# Trial Testimony of Nishad Singh, October 16 and 17, 2023: Transcript, part 7 of 13 (pages 1440 to 1465) [Index](index.html) · [PDF, October 16](pdf/2023-10-16-trial-transcript.pdf) · [PDF, October 17](pdf/2023-10-17-trial-transcript.pdf) · [Whole document](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17.html) · [Web page](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-7.html) · Part 7 of 13. Parts: [1](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-1.html) [2](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-2.html) [3](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-3.html) [4](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-4.html) [5](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-5.html) [6](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-6.html) 7 [8](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-8.html) [9](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-9.html) [10](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-10.html) [11](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-11.html) [12](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-12.html) [13](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-13.html) · About this text version: at the end of this page --- [1440:15] **MR. ROOS:** He described conduct. I am not sure -- [1440:16] **MR. COHEN:** He just said one of the crimes he committed was being a straw donor. [1440:18] **MR. ROOS:** That he committed. I am not sure he has actually said. I'm happy to look at the testimony. [1440:20] **MS. SASSOON:** I think it is also direct evidence. [1440:21] **THE COURT:** Doesn't it really come down to saying that the defendant, as opposed to this witness, is not charged here, as I have told you before, with any crimes involving any violations of campaign finance costs. [1440:25] **MR. COHEN:** That would be fine, your Honor. [1441:1] **MS. SASSOON:** I just want to make sure that FCPA instruction referred to -- it's for the limited purpose of propensity. I don't think that applies here. [1442:1] (At sidebar) [1442:2] **THE COURT:** Members of the jury, I just want to remind you that, as I said earlier in the trial, the defendant is not charged with any criminal violation of campaign finance laws in this case. This evidence is coming in for other purposes, not least of what would be the fact that this witness has pleaded guilty to such a violation. [1442:8] **MR. ROOS:** Thank you, your Honor. [1442:9] **Q.** You testified you pled guilty. How many felonies have you pled guilty to? [1442:11] **A.** Six. [1442:12] **Q.** Is that plea based on criminal activity you have testified about here today? [1442:14] **A.** Yes. And more. [1442:15] **Q.** When you were committing the frauds you testified about, did you know what you were doing was wrong and illegal? [1442:17] **A.** Yes. [1442:18] **Q.** And with respect to the conspiracies you pled guilty to commit wire fraud, securities fraud, commodities fraud and money laundering, who did you conspire with? [1442:21] **A.** I conspired with Ryan Salame, Sam Bankman-Fried, Gary Wang, Caroline Ellison. [1442:23] **Q.** You said you entered into a cooperation agreement. Is that a written agreement? [1442:25] **A.** That is. [1443:1] **MR. ROOS:** If we could pull up for identification 3501-002. [1443:3] **Q.** Mr. Singh, do you recognize this document? [1443:4] **A.** I do. [1443:5] **Q.** What is it? [1443:6] **A.** It's my cooperation agreement. [1443:7] **Q.** Let's go to the last page. [1443:8] Is that your signature on the last page? [1443:9] **A.** Yes. [1443:10] **MR. ROOS:** Your Honor, the government offers 3501-002. [1443:11] **MR. COHEN:** No objection. [1443:12] **THE COURT:** Received. [1443:13] (Government Exhibit 3501-002 received in evidence) [1443:14] **MR. ROOS:** May we publish it? [1443:15] **THE COURT:** You may. [1443:16] **Q.** Mr. Singh, we are not going to go through the whole document, but just for starters, looking at pages 1 and then 2, does that state the crimes that you have pled guilty to? [1443:19] **A.** Yes. [1443:20] **MR. ROOS:** Can we go to page 3. [1443:21] **Q.** You see the first full paragraph on that page. What do you understand this paragraph in the cooperation agreement to require of you? [1443:24] **A.** This paragraph describes my obligations as a part of the cooperation agreement. At a high level, it requires that I [1444:1] provide truthful information to the government, that I testify truthfully if asked, and that I commit no further crimes. [1444:3] **Q.