# Sentencing Submission on Behalf of Nishad Singh, part 2 of 6 (ECF pages 12 to 24) [Index](index.html) · [PDF](pdf/ecf-523-singh-sentencing-submission.pdf) · [Whole document](singh-sentencing-submission-ecf-523.html) · [Web page](singh-sentencing-submission-ecf-523-part-2.html) · Part 2 of 6. Parts: [1](singh-sentencing-submission-ecf-523-part-1.html) 2 [3](singh-sentencing-submission-ecf-523-part-3.html) [4](singh-sentencing-submission-ecf-523-part-4.html) [5](singh-sentencing-submission-ecf-523-part-5.html) [6](singh-sentencing-submission-ecf-523-part-6.html) · About this text version: at the end of this page **Contents** (added for navigation; not part of the document) - D. Nishad’s Time at Alameda and FTX (ECF p. 12) - 1. Nishad’s Path to Becoming a “Valuable Dev” (ECF p. 12) - 2. A “Beloved Colleague” and Manager (ECF p. 16) - 3. Nishad Was Not Focused on Personal Fortune (ECF p. 18) - 4. Nishad’s Efforts at FTX To Do the Right Thing (ECF p. 20) --- *[This part begins partway down ECF page 12.]* ### D. Nishad’s Time at Alameda and FTX As described below and at trial, while Nishad started at Alameda as a low-level software engineer, over time he became a valuable engineer and manager to Alameda and then to FTX. He has been described by many, including the national media, as a member of Sam Bankman-Fried’s “inner circle.”[^1] In some ways – such as managing junior members of FTX’s engineering team or being the person employees felt comfortable approaching with concerns – Nishad was among the company’s leaders. In most ways, however, Nishad was in a significantly different position than his co-defendants. He was not a founder of FTX or Alameda. He did not control company funds for either FTX or Alameda. He was not the CEO or CTO and could not make major decisions on his own. Instead, Nishad started at the proverbial bottom as a ground-level engineer, and even by the end of his time at FTX, when he was Head of Engineering, Nishad worked under Gary Wang’s supervision and did not have nearly the same level of authority or autonomy as Wang. He grew to be regarded as a leader due to his example, not his authority. Because of this – precisely because he was trusted and looked up to by many – his choice *not* to reveal the hole to others when he learned of it in September 2022 was that much more damaging. [^1]: *See, e.g.*, David Yaffe-Bellany, J. Edward Moreno, *Sam Bankman-Fried’s Closest Friends Become His Foes in Courtroom Clash*, THE NEW YORK TIMES (Oct. 12, 2023), available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2023/10/12/technology/sam-bankman-fried-friends-witnesses.html. Below we discuss Nishad’s time and role at FTX generally, before proceeding to describe the offense conduct. #### 1. Nishad’s Path to Becoming a “Valuable Dev” When Nishad started working at Alameda as a software engineer at the end of 2017, it was a small entity led by its cofounders, Bankman-Fried and Wang. Trial Tr. at 1302:17–1303:2. Nishad had no managerial responsibilities at first. *Id.* Having graduated from college just six months earlier and with only four months of entry-level experience, Nishad could perform a small [ECF p. 13] subset of engineering tasks and required direct supervision. In a performance review in 2018, Bankman-Fried described Nishad as an “unfailing[ly] nice person” but a “relatively weak programmer.” Ex. C at 2. Four months into Nishad’s time at Alameda, a dispute with Bankman-Fried led half of Alameda’s employees, including several engineers, to leave. Ex. A at 36 (C. Watanabe). As part of his response to the departures, Bankman-Fried authored a Google document where he described Gary Wang as “the default choice to manage the developers” as he could “design and build large systems, [] was the first developer,” and “built up most of Alameda’s code base.” Ex. D at 2. However, Wang was “not particularly interested in or motivated to manage people.” *Id*. at 4. In Nishad’s relatively short time at Alameda, Bankman-Fried had recognized his ability to work well with others, writing at the time: > Nishad in particular put in a herculean effort to fix the dev team. He took on all of the unrewarding code-cleanup tasks, dove in to [sic] the codebase--messy as it was--and tried as hard as he could to mend up dev team ego contests. He quickly emerged as the second most productive and valuable dev, despite his lack of experience, and as someone the trading team was excited to interface with. *Id.