Sentencing Hearing of Nishad Singh, October 30, 2024: Transcript, part 2 of 2 (pages 24 to 32)

[24:11] Mr. Singh provided this information in a number of ways that were helpful to the government. He did it by describing detailed conversations with Mr. Bankman-Fried. For instance, as the Court heard at his trial testimony, from the beginning, Mr. Singh described a conversation he had with Bankman-Fried on the balcony of a penthouse apartment, in vivid terms, describing the back-and-forth of the conversation, which established that Bankman-Fried knew the size of the debt that FTX was in, the fact that it was not able to cover the customer deposits and that it was a problem that it was continuing spending. That was a conversation that was not otherwise documented or recorded but the government relied on heavily in its case and would not have otherwise been able to prove but for Mr. Singh volunteering it.

[24:25] Another example is the information on the massive [25:1] campaign finance violation scheme perpetrated belie Bankman-Fried, Ryan Salame and others. That's a whole course of conduct that was totally unknown by the government, was brought to our attention exclusively by Mr. Singh and likely would never have been discovered or would only have been discovered by the detailed tracing of financial records, which would have taken months, if not over a year, to do without the help of Mr. Singh. He provided information about a securities fraud scheme that the government was not otherwise aware of that was set forth in our submission. He provided Signal chats that were set to auto delete which would otherwise have been gone without his cooperation. And all of that happened in the very few first weeks and months after FTX's collapse -- so not in the course of preparing for trial or after he had pled guilty, but while his status was still uncertain; he came forward without any reservation and provided cooperation. And that was necessary to bring the charges and bring them quickly.

[25:18] Now, I was struck thinking about this moment in time when I was hearing Mr. Goldstein speak and talking about the ways in which Mr. Singh was not involved in some of the conduct, and I was struck by the thought that it could have been very easy for Mr. Singh to have denied everything. He could have said I didn't know, there's no evidence I was involved in any of these things, because a lot of the ways he inculpated himself in these proffers and interviews was by [26:1] describing conversations which were not otherwise documented or recorded.

[26:3] He didn't have to disclose the campaign finance scheme. He didn't have to disclose his conversations with Bankman-Fried, and you could imagine a different person approaching the situation and choosing the path of denying, deflecting responsibility, minimizing their own role. And I think that the cooperation here was so important and what Mr. Singh should get credit for is the way he approached this from the outset, in terms of immediately accepting responsibility for his role in defrauding customers. And it's important generally, I think, to emphasize that cooperating witnesses need to come forward and be candid from the outset. And generally, as Mr. Goldstein alluded to, that's important for incentivizing cooperation in the future.

[26:16] The way I think about this is there was a fork in the road in effect at the beginning of the case where Mr. Singh could have chosen significant minimization but he chose substantial assistance. And that was critical to the government's case. And I think as the Court considers the message that's sent in such a significant financial fraud such as this one, in the same way that it considers general deterrence, it should think about the message that can be sent in sentencing a cooperating witness who came forward, who could have fought the charges, who could have fought the involvement [27:1] in the conduct, but instead chose immediate cooperation, and think about how that could incentivize cooperation in the future. And here, I think leniency and recognition of Mr. Singh's cooperation would send such an important message.

[27:5] You know, one other comment I want to make before I sit down. This has to do with the time I spent and the rest of the team spent with Mr. Singh in interviews and preps between FTX's collapse and Mr. Bankman-Fried's trial. And I'll say that throughout that period, Mr. Singh expressed extreme remorse, great remorse, for not just how things had ended but how things had taken place. And it was something that he clearly was really grappling with that came through and, I think, set him apart, the emotional aspect to it, that I found genuine, full-throated and weighty. I share this because in case it wasn't clear from our submission, it clearly has really weighed on him, and I believe that has been a motivating factor in his cooperation. Of course, people think about leniency that can come from cooperation. But for Mr. Singh, it was also clear that he wanted to right a wrong or at least start to make that effort and do the right thing. And that's why he came in the door just shortly after FTX's collapse.

[27:22] Thank you.

[27:23] THE COURT: Thank you, Mr. Roos.

[27:24] Mr. Singh, please stand for the imposition of sentence.

[28:1] I'll start by reiterating the fact that this may have been the greatest financial fraud in American history, and it's a very, very serious crime. But I'm entirely persuaded from your testimony at trial and what I've learned from the advocacy of both Mr. Goldstein and his colleague and the government that your involvement was much more limited than certainly Bankman-Fried and Ellison; that it came relatively late in the day; that you were a young man in a situation with a somewhat older person, Bankman-Fried, who was charismatic, demanding, deceitful, and with whom you had a long relationship, particularly with his brother, but with his family and with him. And I recognize how hard it would have been for anybody coming to the realization that you came in September of 2022 to have even begun to know what you should do.

