# Trial Testimony of Nishad Singh, October 16 and 17, 2023: Transcript [Index](index.html) · [PDF, October 16](pdf/2023-10-16-trial-transcript.pdf) · [PDF, October 17](pdf/2023-10-17-trial-transcript.pdf) · [Web page](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17.html) · Parts: [1](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-1.html) [2](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-2.html) [3](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-3.html) [4](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-4.html) [5](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-5.html) [6](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-6.html) [7](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-7.html) [8](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-8.html) [9](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-9.html) [10](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-10.html) [11](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-11.html) [12](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-12.html) [13](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-13.html) · About this text version: at the end of this page **Contents** (added for navigation; not part of the document) - Monday, October 16, 2023 (pages 1298 to 1473) - DIRECT EXAMINATION (page 1298) - Tuesday, October 17, 2023 (pages 1492 to 1623) - CROSS EXAMINATION (page 1492) - REDIRECT EXAMINATION (page 1618) --- ## Monday, October 16, 2023 [1298:14] **MR. ROOS:** Thank you, your Honor. The government calls Nishad Singh. [1298:16] NISHAD SINGH, called as a witness by the government, having been duly sworn, testified as follows: [1298:19] **THE COURT:** You may proceed, Mr. Roos. [1298:20] **MR. ROOS:** Thank you, your Honor. ### [1298:21] DIRECT EXAMINATION [1298:22] BY MR. ROOS: [1298:23] **Q.** Mr. Singh, where were you working last year? [1298:24] **A.** At FTX. [1298:25] **Q.** What was your job at FTX? [1299:1] **A.** I was the head of engineering. [1299:2] **Q.** Did you commit financial crimes while at FTX? [1299:3] **A.** I did. [1299:4] **Q.** What crimes did you commit while working at the company? [1299:5] **A.** I defrauded customers, investors, I participated in money laundering, and I violated campaign finance laws. [1299:7] **Q.** Did you commit those crimes on your own or with others? [1299:8] **A.** With others. [1299:9] **Q.** Who? [1299:10] **A.** Sam Bankman-Fried, Gary Wang, Caroline Ellison, Ryan Salame. [1299:12] **Q.** Who did you defraud? [1299:13] **A.** FTX customers and investors. [1299:14] **Q.** How were those customers and investors defrauded? [1299:15] **A.** For the customers, their money was being spent and they didn't know it. For the investors, they were -- they weren't told of the large hole and were given financials that were doctored. [1299:19] **Q.** And what was your role in the fraud against FTX's customers that you committed with the defendant? [1299:21] **A.** In September of 2022, I learned of the hole. And even after that, implicitly and explicitly, I green-lit transactions that I knew must have been digging the hole deeper and therefore coming from customer funds. [1299:25] **Q.** When you are using the word the hole, what are you [1300:1] referring to? [1300:2] **A.** Like the large deficit in funds that FTX should have had on hand to supply customer withdrawals. [1300:4] **Q.** How large was that hole? [1300:5] **A.** I'm sure it varied over time. When I learned of it in September, my belief is that it was $8 billion. [1300:7] **Q.** Just yes or no, did there come a time you learned what happened with some of the customer money? [1300:9] **A.** Yes. September 2022. [1300:10] **Q.** Two questions on that. [1300:11] First, how did you learn what happened with the money? [1300:12] **A.** From conversations with Sam, Gary, and Caroline. [1300:13] **Q.** So what did you learn what happened with the money? [1300:14] **A.** I learned that there was a hole that was enormous and that it had been spent and lost by Alameda, and I knew that it was $8 billion in size. So the last $8 billion of spend had necessarily come from customers. That spend included things like real estate investments, VC investments, campaign donations, and speculative events in trading. [1300:20] **Q.** You used the word VC. What does that mean? [1300:21] **A.** Venture capital. Alameda acted as a venture capital firm in this crypto space. [1300:23] **Q.** And what is venture capital exactly? Can you give us an example? [1300:25] **A.** Yeah. Maybe one summary is that it's the practice of [1301:1] investing money in other companies hoping for returns. [1301:2] **Q.** Now, you mentioned you committed -- [1301:3] **THE COURT:** Excuse me. Is that any different from buying stock in Apple today or in Google today or in General Motors today? Is venture capital any different from that? [1301:6] **THE WITNESS:** One distinction is, I think often venture capital is done with private equity, so you are not buying something that's publicly traded. [1301:9] **THE COURT:** Go ahead. [1301:10] **Q.** You mentioned you committed financial crimes at FTX. [1301:11] Have you pled guilty to those crimes? [1301:12] **A.** I have. [1301:13] **Q.** Are you testifying here today under a cooperation agreement? [1301:15] **A.** Yes. [1301:16] **Q.** We will talk about all of that a little further. I want to take a step back and ask you about your background. [1301:18] Where did you grow up? [1301:19] **A.** The bay area in California. [1301:20] **Q.** Where did you go to high school? [1301:21] **A.** Crystal Springs Uplands School. [1301:22] **Q.** When did you first meet the defendant, Sam Bankman-Fried? [1301:23] **A.** I think in my sophomore or junior year of high school. [1301:24] **Q.** Were you friends in high school? [1301:25] **A.** I wasn't friends with Sam, but I was close friends with his [1302:1] younger brother, Gabe. [1302:2] **Q.** After high school, did you go to college? [1302:3] **A.** Yes. [1302:4] **Q.** And where did you go to college? [1302:5] **A.** UC Berkeley. [1302:6] **Q.** What did you study at UC Berkeley? [1302:7] **A.** Electrical engineering and computer science. [1302:8] **Q.** What did you do after college? [1302:9] **A.** I briefly worked at Facebook. [1302:10] **Q.** Did there come a time you started working with the defendant? [1302:12] **A.** Yes. [1302:13] **Q.** Approximately when was that? [1302:14] **A.** Late 2017. [1302:15] **Q.** And where did you start working with him? [1302:16] **A.** Alameda Research. [1302:17] **Q.** Who ran Alameda Research at that point in time? [1302:18] **A.** Sam and Gary. [1302:19] **Q.** And what was Sam Bankman-Fried's job at Alameda Research at the time? [1302:21] **A.** He was the CEO, the head trader, and founder. [1302:22] **Q.** What about Gary Wang's job? [1302:23] **A.** Gary was the CTO and a founder. [1302:24] **Q.** What was your position at Alameda Research? [1302:25] **A.** I was a software engineer. [1303:1] **Q.** So were you a manager in any way? [1303:2] **A.** Not initially. [1303:3] **Q.** And what did you do as a software engineer at Alameda Research? [1303:5] **A.** I wrote code that improved or built out trading systems for the traders to use. [1303:7] **Q.** While working at Alameda, did you meet someone named Caroline Ellison? [1303:9] **A.** Yes. [1303:10] **Q.** What was her job at Alameda? [1303:11] **A.** She was a trader. [1303:12] **Q.** Now, did there come a time where you changed jobs? [1303:13] **A.** Yes. [1303:14] **Q.** Where did you start working? [1303:15] **A.** At FTX. [1303:16] **Q.** When was that? [1303:17] **A.** It was in mid 2019. [1303:18] **Q.** What was your initial job at FTX? [1303:19] **A.** Similar. Software engineer. [1303:20] **Q.** So what kind of things did you do at FTX as a software engineer? [1303:22] **A.** It was pretty similar to what I did in Alameda in that I was coding at Sam and Gary's direction, this time not to build out trading systems, but instead to build out the site for other customers to trade on. [1304:1] **Q.** You just mentioned Gary Wang. What was his job at FTX? [1304:2] **A.** Gary was the CTO. [1304:3] **Q.** What is CTO stand for? [1304:4] **A.** Chief technology officer. [1304:5] **Q.** Now, how, if at all, was your job similar to Gary Wang's job at FTX? [1304:7] **A.** It was similar in that we both wrote code. [1304:8] **Q.** Did one of you supervise the other, or were you equals? [1304:9] **A.** We weren't equals. Gary supervised me. On every technical decision of importance I would either get direction from him or advice or leave it to him. [1304:12] **Q.** You mentioned coding. Did the defendant do any coding at FTX? [1304:14] **A.** He did not code himself, but he was very involved in the coding process. [1304:16] **Q.** Can you explain what you mean by that. [1304:17] **A.** Yeah. There is the act of writing code and then there is the act of designing it and thinking about it and architecting it. Sam did not write the code, but he did a lot of the rest of that stuff. He was really involved in the sort of minutia of the architecture of FTX. [1304:22] **Q.** Let me ask you a follow-up question on that. [1304:23] First, the writing of code, what do you mean by that? What is the writing of code? [1304:25] **A.** Yeah. It looks like you are typing out words like you [1305:1] might in a Word document, only it's in a non-English language, like Python or JavaScript. [1305:3] **Q.** Then you said the architecture of the code -- [1305:4] **THE COURT:** Slow down, please. [1305:5] Please tell the jury what those various terms you just used mean. [1305:7] **THE WITNESS:** Python is a programming language in which you can express logic for a computer to execute. JavaScript is a different programming language. [1305:10] **Q.** Thank you. [1305:11] You also mentioned the defendant's involvement in the architecture of the code. What were you referring to? [1305:13] **A.** Sam directed a lot of these specifics of how the code should run and what it should be doing. As an example, Sam designed all the rules for the margin system and the liquidation engine, and Gary implemented them. [1305:17] **THE COURT:** You better tell us what those things are. [1305:18] **THE WITNESS:** Yeah. The margin and liquidation systems are -- they were core to FTX. They were the things that considered users' balances and decided how much they could trade with them, when they should be closed out to prevent losses, and, in general, how assets were considered on the system. [1305:24] **THE COURT:** Proceed. [1305:25] **MR. ROOS:** Thank you, your Honor. [1306:1] **Q.** Who were the founders, by the way, of FTX? [1306:2] **A.** Sam and Gary were. [1306:3] **Q.** And were they equals at the company? [1306:4] **A.** No. [1306:5] **Q.** Were there parts of the business -- sorry. Just to follow up, you said no to whether they were equals. Can you explain the relationship dynamic. [1306:8] **A.** Yes. Gary took instruction from Sam. Gary was in charge of all of the code and the technical systems, and Sam frequently deferred to him on those topics. But on business decisions or on -- almost anything on technical, meetings with investors, any sort of public statements, managing other departments, legal, Sam was in charge. [1306:14] **Q.** Were there parts of the business that you observed the defendant being involved in that Mr. Wang was not involved with? [1306:17] **A.** Yes. [1306:18] **Q.** And what were those parts? [1306:19] **A.** Marketing, raising from investors, sort of running a lot of Alameda's trading, things like endorsement deals, high-level business decisions. [1306:22] **Q.** What do you mean by raising? [1306:23] **A.** Selling FTX equity to investors. [1306:24] **Q.** And you mentioned earlier in your testimony venture capital, or VC. How, if at all, were either Gary or Sam [1307:1] Bankman-Fried involved in that? [1307:2] **A.** I don't think that Gary was involved, but I'm not sure because I wasn't in those meetings myself. I know Sam was very involved in VC investing. [1307:5] **Q.** How do you know that? [1307:6] **A.** From conversations with Sam about it. [1307:7] **Q.** Now, who did you report to at FTX? [1307:8] **A.** Sam and Gary and in various projects other people, but primarily Sam and Gary. [1307:10] **Q.** Did that ever change over time? [1307:11] **A.** No. [1307:12] **Q.** Were there aspects of the business you observed the defendant involved in that you yourself were not involved in? [1307:14] **A.** Yes. [1307:15] **Q.** Which? [1307:16] **A.** A bunch of the ones I had mentioned about -- that Gary wasn't involved in but Sam was: Marketing, raising, making public statements, legal decisions, high-level business decisions. [1307:20] **Q.** Focusing on your role and responsibilities at FTX, how, if at all, did those change over time? [1307:22] **A.** In 2020, I started managing other engineers and growing out the team, other junior engineers, not Gary. And as a part of that I became more involved in management discussions going forward. [1308:1] **Q.** Did you ever live with the defendant? [1308:2] **A.** I did. [1308:3] **Q.** Where and when? [1308:4] **A.** Starting in December of 2021, I lived with him in Albany, which is a luxury resort in the Bahamas. [1308:6] **Q.** Where in Albany did you live with him? [1308:7] **A.** In the Orchid 6 penthouse. [1308:8] **Q.** How would you describe your relationship with the defendant over time? [1308:10] **A.** I have always been intimidated by Sam. [1308:11] **MR. COHEN:** Objecting. Move to strike. [1308:12] **THE COURT:** Ground. [1308:13] **MR. COHEN:** Calls for speculation. [1308:14] **THE COURT:** Overruled. [1308:15] **Q.** How would you describe your relationship with the defendant over time? [1308:17] **A.** Sam is a formidable character, brilliant, so I had a lot of admiration and respect for him. Over time I think a lot of that eroded, and I grew distrustful. [1308:20] **Q.** When you worked at FTX, did you own equity in the company? [1308:21] **A.** I did. [1308:22] **Q.** Approximately how much? [1308:23] **A.** Around 6 or 7 percent. [1308:24] **Q.** On paper, how wealthy did that make you? [1308:25] **A.** I was a billionaire. [1309:1] **Q.** You testified that you were not one of FTX's founders. Who gave you this valuable stake in FTX? [1309:3] **A.** Sam and the lawyers did. [1309:4] **Q.** And how did your stake compare to the defendant's? [1309:5] **A.** It was smaller than Sam's. [1309:6] **Q.** How about to Gary Wang's stake? [1309:7] **A.** Smaller than Gary's. [1309:8] **Q.** Were you aware of anyone besides Sam Bankman-Fried and Gary Wang who had a larger stake than you and worked at FTX? [1309:10] **A.** None others. [1309:11] **Q.** What's your understanding of why you were awarded such a large -- relatively large stake in the company? [1309:13] **A.** In 2020, I asked to not be paid bonuses anymore and instead have equity. It's a lot more efficient for long-term donations. Sam agreed. [1309:16] **Q.** In addition to owning FTX stock, did you get a salary? [1309:17] **A.** Yes. [1309:18] **Q.** And what was your annual salary? [1309:19] **A.** $200,000. [1309:20] **Q.** Did you receive any bonuses? [1309:21] **A.** I did until 2020. [1309:22] **Q.** How much were those bonuses that you did receive? [1309:23] **A.** On the order of a million dollars. [1309:24] **Q.** In addition to the salary, the bonuses, the stock, were you ever given any loans by the company? [1310:1] **A.** I was. [1310:2] **Q.** Were those loans for personal uses or corporate uses or both? [1310:4] **A.** Both. [1310:5] **Q.** We will circle back to that in a bit. [1310:6] While you were working at FTX, did you ever use any form of money from the exchange, so stock, cryptocurrency, loans to make large purchases or payments? [1310:9] **A.** Yes. I made a large investment, I made many donations, and I gave gifts to friends and family. [1310:11] **Q.** When you started working at FTX, did you continue to work at Alameda? [1310:13] **A.** Yes. [1310:14] **Q.** Until what point? [1310:15] **A.** I am not sure exactly when, but I think sometime early or mid 2020. [1310:17] **Q.** Just to be clear, as of early or mid 2020, did you stop working at Alameda? [1310:19] **A.** Right, yes. [1310:20] **Q.** And you only worked at FTX at that point? [1310:21] **A.** Correct. [1310:22] **Q.** By 2022, were you working at Alameda Research at all? [1310:23] **A.** Not at all. [1310:24] **Q.** Who was in charge of Alameda at that point? [1310:25] **A.** Nominally, Caroline Ellison and Sam Trabucco. Ultimately, [1311:1] Sam Bankman-Fried. [1311:2] **Q.** What do you mean by nominally? [1311:3] **A.** Trabucco and Caroline had been named the co-CEOs of Alameda. My understanding is that in the end Sam held a lot of the final say. [1311:6] **Q.** That year, so 2022, what observations if any, did you make about the defendant's involvement in Alameda? [1311:8] **A.** There were a lot of things. Sam had a six-monitor setup, two tall, three wide. In his middle top monitor I saw a spreadsheet pretty frequently there that had Alameda's trading positions. [1311:12] Sam also sometimes had the pointer balances page open. Pointer is like the Alameda trading UI. So this would have displayed all of Alameda's balances on different exchanges and their loans and such as far as that system tracked. [1311:16] Sam also, as far as I understand, unilaterally, without going through Caroline or Sam Trabucco, spent a lot of Alameda's money with the layers effectuating loans through people like me to get them into FTX US or making investments from Alameda Research ventures. [1311:21] I'm sorry. This answer is long. I know. [1311:22] He referenced to me that he had threatened to fire various people at Alameda, including Caroline, implying that he held that power as well. [1312:1] BY MR. ROOS: [1312:2] **Q.** You used the term UI when talking about the pointer page with balances. What does UI mean? [1312:4] **A.** User interface. It's like the website that you'd use. [1312:5] **Q.** You mentioned the defendant's spending at Alameda. How would you describe the defendant's approach to spending? [1312:7] **A.** Excessive. [1312:8] **Q.** What do you mean by that? [1312:9] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. Can we have a foundation, your Honor. [1312:11] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1312:12] **Q.** So, Mr. Singh, did you, in 2022, observe spending by the defendant? [1312:14] **A.** Yes. [1312:15] **Q.** Did you have conversations with the defendant about his spending? [1312:17] **A.** Many. [1312:18] **Q.** In the course of those conversations——we'll start at a high level——did you ever express a view as to his approach to spending? [1312:21] **A.** Many times. [1312:22] **Q.** How would you describe your view of the defendant's approach to spending? [1312:24] **A.** I often learned about large incidents of spend after the fact and got conflicting reports of how much was spent or who [1313:1] was in charge. I'd frequently go to Sam and express that I thought that, you know——my complaints varied by the instance, but that the spend was too large or that it didn't make sense——in essence, a bad business decision——and I also would express that I felt kind of embarrassed and ashamed of how——how much it all reeked of excess and flashiness. It didn't align with what I thought we were building a company for. [1313:8] **Q.** What was the defendant's reaction, if any, when you expressed disagreement with spending? [1313:10] **A.** Also varied by the instance. Most cases I just didn't get a response. In some cases Sam would correctly state that I didn't have sufficient context to evaluate the spending decisions but Sam did because he was sort of out and interacting with the people that were targets of it. I'd hear that, you know, my opinions had already been factored in and if they, you know——he would——I didn't need to continue sharing them. In one instance, with other people around in the office, when I thought we had been fleeced for $20 million, Sam got visibly mad at me and said——he said that it was, you know, people like me sowing seeds of doubt in the company decisions that were the real insidious problem here. It was pretty humiliating. [1313:23] **Q.** Now I want to talk more specifically about the spending that was happening in late 2021 and 2022. [1313:25] Let's just start by category. You mentioned venture [1314:1] spending. What are you referring to? [1314:2] **A.** Venture investments made by Sam and Ramnik and others. [1314:3] **Q.** And then besides the venture spending, what were some of the other categories of spending that you observed in late 2021 and early 2022? [1314:6] **A.** There was large amounts of spending on real estate and endorsement deals, things like deals with celebrities or stadiums. [1314:9] **Q.** Okay. Let's start by talking about venture spending. [1314:10] **MR. ROOS:** And pursuant to stipulation S2003, the government offers Government Exhibit 14A, which, according to the stipulation, is a spreadsheet titled Venture Deals, dated June 17, 2022. [1314:14] **THE COURT:** Stipulation Exhibit S2003 and Government Exhibit 14A are received. [1314:16] (Government's Exhibits S2003 14A received in evidence) [1314:17] **MR. ROOS:** May we publish it? [1314:18] **THE COURT:** You may. [1314:19] BY MR. ROOS: [1314:20] **Q.** Now, Mr. Singh, do you see a spreadsheet on your screen? [1314:21] **A.** I do. [1314:22] **Q.** And are you familiar with some of the——do you see the column that says A on it? [1314:24] **A.** Mm-hmm, yes. [1314:25] **Q.** Do you see below it project names? [1315:1] **A.** Yes. [1315:2] **Q.** Are you familiar with some of the project names listed on this spreadsheet? [1315:4] **A.** Yes, some of them. [1315:5] **Q.** And why don't we, I guess——are you able to see the project names fully? [1315:7] **A.** Some are a little cut off, but I can see most of them. [1315:8] **Q.** Okay. So starting with the top of the sheet, do you see in column A2 and A3, Genesis Digital Assets? [1315:10] **A.** Yes. [1315:11] **Q.** And do you see the——in column E, what the category of that is? [1315:13] **A.** Yes. Mining. [1315:14] **Q.** So are you familiar with an investment in Genesis or a mining company? [1315:16] **A.** Yeah. I don't——yes. I don't recognize the name Genesis Digital Assets, but I know that Sam, Ramnik, and Ryan Salame visited Kazakhstan sometime in late 2021 or early 2022 to look into making a deal with a mining firm there, and I heard later in 2022 from Ramnik that they had spent a billion dollars on it. [1315:22] **THE COURT:** Let me just interpose another dumb question. When I was your age, mining basically referred to digging in the ground for gold and coal and stuff like that. That's not what you're talking about, is it? [1316:1] **THE WITNESS:** Almost in some ways, but no, not exactly. [1316:3] **THE COURT:** Well, would you explain what you were talking about. [1316:5] **THE WITNESS:** Yeah. Cryptocurrencies——proof-of-work cryptocurrencies relied on a large amount of compute being spent to solve problems, and there are big rewards, like in Bitcoin, in the case of the Bitcoin chain, for doing so. Mining is the activity of throwing a bunch of compute at those problems to get Bitcoin. [1316:11] **THE COURT:** Well, I'm sure that's the best I'm going to get. I'm not sure how it's going to help me, but the jury is smarter than I am, and we'll go on. [1316:14] **MR. ROOS:** I'm tempted to take a shot here. [1316:15] **THE COURT:** Feel free. [1316:16] BY MR. ROOS: [1316:17] **Q.** Mr. Singh, so at a very high level, what is a crypto mining company making? [1316:19] **A.** It doesn't really produce physical goods. It instead has a bunch of computers that try to solve problems. Those problems, when solved, are used to bundle together a bunch of transactions on a blockchain, making them official, and making them part of the chain. [1316:24] And so the service they provide is——is sort of verifying and making official transactions that other people [1317:1] have proposed, and their reward is that the chain natively gives them a Bitcoin——it's one or some number of them——every time they do so. [1317:4] **THE COURT:** And please forgive me if we've done this before, but tell everybody what a blockchain is. [1317:6] **THE WITNESS:** It's an electronic database that tracks——it tracks a lot of transactions, but doesn't live in one place; it lives in a distributed manner across many people's computers. [1317:10] BY MR. ROOS: [1317:11] **Q.** And you mentioned an amount. Take a look at column F at the top. Do you see the two transaction amounts at the top there? [1317:14] **A.** Yes. [1317:15] **Q.** And what's their total together for Genesis? [1317:16] **A.** 150——sorry——1,050,000,000. [1317:17] **Q.** And how does that compare to the amount you had heard had been spent on the mining company? [1317:19] **A.** I'd heard 1 billion, so it's pretty close. [1317:20] **Q.** Now take a look at column K, and the first two lines there under Investment Entity. And what is the investment entity listed for this Genesis Digital Assets investment? [1317:23] **A.** Alameda Research LLC. [1317:24] **Q.** What, if any, involvement did the defendant have in acquiring or investing in the mining company you heard about? [1318:1] **A.** I think he was calling the shots there. He went to go visit them for multiple days. That's a pretty extreme sort of sacrifice in Sam's calendar. [1318:4] **THE COURT:** How do you know that? [1318:5] **THE WITNESS:** I don't know that he was the one to pull the trigger on the investment. I do know that Sam was in general the one making the final decision on investments and investment team decisions as a whole. [1318:9] **THE COURT:** And how do you know that? [1318:10] **THE WITNESS:** Conversations with Sam and Ramnik and overhearing their process. [1318:12] **THE COURT:** Proceed. [1318:13] **MR. ROOS:** Thank you, your Honor. [1318:14] BY MR. ROOS: [1318:15] **Q.** Let's take a look at row 4 here on the spreadsheet. Do you see a payment to a project name called Anthropic and the investment amount of $499,999,900? [1318:18] **A.** Yes. [1318:19] **Q.** Are you familiar with Anthropic? [1318:20] **A.** Yes, I am. [1318:21] **Q.** What is it? [1318:22] **A.** It's an AI company focused on AI safety. [1318:23] **Q.** Do you know what the almost $500 million to Anthropic was for? [1318:25] **A.** I know what we were told it was for. It was compute. [1319:1] **Q.** What do you mean by that? [1319:2] **MR. COHEN:** Objection, hearsay. [1319:3] **Q.** Who told you that? [1319:4] **A.** Dario Amodei——I don't know if I'm getting the pronunciation right——who runs Anthropic. [1319:6] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1319:7] **Q.** Just at a high level, not how the funds would be used, but why was money being sent to——withdrawn. [1319:9] To what extent, if at all, was this an investment or acquisition of Anthropic? [1319:11] **A.** It was an investment. [1319:12] **MR. COHEN:** Objection, foundation. [1319:13] **THE COURT:** Answer stricken. You can lay a foundation, if you can. [1319:15] **Q.** Did you have conversations with the defendant about a payment to Anthropic? [1319:17] **A.** I did. [1319:18] **Q.** And what did you understand the payment was for? [1319:19] **THE COURT:** Let's start with what was said. [1319:20] **Q.** What did the defendant say to you? [1319:21] **A.** That we were going to invest $500 million in Anthropic. [1319:22] **Q.** Okay. And what involvement, if any, did the defendant have in the Anthropic investment? [1319:24] **A.** Extreme amount of involvement. I was in the Hong Kong office—— [1320:1] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1320:2] **THE COURT:** What's the objection? [1320:3] **MR. COHEN:** Foundation. [1320:4] **THE COURT:** Yes. Mr. Roos. [1320:5] **Q.** Did you observe the defendant having any involvement in Anthropic? [1320:7] **A.** Yes. [1320:8] **Q.** ——in the Anthropic investment? [1320:9] **A.** Yes. [1320:10] **Q.** Did you have conversations with the defendant about the Anthropic investment? [1320:12] **A.** Yes. [1320:13] **Q.** Based on your conversations and your observations, what, if any, involvement did the defendant have in the Anthropic investment? [1320:16] **A.** He set it up and decided on it. [1320:17] **Q.** What entity does the spreadsheet say was the investment entity for these Anthropic investments? [1320:19] **A.** Alameda Research Ventures LLC. [1320:20] **Q.** Take a look at row 7. And do you see in row 7 the project name is K5? [1320:22] **A.** Yes. [1320:23] **Q.** Do you see the investment amount is $200 million? [1320:24] **A.** Yes. [1320:25] **Q.** And do you see on the spreadsheet in column C who it says [1321:1] the lead is on this investment? [1321:2] **A.** Sam Bankman-Fried. [1321:3] **Q.** Okay. Now who ran K5? [1321:4] **A.** Michael Kives and Bryan Baum. [1321:5] **Q.** Do you know——just yes or no: Do you know whether or not the defendant ever met Michael Kives and Bryan Baum? [1321:7] **A.** I do. Yes, he did. [1321:8] **Q.** And—— [1321:9] **THE COURT:** How do you know that? [1321:10] **THE WITNESS:** I saw them meeting. [1321:11] **THE COURT:** Thank you. [1321:12] **Q.** And did you ever speak to the defendant about meeting Michael Kives and Bryan Baum? [1321:14] **A.** Yes. [1321:15] **Q.** And what, if anything, did he say to you about that? [1321:16] **A.** He was very impressed with their——their level of connection to influential celebrities and entrepreneurs. He thought it would be useful for FTX to leverage those connections. [1321:19] **Q.** Are you familiar with a document about why FTX should partner with K5? [1321:21] **A.** Yes. [1321:22] **MR. ROOS:** Pursuant to stipulation S2003, the government offers Exhibit 42, which, according to the stipulation, is a document titled K5 Relationships and Marketing, dated February 15, 2022. [1322:1] **THE COURT:** It's received. [1322:2] (Government's Exhibit 42 received in evidence) [1322:3] **MR. ROOS:** May we publish? [1322:4] **THE COURT:** You may. [1322:5] **MR. ROOS:** And can we zoom in on the first, let's say, third of this first page. [1322:7] BY MR. ROOS: [1322:8] **Q.** Mr. Singh, have you seen this document before? [1322:9] **A.** Yes, I have. [1322:10] **Q.** What was the context of you seeing it? [1322:11] **A.** Sam sent this to a group of a bunch of people in some form of leadership at FTX. I think it was in the Signal chat called hashtag meetings. [1322:14] **Q.** And what, if anything, did he say about the document? [1322:15] **A.** I don't know——I can't remember anything he said about the document. I just know what the document says. [1322:17] **Q.** Now—— [1322:18] **THE COURT:** Excuse me. Was this sent to you as part of this leadership group or did you come to see it some other way? [1322:21] **THE WITNESS:** I was in that group, so it was sent to me. [1322:23] **THE COURT:** Thank you. [1322:24] Mr. Roos, please. I don't want to have to do this every time. [1323:1] **MR. ROOS:** Thank you, your Honor. [1323:2] BY MR. ROOS: [1323:3] **Q.** Let's start at the top of the document. It says, "In LA last weekend, I met with Michael Kives and his firm, K5." [1323:5] At around the time did you have any conversations with the defendant about meeting with Michael Kives and his firm K5? [1323:7] **A.** Yes. [1323:8] **Q.** And what, if anything, did he say? [1323:9] **A.** Sam said that he had gone to a post- or pre-Super Bowl party in LA and that he had met the most impressive collection of people he ever had in one location and that that dinner party in which he met them was organized by the two folks at K5. [1323:14] **Q.** Now the document says, "In attendance at the dinner at his house were," and lists a bunch of names. Do you see that? [1323:16] **A.** Yes. [1323:17] **Q.** Do you recall the defendant telling you about the dinner? [1323:18] **A.** Yes. [1323:19] **Q.** And now with this list of names of people who were at the dinner, if you recognize a person or people on the list, can you say who they are. [1323:22] **A.** Sure. I can go through them now? [1323:23] **Q.** Please. [1323:24] **A.** Hilary Clinton. She was a presidential candidate. [1323:25] **MR. COHEN:** Stipulated. [1324:1] **THE COURT:** Thank you, Mr. Cohen. [1324:2] **MR. ROOS:** Your Honor, can the witness proceed. [1324:3] **THE COURT:** The witness can proceed. [1324:4] **A.** Doug Emhoff, who is Kamala Harris's husband; Katy Perry is a singer; Orlando Bloom is an actor; Kate Hudson I believe is an actress; Leonardo DiCaprio is an actor; Jeff Bezos ran Amazon. I don't know No. 8. I don't know No. 11. Kendall and Kris Jenner, I honestly could not tell you what they do. [1324:9] **MR. ROOS:** Okay. We can zoom out. [1324:10] **Q.** Now part way down the page, do you see the heading that says "They want with us"? [1324:12] **MR. ROOS:** Can we zoom in on that section. [1324:13] **Q.** And No. 6 says, "Maybe us to invest in them or some stuff, idk." What is "idk"? [1324:15] **A.** "I don't know." [1324:16] **MR. ROOS:** If we could zoom out on this part. And can we zoom in on the part that says, "We get from them." [1324:18] **Q.** It says, "We can get from them essentially infinite connections. I think that if we asked them to arrange a dinner with us, Elon, Obama, Rihanna and Zuckerberg in a month, they would probably succeed." [1324:22] Did you have any conversations with the defendant about getting connections through Michael Kives or K5? [1324:24] **A.** Yes. [1324:25] **Q.** And what, if anything, did the defendant say to you about [1325:1] the purpose of getting connections? [1325:2] **A.** That it would be extremely valuable for FTX's and his own reputation and influence. [1325:4] **Q.** The second number here says, "Potential endorsement deals"; the third says, "Potential unpaid partnerships with celebrities"; the fourth says, "Working together on electoral politics." What, if anything, did the defendant say to you about why those things mattered? [1325:9] **A.** I think he said that these are all areas in which increasing FTX's influence would help propel its success, that endorsement deals and celebrities can promote FTX. I don't recall explicitly talking about the relationship between K5 and electoral politics. [1325:14] **MR. ROOS:** Now let's zoom out from here and go to the next page. [1325:16] And can we zoom in on the last paragraph. [1325:17] **Q.** And do you see the second sentence that says, In particular I think it's something of a one-stop shop for relationships that we should utilize, and can supersede a lot of other things we have"? [1325:21] **A.** I see that. [1325:22] **Q.** Besides writing that document, did you ever——did the defendant ever say anything to you in substance similar to this? [1325:25] **MR. COHEN:** Objection, form. [1326:1] **THE COURT:** Sustained, form. [1326:2] **Q.** What, if anything——well, let me just ask: Yes or no, did you have any other communications with the defendant about a one-stop shop for relationships? [1326:5] **A.** Yes. [1326:6] **Q.** And what, if anything, did the defendant say to you about that? [1326:8] **A.** I recall him using that exact phrase, that it would be extremely convenient to not have to manage many of the relationship brokers but just this one. [1326:11] **MR. ROOS:** We can take this down. [1326:12] **Q.** After you received this document, just yes or no, did the defendant spend any more time with Michael Kives and Bryan Baum? [1326:15] **MR. COHEN:** Objection, foundation. [1326:16] **MR. ROOS:** I'm just asking yes or no, and I'm going to lay the foundation. [1326:18] **THE COURT:** Well, then the question is problematic. It's leading, so let's—— [1326:20] **MR. ROOS:** Okay. I'll rephrase. [1326:21] BY MR. ROOS: [1326:22] **Q.** Mr. Singh, what, if anything, did you observe about the defendant's interactions with Bryan Baum or Michael Kives after you received this document? [1326:25] **THE COURT:** If anything. Or you've got the "if [1327:1] anything." Sorry. [1327:2] **A.** I physically saw them meeting multiple times in the Bahamas penthouse, and I'd heard from Sam that they had gone on——I believe they'd gone on some trips together. Sorry. I knew they'd gone on some trips together. I can't remember if it was before or after this document. [1327:7] **Q.** Okay. Showing you now what's marked for identification as Government Exhibit 1451. Do you recognize people in this photo? [1327:10] **A.** I do. [1327:11] **Q.** Government offers——well, let me just ask you: Who do you recognize, for starters? [1327:13] **A.** Katy Perry is on the far left; Orlando Bloom is to her immediate right; Michael Kives to Orlando Bloom's immediate——he's the man to his immediate right; Sam is immediately to Michael Kives's right; and I don't recognize anyone else. [1327:18] **MR. ROOS:** Government offers 1451. [1327:19] **THE COURT:** Received. [1327:20] (Government's Exhibit 1451 received in evidence) [1327:21] **MR. ROOS:** Can we publish it. [1327:22] **THE COURT:** Yes. [1327:23] **Q.** Mr. Singh, now that the jury can see it, can you point out the individuals that you just identified. [1327:25] **A.** As in like go through the same process? [1328:1] **Q.** Yes. [1328:2] **A.** Sure. Katy Perry is on the far left in the green; immediately to her right is Orlando Bloom with the hat; the man immediately to his right is Michael Kives; and then Sam is immediately to Michael Kives's right. [1328:6] **Q.** Now what, if any, conversations did you have with the defendant about investing in K5? [1328:8] **A.** Sam sent a——like a term sheet of a Google Docs to me and Gary one night after meeting with Bryan Baum in the Bahamas penthouse. [1328:11] **Q.