* at 2. With few other options, Bankman-Fried asked Nishad if he would “supervise and grow the engineering team,” despite Nishad’s youth and inexperience. Ex. A at 46 (G. Singh). Nishad was hesitant to become a manager, but Bankman-Fried maintained that “Gary would figure out how [engineering priorities] should be done, and Sam needed Nishad to handle people-management and training.” *Id*. Nishad accepted the position and “knew he had much to learn.” *Id.*; *see, e.g.*, Ex. A at 14 (L. Zhang). Nishad was tasked with people-management, and he deferred entirely on deciding strategic direction. One of his coworkers observed that Nishad “performed admirably when thrust into a management position at a young age,” but “he sometimes seemed to struggle with asserting his own views, particularly when they might conflict with those of more dominant personalities in the [ECF p. 14] company,” even in areas in which Nishad was “more of a domain expert.” Ex. A at 14 (L. Zhang). This included often deferring entirely to Bankman-Fried, who at the time Nishad looked up to as a role model who had all the answers. In his testimony, Nishad admitted, “I have always been intimidated by Sam.” Trial Tr. at 1308:10. “Sam is a formidable character, brilliant, so I had a lot of admiration and respect for him.” *Id.* at 1308:17–19. In 2018, Bankman-Fried and Wang relocated to Hong Kong to start FTX, while Nishad stayed in Berkeley working for Alameda. Beginning in mid-2019, after Wang had built and launched the exchange, Nishad began pitching in on some FTX engineering work. By the end of 2019, Nishad found himself among the last employees left in Berkeley. *See* Ex. A at 14 (L. Zhang). With the 15-hour time difference, Nishad felt he was “isolated and missing . . . guidance.” Ex. A at 46 (G. Singh). Nishad’s father, whom he spoke to for advice often in this period, writes: > [Nishad] wasn’t in regular meetings with the leadership, but felt even more out of the loop because they had moved to Hong Kong. He looked up to Gary and saw him as a genius, but who was often unavailable for days to answer questions. Nishad found it difficult to get the technical guidance he needed. Being responsible for guiding the other engineers only compounded the issue. *Id*. Though he was reluctant to leave his family, friends, and girlfriend in California, Nishad ultimately relocated to Hong Kong in February 2020. *See* Ex. A. at 46 (G. Singh). By this point, Nishad had fully transitioned to coding for FTX, although he continued to occasionally help with Alameda-related engineering tasks for the next year. Trial Tr. at 1303:12–19, 1310:22–23. As before, Nishad reported to Bankman-Fried and Wang. *Id.* at 1305:7–9. “Gary [Wang] was in charge of all of the code and technical systems,” and Bankman-Fried was responsible for essentially everything else. *Id.* at 1306:5–13. Wang supervised Nishad throughout their time at FTX. As Nishad explained during trial, the two “weren’t equals,” and Nishad took direction from and deferred to Wang on “every technical decision of importance.” *Id.* at 1304:8–11.[^2] [^2]: *See, e.g.*, Trial Tr. at 1304:8–11 (“On every technical decision of importance, [Nishad] would either get direction from [Wang,] or leave it to him.”); 1348:10–17 (“I asked Gary how I could help . . . Gary thought it was not a great [footnote 2 continues on ECF p. 15] attempt, so he took his own stab at it. I deleted my page and we went with Gary’s.”); 1350:16 (“. . . I know what Gary told me to generate there.”); 1523:9–14 (“I asked Gary how I could help. Gary told me that I could try my best to identify the accounts . . . I took a stab. My stab was ignored.”); 1529:14 (“Gary ended up pulling them”); 1542:1 (“I asked Gary about this.”); 1551:15–16 (“Gary dug into why it was the case . . .”). [ECF p. 15] At FTX, Nishad improved his technical abilities, but what made him a valued engineer was his unparalleled work ethic and ability to support the engineers he managed. Numerous former FTX colleagues write that “Nishad worked longer hours than any other developer in the company and carried an astounding burden.” Ex. A at 17 (A. Kalinich). Nishad believed that the more he worked, the more he and the company would ultimately be able to contribute to worthy causes. Andrea Lincoln, a former FTX developer and now a professor of computer science, explains that Nishad spent “long hours in the office, [] at home, and even [] through illness.” Ex. A at 9 (A. Lincoln). While Nishad did not architect the core technical infrastructure of FTX, he was determined to be valuable, handling many of the other engineering tasks that arose. Adam Yedidia, a former FTX developer who testified at trial, describes that in addition to working “between 70 and 80 hours a week in the office,” Nishad was also the “primary engineer on call,” for which he was “on average woken up in the middle of the night 3-4 times per week to deal with issues.” Ex. A at 6 (A. Yedidia). Two former FTX customer support teammates explain what this entailed. Ashish Suvarna shares how he “often called Nishad, waking him up at 3am his time for critical issues.” Ex. A at 19 (A. Suvarna). While not always sure if an issue was critical, “Nishad always encouraged us to err on the side of caution and call him anyway.” *Id.