totally sympathized with feeling intimidated, and he felt lucky to be working with so many brilliant people. After that visit, we talked about how he missed learning about and being engaged with the details of the causes he cared so much about. At one point shortly thereafter, he even applied to and went through a rigorous interview process at a nonprofit that made grants to effective charities. The job was not necessarily a great fit for his training – it was entirely nontechnical – but their mission was something he cared deeply about. The job would have paid about ten times less than he was making at Alameda, but after receiving the offer he was still an inch away from accepting it. I understood why Nishad opted to turn down the job at the nonprofit. He explained that when he mentioned to Sam that he was considering leaving Alameda, Joe Bankman (Sam’s Dad) had a conversation with Nishad and convinced him that Alameda really needed him, at least for another year. At his core, Nishad is a people person whose deeply compassionate nature compels him to serve where he feels he is most needed. So he stayed, but he also remained on good terms with the nonprofit, often turning to them for advice on charitable donations he was considering. Another admirable thing about Nishad is his genuine humility. As FTX grew and became widely popular, Nishad was uninterested in seeking any kind of recognition for his role in their success. He declined to do media interviews or participate in rankings like the Forbes 30 Under 30 list, which recognizes top young entrepreneurs. Even as his brother, I’d only find out about the company’s amazing growth through the news or conversations with our friends. Garnering attention for himself is just not part of Nishad’s DNA. **Filling his heart: the most generous person I know** I think what makes Nishad truly extraordinary is his selflessness, the fact that he’ll do things to help others without regard to his personal and financial well-being. [ECF p. 54] I remember one story Claire told me when I was catching up with her after she and Nishad moved to Hong Kong. An engineer that Nishad adored moved to Hong Kong but quit because he chafed with the personalities there. As part of the engineer’s exit, in lieu of paying his prorated bonus, Sam agreed to donate a large amount of crypto to a charity of his choosing. When the time came, the engineer reached out to Nishad, and Nishad requested Sam make the donation, but was repeatedly ignored. So Nishad used his own money to fulfill the promise and updated the engineer that the company had completed the donation. I asked him why he did this, or why at the very least he didn’t tell the engineer who really paid. Nishad told me, “[The ex-engineer] already likes me; why make him feel even more aggrieved at the company?” It continues to blow my mind that Nishad gave away nearly everything he took home from Alameda and FTX despite the extraordinary wealth he attained. What kind of person would do that? Even the most well-known philanthropists you read about make sure they pay themselves first. Not Nishad. **Visiting Nishad and FTX in the Bahamas** After FTX moved to the Bahamas, my girlfriend and I got a chance to visit Nishad and Claire in 2022. I was excited to see him and meet his fellow engineers, who I’d heard so much about. When we arrived, it quickly became clear Nishad was uncomfortable with the luxury condo. One evening we joined Nishad’s housemates in their apartment for some dinner being made. The table was divided: on one side, Sam and the others were having a discussion; on the other side, my brother, Claire, my girlfriend, and I were having a separate conversation. When Nishad tried to join the other conversation, his attempt was briefly acknowledged, but then ignored. We left shortly thereafter to spend time more comfortably elsewhere with Nishad’s friends – the people Nishad and Claire usually hung out with. He really did like some of his housemates, but outside the apartment, I felt him relax and be himself, and I felt more comfortable as a result. On that trip, we had some of the meaningful and joyful moments I sorely missed from our time apart. But I left agreeing with my mom’s impression from her earlier visit: that Nishad was embedded and committed to the company, but wasn’t happy, and wasn’t at home. **The FTX collapse and its aftermath** I will never forget first seeing Nishad when he got back from the airport in November 2022. He couldn’t speak or even hug me back when I embraced him. When he finally found his voice, all he could say was, “I’m so sorry,” “I can’t believe how much this is going to hurt all of you,” and “we’ve hurt so many people.” I think he was in shock. We all were. As he finally began to speak more, his horror about the magnitude of the situation became clear and he was consumed by remorse. For a long time, Nishad couldn’t face most of our family or close friends. He was deeply ashamed, and when he did finally begin to see people, all he could do was apologize. In those early days after the collapse, I barely left his side. I remember him taking a call with the bankruptcy estate describing what it'd take, technically, to reboot the