** After receiving that term sheet what, if anything, did you discuss? [1328:13] **A.** I was pretty shocked. It laid out hundreds of millions of dollars of bonuses to Michael Kives and Bryan Baum and proposed up to a billion dollars long term of capital to give to their VC firm. Surprising given that in the previous——by my understanding till this point was that investments—— [1328:18] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1328:19] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1328:20] **MR. ROOS:** I'm sorry. To which part? To his understanding up to this point? [1328:22] **THE COURT:** "Surprising given that." [1328:23] **MR. ROOS:** Okay. Thank you, your Honor. [1328:24] BY MR. ROOS: [1328:25] **Q.** Had you had any conversations with the defendant prior to [1329:1] this point about the nature of the investment? [1329:2] **A.** I talked with him about the possibility of investment. The sizes and the actual nature of them, not——I don't think we talked about those. [1329:5] **Q.** After you received this term sheet what, if anything, did you say to the defendant? [1329:7] **A.** The first thing I asked was: Is this a done deal? Can we go back on this? [1329:9] **Q.** What, if anything, did he say? [1329:10] **A.** He said: It's basically done. It's not in stone, but consider it done. [1329:12] **Q.** Did you have——did you speak further after that? [1329:13] **A.** Yeah. I was very concerned that a move like this was highly expensive and maybe not worth it on its own right. I was concerned that K5 was value extracted and that they would share—— [1329:17] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1329:18] **THE COURT:** Strike the answer. You can re-put the question. [1329:20] **Q.** So what, if anything——after the point you testified up to, what, if anything, did you discuss with the defendant? [1329:22] **A.** I was worried that partnering with K5 and giving them this much money would be really toxic to FTX and Alameda culture; that every day I was actively trying to espouse——I felt we all were——that politicking and social climbing was not going to be [1330:1] rewarded, and here we were rewarding people in exorbitant amounts. [1330:3] **MR. COHEN:** Same objection. [1330:4] **THE COURT:** Sir, is that something you thought or is that something you both thought and said to the defendant? [1330:6] **THE WITNESS:** Thought and said. [1330:7] **THE COURT:** Thank you. [1330:8] Let's go on. [1330:9] BY MR. ROOS: [1330:10] **Q.** So after you said that to the defendant, how, if at all, did he respond? [1330:12] **A.** I think I said a few more things and then he responded. [1330:13] **Q.** What else did you say to the defendant? [1330:14] **A.** I asked that if we must go through with this that it not interact with FTX lest it mess up FTX's culture and that that meant that Sam would be the person interacting with them, not FTX people, and that it would be Sam's money and not FTX money. [1330:18] **MR. ROOS:** Could we please put back up Government Exhibit 14A. [1330:20] And can we look at column K of row 7. [1330:21] **Q.** And what investment entity does the spreadsheet say was used for K5? [1330:23] **A.** Alameda Research Ventures LLC. [1330:24] **Q.** Now do you see on this spreadsheet in row 10 a project name called Dave Inc.? [1331:1] **A.** Yes. [1331:2] **Q.** Do you know what Dave Inc. is? [1331:3] **A.** It's a neobank. [1331:4] **Q.** What's a neobank? [1331:5] **A.** It's like a bank that exists primarily online, doesn't have brick-and-mortar stores, I believe. [1331:7] **MR. ROOS:** We can take that down. [1331:8] **Q.** Besides the venture investments, what other spending was happening in the first quarter of 2022? [1331:10] **A.** There was spending on endorsement deals and real estate. [1331:11] **MR. ROOS:** So pursuant to stipulation S2003, the government offers Exhibit 343, which, according to stipulation, is a spreadsheet dated March 23, 2022, called Sponsorships Full. [1331:15] **THE COURT:** 343 is received. [1331:16] (Government's Exhibit 343 received in evidence) [1331:17] **MR. ROOS:** May we publish? [1331:18] **THE COURT:** You may. [1331:19] BY MR. ROOS: [1331:20] **Q.** Mr. Singh, are you familiar with this spreadsheet? [1331:21] **A.** Yes. [1331:22] **Q.** And just as a category, what is listed on it? [1331:23] **A.** Sponsorship deals and how much they cost. [1331:24] **Q.** Okay. Starting at the top, do you see the numbers 1a, 1b, and 1c? [1332:1] **A.** Yes. [1332:2] **Q.** And what are——what is the Miami-Dade FTX Arena? [1332:3] **A.** The Miami Heat NBA stadium that was renamed FTX Arena. [1332:4] **Q.** And did FTX have a sponsorship agreement with them? [1332:5] **A.** Yes. [1332:6] **MR. ROOS:** Can we show the witness Government Exhibit 1478. [1332:8] **Q.** Do you recognize this? [1332:9] **A.** This is that arena. [1332:10] **MR. ROOS:** Government offers 1478. [1332:11] **THE COURT:** It's received. [1332:12] (Government's Exhibit 1478 received in evidence) [1332:13] **MR. ROOS:** May we publish it. [1332:14] **THE COURT:** You may. [1332:15] **Q.** Mr. Singh, what are we looking at? [1332:16] **A.** This is the Miami Heat stadium that was renamed to FTX Arena. [1332:18] **Q.** And do you know what team plays at the Miami Heat stadium? [1332:19] **A.** Miami Heat. [1332:20] **Q.** What's that? [1332:21] **A.** It's an NBA team. [1332:22] **MR. ROOS:** Let's put back up Government Exhibit 343, please. [1332:24] **Q.** How much did the Miami Heat arena sponsorship cost? [1332:25] **A.** Summing the first three numerical values in column O, it's [1333:1] $205 million. [1333:2] **Q.** No. 2 on this list, which is row 8, says MLB. Was there an MLB endorsement? [1333:4] **A.** Yes. [1333:5] **Q.** What does MLB stand for? [1333:6] **A.** I think Major League Baseball. [1333:7] **Q.** What was the total deal amount? [1333:8] **A.** I don't know if rows 9 and 10 contribute, but around $150 million. [1333:10] **Q.** Do you see——let's look down to row 14 and 15. And do you know who Steph Curry is? [1333:12] **A.** Yes, a great basketball player. [1333:13] **Q.** And did FTX have any sort of arrangement with Steph Curry? [1333:14] **A.** Yes. [1333:15] **Q.** What? [1333:16] **A.** I actually don't know the full nature of that. [1333:17] **Q.** Okay. What was the total deal size listed on this spreadsheet? [1333:19] **A.** According to this—— [1333:20] **MR. COHEN:** Is he just reading this? Is there a basis beyond that? [1333:22] **THE COURT:** Yes. Let's find out. [1333:23] **Q.** Mr. Singh, at the time this was happening, as these endorsements were happening, were you familiar with some of the endorsements and their amounts? [1334:1] **A.** I mostly learned about them after their——after the fact and certainly learned about the amounts after the fact. [1334:3] **Q.** And just to be clear, when you say after the fact, when are you referring to? [1334:5] **A.** After the payment had been made, the deals had been agreed on. [1334:7] **Q.** But when in 2022 or 2023? [1334:8] **A.** Like late 2022. I saw——I saw——this sheet was shown to me by Jayesh in late October or early November 2022. [1334:10] **Q.** Who is Jayesh? [1334:11] **A.** Jayesh Peswami was the head of finance for FTX. [1334:12] **Q.** Okay. And what were those circumstances of him sending this to you? [1334:14] **A.** He came over to my desk and he asked me about a topic called goodwill, which he explained was something like the net present value of future expected growth of an entity, and he wanted to know what a reasonable number for Blockfolio's goodwill will be. We talked about user growth. To substantiate user growth, he showed me how much was being spent on endorsements, which, in theory, lead to user growth. [1334:21] **Q.** So you've seen this spreadsheet before? [1334:22] **A.** Yes, I'd seen it before, at that time. [1334:23] **Q.** Just a few others. [1334:24] Row 21 says Riot LCS. Do you know what that's a reference to? [1335:1] **A.** Riot is the company that makes League of Legends. LCS is the competitive league that they run. [1335:3] **Q.** What, if any, relationship did of this with FTX? [1335:4] **A.** This is an endorsement deal with FTX. [1335:5] **Q.** Can we look at row 9. I'm sorry. Not row 9. If we look at No. 9a on the list. [1335:7] Are you familiar with Tom Brady and Gisele Bündchen? [1335:8] **A.** Yes. [1335:9] **Q.** And who are they? [1335:10] **A.** Tom Brady is a great quarterback; Gisele Bündchen is a model and philanthropist. [1335:12] **Q.** What, if any, relationship were you aware of at the time between Tom Brady and Gisele Bündchen and FTX? [1335:14] **A.** I knew there was some form of——there were a couple things. There was some form of endorsement deal. I also know that FTX was coordinating on some philanthropic efforts with Gisele. [1335:17] **Q.** Let's look at No. 27 on this list. [1335:18] And do you see the name Larry David? [1335:19] **A.** Yes. [1335:20] **Q.** Who is that? [1335:21] **A.** He wrote Seinfeld. [1335:22] **Q.** Okay. And do you know what the sponsorship was for? [1335:23] **A.** This was for his role in the Super Bowl ad. [1335:24] **Q.** Now let's look at line 72. [1335:25] And what was the total deal amount? [1336:1] **A.** 1.13 billion. [1336:2] **MR. ROOS:** We can take that down. [1336:3] **Q.** You mentioned that money in late 2021 and 2022 was being spent on real estate. [1336:5] **THE COURT:** Before we get into the real estate business, we'll maybe take our morning break. Fifteen minutes, please. [1336:8] **THE DEPUTY CLERK:** All rise. Would the jury please come this way. [1336:10] (Recess) [1336:11] (In open court; jury present) [1336:12] **THE COURT:** And folks, forgive me for one minute. Just let me see Mr. Cohen and Mr. Roos at the sidebar. [1337:1] (At the sidebar) [1337:2] **THE COURT:** During the recess, I just received an automatic email saying that Mr. Bork is on extended leave. [1337:4] **MR. COHEN:** Oh. [1337:5] **THE COURT:** And in case of need, call Adam Johnson, and here's the number. I'm certainly not going to put it on the record. [1337:8] **MR. COHEN:** Thank you, your Honor. [1337:9] **THE COURT:** Do you have it? [1337:10] **MR. ROOS:** Yes, we have it. [1337:11] **THE COURT:** Okay. [1338:1] (In open court) [1338:2] **THE COURT:** Okay. Let's proceed. [1338:3] BY MR. ROOS: [1338:4] **Q.** Mr. Singh, before we broke, I'd asked you about real estate. And why don't we just—— [1338:6] **MR. ROOS:** Pursuant to stipulation S2003, the government offers Exhibit 3, which, according to the stipulation, is a spreadsheet called FTX PHL Properties 2021, Leased and Purchased. [1338:10] **THE COURT:** Received. [1338:11] (Government's Exhibit 3 received in evidence) [1338:12] **MR. ROOS:** May we publish it? [1338:13] **THE COURT:** You may. [1338:14] BY MR. ROOS: [1338:15] **Q.** Mr. Singh, do you see in column A a list of properties by address? [1338:17] **A.** Yes. [1338:18] **Q.** Okay. Are you familiar with any of the properties listed in this spreadsheet? [1338:20] **A.** A handful of them. [1338:21] **Q.** Which do you recognize? [1338:22] **A.** There's Albany Lot No. 44 Conch Shack, I recognize that; I think I visited some of the ones in rows 3, 4, and 5 that say Charles at the end; on row 8, Gemini Unit 1D was one of Sam's apartments; on row 12, the Orchid penthouse was Sam's apartment [1339:1] that I and Sam and some eight others lived in. [1339:2] **MR. ROOS:** Could we scroll down. [1339:3] **A.** I recognize some of these One Cable Beach ones. I see that there are five and I only know of three, and I don't know which is which, but I know there were three, at least three apartments purchased at One Cable Beach under my and Sam's and Gary's name. [1339:8] **Q.** Do you recognize any of the other ones? [1339:9] **A.** Two others. Old Fort Bay, lots 5A and 5B. I'm not certain, but I know that Joe Bankman lived in one home in Old Fort Bay, and this might be the one. [1339:12] And then on row 35, the Veridian Corporate Center No. 23, that was part of the FTX office. [1339:14] **MR. ROOS:** Could we scroll back up to the top. [1339:15] **Q.** I just want to clarify, in row 8 it says Albany Building 9, unit 1D. Is that one of the properties you just identified the defendant lived in? [1339:18] **A.** Yeah. [1339:19] **Q.** And so I want to be clear. You testified earlier that you lived with the defendant. Did you live in that property? [1339:21] **A.** No. I lived in the Orchid penthouse in row 12. Sam moved at some point to Gemini 1D. [1339:23] **MR. ROOS:** Could we publish Government Exhibit 1542, which is in evidence. [1339:25] **THE COURT:** Yes. [1340:1] **Q.** What's this? [1340:2] **A.** This is that——the penthouse that me, Sam, and others lived in. [1340:4] **Q.** Who else lived there? [1340:5] **A.** There were I think eight others. I can——I can list them? [1340:6] **Q.** Okay. [1340:7] **A.** Claire Watanabe, my girlfriend; Adam Yedidia and Andrea Lincoln; Leila Clark; Duncan Rheingans-Yoo; Caroline Ellison; Sam. [1340:10] **Q.** What, if any, conversations did you have with the defendant about purchasing real estate in 2021 or 2022? [1340:12] **A.** We had a couple conversations. I can describe them. [1340:13] **Q.** Let me ask you more specifically then, what, if any, conversations did you have with the defendant generally about spending on real estate? [1340:16] **A.** I had one conversation with him while I was still in Hong Kong, where he was talking to a group of people that I was in. He praised Dan Friedberg and Ryan Salame's real estate purchases freely. [1340:20] **Q.** And what, if any, conversations did you have with the defendant about purchasing the penthouse apartment that's depicted on the screen? [1340:23] **A.** That group I mentioned, we wanted to live together, so we were searching for a place, we'd landed on one a fair bit less expensive; we went——some group went to go see this apartment. [1341:1] Sam really liked this one. Sam's a fan of views. And there was substantial disagreement about if we should go with it, in part because it was really expensive, in part because it's just super ostentatious. At one point I talked to Sam and expressed that discomfort. Sam said that he would pay $100 million for the drama to just be done with and go away, which I took as a pretty clear sign that I should shut up and we should move forward with this. [1342:1] **MR. ROOS:** Now, we can take this down. [1342:2] **Q.** Focusing on the period of late 2021 and early 2022, at that time what did you believe the state of Alameda's finances were? [1342:4] **A.** I thought it was fantastically wealthy. [1342:5] **Q.** Just to be clear, what, if any, direct involvement in Alameda's finances did you have at that point? [1342:7] **A.** None. [1342:8] **Q.** Did there come a time in 2022 when there was a change to the cryptocurrency market? [1342:10] **A.** Yes. [1342:11] **Q.** What happened? [1342:12] **A.** Are you referring to the crash in May? [1342:13] **Q.** Let me ask you about that. What, if any, crash in cryptocurrency prices happened in May? [1342:15] **A.** Luna and UST, an associated stablecoin, had some algorithmic failure and it crashed and, with it, brought down a bunch of other crypto prices. [1342:18] **Q.** Around that time what, if any, conversations did you have with the defendant about the availability? [1342:20] **THE COURT:** I'm sorry. Can we just back up. [1342:21] What's an algorithmic failure? [1342:22] **THE WITNESS:** It's a failure in this case in the financial design of those two tokens and their interactions. I suppose the algorithm itself operated as expected. It was just not robust. [1343:1] **THE COURT:** What is the algorithm supposed to do? [1343:2] **THE WITNESS:** I don't actually remember the mechanics of how Luna and UST were supposed to work that well. Something about its design led to an interaction in which their price was driven to near zero. [1343:6] **THE COURT:** All right. We will take it from there. [1343:7] **MR. ROOS:** Thank you, your Honor. [1343:8] **Q.** Around this time, what, if any, conversations did you have with the defendant about the availability of money? [1343:10] **A.** That night that the crash happened, I was in the Chicago office, maybe 1, 2 a.m., or something like that. I was walking to get a snack from the pantry, and I was beckoned into a room with Ramnik Arora and Tristan Yver. Forgive me. This is not a conversation with Sam. I can skip ahead. [1343:15] **Q.** I'll ask you the question again. What, if any, conversations did you have with the defendant about the availability of money after the change in the cryptocurrency market? [1343:19] **A.** Sometime in the weeks to months following this crash, there were meetings held inside my room inside the penthouse in which the topic of needing more collateral or needing more capital, rather, came up. There was a lot of mention of the lending market drying out. [1343:24] **MR. COHEN:** Can we have a foundation, your Honor? [1343:25] **MR. ROOS:** No problem. [1344:1] **THE COURT:** Go ahead. [1344:2] **Q.** You mentioned meetings in your room. For starters, are you referring to the penthouse? [1344:4] **A.** Yes. [1344:5] **Q.** And who were in some of these meetings? [1344:6] **A.** Always Sam, me, Gary, Caroline, Ramnik. Often Constance, Adam, Claire, Can Sun, Brett Harrison. [1344:8] **Q.** To pick up on your answer, what was the topic of some of these meetings? [1344:10] **A.** For some of these meetings -- but forgive me, I don't remember who all exactly was in it, but I know for certain Sam, Caroline, myself, Gary, Ramnik -- that the topic was how to address the fact that the capital markets -- that the lending markets are drying up and that capital is harder to come by. Alameda had taken out large loans from third-party lenders, and presumably it was getting harder to source new loans or to keep a hold of the old loans in this new marketing regime. [1344:18] **Q.** Let me ask you a few follow-up questions. [1344:19] So you said capital. What are you referring to? [1344:20] **A.** Lent funds for trading or other purposes. [1344:21] **Q.** You mentioned lending twice. Who was lending in this context? [1344:23] **A.** Third-party crypto lenders. Genesis is a name that comes to mind here. [1344:25] **Q.** What's a third-party crypto lender? [1345:1] **A.** It's a firm that's in the business of lending money to, in this case, trading firms and just collecting interest on it. [1345:3] **Q.** What, if anything, did the defendant say in these conversations? [1345:5] **A.** A number of things. Sam acknowledged and agreed that capital was short. He talked about the need for capital. There were a lot of acquisitions he wanted to make. There was a discussion about if raising would be viable. [1345:9] **THE COURT:** What does raising mean in this context, please? [1345:11] **THE WITNESS:** Thanks. Raising money for FTX by selling its equity. [1345:13] **THE COURT:** Thank you. [1345:14] **Q.** You mentioned a few things: Borrowing, raising. Was there anything else in your answer about what he raised in the conversations? [1345:17] **A.** There were specifics along those lines. For example, Ramnik and Sam, I don't remember which proposed it at first, but both talked about it a lot, discussed the idea of acquiring large lending -- large sources of capital that may or may not have been lending to customers of the business, groups like Celsius, Voyager, BlockFi, in part to bail out the space and in part to make Alameda have access to more funds to borrow. [1345:24] **Q.** You have mentioned the name Ramnik a few times. What was his role at FTX? [1346:1] **A.** His title was head of product, but he primarily worked on other matters. He headed up, along with Sam, VC investments and raising from FTX investors as in selling FTX equity. [1346:4] **Q.** Focusing on the same time period, what, if anything, did the defendant say about the availability of money to be borrowed? [1346:7] **A.** That it was quickly drying up. [1346:8] **Q.** Now, I want to turn your attention to June of 2022. Did there ever come a time where you were involved in a project relating to Alameda's balances? [1346:11] **A.** Yes. [1346:12] **Q.** When was this, approximately? [1346:13] **A.** Mid June 2022. [1346:14] **Q.** Who did you work with on the project? [1346:15] **A.** Caroline, Sam, and Gary. [1346:16] **Q.** Can you describe what the project was at a high level. [1346:17] **A.** Yeah. Caroline sent over a Google Doc that had -- it reflected Alameda's system's records of what they had in balances on FTX. It was extremely negative. She asked if this was correct. [1346:21] **Q.** Now, were you working at FTX at this time? [1346:22] **A.** Yes. [1346:23] **Q.** And what, if any, role did you have at Alameda Research as of June 2022? [1346:25] **A.** I was friends with them socially, but I didn't have a role. [1347:1] I wasn't working there. [1347:2] **Q.** How did working on this project fit into your overall responsibilities at FTX, if at all? [1347:4] **A.** It was pretty anomalous. It was regular for me. I didn't have any hesitation about jumping on things that needed help. If it was something that was for Alameda that related to FTX, that was fine, but I had not considered Alameda finances until this point. [1347:9] **Q.** What, if any, involvement had you had at looking at Alameda's balances prior to June 2022? [1347:11] **A.** None that I recall. [1347:12] **Q.** Why were you involved in this project to calculate Alameda's balances? [1347:14] **A.** I don't know what Caroline was thinking when she messaged the group with me, but insofar as this is a project that relies on looking at FTX, the database there, and confirming if the data that they are streaming to their system is valid, I had comfort in those technical systems. [1347:19] **Q.** You mentioned that Caroline Ellison circulated a spreadsheet. What, if anything, did the defendant say before receiving it? [1347:22] **A.** I distinctly remember -- [1347:23] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1347:24] **THE COURT:** What is the objection? [1347:25] **MR. COHEN:** No foundation. [1348:1] **THE COURT:** I thought I heard it, but, Mr. Roos, won't hurt to hear it again. [1348:3] **Q.** Just to be clear, who was the spreadsheet circulated to? [1348:4] **A.** At the very least, myself, Gary, and Sam. [1348:5] **Q.** And what, if anything, did the defendant say about the spreadsheet? [1348:7] **A.** Sam said this can't be right. There has got to be an error. Let's dig into it. [1348:9] **Q.** After that, who, if anyone, dug into it? [1348:10] **A.** Gary and I did. I asked Gary how I could help because I wasn't sure what the areas of uncertainty might be. Gary asked that I find and search for all the accounts in the FTX database that are either Alameda's or ultimately Sam is responsible for, so Sam morally owns, and to list them and list the dollar value of their holdings. I made an attempt at that. I think -- Gary thought it was not a great attempt, so he took his own stab at it. I deleted my page and we went with Gary's. [1348:18] **MR. ROOS:** Let's take a look at Government Exhibit 50, which is in evidence, and, according to the stipulation, S2003, it is a June 13, 2022 spreadsheet called Alameda balances by FTX sub. [1348:22] **THE COURT:** And the exhibit number again, please? [1348:23] **MR. ROOS:** Government Exhibit 50, which is in evidence. [1348:25] **THE COURT:** Thank you. [1349:1] **Q.** Just briefly starting on sheet 1, what is this sheet? [1349:2] **A.** This is the sheet that -- that Caroline sent that shows Alameda systems' understanding of their balances in all of these FTX accounts. [1349:5] **Q.** Let me just take a background question of what we are looking at here. [1349:7] What kind of document or file is this? [1349:8] **A.** I recall this being a Google Doc. [1349:9] **Q.** What kind of document do you recognize is on the screen? [1349:10] **A.** Do you mind rephrasing that? [1349:11] **Q.** I'm wondering what was the format in which you received this information? [1349:13] **A.** I received it in Google Docs form, Google Sheets. [1349:14] **Q.** What's Google Sheets? [1349:15] **A.** It's a cloud-based version of Microsoft Excel. [1349:16] **Q.** Did it resemble what we are looking at here? [1349:17] **A.** Yeah, very closely. Had all the same contents. [1349:18] **Q.** So what was this first sheet, sheet 1? [1349:19] **A.** This is the sheet that I first saw when Caroline sent us the document, so presumably the one that Caroline wrote. [1349:21] **MR. ROOS:** Let's now look at sheet 2. [1349:22] **Q.** What's this sheet? [1349:23] **A.** This is the sheet that Gary made with his attempt at the technical exercise that I described. [1349:25] **Q.** Let me ask you a few questions about what we are seeing [1350:1] here. [1350:2] The first column, A, says, in the first row, ID, and then there are a bunch of numbers below it. [1350:4] What does that column refer to? [1350:5] **A.** These are the IDs of those accounts in the FTX database. [1350:6] **Q.** What do you mean, the IDs of accounts in the FTX database? [1350:7] **A.** Many objects in FTX's database had numbers associated with them and uniquely identified them. Those are called IDs colloquially. These are those identifying numbers for the accounts table. [1350:11] **Q.** What's listed in column B on the spreadsheet? [1350:12] **A.** The user name of those accounts. This is another column in the accounts table. [1350:14] **Q.** What's listed in column C? [1350:15] **A.** I didn't generate this, but I generated my version of it and I know what Gary told me to generate there. So inferring that he did the same thing or assuming he did, this is the dollar value of the holdings in each of those accounts. [1350:19] **Q.** So let me ask you about a few of the accounts here. You testified that the defendant said that the initial balance that Caroline Ellison calculated was wrong. Was it? [1350:22] **A.** Yes. [1350:23] **Q.** Why was that balance figure wrong? [1350:24] **A.** There were many reasons it was wrong. The one that had the biggest effect, I believe, is that fiat@FTX.com, which [1351:1] represented the total amount that was in bank accounts to be custodied of customer fiat, that calculation, the system that had been updating that number had a bug such that the obligation that Alameda had was overstated by nearly $8 billion. [1351:6] **Q.** Let's break down your answer. [1351:7] Starting with the basics, what do you mean when you say fiat deposits? [1351:9] **A.** FTX supported customers sending traditional currencies. That's what I meant by fiat, things like dollars, euros, GBP. [1351:11] **Q.** How were those fiat deposits recorded at FTX? [1351:12] **A.** In a number of ways. One of these systems involved in tracking them interacted with fiat@FTX.com's balances in that a deposit sent to a bank account was credited to a customer on the FTX system by, in effect, transferring from them in the sort of a technical system from the fiat@FTX.com account. [1351:17] **Q.** What kind of account is the fiat@FTX.com account? [1351:18] **A.** It's a special account. It's not one that customers would log into. It's an accounting-oriented account. [1351:20] **Q.** What does the total in the fiat@FTX.com account represent? [1351:21] **A.** Absent bugs, it is supposed to represent negative the amount that has been net deposited of fiat in the FTX system by customers. [1351:24] **Q.** What do you mean negative the net amount that's been deposited? [1352:1] **A.** If the balance here was negative $10, then that should represent that customers have on net, after all deposits and withdrawals, deposited $10 into bank accounts. [1352:4] **THE COURT:** I'm sorry. Into what bank accounts? [1352:5] **THE WITNESS:** Bank accounts that customers were directed to send to by FTX to be credited on the FTX system, managed either by Alameda or FTX at different times. [1352:8] **THE COURT:** And so is it correct that that was money which, at least in a sense, Alameda was borrowing from or owed to FTX? [1352:11] **THE WITNESS:** It certainly owed it to FTX. [1352:12] **THE COURT:** Proceed. [1352:13] **MR. ROOS:** Thank you. [1352:14] **Q.** What does the term fiat liability refer to? [1352:15] **A.** It refers to the magnitude of this number, the amount that Alameda needs to have custodied on behalf of FTX customers in banks. [1352:18] **Q.** What's the relationship between the number and the fiat@FTX.com account and what's supposed to be in the bank accounts? [1352:21] **A.** It is always larger than what should be in bank accounts, but it's very close. The reason it's larger is because for some time deposits had been going into FTX bank accounts, not Alameda ones. Through that point is that the fiat@FTX.com number would have represented exactly what should be in Alameda [1353:1] bank accounts. [1353:2] **Q.** We will come back to what you just said in a moment. [1353:3] You mentioned earlier in your testimony a bug. Can you describe what you are referring to. [1353:5] **A.** Yes. Sometime in 2021, Adam Yedidia was working on the fiat system and automating the elements of it. In doing so, he accidentally introduced a bug that prevented the correct accounting for fiat@FTX.com's balances on specific types of withdrawals. [1353:10] As a result, over time there was an error that grew in the balance stored for fiat@FTX.com such that, by June, it was -- the stated number is negative 19 billion but the correct number would have been negative 11. [1353:14] **THE COURT:** That's June of which year, please? [1353:15] **THE WITNESS:** 2022. [1353:16] **THE COURT:** Thank you. [1353:17] **Q.** Approximately when in June 2022? [1353:18] **A.** Mid June 2022. [1353:19] **Q.** Just a few more background questions on this topic. [1353:20] Prior to your discussion of balances in June 2022, had you learned whether or not Alameda was accepting FTX customer deposits? [1353:23] **A.** Yes. [1353:24] **Q.** When did you know of that? [1353:25] **A.** Very, very early in FTX's existence. One of the first [1354:1] things that FTX did before going live was connecting it to OTC.FTX.com, which was a reskin of another OTC system that Gary and Sam had built. That system supported depositing fiat into Alameda's bank accounts. That system could be used to onboard funds via fiat deposits to FTX once they were linked. [1354:6] **Q.** What, if any, conversations did you have with the defendant about Alameda receiving FTX customer deposits prior to June 2022? [1354:9] **A.** We had discussions on improving this set up technically that I helped sort of direct Adam to pursue. I'd also heard from him and from others that the reason that Alameda bank accounts were used at all in the beginning was because FTX had a hard time securing bank accounts but Alameda already had them. [1354:15] **Q.** Who was the him in the answer you just gave? [1354:16] **A.** Sam. [1354:17] **Q.** Prior to June 2022, had you ever spoken to the defendant about the fiat@FTX account? [1354:19] **A.** Yes. [1354:20] **Q.** What did he say to you? [1354:21] **A.** He understood that it was something that Alameda -- [1354:22] **MR. COHEN:** Can we have a time frame, please. [1354:23] **THE COURT:** Prior to June of 2022. [1354:24] **MR. COHEN:** More than that. [1354:25] **THE COURT:** Pardon? [1355:1] **MR. COHEN:** Is there anything more than that? [1355:2] **THE COURT:** You can inquire. [1355:3] **MR. COHEN:** OK. Thank you, your Honor. [1355:4] **THE COURT:** Proceed. [1355:5] **A.** Early, maybe December 2019, I remember discussions about the setup of fiat@FTX.com. I think I overheard them. This was an audit discussion I was participating in myself in which there was talk about how fiat@FTX.com would be incorporated into Alameda's own native sense of what their balances were, such that customer deposits made into bank accounts, plus their consideration of fiat@FTX.com, should always be zero. [1355:12] **Q.** Who do you recall participating in that conversation you overheard? [1355:14] **A.** Sam Bankman-Fried, Jen Chan, and I believe at least one trader or Alameda engineer, but I don't remember who. [1355:16] **Q.** What was Jen Chan's role? [1355:17] **A.** Chief of staff of FTX. [1355:18] **THE COURT:** Could I just ask go back a minute. [1355:19] You were asked whether prior to your discussions of balances in June '22 you had learned whether or not Alameda was accepting FTX customer deposits, and you said yes. [1355:22] Then you were asked: When did you know that? You said: Very, very early in FTX's existence. One of the first things FTX did before going live was connecting it to OTC.FTX.com, which was a reskin of another OTC system that Gary [1356:1] and Sam had built. That system supported depositing fiat into Alameda's bank accounts. So that system could be used to onboard funds via fiat deposits to FTX once they were linked. [1356:4] Now, can you explain that answer. [1356:5] **THE WITNESS:** I can talk about it mechanically, what a customer would do and how the funds -- [1356:7] **THE COURT:** What we are trying to find out is what you knew about Alameda taking or not taking FTX customer deposits very early in FTX's existence. Could you pick it up from there. [1356:11] **THE WITNESS:** Me? [1356:12] **THE COURT:** Yes. That's to you. That's a fair question. [1356:14] **THE WITNESS:** I knew that FTX customers could deposit funds to Alameda bank accounts in order to be credited with those funds on FTX to trade from FTX's inception and that one of the ways they could do it is by depositing to Alameda bank accounts through the separate system called OTC.FTX.com and then transferring those to FTX.com. [1356:20] **THE COURT:** Was there another way? [1356:21] **THE WITNESS:** In December of 2019, an analogous system was set up, but directly on FTX. So customers could, on FTX, view wire instructions that they should send their funds to, and those wire instructions were for Alameda bank accounts. [1356:25] **THE COURT:** Then how were those deposits reflected and [1357:1] where? [1357:2] **THE WITNESS:** Those deposits were sent to Alameda bank accounts, and then the technical FTX system through use of -- through somebody observing the deposits into bank accounts, somebody would go and manually credit on the FTX system the corresponding user with the amount that they had sent to the bank account, and in that process what would happen under the hood is that fiat@FTX.com would go negative via the amount deposited and the customer's account would go positive via the amount deposited. [1357:11] The net effect is, a customer sent $10 to an Alameda bank account. Somebody working for Alameda or FTX on the FTX system presses a button that credits the user on FTX with 10 virtual dollars and decrements fiat@FTX's.com balance by $10. [1357:15] **THE COURT:** Which other FTX.com balance? [1357:16] **THE WITNESS:** Fiat@FTX.com's balance. [1357:17] **THE COURT:** That's the way it was supposed to work, right? [1357:19] **THE WITNESS:** Right. [1357:20] **THE COURT:** What was the bug? [1357:21] **THE WITNESS:** The bug, which I think was introduced sometime in 2021, was that when a withdrawal was processed in a specific programmatic way, the customer's balance was successfully decremented, the funds were successfully sent through actual bank accounts, but fiat@FTX.com's like virtual [1358:1] balance was not successfully incremented. [1358:2] **THE COURT:** So the apparent liability, from the point where the bug was introduced, owed by Alameda to FTX grew and grew. Is that right? [1358:5] **THE WITNESS:** Yes. [1358:6] **THE COURT:** And part of that balance was there because it belonged there and part of it was the result of the bookkeeping error by virtue of the failure to reflect the withdrawal from the customer account in the fiat@FTX account, yes? [1358:11] **THE WITNESS:** That's exactly right. [1358:12] **THE COURT:** Let's go on. [1358:13] **MR. ROOS:** Thank you. [1358:14] **Q.** And who identified that error or bug? [1358:15] **A.** I am not sure who first identified it, but, in late 2021, I overheard a conversation between Gary and Adam Yedidia or Gary was explaining it to Adam. [1358:18] **Q.** Take a look at lines 13 and 14 of the spreadsheet. [1358:19] What does this reflect? [1358:20] **A.** Line 13 reflects what was literally in the fiat@FTX.com's like virtual balance. Line 14 is something that Gary added as a correction for the effect size of the bug until this point. [1358:23] **Q.** Judge Kaplan asked you about the fiat@FTX account balance being overstated. Where, if anywhere on the spreadsheet, does it reflect that number? [1359:1] **A.** Negative 19 billion is an overstatement by the number in cell C14. [1359:3] **Q.** Where, if anywhere, is the correction to that overstatement? [1359:5] **A.** In row 14, C14. [1359:6] **Q.** With those two pieces of information, are you able to determine the correct fiat@FTX.com balance as of this date? [1359:8] **A.** This correctly determines the total amount of customer deposits sent to FTX or Alameda bank accounts. There is one additional step that needs to be taken to find out how much had been sent to Alameda versus FTX bank accounts. [1359:12] **Q.** Just sticking on this for a moment, how can you determine what the correct balance in fiat@FTX.com is? [1359:14] **A.** Summing these two numbers. [1359:15] **Q.** So summing those two numbers, what was the correct balance in fiat@FTX.com at the time? [1359:17] **A.** About negative $11 billion. [1359:18] **Q.** So what does a negative $11 billion reflect? [1359:19] **A.** It reflects that in banks, Alameda's or FTX, there should be $11 billion of fiat sent by customers. [1359:21] **Q.** Now, at the time of the conversation you had in June 2022 about the fiat bug, what, if any, involvement did you have in Alameda's banking? [1359:24] **A.