* Reynaldo Suero writes: “It didn’t matter if other developers caused the issue, were more knowledgeable, or were supposed to be ‘on call,’ Nishad was the one who actually responded to us and our customers. Over time, Nishad became the person that the customer support team knew they could count on.” Ex. A at 11 (R. Suero). Adam Jin, another former FTX colleague, recalls “a rare half-day” social outing “to go wake surfing in Hong Kong.” Ex. A at 23 (A. Jin). Just as Nishad started to gain his balance on the board, his phone went off back in the boat. “Without a moment’s hesitation, [Nishad] jumped into the water, swam back to the boat, dripping wet, pulled out the mobile phone and laptop, and [ECF p. 16] immediately started working . . .” *Id.* Adam Kalinich, another FTX engineer, shares that “if a complicated or urgent situation arose,” Nishad would always “jump on it” and “stick around to be as helpful as possible even when he needed to call in more experienced developers.” Ex. A at 17 (A. Kalinich). Even when on vacation with his family, “[e]verywhere Nishad went, there was the ever present backpack” with his computer, and he would constantly get on “calls to help solve [technical] problems.” Ex. A at 82 (K. Watanabe), 118 (M. Thirumale). Nishad’s work ethic and example led him to be seen as a leader at the company. As his colleagues explain: “People in the company looked up to Nishad as a leader despite his young age and only Director title, and because of how hard he worked and how well he treated others.” Ex. A at 11 (R. Suero). Another colleague writes: “Seeing Nishad work relentlessly all the time and look after others drove us further and all of us worked harder. Although Nishad was often the youngest person in the room, he led by example and earned the respect of others through his actions.” Ex. A at 20 (A. Suvarna). #### 2. A “Beloved Colleague” and Manager As a manager, Nishad was adored, as the letters included with this submission make clear. Yedidia refers to Nishad as “easily the best boss I’ve ever had,” describing him as “warm and patient, extremely kind and hardworking,” and writes that “[m]any if not most of [his] fondest memories of FTX are being [Nishad’s] coworker.” Ex. A at 7 (A. Yedidia). Yedidia “admired him deeply” at FTX and still does. *Id.* at 6. Phillipe Maes, a former FTX engineer, writes that he “doubt[s] there would have been a better place to grow professionally” than at FTX, which “wouldn’t have been possible without Nishad’s endless trust and patience.” Ex. A at 21 (P. Maes). Another FTX engineer shares how Nishad “clearly” enjoyed finding ways to make his team happy like “[f]iguring out which projects [they would] enjoy” or “who [they would] like working with.” Ex. A at 12 (W. Kaufman). Nishad regularly checked in with the employees he was managing on a personal level, asking if they were doing well or “if he could do something to make” someone’s life “easier.” Ex. A at 21 (P. Maes). Kalinich calls Nishad “one of the most selfless individuals [he has] ever known,” noting how, despite being able to delegate almost any task, [ECF p. 17] Nishad “would always take on the most unpleasant tasks himself” to avoid placing the burden on his team. Ex. A at 17 (A. Kalinich). While working long hours at FTX, Kalinich opened up to Nishad about the suicide of his best friend. Kalinich shares that Nishad’s “empathy during that difficult period meant more to me than words can express” and how he “learned invaluable lessons about treating colleagues with kindness and respect.” *Id.* at 18. Former FTX General Counsel Can Sun, who testified at trial, writes that Nishad “consistently demonstrated kindness and consideration for others, both in and out of the workplace.” Ex. A at 26 (C. Sun). Nishad “was someone his colleagues could rely on, not only for his professional contributions but also for his empathy and willingness to support those around him.” *Id.