** If you satisfy those obligations, what is your understanding as to what the government will do? [1444:5] **A.** The government believes that my assistance was substantial, they can write a 5K letter to the judge to be considered at my sentencing. [1444:8] **Q.** What's a 5K letter? [1444:9] **A.** It's a letter that describes the extent of my cooperation and what crimes I committed. [1444:11] **Q.** If you were to violate your agreement by not telling the truth or by committing more crimes, what do you understand would happen to your cooperation agreement? [1444:14] **A.** It may not be sent. [1444:15] **Q.** What may not be sent? [1444:16] **A.** The 5K letter. It wouldn't be created and sent to the judge. [1444:18] **Q.** And could your cooperation agreement be voided? [1444:19] **A.** The agreement itself would not be voided. [1444:20] **Q.** Have you been sentenced yet to the crimes that you pled guilty to? [1444:22] **A.** Not yet. [1444:23] **Q.** What is your maximum sentence you could face? [1444:24] **A.** Seventy-five years. [1444:25] **Q.** Have you received any promises about the sentence you will [1445:1] receive? [1445:2] **A.** None. [1445:3] **Q.** Sitting here today, do you know what sentence you are going to get? [1445:5] **A.** I don't know. [1445:6] **Q.** What sentence are you hoping for? [1445:7] **A.** I'm hoping for no jail time. [1445:8] **Q.** Who decides your sentence? [1445:9] **A.** The judge does. [1445:10] **Q.** Now, does you getting a 5K letter from the government depend in any way on the outcome of this trial? [1445:12] **A.** No. [1445:13] **Q.** You said one of the crimes you pled guilty to was conspiracy to commit securities fraud? [1445:15] **A.** Yes. [1445:16] **Q.** On FTX investors. [1445:17] I want to ask you some additional questions about that. [1445:19] When you were working at FTX, did you ever work on a project relating to making FTX's revenues higher? [1445:21] **A.** Yes. [1445:22] **Q.** And when approximately was that project? [1445:23] **A.** December 30 or 31 of 2021. [1445:24] **Q.** Can you describe what the project was. [1445:25] **A.** I made transfers from one of Sam's companies to another, to [1446:1] FTX, to make it appear as though FTX had higher revenues. [1446:2] **Q.** So a few follow-up questions on this. [1446:3] First, just to be clear, where were FTX's revenues at this point in time? [1446:5] **A.** What were they for the previous year? [1446:6] **Q.** Before the project, what had FTX's revenues been calculated to? [1446:8] **A.** Around 950 or $960 million for that year. [1446:9] **Q.** What was the project that you worked on? [1446:10] **A.** Sam messaged me and Gary and possibly others, but certainly the two of us, in Signal asking what we could do to get revenue over the line of a billion dollars. [1446:13] **Q.** What, if anything, did you discuss in that Signal message -- conversation after that? [1446:15] **A.** Sam and Gary talked about a number of options. In the end, Sam landed on charging for the service of Serum staking. [1446:17] **Q.** So for starters, I think you mentioned it, but can you remind us what Serum is? [1446:19] **A.** It's a token that Sam and Gary made. [1446:20] **Q.** What is Serum staking? [1446:21] **A.** Customers could so-call stake their Serum on FTX, which entailed locking up those tokens such that they couldn't be sold, in return for some interest. [1446:24] **Q.** If you didn't sell your tokens, you got interest? [1446:25] **A.** Right. [1447:1] **Q.** And what was FTX's involvement in that? [1447:2] **A.** FTX facilitated distributing the staking rewards, facilitating the distribution of interest from the ECO Serum account. [1447:5] **Q.** Can you explain what the defendant proposed with respect to charging for that service. [1447:7] **A.** The defendant -- Sam proposed charging ECO Serum to the account that paid the interest, 25 percent of the USD equivalent of the interest distributed to FTX. [1447:10] **Q.** And how, if at all, would that affect FTX's revenues? [1447:11] **A.** It would -- I know that, after calculating, it was determined that it would bring it over the line of 1 billion. I think that it added $50 million or so in revenue. [1447:14] **Q.** Remind us, when was the date that this conversation occurred? [1447:16] **A.** It was either December 30 or 31 of 2021. [1447:17] **Q.** Was the plan to charge that $50 million amount at the end there? [1447:19] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. Leading. [1447:20] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1447:21] **Q.