** None. [1359:25] **Q.** At this point did you know whether or not Alameda had $11 [1360:1] billion in its bank account? [1360:2] **A.** I believed it did, but I didn't know either way. [1360:3] **Q.** What was your understanding as to whether Alameda was allowed to use or spend the FTX customer fiat deposits it had received? [1360:6] **A.** I didn't have an affirmative understanding, but using it would break common-sense expectations from customers. [1360:8] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1360:9] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1360:10] **MR. ROOS:** Judge, can we have a moment on this one? [1360:11] **THE COURT:** Ask another question. [1360:12] **MR. ROOS:** I'll come back to that, actually. [1360:13] **Q.** Now, do you see below this, in row 17, an account called info@AlamedaResearch? [1360:15] **A.** Yes. [1360:16] **Q.** What is the balance at the time of info@AlamedaResearch? [1360:17] **A.** Negative $2.78 billion. [1360:18] **Q.** Do you recognize that account? [1360:19] **A.** Yes. This is the main Alameda trading account. [1360:20] **Q.** How was it possible for Alameda to have a balance in its main account of negative $2.7 billion? [1360:22] **A.** Alameda had a flag granted to them, a feature called allow negative, which by this point allowed them to be negative via withdrawing or transferring or trading arbitrary amounts, unlimited amounts. [1361:1] **Q.** What was the flag called? [1361:2] **A.** Allow negative. [1361:3] **Q.** And what, if any, role did you have in the creation of allow negative? [1361:5] **THE COURT:** Let's just find out what he's talking about when we are talking about a flag. I don't imagine it's Don't Tread on Me. [1361:8] **THE WITNESS:** It's a property of this account stored in the database. Flag means that it can either be true or false, and in this case this allow negative property for this account was true. [1361:12] **Q.** So it's like a feature? [1361:13] **A.** It's a feature. [1361:14] **THE COURT:** It's a feature of the program, right? [1361:15] **THE WITNESS:** Yes. [1361:16] **THE COURT:** The same kind of feature that when you try to write a check on my bank account for a million dollars, the bank won't pay it, right? I haven't got a million dollars. [1361:19] **THE WITNESS:** Same type of thing. [1361:20] **Q.** If you have the feature turned on that allows negative, what does that allow? [1361:22] **A.** It allows you to withdraw more than your balance such that you can have a negative balance in the end without bound. [1361:24] **Q.** What, if any, involvement did you have in creating that feature? [1362:1] **A.** I wrote the first version of allow negative, which had meaningfully different abilities. [1362:3] **Q.** Before I ask you about the abilities, when you say you wrote it, what do you mean? What are you referring to? [1362:5] **A.** Under Gary's and Sam's advisement and direction, I wrote the computer code that added this allow negative feature to the code base. [1362:8] **Q.** What computer code? [1362:9] **A.** The python future code used as part of the FTX system. [1362:10] **Q.** What do you mean by code base? [1362:11] **A.** FTX had a lot of code that it used to sort of run its technical systems. Code base is a term that encapsulates all of that code. [1362:14] **Q.** I want to be clear about something. Judge Kaplan asked you a question about where the flag was and your testimony was in the database. You just testified about the code. Are those the same things or different? [1362:18] **A.** They are different. [1362:19] **Q.** What's the difference? [1362:20] **A.** The code defines how the system functions, depending on whether or not an account has the flag. The database shows and stores if an account has a flag. [1362:23] **Q.** Where does this allow negative feature show up for Alameda? [1362:24] **A.** It shows up as turned on for them in the database. [1362:25] **Q.** Now, what did the allow negative feature allow Alameda to [1363:1] do initially? [1363:2] **A.** Initially, it allowed them to go negative up until they hit their collateral limit, but they can go negative in any currency until that point. [1363:5] **Q.** You mentioned it changed. What, if any, changes are you aware of? [1363:7] **A.** There were changes later in 2020, such that it could then go negative without any balance, so not bounded by its collateral limit, and there was a change added such that it would never be liquidated. [1363:11] **Q.** Let me ask you about each of those things. Starting with the last one, what do you mean by, it would never be liquidated? [1363:14] **A.** Should I describe liquidation first? [1363:15] **Q.** Sounds good. [1363:16] **A.** Liquidation is the process of closing out an account that otherwise might end up under water. If an account is put on a bet that could lose by more than the account has collateral in it, it's the exchange's job to sort of close out that bet before that trade has lost more money than the customer initially deposited. It's a safeguard for the exchange and for other customers that, when executed well, prevents accounts from ever going negative, thereby dipping into other customers' assets. [1363:25] **Q.** And you testified that Alameda's account was exempt from [1364:1] that liquidation. What does that mean? [1364:2] **A.** That Alameda could be in a position where it was liable to lose a lot of money and hurt other customers, or not just liable but well beyond that fact, had lost a lot of money or borrowed a lot of money such that it was taken from other customers without the system then taking any actions to close out their account or prevent that. [1364:8] **Q.** What were the other -- you listed them. But what were the other features that allowed negative -- maybe I'm using the word features too many times. What else did allow negative permit an account to do besides avoiding liquidation and going negative? [1364:13] **A.** It allowed many means of arriving at a negative balance, such as withdrawing money that it didn't have, so any withdrawing such that it was very negative, transferring to others such that it was negative, trading such that it was negative. [1364:18] **Q.** What do you mean trading such that it was negative? [1364:19] **A.** Selling a Bitcoin when Alameda's balance was zero Bitcoins, so they would have negative 1 at the end of it. [1364:21] **Q.** When Alameda had a negative balance in its account and was withdrawing money, where did that money come from? [1364:23] **A.** Other customers. [1364:24] **Q.** Why? [1364:25] **A.** There is only a few sources of funds that comprise what's [1365:1] in FTX's wallets. There is FTX's revenue. Then there is customer assets less Alameda and there is Alameda assets. If Alameda's like stated ownership of an amount is zero and then they go and withdraw it, it must necessarily be coming from one of the other parts or both. For non-USD tokens, if FTX only made revenue in USD-like tokens, then it was necessarily coming from other FTX customers. [1365:8] **Q.** I have to ask, what is a USD token? [1365:9] **A.** There are some tokens, like USDC, TUSD, that are stablecoins that are pegged to the dollar, and that in the crypto space are sometimes treated interchangeably with dollars. [1365:13] **Q.** What's a stablecoin? [1365:14] **A.** A coin that holds its value at $1, one U.S. dollar. [1365:15] **Q.** It's a form of cryptocurrency? [1365:16] **A.** Right. [1365:17] **Q.** When you participated in the creation of the allow-negative feature, what did you understand its purpose to be? [1365:19] **A.** I was told it was for two purposes. It was for unifying a set of existing functionalities for accounts like Alameda accounts to go negative and for giving FTX staff the ability and a page to transfer locked forms of FTT to customers or to pay expenses. [1365:24] **Q.** When was it that you were told those were the purposes? [1365:25] **A.** The day of or -- as I was writing the code, so the day of [1366:1] or the day before, when I was instructed to write the code. [1366:2] **Q.** I'm looking for a date or a year. When was that? [1366:3] **A.** July 2019. [1366:4] **Q.** You said someone told you this. Who told you this? [1366:5] **A.** Sam gave me the project of making a page to allow transferring forms of FTT such that balances of the account that the transfer was coming from could end up negative. Gary suggested the specific implementation in details, including adding the allowed negative flag and sort of all the minutia of what that meant in the code. [1366:11] **Q.** Taking us back to June 2022 and the spreadsheet, what was your reaction when you saw Alameda had a negative $2.7 billion balance in its main account? [1366:14] **A.** It seriously concerned me. This seemed like a real abuse of a feature that until this point I believed was serving FTX, not hurting it. [1366:17] **Q.** As far as you knew, what was your understanding as to what customers had agreed to? [1366:19] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1366:20] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1366:21] **Q.** What was your understanding as to whether using customer funds was appropriate? [1366:23] **A.** It was inappropriate. [1366:24] **Q.** Why? [1366:25] **A.** Does not meet the default expectations a customer would [1367:1] have, and I don't recall -- [1367:2] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1367:3] **MR. ROOS:** Relevant to his mental state. [1367:4] **THE COURT:** Sustained. Excuse me. Overruled. [1367:5] **THE WITNESS:** Should I continue? [1367:6] **THE COURT:** Continue. [1367:7] **A.** Yes. And I don't ever recall it being stated to customers that their funds were being taken, and I remember affirmative descriptions from Sam and others that Alameda didn't have special treatment, and this would constitute a form of special treatment. [1367:12] **Q.** What led you to conclude that the negative 2.7 was, to use your word, abuse and not an allowed use of allow negative? [1367:14] **A.** The allowed usage or the acceptable uses in my mind resulted -- were ones such that accounts would be negative for incidental reasons and in small amounts and then be shortly after -- would be topped off shortly after. [1367:18] This is not a small amount. It does not strike me as incidental. I expected that this had been there for a while if it was this negative. And it sort of couldn't have been a mistake. This number, Alameda's main accounts balance, is a front-and-center number in all of Alameda's trading systems. It's the sort of thing from my time at Alameda I couldn't imagine being missed or ignored by anyone there. [1367:25] **Q.** Let's take a look at column I and J. What's reflected in [1368:1] that column? [1368:2] **A.** There is a total that includes -- it is probably the result of a sum of column C, maybe absent a few lines. [1368:4] **Q.** If you just look at the top here, I am going to circle it, seeing that, do you know what the total refers to? [1368:6] **A.** If there isn't something in D indicating to exclude a given row, then the sum is the corresponding value in column C. [1368:8] **MR. ROOS:** Can we just scroll down and so the witness can see whether there is something in D. [1368:10] Let's go back up. [1368:11] **Q.** What does the total in column J refer to? [1368:12] **A.** It looks like it's just the sum, all the things that we see in column C. [1368:14] **Q.** What's in column C? [1368:15] **A.** USD values of the holdings in each of those accounts. [1368:16] **Q.** Now, in response to one of Judge Kaplan's questions you mentioned that there was a change in terms of which accounts were receiving money. [1368:19] Do you remember that answer? [1368:20] **A.** Yes. [1368:21] **Q.** What was the change in the bank accounts receiving money? [1368:22] **A.** Over the course of 2021 and early 2022, FTX started acquiring bank accounts and customer deposits and withdrawals are processed out of those, not the Alameda ones. [1368:25] **MR. ROOS:** We can take the spreadsheet down, by the [1369:1] way. [1369:2] **Q.** After FTX got bank accounts in its name, what did the balance in that fiat@FTX account reflect? [1369:4] **A.** It reflected the total amounts that should have been in Alameda and FTX bank accounts on behalf of customers. [1369:6] **Q.** So to be clear, was Alameda responsible for the entirety of that fiat liability? [1369:8] **A.** No. [1369:9] **Q.** What part? [1369:10] **A.** They were responsible for the amounts that had been sent to Alameda bank accounts, and then the rest FTX was responsible for. [1369:13] **Q.** How, if at all, did FTX or Alameda address the combined number in the fiat@ account? [1369:15] **A.** Sorry. I am not sure what you mean. Do you mind rephrasing. [1369:17] **Q.** You mentioned that Alameda was not responsible for the entirety of the fiat@ balance? [1369:19] **A.** Right. [1369:20] **Q.** What, if anything, was done to address the fact that Alameda was not responsible for the entire amount? [1369:22] **A.** Adam, Andrea, and Gary went through an exercise with help of the fiat settlement team to determine what the right split was and then separate the liabilities, so they were recorded in separate areas. [1370:1] **Q.** What do you mean by the right split? [1370:2] **A.** Determine how much had been sent to Alameda bank accounts, how much had been sent to FTX bank accounts, confirm that there is some lined up with what was stated for fiat@FTX.com, and then split that fiat@FTX.com balance into two balances: One corresponding to what Alameda owed, one corresponding to what FTX owed. [1370:8] **Q.** You used the word exercise. Do you mean like a project? [1370:9] **A.** Yes. [1370:10] **Q.** When was that project to split the fiat liability? [1370:11] **A.** Sometime in the weeks or months after this June exercise where we discovered this bug. [1370:13] **Q.** Who took the lead on determining what Alameda owed? [1370:14] **A.** I'm not confident. I believe -- I know that Adam ended up writing and executing a lot of the code. I know that Gary was very involved in it. [1370:17] **Q.** What's your understanding of what Adam Yedidia or others did to figure out the balance split? [1370:19] **A.** I don't have an understanding affirmatively. [1370:20] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1370:21] **THE COURT:** If you don't have one, let's stop there. [1370:22] **Q.** Just to be clear, did you work on this project directly? [1370:23] **A.** No. [1370:24] **Q.** Now, what, if anything, did you learn about the results of this project? [1371:1] **A.** That it had happened, that there was in fact a split made, that fiat@FTX.com after the split represented the amounts that were in FTX bank accounts or that FTX was responsible for, and that there was a new subaccount created called FTX fiat old under the info@Alameda Research account that reflected how much Alameda was responsible for or should be in Alameda's banks. [1371:7] **Q.** Let's break your answer down there. [1371:8] First, it wasn't clear to me. Do you know how much of the fiat@FTX.com liability Alameda was responsible for? [1371:10] **A.** Yes. [1371:11] **Q.** What amount? [1371:12] **A.** I recall seeing that it was around $8 billion. [1371:13] **Q.** You testified that the amount of that fiat liability was split between two accounts. Can you explain what you mean? [1371:15] **A.** Fiat@FTX.com was originally, or as of June we saw, like negative $11 billion. Alameda owed 8 of that. So if the split was done on that date, then the negative $11 billion in fiat@FTX.com would be reduced to negative $3 billion, and a separate account would be created under Alameda's account with the remaining negative 8. [1371:21] **Q.** To use your example, prior to the project, the total liability was 11 billion, is that right? [1371:23] **A.** Yes. [1371:24] **Q.** The split happens. How much was determined to be -- how much was FTX determined to be responsible for? [1372:1] **A.** I don't remember that number. I only remember Alameda's number. [1372:3] **Q.** Let's do it the other way. How much was Alameda determined to be responsible for? [1372:5] **A.** $8 billion worth of fiat. [1372:6] **Q.** Where was that fiat liability put? [1372:7] **A.** It was put into a subaccount of info@AlamedaResearch.com called FTX old. [1372:9] **Q.** What do you mean by a subaccount of info@AlamedaResearch.com? [1372:11] **A.** Alameda employees could log into, like with a user name and password on the site, a high-level account called info@AlamedaResearch.com, but within it there were many subaccounts that had their own distinct balances. Subaccounts had names. [1372:16] There is a new subaccount called FTX fiat old, whose balances didn't reflect Alameda's trading activity; just their share of this fiat liability. [1372:19] **Q.** What was put in that account? [1372:20] **A.** All the obligations that Alameda had for customer fiat, customer fiat they should have been holding in banks. [1372:22] **Q.** What was left in the fiat@FTX.com account? [1372:23] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. Foundation. [1372:24] **MR. ROOS:** I think he has laid it. [1372:25] **THE COURT:** Yes. I think so. Overruled. [1373:1] **A.** What was left in the FTX -- the fiat@FTX.com was everything else, so amounts that should have been in FTX bank accounts. [1373:3] **MR. ROOS:** The government offers Government Exhibit 647, which, according to stipulation S2002, is a screenshot of a part of the FTX database. [1373:6] **THE COURT:** Received. [1373:7] (Government Exhibit 647 received in evidence) [1373:8] **MR. ROOS:** May we publish it, your Honor. [1373:9] **THE COURT:** You may. [1373:10] And hand out reading glasses. [1373:11] **MR. ROOS:** Mr. Ahuja will have to use the zoom function. [1373:13] **Q.** Mr. Singh, I just want to start just by getting the lay of the land, ask you a few background questions of what we are looking at before we get into the details. OK? [1373:16] First, what is the screenshot of? [1373:17] **A.** This is the result of a query on the FTX database. [1373:18] **Q.** I want to ask you about the various columns we have here. [1373:19] **MR. ROOS:** The first column -- maybe, Mr. Ahuja, can we zoom in on the heading and some of the numbers. [1373:21] **Q.** What does this first column relate to? [1373:22] **A.** These are account IDs. We talked about IDs in the database earlier. These are the same ones, just for different accounts. [1373:24] **Q.** What is the account ID 9? [1373:25] **A.** That is the account ID of Alameda's main trading account. [1374:1] **MR. ROOS:** Zoom out on this and zoom in on the next column from account user name. [1374:3] **Q.** What sort of information is in the from-account user name? [1374:4] **A.** It describes the account that the transfer is sent from. This spreadsheet shows transfers acquired in the database. [1374:6] **Q.** In terms of the types of information in the database, are you able to view transfer transactions? [1374:8] **A.** Yes. [1374:9] **Q.** What's a transfer? What do you mean by that? [1374:10] **A.** It's a simple movement of money from one account to another. There is not necessarily a physical analogue. It's not that money is wired in the real world. It's just sort of a change of ownership of some amount of money in the FTX system. [1374:14] **MR. ROOS:** We can zoom out from here. [1374:15] **Q.** Do you see where -- we looked at from-account ID, from-account user name. [1374:17] Do you see the next one, to-account ID? [1374:18] **A.** Yes. [1374:19] **Q.** What does that refer to? [1374:20] **A.** It's the account ID of the account to which the funds were sent in each given transfer. [1374:22] **Q.** The next one. [1374:23] **A.** The user name of that destination account. [1374:24] **Q.** The next one. [1374:25] **A.** The time of the transfer. [1375:1] **Q.** So basically from, to, time, date, is that right? [1375:2] **A.** Yes. [1375:3] **Q.** You see the column called coin ID and next to it ticker and next to it coin name. [1375:5] **MR. ROOS:** Can we take those three together. [1375:6] **Q.** What is this information? [1375:7] **A.** These are all descriptors of the asset transferred. They described the numerical ID in the database, the ticker or shorthand representation of that coin or asset, and then the full name of that coin or asset. [1375:11] **Q.** So starting at the top, USD, what's that? [1375:12] **A.** U.S. dollars. [1375:13] **Q.** Then just to take another one, EUR, what's that? [1375:14] **A.** Euro. [1375:15] **MR. ROOS:** We can zoom out on this. [1375:16] The next two columns, can we take those. [1375:17] **Q.** What's the information on these two columns? [1375:18] **A.** They describe the sizes of the transfer. The first column does so in units of the coin. The second column does so in dollar-equivalence units. [1375:21] **Q.** Let's look at the last column. What does notes refer to? [1375:22] **A.** These are notes that are added to the transfer. The first two look to me like notes automatically added by the FTX system. All the other ones were added by a developer running the script. [1376:1] **MR. ROOS:** We can zoom out. [1376:2] **Q.** For any particular transfer how do we read this, left to right, right to left, up to down? [1376:4] **A.** Left to right. [1376:5] **Q.** Just give us an example. [1376:6] **MR. ROOS:** Let's zoom in on the first transaction on August 17, so it's the third one down. This is not going to work, to zoom in on it that way. Why don't we start with just the first five columns and zoom in for that date, so row 3 -- that's fine. [1376:11] **Q.** Can you just narrate -- for the row 3, narrate for us what this transaction is. [1376:13] **A.** The first row here describing a transfer made on August 17 of 2022 from info@Alameda Research.com/FTX fiat old to fiat@FTX.com. [1376:16] **MR. ROOS:** Let's look at, just so can get it zoomed in, the rest of that row 3 from coin ID to the end of it. [1376:18] **Q.** So a transfer on that date in what? [1376:19] **A.** Of euros in the amount of 339 million with notes attached called moving counterparty balances to different account. [1376:21] **Q.** What was the effect of the info@Alameda Research FTX fiat old subaccount transferring, to take the first one, that amount of euros to the fiat@FTX.com account? [1376:24] **A.** The FTX fiat old account became that much more negative in euros, and the fiat@FTX.com account became that much more [1377:1] positive. If this was the amount that was determined that Alameda should have in its bank accounts for euros, now FTX fiat old after this transfer would correctly reflect the amount Alameda owed, and fiat@FTX.com would correctly reflect the amount that FTX owed. [1377:6] **Q.** Just to clarify, is money actually being transferred, or is it a bookkeeping entry, or something else? [1377:8] **A.** This is bookkeeping. There isn't a physical wire that associates with it. [1377:10] **Q.** Zooming out, looking at all of the transfers that occurred on August 17, what was the combined effect of these? [1377:12] **A.** The movement of lots of funds. Lots of liabilities shifted from fiat@FTX.com to FTX fiat old. [1377:14] **Q.** I think said earlier that the end result was that this info@Alameda Research FTX fiat old account had approximately a negative $8 billion balance? [1377:17] **A.** Correct. [1377:18] **Q.** How was that account able to have a negative $8 billion balance? [1377:20] **A.** It, as an accounting account, had the allow-negative flag, which allowed it to be unboundedly negative. [1377:22] **Q.** What does unboundedly -- [1377:23] **A.** Without bound. It could go negative without consequence or limits. [1377:25] **Q.** After the fiat balance, the negative fiat balance was [1378:1] assigned to this Alameda subaccount, what happened? [1378:2] **A.** I was -- I noticed it at some point. [1378:3] **Q.** Why did you notice it? [1378:4] **A.** Jayesh had asked me to pull some FTX revenue stats from the database. In doing so, I observed that one line item for revenue, line of interest fees, had spiked dramatically, from like $200,000 to 800,000. I dug into why it had done so and identified that the marginal $800,000 lined up with one bip, which was a rate charged to the additional negative $8 billion now housed in Alameda's main account. [1379:1] BY MR. ROOS: [1379:2] **Q.** All right. So a few follow-ups. [1379:3] First, when was it that you saw Alameda Research was being charged more interest on its accounts? [1379:5] **A.** I don't remember the exact date, but I——I think July or August. [1379:7] **Q.** You mentioned this was related to a conversation with someone named Jayesh. Who is that? [1379:9] **A.** Jayesh was the head of finance for FTX. [1379:10] **Q.** Okay. And could you explain how it was that this account was being——or withdrawn. [1379:12] Can you explain why it was that this account was accruing interest. [1379:14] **A.** There was a system in place to charge Alameda and other accounts with lines of credit, if configured, for their used line of credit. This considered negative balances. As part of moving fiat@ftx.com, part of that amount, into FTX fiat old, there was an additional negative $8 billion in one of the Alameda high-level accounts, and so that was considered as part of what was the used line of credit and they were now being charged interest on it. [1379:22] **Q.** I'm going to ask you some more questions about line of credit in a bit, but just at a high level, what is a line of credit? [1379:25] **A.** It's a nonwithdrawable dollar amount that's granted to [1380:1] allow for easier trading without actually having to deposit as much money. [1380:3] **Q.** And why was this $8 billion negative balance on the FTX fiat old account being charged interest as a line of credit? [1380:5] **A.** Because it contributed to total negative balances in all subaccounts of this user, which was one of the factors considered when determining how much of Alameda's granted line of credit was used and therefore charged interest on. [1380:9] **Q.** Now what, if any, conversations did you have with the defendant about the charging of interest on this account? [1380:11] **A.** I brought this up with him. I said, it looks like after the splits that Adam and Andrea did of FTX versus Alameda fiat liabilities, they put it inside a subaccount that's contributing to the amount that Alameda is charged in interest. [1380:15] **Q.** What, if anything, did he say in response? [1380:16] **A.** He said that seemed incorrect, in theory those balances are in banks, it's not something that they're borrowing in sort of the traditional sense, they're custodying it, so they shouldn't be charged interest, let's move as a liability out of a location where it's being charged interest. [1380:21] **Q.** What happened next? [1380:22] **A.** I followed his instructions. I asked a group with a bunch of Alameda FTX and traders——Alameda traders and developers and FTX developers if there was an account that I could move this to that they were tracking so they wouldn't lose track of it [1381:1] such that it was——such that it wouldn't be charged interest anymore, and I believe one of Terence Choo and Caroline Ellison gave me the name of the account to move it to. [1381:4] **Q.** And who was on——who do you recall being on that message exchange about this? [1381:6] **A.** This was in Signal. At the very least it included me, Gary, Adam, Andrea, Sam, Terence Choo, and Caroline Ellison. I believe it also had other Alameda traders and FTX developers. [1381:9] **Q.** And so was this FTX fiat old account moved? [1381:10] **A.** Yes. [1381:11] **Q.** To what account was it moved to? [1381:12] **A.** I moved it to the account that I was given by the Alameda traders, one called seoyuncharles88@gmail.com. [1381:14] **MR. ROOS:** Could we please publish what's in evidence as Government Exhibit 645. [1381:16] And could we zoom in on, just to make it a little larger, how about the first three columns. [1381:18] **Q.** And Mr. Singh, what does this show? [1381:19] **A.** These show the subaccounts under the seoyuncharles88@gmail.com account. The first column is an account ID. We've talked about that some. The second column described the ID of the user that the subaccount is housed under. So in all cases it's the seoyuncharles88 account. And the user name describes the——like the label for the account, which is only generated at the time that the account is [1382:1] created. [1382:2] **Q.** So looking at the user name, at the last one on this list, is that the same user name as the one we saw on the last exhibit? [1382:5] **A.** Yes. [1382:6] **Q.** And why is that user name for that subaccount now associated with seoyuncharles88@gmail.com? [1382:8] **A.** The user name says inputalameda-research.com because it was Adam or Andrea made the subaccount under info@alameda-research.com. It now shows it being associated with seoyuncharles88 because at instruction, I moved its ownership from inputalameda-research.com to seoyuncharles88. [1382:13] **Q.** What was the result of moving this subaccount to be under seoyuncharles88@gmail.com account? [1382:15] **A.** My understanding is that the——Alameda continued to track the liability as it had——no change there——but that interest was no longer being charged on this amount. [1382:18] **Q.** And how, if at all, was the defendant involved in the movement of this subaccount to the seoyun account? [1382:20] **A.** He instructed me to make the movement, and he was in the chat in which a trader told me which account to move it to. [1382:22] **MR. ROOS:** Your Honor, I'm about to change topics. I can keep going or—— [1382:24] **THE COURT:** No. I think we could use a break. [1382:25] **MR. ROOS:** Okay. [1383:1] **THE COURT:** 2:00, members of the jury. [1383:2] **THE DEPUTY CLERK:** Will the jurors please come this way. Bring your notebooks with you. All rise. [1383:4] (Luncheon recess) [1384:1] AFTERNOON SESSION [1384:2] 2:07 p.m. [1384:3] (In open court; jury present) [1384:4] **THE COURT:** The jurors and the defendant all are present, as they have been throughout. [1384:6] The witness is reminded he's still under oath. [1384:7] Mr. Roos, you can continue. [1384:8] **MR. ROOS:** Thank you, your Honor. [1384:9] BY MR. ROOS: [1384:10] **Q.** I want to change topics and talk to you about futures trading and collateral. [1384:12] Did FTX allow customers to trade cryptocurrency futures? [1384:14] **A.** Yes. [1384:15] **Q.** And what's a cryptocurrency future? [1384:16] **A.** It's a product that customers can buy such that if it goes up, they'll make money, or short, that if it goes down, they'll make money. [1384:19] **Q.** So for example, what does a Bitcoin future do? [1384:20] **A.** It's a product, a financial product, that eventually resolves the price of a Bitcoin and so users can bet on Bitcoin by trading it. [1384:23] **Q.** What do you mean by resolves the price of a Bitcoin? [1384:24] **A.** At some point the future will expire. When it does, it will be——every——every future that is purchased will turn into [1385:1] the price of Bitcoin at the time of expiry. [1385:2] **Q.** So if I thought the price of Bitcoin was going to go up, what would I do? [1385:4] **A.** You would buy the future. [1385:5] **Q.** What type of future? [1385:6] **A.** The Bitcoin future. [1385:7] **Q.** And what if I thought the price of Bitcoin was going to go down? [1385:9] **A.** You'd short the future, or sell it. [1385:10] **Q.** Now to do futures trading——well, let me ask you, did ftx.com allow futures trading? [1385:12] **A.** From day one. [1385:13] **Q.** And to do futures trading, what was required of a customer? [1385:14] **A.** Customer had to deposit collateral. [1385:15] **Q.** What's collateral? [1385:16] **A.** Real liquid funds that the customer owned used as safety buffer such that if they lose money, the customer can get liquidated, their positions closed, before they lose the entirety of their collateral. [1385:20] **Q.** Okay. So to break that down, what can be collateral? [1385:21] **A.** Liquid funds, things like dollars or Bitcoin or other tokens. [1385:23] **Q.** Did FTX treat different types of collateral differently? [1385:24] **A.** Yes. [1385:25] **Q.** How so? [1386:1] **A.** Some forms of collateral, everything that wasn't just US dollars or other forms of fiat, had a haircut applied to it, meaning that if, you know, one Bitcoin was worth $20,000, it may only contribute $18,000, say, towards their effective collateral. [1386:6] **Q.** What requirements did FTX have, if any, about where collateral had to be kept? [1386:8] **A.** On the exchange. [1386:9] **Q.** What do you mean by that? [1386:10] **A.** Customers had to deposit their collateral. [1386:11] **Q.** Deposit it where? [1386:12] **A.** To FTX. [1386:13] **Q.** And you mentioned liquidations, and you talked about that in the morning. What happened if a customer, for example, was shorting Bitcoin and they started to lose money? [1386:16] **A.** If a customer was losing enough money——money——enough money that it approached the value of their collateral, so say if they had a thousand dollars of collateral and they had lost $600 in trading, there would be some point, maybe, you know, when they lost 700, at which——when FTX would liquidate the customer, closing their positions, as in selling off whatever futures bets they had made, hopefully——with a goal that they wouldn't lose the remaining $300. [1386:24] **Q.** Are you familiar with the term "clawback"? [1386:25] **A.** Yes. [1387:1] **Q.** What's a clawback? [1387:2] **A.** A clawback is a mechanism for resolving any losses that arise from a liquidation. And by losses here, I mean instances in which the account being liquidated ends up negative. So you could imagine that somebody has——same thing——a thousand dollars of collateral, they make a bet, and before the liquidation is complete, their futures position has actually lost $1,001, so they've lost more money than they ever deposited in collateral. There's negative $1 around to resolve. One way of resolving this is through a clawback, a system in which that 1 dollar is——that loss is sort of socialized, so it's called, across a bunch of other users, as in everybody else pays. [1387:13] **Q.** While you were working at FTX did it ever do clawbacks? [1387:14] **A.** No, not that I'm aware of. [1387:15] **Q.** And what did the code say, if anything, about clawbacks? [1387:16] **A.** Yeah, I brought this up with Sam and Gary at some point when I discovered it. Clawbacks weren't even implemented. [1387:18] **Q.** What do you mean "weren't even implemented"? [1387:19] **A.** That the code could never cause a clawback. [1387:20] **Q.** So what does that mean? [1387:21] **A.** Even in instances in which a customer account ended up negative and the insurance fund, which is a sort of bailout pool of cash, was empty, the expected option for resolving the negative balance would be a clawback, but there was nothing in the code that would do that. Instead, the account would remain [1388:1] negative and——and Sam and Gary or others would sort of manually handle it however they saw fit. [1388:3] **Q.** Now did Alameda do——I'm sorry. Did Alameda trade futures on FTX? [1388:5] **A.** Yes. [1388:6] **Q.** You testified a moment ago that futures trading typically required collateral. What, if any, conversations did you have with the defendant about the collateral Alameda had to support its trading, its futures trading? [1388:10] **A.** I had a discussion in September, early September, about this. [1388:12] **Q.** What did you—— [1388:13] **THE COURT:** What year? [1388:14] **THE WITNESS:** 2022. [1388:15] **Q.** What did you discuss with the defendant in September 2022 about this? [1388:17] **A.** That historically, according to a project that I'd run, like a batch historical data, there were points when Alameda's main account had not nearly enough collateral if you did not include their enormous line of credit. [1388:21] **Q.** Okay. So let's start with the timing of this conversation. Do you remember approximately what date it occurred on? [1388:23] **A.** Yeah. I believe it was either like August——sometime between August 31st and September 2nd. [1388:25] **Q.** You mentioned a calculation you did. What was the [1389:1] calculation? [1389:2] **A.** I wrote a script that would emit for each day Alameda's total position size, as in the USD equivalent of how many——how much they had on in futures positions, the total collateral they had in the system, and how much collateral was needed to support their positions. From these, I could determine how——how much collateral they didn't have, and so how much of their line of credit in their main accounts they were using. [1389:9] **Q.** And so before we talk about line of credit, what did you determine about how much collateral they didn't have? [1389:11] **A.** There were points when, using just their deposits, not their line of credit, Alameda had around $10 billion——they were like on——$10 billion short of what they needed to be. [1389:14] **Q.** Now you've mentioned line of credit a few times. For starters, what is a line of credit? [1389:16] **A.** In the context of FTX, it's an amount that is granted to the customer, it's not withdrawable, but it contributes towards what FTX considered to be their collateral, meaning that customers could trade using that line of credit as if they had deposited funds but without actually having done so. [1389:21] **Q.** Just to be clear, is a line of credit the same as collateral? [1389:23] **A.** It's not the same. [1389:24] **Q.** What's the difference? [1389:25] **A.** It's——if there's——there aren't physical assets backing, [1390:1] there's just trust. [1390:2] **Q.** Did Alameda have a line of credit? [1390:3] **A.