* And even as Ryan Salame publicly criticized Nishad for cooperating with prosecutors in a series of Twitter posts, he also described Nishad as “one of the most genuinely nice human beings I’ve ever met. The guy absolutely wrecked me, and I still think this.”[^3] [^3]: Ryan Salame (@rsalame7926), X (F/K/A TWITTER), https://x.com/rsalame7926/status/1811235249197576303. Perhaps most indicative of Nishad’s good-heartedness is how he treated people he had no professional relationship with. Christian Drappi, another witness at trial, explains that while “it was all too common for higher-ranking FTX employees to treat the Bahamas staff with much less than the respect they deserved . . . Nishad was the opposite” and “was warm to everyone he came across, no matter who they were.” Ex. A at 25 (C. Drappi). A former house cleaner during Nishad’s time at FTX in Hong Kong writes that Nishad was unlike any other boss she has ever worked for because he treated her “like family,” someone who worked long hours but still had time to check in with her at the end of the day, and who stayed in contact even after moving from Hong Kong to the Bahamas. Ex. A at 68 (G. Benag). A former personal trainer in Hong Kong, Charles Dunford, who was facing significant financial hardship after a series of business decisions and COVID restrictions in Hong Kong, writes about Nishad taking “concrete” steps to introduce him to FTX employees as a potential clientele base. Ex. A at 69 (C. Dunford). While Nishad could have “looked down” on Dunford, who is much older than Nishad, “he did the opposite” and [ECF p. 18] as a result, Dunford is “grateful for the friendship and support” Nishad gave him during this difficult time. *Id.* And Jack Zhang, FTX’s former chef, writes that he remains grateful for Nishad’s help in finding a school for his daughter when his family moved to the Bahamas, and how his respect for Nishad only grew when he learned that Nishad treated all employees with the same level of care. Ex. A at 16 (J. Zhang). #### 3. Nishad Was Not Focused on Personal Fortune Even as Nishad became, on paper, worth tens and eventually hundreds of millions of dollars before FTX collapsed, he was not focused on personal fortune. He did, however, use his newfound financial circumstances to help others – both those close to him and charitable organizations. For example, as noted above, Nishad paid for [REDACTED] for Claire’s mother. Ex. A at 38 (C. Watanabe). On another occasion, he paid for a friend’s medical and living expenses after a severe injury. *Id.* Nishad’s close friend Colin Smith writes that in traveling to the same location for vacation together, he discovered Nishad flew internationally in economy even though Nishad had purchased a business class ticket for Smith. Ex. A at 140 (C. Smith). As Smith notes: “Spending on others is fine for Nishad. He loves spending on charity and making his loved ones happy. Spending on himself, however, is awkward, uncomfortable, and ultimately shameful.” *Id.* In another example, Nishad’s brother describes a situation in which an engineer quit after personal conflict with some of the personalities at FTX. Ex. A at 54 (M. Singh). As a part of the engineer’s exit agreement, Bankman-Fried had agreed to donate a large sum to the charity of the engineer’s choice in lieu of the engineer’s outstanding bonus. *Id.* When Bankman-Fried would not make the donation, “Nishad used his own money to fulfill the promise.” *Id.* What is more, as with every one of his donations, Nishad did not seek credit for this, and never informed the engineer that the money had come from him personally. *Id.* Indeed, in keeping with his reason for joining Alameda in the first place, Nishad donated considerably to charity. For example, after Nishad and Claire (his now fiancée) conferred with charitable giving advisors for months, Nishad ultimately donated more than $10 million to five [ECF p. 19] nonprofits in need of funding. Ex. A at 36 (C. Watanabe). And in another instance, described in more detail below, Nishad provided several million dollars to a philanthropic foundation he trusted for donations that they believed would have the most effect. At no point did Nishad ever attempt to draw attention to his philanthropic giving, let alone his wealth, for his own reputational benefit – whether that attention was from the press or internally within FTX and Alameda. To the contrary, he actively sought to avoid it, which distinguished him from other leaders at the company. For example, Bankman-Fried,[^4] Wang,[^5] and Ellison[^6] each chose to participate in Forbes’ various lists for the wealthiest individuals or “30 Under 30.” Nishad was offered the opportunity to do so, but declined. Ex. A at 53 (M. Singh). Put simply, Nishad used his wealth in genuinely altruistic ways, and never engaged in self-aggrandizement while at Alameda or at FTX. *See, e.g.