** What, if any, was the plan with respect to when to charge those payments to ECO Serum? [1447:23] **A.** I was told to make it appear as though they had been getting charged throughout the year, so to backdate the transactions associated with paying this fee. [1448:1] **Q.** Who told you that? [1448:2] **A.** Sam. [1448:3] **Q.** And what do you mean, backdating the charging of the fee? [1448:4] **A.** The FTX database that he looked at has time stamps in it for when transactions happen, but in some cases those time stamps are mutable and can be adjusted and changed. So I was being asked here to make transfers and then to go into the database and reassign the dates for them. [1449:1] BY MR. ROOS: [1449:2] **Q.** What would the effect have been of making those transfers? [1449:3] **A.** The effect of making the transfers would have been to increase FTX's stated revenue, but not real revenue, by some $50 million, and the effect of the backdating would be to make it appear as though that had been getting paid out throughout the year, as opposed to all at the end. [1449:8] **MR. ROOS:** Let's take a look at Government Exhibit 51. [1449:9] The government offers pursuant to S2003, stipulation. [1449:10] **THE COURT:** Received. [1449:11] (Government's Exhibit 51 received in evidence) [1449:12] **MR. ROOS:** May we publish it? [1449:13] **THE COURT:** Yes. [1449:14] BY MR. ROOS: [1449:15] **Q.** Mr. Singh, what are we looking at here? [1449:16] **A.** I recognize this as the FTX stats file, one that Sam made and posted inside a, among other places, a Slack channel that I was in that contained a lot of people, 20 or 30 people, with interest in raising, and I understand that copies of this spreadsheet or versions of it made their way into—— [1449:21] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1449:22] **THE COURT:** Sustained as to the understanding. [1449:23] **Q.** What, if anything, did you talk to the defendant or other FTX employees about what was done with this spreadsheet? [1449:25] **A.** Ramnik told me that versions of this spreadsheet made their [1450:1] way into data rooms that were shared with FTX investors. [1450:2] **Q.** Now looking at this first tab, the overview page, where does it say FTX's revenue for year 2021? [1450:4] **A.** Cell E8. [1450:5] **Q.** And what is that revenue number? [1450:6] **A.** Just over a billion dollars. [1450:7] **MR. ROOS:** Now, Mr. Ahuja, can we please see the tab FTX data. [1450:9] **Q.** Mr. Singh, where does the information for FTX data come from? [1450:11] **A.** I believe that this is a download of data that was collated and—— [1450:13] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1450:14] **THE COURT:** Yes. Sustained. Strike the answer. [1450:15] Mr. Roos, foundations are sometimes necessary. [1450:16] **MR. ROOS:** Yes, your Honor. [1450:17] So let's go over to the tab that says Staking Fees, and can we scroll down. Scroll down to like the year 2021. So you'll have to go down a bunch, maybe using the side tab. [1450:20] BY MR. ROOS: [1450:21] **Q.** And Mr. Singh, do you see a number in the column W called Staking Fees? [1450:23] **A.** I do. [1450:24] **Q.** And are you familiar with where those figures come from? [1450:25] **A.** This is a reflection of the erroneous transfers that I made [1451:1] and backdated of one of them. [1451:2] **Q.** What are you referring to? [1451:3] **A.** The transfers that I'd made on December 30th or 31st of 2021, supposedly for eco Serum paying FTX 25 percent of the USD value of the distributed interest. I made those once per month, backdated them so they looked like they happened once per month, and this is the USD value of one of those transfers. [1451:8] **Q.** Now where did you make those transfers? [1451:9] **A.** I made them using a Python script. They ended up in the FTX database. [1451:11] **Q.** Now you mentioned this is one of those monthly payments. Are there other such monthly revenue, or staking fee payments? [1451:13] **A.** Yes, one per month. [1451:14] **Q.** Throughout the period of 2021? [1451:15] **A.** Yes. [1451:16] **Q.** And are they for a month that predate December 2021? [1451:17] **A.** Yes. [1451:18] **Q.** What was the result of including these staking fees, these backdated staking fees, in the revenue total for 2021? [1451:20] **A.** It was the difference between FTX being under and over a billion dollars of revenue in 2021. [1451:22] **Q.** What, if anything, did you discuss with the defendant about backdating? [1451:24] **A.