** An enormous one. [1390:4] **Q.** How large was it? [1390:5] **A.** By the end, it was $65 billion. [1390:6] **Q.** How did that compare to other customers? [1390:7] **A.** Significantly larger. [1390:8] **Q.** What do you mean by that? [1390:9] **A.** Other customers, if memory serves, had lines of credit on the order of hundreds or tens of millions of dollars. [1390:11] **Q.** As far as you knew, was it publicly known outside of Alameda——sorry——outside of FTX that Alameda had a $65 billion line of credit? [1390:14] **A.** Not that I know of. I don't think it was known. [1390:15] **Q.** So circle back to your conversation with the defendant on September 1st or 2nd. After you told him that Alameda did not have enough collateral in FTX without its line of credit, what, if anything, did he say? [1390:19] **A.** His first question was if I was including all of Alameda's other subaccounts and accounts on the system. I responded no, the purpose of this exercise was just for evaluating Alameda's main account, the one we've seen with account ID 9. Sam came back to me sometime later and asked if I could transfer in the Serum that I, Gary, Caroline, and Sam personally held into Alameda's main account, at some historical time, to make it [1391:1] appear that Alameda always had more collateral than it did. [1391:2] **Q.** Okay. For starters, what's Serum? [1391:3] **A.** Serum is a cryptocurrency that Sam and Gary created. [1391:4] **Q.** And why did you, Gary Wang, and Sam Bankman-Fried have Serum in your own accounts? [1391:6] **A.** We, like other employees, bought a lot of it at Serum's genesis. Sam decided how much everyone could buy. I think everyone bought the maximum allotted amount. [1391:9] **Q.** What would it mean to move the Serum? [1391:10] **A.** It would mean——like mechanically, you mean? [1391:11] **Q.** Yeah. What were you talking about there? [1391:12] **A.** Yeah. Making a transfer, like the ones we've seen in the FTX database, but backdating it, making it appear as though it happened earlier so that it looked as if the funds had been there for a long time. [1391:16] **Q.** You used the phrase earlier in your testimony "a historical time." What did you mean by that? [1391:18] **A.** Some previous time, sometime before Alameda had, you know, $10 billion less than it should have, or it was using $10 billion of its line of credit. [1391:21] **Q.** What was the purpose of backdating? [1391:22] **A.** To make it appear as if Alameda did have sufficient collateral to fool the eventual targets of——the eventual—— [1391:24] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1391:25] **THE COURT:** What's the objection? [1392:1] **MR. COHEN:** To the latter part of the answer. [1392:2] **MR. ROOS:** Relevant to his understanding of the purpose. [1392:4] **THE COURT:** Overruled. [1392:5] BY MR. ROOS: [1392:6] **Q.** Go ahead. [1392:7] **A.** I understood the purpose to be to fool the eventual recipient of this——this, like, data that I was collecting, which was the CFTC. [1392:10] **Q.** What's the CFTC? [1392:11] **A.** Blanking on the first letter. [1392:12] **Q.** If you don't remember what the acronym is, can you just tell what you understand the agency to be or what the acronym stands for? [1392:15] **A.** Commodities and futures trading commission, possibly. [1392:16] **Q.** Now this transaction you testified about, can you walk——can you describe how it would have changed that negative $10 billion number. [1392:19] **A.** All right. So it would have made it look like Alameda's main account held much more Serum than it actually did. But the Serum was actually, you know, in locked form. It would be locked Serum. That's what we had, locked Serum by default, because it isn't liquid, it can't be sold, was not something that FTX considered to be contributing to collateral. And so implicit in Sam's request was to also adjust the rules about [1393:1] what I was computing as collateral to include this locked asset. It would make it eventually appear as if Alameda was using a lot less of its line of credit, not $10 billion. [1393:4] **Q.** And how, if at all, would this have affected Alameda's line of credit that you were talking about? [1393:6] **A.** Do you mind clarifying the question. [1393:7] **Q.** You said this was in the context of a conversation about collateral and lines of credit. How, if at all, did including this Serum affect the line of credit issue? [1393:10] **A.** It didn't change anything about the line of credit directly. What it did was it would have adjusted my calculation about how much of it was used since any amount of collateral held was necessarily counted against what was, you know——it wasn't——that's an amount that wasn't drawn from the line of credit and wasn't used from the line of credit. [1393:16] **Q.** Now did you do this transaction? [1393:17] **A.** I didn't. [1393:18] **Q.** Why not? [1393:19] **A.** It felt wrong. I mean, I was fine giving up my personal assets. I'd taken on debts and given up my assets for the company countless times. But I understood the purpose of this exercise to be, you know, to fool a US regulator and to fool employees of the company, and I wasn't comfortable with that. [1393:24] **Q.** While we're on this topic of line of credits, I want to ask you a few follow-up questions. [1394:1] To be clear, did most customers on FTX have lines of credit? [1394:3] **A.** Not most. [1394:4] **Q.** And who did have lines of credit? [1394:5] **A.** The EIT users, sometimes those were individuals, but oftentimes they were trading firms, large trading firms. [1394:7] **Q.** And apart from Alameda, did any customers have lines of credit in the range of a billion dollars or more? [1394:9] **A.** I don't recall what the largest one was outside of Alameda by the end of FTX, but I know that at some point in 2022 when I inspected them, there weren't any that were over a billion dollars except for Alameda's. [1394:13] **MR. ROOS:** At this time the government offers Government Exhibit 5, which, according to a stipulation marked S2003, is a spreadsheet titled locs, dated September 5, 2022. [1394:16] **THE COURT:** Received. [1394:17] (Government's Exhibit 5 received in evidence) [1394:18] **Q.** Mr. Singh, I want to ask you about a few of the numbers on this spreadsheet before you, okay? [1394:20] **A.** Okay. [1394:21] **Q.** Do you see in column A, the heading says email? [1394:22] **A.** Yes. [1394:23] **Q.** And in column B, it says sum? [1394:24] **A.** Yes. [1394:25] **Q.** So reading in those two columns, do you see row 2, where it [1395:1] says info@alameda-research.com? [1395:2] **A.** Yes. [1395:3] **Q.** And do you see what the sum number is? [1395:4] **A.** Right. It's north of 65 billion. [1395:5] **Q.** Do you recognize that number? [1395:6] **A.** Yeah. [1395:7] **Q.** What do you recognize it as? [1395:8] **A.** This is——this matches my recollection of what the line of credit was for, for Alameda's account. [1395:10] **Q.** And what's the next largest below it? [1395:11] **A.** 150 million given to Genesis Capital. [1395:12] **Q.** Now does this spreadsheet anywhere show Alameda's balances on FTX? [1395:14] **A.** So I don't——I didn't see this spreadsheet while I was at FTX and I don't know how all the values were computed, but—— [1395:16] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1395:17] **THE COURT:** The document speaks for itself, counsel. [1395:18] **Q.** Do you see this net number? [1395:19] **A.** Yes. [1395:20] **Q.** Okay. What's the net number? [1395:21] **A.** It's the sum of—— [1395:22] **MR. COHEN:** Same objection. [1395:23] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1395:24] **MR. ROOS:** Can I just have him read the number into the record. That's actually all I was going for. [1396:1] **THE COURT:** You've got it highlighted, and the jury is looking at it there. [1396:3] **MR. ROOS:** Okay. Thank you, your Honor. [1396:4] BY MR. ROOS: [1396:5] **Q.** Picking up on something you said a moment ago, this document that lists that 65 billion number and this negative 5 billion number, did you see this while you were at Alameda? [1396:8] **A.** No, nor while at FTX that I recall. [1396:9] **Q.** Okay. And do you recognize the writing style on it? [1396:10] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1396:11] **A.** Yes. [1396:12] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1396:13] **Q.** Are you familiar——do you have any familiarity with the defendant's writing style? [1396:15] **A.** A lot of familiarity. [1396:16] **Q.** How? [1396:17] **A.** I've seen his writing and writing process many times over our five years working together. [1396:19] **Q.** Did you ever see him write any spreadsheets? [1396:20] **A.** All the time. [1396:21] **Q.** Are you familiar with his writing style on spreadsheets? [1396:22] **A.** Yes. [1396:23] **Q.** Do you recognize anything about the writing style in this spreadsheet? [1396:25] **A.** I do. [1397:1] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1397:2] **MR. ROOS:** 901(b)(4) and (b)(5). [1397:3] **THE COURT:** Did you say (d) or (b)? [1397:4] **MR. ROOS:** (b) as in boy, (4) and (5). [1397:5] **THE COURT:** Thank you. [1397:6] I think you need a better foundation than you have. [1397:7] BY MR. ROOS: [1397:8] **Q.** Were there any——you testified a moment ago that you reviewed spreadsheets written by the defendant. Were there any distinctive characteristics about how he wrote spreadsheets? [1397:11] **A.** There were. [1397:12] **Q.** What were they? [1397:13] **A.** They were rarely ever color coded; they frequently exhibited some sort of casualness about naming and structure; they rarely had capital letters; they usually, my recollection, often had data on the left and summaries of that data on the right, as opposed to like further down. [1397:18] **Q.** How about how, if at all, accounts were referred to in them? [1397:20] **A.** If——if they were like pulled from a data source, they might include like the full description of the account or login. Else they would refer——you'd often have shorthand that——that Sam used. [1397:24] **Q.** And do you see in column L the four email addresses? [1397:25] **A.** Yes. [1398:1] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1398:2] **THE COURT:** Overruled. [1398:3] **Q.** Do you recognize those email addresses? [1398:4] **A.** I do. [1398:5] **Q.** And who did they belong to? [1398:6] **A.** The first belongs to Sam. [1398:7] **THE COURT:** No, no, no, no, no. You're just reading from the document now. [1398:9] **MR. ROOS:** I'm just asking him whose email addresses does he recognize. [1398:11] **THE COURT:** Fair enough. Okay. Go ahead. [1398:12] **A.** The first belongs to Sam, the second to Caroline, the third to Gary, the fourth to me. To clarify, when I say belongs, my——mine and possibly Sam's and Gary's weren't like beneficially owned by us. They were admin accounts to be used on the system. [1398:17] **Q.** Now do you recognize the writing style in the document? [1398:18] **A.** I do. [1398:19] **Q.** Whose writing style do you recognize? [1398:20] **A.** Sam's. [1398:21] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1398:22] **THE COURT:** Members of the jury, it's ultimately up to you to decide whether this document was written by the person who the witness is going to identify. There's enough here so that I've concluded you're entitled to make that judgment one [1399:1] way or the other. [1399:2] Okay. Overruled. [1399:3] **A.** Forgive me. This isn't a question that you asked, but another distinctive characteristic—— [1399:5] **Q.** No. I think there was a pending question. There was an objection, I think your Honor overruled, so I think you have to answer the question. [1399:8] **MR. ROOS:** Is that right, your Honor? [1399:9] **THE COURT:** Yes. And I think he answered before, or at least before the reporter got Mr. Cohen's objection. Whether that was temporally right or not, I don't know, but he answered. [1399:13] **MR. ROOS:** Okay. My apologies. I didn't see it. [1399:14] BY MR. ROOS: [1399:15] **Q.** Now you said that you did not see this spreadsheet at the time. Did there come a time when you later learned some of the information? [1399:18] **A.** Yes. [1399:19] **Q.** So let's move forward. [1399:20] **MR. ROOS:** We can take this down. [1399:21] **Q.** Do you recall ever participating in a conversation about shutting down Alameda? [1399:23] **A.** Yes. [1399:24] **Q.** And what led to that conversation? [1399:25] **A.** Sam sent a Google Doc over Signal to me and Gary titled "We [1400:1] came, we saw, we researched." It laid out a case for shutting down Alameda, citing that Sam didn't have faith in its——the competency of its leadership without him more involved, and that the PR cost with both FTX and Alameda coexisting was high. [1400:5] **Q.** What type of document was this, just to be clear? [1400:6] **A.** A Google Doc. [1400:7] **Q.** Did it have a title? [1400:8] **A.** "We came, we saw, we researched." [1400:9] **Q.** Did you read the Google Doc about shutting down Alameda? [1400:10] **A.** I read most but not all of it. [1400:11] **Q.** After reading the document what, if any, proposals did you make with respect to Alameda? [1400:13] **A.** It occurred to me that the cost, the cost that Sam cited was Alameda and FTX coexisting; really the cost is Alameda existing on FTX, and so I proposed shutting down Alameda on FTX as opposed to shutting down Alameda entirely. [1400:17] **Q.** What would be required to shut down Alameda on FTX? [1400:18] **A.** I remember I listed out what I believed the requirements would be in the chat. We'd have to close a bunch of illiquid markets that Alameda was primarily market making on. They were not a significant market maker overall, but there were some markets where nobody else bothered to trade. We'd have to revamp how the OTC system worked——over-the-counter trading. Alameda was sort of plugged in as the only provider for those trades, but that could have been——that could have been, you [1401:1] know, given to a pool of market makers. We'd have to have Alameda close out all of its accounts, return everything that it was negative in, like that main account that was negative 2.8 billion, withdraw everything that it was positive in. Maybe a few other things. But those are some big ones. [1401:6] **Q.** So let me ask you a few questions about closing out Alameda on FTX. [1401:8] For starters, by this time, September 2022, to what extent was Alameda's presence on FTX necessary for market making? [1401:11] **A.** Not very. [1401:12] **Q.** What do you mean by that? [1401:13] **A.** There was a time when Alameda was in some 20, 30 percent of trades. By 2022, or at least by a point in 2022, Alameda was only a party to like some 2 percent of trades or thereabouts. Alameda was not nearly as significant a player as it used to be on the platform. The ways in which it was involved that still provided value to the exchange were replaceable for——or not so important that it was necessary. [1401:20] **Q.** And by 2022, did Alameda need the "Allow Negative" feature to do market making? [1401:22] **A.** I don't know all the details of how it did its market making, and it's possible that it like availed of "Allow Negative" in some way, but fundamentally, no, I don't think that to perform the duties that were more important of it, it [1402:1] needed all the things that "Allow Negative" granted. [1402:2] **Q.** By 2022, was Alameda needed for stablecoin conversion? [1402:3] **A.** They were never needed for it. My belief is that they were doing it out of convenience in the beginning. Certainly once FTX had grown, it had enough staff, those staff could just manage the stablecoin creations and redemptions. [1402:7] **Q.** You mentioned that Alameda would need to close out its accounts. What did you mean by that? [1402:9] **A.** Alameda had many accounts on FTX. Like we'd seen with that other spreadsheet, some of them were big positive numbers, some of them big negative numbers. Each of those has underlying numbers for, you know, balances of specific coins. Closing out means making every one of those numbers zero, by depositing any amounts that are negative and withdrawing any amounts that are positive. [1402:16] **Q.** So after you proposed shutting down Alameda on FTX, what, if anything, did the defendant say? [1402:18] **A.** I first proposed it inside the chat with myself, Gary, and him, and asked if I could share it with Caroline to talk about its viability. Sam said "not crazy." His way of—— [1402:21] **THE COURT:** He said what? [1402:22] **THE WITNESS:** "Not crazy." He used "not crazy" to greenlight a proposal without fully endorsing it. [1402:24] **Q.** Did you ask Caroline Ellison about the viability of shutting down Alameda trading on FTX? [1403:1] **A.** I did. I sent a message inside the hashtag organization Signal group, which had me, Gary, Caroline, and Sam. I said: The PR costs of having Alameda on FTX seem really steep. I'm thinking about if it's possible to have Alameda shut down on FTX. Here are some six things I think that would take. [1403:6] **Q.** You mentioned PR costs. What were you referring to? [1403:7] **A.** Public relations cost, that there was a lot of worry and fear in the crypto ecosystem about conflicts of interest between Alameda and FTX. [1403:10] **Q.** So how did Caroline Ellison respond to your message? [1403:11] **A.** She said——and I believe verbatim——"That's impossible." [1403:12] **Q.** How did you respond to that? [1403:13] **A.** I said: Which part of it? I was pretty alarmed. And I was hoping it wasn't the part about closing out accounts. [1403:15] **Q.** What did she say? [1403:16] **A.** That it was the part about closing out accounts. [1403:17] **Q.** Just to be clear, who was on this hashtag organization Signal chat? [1403:19] **A.** Me, Gary, Sam, Caroline. [1403:20] **Q.** What, if anything, did Gary Wang say in the conversation at this point? [1403:22] **A.** At this point Gary said Alameda is borrowing 13 billion from FTX. [1403:24] **Q.** What did you say in response to that? [1403:25] **A.** I was really hoping that I misunderstood, and I called for [1404:1] a meeting immediately. [1404:2] **Q.** What was your reaction about hearing Alameda owed $13 billion? [1404:4] **A.** I was really afraid. [1404:5] **Q.** What do you mean? [1404:6] **A.** The June exercise, I thought Alameda had positive balances on FTX, that it was borrowing lots in some places but that overall they had more money than they didn't. This suggested an entirely different reality. I was hoping that I didn't really understand what Gary meant by borrowing, but if I did, this was absolutely devastating. [1404:12] **Q.** And how, if at all, did Alameda's borrowing $13 billion from FTX affect FTX customer funds? [1404:14] **A.** The borrowing had to have been from customer funds in large part because FTX itself didn't have——like, didn't own that much money. [1404:17] **Q.** How, if at all, did the defendant react when Caroline Ellison said Alameda has——I'm sorry——when Gary Wang said Alameda was borrowing 13 billion from FTX? [1404:20] **A.** I was sitting next to Sam at the time. We were in the office. So I got some real sense. He seemed unsurprised and made up what I understood to be a false excuse for dodging the meeting. [1404:24] **Q.** So you mentioned the meeting. Did you in fact meet? [1404:25] **A.** Yes. [1405:1] **Q.** Okay. And then who did you meet with? [1405:2] **A.** Just Gary and Caroline because Sam didn't come. [1405:3] **Q.** What was your belief at this point as to whether Alameda could repay the $13 billion it owed? [1405:5] **A.** Before the meeting I was really hoping that I misunderstood what had been said and that Alameda could in fact close out and repay what it owned. After the meeting I was significantly less hopeful. [1405:9] **Q.** Now did there come a time when you spoke to the defendant about this topic? [1405:11] **A.** That evening. [1405:12] **Q.** And where did you speak with the defendant? [1405:13] **A.** On the balcony of the Orchid 6 penthouse where we lived. [1405:14] **Q.** Why did you meet on the balcony? [1405:15] **A.** Sam and I almost never met; very, very rarely. I knew this needed to be really private. I figured that if we went to our two most common spaces to talk, which were my room or in the office, that both of those were very frequently used by other people for meetings and that others could stumble in on us, and I knew that there was something really serious going on and I didn't want people stumbling in. [1405:22] **Q.** What time of day was this? [1405:23] **A.** Evening into night. [1405:24] **MR. ROOS:** Could we please publish Government Exhibit 1554, which is in evidence. [1406:1] **Q.** Mr. Singh, what's this? [1406:2] **A.** This is the balcony that we met on. [1406:3] **Q.** Where were you located on this balcony when you spoke with the defendant? [1406:5] **A.** I was pacing behind where these baskets on the left are. Sam was reclined on one of the white like chaise chairs behind that. [1406:8] **Q.** How long was your conversation with the defendant on the balcony? [1406:10] **A.** Hour, hour and a half. [1406:11] **Q.** Let me ask you a few questions about the conversation. [1406:12] First, how did the conversation begin? [1406:13] **A.** I said: Caroline's really freaked out about the NAV situation and so am I. NAV, by the way, means net asset value, which was——I wasn't very fluent in financial terms. This was my crude way of referring to the hole. [1406:17] **Q.** What do you mean by the hole? [1406:18] **A.** The fact that Caroline had suggested that Alameda couldn't return its borrows, that meant that there was, in my lingo, a hole, a deficit of customer funds. [1406:21] **Q.** What, if anything, did the defendant say in response to your initial comment that you and Caroline Ellison were freaking out? [1406:24] **A.** He said: I'm not sure what there is to worry about. NAV is fantastic by almost any measure. It was super positive even [1407:1] if you don't include FTX and FTX.US equity. [1407:2] **Q.** Did you speak to the defendant directly about the hole? [1407:3] **A.** Yes. [1407:4] **Q.** And what did you discuss? [1407:5] **A.** I said next: Well, what about what Caroline said today and Gary said today, that there's 13 billion borrowed and we can't pay it all? Sam said: Right, that. We are a little short on deliverable. [1407:9] **Q.** What do you mean by deliverable? [1407:10] **A.** Assets that can be delivered to customers as opposed to illiquid assets. [1407:12] **Q.** Did he say by how much FTX was short on deliverable assets? [1407:13] **A.** I asked: How much is it short by? Sam said: That is the wrong question to be asking. The right question is how much can we deliver, and in 24 hours, if pressed, I think we could deliver around $5 billion; given some more weeks, substantially more; given some more weeks after that, substantially more. [1407:18] **Q.** Now what, if anything, did the defendant say about how this had been affecting him over the prior year? [1407:20] **A.** He did describe it. I said something like "Jesus F'ing Christ." Sam said: Yeah, this has been taxing me some 5 to 10 percent of my productivity for——and he either said for this year or like for this calendar year or since before the last year. I said: I think this is going to be doing a lot more damage to me, hitting me a lot harder. Sam said: Yeah, I was [1408:1] worried about this. In hindsight, it might have been a mistake for me to circulate that document this morning. People are thus going to freak out. I said: I understand it's not productive to respond emotionally. [1408:5] **Q.** What, if anything, did you discuss about a plan for addressing Alameda's negative balance? [1408:7] **A.** I asked what the hell the plan was, what are we going to do. Sam said he's not too worried and he described a number of sort of strategies that we could pursue in parallel going forward. [1408:11] **Q.** What kind of strategies did he describe? [1408:12] **A.** He described selling off Alameda's illiquid but, according to his estimation, valuable assets, and properties; he described, for the ones that weren't sellable but generated revenue, making sort of low-hanging changes to make them more profitable; he discussed raising from investors, selling FTX equity; and he discussed making FTX——oh, he said that FTX.US futures, which we believed would come online, you know, any day now, would be a boon to the company, and would be great for revenue and for its valuation, and that there were many engineering projects that were crucial and were themselves very valuable. [1408:23] **Q.** Did you have any discussions about expenses? [1408:24] **A.** Yes. [1408:25] **Q.** What did you discuss? [1409:1] **A.** I asked if now, Sam would take seriously cutting expenses or——and curbing them going forward. He said yes, definitely, he's working with that——working on that with Ramnik. [1409:4] **MR. ROOS:** We can take this down. [1409:5] **Q.** After this conversation, what was your mental state? [1409:6] **A.** I was blindsided and horrified. I felt really betrayed, that five years of blood, sweat, and tears from me and so many employees, driving towards something that I thought was a beautiful force for good, had turned out to be so evil. I knew that customers were betrayed. So many customers had to put their trust in us. And, you know, according to Sam's take, chances to rebuild this hole depended enormously on me continuing to try to make the company successful, and I knew that would require me betraying customers and employees. [1409:15] **Q.** Did you consider leaving the company? [1409:16] **A.** Every day. [1409:17] **Q.** Why didn't you? [1409:18] **A.** How could I live with myself if my departure precipitated a fall that might have been unavoidable——or might have been avoidable. [1409:21] **Q.** After your conversation with the defendant on the balcony, what steps, if any, did the defendant take with respect to raising money for the company? [1409:24] **A.** He followed through on the plan that he discussed in that—— [1409:25] **MR. COHEN:** Objection, foundation. [1410:1] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1410:2] **Q.** You testified that the defendant said he had plans for raising money; is that right? [1410:4] **A.** In that conversation on the balcony, Sam——I had asked to get more details on prospects and plans regarding raising money from investors. Sam had mentioned that he was planning to go to New York in two weeks with Ramnik, and in a month, from the conversation, he was planning on going to the Middle East with Ramnik and Scaramucci. [1410:10] **Q.** Who is Scaramucci? [1410:11] **A.** I think Anthony is his first name. He was the press secretary or chief of staff for Trump for some time and runs a VC firm, I think. [1410:14] **Q.** And after your conversation on the balcony, what, if anything, did you observe about whether these trips took place? [1410:16] **A.** They took place. [1410:17] **Q.** Now did there come a time when the defendant returned from the Middle East? [1410:19] **A.** Yes. [1410:20] **Q.** What, if anything, did the defendant say to employees at FTX about how the trip went? [1410:22] **A.** Sam arrived back from the Middle East in the middle of the day on a weekday, came into the office, and attracted a crowd, like he often does. Sam was regaling everybody with stories of the Middle East and how successful it was and talking about how [1411:1] it's turning a corner and being more progressive culturally and so on. [1411:3] **Q.** Did you speak to the defendant after his return from the Middle East? [1411:5] **A.** Yes. [1411:6] **Q.** In what setting? [1411:7] **A.** I asked him if we could meet again privately. Again, this was an exceedingly rare thing. I did this like less than once a year on average. But I wanted to know what the real deal was with prospects for the raise. [1411:11] **Q.** And did you meet privately? [1411:12] **A.** We did, in his apartment in Gemini 1D. [1411:13] **Q.** Okay. Can you describe the conversation in the apartment. [1411:14] **A.** I started by saying: I'm really not doing well, I thought I might quit, in that conversation. I kind of wanted to put him on notice. I asked: How is it going with NAV? What's the plan? Any updates? I was standing in the living room area, right behind the counter to his kitchen. He was in the kitchen with his back up against the fridge. He described for me in some real detail what the Middle East trip was like and what prospects were from raising——for raising from various investors there. [1411:23] **Q.** Did he say how much money he thought could be raised? [1411:24] **A.** He said that we can make——it's still possible that nothing comes out of this deal, that $0 could be raised, but that we [1412:1] could also come out of this with another $5 billion. [1412:2] **Q.** So 5 billion is not 13 billion. What, if anything, did you discuss about the difference? [1412:4] **A.** I said: I'm really happy to hear we can pull up that much, but, like, oh, my god, we have a lot left. What's the plan? Like, tell me you've got some updates. Sam said: The main line plan remains, making FTX successful and growing it, and that depends on a huge part in you. You're one of the few people, Nishad, that can take that kind of work off my plate so I can focus on the rest of this. [1412:11] **Q.** What was the tone of this conversation? [1412:12] **A.** I was really afraid to ask for a conversation, and I think my fears kind of bore out. Sam was on edge, and I felt he was very mad at me for talking about this, and it was tense. There were long periods of silence. Sam has a——some physical twitches for when he gets angry. [1412:17] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1412:18] **THE COURT:** Strike the last sentence. [1412:19] **MR. ROOS:** Your Honor, I think it's relevant to the tenor of the conversation. [1412:21] **THE COURT:** It's unresponsive to the question. [1412:22] **MR. ROOS:** Yes, your Honor. [1412:23] BY MR. ROOS: [1412:24] **Q.** What was the defendant's body language in the conversation? [1412:25] **MR. COHEN:** Same objection. [1413:1] **THE COURT:** Overruled. [1413:2] **A.** Sam has some physical tells for when he is thinking hard or is upset, and a lot of those were on display. [1413:4] **Q.** What are you referring to? [1413:5] **A.** Puffed out his chest, had his hand back, hands back, he was grinding his finger, closing his eyes, grinding his teeth or tongue in his mouth, and when he opened them to respond, he would sort of glare at me with some intensity. This didn't happen for the whole conversation, but it did happen at specific points, like when I asked, like, Dear god, what else is there? Give me some updates. I ended up apologizing to him at the end for asking for the meeting because I could tell it was so unwelcome. [1413:14] **Q.** Now you testified about cutting expenses. Withdrawn. [1413:15] You testified about, during the conversation you had on the balcony, a portion of the conversation about cutting expenses. I want to ask you some follow-up questions about expenses in the fall of 2022, okay? [1413:19] **A.** Okay. [1413:20] **Q.** All right. So how, if at all, did spending change in September onwards? [1413:22] **A.** In some ways I was pleasantly surprised. I really pushed for a number of large items to be cut, and I think I was successful in cutting maybe a couple hundred million dollars of spend. But there was also a point——there were a couple of [1414:1] points when I felt like our real obligation to be doing so was not being taken seriously and that it was much, much more that was either cuttable or at least strongly curtailed, that Sam simply wasn't cutting. [1414:5] **Q.** Now after the conversation with the defendant about the $13 billion hole, what, if any spending did you speak to him about specifically? [1414:8] **A.** I spoke to him about various endorsement deals, spoke to him about reversing the AZA acquisition, spoke to him about reversing the Embed acquisition, spoke to him about canceling the kind of disgusting FTX office plans——it was going to be a big F——that cost——at first I heard 50 million, eventually 250 million. [1414:14] **Q.** Let me ask you about what things you just said. [1414:15] You said AZA. What's that? [1414:16] **A.** I forgot what it stands for, but it's a payments company that FTX had——was some part of the way through acquiring, but I believe was still a reversible transaction. [1414:19] **Q.** And what's Embed? [1414:20] **A.** Embed is a company that FTX.US acquired at Brett Harrison's behest to list FTX.US stocks. [1414:22] **Q.** In September of 2022, did you have any disagreements with the defendant about spending? [1414:24] **A.** Yeah. [1414:25] **Q.** What topics did you disagree with him on? [1415:1] **A.** You said in September? [1415:2] **Q.** September 2022 onwards. [1415:3] **A.** In one instance, I saw that spreadsheet we looked at earlier that Jayesh showed me that had outlays——that described outlays of future spend on endorsement deals. I was really upset about that. There were way more than I knew about. Many of the numbers are much bigger than what I'd been told. And there was like a billion dollars headed out the door. If FTX was making a billion dollars a year, this puts us like a year of revenue behind with a hole. And so I approached Sam and said: You know, this is crazy. We need to cut as much of this as we can. I thought you were on this. [1415:13] **Q.** And what, if anything, did he say? [1415:14] **A.** He said he didn't think that these were bad spends, and he sort of like challenged me to point to one that was worth cutting. I did point to a couple. And for the ones I pointed at, he agreed that they were bad, but he said that those weren't his fault and that everybody proposing cutting them was shortsighted because the cost associated with cutting them was about like 70 percent of the cost of seeing them through and so it wasn't worth it. [1415:22] **Q.** Was there any other spending that you had disagreements about in September 2022 to November 2022? [1415:24] **A.** There are the others I mentioned, AZA and Embed. [1415:25] **Q.** What about any——what, if any, proposed transactions did you [1416:1] have disagreements about? [1416:2] **A.** There was a point when Sam was in the Middle East, he sent a message to a Signal group called hashtag meetings, or hashtag groups, which contained a lot of folks in leadership——maybe some eight or ten of them——basically pitching that FTX do a deal with Telegram. [1416:7] **Q.** And what happened in response to that proposal? [1416:8] **A.** Yeah, Sam described that FTX could build a payment-processing service for Telegram and that Telegram would give us a lot of TON, which was their coin, some hundreds of millions of dollars' worth. Seemed like a huge win, wasn't a big lift to build this payment service, probably, and we get a lot of money for it. Ramnik clarified that we'd also pay $120 million for it. [1416:15] **Q.** How did you respond to that? [1416:16] **A.** Made me extremely nervous. Getting even longer random illiquid tokens was not something I was excited about, especially when the cost would come from customers. [1416:19] **Q.** What do you mean by that? [1416:20] **A.** Spending dollars, spending anything, after September was necessarily digging the customer deficit hole deeper. [1416:22] **Q.** Why do you say that's the case? [1416:23] **A.** FTX was short on funds to give to customers. Alameda owed that back. If either FTX or Alameda was spending liquid funds to acquire more illiquid stuff that was not for customers, that [1417:1] was necessarily spending customer funds, not for customer benefit. [1417:3] **Q.** When you responded to this potential Telegram deal, how did the defendant respond, if at all? [1417:5] **A.** Yeah. To clarify, in the larger group, I wasn't transparent about my worry that this was digging into customer funds. Not everybody knew about it. Not everybody knew about the hole. But I raised a number of other objections, as did Caroline. Sam ultimately said to the larger group: We're going ahead with this, Ramnik and I are. You guys shouldn't feel responsible for it. That's not why I shared it. Unless you have any serious new objections, we're going ahead. And then he repeated separately, inside hashtag organization——the group with me, Sam, Gary, and Caroline, the folks that definitely knew about the hole, as far as I knew——that it wasn't our responsibility, don't worry about it. [1417:17] **MR. ROOS:** Pursuant to stipulation S2003, the government offers Exhibit 14B, which, according to the stipulation, is a spreadsheet titled Venture Deals, dated September 26, 2022. [1417:21] **THE COURT:** Received. [1417:22] (Government's Exhibit 14B received in evidence) [1417:23] **MR. ROOS:** May we publish it? [1417:24] **THE COURT:** Yes. [1417:25] BY MR. ROOS: [1418:1] **Q.** Mr. Singh, is this spreadsheet similar to the one we looked at this morning? [1418:3] **A.** Yes. [1418:4] **Q.** I just want to ask you about a few of the venture deals. [1418:5] First, do you see in lines 2, 7, and 9 something called Modulo Capital? [1418:7] **A.** Yes. [1418:8] **Q.** Do you know what Modulo Capital is? [1418:9] **A.** It's a trading firm run by some old associates of Sam. [1418:10] **Q.** Where was Modulo Capital based? [1418:11] **A.** I don't know where it was initially, but it moved to the Bahamas. [1418:13] **Q.** Who ran Modulo Capital? [1418:14] **A.** Lily Zhang. [1418:15] **Q.** And do you see——let's focus on line 7. What was the investment amount for that Modulo Capital transaction? [1418:17] **A.** For the specific one or the sum of them? [1418:18] **Q.** For the specific one. [1418:19] **A.