*, Ex. A at 8 (C. Howells) (“Despite his significant role, [Nishad] always shied away from the spotlight. He had no interest in mingling with famous personalities who often visited the company or being interviewed.”). [^4]: Steven Ehrilich, et al., *Meet the World’s Richest 29-Year-Old: How Sam Bankman-Fried Made a Record Fortune in the Crypto Frenzy*, FORBES (Apr. 21, 2022), available at: https://www.forbes.com/sites/stevenehrlich/2021/10/06/the-richest-under-30-in-the-world-all-thanks-to-crypto. [^5]: Chase Peterson-Withorn, *The Forbes 400 2022: 10 Riches Newcomers*, FORBES (Sept. 22, 2022) (listing Wang at #8, worth $4.6 billion), available at: https://www.forbes.com/pictures/632c9961494bcfca4923daa8/8gary-wang/. [^6]: Maria Abreu, et al., *Forbes 30 Under 30 North America 2022*, FORBES (2022) (listing Ellison as co-CEO of Alameda Research), available at: https://www.forbes.com/30-under-30/2022/finance. Indeed, Nishad’s financial selflessness extended to the company and was, at times, taken advantage of by others. This was most evident with respect to Nishad agreeing to forgo cash bonuses,[^7] refraining from selling his assets, and taking on company loans as advised by Bankman-Fried and FTX’s legal team. It is these “loans” – which were for the benefit of the company, and often to the detriment of Nishad – that comprise what has been reported as more than $500 million [ECF p. 20] that Nishad supposedly received from Alameda.[^8] [^7]: In 2020, Bankman-Fried advised Nishad to take equity options and forgo future cash bonuses, arguing it would result in better long-term tax treatment if Nishad intended to donate them. This also helped preserve company cash in the short term. Nishad agreed. Every other employee, except for Bankman-Fried and Wang, received cash bonuses. Unlike Bankman-Fried and Wang, who were founders of FTX and held equity at no cost from the start, Nishad received options that needed to be exercised at substantial cost later. [^8]: *See, e.g.*, Ben Weiss, *Prosecutors say a private message from Sam Bankman-Fried shows criminal intent. SBF says he was just trying to comfort a friend in distress*, FORTUNE (Oct. 30, 2023) (discussing approximately $500 million in loans that Nishad received), available at: https://fortune.com/crypto/2023/10/30/prosecutors-private-message-nishad-singh-sam-bankman-fried-sbf-criminal-intent-friend-distress-suicidal. By far the most significant example of such a transaction occurred in late 2021. Earlier that year, Nishad sought to exercise his equity options in FTX for the purpose of either donating the options or eventually selling them and donating the proceeds. Trial Tr. at 1514:5–8. Nishad proposed selling his FTT and other crypto holdings to fund the exercise. Instead, months later, Bankman-Fried and his advisors, including company attorneys, asked Nishad to acquire the equity through different means: taking on a $477 million loan from Alameda to acquire the shares at a strike price over four times *higher* than the price Nishad was entitled to under the terms of his options. This benefitted FTX from a tax perspective, but came at a huge financial disadvantage to Nishad (who easily could have sold his tokens at that time in order to exercise the options at their then-significantly lower strike price). *Id.* at 1459:13–19, 1621:6–1622:6. Feeling pressured, Nishad agreed to the transaction, and was praised by the attorneys for his generosity to the company. No money was actually received by Nishad (or indeed ever left Alameda’s bank accounts, as far as Nishad understands), with the result simply being an on-paper $477 million debt owed by Nishad to Alameda. *Id.* at 1621:6–7. In the following months and throughout 2022, company attorneys asked Nishad to sign additional loan agreements in connection with FTX U.S. acquisitions, which he agreed to do. *See, e.g.