** He told me to do it. [1451:25] **Q.** What, if anything, did you learn about this, about the [1452:1] revenue number being shared with investors? [1452:2] **A.** I didn't learn anything affirmatively, but I knew it was shared. [1452:4] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1452:5] **A.** I assumed it was shared. [1452:6] **Q.** Relevant to his state of mind. [1452:7] **THE COURT:** Overruled. [1452:8] I'm sorry. I'm going to sustain that. [1452:9] **MR. ROOS:** Okay. [1452:10] **THE COURT:** The jury will disregard it. [1452:11] **Q.** Now what, if any, information about this revenue number was given to auditors? [1452:13] **A.** It was. These numbers were given to auditors. [1452:14] **Q.** Just to back up for a second, did FTX have auditors? [1452:15] **A.** Yes. [1452:16] **Q.** And what, if anything, were they doing in 2021, and 2022? [1452:17] **A.** Looking at financials for the previous years at FTX. [1452:18] **Q.** And so I think you answered that information was given to auditors. What, if anything, did auditors ask to see? [1452:20] **MR. COHEN:** Foundation, objection. [1452:21] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1452:22] **Q.** So just to take a step back, you testified that information was provided to auditors; is that right? [1452:24] **A.** Correct. [1452:25] **Q.** Did you have any conversations with auditors about the [1453:1] staking fees? [1453:2] **A.** I did. [1453:3] **Q.** And what, if anything, was asked of you about the staking fees? [1453:5] **A.** I was asked to describe what they were. [1453:6] **Q.** And to what extent, if at all, were you asked about materials relating to the staking fees? [1453:8] **A.** Jayesh, afterwards, at some point after my conversation describing the, like, technical basis for this number, asked me if there——if the auditors were interested in seeing an agreement about it. I told him I don't have the agreement and I redirected him to Sam. [1453:13] **MR. ROOS:** The government offers Exhibit 323 pursuant to stipulation S2003. [1453:15] **THE COURT:** Received. [1453:16] (Government's Exhibit 323 received in evidence) [1453:17] **MR. ROOS:** May we publish it? [1453:18] **THE COURT:** Yes. [1453:19] BY MR. ROOS: [1453:20] **Q.** Mr. Singh, at the top of this agreement it says Rewards Agent Agreement. Do you see that? [1453:22] **A.** I do. [1453:23] **Q.** And do you see the parties listed in it? [1453:24] **A.** Yes. [1453:25] **MR. ROOS:** Let's go to the end of the document. [1454:1] **Q.** What are the parties listed to the agreement on the end of the document? [1454:3] **A.** Incentive Ecosystem Foundation and FTX Trading Ltd. [1454:4] **Q.** Are you familiar with Incentive Ecosystem Foundation? [1454:5] **A.** Sort of. [1454:6] **Q.** Okay. And FTX Trading Ltd.? [1454:7] **A.** Yes. [1454:8] **Q.** And who signed on behalf of FTX Trading Ltd.? [1454:9] **A.** Sam Bankman-Fried. [1454:10] **Q.** Okay. Now let's go back to the first page. [1454:11] Do you see here where it says the fee amount that would be paid? [1454:13] **A.** Yes. [1454:14] **Q.** And what was the fee amount listed in this agreement? [1454:15] **A.** 25 percent of the distributed rewards. [1454:16] **Q.** And what fee percentage did you discuss with the defendant in December of 2021? [1454:18] **A.** 25 percent. [1454:19] **Q.** Now do you see the date on this document—— [1454:20] **A.** Yes. [1454:21] **Q.** ——at the top? And what is the date of the document? [1454:22] **A.** January 1, 2021. [1454:23] **Q.** When was it that you first discussed fees for staking Serum with the defendant? [1454:25] **A.** December 30th or 31st, 2021. [1455:1] **Q.** Let me just be clear about something. Had you seen this document back in 2021? [1455:3] **A.** No. [1455:4] **MR. ROOS:** We can take this down. [1455:5] **Q.** In addition to this——my questions to you about revenue, what, if anything, was done at FTX to remove losses from the company's expenses? [1455:8] **A.** In one instance, there were a bunch of accounts that found an exploit in Gary's original version of the spot margin system. They had essentially borrowed a lot of dollars against some MobileCoin, but if sold, the MobileCoin wasn't going to actually cover the full amount. [1455:13] **MR. COHEN:** Objection, foundation. [1455:14] **THE COURT:** Try again, Mr. Roos. The jury will disregard it. [1455:16] **Q.** So just to take it in pieces, I asked you what, if anything, was done at FTX to remove losses from the total expenses. Were there——so let me actually ask you instead: In 2021, were you aware of any losses——just yes or no——associated with problems in the margins of some? [1455:21] **A.