** $250 million. [1418:20] **Q.** Do you see who the spreadsheet says the lead is? [1418:21] **A.** It says——can you click on the cell. Sam Bankman-Fried. [1418:22] **Q.** And look over at the closing date. It says September 26, 2022. Was this before or after your conversation about the $13 billion hole? [1418:25] **A.** After. [1419:1] **Q.** While we're on this spreadsheet, do you see Skybridge Capital? [1419:3] **A.** Yes. [1419:4] **Q.** And do you know what Skybridge Capital is? [1419:5] **A.** Scaramucci's VC firm. [1419:6] **Q.** Anthony Scaramucci you referred to earlier? [1419:7] **A.** Yes. [1419:8] **Q.** Do you see the date for that transaction? [1419:9] **A.** Yes. [1419:10] **Q.** September 7, 2022? [1419:11] **A.** Yes. [1419:12] **MR. ROOS:** We can take this spreadsheet down. [1419:13] **Q.** This morning in your testimony you mentioned that there were loans made to you for corporate purposes. What were those loans for? [1419:16] **A.** There were various ones for various purposes. Two high-level categories include amounts that ran through me for campaign donations and amounts that didn't literally go through me but on paper I was on the hook for, for money ultimately sent to FTX.US for its investments. [1420:1] **Q.** So let's split those apart. For that second category, starting there, for the investments, how were those transactions structured? [1420:4] **A.** I don't know for all of them. For at least one of them, the way it was structured, was that Alameda, on paper, would loan me, Sam, and Gary a large amount of money, and that, on paper, we would go and immediately give it to FTX US. I am not sure if that was a loan or if that was an investment. FTX US would then have money to go make purchases or acquisitions that it needed. [1420:11] **Q.** What do you mean by, on paper? [1420:12] **A.** I don't recall the actual money ever hitting any accounts of mine or going through them, and I don't know how the funds actually moved. This was an on-paper, like description for like -- I am not sure if it actually described, well, the physical reality of what happened. [1420:17] **Q.** You also mentioned some loans for political donations. What were you referring to? [1420:19] **A.** There were political donations made in my name, using my bank account, so these did literally go through my bank account, the funds deposited straight from Alameda. [1420:22] **Q.** How were some of those donations funded? [1420:23] **A.** Some were funded with my money or money taken as a borrow from my FTX account or money from my salary. Some of it was funded from transfers directly from Alameda accounts. [1421:1] **Q.** How would you describe your involvement in the majority of these donations? [1421:3] **A.** The majority by count or size? [1421:4] **Q.** By count. [1421:5] **A.** Very, very minimal. [1421:6] **Q.** What do you mean by that? [1421:7] **A.** I tried to be as uninvolved as possible. I sort of had my head elsewhere. [1421:9] **Q.** Walk us through how the donations were made. [1421:10] **A.** There was a Signal chart called donations processing in which Sam or Gabe, his brother, or Michael Sadowsky, who worked with Gabe, or their associates would request that a donation be made in my name. Ryan Salame, who had access to my bank account, would transfer money out of my bank account for that purpose, and in some of the cases, I think when the size of the transfer was large enough, there would be an email that would go to me. I would get prompted, often repeatedly because I was usually delinquent, to click on the approve button, and then it would go out. [1421:20] **Q.** What was your job with respect to the donations that were made in your name? [1421:22] **A.** It changed over time. Initially, I was invested in and cared about and was just kind of -- initially, there were meaningfully my donations, but for the majority of them, and after some point in time, my role was to click a button. [1422:1] **Q.** Did some of these donations occur in the fall of 2022? [1422:2] **A.** They did. [1422:3] **Q.** Did they occur after you learned about the $13 billion hole? [1422:5] **A.** They did. [1422:6] **Q.** Now, who was Ryan Salame? [1422:7] **A.** He was the CEO of FTX digital markets, and he also ran the fiat management team at FTX and OTC trading at Alameda. [1422:9] **Q.** I show you now what's been marked for identification as Government Exhibit 1808. [1422:11] Do you recognize this? [1422:12] **A.** That's Ryan Salame. [1422:13] **MR. ROOS:** The government offers Exhibit 1808. [1422:14] **THE COURT:** Received. [1422:15] (Government Exhibit 1808 received in evidence) [1422:16] **MR. ROOS:** May we publish? [1422:17] **THE COURT:** Yes. [1422:18] **Q.** Now that the jury can see, who is this? [1422:19] **A.** This is Ryan Salame. [1422:20] **Q.** What was Ryan Salame's role with respect to the political donations? [1422:22] **A.** I don't know the full extent of it. What I observed is that Ryan Salame had access to my bank account, to Sam's bank account, and that he would like log in to my account at Prime Trust, that's where I had a bank account, would send and [1423:1] specify the details for a wire to be spent to a political candidate or a super PAC and then would ping me in the chat to ask me to click OK in my email to have it get sent out. [1423:4] **Q.** What chat are you referring to? [1423:5] **A.** The donations processing chat. [1423:6] **Q.** What sort of messaging platform was that donation processing chat on? [1423:8] **A.** Used Signal. [1423:9] **MR. ROOS:** The government offers Exhibit 475, pursuant to stipulation S2003. Per the stipulation, this document is a message exchange between or thread among Nishad Singh, Samuel Bankman-Fried, Ryan Salame and others. [1423:13] **THE COURT:** Received. [1423:14] (Government Exhibit 475 received in evidence) [1423:15] **MR. ROOS:** May we publish it? [1423:16] **THE COURT:** You may. [1423:17] **Q.** Mr. Singh, are these screenshots of the Signal chat you mentioned? [1423:19] **MR. COHEN:** Your Honor before we proceed, may we request a limiting instruction regarding the others on the chat besides the individuals identified by Mr. Roos? [1423:22] **MR. ROOS:** Depends on who he is talking about, I think. [1423:24] **THE COURT:** Who are you talking about? [1423:25] **MR. ROOS:** None of them are admissible under [1424:1] 801(d)(2)(D) and (d)(2)(E). [1424:2] **THE COURT:** Why don't we take our break, 15 minutes. [1424:3] (Jury not present) [1424:4] (Recess) [1424:5] **THE COURT:** Before we bring in the jury, counsel, with respect to any proposed additions to the jury charge, I would like a red line whenever you submit them. [1424:8] **MR. ROOS:** No problem. [1424:9] On the exhibit, I think basically nobody is objecting to the admission, if I understand it correctly. It is to how the jury is to consider various messages. Basically, the witness, Ryan Salame, the defendant are all on it, and then there are some other folks, Gabe Bankman-Fried, Michael Sadowsky, Keenan Lantz, and some other individuals. [1424:15] The government's view is that the messages by those individuals are agent statements or are commands, directives, questions that are nonhearsay, and I think the defense position may be that they should be offered not for their truth. [1424:19] **THE COURT:** Take your best three that you think are a problem if offered for the truth and explain it to me. [1424:21] **MR. COHEN:** Sure. [1424:22] Mr. Keenan Lantz and Mr. Michael Sadowsky did not work for Alameda, did not work for FTX. They were political consultants to another company called Gap that was run by the defendant's brother and others. It's really -- I don't think [1425:1] there is any allegation, at least not that I have heard, that any of them are part of the conspiracy, and in terms of the agency argument, the government is essentially arguing they are agents of agents of agents, and we think it goes too far. [1425:5] **THE COURT:** What I was hoping to get is for you to point me to the best three and tell me why it matters apart from having a quiz on the law of evidence. [1425:8] **MR. COHEN:** I'm sorry, your Honor. [1425:9] I don't know what page counsel intends to go through is part of the problem. [1425:11] **MR. ROOS:** I am going to start with the first one, Keenan Lantz. Ryan Salame can we get -- [1425:13] **THE COURT:** What are you reading from? [1425:14] **MR. ROOS:** This is the second page of Government Exhibit 475. This one, for instance, is by Keenan Lantz. And setting aside even the agency determination under -- [1425:17] **THE COURT:** There is no part of it that's offered for the truth. [1425:19] **MR. ROOS:** It's a question or a directive, exactly. [1425:20] **THE COURT:** Right. [1425:21] Is there anything here that's offered for the truth by somebody who you claim is not an agent or a conspirator, Mr. Cohen, that matters at all in this case? [1425:24] **MR. COHEN:** All I was asking for was an instruction as to the people that it is not being offered for the truth for. [1426:1] **THE COURT:** I understand that. But does any of it matter? [1426:3] **MR. COHEN:** To the extent this is in evidence and the jury can read it, it could matter. [1426:5] **THE COURT:** You are not getting my point. I'm sorry. [1426:6] **MR. ROOS:** If I could -- [1426:7] **THE COURT:** If somebody wrote a message here that said, what time is it, and he wasn't an agent, who cares if it's offered for the truth or not offered for the truth, and why should there be a limiting instruction. Why should all of us be taking time on that issue? If there is something here that potentially hurts, I'm with you all the way. [1426:13] **MR. COHEN:** I understand, your Honor. I'm a little limited because up until just now I didn't know what part of this they were going to offer. [1426:16] Hold on one second. [1426:17] **MR. ROOS:** I'm offering the whole thing, but if this is helpful to move us along, we can just put this in. If Mr. Cohen wants to flag something for me overnight about something that's for the truth that he finds problematic, we could then work it out and raise it. [1426:22] **MR. COHEN:** That would be fine. [1426:23] **THE COURT:** That sounds fine. [1426:24] Bring in the jury and let's get the witness. [1426:25] Thank you for resolving that way, both of you. [1427:1] (Jury present) [1427:2] **THE COURT:** The defendant and the jurors all are present, as they have been throughout. [1427:4] Mr. Roos, you may continue. [1427:5] **MR. ROOS:** Thank you, your Honor. [1427:6] May we now publish Government Exhibit 475? [1427:7] **THE COURT:** You may. It is received. [1427:8] **Q.** Mr. Singh, what messaging platform was the donation processing messaging thread on? [1427:10] **A.** On Signal. [1427:11] **Q.** Do you see at the top where it says March 28, 2022? [1427:12] **A.** Yes. [1427:13] **Q.** Do messages exist going that far back? [1427:14] **A.** Not on the device that took a screenshot. [1427:15] **Q.** What device was that? [1427:16] **A.** My laptop. [1427:17] **Q.** How far back do the messages go? [1427:18] **A.** Four weeks since the time of the screenshot, which was sometime in November. [1427:20] **Q.** Why is it that they only go back four weeks? [1427:21] **A.** Because the disappearing message timer was set to four weeks. [1427:23] **Q.** What's a disappearing messaging timer? [1427:24] **A.** It specifies a retention period for messages such that messages that are older than that period get deleted. [1428:1] **MR. ROOS:** Mr. Ahuja, can we go to the second page of this document. [1428:3] **Q.** Starting with the first message in the chat, someone named Keenan Lantz sends a message. Who is Keenan Lantz? [1428:5] **A.** Keenan Lantz worked for Gabe Bankman-Fried and Michael Sadowsky. [1428:7] **Q.** Who is Michael Sadowsky? [1428:8] **A.** He was Gabe's partner, partner at work at Guarding Against Pandemics. [1428:10] **Q.** What's Guarding Against Pandemics? [1428:11] **A.** It was a PAC that Gabe and Michael ran. [1428:12] **Q.** What, if any, relationship did that have to the defendant? [1428:13] **A.** Did the PAC? [1428:14] **Q.** Yeah. [1428:15] **A.** Sam funded it. [1428:16] **Q.** Focusing on this first page, it says: @Salams, can we get the 20K from Nishad Singh to the Delaware democratic party today. [1428:19] Who is @Salams? [1428:20] **A.** That's Ryan Salame. This is my nickname in my phone for him. [1428:22] **Q.** What is the reason Lantz asked him to send $20,000 from you to the democratic party of Delaware? [1428:24] **A.** Keenan knew, I believe it had been well established by this point, October 17, that Ryan was the person who was actually [1429:1] logging in to my bank account and sending wires. [1429:2] **Q.** Were you involved in the decision to donate to the democratic party of Delaware? [1429:4] **A.** Not at all. [1429:5] **Q.** Two messages down, Salame or Salams says: This is queued up. And adds: Also resent the last five verification emails. [1429:7] What did you understand that to be a reference to? [1429:8] **A.** These are referencing the same type of thing. Here Ryan is saying that he has queued up a donation, as in he has like put it into my bank account, but I had to click approve on an email that was sent to me, and I missed the window for clicking approve on a bunch of others, which is typical. I wasn't paying a lot of attention to this. So he resent them and he requests here that I click OK on them as well. [1429:15] **Q.** When Salame was setting up donations like this for you, where did you understand the money was coming from? [1429:17] **A.** A combination of my money and money that he had deposited -- I don't know that he did it. Somebody had deposited directly into my bank account. [1429:20] **Q.** How did the money go to the campaigns? [1429:21] **A.** Through a wire like from my bank account. [1429:22] **Q.** You used the term earlier, when describing Guarding Against Pandemics, a PAC. Do you know what that stands for or what it refers to? [1429:25] **A.** Political action committee. [1430:1] **Q.** Just to be clear, how would the money go from Alameda, in the cases it came from Alameda, to the campaign? [1430:3] **A.** Funds would start out with Alameda at some bank account. They would get transferred into -- wired to my Prime Trust account, which is another bank account, and then Ryan would request a wire withdrawal from my bank account to the campaign as a destination, and I would click OK in my email. [1430:8] **MR. ROOS:** Mr. Ahuja can we go to the next page of this Signal chat. [1430:10] **Q.** Mr. Singh, do you see partway down the page where Keenan Lantz asks @SamBF: Will you be cool with me being able to set up wires via PT? [1430:13] For starters, who is Sam BF? [1430:14] **A.** That's Sam Bankman-Fried. This is what I had him as in my phone. [1430:16] **Q.** Where it says, set up wires via PT, what is that a reference to? [1430:18] **A.** I believe he is asking if there can be a Prime Trust PT account for Sam that Keenan would set up and have access to. [1430:20] **Q.** Do you see below this where Sam BF writes: Think so? [1430:21] **A.** Yes. [1430:22] **MR. ROOS:** Could we zoom in on the portion below that. [1430:23] **Q.** The Salames message says: SBFs are all queued and sent. [1430:24] What is queued and sent a reference to? [1430:25] **A.** I understand it to mean that Ryan already had access to [1431:1] some bank accounts under Sam's name, and he had done what he did for me, which was to send the wires. He might also be saying here that he clicked -- [1431:4] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1431:5] **THE COURT:** Strike everything after he might, including he might. [1431:7] **Q.** What was your understanding with respect to whether the defendant had a similar setup as to use for paying donations? [1431:9] **A.** That was my belief inferring from the messages and thread like this one. [1431:11] **MR. COHEN:** Same objection. [1431:12] **THE COURT:** Pardon me? [1431:13] The answer is stricken. [1431:14] Move on, please. [1431:15] **MR. ROOS:** We can take this thread down. [1431:16] **Q.** In addition to having your bank account used to make wire transfer donations, how, if at all, were checks used for making donations? [1431:19] **A.** I signed a bunch of blank checks attached to my Wells Fargo account, which at first only contained my salary, but eventually also contained money that I had wired to it from my Prime Trust account. Those were used by Gabe and his team to make donations in my name to candidates. [1431:24] **Q.** What do you mean by, you used checks? What did you do? [1431:25] **A.** I signed blank checks. [1432:1] **Q.** What did you do with them after you signed blank checks? [1432:2] **A.** I handed them back to Gabe's assistant, who provided them to me. [1432:4] **Q.** Can you describe the circumstances of you signing those blank checks. [1432:6] **A.** Yeah. Gabe had called me asking that -- [1432:7] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1432:8] **THE COURT:** Ground. [1432:9] **MR. COHEN:** Hearsay. [1432:10] **MR. ROOS:** Effect on the listener. [1432:11] **THE COURT:** Received for the effect on the listener, the witness. [1432:13] Members of the jury, not for the truth. [1432:14] **THE WITNESS:** Continue? [1432:15] **THE COURT:** Yes, please. [1432:16] **A.** Gabe had called me asking if I was OK with making a lot of small donations to democratic candidates. We talked some about the purpose of it. I said OK. [1432:19] **Q.** What happened next? [1432:20] **A.** I tried to -- I gave my credit card to Gabe, or maybe to Keenan Lantz, so that he could try to make payments through ActBlue using my credit card, drawing on my salary. It was -- my credit card got rejected at some point. He tried to make a PayPal for the same reason. This also had some issues. Eventually it seemed that checks were the most viable option [1433:1] left. So Gabe called me saying that he was flying out one of his assistants with a bunch of checks from my bank account. I had given them access to my bank account for me to sign. [1433:4] **THE COURT:** What is ActBlue? [1433:5] **THE WITNESS:** ActBlue is a platform used to make donations to democrats. [1433:7] **THE COURT:** And you said he was flying out one of his assistants. What did that mean? [1433:9] **THE WITNESS:** One of his assistants had a lot of checks from my bank account, but they weren't signed yet. So she was going to arrive in the Bahamas and meet me at the office where I would sign them and hand them back to her. [1433:13] **THE COURT:** Go ahead, Mr. Roos. [1433:14] **MR. ROOS:** Thank you. [1433:15] **Q.** For the donations that were made in your name in the fall of 2022 that were funded with wires from Alameda, from where did you understand the money was coming from? [1433:18] **A.** Customers. [1433:19] **Q.** Why is your answer customers? [1433:20] **A.** There was an enormous hole, I knew, deficit in funds at FTX for customers, and Alameda sort of also had that hole. It was theirs to fill. Alameda sending me money to spend, as opposed to keeping money for customers, say, necessarily deepens that hole and is drawing on funds that would have otherwise gone to customers. [1434:1] **THE COURT:** From where did you get that understanding? [1434:2] **THE WITNESS:** From my conversation in September with Sam in which he told me $5 billion was deliverable, and I earlier that day heard that there was a $13 billion amount borrowed by Alameda from FTX. [1434:6] **THE COURT:** Thank you. [1434:7] **Q.** Now, you testified that many of these donations you were not involved in. What is your understanding about why the donations were made in your name? [1434:10] **A.** For advantageous optics, that it was useful for my name to be associated with some donations, even if the end recipient understood that they were really coming from someone else. [1434:13] **MR. ROOS:** Now, the government offers Government Exhibit 477 pursuant to stipulation S2003. [1434:15] **THE COURT:** Received. [1434:16] (Government Exhibit 477 received in evidence) [1434:17] **MR. ROOS:** May we publish it? [1434:18] **THE COURT:** You may. [1434:19] **Q.** Mr. Singh, what type of document or record is this? [1434:20] **A.** This is also a Signal chat with screenshots from my phone, as opposed to a computer. [1434:22] **Q.** Who is the Signal chat with? [1434:23] **A.** Michael Sadowsky. [1434:24] **Q.** Was he also part of that donation processing chart? [1434:25] **A.** Yes. [1435:1] **Q.** Does this Signal chart concern any particular donation? [1435:2] **A.** Yes. [1435:3] **Q.** Which one? [1435:4] **A.** There was a donation to be made to the LGBTQ victory fund. [1435:5] **MR. ROOS:** Mr. Ahuja, can we go to the next page. [1435:6] **Q.** About halfway down there is a message. The next one too. It says: In general, you, being the center left face of our spending, will mean you giving to a lot of woke, swear word, for transactional purposes. [1435:10] Had you had conversations about that in the past? [1435:11] **A.** Yes, yes, though less crudely. [1435:12] **Q.** What did you understand this to refer to? [1435:13] **A.** That donations that were really effectuated by a group of people, not just me, would be made in my name, so I would be the face of those donations, and that there would be targeted at center left recipients. The four transactional purposes part, I believe, refers to the fact that -- [1435:18] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1435:19] **MR. ROOS:** It goes to his understanding, and it's based on what he said in his past conversations. [1435:21] **THE COURT:** Let's find that out. [1435:22] **Q.** The belief you are about to testify about transactional purposes, to what extent, if at all, was that based on past conversations? [1435:25] **A.** Past conversations and this one. This thread describes the [1436:1] transaction. [1436:2] **THE COURT:** Past conversations with whom? [1436:3] **THE WITNESS:** With Michael and Gabe and Sam. [1436:4] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1436:5] And Sam. Overruled. [1436:6] **Q.** What were you referring to with transactional purposes? [1436:7] **A.** That on its face a donation may appear to be for one purpose, say going to a PAC called the LGBTQ Victory Fund. But, in reality, the true purpose is something else, and it may be the funds end up affecting some outcome that seems unrelated to LGBTQ efforts. [1436:12] **MR. ROOS:** Go to the next page. [1436:13] **Q.** On the next page you write: I think I need to do some of this and prob see if there are other viable people at FTX for it. [1436:16] What did you mean by, see if there are other viable people at FTX for it? [1436:18] **A.** I wasn't comfortable being in this position for very long, and so I put it on myself here to search for replacements for me, other people at FTX willing to have their name be used for donations. [1436:22] **MR. ROOS:** We can take this down. [1436:23] **Q.** What, if anything, was done to track donations made by FTX employees, FTX and Alameda employees? [1436:25] **A.** I partook in some tracking myself. That's really all I [1437:1] know about there. [1437:2] **Q.** What, if any, involvement in tracking did you have with the defendant? [1437:4] **A.** There was a point in 2022 when Sam had asked a group of us -- I believe me, Caroline, Ryan, Gary, Adam, and others -- if we could contribute to a spreadsheet, a Google sheet that he made, listing the donations that we had been a part of so that he could understand and represent to others what all FTX and Alameda employees were donating to and where our influence was. [1437:10] **MR. ROOS:** Government offers Exhibit 28, which, according to stipulation S2003, is a spreadsheet called Alameda FTX donations. [1437:13] **THE COURT:** Received. [1437:14] (Government Exhibit 28 received in evidence) [1437:15] **MR. ROOS:** May we publish it? [1437:16] **Q.** Mr. Singh, have you seen this before? [1437:17] **A.** I have. In Google Sheet form. [1437:18] **Q.** What do you mean, in Google Sheet form? [1437:19] **A.** That the actual document that I touched and that Sam circulated was a Google Sheet. This appears to be a Microsoft Excel version of it. [1437:22] **Q.** Now, what is this particular spreadsheet about? [1437:23] **A.** It's about the donations made by various people -- those are listed on the bottom in tabs -- to various recipients. [1437:25] **Q.** Who are the various people in the tabs? [1438:1] **A.** From left to right: SBF, so that's Sam; FTX US, the company; Nishad, that's me; Caroline, that's Caroline Ellison; RDS, Ryan Salame. [1438:4] **Q.** Let's look at your tab. Can you explain what each of the columns relates to. [1438:6] **A.** The first is attempt at categorizing the motivations or type of donation. The second is a recipient column that just names a recipient. Date is the date of the transfer. USD amount is the dollar equivalent of the amount transferred. In some cases there is crypto here, but in most cases there are dollars sent. Notes is some additional context I added. U.S. tax deductible is my almost-wrong-in-all-cases guess if the donation was tax deductible. [1438:14] **Q.** Who, if anyone, asked for all these donations to be listed in the spreadsheet? [1438:16] **A.** Sam did. [1438:17] **MR. ROOS:** We can take this down. [1438:18] **Q.** I want to change topics. [1438:19] You mentioned this morning that you are testifying here pursuant to a cooperation agreement, is that right? [1438:21] **A.** That's right. [1438:22] **Q.** Did you plead guilty to crimes at the time you entered into a cooperation agreement? [1438:24] **A.** Yes. [1438:25] **Q.** Before you pled guilty, had you met with federal [1439:1] prosecutors and the FBI? [1439:2] **A.** Many times. [1439:3] **Q.** And when did you start meeting with prosecutors? [1439:4] **A.** Somewhere around November 20, 2022. [1439:5] **Q.** When you first met with the FBI or with prosecutors, had you been arrested or charged with crimes? [1439:7] **A.** No. [1439:8] **Q.** How many times have you met with prosecutors? [1439:9] **A.** I am not sure the exact number. Maybe around 20 times. [1439:10] **Q.** In those meetings did you discuss your own involvement in crimes? [1439:12] **A.** I did. [1439:13] **Q.** What crimes did you bring to the attention of prosecutors? [1439:14] **A.** I discussed how I defrauded customers, investors, how I was a straw donor for campaign donations, and how I knew that the money going to those donations was from customer funds. [1439:17] **Q.** Did you talk about the defendant in your meetings? [1439:18] **A.** I did. [1439:19] **Q.** What about other individuals? [1439:20] **A.** Talked about other individuals. [1439:21] **Q.** In general, what charges have you pled guilty to? [1439:22] **A.** Defrauding customers, defrauding investors, campaign finance violations, and money laundering. [1439:24] **MR. COHEN:** Your Honor, may I have a brief sidebar? [1439:25] **THE COURT:** Yes. [1440:1] (At sidebar) [1440:2] **MR. COHEN:** Your Honor, I didn't want to interrupt Mr. Roos in front of the jury, but I wanted to ask the Court at the appropriate time to give a 404(b) instruction on the political campaign testimony we will hear today. [1440:6] **THE COURT:** Haven't I done that already? [1440:7] **MR. COHEN:** I thought you gave it on a different topic, on the FCPA topic. I think you did that last week. [1440:9] **THE COURT:** Is there any objection? [1440:10] **MR. ROOS:** I don't think there has been a 404(b) instruction on the campaign finance. [1440:12] I guess the question I have is, what do you have in mind at this point? I am not sure that he has testified -- [1440:14] **MR. COHEN:** He just did. [1440:15] **MR. ROOS:** He described conduct. I am not sure -- [1440:16] **MR. COHEN:** He just said one of the crimes he committed was being a straw donor. [1440:18] **MR. ROOS:** That he committed. I am not sure he has actually said. I'm happy to look at the testimony. [1440:20] **MS. SASSOON:** I think it is also direct evidence. [1440:21] **THE COURT:** Doesn't it really come down to saying that the defendant, as opposed to this witness, is not charged here, as I have told you before, with any crimes involving any violations of campaign finance costs. [1440:25] **MR. COHEN:** That would be fine, your Honor. [1441:1] **MS. SASSOON:** I just want to make sure that FCPA instruction referred to -- it's for the limited purpose of propensity. I don't think that applies here. [1442:1] (At sidebar) [1442:2] **THE COURT:** Members of the jury, I just want to remind you that, as I said earlier in the trial, the defendant is not charged with any criminal violation of campaign finance laws in this case. This evidence is coming in for other purposes, not least of what would be the fact that this witness has pleaded guilty to such a violation. [1442:8] **MR. ROOS:** Thank you, your Honor. [1442:9] **Q.** You testified you pled guilty. How many felonies have you pled guilty to? [1442:11] **A.** Six. [1442:12] **Q.** Is that plea based on criminal activity you have testified about here today? [1442:14] **A.** Yes. And more. [1442:15] **Q.** When you were committing the frauds you testified about, did you know what you were doing was wrong and illegal? [1442:17] **A.** Yes. [1442:18] **Q.** And with respect to the conspiracies you pled guilty to commit wire fraud, securities fraud, commodities fraud and money laundering, who did you conspire with? [1442:21] **A.** I conspired with Ryan Salame, Sam Bankman-Fried, Gary Wang, Caroline Ellison. [1442:23] **Q.** You said you entered into a cooperation agreement. Is that a written agreement? [1442:25] **A.** That is. [1443:1] **MR. ROOS:** If we could pull up for identification 3501-002. [1443:3] **Q.** Mr. Singh, do you recognize this document? [1443:4] **A.** I do. [1443:5] **Q.** What is it? [1443:6] **A.** It's my cooperation agreement. [1443:7] **Q.** Let's go to the last page. [1443:8] Is that your signature on the last page? [1443:9] **A.** Yes. [1443:10] **MR. ROOS:** Your Honor, the government offers 3501-002. [1443:11] **MR. COHEN:** No objection. [1443:12] **THE COURT:** Received. [1443:13] (Government Exhibit 3501-002 received in evidence) [1443:14] **MR. ROOS:** May we publish it? [1443:15] **THE COURT:** You may. [1443:16] **Q.** Mr. Singh, we are not going to go through the whole document, but just for starters, looking at pages 1 and then 2, does that state the crimes that you have pled guilty to? [1443:19] **A.** Yes. [1443:20] **MR. ROOS:** Can we go to page 3. [1443:21] **Q.** You see the first full paragraph on that page. What do you understand this paragraph in the cooperation agreement to require of you? [1443:24] **A.** This paragraph describes my obligations as a part of the cooperation agreement. At a high level, it requires that I [1444:1] provide truthful information to the government, that I testify truthfully if asked, and that I commit no further crimes. [1444:3] **Q.** If you satisfy those obligations, what is your understanding as to what the government will do? [1444:5] **A.** The government believes that my assistance was substantial, they can write a 5K letter to the judge to be considered at my sentencing. [1444:8] **Q.** What's a 5K letter? [1444:9] **A.** It's a letter that describes the extent of my cooperation and what crimes I committed. [1444:11] **Q.** If you were to violate your agreement by not telling the truth or by committing more crimes, what do you understand would happen to your cooperation agreement? [1444:14] **A.** It may not be sent. [1444:15] **Q.** What may not be sent? [1444:16] **A.** The 5K letter. It wouldn't be created and sent to the judge. [1444:18] **Q.** And could your cooperation agreement be voided? [1444:19] **A.** The agreement itself would not be voided. [1444:20] **Q.** Have you been sentenced yet to the crimes that you pled guilty to? [1444:22] **A.** Not yet. [1444:23] **Q.** What is your maximum sentence you could face? [1444:24] **A.** Seventy-five years. [1444:25] **Q.** Have you received any promises about the sentence you will [1445:1] receive? [1445:2] **A.** None. [1445:3] **Q.** Sitting here today, do you know what sentence you are going to get? [1445:5] **A.** I don't know. [1445:6] **Q.** What sentence are you hoping for? [1445:7] **A.** I'm hoping for no jail time. [1445:8] **Q.** Who decides your sentence? [1445:9] **A.** The judge does. [1445:10] **Q.** Now, does you getting a 5K letter from the government depend in any way on the outcome of this trial? [1445:12] **A.** No. [1445:13] **Q.** You said one of the crimes you pled guilty to was conspiracy to commit securities fraud? [1445:15] **A.** Yes. [1445:16] **Q.** On FTX investors. [1445:17] I want to ask you some additional questions about that. [1445:19] When you were working at FTX, did you ever work on a project relating to making FTX's revenues higher? [1445:21] **A.** Yes. [1445:22] **Q.** And when approximately was that project? [1445:23] **A.** December 30 or 31 of 2021. [1445:24] **Q.** Can you describe what the project was. [1445:25] **A.** I made transfers from one of Sam's companies to another, to [1446:1] FTX, to make it appear as though FTX had higher revenues. [1446:2] **Q.** So a few follow-up questions on this. [1446:3] First, just to be clear, where were FTX's revenues at this point in time? [1446:5] **A.** What were they for the previous year? [1446:6] **Q.** Before the project, what had FTX's revenues been calculated to? [1446:8] **A.** Around 950 or $960 million for that year. [1446:9] **Q.** What was the project that you worked on? [1446:10] **A.** Sam messaged me and Gary and possibly others, but certainly the two of us, in Signal asking what we could do to get revenue over the line of a billion dollars. [1446:13] **Q.** What, if anything, did you discuss in that Signal message -- conversation after that? [1446:15] **A.** Sam and Gary talked about a number of options. In the end, Sam landed on charging for the service of Serum staking. [1446:17] **Q.** So for starters, I think you mentioned it, but can you remind us what Serum is? [1446:19] **A.** It's a token that Sam and Gary made. [1446:20] **Q.** What is Serum staking? [1446:21] **A.** Customers could so-call stake their Serum on FTX, which entailed locking up those tokens such that they couldn't be sold, in return for some interest. [1446:24] **Q.** If you didn't sell your tokens, you got interest? [1446:25] **A.** Right. [1447:1] **Q.** And what was FTX's involvement in that? [1447:2] **A.** FTX facilitated distributing the staking rewards, facilitating the distribution of interest from the ECO Serum account. [1447:5] **Q.** Can you explain what the defendant proposed with respect to charging for that service. [1447:7] **A.** The defendant -- Sam proposed charging ECO Serum to the account that paid the interest, 25 percent of the USD equivalent of the interest distributed to FTX. [1447:10] **Q.** And how, if at all, would that affect FTX's revenues? [1447:11] **A.** It would -- I know that, after calculating, it was determined that it would bring it over the line of 1 billion. I think that it added $50 million or so in revenue. [1447:14] **Q.** Remind us, when was the date that this conversation occurred? [1447:16] **A.** It was either December 30 or 31 of 2021. [1447:17] **Q.** Was the plan to charge that $50 million amount at the end there? [1447:19] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. Leading. [1447:20] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1447:21] **Q.** What, if any, was the plan with respect to when to charge those payments to ECO Serum? [1447:23] **A.** I was told to make it appear as though they had been getting charged throughout the year, so to backdate the transactions associated with paying this fee. [1448:1] **Q.** Who told you that? [1448:2] **A.** Sam. [1448:3] **Q.** And what do you mean, backdating the charging of the fee? [1448:4] **A.** The FTX database that he looked at has time stamps in it for when transactions happen, but in some cases those time stamps are mutable and can be adjusted and changed. So I was being asked here to make transfers and then to go into the database and reassign the dates for them. [1449:1] BY MR. ROOS: [1449:2] **Q.** What would the effect have been of making those transfers? [1449:3] **A.** The effect of making the transfers would have been to increase FTX's stated revenue, but not real revenue, by some $50 million, and the effect of the backdating would be to make it appear as though that had been getting paid out throughout the year, as opposed to all at the end. [1449:8] **MR. ROOS:** Let's take a look at Government Exhibit 51. [1449:9] The government offers pursuant to S2003, stipulation. [1449:10] **THE COURT:** Received. [1449:11] (Government's Exhibit 51 received in evidence) [1449:12] **MR. ROOS:** May we publish it? [1449:13] **THE COURT:** Yes. [1449:14] BY MR. ROOS: [1449:15] **Q.** Mr. Singh, what are we looking at here? [1449:16] **A.** I recognize this as the FTX stats file, one that Sam made and posted inside a, among other places, a Slack channel that I was in that contained a lot of people, 20 or 30 people, with interest in raising, and I understand that copies of this spreadsheet or versions of it made their way into—— [1449:21] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1449:22] **THE COURT:** Sustained as to the understanding. [1449:23] **Q.** What, if anything, did you talk to the defendant or other FTX employees about what was done with this spreadsheet? [1449:25] **A.** Ramnik told me that versions of this spreadsheet made their [1450:1] way into data rooms that were shared with FTX investors. [1450:2] **Q.** Now looking at this first tab, the overview page, where does it say FTX's revenue for year 2021? [1450:4] **A.