*, Trial Tr. at 1420:1–16, 1459:20–1460:6. Similarly, none of these loans benefited Nishad personally or involved funds reaching his bank account. #### 4. Nishad’s Efforts at FTX To Do the Right Thing Just as Nishad’s caring nature distinguished him among FTX’s leadership, so did his moral compass. We do not raise this point to diminish the serious moral errors which Nishad also made, and for which he takes full responsibility, as we address in detail below. But it is important to note that on numerous occasions, and as virtually everyone who got to know him at FTX would agree, Nishad “tr[ied] his best to do the right thing in so many difficult circumstances . . .” Ex. A at 7 [ECF p. 21] (A. Yedidia). As one example, a former FTX colleague recalls how Nishad “advocated for higher salaries for the Bahamian staff when he realized the discrepancies that existed” and how “[h]e didn’t just talk about making changes; he took action to ensure that everyone, regardless of their background, was compensated fairly.” Ex. A at 8 (C. Howells). For customers of FTX, Nishad was often their advocate within the company. Adam Jin explains how Nishad resolved an issue regarding “unsupported” token deposits. Ex. A at 23 (A. Jin). Nishad developed a new system to recover these assets for customers, saving them “millions of dollars in potentially lost funds” and setting a new standard in the industry. Jin explains that “Nishad undertook this task out of a genuine desire to protect users and their assets.” *Id.* In a separate instance, Yedidia recalls Nishad working from his bed with COVID to prevent an ongoing scam that exploited elderly users by convincing them to wire their savings to the perpetrators. Nishad “called and gently talked to [the victims] to figure out what was wrong and reassure them,” “developed a system for preventing this species of scam,” and successfully pushed “for the company to reimburse the users who had been scammed, at the company’s expense.” Ex. A at 7 (A. Yedidia).[^9] [^9]: Other staff at FTX were not unanimously in favor of using corporate funds to repay victims, but Nishad insisted that it was the right thing to do. This occurred in a Signal chat called “Wire Fraud,” a channel that was misreported about in the press as possibly being related to furthering the customer fraud scheme in this case. Ed Pilkington, *Sam Bankman-Fried and other FTX staff allegedly had ‘Wirefraud’ chat group*, THE GUARDIAN (Dec. 13, 2022), available at: https://www.theguardian.com/business/2022/dec/13/sam-bankman-fried-ftx-signal-wirefraud-chat-alameda. Nishad was also the leading and often lone voice against irresponsible spending and risky or needless business deals. As the Government elicited during trial, while Nishad often learned of large expenditures after the fact, he would “frequently go to Sam” and express his concerns, which varied depending on the expenditure, including by telling Bankman-Fried how some were “a bad business decision” or “how much it all wreaked [sic] of excess and flashiness.” Trial Tr. at 1312:22–1313:7. Bankman-Fried’s reactions to Nishad varied, ranging from telling Nishad he lacked sufficient context to evaluate certain expenditures, to dismissing his input by saying his views had already been factored in and that “[he] didn’t need to continue sharing them,” or even [ECF p. 22] outright public humiliation. *Id.* at 1313:8–22. For instance, when Nishad told Bankman-Fried that he believed FTX “had been fleeced for $20 million,” Bankman-Fried became “visibly mad” and said – in the middle of the office at daytime, in front of others at the company, including people Nishad was responsible for managing – “that it was [] people like [Nishad] sowing seeds of doubt in the company decisions that were the real insidious problem here.” *Id.* As Nishad testified, this was a “humiliating” experience. *Id.* During Bankman-Fried’s trial, Nishad spoke about other instances where he pushed back against Bankman-Fried’s excessive spending: - Nishad testified about living in the “Orchid” penthouse, which Bankman-Fried wanted to purchase because he “really liked” it and is a “fan of views.” Trial Tr. at 1340:20–1341:8. Nishad felt uncomfortable about living at Orchid “because it was really expensive, [and] in part because it’s just super ostentatious.” *Id.* Nishad expressed these concerns directly to Bankman-Fried. Bankman-Fried responded that “he would pay $100 million for the drama to just be done with and go away, which [Nishad] took as a pretty clear sign that [he] should shut up and we should move forward with this.” *Id.