** Yes. [1455:22] **Q.** And how did you come to learn about those losses? [1455:23] **A.** Ryan Salame and Sam Bankman-Fried sounded the alarms about somebody exploiting the margin system. [1455:25] **Q.** Can you describe what you learned. [1456:1] **A.** I learned that there were a number of accounts that had deposited a lot of MOB——or M-O-B, MobileCoin——as collateral, and had withdrawn a lot of USD against it using the spot margin system. They had done so in a way such that the——in a way that the FTX margin system essentially overvalued how much it could get out of the MobileCoin, meaning that these accounts weren't yet liquidated but really should have been much earlier. [1456:8] **Q.** And what, if any, losses resulted from this? [1456:9] **A.** I heard from Sam Bankman-Fried——he told me, after it was addressed, that the losses would constitute a fraction of Alameda's revenue that year, around $1 billion. [1456:12] **Q.** What, if anything, did the defendant say about what should be done with the loss? [1456:14] **A.** He directed the reassigning of the accounts themselves that had on these positions that should have been but were not liquidated to Alameda, meaning that Alameda absorbed the losses associated with those accounts. [1456:18] **Q.** And what, if anything, was the effect of moving those losses to Alameda's account? [1456:20] **A.** It meant that because Alameda data is not publicly shared, that these losses would not be publicly shared. [1456:22] **Q.** Okay. I want to change topics. [1456:23] Directing your attention to November of 2022. Can you, at a high level, describe what happened to FTX. [1456:25] **A.** Collapsed. Customers tried to withdraw their money and FTX [1457:1] didn't have it. [1457:2] **Q.** So let's break it down. [1457:3] Did there come a time in November 2022 when you learned about an increase in customer withdrawals? [1457:5] **A.** Yes, November 5th. [1457:6] **Q.** And what did you observe at the time? [1457:7] **A.** Clients had moved a lot of FTT that they owned on chain to their exchange. This signaled to the crypto industry that a lot of FTT was about to be sold. This followed a leak of an Alameda balance sheet that had been published a few days earlier. I was very concerned that this might spell doom and the end of our attempts to make customers whole, and the end of the ongoing fraud, and that the mechanism for the doom would have been customers withdrawing. [1457:15] **Q.** And so can you explain why you were concerned that withdrawals would be a problem for FTX. [1457:17] **A.** Because customers believed, were told that they had balances that were not backed, and so if they withdrew more than the limited funds that existed, it would become evident that there was an enormous hole and that their funds had been used. [1457:22] **Q.** Just to clarify your answer, you said customers were told that they had funds that were not backed. Did you mean customers were told that they had funds and they were not backed or customers were told they had funds but were not [1458:1] backed? [1458:2] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1458:3] **THE COURT:** Overruled. [1458:4] **A.** The former. [1458:5] **Q.** Now earlier in your testimony you told us about some loans that had been made to you for corporate purposes. Do you remember that? [1458:8] **A.** Yes. [1458:9] **Q.** When withdrawals started picking up at FTX in November 2022, what, if any, conversations did you have with the defendant about those loans? [1458:12] **A.** A few days or maybe a day after my worries, I was terrified that due to the collapse, I wouldn't be able to repay all my loans that I once thought I could, and I asked that we find an erroneous way to sort of remove them. [1458:16] **MR. ROOS:** The government offers Exhibit 480A pursuant to stipulation S2003. [1458:18] **MR. COHEN:** No objection. [1458:19] **THE COURT:** Received. [1458:20] (Government's Exhibit 480A received in evidence) [1458:21] **MR. ROOS:** May we publish it? [1458:22] **THE COURT:** You may. [1458:23] **MR. ROOS:** Could we zoom in on first the blue messages. [1458:25] **Q.** And let me ask: What is this document? [1459:1] **A.** This is a screenshot from my computer of a Signal chat with Sam. [1459:3] **Q.** And so focusing on your message——I'm sorry. Withdrawn. [1459:4] Whose message is this? [1459:5] **A.** Mine. [1459:6] **Q.