** Cell E8. [1450:5] **Q.** And what is that revenue number? [1450:6] **A.** Just over a billion dollars. [1450:7] **MR. ROOS:** Now, Mr. Ahuja, can we please see the tab FTX data. [1450:9] **Q.** Mr. Singh, where does the information for FTX data come from? [1450:11] **A.** I believe that this is a download of data that was collated and—— [1450:13] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1450:14] **THE COURT:** Yes. Sustained. Strike the answer. [1450:15] Mr. Roos, foundations are sometimes necessary. [1450:16] **MR. ROOS:** Yes, your Honor. [1450:17] So let's go over to the tab that says Staking Fees, and can we scroll down. Scroll down to like the year 2021. So you'll have to go down a bunch, maybe using the side tab. [1450:20] BY MR. ROOS: [1450:21] **Q.** And Mr. Singh, do you see a number in the column W called Staking Fees? [1450:23] **A.** I do. [1450:24] **Q.** And are you familiar with where those figures come from? [1450:25] **A.** This is a reflection of the erroneous transfers that I made [1451:1] and backdated of one of them. [1451:2] **Q.** What are you referring to? [1451:3] **A.** The transfers that I'd made on December 30th or 31st of 2021, supposedly for eco Serum paying FTX 25 percent of the USD value of the distributed interest. I made those once per month, backdated them so they looked like they happened once per month, and this is the USD value of one of those transfers. [1451:8] **Q.** Now where did you make those transfers? [1451:9] **A.** I made them using a Python script. They ended up in the FTX database. [1451:11] **Q.** Now you mentioned this is one of those monthly payments. Are there other such monthly revenue, or staking fee payments? [1451:13] **A.** Yes, one per month. [1451:14] **Q.** Throughout the period of 2021? [1451:15] **A.** Yes. [1451:16] **Q.** And are they for a month that predate December 2021? [1451:17] **A.** Yes. [1451:18] **Q.** What was the result of including these staking fees, these backdated staking fees, in the revenue total for 2021? [1451:20] **A.** It was the difference between FTX being under and over a billion dollars of revenue in 2021. [1451:22] **Q.** What, if anything, did you discuss with the defendant about backdating? [1451:24] **A.** He told me to do it. [1451:25] **Q.** What, if anything, did you learn about this, about the [1452:1] revenue number being shared with investors? [1452:2] **A.** I didn't learn anything affirmatively, but I knew it was shared. [1452:4] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1452:5] **A.** I assumed it was shared. [1452:6] **Q.** Relevant to his state of mind. [1452:7] **THE COURT:** Overruled. [1452:8] I'm sorry. I'm going to sustain that. [1452:9] **MR. ROOS:** Okay. [1452:10] **THE COURT:** The jury will disregard it. [1452:11] **Q.** Now what, if any, information about this revenue number was given to auditors? [1452:13] **A.** It was. These numbers were given to auditors. [1452:14] **Q.** Just to back up for a second, did FTX have auditors? [1452:15] **A.** Yes. [1452:16] **Q.** And what, if anything, were they doing in 2021, and 2022? [1452:17] **A.** Looking at financials for the previous years at FTX. [1452:18] **Q.** And so I think you answered that information was given to auditors. What, if anything, did auditors ask to see? [1452:20] **MR. COHEN:** Foundation, objection. [1452:21] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1452:22] **Q.** So just to take a step back, you testified that information was provided to auditors; is that right? [1452:24] **A.** Correct. [1452:25] **Q.** Did you have any conversations with auditors about the [1453:1] staking fees? [1453:2] **A.** I did. [1453:3] **Q.** And what, if anything, was asked of you about the staking fees? [1453:5] **A.** I was asked to describe what they were. [1453:6] **Q.** And to what extent, if at all, were you asked about materials relating to the staking fees? [1453:8] **A.** Jayesh, afterwards, at some point after my conversation describing the, like, technical basis for this number, asked me if there——if the auditors were interested in seeing an agreement about it. I told him I don't have the agreement and I redirected him to Sam. [1453:13] **MR. ROOS:** The government offers Exhibit 323 pursuant to stipulation S2003. [1453:15] **THE COURT:** Received. [1453:16] (Government's Exhibit 323 received in evidence) [1453:17] **MR. ROOS:** May we publish it? [1453:18] **THE COURT:** Yes. [1453:19] BY MR. ROOS: [1453:20] **Q.** Mr. Singh, at the top of this agreement it says Rewards Agent Agreement. Do you see that? [1453:22] **A.** I do. [1453:23] **Q.** And do you see the parties listed in it? [1453:24] **A.** Yes. [1453:25] **MR. ROOS:** Let's go to the end of the document. [1454:1] **Q.** What are the parties listed to the agreement on the end of the document? [1454:3] **A.** Incentive Ecosystem Foundation and FTX Trading Ltd. [1454:4] **Q.** Are you familiar with Incentive Ecosystem Foundation? [1454:5] **A.** Sort of. [1454:6] **Q.** Okay. And FTX Trading Ltd.? [1454:7] **A.** Yes. [1454:8] **Q.** And who signed on behalf of FTX Trading Ltd.? [1454:9] **A.** Sam Bankman-Fried. [1454:10] **Q.** Okay. Now let's go back to the first page. [1454:11] Do you see here where it says the fee amount that would be paid? [1454:13] **A.** Yes. [1454:14] **Q.** And what was the fee amount listed in this agreement? [1454:15] **A.** 25 percent of the distributed rewards. [1454:16] **Q.** And what fee percentage did you discuss with the defendant in December of 2021? [1454:18] **A.** 25 percent. [1454:19] **Q.** Now do you see the date on this document—— [1454:20] **A.** Yes. [1454:21] **Q.** ——at the top? And what is the date of the document? [1454:22] **A.** January 1, 2021. [1454:23] **Q.** When was it that you first discussed fees for staking Serum with the defendant? [1454:25] **A.** December 30th or 31st, 2021. [1455:1] **Q.** Let me just be clear about something. Had you seen this document back in 2021? [1455:3] **A.** No. [1455:4] **MR. ROOS:** We can take this down. [1455:5] **Q.** In addition to this——my questions to you about revenue, what, if anything, was done at FTX to remove losses from the company's expenses? [1455:8] **A.** In one instance, there were a bunch of accounts that found an exploit in Gary's original version of the spot margin system. They had essentially borrowed a lot of dollars against some MobileCoin, but if sold, the MobileCoin wasn't going to actually cover the full amount. [1455:13] **MR. COHEN:** Objection, foundation. [1455:14] **THE COURT:** Try again, Mr. Roos. The jury will disregard it. [1455:16] **Q.** So just to take it in pieces, I asked you what, if anything, was done at FTX to remove losses from the total expenses. Were there——so let me actually ask you instead: In 2021, were you aware of any losses——just yes or no——associated with problems in the margins of some? [1455:21] **A.** Yes. [1455:22] **Q.** And how did you come to learn about those losses? [1455:23] **A.** Ryan Salame and Sam Bankman-Fried sounded the alarms about somebody exploiting the margin system. [1455:25] **Q.** Can you describe what you learned. [1456:1] **A.** I learned that there were a number of accounts that had deposited a lot of MOB——or M-O-B, MobileCoin——as collateral, and had withdrawn a lot of USD against it using the spot margin system. They had done so in a way such that the——in a way that the FTX margin system essentially overvalued how much it could get out of the MobileCoin, meaning that these accounts weren't yet liquidated but really should have been much earlier. [1456:8] **Q.** And what, if any, losses resulted from this? [1456:9] **A.** I heard from Sam Bankman-Fried——he told me, after it was addressed, that the losses would constitute a fraction of Alameda's revenue that year, around $1 billion. [1456:12] **Q.** What, if anything, did the defendant say about what should be done with the loss? [1456:14] **A.** He directed the reassigning of the accounts themselves that had on these positions that should have been but were not liquidated to Alameda, meaning that Alameda absorbed the losses associated with those accounts. [1456:18] **Q.** And what, if anything, was the effect of moving those losses to Alameda's account? [1456:20] **A.** It meant that because Alameda data is not publicly shared, that these losses would not be publicly shared. [1456:22] **Q.** Okay. I want to change topics. [1456:23] Directing your attention to November of 2022. Can you, at a high level, describe what happened to FTX. [1456:25] **A.** Collapsed. Customers tried to withdraw their money and FTX [1457:1] didn't have it. [1457:2] **Q.** So let's break it down. [1457:3] Did there come a time in November 2022 when you learned about an increase in customer withdrawals? [1457:5] **A.** Yes, November 5th. [1457:6] **Q.** And what did you observe at the time? [1457:7] **A.** Clients had moved a lot of FTT that they owned on chain to their exchange. This signaled to the crypto industry that a lot of FTT was about to be sold. This followed a leak of an Alameda balance sheet that had been published a few days earlier. I was very concerned that this might spell doom and the end of our attempts to make customers whole, and the end of the ongoing fraud, and that the mechanism for the doom would have been customers withdrawing. [1457:15] **Q.** And so can you explain why you were concerned that withdrawals would be a problem for FTX. [1457:17] **A.** Because customers believed, were told that they had balances that were not backed, and so if they withdrew more than the limited funds that existed, it would become evident that there was an enormous hole and that their funds had been used. [1457:22] **Q.** Just to clarify your answer, you said customers were told that they had funds that were not backed. Did you mean customers were told that they had funds and they were not backed or customers were told they had funds but were not [1458:1] backed? [1458:2] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1458:3] **THE COURT:** Overruled. [1458:4] **A.** The former. [1458:5] **Q.** Now earlier in your testimony you told us about some loans that had been made to you for corporate purposes. Do you remember that? [1458:8] **A.** Yes. [1458:9] **Q.** When withdrawals started picking up at FTX in November 2022, what, if any, conversations did you have with the defendant about those loans? [1458:12] **A.** A few days or maybe a day after my worries, I was terrified that due to the collapse, I wouldn't be able to repay all my loans that I once thought I could, and I asked that we find an erroneous way to sort of remove them. [1458:16] **MR. ROOS:** The government offers Exhibit 480A pursuant to stipulation S2003. [1458:18] **MR. COHEN:** No objection. [1458:19] **THE COURT:** Received. [1458:20] (Government's Exhibit 480A received in evidence) [1458:21] **MR. ROOS:** May we publish it? [1458:22] **THE COURT:** You may. [1458:23] **MR. ROOS:** Could we zoom in on first the blue messages. [1458:25] **Q.** And let me ask: What is this document? [1459:1] **A.** This is a screenshot from my computer of a Signal chat with Sam. [1459:3] **Q.** And so focusing on your message——I'm sorry. Withdrawn. [1459:4] Whose message is this? [1459:5] **A.** Mine. [1459:6] **Q.** Okay. And focusing on your message, you say there, "one thing that'd seriously help me is if I didn't have debts." What debts were you referring to? [1459:9] **A.** There were hundreds of millions of dollars of loans that I had taken for the——for Alameda's and FTX's purposes, or loans that I'd taken for personal purposes but that Sam had requested I take in the form of a loan as opposed to selling my FTT. [1459:13] **Q.** And you say here, "500 million for me exercising," what's that a reference to? [1459:15] **A.** I received a $477 million on-paper loan in December or November of 2021, nominally for me to exercise shares that were granted to me. [1459:18] **Q.** And who, if anyone, had the idea for you to take that loan? [1459:19] **A.** Sam did. [1459:20] **Q.** The same sentence says, "for me exercising, more for US investments." What were you referring to there? [1459:22] **A.** There were on the order of $100 million or maybe more of other loans that ran through me for expenditures from FTX.US, things like acquiring LedgerX, acquiring Embed. [1459:25] **Q.** What do you mean by ran through you? [1460:1] **A.** Using the setup I described earlier in which the lawyers would paper up a transaction, a loan from Alameda through me, Sam, and Gary, and maybe others, but certainly the three of us, and that those funds would ultimately make their way into FTX.US's wallets and that FTX.US could spend that money to——to make acquisitions. [1460:7] **Q.** The third line here, it says, "maybe 80 million extra or so are donations/personal/etc. that went through my bank acc and are in my name." What were you referring to? [1460:10] **A.** Here I'm referring to instances in which I'd withdrawn from my FTX account using the spot margin system or instances in which Sam had given me like a loan. These are instances in which I'd first asked to sell FTT but Sam preferred I take a loan. And so these are ones that are in my name. These also include the transfers directly from Alameda into my bank accounts that, you know, weren't discussed beforehand. [1460:17] **Q.** Just so we're clear, when it says "through my bank acc," what is that? [1460:19] **A.** Bank account. [1460:20] **Q.** Now you see lower it says, "would you be ok letting me trade to get rid of the approximately 80?" What were you referring to? [1460:23] **A.** I was asking if I could make some fictitious transactions such that it looked like I had paid off this amount that I owed. [1461:1] **MR. ROOS:** Let's zoom out. [1461:2] And can we zoom in on the bottom three messages. [1461:3] **Q.** And the defendant asks, "what does trade mean?" And you say, "sell FTT or SRM earlier in 2022." What does that mean? [1461:5] **A.** I was asking if I could make a trade, selling the tokens that I had asked to previously sell, but backdating them to points that would cover the size of the loans. [1461:8] **Q.** You've mentioned FTT previously. What's SRM? [1461:9] **A.** SRM is Serum. [1461:10] **Q.** And why did you want to get out of these loans? [1461:11] **A.** I was really afraid of what it would look like, that I would look really corrupt, that I would, you know——the interpretation to them would——would be——would be really negative. [1461:15] **Q.** Why did you feel comfortable proposing a backdated transaction? [1461:17] **A.** It's something I knew could be done because Sam had proposed, you know, once to me in other contexts. [1461:19] **Q.** And the defendant says, "I think that's probably fine." After that, did you go through with this transaction? [1461:21] **A.** No. [1461:22] **Q.** Why not? [1461:23] **A.** It felt wrong. I was not——not to make an excuse for my having proposed this, not at all, but I was in different levels of having a right mind throughout these days, and in better [1462:1] moments, I didn't pursue it. [1462:2] **MR. ROOS:** We can take this down. [1462:3] **Q.** Now directing your attention to November 6, did there ever come a time where you discussed Alameda's balances with the defendant? [1462:6] **A.** Yes. [1462:7] **Q.** And what did you discuss? [1462:8] **A.** Forgive me. You're asking about November? [1462:9] **Q.** November 6. [1462:10] **A.** Yes. On November 6th, we talked about how there was a hole. [1462:12] **Q.** Any other specifics you recall? [1462:13] **A.** Sorry. This is specifically about Alameda balances? [1462:14] **Q.** Correct. [1462:15] **A.** I recall Sam drafting——Sam and Caroline drafting balance sheets that showed all of FTX and Alameda's assets versus liabilities. [1462:18] **Q.** As part of these discussions, what, if any, conversations did you have about the old FTX fiat account you testified about earlier in your testimony today? [1462:21] **A.** One of the exercises that related to determining Alameda's balances that Sam asked me for help in was giving him a list of the USD values in various accounts, much like the June exercise that we had done. He provided me a list of accounts and referenced the seoyun one, the one that now held the FTX fiat [1463:1] old obligation. [1463:2] **Q.** Let's take a look. [1463:3] **MR. ROOS:** Government offers Exhibit 480B, which is a message exchange between the witness and the defendant, pursuant to stipulation S2003. It's dated November 6, 2022. [1463:6] **THE COURT:** This is 480D or—— [1463:7] **MR. ROOS:** This is 480B as in boy. [1463:8] **THE COURT:** Thank you. Received. [1463:9] (Government's Exhibit 480B received in evidence) [1463:10] **MR. ROOS:** May we publish it? [1463:11] **THE COURT:** Yes. [1463:12] BY MR. ROOS: [1463:13] **Q.** Mr. Singh, what type of message is this? [1463:14] **A.** This is also a Signal message, this time sent from Sam. [1463:15] **Q.** And what's the date of it? [1463:16] **A.** Sunday, November 6th. [1463:17] **Q.** And focusing on the message, how, if at all, does this relate to what you were just describing about the seoyun account? [1463:20] **A.** The bottom account, in the first message, Sam's enumerating a bunch of accounts for me to grab the USD value of. In the second message, Sam says to include the seoyun one, which has the old fiat account. [1463:24] **Q.** And how did you know what the defendant was talking about? [1463:25] **A.** Because we had had the discussion months earlier about me [1464:1] moving it to——moving the FTX fiat old subaccount into a different account so that Alameda wasn't charged interest but could still know about it. [1464:4] **Q.** And several months prior, which you testified about earlier, what was the balance in that account at the time? [1464:6] **A.** Negative 8 billion. [1464:7] **MR. ROOS:** Okay. We can take this down. [1464:8] **Q.** Now let's focus on the evening of November 6. On that evening did you have any conversations with the defendant about tweeting or Twitter? [1464:11] **A.** There was a war room of sorts that had gathered in Sam's apartment in Gemini 1D with Sam, Caroline, Gary, me, Ryan Salame on the phone, Ramnik Arora, and eventually others. One of the items being discussed was how to address the crisis now at hand publicly. They were discussing versions of a tweet that Sam was workshopping. There was a point when they were discussing whether or not to characterize FTX as solvent or well capitalized. I felt very uncomfortable with both definitions. I felt neither was true. I leaned over the couch in which they were talking and said: I'm not comfortable with this. I'm recusing myself. They acknowledged in a kind of annoyed way and proceeded. [1464:23] **Q.** You used "they" a few times at the end of your statement there. Who is "they"? [1464:25] **A.** Specifically, I was leaning over the section of the couch [1465:1] with Sam and Ramnik, but the whole group heard. [1465:2] **Q.** And whose tweet were they drafting? [1465:3] **A.** Drafting a potential tweet for Sam to send. [1465:4] **Q.** And you said you recused yourself. Is that something——what did you mean by that? [1465:6] **A.** I don't know that I had the most precise definition at the time. I mostly wanted to express that I didn't approve of this and——but I didn't——I acknowledged I didn't have the power to stop them. I'd already made clear my preferences on what to say and so I just didn't want to be involved. [1465:11] **Q.** Why weren't you comfortable with the tweeting? [1465:12] **A.** It was really dishonest, and I was, you know——I'd been asking if we could just halt withdrawals instead. [1465:14] **Q.** Did the defendant tweet after that? [1465:15] **A.** Yes. [1465:16] **Q.** Showing you now Government Exhibit 866, which is in evidence. [1465:18] **MR. ROOS:** And could we zoom in on the date and time of the first tweet. [1465:20] **Q.** Mr. Singh, when is this in relation to the conversation you were just describing? [1465:22] **A.** The following morning. [1465:23] **Q.** Let's look at the first tweet. The defendant says, "FTX is fine. Assets are fine." Was that accurate as of November 7, 2022? [1466:1] **A.** No. [1466:2] **Q.** Why not? [1466:3] **A.** We had determined definitively that FTX had a hole. That was clear to everybody involved in the discussion I just mentioned. [1466:6] **Q.** Did those discussions include the defendant? [1466:7] **A.** Yes. [1466:8] **MR. ROOS:** Okay. Zoom out from here. And let's look at the one below it. [1466:10] **Q.** That tweet includes a statement, "FTX has enough to cover all client holdings." Was that true at the time? [1466:12] **A.** This is an even narrower statement that is even——and therefore even more false. [1466:14] **Q.** Why? [1466:15] **A.** FTX did not have enough to cover client holdings. That was the sense in which it was not fine. [1466:17] **Q.** At or before the time the defendant tweeted this, had you discussed the state of FTX assets with him? [1466:19] **A.** Yes. [1466:20] **Q.** Had you discussed the issues that you've testified about relating to customer funds? [1466:22] **A.** By that——I discussed with him the existence of a hole, and he——he quantified it by putting together these balance sheets. [1466:24] **Q.** What, if anything, did you understand the purpose of the tweets were based on your involvement in the conversation you [1467:1] testified about? [1467:2] **A.** I'd overheard in the conversation opinions that these tweets should be really strong, which I understood to be a euphemism for particularly misleading in such a way that will quell fears definitively. [1467:6] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1467:7] **THE COURT:** Mr. Roos. [1467:8] **MR. ROOS:** His understanding is relevant as a co-conspirator. [1467:10] **THE COURT:** Yes. Overruled. [1467:11] **A.** I understood "strong" to mean making a very confident and therefore misleading statement, or false statement, about FTX's financial condition. [1467:14] **Q.** Was the defendant in that conversation? [1467:15] **A.** Yes. [1467:16] **MR. ROOS:** We can take this down. [1467:17] So Judge, I'm very close to the end, but I don't think I'm going to make it by 8:30——by 4:30. [1467:19] **THE COURT:** I was worried about 8:30. [1467:20] **MR. ROOS:** Certainly we'll make it by 8:30. [1467:21] Would you like me to continue——I think I've got about two minutes left——or I can stop here. I'm about to switch topics. [1467:24] **THE COURT:** Well, you've got two minutes left. [1467:25] **MR. ROOS:** Okay. Thank you. [1468:1] BY MR. ROOS: [1468:2] **Q.** During the next week in November, the week in November that we've been discussing, did you have any conversations with the defendant about possible explanations for Alameda's borrowing? [1468:5] **A.** Yes. [1468:6] **Q.** What did you discuss? [1468:7] **A.** He asked me to determine the total amounts that had flown through the spot margin system historically, the largest amounts that had ever been lent and borrowed. [1468:10] **Q.** What is the spot margin system? [1468:11] **A.** FTX supported a peer-to-peer borrowing system such that customers could explicitly lend their funds for others to borrow. [1468:14] **Q.** And are customers automatically involved in the spot margin system? [1468:16] **A.** No. They have to opt in. [1468:17] **Q.** What specifically did the defendant ask you when he raised the possibility of the spot margin system? [1468:19] **A.** He asked me to run a database query to fetch the largest——the most that had been borrowed or lent at any point in time for each coin through the spot margin system. [1468:22] **Q.** And was it the case that the hole that you've testified about was the result of borrowing through the spot margin system? [1468:25] **A.** No. [1469:1] **Q.** Why do you say no? [1469:2] **A.** Funds were taken from bank accounts, which had nothing to do with the spot margin system, and negative amounts in the main Alameda account did not have spot margin enabled. It borrowed——and were able to because of the "Allow Negative" flag. [1469:7] **Q.** What do you mean that the main account didn't have spot margin enabled? [1469:9] **A.** Customers had to opt in to borrowing and participating in the borrow/lending system. This would, you know——opting in was a——is tantamount to enabling spot margin. Alameda's main account, though it was really negative at times and was borrowing, wasn't doing so through this system. [1469:14] **Q.** Now changing dates and directing your attention to November 8, 2022, did you speak to an attorney on that day named Dan Friedberg? [1469:17] **A.** I did. [1469:18] **Q.** And did you tell the defendant about that conversation? [1469:19] **A.** I did. [1469:20] **MR. ROOS:** Your Honor, the government offers Exhibit 480C, which is a message exchange between the defendant and the witness on November 8th, pursuant to stipulation S2003. [1469:23] **THE COURT:** 480C is received. [1469:24] (Government's Exhibit 480C received in evidence) [1469:25] **MR. ROOS:** May we publish it? [1470:1] **THE COURT:** You may. [1470:2] BY MR. ROOS: [1470:3] **Q.** Who is this Signal chat between? [1470:4] **A.** Also between me and Sam. [1470:5] **Q.** What's the date on it? [1470:6] **A.** Tuesday, November 8th. [1470:7] **Q.** You write to the defendant, "when you briefly called Dan he was very upset with us and blamed basically the three of us and said it was super [f'd] up, etc." Who is the Dan in this sentence? [1470:11] **A.** Dan Friedberg. [1470:12] **Q.** You wrote that when he called, he blamed the three of you. What were you referring to? Who were you referring to? [1470:14] **A.** In the call, Dan blamed me, Sam, and Gary. That's what I meant, although I don't know that my meaning was clear in the message. [1470:17] **MR. ROOS:** Now can we zoom out of this. [1470:18] **Q.** And how did the defendant respond? [1470:19] **A.** He said that that matched his understanding, that Dan was really upset at us, and that it lined up with what Joe——Joe Bankman——had told him. [1470:22] **Q.** Just to be clear, who is Dan F? [1470:23] **A.** Dan Friedberg. [1470:24] **Q.** And so to close the loop on this, you say that Dan F was very upset, and his message in response to that is, "yup, makes [1471:1] sense"? [1471:2] **A.** I said a few things. I said Dan is upset and that Ryan is likely to resign if we don't proceed correctly. Sam is saying, "yup, makes sense" maybe to part or all of that. [1471:5] **Q.** Okay. And then do you see where the defendant says, "fwiw"? What is that? [1471:7] **A.** "For what it's worth." [1471:8] **Q.** "For what it's worth, I don't hate the idea of them being pissed at me—–I don't know, there are pros and cons, and probably mostly cons, but it might help them." [1471:11] And so do you see that there? [1471:12] **A.** Yes. [1471:13] **Q.** And you wrote——can we zoom out of this—–"this is wildly selfish of me, but they may need to know that it wasn't a ton of people orchestrating it. I think it makes them more likely to want to be here to help save the situation and the others at least." [1471:18] What were you referring to here? [1471:19] **A.** I really wanted Sam to clarify what everyone's role in this fraud was, that it's selfish, my request, because I wanted him to clarify that I wasn't orchestrating it and that I learned about it really late. I wanted Sam to clarify that he was orchestrating it. [1471:24] **MR. ROOS:** Judge, do you want me to keep going or stop here? [1472:1] **THE COURT:** Well, you told me you'd be done in two minutes. [1472:3] **MR. ROOS:** Sorry. I did say I have two minutes. I have probably three more minutes of testimony. [1472:5] **THE COURT:** This time I'm holding you to it. [1472:6] **MR. ROOS:** Thank you, your Honor. [1472:7] BY MR. ROOS: [1472:8] **Q.** So why were you asking for him to clarify that he was orchestrating it? [1472:10] **A.** Two reasons. I was under severe emotional distress from people like Dan Friedberg calling me and blaming me for the entirety of this, and I was certainly guilty for participating in it since September, but I don't feel that I made the hole. And secondly——and I sort of wanted my——the state of my relationship with these people I loved and tried to do right by to remain intact and for them not to hate me. [1472:17] Secondly, there was a crazy blame game going on and people weren't being productive. Now more than ever, to salvage whatever we could, FTX employees needed to be productive, and resolving the blame game quickly and definitively seemed like it would be a path towards that. [1472:22] **Q.** What do you mean resolving the blame game? [1472:23] **A.** Sam making clear that he was responsible, that I was responsible in another capacity, that everyone responsible was responsible, and then moving past it so we could just maybe [1473:1] sell to Binance or do whatever we could to save what we could. [1473:2] **Q.** You mentioned Dan Friedberg a few times now. What was his role at FTX? [1473:4] **A.** He was the——he went by a couple titles, but fundamentally he was the lead——lead lawyer. He was sort of chief legal decision-maker on everything. [1473:7] **Q.** And just for context, what was your mental state at this point when you were asking the defendant to do these things? [1473:9] **A.** I'd been suicidal for some days. [1473:10] **Q.** And why did you want him to come clean? [1473:11] **THE COURT:** Hasn't that been asked and answered? [1473:12] **Q.** Well, let me ask you this question this way. [1473:13] **MR. ROOS:** Well, actually, let's just zoom out. [1473:14] And can we go further down. [1473:15] Last message, can we zoom in on it. [1473:16] **Q.** Can you just read what he wrote in response to you. [1473:17] **A.** Sam said, "yup, for what it's worth, I don't think that's super selfish. I think that's probably correct." [1473:19] **MR. ROOS:** No further questions. [1473:20] **THE COURT:** All right. Thank you. [1473:21] Ladies and gentlemen, 9:30 tomorrow morning. [1473:22] Counsel remain. *[The rest of the transcript for October 16 is not reproduced. Pages 1474 to 1478 record a discussion between the judge and the lawyers after the jury had left for the day, about scheduling and about matters concerning the defendant. Pages 1479 to 1484 are sealed by order of the court.]* ## Tuesday, October 17, 2023 *[Page 1487 is the cover page of the transcript for October 17. Pages 1488 to 1490 are sealed by order of the court. Page 1491, a short exchange between the judge and the lawyers before the jury came in, about exhibits for a later witness, is not reproduced.]* [1492:1] (Jury present) [1492:2] **THE COURT:** Good morning, folks. I hope you had a nice evening. [1492:4] Mr. Singh, you're still under oath. [1492:5] The record will reflect the jurors and the defendant all are present, as they have been throughout. [1492:7] Cross-examination, Mr. Cohen. [1492:8] **MR. COHEN:** Thank you, your Honor. [1492:9] NISHAD SINGH, resumed. ### [1492:10] CROSS EXAMINATION [1492:11] BY MR. COHEN: [1492:12] **Q.** Good morning, Mr. Singh. [1492:13] **A.** Good morning. [1492:14] **Q.** I'd like to ask you, if I ask you a question that you can answer yes or no, please do so. [1492:16] **A.** Sounds good. [1492:17] **Q.** Do you recall yesterday you testified about FTX's business spending? [1492:19] **A.** Yes. [1492:20] **Q.** Things like sponsorships and venture investments, correct? [1492:21] **A.** Yes. [1492:22] **Q.** And I believe you testified at page 1313 that you thought the spend was too large or didn't make sense. Do you recall that, sir? [1492:25] **A.** I don't recall exactly what I said. In many instances I [1493:1] thought it was too large or didn't make sense, not in all. [1493:2] **Q.** Okay. Fair to say that in certain instances you disagreed with the business rationale for the spend? [1493:4] **A.** Right. [1493:5] **Q.** You thought that spending on such items was too large. [1493:6] **A.** Right. [1493:7] **Q.** And is it fair to say that at certain times Sam had a different business judgment as to that spend? [1493:9] **A.** Frequently. [1493:10] **Q.** And Sam ran the business side of FTX, correct? [1493:11] **A.** Yes. [1493:12] **Q.** Now did FTX have a marketing group? [1493:13] **A.** It had a lot of employees that worked on marketing in some capacity. [1493:15] **Q.** And from time to time those employees would make recommendations to Sam about marketing initiatives, correct? [1493:17] **MR. ROOS:** Objection, hearsay. [1493:18] **MR. COHEN:** I'll rephrase, your Honor. [1493:19] **THE COURT:** Yes, please. [1493:20] **Q.** Do you know if from time to time the marketing group would make recommendations to Sam? [1493:22] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. Hearsay. [1493:23] **THE COURT:** Overruled. [1493:24] The question is whether you know one way or the other. [1493:25] **A.** Yes, I read in Slack—— [1494:1] **THE COURT:** No, no, no. The answer was yes. Just stop there. [1494:3] **Q.** Let's talk for a moment about sponsorships. Was it your view, Mr. Singh, that FTX shouldn't have any corporate sponsorships? [1494:6] **A.** I'm not sure that I had a view that extreme. I don't think I had a very precise view on what should happen. [1494:8] **MR. COHEN:** If we could pull up Government Exhibit 343 in evidence, please. [1494:10] **Q.** This is a document entitled List of Sponsorships. Do you recall going over this with us yesterday, Mr. Singh? [1494:12] **A.** Yes. [1494:13] **Q.** Okay. And counsel directed you to line 3. [1494:14] **MR. COHEN:** Brian, could we have line 3. [1494:15] **Q.** And that was the sponsorship for the Miami-Dade FTX Arena. Do you see that, Mr. Singh? [1494:17] **A.** Yes. [1494:18] **Q.** And you told us yesterday about the spend of 135 million on that sponsorship, correct? [1494:20] **A.** Yes. [1494:21] **MR. COHEN:** Okay. Now why don't we——Brian, if we might expand this and cover some things that weren't covered yesterday. [1494:24] Let's take a look at the——Brian, move it a little bit more to my right. [1495:1] Okay. Other way. Other way. Okay. That's good. [1495:2] BY MR. COHEN: [1495:3] **Q.** All right. If you can look at the heading that I'm circling, Mr. Singh, Deal Start Date and Duration, do you see that, sir? [1495:6] **A.** I do. [1495:7] **Q.** Is it fair to say that for the Miami-Dade FTX Arena, the duration of the sponsorship was 19 years? [1495:9] **A.** Yes, that's what this suggests. [1495:10] **Q.** Okay. With a start date of March 22, 2021. [1495:11] **A.** That's what the spreadsheet says. [1495:12] **MR. COHEN:** Okay. If we could continue, Brian, moving along on that same row, to the right. [1495:14] If you go to the column entitled Outlay, and Brian, bring that all the way over, please. [1495:16] **Q.** And that shows, Mr. Singh, the outlay per year of this $135 million commitment, correct? [1495:18] **MR. ROOS:** Objection, foundation. [1495:19] **Q.** Do you see that, sir? [1495:20] **THE COURT:** Well, just a minute. We're not performing eye examinations here. [1495:22] **MR. COHEN:** Sorry, Judge. [1495:23] **THE COURT:** I mean, it says what it says. [1495:24] **MR. COHEN:** Okay. [1495:25] **Q.** Now, Mr. Singh, this sponsorship of the FTX Arena was aimed [1496:1] at promoting FTX's brand and awareness, correct? [1496:2] **MR. ROOS:** Objection, foundation. [1496:3] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1496:4] **Q.** Did you have a view about whether or not it was a useful thing to promote FTX's brand? [1496:6] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1496:7] **THE COURT:** Ground? [1496:8] **MR. ROOS:** Relevance. [1496:9] **MR. COHEN:** This was—— [1496:10] **THE COURT:** Pardon me? [1496:11] **MR. COHEN:** I'm sorry. I didn't mean to interrupt your Honor. [1496:13] **THE COURT:** Go ahead. I'm looking to you for a response. [1496:15] **MR. COHEN:** Oh. This was covered yesterday, and this is relevant because yesterday we were told that this was excessive spend with no purpose. [1496:18] **THE COURT:** Overruled. [1496:19] BY MR. COHEN: [1496:20] **Q.** You can answer my question, Mr. Singh. [1496:21] **A.** Do you mind repeating it. [1496:22] **MR. COHEN:** Let's read it back. [1496:23] **THE COURT:** The question was: "Did you have a view about whether or not it was a useful thing to promote FTX's brand?" That's the question. Please answer it. [1497:1] **A.** I understood that it had business benefits and costs. The specific, you know——if I specifically thought any given transaction was useful depended on the details of that transaction. [1497:5] **Q.** And the business benefits and costs were for Sam to weigh, correct? [1497:7] **A.** Yes. [1497:8] **MR. COHEN:** All right. We can take that down, Brian. [1497:9] **Q.** Now you also mentioned yesterday——you covered a topic of venture spending. Do you recall that, Mr. Singh? [1497:11] **A.** Yes. [1497:12] **Q.** And one of the topics you covered was a company called K5. Do you recall that? [1497:14] **A.** I do. [1497:15] **Q.** And that was a company run by, among others, Michael Kives, correct? [1497:17] **A.** Oh, forgive my pronunciation yesterday. Yes. [1497:18] **MR. COHEN:** Can we pull up Government Exhibit 42, please. [1497:20] **Q.** Do you recall going over this with counsel yesterday? [1497:21] **A.** Yes. [1497:22] **Q.** And if you look at the second line from the top, Mr. Bankman-Fried stated that "Mr. Kives is probably the most connected person I've ever met. In attendance at the dinner at his house were:" and then it lists a number of people who you [1498:1] identified. Do you recall that? [1498:2] **A.** I do. [1498:3] **Q.** Okay. Did you——based on your working at FTX, did you have a view about whether there was a value in having connection with celebrities and entrepreneurs? [1498:6] **A.