* Text messages between Nishad and his mother from mid-2022 reveal how uncomfortable he was living at Orchid, so much so that he asked his family to stay elsewhere during their visit out of sheer embarrassment. *See* Ex. A at 43 (images of texts from Nishad to his mother: “I think living here is wearing on me too; I find justifying the home to myself very effortful and draining. Was just talking with Claire now about maybe moving out”; ***“I know it’s not on me but it feels so incongruent with my values”; “Walking into here is so uncomfortable”*** (emphasis added)). - Nishad testified about FTX’s investment in K5, an entity that Bankman-Fried wanted to use to boost his social standing with politicians and celebrities, including figures like Hillary Clinton and the pop star Katy Perry. Nishad was “shocked” when he saw the term sheet contemplating bonuses over $100 million and an investment of up to $1 billion. Trial Tr. at 1328:11–16. He interrogated Bankman-Fried about the deal, asking if there was a way to reconsider but was told it was “basically done.” *Id.* at 1329:5–11. Nishad warned that an investment into K5 would be “really toxic” to the culture of a company Nishad had joined explicitly because of its stated charitable mission. *Id.* at 1329:22–1330:7. Bankman-Fried went ahead anyway. - Nishad testified about a $1 billion investment that Alameda had made into Genesis Digital Assets, a cryptocurrency mining company in Kazakhstan. Trial Tr. at 1315:8–1318:12. After learning about the investment, Nishad urged Bankman-Fried to either get out of the deal or to sell the stake back to the company. Sam did not take meaningful steps to do so. [ECF p. 23] Around the time FTX employees relocated to the Bahamas, Nishad recognized a distinct shift in the company’s culture. It had devolved from an idealistic and altruistically oriented startup to a chaotic, sprawling, and greedy organization. Claire’s mother, Pam Watanabe, visited Claire and Nishad around this time. She describes that Nishad “talked earnestly about how embarrassed and alone he felt over the amount and kind of spending at the company.” Ex. A at 80 (P. Watanabe). Pam summarizes her impressions from that visit: “He seemed overwhelmed by the enormity of the job, but still felt resolute about the good he believed they could achieve . . . I was torn between feeling proud of him and worried for him. It was clear he was exhausted and lonely.” *Id.* The rampant growth of the company, and Bankman-Fried’s tendency to approve business ideas he found promising without regard to engineering resources, left Nishad in an extremely difficult place. Nishad would often be charged with the engineering work associated with the new investment or partnership of the day. As Claire (who ultimately worked at FTX as well) describes, Nishad could either try to “challenge” and “reverse[]” the arrangement, or could do the engineering work “so the money wouldn’t be wasted,” and “[h]e often tried both.” Ex. A at 38 (C. Watanabe). Simultaneously, Nishad had to manage and attend to the morale of his team, interpreting vague dictates from a jet-setting and rarely present Bankman-Fried, or seeking advice from an increasingly hard-to-reach Wang, all while working through the middle of the night to solve problems. *Id.* at 37. Nishad’s coworkers noticed that this all came at the “apparent detriment of his own health.” Ex. A at 17–18 (A. Kalinich). In the midst of this, Nishad’s mother went to visit him in February 2022. She writes of that visit: > The moment I saw him, I knew he was doing much worse. He had gained a lot of weight and was exhausted in a way that was not just explained by the long hours . . . We went on a walk just the two of us, and he confided in me that he felt like the company was losing what made it special. People were focused on compensation instead of work, and Sam kept agreeing to more that stretched the team thinner . . . . He said he felt he was constantly fighting battles he [ECF p. 24] wished he didn’t have to. Ex. A at 43 (A. Singh). As discussed in more detail below, just months later, Nishad’s distress at the company’s direction turned into horror when he learned of the devastating reality: that Alameda had effectively stolen billions of dollars in FTX customer funds. Nishad chose to stay at FTX, and he fought even more aggressively to prevent reckless company spending of what he had just learned were customer funds and mitigate Bankman-Fried’s worst instincts. But by choosing to stay, he also became complicit in Bankman-Fried’s scheme in its final two months, and took actions that harmed customers. This conduct was wrong, and Nishad regrets his participation every day. --- **About this text version** This is a text version of the sentencing memorandum that Nishad