** Okay. And focusing on your message, you say there, "one thing that'd seriously help me is if I didn't have debts." What debts were you referring to? [1459:9] **A.** There were hundreds of millions of dollars of loans that I had taken for the——for Alameda's and FTX's purposes, or loans that I'd taken for personal purposes but that Sam had requested I take in the form of a loan as opposed to selling my FTT. [1459:13] **Q.** And you say here, "500 million for me exercising," what's that a reference to? [1459:15] **A.** I received a $477 million on-paper loan in December or November of 2021, nominally for me to exercise shares that were granted to me. [1459:18] **Q.** And who, if anyone, had the idea for you to take that loan? [1459:19] **A.** Sam did. [1459:20] **Q.** The same sentence says, "for me exercising, more for US investments." What were you referring to there? [1459:22] **A.** There were on the order of $100 million or maybe more of other loans that ran through me for expenditures from FTX.US, things like acquiring LedgerX, acquiring Embed. [1459:25] **Q.** What do you mean by ran through you? [1460:1] **A.** Using the setup I described earlier in which the lawyers would paper up a transaction, a loan from Alameda through me, Sam, and Gary, and maybe others, but certainly the three of us, and that those funds would ultimately make their way into FTX.US's wallets and that FTX.US could spend that money to——to make acquisitions. [1460:7] **Q.** The third line here, it says, "maybe 80 million extra or so are donations/personal/etc. that went through my bank acc and are in my name." What were you referring to? [1460:10] **A.** Here I'm referring to instances in which I'd withdrawn from my FTX account using the spot margin system or instances in which Sam had given me like a loan. These are instances in which I'd first asked to sell FTT but Sam preferred I take a loan. And so these are ones that are in my name. These also include the transfers directly from Alameda into my bank accounts that, you know, weren't discussed beforehand. [1460:17] **Q.** Just so we're clear, when it says "through my bank acc," what is that? [1460:19] **A.** Bank account. [1460:20] **Q.** Now you see lower it says, "would you be ok letting me trade to get rid of the approximately 80?" What were you referring to? [1460:23] **A.** I was asking if I could make some fictitious transactions such that it looked like I had paid off this amount that I owed. [1461:1] **MR. ROOS:** Let's zoom out. [1461:2] And can we zoom in on the bottom three messages. [1461:3] **Q.** And the defendant asks, "what does trade mean?" And you say, "sell FTT or SRM earlier in 2022." What does that mean? [1461:5] **A.** I was asking if I could make a trade, selling the tokens that I had asked to previously sell, but backdating them to points that would cover the size of the loans. [1461:8] **Q.** You've mentioned FTT previously. What's SRM? [1461:9] **A.** SRM is Serum. [1461:10] **Q.** And why did you want to get out of these loans? [1461:11] **A.** I was really afraid of what it would look like, that I would look really corrupt, that I would, you know——the interpretation to them would——would be——would be really negative. [1461:15] **Q.** Why did you feel comfortable proposing a backdated transaction? [1461:17] **A.** It's something I knew could be done because Sam had proposed, you know, once to me in other contexts. [1461:19] **Q.** And the defendant says, "I think that's probably fine." After that, did you go through with this transaction? [1461:21] **A.** No. [1461:22] **Q.** Why not? [1461:23] **A.** It felt wrong. I was not——not to make an excuse for my having proposed this, not at all, but I was in different levels of having a right mind throughout these days, and in better [1462:1] moments, I didn't pursue it. [1462:2] **MR. ROOS:** We can take this down. [1462:3] **Q.** Now directing your attention to November 6, did there ever come a time where you discussed Alameda's balances with the defendant? [1462:6] **A.** Yes. [1462:7] **Q.** And what did you discuss? [1462:8] **A.** Forgive me. You're asking about November? [1462:9] **Q.** November 6. [1462:10] **A.** Yes. On November 6th, we talked about how there was a hole. [1462:12] **Q.** Any other specifics you recall? [1462:13] **A.** Sorry. This is specifically about Alameda balances? [1462:14] **Q.** Correct. [1462:15] **A.** I recall Sam drafting——Sam and Caroline drafting balance sheets that showed all of FTX and Alameda's assets versus liabilities. [1462:18] **Q.