[28:15] In moments of uncertainty like that, especially moments in the life of young and inexperienced people, without exposure to the world that the lawyers in this room have long been exposed to, I imagine you had no real idea of what to do except I'll get better. It's not an excuse, but it's something that I think I understand.

[28:21] And then something like eight weeks later, the crisis erupted, in public, in full view, and you then realized the only responsible thing to do, which is what you did. You didn't try to figure out what was the spectrum of options and which ones best served your personal self-interest. You knew [29:1] that it was wrong. You had known it was wrong, and you tried to help.

[29:3] Now, I'm not foolish enough to think that there was no self-interest involved. Obviously there must have been, but you did the right thing. You very quickly, within days of the bankruptcy, told the truth, and what's even more telling is the extent to which you immediately and truthfully, as far as I can see, fully unburdened yourself to the government about the wrongdoing of which you were aware and they quite clearly were not and that were not really implied by what had come to the public attention at the time of the bankruptcy filing and right around then. So that kind of underscores for me that there was not only self-interest but a serious moral element to what you did, and you are entitled to a lot of credit for that.

[29:15] Your cooperation in this case has been remarkable. You're not the only one who has cooperated in a remarkable way, but you certainly are a very important cooperator who has contributed to what, to me, seems an appropriate result all around. And I think the point that's been made, both by your counsel and by Mr. Roos, is that as important as setting examples of defendants who have been culpable in great wrongdoing by imposing punishments that get people's attention, it is equally important to take due account of the fact that you can go too far in doing that, by which I mean being so harsh, so taken with the enormity of the offense, that you [30:1] impose a sentence that discourages others from doing what you did. And I don't intend to do that.

[30:3] Your case is not the case that Ms. Ellison's was. She was involved from the beginning. She knew for years what was going on. She got plenty of credit for cooperation, but you deserve more.

[30:7] For that reason and others, it is the judgment of this Court that you be committed to the custody of the attorney general of the United States, or his designee, for a term of imprisonment of time served on each count, the terms to be served concurrently; that you thereafter serve a term of supervised release of three years; and that you pay the mandatory special assessment of $600.

[30:14] It is further adjudged that you shall forfeit to the United States the sum of $11,20,000,000 jointly and severally with the codefendants, as the term "codefendants" is defined in the amended consent preliminary order of forfeiture, as to specific property money judgment that I've signed already and will refer to in my further remarks as the preliminary order, as well as all of the specific property, as that term is defined in the preliminary order or as more specifically provided in the preliminary order.

[30:23] The Court declines to order restitution based on my finding that determining complex issues of fact related to the cause and amount of the victims' losses would complicate and [31:1] prolong the sentencing process. I instead grant the government's motion to authorize the United States to compensate victims with finally forfeited assets through a remission process, as restitution would be impractical in this case.

[31:6] The term of supervised release shall be subject to the mandatory, the standard and the special conditions of supervision set forth at pages 29 to 42 of the presentence report, which you have told me you have read. To the extent that the special conditions are not imposed for entirely obvious reasons, they are imposed for the reasons summarized in the presentence report.

[31:13] Does either counsel wish to have me read out the conditions on to the record?

[31:15] MR. GOLDSTEIN: No, your Honor.

[31:16] MR. ROOS: No, your Honor.

[31:17] THE COURT: OK. Thank you.

[31:18] I advise you that to whatever extent you haven't previously waived it, you have the right to appeal from the judgment imposing this sentence. If you wish to appeal, you must file a written notice of appeal with the clerk of the district court no later than 14 days after the date on which judgment is entered on the docket, which is likely to be, I think, tomorrow. In the event you wish to appeal and you can't afford to pay the fees necessary to do so, you may apply for [32:1] permission to appeal as a poor person. If that application were granted, you would be permitted to appeal without payment of the fees, and if you couldn't afford a lawyer, a lawyer would be appointed for you at government expense.

[32:5] You may be seated.

[32:6] I have two other things to say.

[32:7] The first is to express appreciation to counsel on both sides for very illuminating and very helpful sentencing submissions, however long they were.

[32:10] And I would like to say to Mr. Singh's parents -- and this is purely personal; this is not a judicial judgment of any kind -- I don't see anything you did wrong.

[32:13] OK. Thanks, folks.

[32:14] (Adjourned)