exchange. When he was called in to help triage the hack that occurred shortly after the collapse, he and Claire urgently called their old coworkers, asking about their safety in case they were being physically threatened into draining funds. In those days, when Nishad wasn't actively helping, he was in despair. [ECF p. 55] When the government engaged Nishad’s help, it gave him a renewed sense of purpose. Even if he couldn’t solve FTX’s problems directly, he could help them understand FTX’s engineering systems and provide whatever information he could. As the months passed and Nishad’s mental health stabilized, he started volunteering and providing care to others in the hands-on way he had missed for so long. He now volunteers at a homeless shelter and has contributed hundreds of hours of coding to an affordable and sustainable housing non-profit. Nishad feels best when he’s helping others and being able to do so has helped him live again. **My hopes for Nishad** Nishad understands the gravity of his wrongdoings. I know he’s aware of the long-term consequences he will continue to face – his ruined reputation, the lawsuits, and the personal and professional setbacks that will follow him for years to come. He’s forfeited all of his assets willingly and is coming out of this experience without any gains from his time at Alameda and FTX. As his brother, I believe he’s dealt with his mistakes with dignity and I’ve seen first-hand how this experience has changed him. He wants to focus on individual, hands-on projects that are meaningful to him and his communities. This isn’t just a hope, it’s actually what he is doing, and what I believe he will continue to do going forward. Nishad has found the spirit to live instead of simply crumpling into a ball or worse. In the months immediately following the collapse, I wasn’t sure he’d ever get to this place. These days, we see each other all the time. Nishad was worried that I would be socially ostracized because of his actions, but that hasn’t been the case. My housemates love it when he stays over, and Nishad loves hosting them over the weekends in the apartment where he lives. I am so proud of him and I’m incredibly lucky to have him as my big brother. As you consider Nishad’s future, I humbly ask you to consider not only the person he was when he made his serious mistakes, but also the person he is now and the person he’s striving to become in the future. Thank you for your time and consideration. Sincerely, Malhar Singh --- **About this text version** This is a text version of Exhibit A to the [sentencing submission](singh-sentencing-submission-ecf-523.html) filed for Nishad Singh on October 16, 2024 in *United States v. Nishad Singh*, No. 22-cr-673 (LAK), in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York. The exhibit’s cover page calls it “Sentencing Letters Submitted On Behalf of Nishad Singh”. It holds an index of letters and the 105 letters that the index lists, in the index’s groups: former Alameda and FTX employees, immediate family, teachers and professionals, the volunteering community, extended family, and friends. It is docket entry 523-1 (“ECF No. 523-1”) and runs 210 pages. The public filing is redacted in places. **Note by this site, not part of the document:** Letters to the judge from family, friends, former colleagues and others, among them eighteen former employees of FTX and Alameda (ECF No. 523 at 2). - This is part 6 of 19 of the text version, covering ECF pages 49 to 55. The document is divided so that software which reads only the beginning of a long page can still read all of it. Other parts: [part 1](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-1.html), [part 2](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-2.html), [part 3](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-3.html), [part 4](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-4.html), [part 5](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-5.html), [part 7](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-7.html), [part 8](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-8.html), [part 9](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-9.html), [part 10](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-10.html), [part 11](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-11.html), [part 12](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-12.html), [part 13](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-13.html), [part 14](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-14.html), [part 15](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-15.html), [part 16](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-16.html), [part 17](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-17.html), [part 18](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-18.html), [part 19](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-19.html). The whole document on one page: [exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1.html](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1.html). No copy of this exhibit’s PDF is held here. The exhibit is ECF No. 523-1 on the court’s docket, which is available through