** As part of these discussions, what, if any, conversations did you have about the old FTX fiat account you testified about earlier in your testimony today? [1462:21] **A.** One of the exercises that related to determining Alameda's balances that Sam asked me for help in was giving him a list of the USD values in various accounts, much like the June exercise that we had done. He provided me a list of accounts and referenced the seoyun one, the one that now held the FTX fiat [1463:1] old obligation. [1463:2] **Q.** Let's take a look. [1463:3] **MR. ROOS:** Government offers Exhibit 480B, which is a message exchange between the witness and the defendant, pursuant to stipulation S2003. It's dated November 6, 2022. [1463:6] **THE COURT:** This is 480D or—— [1463:7] **MR. ROOS:** This is 480B as in boy. [1463:8] **THE COURT:** Thank you. Received. [1463:9] (Government's Exhibit 480B received in evidence) [1463:10] **MR. ROOS:** May we publish it? [1463:11] **THE COURT:** Yes. [1463:12] BY MR. ROOS: [1463:13] **Q.** Mr. Singh, what type of message is this? [1463:14] **A.** This is also a Signal message, this time sent from Sam. [1463:15] **Q.** And what's the date of it? [1463:16] **A.** Sunday, November 6th. [1463:17] **Q.** And focusing on the message, how, if at all, does this relate to what you were just describing about the seoyun account? [1463:20] **A.** The bottom account, in the first message, Sam's enumerating a bunch of accounts for me to grab the USD value of. In the second message, Sam says to include the seoyun one, which has the old fiat account. [1463:24] **Q.** And how did you know what the defendant was talking about? [1463:25] **A.** Because we had had the discussion months earlier about me [1464:1] moving it to——moving the FTX fiat old subaccount into a different account so that Alameda wasn't charged interest but could still know about it. [1464:4] **Q.** And several months prior, which you testified about earlier, what was the balance in that account at the time? [1464:6] **A.** Negative 8 billion. [1464:7] **MR. ROOS:** Okay. We can take this down. [1464:8] **Q.** Now let's focus on the evening of November 6. On that evening did you have any conversations with the defendant about tweeting or Twitter? [1464:11] **A.** There was a war room of sorts that had gathered in Sam's apartment in Gemini 1D with Sam, Caroline, Gary, me, Ryan Salame on the phone, Ramnik Arora, and eventually others. One of the items being discussed was how to address the crisis now at hand publicly. They were discussing versions of a tweet that Sam was workshopping. There was a point when they were discussing whether or not to characterize FTX as solvent or well capitalized. I felt very uncomfortable with both definitions. I felt neither was true. I leaned over the couch in which they were talking and said: I'm not comfortable with this. I'm recusing myself. They acknowledged in a kind of annoyed way and proceeded. [1464:23] **Q.** You used "they" a few times at the end of your statement there. Who is "they"? [1464:25] **A.** Specifically, I was leaning over the section of the couch [1465:1] with Sam and Ramnik, but the whole group heard. [1465:2] **Q.** And whose tweet were they drafting? [1465:3] **A.** Drafting a potential tweet for Sam to send. [1465:4] **Q.** And you said you recused yourself. Is that something——what did you mean by that? [1465:6] **A.** I don't know that I had the most precise definition at the time. I mostly wanted to express that I didn't approve of this and——but I didn't——I acknowledged I didn't have the power to stop them. I'd already made clear my preferences on what to say and so I just didn't want to be involved. [1465:11] **Q.** Why weren't you comfortable with the tweeting? [1465:12] **A.** It was really dishonest, and I was, you know——I'd been asking if we could just halt withdrawals instead. [1465:14] **Q.** Did the defendant tweet after that? [1465:15] **A.** Yes. [1465:16] **Q.