Singh’s lawyers, Cooley LLP, filed on October 16, 2024 in *United States v. Nishad Singh*, No. 22-cr-673 (LAK), in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York. It is docket entry 523 (“ECF No. 523”) and runs 63 pages. The public filing is redacted in places. **Note by this site, not part of the document:** Its sections are a preliminary statement (pages 2 to 4), Singh’s personal history (pages 5 to 24), his role in the offense conduct (pages 25 to 45), his remorse and cooperation (pages 46 to 50), his life since FTX’s collapse (pages 51 to 53), and the sentencing guidelines and statutory factors (pages 54 to 62). - This is part 2 of 6 of the text version, covering ECF pages 12 to 24. The document is divided so that software which reads only the beginning of a long page can still read all of it. Other parts: [part 1](singh-sentencing-submission-ecf-523-part-1.html), [part 3](singh-sentencing-submission-ecf-523-part-3.html), [part 4](singh-sentencing-submission-ecf-523-part-4.html), [part 5](singh-sentencing-submission-ecf-523-part-5.html), [part 6](singh-sentencing-submission-ecf-523-part-6.html). The whole document on one page: [singh-sentencing-submission-ecf-523.html](singh-sentencing-submission-ecf-523.html). The PDF this text was made from is [here](pdf/ecf-523-singh-sentencing-submission.pdf), and the same filing is on [CourtListener](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.594742/gov.uscourts.nysd.594742.523.0.pdf). This part as plain text: [singh-sentencing-submission-ecf-523-part-2.txt](singh-sentencing-submission-ecf-523-part-2.txt). The other documents from the case: [index](index.html). - It was converted by software from the PDF filed on the court’s docket. Every page that holds text was then compared by machine with a separate extraction of the same PDF. Page 50, which is an image of the page, was typed out and read against the image. If this text and the PDF ever differ, the PDF controls. - `[ECF p. 14]` marks the start of page 14 of the PDF, counted by the page numbers the court stamps at the top of each page (“Page 14 of 63”). A citation such as “ECF No. 523 at 14” uses those numbers. The memorandum’s own page numbers, printed at the foot of its pages, are one lower. - Footnotes appear directly after the paragraph that cites them, not at the foot of the page. In the PDF each footnote is printed on the page that carries its number in the text, so a footnote is cited by that page. Footnote 2 runs on to a second page, and the marker `[footnote 2 continues on ECF p. 15]` shows where. - `[REDACTED]` marks a passage blacked out in the public filing. The redactions are those of the filing itself. - Page 50 of the PDF is an image of the page. Its text was typed out from the image, and a note at that place in the text says what was done. - Italic and bold type are shown with asterisks, and block quotations and other set-off passages with `>`. One asterisk belongs to the original (`at *2`, on page 60); in the plain-text version it is written `\*` so that it is not read as emphasis. Line breaks inside paragraphs and the spacing of the original are not reproduced, and neither are the court’s stamp at the top of each page and the memorandum’s own page numbers at the foot. Ruled lines and underlining are not reproduced either: the caption on page 1 and the signature block on page 62 are set in ruled boxes, a short rule stands above the footnotes on each page that has them, and the title on page 1, the heading “CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE” on page 63 and the signatures on pages 62 and 63 are underlined. The caption on page 1 and the signature block on page 62 are set in two columns, and each is given here one column after the other. Errors in the original are left as they are. - The memorandum cites exhibits that are separate documents. Text versions of two of them are on this site: [Exhibit A](exhibit-a-letters-to-the-court-ecf-523-1.html) (letters to the Court, ECF No. 523-1) and [Exhibit B](exhibit-b-singh-letter-to-the-court-ecf-523-2.html) (Singh’s letter to the Court, ECF No. 523-2). Exhibits C and D (two documents written by Samuel Bankman-Fried, ECF Nos. 523-3 and 523-4) are not reproduced on this site. The New York Times hosts [a PDF of the sentencing submission together with its exhibits](https://static01.nyt.com/newsgraphics/documenttools/02780b6d3f9a0f08/dd12bbcd-full.pdf), and the court’s docket is available through PACER. A citation such as “Ex. A at 45” gives the page of the exhibit as the court stamps it.