** Yes, I believed that it could be valuable for the business. [1498:7] **Q.** Depending on the circumstances, correct? [1498:8] **A.** Right. Depending on the circumstances. [1498:9] **Q.** And I believe you testified that you discussed with Mr. Bankman-Fried that someone like Mr. Kives could be a one-stop shop for such relationships, correct? [1498:12] **A.** I discussed that in that Sam told me that, that it could be a one-stop shop for relationships. [1498:14] **Q.** And this would eliminate the need to have multiple brokers trying to develop such relationships, correct? [1498:16] **A.** I don't remember exactly what words Sam used, but he, in this document, says something to that effect, and I recall something to that effect being said in person to me. [1498:19] **Q.** Did you agree with that, sir? [1498:20] **A.** I didn't know. I didn't know who the other brokers were or the quality of the relationships Michael Kives had with these people. [1498:23] **Q.** So you had no view on whether it was better to have one person or multiple brokers. [1498:25] **A.** There was a cost of juggling multiple, but all else equal, [1499:1] having more connections is better. [1499:2] **MR. COHEN:** Now we can take that down, Brian. [1499:3] **Q.** Based on your interaction with Mr. Bankman-Fried, did you have any understanding about whether or not the relationship with K5 involved something more than being in a broker relationship? [1499:7] **MR. ROOS:** Objection, foundation. [1499:8] **THE COURT:** Mr. Cohen, what do you say to that? [1499:9] **MR. COHEN:** I asked his understanding, your Honor. [1499:10] **THE COURT:** Yes, I understand. Why is his understanding on that appropriate? [1499:12] **MR. COHEN:** Because, your Honor, again, yesterday we were told these were all reckless and frivolous investments, and I'm entitled to show that there was way more to it than we were told yesterday, so that's the relevance. [1499:16] **THE COURT:** I'll allow it for a moment, anyway. [1499:17] **MR. COHEN:** Okay. All I need is a moment, your Honor. [1499:18] Can we read the question back, please. [1499:19] **THE COURT:** Please read it back. [1499:20] (Record read) [1499:21] **A.** I know at least one other project that did not itself seem like it was just exercising K5's ability as a broker. [1499:23] **Q.** What was that project, Mr. Singh? [1499:24] **A.** Sam investing in a tequila brand run by a famous celebrity. [1499:25] **Q.** Okay. You also mentioned that in addition to the Kives [1500:1] relationship there were other venture investments that FTX spent on. Do you recall that, sir? [1500:3] **A.** Yes. [1500:4] **Q.** Okay. And you mentioned I believe a mining company, correct? [1500:6] **A.** Bitcoin mining company. [1500:7] **Q.** Bitcoin mining. And the judge explained to all of us that wasn't an in-the-ground mining company, correct? [1500:9] **A.** And I tried my best and likely failed to clarify further. [1500:10] **Q.** Now did you participate, Mr. Singh——let me back up. [1500:11] Have you ever heard the term "due diligence"? [1500:12] **A.** Yes. [1500:13] **Q.** What does it mean to you? [1500:14] **A.** The process of analyzing the internals of a company to understand how it functions. [1500:16] **Q.** And is that done prior to investing in a company? [1500:17] **A.** In general. [1500:18] **Q.** Okay. Did you participate in any of the due diligence relating to the venture investments you described yesterday? [1500:20] **A.** Give me a moment. I'm trying to think about if there is even a single one. [1500:22] I did for Anthropic. [1500:23] **Q.** And just to remind the jury, Anthropic was the AI company, correct? [1500:25] **A.** Yes. [1501:1] **Q.** And you participated in the due diligence in determining whether to make the investment, correct? [1501:3] **A.** Not quite. The investment was first made, the large one, from Sam, and I was really proud of it, and I also wanted to make an investment, or view it as a donation, and so I separately went and talked with the Anthropic folks. [1501:7] **Q.** So you asked to make a personal investment in the Anthropic company, correct? [1501:9] **A.** No. Initially I thought it would be further investment or donation from Alameda. [1501:11] **Q.** Didn't you just say you wanted to personally invest? [1501:12] **A.** I wanted to be personally involved. [1501:13] **Q.** Okay. Mr. Singh, can we try my question. Did you personally——did you——were you interested in personally investing in Anthropic? [1501:16] **A.** Before—— [1501:17] **Q.** At any time. [1501:18] **A.** Yeah, at any time, yes, at one point I was. [1501:19] **Q.** Now you also testified yesterday about spending on Bahamas properties. Do you recall that, sir? [1501:21] **A.** I do. [1501:22] **MR. COHEN:** Can we call up GX 3, please. [1501:23] **Q.** Do you recall providing testimony about GX 3, which was the list of the properties purchased in the Bahamas? Do you recall that, sir? [1502:1] **A.** I do. [1502:2] **Q.** Okay. Just quickly, before I forget, No. 2, it says Albany Lot 44, Conch Shack. Do you see that, sir? [1502:4] **A.** Yes. [1502:5] **Q.** What was that? [1502:6] **A.** This was a house that was conveyed or——that was conveyed to Constance Wang or just one that she lived in. [1502:8] **MR. COHEN:** Okay. And we can take this down. [1502:9] **Q.** I believe you testified that you and Mr. Bankman-Fried and others, eight in total, wanted to live together in the Bahamas, correct? [1502:12] **A.** I forget if it was exactly eight, but yes, a group of us wanted to live together. [1502:14] **Q.** Fair enough. You and your girlfriend? [1502:15] **A.** Yes. [1502:16] **Q.** Mr. Bankman-Fried? [1502:17] **A.** Yes. [1502:18] **Q.** Mr. Yedidia and his girlfriend? [1502:19] **A.** Yes. [1502:20] **Q.** Others. Correct? [1502:21] **A.** Yes. [1502:22] **Q.** So you told us that you looked for——you looked for housing and you saw a place that was less expensive than the penthouse that was ultimately purchased. Do you recall that, sir? [1502:25] **A.** A few places, yes. [1503:1] **Q.** Few places. And when Mr. Bankman-Fried indicated he was interested in the Orchid 6 penthouse, you had a substantial disagreement. You told us that yesterday. [1503:4] **A.** I had a disagreement. [1503:5] **Q.** You didn't say substantial disagreement yesterday? [1503:6] **A.** I forget exactly what I said yesterday. [1503:7] **Q.** Didn't you tell us yesterday that you thought it was really expensive and super ostentatious? [1503:9] **A.** Yes. [1503:10] **Q.** Okay. But Mr. Bankman-Fried went ahead, went ahead with the purchase anyway, correct? [1503:12] **A.** Right. [1503:13] **Q.** And then you moved into the apartment. [1503:14] **A.** I did. [1503:15] **Q.** You and your girlfriend lived in one of the master bedroom suites, didn't you? [1503:17] **A.** The nicest room in the house. [1503:18] **Q.** And you lived there until you left the Bahamas in November of 2022, correct? [1503:20] **A.** Correct. [1503:21] **Q.** Okay. And prior——you told us this yesterday. Prior to November 2022, you were a billionaire. [1503:23] **A.** So I believed. [1503:24] **Q.** Okay. Mr. Bankman-Fried was a billionaire. [1503:25] **A.** So I believed. [1504:1] **Q.** The other members in the apartment were worth at least millions of dollars, correct? [1504:3] **A.** So I believed. [1504:4] **Q.** Would you regard it as really expensive for a group of billionaires and millionaires to live in a $30 million apartment? [1504:7] **A.** The expense would be the same no matter the wealth of the people living in it. [1504:9] **Q.** So your view is it was really expensive. [1504:10] **A.** In absolute terms, yes. [1504:11] **Q.** What about relative to the wealth of the people living in the apartment? [1504:13] **A.** I don't really know what's reasonable for billionaires to do. I don't know other billionaires. [1504:15] **Q.** So you have no view. [1504:16] **A.** I felt confused about it. [1504:17] **Q.** Okay. But not confused enough to move out. [1504:18] **A.** Oh, I considered moving out many times. [1504:19] **Q.** But you didn't. [1504:20] **A.** I didn't. [1504:21] **Q.** Okay. Now I want to move to a different topic, Mr. Singh. Bear with me a moment. [1504:23] Do you recall yesterday that you told us that you were asked what your role was in the fraud against FTX's customers that you committed with the defendant? Do you recall being [1505:1] asked that question, sir? [1505:2] **A.** Or something to its effect, yes. [1505:3] **Q.** Okay. Fair enough. [1505:4] And you told us that "In September of 2022, I learned of the hole and even after that, implicitly and explicitly, I greenlit transactions that I knew must have been digging the hole deeper and therefore coming from customer funds." Do you recall giving that testimony yesterday? [1505:9] **A.** Or something to that effect, yes. [1505:10] **Q.** Okay. So you also testified yesterday that you first learned that customer funds were being deposited, FTX customer funds were being deposited in Alameda bank accounts as early as 2019. Do you recall that, sir? [1505:14] **A.** Yes. [1505:15] **Q.** And you gave us an example from 2019 and 2020, correct? [1505:16] **A.** Sorry. I don't remember which examples I gave, but—— [1505:17] **Q.** That's fine. So I take it you didn't think that was wrong. [1505:18] **A.** Not at the time. [1505:19] **Q.** Okay. And then you told us yesterday that——and we'll get to this more in a bit——you told us about a sequence in June, beginning in June 2022, where you were asked to look into certain balances of Alameda. Do you recall that, sir? [1505:23] **A.** I do. [1505:24] **Q.** Okay. We'll get to that in a minute. [1505:25] But you also told us that when you first learned about [1506:1] the situation in June, "I thought Alameda had positive balances on FTX, that it was borrowing in lots in some places but that overall they had the money." Do you recall giving us that testimony? [1506:5] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. I think Mr. Cohen is just rereading his testimony from yesterday. [1506:7] **MR. COHEN:** I'm setting up the question, your Honor. This is cross-examination. [1506:9] **THE COURT:** Mr. Cohen, I understand what's happening in this courtroom, and I don't need that. If you're reading from the transcript, read from the transcript and identify by page and line what you're reading from. [1506:13] **MR. COHEN:** I thought I was. Okay. I will, your Honor. [1506:15] **THE COURT:** Well, let's proceed that way. [1506:16] **MR. COHEN:** Let's go to the transcript. For counsel and the Court's benefit, this is page 1404. You don't have to show it to the witness, but for counsel and the Court, lines 5 through 11. [1506:20] BY MR. COHEN: [1506:21] **Q.** "Q. What do you mean?" [1506:22] "The June exercise, I thought Alameda had positive balances on FTX, that it was borrowing lots in some places but that overall, they had more money than they didn't. This suggested an entirely different reality. I was hoping that I [1507:1] didn't really understand what Gary——what Gary meant by borrowing, but if I did, this was absolutely devastating." [1507:3] Do you see that, sir? Did you hear that, sir? I'm sorry. [1507:5] **A.** I hear that. [1507:6] **Q.** And you gave that testimony yesterday. [1507:7] **A.** I believe so. [1507:8] **Q.** All right. So as of June——this is the date that you gave the testimony in——your concern was whether or not Alameda had assets to cover the borrowing. [1507:11] **A.** I had other concerns as well. [1507:12] **Q.** In the passage I just read, that was what you told us. [1507:13] **MR. ROOS:** Speaks for itself. [1507:14] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1507:15] **Q.** Now what were your other concerns in June? [1507:16] **A.** The exercise showed that there were specific accounts that were extremely negative, like the main account. To be in that position suggested a use of "Allow Negative" that didn't meet the spirit that I expected these privileges to be used in. [1507:20] **Q.** Okay. And so prior to June of 2022 was it your view that as long as the balances were offset by sufficient assets, the borrowing was appropriate? [1507:23] **A.** That was not my view. [1507:24] **Q.** What was your view? [1507:25] **A.** On what specifically? [1508:1] **Q.** Prior to June——I understand your testimony about June, and we'll come back to that——did you have a view about whether or not Alameda could borrow provided that the borrowing was supported by assets? [1508:5] **A.** There were many circumstances in which I thought that would not be appropriate. [1508:7] **Q.** You didn't think——you didn't think there were circumstances in which it would be appropriate. [1508:9] **MR. ROOS:** Objection, vague and asked and answered. [1508:10] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1508:11] **Q.** Mr. Singh, do you recall yesterday you told us you had many meetings with the government? [1508:13] **A.** Yes. [1508:14] **Q.** And I think you said you had about 20 such meetings. [1508:15] **A.** That sounds right. [1508:16] **Q.** And in those meetings the prosecutors would ask you questions? [1508:18] **A.** They would. [1508:19] **Q.** And you would try to answer them the best you could? [1508:20] **A.** Correct. [1508:21] **Q.** Okay. Do you recall meeting with them in——well, let me do it this way. Is it fair to say that your first meeting with the prosecutors was in November of 2022? [1508:24] **A.** I believe that's right. [1508:25] **Q.** November 21st? [1509:1] **A.** I don't remember the exact date. Sorry. But I believe that's right. [1509:3] **Q.** Is it fair to say that you had meetings in November, December, and January——November and December of 2022? [1509:5] **A.** Yes. [1509:6] **Q.** And then you had meetings with them again in January, February, and March of the following year? [1509:8] **A.** Yes. [1509:9] **Q.** And then you had additional meetings in May and August? [1509:10] **A.** Sorry. I forget all the exact dates. [1509:11] **Q.** And you had meetings in September and October. [1509:12] **A.** Yes. [1509:13] **Q.** Including a meeting this past week. [1509:14] **A.** Yes. [1509:15] **Q.** Do you recall having a meeting with the prosecutors on January 4th of 2023? [1509:17] **A.** Sorry. I don't remember the specific dates of our meetings. [1509:19] **Q.** A January meeting. [1509:20] **A.** I remember meeting in January. [1509:21] **Q.** Okay. Do you recall telling the prosecutors that to you, the idea of borrowing from anywhere, as long as you were good for it, didn't feel wrong? [1509:24] **A.** I don't remember saying that. [1509:25] **MR. COHEN:** Can we call up 3501-021 just for the [1510:1] witness, please. Page 14. [1510:2] Okay. If you can go to the last paragraph at the bottom, Brian. [1510:4] And go to the last two sentences. [1510:5] **Q.** Mr. Singh, read those to yourself and tell us whether or not they refresh your recollection that you told that to the prosecutors. [1510:8] **A.** I don't—— [1510:9] **MR. ROOS:** Objection to the form. [1510:10] **THE COURT:** What's the form objection? [1510:11] **MR. ROOS:** To "telling it to the prosecutors" in the underlying question. [1510:13] **THE COURT:** I'm sorry, what? [1510:14] **MR. ROOS:** Just the formulation of the "do you recall telling that to the prosecutors." [1510:16] **THE COURT:** Sustained as to form. [1510:17] **MR. COHEN:** Let me see if we can address the Court's, counsel's issue. [1510:19] BY MR. COHEN: [1510:20] **Q.** Mr. Singh, read that to yourself, and does that refresh your recollection about what you said to the prosecutors? [1510:22] **A.** Yes, but not about the exact topic we're talking about. [1510:23] **Q.** So it doesn't refresh you about the topic we just discussed. [1510:25] **A.** About borrowing in general? No. This refreshes me on [1511:1] something specific I thought about bank accounts. [1511:2] **MR. COHEN:** Okay. Then let's take that down. [1511:3] **Q.** When you considered the assets that would be posted as security for the loans, did the nature——did you take into account the nature of the assets? [1511:6] **MR. ROOS:** Objection, vague and foundation. [1511:7] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1511:8] **MR. COHEN:** Sure. [1511:9] **Q.** Coming back to——we were talking about what your thinking was prior to June of 2022. Do you recall that, sir? [1511:11] **A.** I do. [1511:12] **Q.** Okay. In the period prior to 2022 did you take——in thinking about what was going on at Alameda and whether anything was wrong, did you take into account the nature of the assets that Alameda was posting as collateral? [1511:16] **MR. ROOS:** Objection, foundation. [1511:17] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1511:18] **Q.** Now your view changed at some point? Or let me ask you a better question. When did you first believe you had done anything wrong? [1511:21] **A.** I knew that I'd done something wrong when I helped doctor the Serum staking fees revenue. [1511:23] **Q.** When was that, sir? [1511:24] **A.** That was December 30th or 31st of 2021. [1511:25] **Q.** Okay. And coming into the period prior to June, other than [1512:1] the staking fees you just talked about, is there anything else you thought you had done wrong? [1512:3] **A.** I'm not sure. [1512:4] **Q.** And then you told us yesterday your view changed in September 2022; is that correct? [1512:6] **A.** Sorry. On what specifically? [1512:7] **Q.** About what you had done wrong. [1512:8] **MR. ROOS:** Objection, vague. [1512:9] **THE COURT:** Yes. I don't understand, Mr. Cohen. I thought the witness just said that he first believed that he did something wrong in December——I'm mistaken. Excuse me. You go ahead. [1512:13] You can re-put the question. [1512:14] **MR. COHEN:** Okay. [1512:15] BY MR. COHEN: [1512:16] **Q.** I want to understand, to the Court's comment, what you thought in September 2022 was wrong with your conduct. [1512:18] **A.** My conduct before that point or after that point? [1512:19] **Q.** Take it in steps. Let's do before first. [1512:20] **A.** Before that point, I knew that in June, I had observed Alameda borrowing in large amounts in a way that didn't meet the expectations I had and what I'd been told about how Alameda would use things like "Allow Negative." Even in June, when I suspected there was wrongdoing there, I took cues from the people around me and didn't pursue it further. [1513:1] In September, I understood not only had there been an enormous amount of borrowing but that the money wasn't there at all. [1513:4] **Q.** Okay. So, all right. We're going to come back to June, we're going to come back to September. I don't want to do them in bits and pieces. Just let me cover another topic quickly. [1513:7] Do you recall that yesterday counsel asked you questions about your compensation while you worked for FTX? [1513:9] **A.** Yes. [1513:10] **Q.** And I believe you told us that you made a salary of about 200,000? [1513:12] **A.** Yes. [1513:13] **Q.** And that you'd receive cash bonuses around 1 to 2 million; is that correct? [1513:15] **A.** I think that's right. [1513:16] **Q.** Now you also received loans from FTX, correct? [1513:17] **A.** Many. [1513:18] **Q.** And you touched on a loan yesterday, but I'd like to go over it with you in a bit more detail, sir. Let me just give you the foundation. [1513:21] Is it fair to say that at a certain point you borrowed 477 million from FTX? [1513:23] **A.** In a sense. [1513:24] **Q.** In a sense. And this was to purchase options? [1513:25] **A.** Yes. [1514:1] **Q.** Shares in FTX? [1514:2] **A.** Yes. [1514:3] **Q.** Okay. And it was to buy more equity in FTX, correct? [1514:4] **A.** To buy my first equity in FTX. [1514:5] **Q.** Okay. And you said that one of the reasons you were looking to do this was you wanted to donate the money to charity. [1514:8] **A.** Right. [1514:9] **Q.** Did you end up doing that? [1514:10] **A.** No. [1514:11] **Q.** Okay. And you said that there were taxes used with regard to how it was to be structured, correct? [1514:13] **A.** The reason I believe—— [1514:14] **Q.** I'm sorry. Let me ask a better question, sir. The "this" being how the loans would be structured. [1514:16] **A.** The reason it was structured this way was so that there was a smaller outlay of cash from Alameda, with the tradeoff being that I took on a large debt. [1514:19] **Q.** Okay. And you just answer this yes or no, sir. You consulted with attorneys about how to structure this loan, correct? [1514:22] **A.** Yes. [1514:23] **Q.** Okay. I believe you mentioned Dan Friedberg; is that correct? [1514:25] **THE COURT:** Well, Mr. Cohen, it's not clear whether [1515:1] you're asking whether he did that in connection with this or whether he ever consulted Dan Friedberg about anything. [1515:3] **MR. COHEN:** I meant in this, your Honor. [1515:4] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. Misstates testimony then. [1515:5] **Q.** Who were the lawyers you consulted with about this $477 million loan? [1515:7] **A.** Can Sun; Joe Bankman; two of Sam's personal tax lawyers, David Forst, Sean McElroy, and others. [1515:9] **Q.** Where did David Forst and Sean McElroy work, if you know? [1515:10] **A.** I don't know. I think Fenwick & West but I'm not sure. [1515:11] **Q.** Fenwick & West was an outside law firm? [1515:12] **A.** Yes. [1515:13] **Q.** And Can, C-A-N, Sun was the general counsel of FTX, correct? [1515:15] **A.** Yes. [1515:16] **Q.** Now documentation was prepared for that loan, correct? [1515:17] **A.** Yes. [1515:18] **Q.** And you signed that documentation. [1515:19] **A.** Yes. [1515:20] **Q.** Now you also——did you also receive a loan for $10 million? [1515:21] **A.** I did. [1515:22] **Q.** And that was for funds you wanted to provide to your parents, correct? [1515:24] **A.** Family and friends. [1515:25] **Q.** Okay. Family and friends. And that loan was in 2021, [1516:1] correct? [1516:2] **A.** Yes, I believe early 2021. [1516:3] **Q.** And that was money you borrowed from FTX in order to pay to family members. [1516:5] **A.** Not quite. [1516:6] **Q.** Was it money you borrowed from FTX? [1516:7] **A.** No. [1516:8] **Q.** You didn't borrow it. [1516:9] **A.** I did borrow it. [1516:10] **Q.** Okay. So—— [1516:11] **A.** Sorry. To be clear—— [1516:12] **Q.** Let me try, Mr. Singh. Did you borrow $10 million from FTX? [1516:14] **A.** No. [1516:15] **Q.** No. How did it get to you? [1516:16] **A.** Sam gave it to me. [1516:17] **Q.** Sam gave it to you from——through FTX? [1516:18] **A.** I don't think so. [1516:19] **Q.** Okay. And those were funds that were used to pay for your family-related expenses. [1516:21] **A.** They were gifts to family and friends, and some amount was donated. [1516:23] **Q.** Okay. Why don't we now move to another topic, Mr. Singh. And let's talk about June, June of 2022. [1516:25] Well, I think we have to go back a little bit. Do you [1517:1] recall giving testimony yesterday about a bug in the fiat@ account system? [1517:3] **A.** I do. [1517:4] **Q.** And without getting too technical, the effect of this bug was to make it look like Alameda's balances were more negative than they really were, or that——let me rephrase——that Alameda owed more money to FTX than it really did? [1517:8] **A.** The effect of the bug was that the fiat@ftx.com's stated balance was more negative than the——than what it should have actually been, and Alameda was consuming this balance and treating it as something that they were on the hook for, as I understood, and so Alameda overestimated how much they should have had in bank accounts to back customer deposits. [1517:14] **Q.** So the net of it was Alameda overestimated the amount it owed to——back to FTX. [1517:16] **A.** Yes. [1517:17] **Q.** And I believe you told us yesterday that you first became aware of the bug in 2021. [1517:19] **A.** I think either November or December of '21. [1517:20] **Q.** And tell us again how you first learned of it. [1517:21] **A.** It was in the Bahamas office. It was late at night. Gary and Adam sat a few desks away from me, and I overheard them talking about the bug. [1517:24] **Q.** Okay. And what did you overhear? [1517:25] **A.** I think Gary was explaining that it existed. Adam was [1518:1] worried. Gary assured that the direction of the bug was safe, that Alameda overestimated, not underestimated how much it should keep in banks. [1518:4] **Q.** Okay. Did they discuss——did they go over how big the bug was at that time? [1518:6] **A.** I can't remember if they did. I remember asking for details, and at some point I had an understanding of the size—— [1518:8] **Q.** I'm just asking about the conversation with Gary and Adam. We'll get to the rest in a bit. Can you try——can we try again, Mr. Singh. [1518:11] **A.** I can't remember if they said the size of the bug. [1518:12] **Q.** Okay. And you mentioned that Gary said it was in a safe direction. What did you understand that to mean? [1518:14] **A.** That Alameda believed because of the bug that they should be custodying more, not less cash than they actually needed to for customers. [1518:17] **Q.** So it was safe from the FTX point of view. [1518:18] **A.** Yes. [1518:19] **Q.** Okay. Do you remember how, if at all, Mr. Wang and Mr. Yedidia reacted to this? [1518:21] **A.** Adam was worried. [1518:22] **Q.** I'm sorry? [1518:23] **A.** Adam Yedidia was worried about it. After Gary gave his explanation, he seemed relaxed. [1518:25] **Q.** Isn't it true that Gary joked about the bug? [1519:1] **A.** Yes. I think that's right. [1519:2] **Q.** He thought it was funny, correct? [1519:3] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1519:4] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1519:5] **Q.** He seemed relaxed about it, you said. [1519:6] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1519:7] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1519:8] He said Adam seemed relaxed. [1519:9] **MR. COHEN:** I don't think that was the testimony, your Honor, but I'll ask again. [1519:11] **Q.** What was Gary's reaction? [1519:12] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. It was either asked and answered or it's speculation. [1519:14] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1519:15] And you're right, Mr. Cohen, he did say Gary. [1519:16] **MR. COHEN:** So then I don't need to go back since it's already in the record. [1519:18] **THE COURT:** You don't need to go back. [1519:19] **MR. COHEN:** Then I won't. Okay. [1520:1] **Q.** Did you have any reaction at the time, Mr. Singh, of this conversation? [1520:3] **A.** I did. [1520:4] **Q.** What was your reaction? [1520:5] **A.** I shared Adam's worry. After Gary explained that it was safe, I asked Gary if Alameda is in fact tracking this number. Gary said he's pretty sure but that it wouldn't hurt for me to confirm. I asked Caroline if they were. Caroline said they were. [1520:10] **Q.** Let's move forward then to June of 2022 now, sir. [1520:11] I believe you told us you had a communication with Caroline Ellison about Alameda's net asset value being close to zero. [1520:14] Do you recall telling us about that yesterday? [1520:15] **A.** Sorry. I don't. [1520:16] **Q.** Do you recall speaking with Caroline Ellison at all in June of 2022? [1520:18] **A.** Yes. [1520:19] **Q.** By speak, just to be clear, I mean either orally or over Signal or Slack or so forth. [1520:21] **A.** That's how I interpreted it, yes. [1520:22] **Q.** What was the gist of the conversation about the state of Alameda's net asset value? [1520:24] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. Hearsay. [1520:25] **THE COURT:** Why isn't it, Mr. Cohen? [1521:1] **MR. COHEN:** It goes to the effect on the listener, your Honor. [1521:3] **THE COURT:** That's relevant why? [1521:4] **MR. COHEN:** Because we are talking about the state of mind of one of the coconspirators or the alleged coconspirators. [1521:7] **THE COURT:** Mr. Roos. [1521:8] **MR. ROOS:** Maybe I guess we will see where the answer takes us. [1521:10] **THE COURT:** Overruled. [1521:11] **MR. COHEN:** Can we have the question read back? [1521:12] **THE COURT:** Sure. [1521:13] (Record read) [1521:14] **A.** The conversation I remember was the one in which Caroline sent the spreadsheet that we talked about yesterday. I don't recall parts of this conversation referencing that Alameda's NAV was zero. [1521:18] **Q.** Do you recall anything with Ms. Ellison about what the state of Alameda was in terms of its solvency? [1521:20] **A.** In June? [1521:21] **Q.** Um-hum. [1521:22] **A.** No. [1521:23] **Q.** Let's move forward because I think you covered a number of different sequences with respect to June and I want to make sure I understand them, sir. [1522:1] Can you please tell us, as best you can, who you spoke with about this bug in June. [1522:3] **A.** You would like me to list the people? [1522:4] **Q.** I would like you to list the sequence, to the extent you can. [1522:6] **A.** Sure. Tell me if I'm -- if my answer -- [1522:7] **Q.** Do your best, sir. [1522:8] **A.** Caroline sent a spreadsheet, I think a Google Sheet, that contained a list of accounts labeled as if they were from Alameda's pointer system, so Alameda's nomenclature and the total value held in each. These were accounts that Alameda owned on FTX, things like the fiat account and their trading account. They showed some extremely large negative number when considered together. [1522:15] **Q.** If I could stop you for a moment, sir. Who did she send that to, the Google Sheet that you referred to? [1522:17] **A.** I know that she sent it to me, Sam, and Gary. I don't know if she also sent it to other people. [1522:19] **Q.** Was this on one Signal communication? [1522:20] **A.** I don't remember. [1522:21] **Q.** Are you sure she sent it to you, Sam, and Gary? [1522:22] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1522:23] **THE COURT:** Overruled. [1522:24] **A.** I am sure that the four of us got on a Google Meet and worked on like investigating it. I am not sure that she only [1523:1] sent it to the four of us. [1523:2] **Q.** Let's continue with the sequence, sir. [1523:3] **A.** Sure. Sam sees the spreadsheet and said something to the effect of, this can't be right. There has got to be a bug. Let's look into it. [1523:6] **Q.** This was in a different Signal or the same Signal? [1523:7] **A.** I can't recall. Sorry. [1523:8] **Q.** Keep going. [1523:9] **A.** I asked Gary how I could help. Gary told me that I could try my best to identify the accounts in the FTX database that either belonged to Alameda explicitly or morally, morally meaning that in the end there were things that Sam was responsible for. [1523:14] I took a stab. My stab was ignored. Gary took a stab. I added a column to add notes for which elements of Gary's list -- which items Gary had pulled that I thought weren't actually belonging to Alameda. And then I recall Gary pointed out the bug. He calculated the bug. [1523:19] **Q.** If I can stop you for a moment, sir. [1523:20] These conversations you have just been going through for us, were they all over Signal or Slack, or any of them in person? [1523:23] **A.** A number of it was over Google Meet, like done orally. [1523:24] **Q.** Were there any that were in person? [1523:25] **A.** I think Gary was next to me in the office, but I don't [1524:1] recall for sure. Sam may have been. I don't think Caroline was next to me. [1524:3] **Q.** So you don't recall Caroline being there in person? [1524:4] **A.** Not for this. [1524:5] **Q.** You are not sure if Sam was there in person? [1524:6] **A.** Correct. [1524:7] **Q.** Keep going. [1524:8] **A.** Gary identified the bug and calculated its effect size, which was around $8 billion. Caroline posted a screenshot of the graph that she had created that showed two things. One was Alameda's unexpected balance breaks over time or unexplained balance breaks, which I understood to mean something like unexplained changes in the balances that they were fetching, things that they couldn't reconcile against records of trades or withdrawals. [1524:16] And then she posted the effect size, I think, that either Gary or I had given her of the bug over time. These charts showed two lines that were largely parallel, implying that this bug explained at least a large portion of what was unexplained in Alameda's observed balance breaks. [1524:21] **Q.** If I could stop you there for a moment, Mr. Singh. [1524:22] You used a couple of phrases I just want to go over. You used a phrase called balance break. What did you mean by that? [1524:25] **A.** Balances in a trading system change over time. There are [1525:1] also transactions that can explain those changes. If you infer just from the transactions that you received what balances would result from them and you compare them against the actual balances that you are retrieving and fetching live, sometimes there is a difference because you might be missing records or you might be misinterpreting records. That difference is a break. [1525:8] **Q.** In this situation was the break the size of the bug, the effect of the bug? [1525:10] **A.** I don't think it was exactly. I recall that this chart Caroline showed suggested that a large fraction of it was explained by the bug. [1525:13] **Q.** Do you recall, when you first spoke -- you overheard Gary and Adam Yedidia at the end of 2021 talk about the bug, whether the topic of a break came up? [1525:16] **A.** I don't recall. [1525:17] **Q.** Now, when you learned that the break was $8 billion, were you surprised? [1525:19] **A.** Yes. [1525:20] **Q.** Were you surprised that it had not been tracked? [1525:21] **A.** I was surprised -- no, not exactly. [1525:22] **Q.** Didn't you just tell us that Gary assured you it was being tracked by Ms. Ellison and others? [1525:24] **A.** Gary believed that it was being tracked. Caroline assured me that it was being tracked. [1526:1] **Q.** So Gary's belief was incorrect? [1526:2] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1526:3] **THE COURT:** I think the witness can handle that question. [1526:5] **A.** No. Gary wasn't incorrect. [1526:6] **Q.** What about Caroline? [1526:7] **A.** Caroline wasn't incorrect. [1526:8] **Q.** So it hadn't been tracked? [1526:9] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. Vague. [1526:10] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1526:11] **Q.** Let me go back to your answer because I want to make it a little more focused. When you answered about what was being tracked, were you referring to the balances in the fiat@ account or the effect of the bug or, I guess, both? [1526:15] **A.** Just the balances in the fiat account. [1526:16] **Q.** Based on your interaction with the work you did in June, did you have a view about whether those balances had been tracked prior to June? [1526:19] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1526:20] **THE COURT:** Sustained. Form at least. [1526:21] **Q.** The topic of the break come up? [1526:22] **A.** Sorry. When? [1526:23] **Q.** About whether the break had been tracked since the end of the prior year that had come on. [1526:25] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. When? [1527:1] **MR. COHEN:** Since 2021. [1527:2] **THE COURT:** I don't understand what counsel means by the break at this point. [1527:4] **MR. COHEN:** The bug. The size of the bug. [1527:5] **A.** Sorry. Your question -- could you repeat the question? [1527:6] **Q.** Sure. [1527:7] Let me ask it this way. Mr. Singh, did you ever track the bug, size of the bug or its effect, prior to June 2022? [1527:9] **A.** Not prior to June 2022 that I recall. [1527:10] **Q.** Based on your interactions with others at Alameda and FTX, do you think anyone else did? [1527:12] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1527:13] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1527:14] If I understand what you said, Mr. Singh, Gary told you that he thought the size of the overstatement was being tracked. Caroline subsequently assured you that that was so. Is that right so far? [1527:18] **THE WITNESS:** That's not quite right. [1527:19] **THE COURT:** Then correct me, please. [1527:20] **THE WITNESS:** Gary assured me that the full balance, not separately the size of the error, was being tracked. Gary assured me that the fiat@FTX.com balance, which included the bug, was being tracked. Caroline assured me it was. I don't think anybody told me that the size of the bug was being tracked over time. [1528:1] **THE COURT:** I said the size of the overstatement, not the size of the bug, Mr. Singh. [1528:3] The bug was an error in the computer code, right? [1528:4] **THE WITNESS:** Correct. [1528:5] **THE COURT:** And it had an effect, right? [1528:6] **THE WITNESS:** Correct. [1528:7] **THE COURT:** The effect was to overstate the amount owed by Alameda to FTX, correct? [1528:9] **THE WITNESS:** Correct. [1528:10] **THE COURT:** Please, Mr. Cohen, take it from there. [1528:11] **MR. COHEN:** Can we have just the last exchange with his Honor read back, please? [1528:13] **THE COURT:** Yup. I think his Honor may have asked that question. I just want to hear it again. [1528:15] (Record read) [1528:16] **MR. COHEN:** I think his Honor has covered it. [1528:17] **Q.** Very quickly, Mr. Singh, the fiat account was tracked, not the amount of the bug? [1528:19] **A.** Not the size of the error as a result of the bug. [1528:20] **Q.** I am going to ask you to complete the sequence, but before you do that, you used a phrase called morally responsible for certain amounts. What did you mean by that? [1528:23] **A.