** Showing you now Government Exhibit 866, which is in evidence. --- **About this text version** This is a text version of the court reporter’s transcript of the testimony of Nishad Singh at the trial of Samuel Bankman-Fried, *United States v. Samuel Bankman-Fried*, 22 Cr. 673 (LAK), before Judge Lewis A. Kaplan and a jury in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York. The government called Singh as a witness on October 16, 2023, and he was excused on October 17, 2023. His testimony runs from page 1298 to page 1623 of the trial transcript, which was prepared by Southern District Reporters, P.C. **Note by this site, not part of the document:** Direct examination by the government begins at trial transcript page 1298 (ECF No. 366), cross-examination by Bankman-Fried’s counsel at page 1492 (ECF No. 368), and redirect at page 1618. Singh’s account of when and how he learned of the hole in customer funds, his choice to stay and become complicit in the conspiracy, and his actions in the short period before the collapse is mainly at pages 1388 to 1417 and 1456 to 1473. - This is part 7 of 13 of the text version, covering pages 1440 to 1465. The document is divided so that software which reads only the beginning of a long page can still read all of it. Other parts: [part 1](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-1.html), [part 2](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-2.html), [part 3](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-3.html), [part 4](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-4.html), [part 5](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-5.html), [part 6](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-6.html), [part 8](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-8.html), [part 9](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-9.html), [part 10](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-10.html), [part 11](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-11.html), [part 12](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-12.html), [part 13](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-13.html). The whole document on one page: [trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17.html](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17.html). PDFs of the court reporter’s transcript for the two days, each holding the whole trial day except the pages sealed by the court, are held here: [October 16](pdf/2023-10-16-trial-transcript.pdf) and [October 17](pdf/2023-10-17-trial-transcript.pdf). The copies filed on the court’s docket are on CourtListener: [ECF No. 366](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.590940/gov.uscourts.nysd.590940.366.0.pdf) and [ECF No. 368](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.590940/gov.uscourts.nysd.590940.368.0.pdf). This part as plain text: [trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-7.txt](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-7.txt). The other documents from the case: [index](index.html). - It was made from a text extraction of the transcript for the two trial days and then compared by machine, line by line, with the PDFs of the court reporter’s transcript that are held here: each of the 7,473 lines of the testimony holds the same words at the same page and line number as in the PDF. The held PDFs do not bear the filing stamp of the court’s docket; the copies filed on the docket are ECF Nos. 366 and 368. If this text differs from the official transcript, the official transcript controls. - A marker such as `[1604:12]` gives the transcript page and line at which the text after it begins. There is a marker at the start of every paragraph and wherever a new page begins, so `[1604:1]` is the top of page 1604. Court filings cite the same page numbers: “Trial Tr. at 1604” means page 1604. - The original is typed 25 numbered lines to a page. Here each paragraph runs on as ordinary text. The line numbers, the reporter’s running header and footer, and the double spaces of the typescript are not reproduced. The line number in each marker is the number printed beside that line in the PDF. 18 pages are not full. The reporter’s note “(Continued on next page)”, which stands at the foot of 17 pages, is left out. - It covers the testimony from the moment the witness was called until he was excused, including the conferences at the bench and the discussions between the judge and the lawyers that took place in between. The places where the transcript for these two days is not reproduced, and the pages that are sealed, are noted in italics. - A paragraph begins here where the typescript labels a question, an answer or a speaker, or indents a line. The heading of each examination and the caption that names the witness are each kept as one paragraph. - The speaker labels, including Q. and A., are set in bold for readability; the original does not do that. The two headings that give the date were added. Dashes are reproduced as they appear, which differs between the court reporters who took turns: some typed `--` and some typed long dashes. - Nothing has been corrected.