PACER, and The New York Times hosts [a PDF of the sentencing submission together with its exhibits](https://static01.nyt.com/newsgraphics/documenttools/02780b6d3f9a0f08/dd12bbcd-full.pdf). The PDF as filed shows the contact details that this text leaves out. This part as plain text: [exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-6.txt](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1-part-6.txt). The other documents from the case: [index](index.html). - It was converted by software from a PDF copy of the exhibit that carries the court’s filing stamp on every page, and every page that holds text was then compared by machine with a separate extraction of the same PDF. Ten pages are images of pages, and the PDF holds none of their wording as text: the index on pages 2 and 3, and the letters on pages 17, 18, 26, 95, 101, 102, 103 and 146. They were typed out from the page images and read against the images again; a note in the text marks each. The letter on page 101 is handwritten, and words that are crossed out in it are left out. If this text and the PDF ever differ, the PDF controls. - `[ECF p. 122]` marks the start of page 122 of the exhibit, counted by the page numbers the court stamps at the top of each page (“Page 122 of 210”). The sentencing submission cites the exhibit by those numbers, as in “Ex. A at 122”. - The heading in square brackets above each letter, such as “[Letter from Adam Yedidia (Former FTX Engineer)]”, was added by this site so that a letter can be found. It gives the author and the title or relationship in the words of the exhibit’s own index of letters (pages 2 to 4). The name in the index is not always the name as the letter gives it: the two may differ, for example, in spelling, by a middle name or initial, by a second surname, by a name that the index adds in brackets, by a short form of a first name or by initials, and the letter on page 101 is signed with another given name. The index gives page 121 for a letter that begins on page 122, and page 187 for a letter that begins on page 186; the headings stand where the letters begin. The headings without brackets (“Index of Letters”, “Letters from Immediate Family” and the like) are the exhibit’s own. - `[REDACTED]` marks what is blacked out in the public filing. The redactions are the filing’s own. One mark may stand for a single word or for many lines, so the marks do not show how much is covered. Pages 62 and 63 are blacked out in full, and each is given as a single `[REDACTED]`. - This site leaves out contact details that the public filing shows: 41 email addresses, 40 telephone numbers, 1 fax number and 7 street addresses. They are those of the people who wrote the letters and of their offices, except for one telephone number that stands at the top of each of the four screenshots of text messages on page 43 and is counted four times. Each place is marked, for example `[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]`. The court’s own address is kept, and so are the names of towns and states, ZIP codes, and the names of firms, organisations and buildings. Apart from these details and what the other notes here list, no word was left out. - Signatures written by hand and a photograph on page 149 are not reproduced. On page 13 the signature is a picture of the writer’s name in a script typeface; a note there gives the name. The image on page 43, four screenshots of text messages, was typed out, except for the small symbols at the top of each screenshot and the grey words in the empty entry field at its foot; notes in the text say where the image begins and ends. - Bold and italic type are shown with asterisks. Where the original itself has an asterisk, begins a line with a dash or with a number and a full stop, or sets a row of underscores on a line of its own (page 8), this plain-text version puts a backslash before it (`\*`, `\-`, `1\.`, `\_`) so that it is not read as formatting. The backslash is not in the original. Line breaks inside paragraphs and the spacing of the original are not reproduced. Neither are the court’s stamp at the top of each page, the page number printed at the foot of each page (“Page 122 of 210”), the page numbers 1 to 6 that one letter prints on its own pages (pages 35 to 40), underlining, ruled lines and the colour of type. A ligature (one character that joins two or three letters, as in “fi”) is written as its letters. On the typed pages, straight and curly quotation marks may differ from the original. Errors in the original are left as they are, except that the reading of the handwritten letter on page 101 gives words in their usual spelling, as the note there says. - On page 60 a signature block is set in two columns side by side. The left column is given first, then the right. - Where a page ends at the end of a sentence, this text starts a new paragraph on the next page. The original often does not show whether a new paragraph begins there. In a few places a letter starts a sentence on a new line with no space or indent before it, although the line above ends well short of the right margin; this text starts a new paragraph there. In some other places the original leaves the division into paragraphs open.