** There are some accounts in the FTX system that are explicitly under Alameda's name, things like info@AlamedaResearch.com. There are other accounts, like [1529:1] Project Serum accounts, that on their face don't belong to Alameda Research but that I understood, in the end, Sam beneficially owned. Those accounts would be morally but not explicitly owned by Alameda or Sam, so those were to be included inside of this calculation. [1529:6] **Q.** Meaning in the event that they were needed, you understood that Sam would make use of those assets for Alameda? [1529:8] **A.** Really just that they fell under the large umbrella of things that Sam controlled, which was not just Alameda. [1529:10] **Q.** But you considered it in connection with considering the assets of Alameda? [1529:12] **A.** I was told to pull those balances. [1529:13] **Q.** And you pulled them? [1529:14] **A.** Gary ended up pulling them. [1529:15] **Q.** Why don't we complete the sequence, sir. [1529:16] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1529:17] **THE COURT:** I think it's a little hard to start in the middle of the ocean at this point. Try to pin it down. [1529:19] **Q.** You told us, Mr. Singh, about communications you had with Gary, Sam, and Caroline over communications about addressing the impact of the bug. Can you tell us what happened next. [1529:22] **A.** Gary identified -- I think I may have said this. Forgive me if I'm repeating myself. Gary had identified the bug. He identified its effect size as of the current date then, so as of the date we were doing the exercise. Caroline demonstrated [1530:1] that this bug explained a lot of what had been unexplained in Alameda's observed balance breaks. [1530:3] I believe I asked -- said I thought this was fixed in November. I don't remember if I got a response, but it's a silly question. It hadn't been fixed. I don't recall everything that happened after that. [1530:7] The next thing I do recall is sensing from others a palpable sense of relief and even celebration. Sam made a joke or sort of like comment on how it was amazing that such a large balance break could be explained just by a single thing, a single bug. [1530:12] **Q.** We have now talked -- everything you just told us about the bug took place in June and July of 2022. [1530:14] **A.** I think everything I just described now was on a single day, like a single -- in a single hour over Google Meet or something. [1530:17] **Q.** It's a series of communications over Google Meet? [1530:18] **A.** One Google Meet, one long discussion over Google Meet. [1530:19] **Q.** With potentially some in-person communications as well? [1530:20] **A.** Yeah. [1530:21] **Q.** Do you believe you are clear on the sequence of what happened? [1530:23] **A.** I don't think I remember everything about it. [1530:24] **Q.** But on what you just told us, you believe you are clear on that, correct? [1531:1] **A.** I'm stating the sequence the best to the best of my ability. [1531:3] **Q.** Now, we talked about the 20 interviews you've had with the prosecutors, correct, sir? [1531:5] **A.** Correct. [1531:6] **Q.** Do you recall speaking with them in January of this past year, January 4? [1531:8] **A.** I don't recall the specific date, but I do think I met with them in January. [1531:10] **Q.** And at that point you had already had many meetings with them, correct? [1531:12] **A.** Yeah. I had had more than one. [1531:13] **Q.** Does it refresh you that you had more than five? [1531:14] **A.** I would believe it. [1531:15] **Q.** Fair enough. And you had gone over the topic of what happened in June with them, correct? [1531:17] **A.** I think so. [1531:18] **Q.** Isn't it fair to say that you told the prosecutors that you had a surprising amount of haziness when trying to recall events in June and July of 2022? [1531:21] **A.** I don't remember saying those exact words, but I did acknowledge that there was a lot that I -- there was a lot that I didn't remember the details around from that time. [1531:24] **Q.** In particular as to June and July of 2022. [1531:25] **A.** I don't know if I said specifically those dates or months. [1532:1] **MR. COHEN:** Why don't we call up for the witness only 3501-021, page 17. [1532:3] Brian, if you could go to the second-to-last paragraph and call it out, pull it up. [1532:5] **Q.** Mr. Singh, take a moment and read this to yourself. The question is whether it refreshes your recollection as to what you told the prosecutors about your haziness in the meeting with them on January 4, 2023. [1532:9] **A.** Sorry. Could you repeat the ask again? [1532:10] **Q.** Sure. This is whether or not it refreshes your recollection as to what you told prosecutors about your surprising amount of haziness in 2020 in June and July of 2022. Yes or no, does it refresh your recollection? [1532:14] **A.** I still don't remember having said it specifically about June or July of 2022, but I could believe that I did. [1532:16] **MR. COHEN:** We can take that down. [1532:17] **THE COURT:** The question was, does it refresh your recollection, not whether you could believe that you did. [1532:19] **THE WITNESS:** Fair point. The transcript or, I guess, the notes themselves don't actually refresh my recollection. I do separately remember -- [1532:22] **THE COURT:** You've answered the question. [1532:23] Could we move on. [1532:24] **MR. COHEN:** Yes, your Honor. [1532:25] **Q.** Let's continue with what happened in June. [1533:1] Do you recall telling us, Mr. Singh, that after the discussions we have already covered there was a discussion about fixing the bug? [1533:4] **A.** Forgive me. I missed I think part of your sentence, but I do remember there being discussions about fixing the bug. [1533:6] **Q.** Just to remind us, what were those conversations about? [1533:7] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1533:8] **THE COURT:** I imagine they were about fixing the bug. Isn't that what the point was? [1533:10] **MR. COHEN:** It did occur to me, your Honor. [1533:11] **THE COURT:** Good. [1533:12] **Q.** Who was tasked with fixing the bug? [1533:13] **A.** I wasn't involved in the project, so I don't know who was tasked with it. I do know that Gary and Adam worked on it. [1533:15] **Q.** Was a document created to document what had happened with the bug fix? [1533:17] **A.** Adam wrote one. [1533:18] **Q.** Did you ever hear the term a postmortem document? [1533:19] **A.** Yes. [1533:20] **Q.** What did that refer to in this context? [1533:21] **A.** A document describing an error or like a bug and the sequence of steps taken to address it and lessons to take. [1533:23] **Q.** And did you have occasion to review the postmortem relating to the bug that Adam prepared? [1533:25] **A.** I don't think that I read it in its entirety. I did talk [1534:1] with Adam about it. [1534:2] **Q.** Did you think that the fix had been done properly? [1534:3] **A.** Yes. [1534:4] **Q.** And the postmortem referred to the fix of the $8 billion bug, correct? [1534:6] **A.** And other considerations around it. [1534:7] **Q.** Such as? [1534:8] **A.** There were identifying the exact size of the bug, had some complicated elements. Adam walked through a lot of the considerations that he and Gary had sort of thought through. Beyond talking about the fix for the bug, it talked about the mechanical process that they took to ensure it wouldn't happen again and ensure a safe migration. [1534:14] **Q.** So the technical issues that had been involved in fixing the bug and making sure it wouldn't happen again? [1534:16] **A.** Yes. [1534:17] **Q.** Did you think this was an appropriate thing for Gary and Adam to be doing? [1534:19] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1534:20] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1534:21] **Q.** Did you have a view about whether or not this memorandum should have been prepared? [1534:23] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1534:24] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1534:25] **Q.** Let's move on, Mr. Singh. [1535:1] You mentioned yesterday that there came a time when there was an attempt to split out the balance of the fiat@ account from Alameda and FTX. [1535:4] Do you recall that, sir? [1535:5] **A.** I do. [1535:6] **Q.** And when in relation to the bug fix was this? [1535:7] **A.** I believe it was after. [1535:8] **Q.** Was it after the memo we just discussed? [1535:9] **A.** I believe so, but I am not 100 percent certain. [1535:10] **Q.** Can you describe for us what steps were taken to split out the balances. [1535:12] **MR. ROOS:** Foundation. [1535:13] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1535:14] **Q.** Were you involved with this at all, Mr. Singh? [1535:15] **A.** No. [1535:16] **Q.** Did you come to learn of it? [1535:17] **A.** I came to learn that the exercise had been done. [1535:18] **Q.** Did you learn the outcome of the exercise? [1535:19] **A.** Some parts of it, yes. [1535:20] **Q.** Tell us what you learned. [1535:21] **A.** I learned that there had been an account, a new subaccount called FTX fiat old made under the info@AlamedaResearch.com main account, and that it now reflected the amounts owed by Alameda to FTX and that fiat@FTX.com now reflected the amounts that FTX owed to FTX. [1536:1] **Q.** Are you done with your answer? [1536:2] **A.** I am. [1536:3] **Q.** Did you have an understanding of the purpose of the FTX underscore fiat underscore old account? [1536:5] **A.** I inferred it. [1536:6] **Q.** What did you infer? [1536:7] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1536:8] **THE COURT:** Ground. [1536:9] **MR. ROOS:** Foundation, relevance. [1536:10] **THE COURT:** What's the relevance? [1536:11] **MR. COHEN:** The relevance is we heard about this sequence yesterday in a way designed to suggest it was done in secret and designed to keep this account from everyone. [1536:14] **MR. ROOS:** Withdrawn. [1536:15] **MR. COHEN:** I'm entitled to explore it. [1536:16] **THE COURT:** The objection is withdrawn. [1536:17] **MR. COHEN:** Can we have the question back, please. [1536:18] **THE COURT:** Yes, of course. [1536:19] (Record read) [1536:20] **A.** I inferred that it was made and separated from fiat@FTX.com to track the correct amount that Alameda owed FTX in customer fiat deposits. [1536:23] **Q.** To track it, correct? [1536:24] **A.** Correct. [1536:25] **Q.** Then there came a time when that account was moved again, [1537:1] correct? [1537:2] **A.** Yes. [1537:3] **Q.** And I believe you told us about -- I am going to pronounce this incorrectly I'm sure -- the Seoyun account. [1537:5] Do you recall that, sir? [1537:6] **A.** I do. [1537:7] **Q.** Do you have any involvement with that? [1537:8] **A.** I moved the subaccount to this Seoyun account. [1537:9] **Q.** You were the person who moved the account from FTX old to Seoyun? [1537:11] **A.** I either moved it or I asked Andrea to move it. Either way, I directed it. [1537:13] **Q.** For record purposes Andrea is Andrea Lincoln? [1537:14] **A.** Correct. [1537:15] **Q.** Who worked with Adam and Gary, correct? [1537:16] **A.** Right. [1537:17] **Q.** What was your purpose for moving it? [1537:18] **A.** I was told to. [1537:19] **Q.** Who told you? [1537:20] **A.** Sam told me to move it and a trader told me where I should move it to, such that it was still tracked. [1537:22] **Q.** I believe you referred yesterday to -- the trader was Terence Choo, is that correct? [1537:24] **A.** I think it was Terence Choo, but there is some chance it was Caroline Ellison. [1538:1] **Q.** Both Caroline and Terence worked for Alameda, correct? [1538:2] **A.** Correct. [1538:3] **Q.** In the trading group at Alameda. [1538:4] **A.** That's my understanding. [1538:5] **Q.** They advised you where to move the account, correct? [1538:6] **A.** They did. [1538:7] **Q.** Did you know why -- withdrawn. [1538:8] Did the topic of why this account, as opposed to another one, came up? [1538:10] **A.** In that I specified the parameters that I viewed as important. I specified that it shouldn't be under one of the accounts that was in consideration for how much Alameda was charged line-of-interest fees on. And I asked what is another account that you guys are tracking that isn't in that set. [1538:15] **Q.** And they provided you with the account? [1538:16] **A.** Yes. [1538:17] **MR. COHEN:** Your Honor, this might be a good time for our morning break. [1538:19] **THE COURT:** OK. 11:15, folks. [1538:20] (Recess) [1538:21] **THE COURT:** The record will reflect that the defendant and the jurors all are present, as they have been throughout. [1538:23] The witness is reminded he is still under oath. [1538:24] Mr. Cohen, you may proceed when you are ready. [1538:25] **MR. COHEN:** Thank you, your Honor. [1539:1] **Q.** New topic, Mr. Singh. [1539:2] I want to go back. Counsel covered with you some questions about certain of the code base features. [1539:4] Do you recall your testimony about that yesterday? [1539:5] **A.** Forgive me. I don't know what you mean by counsel. [1539:6] **Q.** I mean Mr. Roos. I'm sorry. [1539:7] **A.** I recall talking about code changes. [1539:8] **Q.** Let me start with allow negative. My first question is a when question. When did you first learn about the allow-negative feature? [1539:11] **A.** July 2019. [1539:12] **Q.** How did you learn about that? [1539:13] **A.** I was told to write it. I did. [1539:14] **Q.** So you were the person who put it together? [1539:15] **A.** In some sense, I wrote the code, but I was sort of given pretty clear and explicit instructions from others. [1539:17] **Q.** When you wrote it in 2019, what was the purpose of the code? [1539:19] **A.** It was to facilitate FTX admins moving FTT from designated accounts or making trades in FTT from designated accounts and to modernize an existing set of features that would allow accounting-oriented accounts to go negative. [1539:23] **Q.** Was this at all in connection with market-making functions? [1539:24] **A.** I am not sure. [1539:25] **Q.** Did there come a time that you came to believe that the [1540:1] allow-negative feature was used in connection with market-making functions? [1540:3] **A.** Yes. [1540:4] **Q.** When was that, sir? [1540:5] **A.** I don't know precisely. [1540:6] **Q.** Approximately is fine. [1540:7] **A.** 2020. [1540:8] **Q.** How did you learn of that? [1540:9] **A.** I remember a conversation I had with Gary Wang in which I was thinking about making some changes to some code related to OTC trades, and I noticed that Alameda was the only provider -- [1540:12] **Q.** Could I interrupt you for a moment, sir. Can you tell the jury what OTC trades are. [1540:14] **A.** Over the counter. I don't think that does a great job describing it. If I may. [1540:16] **Q.** Does it mean not on the exchange? [1540:17] **A.** No. [1540:18] **Q.** Tell us what you are thinking. [1540:19] **A.** It means not on an order book. So a customer could basically request -- just say I want to buy one Bitcoin. Tell me how many dollars that takes. They get back an answer. They have some time before they have to accept -- before they can -- before that sort of quote expires. They can say I accept and it happens. This is different from submitting an order on an order book. [1541:1] **Q.** Please continue. [1541:2] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. Calls for a narrative. [1541:3] **THE COURT:** Sustained. Ask a more specific question, please. [1541:5] **MR. COHEN:** Sure. [1541:6] **Q.** You were describing for us how you came to the understanding of a connection, if any, between allow negative and market making. [1541:9] **A.** As a part. [1541:10] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. I don't think there was a question. He was just describing what the witness was testifying to. [1541:13] **THE COURT:** Yes. I agree. [1541:14] **Q.** Could you tell us the basis for coming to the view, if you did, that there was a connection between the allow-negative code and market making? [1541:17] **A.** I am describing only one instance. There may have been others. Is that OK? [1541:19] **Q.** Yup. [1541:20] **A.** I was thinking about making some change, I can't recall what, to the code related to these OTC trades. I noticed that the balances of the provider, Alameda, weren't checked when accepting an OTC trade, meaning that if Alameda didn't have funds that would otherwise be necessary for making the trade, it could go through anyway. [1542:1] I asked Gary about this. This is a reflection of allow negative. And he described to me the type of situation where this seems like the right thing for the exchange to do. [1542:4] **Q.** Which was what? [1542:5] **A.** I don't know if he gave this precise example, but one comes to mind. [1542:7] **THE COURT:** Could we stick to what actually happened instead of what you think now. [1542:9] **THE WITNESS:** Fair enough. [1542:10] **A.** He gave an example. I can't remember the exact example. It seemed valid to me. [1542:12] **Q.** Let me ask you this, Mr. Singh. As a result of the allow-negative feature, was Alameda allowed to sell tokens it didn't have at the time? [1542:15] **A.** In some ways. But I have since discovered that that was -- allow negative was actually not the section of code proximately responsible for that. [1542:18] **Q.** But at the time, meaning 2019 and 2020, that's what you believed? [1542:20] **THE COURT:** Sorry. What is what he believed? [1542:21] **MR. COHEN:** That the allow negative allowed Alameda to sell coins it did not yet own. [1542:23] **A.** I don't know that I thought about it in 2019 and 2020. I expect that I was told that or thought about it in 2021 and certainly at least in one instance in 2022. [1543:1] **Q.** In 2019, 2020, when you were working on the code, did you have a view about whether it permitted Alameda to purchase newly issued tokens? [1543:4] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1543:5] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1543:6] **Q.** Did you ever have a view about -- let me back up. [1543:7] Did you participate, Mr. Singh -- let me back up. [1543:8] Do you have an understanding of what it is to issue a token? [1543:10] **A.** I have some understanding. [1543:11] **Q.** Why don't you tell us that. [1543:12] **A.** I am not sure I know that I am talking about what you are. Can you specify a little more what you mean? [1543:14] **Q.** Sure. Do exchanges sometimes issue tokens? [1543:15] **A.** Can you specify even further? [1543:16] **Q.** For example, Binance issued BNB. Are you familiar with that? [1543:18] **A.** Yes. [1543:19] **Q.** And if Binance was issuing BNB or some similar token and a customer on Alameda wanted to buy at the issuance, would they be able to? [1543:22] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. Foundation. [1543:23] **THE COURT:** Yes. I think you have to lay a foundation for that. [1543:25] **Q.** Based on your experience as the author of the [1544:1] allow-negative feature in the code, are you familiar with whether those features had anything to do with Alameda's ability to buy newly issued tokens? [1544:4] **A.** At the time I wrote the feature, I don't think I had anything relating to buying tokens. [1544:6] **Q.** I meant selling tokens. [1544:7] **A.** Even that. That was not the purpose that I was told it was made for. [1544:9] **Q.** We talked yesterday about stablecoins. [1544:10] Do you recall that, sir? [1544:11] **A.** Yes. [1544:12] **Q.** In your experience as the author of the allow-negative feature, did it have any impact on Alameda's ability to purchase stablecoins? [1544:15] **A.** No. [1544:16] **Q.** Did it have any impact on stablecoins at all? [1544:17] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. Vague. [1544:18] **THE COURT:** Overruled. [1544:19] **A.** The feature changed nothing about Alameda's interaction with stablecoins. [1544:21] **Q.** Did it have any effect at all? [1544:22] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1544:23] **THE COURT:** Asked and answered. [1544:24] **Q.** Let me ask you this, Mr. Singh. It is going to take me a moment to pronounce this. Have you ever heard of a term called [1545:1] auto de-leveraging event? [1545:2] **A.** Yes. [1545:3] **Q.** What's that? [1545:4] **A.** It may take me a moment to explain. Is that OK? [1545:5] **Q.** That's fine. [1545:6] **A.** In the context of FTX, some liquidations were performed off market, which is to say an account that didn't have sufficient collateral to support its positions would enter liquidation. And, if it was getting close enough to being under water, those positions would be closed out or traded against designated backstop liquidity providers, as opposed to selling those positions in the market so it can be done more quickly. [1545:13] Those backstop liquidity providers could continue to absorb these trades, as in act as the counterparty to these liquidations, so long as they met a few conditions. [1545:16] If those conditions weren't met for any backstop liquidity providers for a given liquidation instance, then FTX enacted auto de-leveraging. This is not code I wrote, so I'm not super familiar, but my understanding of what this is is that it's essentially like picking other users that have not explicitly opted in being backstop liquidity providers to perform the same role for the sake of that liquidation. [1546:1] BY MR. COHEN: [1546:2] **Q.** Let me see if I can just break this down. [1546:3] You said that this situation arose when an account was in danger or at risk of being closed out. Can you explain what you mean by that. [1546:6] **A.** Accounts were liquidated, under some circumstances; some liquidations could result in ADL events. [1546:8] **Q.** Okay. And by closed out, is this what we were talking about——well, let me rephrase. [1546:10] This means a customer has a position in an account and a certain amount of collateral and the value of the position starts to fall sufficiently that the——that that——actually, I forgot to ask you one more thing. [1546:14] Have you ever heard the term "risk engine"? [1546:15] **A.** Yeah. [1546:16] **Q.** Okay. Did FTX have a risk engine? [1546:17] **A.** Yeah. [1546:18] **Q.** How did that——what was that? [1546:19] **A.** A lot of things that went into it, I suppose. Do you mind clarifying some more. [1546:21] **Q.** Did the risk engine have anything to do with closing out positions? [1546:23] **A.** Right. Liquidations were a part of the risk engine. [1546:24] **Q.** Okay. And so if the risk engine, which was basically computer run, noticed that an account was going below its [1547:1] collateral limit, it would step in and liquidate that account, correct? [1547:3] **A.** That's almost right. If it noticed that it had insufficient collateral to support its positions. There was not a collateral limit at play. [1547:6] **Q.** So it would go into the customer's account and sell the positions to get it back in balance, correct? [1547:8] **A.** That's not exactly how I'd put it. [1547:9] **Q.** How would you put it, sir? [1547:10] **A.** That the liquidation engine would sell, or buy, close out their positions, because the customer could be long or short. [1547:12] **Q.** Okay. And then you referenced something called a backstop liquidity provider. What was that? [1547:14] **A.** Designated accounts were used as the counterparties for some of the trades that were required to close out these positions. [1547:17] **Q.** And was Alameda a backstop liquidity provider? [1547:18] **A.** It was. [1547:19] **Q.** Were other entities backstop liquidity providers? [1547:20] **A.** Over time there were many. [1547:21] **Q.** So if the engine was closing out an individual customer's account and there weren't sufficient assets, the backstop liquidity provider would step in, correct? [1547:24] **A.** It didn't depend on if there were insufficient assets. The customer would be getting liquidated because they had [1548:1] insufficient assets. [1548:2] **Q.** And if that were the case, then the backstop liquidity provider would step in. [1548:4] **A.** Right, under some further conditions. [1548:5] **Q.** Okay. And what would happen if the backstop liquidity providers didn't themselves have sufficient collateral? [1548:7] **A.** If none of them did——this would be one criterion for eligibility of a backstop to match against this liquidation. If there were no such eligible backstop liquidity providers, then the system would perform ADLs, or auto-deleveraging fills. [1548:11] **Q.** What did that mean? [1548:12] **A.** It meant——this area I'm a little uncertain about because I didn't write the code, but I believe it's that it selected other customers to perform the same role that the backstop liquidity providers would have, and serve as counterparties to the liquidation trade. [1548:17] **Q.** Okay. So if customer A had an account that was going into liquidity——liquidation and that account had insufficient assets, the next stage would be the backstop liquidity providers, correct? [1548:21] **A.** Sorry. Could you repeat that. [1548:22] **Q.** Sure. If the——I want to see if we can make this a little bit more concrete for the jury. [1548:24] So if customer A had an account that was being liquidated and had insufficient assets, I believe you told us [1549:1] the next step would be to take it the level of the backstop liquidity providers. [1549:3] **A.** It's getting liquidated because it has insufficient assets. [1549:4] **Q.** Correct. [1549:5] **A.** So in getting liquidated, it may go and get——it may enter a mode in which it will be liquidated against backstop liquidity providers. [1549:8] **Q.** Correct. And then I think you told us that if they, the backstop liquidity providers, had insufficient assets, we'd have an auto-deleveraging event? [1549:11] **A.** There were multiple conditions that could lead to a backstop being ineligible. One of them is that they had insufficient assets. If that——if those conditions are met for all backstop liquidity providers, then the system would enact ADLs. [1549:16] **Q.** And that would mean the in——the account would be covered by the assets of other customers on the exchange. [1549:18] **A.** Not quite. [1549:19] **Q.** Okay. Tell us quite. [1549:20] **A.** There is not an exchange of value. There's a very small exchange of value in a liquidation trade. It's not that——it's not that the liquidating account is underwater and therefore needs to get topped up by other customers. It's that——it's that they have positions on that are risky that need to be handed off to other customers. Those other customers, be them [1550:1] backstop liquidity providers or those selected by ADL, receive the positions at slightly better than market value, being that in that moment they actually make some money. It's not that they're giving up their collateral for it, but they are taking on risk that they did not themselves put on. [1550:6] **Q.** Right. So using our example now, customer B or customer C or so forth, in your words, are having positions handed off to them. [1550:9] **A.** Yes. [1550:10] **Q.** And they're going to get them at a favorable price, but they themselves are now at risk, correct? [1550:12] **A.** Right. But it may turn favorable quickly. [1550:13] **Q.** Let me call your attention to July of 2020. Did FTX experience an auto-deleveraging event? [1550:15] **A.** I recall it——I recall one around early August, so it's possible that this one was in July. [1550:17] **Q.** Okay. Why don't you tell us what happened. [1550:18] **MR. ROOS:** Objection, foundation. [1550:19] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1550:20] **Q.** Okay. What do you recall about the auto-deleveraging event that took place in July or August of 2020? [1550:22] **A.** I recall that it happened that there were ADL fills for what I think was the first time in FTX's existence, meaning that the——forgive me, I'm using the abbreviation, or the acronym——the ADL system had kicked in, which meant that there [1551:1] were no——there was a point at which there was a liquidation and there were no eligible backstop providers. [1551:3] **Q.** So it went to the next level, to the customer level. [1551:4] **A.** Right. [1551:5] **Q.** Correct. Were you aware if FTX had any response to this? [1551:6] **A.** Yes. [1551:7] **Q.** What was it, sir? [1551:8] **A.** I don't remember everything about it, but I can describe some things that I talked about with Sam and Gary—— [1551:10] **Q.** Just describe what you remember. [1551:11] **A.** It was undesirable for customers to take on these positions without opting in, basically being ADL recipients, all else equal. All else equal, this probably——this sort of universe of FTX customers and FTX itself would have preferred that it go to the designated backstop providers. Gary dug into why it was the case that there were no eligible providers. Gary determined that it was because, among other things, Alameda was not eligible and that Alameda was not eligible because its free collateral was zero and that the reason that its free collateral was zero was not because it had a bunch of positions but because it had tons and tons of open orders out——open orders for the purpose of providing liquidity on the hundreds of markets or so. Those exhaust collateral. [1551:24] **Q.** You said that having this auto-deleveraging event was undesirable. What did you mean by that? [1552:1] **A.** It's my opinion. I don't know if I can sort of claim that there's a higher level truth to it being undesirable or not. [1552:3] **Q.** Well, you just said it. I'm just trying to get at what you meant by it. [1552:5] **A.** Yeah, forgive me. I was clarifying. My opinion, and the opinion espoused by Sam and Gary at the time, was that having random customers take on the——these positions and have them handed off to them is worse than having designated customers take them on. [1552:10] **Q.** Okay. To your knowledge, Mr. Singh, was anything done in response to the auto-deleveraging event? [1552:12] **A.** Yes. [1552:13] **Q.** What was that? [1552:14] **A.** So Gary inferred that it was because——a cause was that Alameda was putting out a ton of orders and therefore had low collateral, had zero free collateral, but free for the——for the purposes of placing more orders or accepting trades, not free in the sense if they were to be liquidated, because there's an assumption that orders can be canceled upon liquidation, which would have just them getting a lot of collateral back. [1552:21] **THE COURT:** You used the term pre collateral or free collateral. Would you explain that. [1552:23] **THE WITNESS:** Free collateral. [1552:24] **THE COURT:** First of all, was it pre collateral or free collateral? [1553:1] **THE WITNESS:** Free collateral. Free meaning available. [1553:3] **THE COURT:** Okay. [1553:4] **A.** Customers——to clarify that, customers in FTX deposited collateral. Collateral would be exhausted or, you know, made not free by putting on positions or by having open orders out on markets that, you know, were liable if traded against to create positions. [1553:9] The latter thing, open orders, were primarily responsible, as Gary told me, for Alameda having zero free collateral at the time of the liquidation that caused the ADLs. [1553:12] I believe you asked me what happened. [1553:13] **Q.** I did. And were any steps taken with respect to the code base upon that determination? [1553:15] **A.** Yes. [1553:16] **Q.** What was that? [1553:17] **A.** I think at first I added some alerts in the section of the code that would basically emit if Alameda had or others had zero free collateral, and if that was actually the cause, such that in the next instance if this happened, we had some more debugging visibility. We did, and it showed zero free collateral. It was talked about——but I don't remember if it actually happened——increasing Alameda's line of credit, because increasing it increases their free collateral. Lines of credit directly increased collateral and therefore free collateral. [1554:1] **Q.** And——I'm sorry. Finish your answer if you're not done. [1554:2] **A.** Ultimately, Sam asked me why would it depend at all on free collateral if Alameda is just going to exhaust it all in open orders, and we know that the open orders aren't themselves risky, but not consuming collateral in the same way that having to position does, then why don't we, for Alameda, just remove the condition that we attend to its free collateral when determining if it's an eligible backstop provider for a liquidation. [1554:10] **Q.** And was that condition removed? [1554:11] **A.** Yes. [1554:12] **Q.** That meant in an auto-deleveraging situation Alameda could again step in and be another source of capital. [1554:14] **A.** It meant——correct. Specifically, the difference is that if the sole cause of Alameda being an ineligible backstop provider was that it didn't have enough free collateral, that was no longer considered. [1554:18] **Q.** And in your view, Mr. Singh, would that be helpful to customers? [1554:20] **A.** Yes. [1554:21] **Q.** Why? [1554:22] **A.** In my view at the time, it would be helpful to customers. [1554:23] **Q.** Why? [1554:24] **A.** Because it would prevent the undesirable ADL as opposed to backstop fills. [1555:1] **Q.** Did you ever hear the term "code commits"? [1555:2] **A.** Yes. [1555:3] **Q.** What does that mean to you? [1555:4] **A.** A code commit is a package change of code submitted to a code base. [1555:6] **Q.** Did you ever author code commits? [1555:7] **A.** All the time. [1555:8] **Q.** Okay. And were they——were these like notes you made for other developers to see? [1555:10] **A.** There were elements of the code commits that were. [1555:11] **MR. COHEN:** If we could call up for the witness——witness only——DX 1102. [1555:13] Pursuant to Defense Exhibit S-3002, it's been stipulated that this document—— [1555:15] **THE COURT:** I'm sorry. DX 3002? [1555:16] **MR. COHEN:** Yes, that's the stipulation as to the authenticity of this document. [1555:18] BY MR. COHEN: [1555:19] **Q.** Mr. Singh, can you take a moment and take a look at what's been marked as Defense Exhibit 1102. [1555:21] **A.** I see it. And forgive me. This isn't what you asked, but—— [1555:23] **THE COURT:** Just a minute. [1555:24] **THE WITNESS:** Yes. [1555:25] **THE COURT:** You stick to answering the questions that [1556:1] are asked, okay? [1556:2] **THE WITNESS:** Okay. [1556:3] **MR. COHEN:** I think we've worked it out, your Honor. [1556:4] **THE COURT:** What have you worked out? [1556:5] **MR. ROOS:** I was just asking Mr. Cohen if it's just this page. I couldn't tell. And assuming it's just this page, no objection. [1556:8] **THE COURT:** Well, first of all, is 3002 being offered? [1556:9] **MR. COHEN:** 3002 is the stipulation, your Honor. [1556:10] **THE COURT:** Yes, but has it been offered? [1556:11] **MR. COHEN:** We offer 3002. [1556:12] **THE COURT:** Received. [1556:13] (Defendant's Exhibit S-3002 received in evidence) [1556:14] **THE COURT:** Now what about this 1102? [1556:15] **MR. COHEN:** Your Honor—— [1556:16] **THE COURT:** Let's get the first question answered. Is it a one-page document? [1556:18] **MR. COHEN:** It is not. [1556:19] **THE COURT:** It is not. [1556:20] **MR. COHEN:** It is not. We would like to offer page 1 and page 18, pursuant to the stipulation. [1556:22] **MR. ROOS:** No objection to 1. And if we could just see 18. [1556:24] No objection, to those two pages. [1556:25] **THE COURT:** Pages 1 and 18 of Defendant's 1102 are [1557:1] received. [1557:2] (Defendant's Exhibit 1102 (pages 1 and 18 only) received in evidence) [1557:4] **MR. COHEN:** Can we publish those to the jury, your Honor. [1557:6] **THE COURT:** You may. [1557:7] **MR. COHEN:** Brian, could you call them up, please. [1557:8] BY MR. COHEN: [1557:9] **Q.** All right. Let's start with page 1, Mr. Singh. Is this an example of a code commit, the top of page 1? [1557:11] **A.** Yes, this is one representation of a code commit. [1557:12] **Q.** So if you look at the—— [1557:13] **MR. COHEN:** Brian, if you could call out the top paragraph. [1557:15] **Q.** Okay. So this one, for example, is author Gary Wang, date May 23rd, "add borrow column to balances." What's your understanding of what this means? [1557:18] **A.** Forgive me. What do you mean by "this"? [1557:19] **Q.** My question is simply: Is this an example of a type of code commit? [1557:21] **THE COURT:** Asked and answered. [1557:22] **Q.** Okay. Let's go to page 18. [1557:23] Okay. If we could go to the top, the top box. We've been talking about the period of August 2020 and the auto-deleveraging event, and there's a line that says, "Author: [1558:1] Nishadsingh1." Is that you, sir? [1558:2] **A.** That's me. [1558:3] **Q.** And there's an entry that says "address ADLs (#977)." Do you see that, sir? [1558:5] **A.** I see it. [1558:6] **Q.** What did that refer to? [1558:7] **A.** A little easier if——I could be more confident if I read the corresponding code, but I assume this is one of the two changes I discussed so far——there were others——about making ADLs less likely. [1558:11] **Q.** Okay. And continuing on the page. [1558:12] **MR. COHEN:** If we go down to the next box. Go down further. Okay. Call that out. [1558:14] **Q.** This is another code commit written by you, sir? [1558:15] **A.** Yes. [1558:16] **Q.** Okay. And it says, "be extra careful not to liquidate PMM, clean up messages." Do you see that, sir? [1558:18] **A.** I do. [1558:19] **Q.** Okay. What's a PMM? [1558:20] **A.** The primary market maker, which meant Alameda. [1558:21] **Q.** Okay. Because at the time it was the main market maker for FTX, correct? [1558:23] **A.** PMM is also how the code referred to that. [1558:24] **Q.** And what did you mean by "be extra careful not to liquidate"? [1559:1] **A.** I think answering this requires me continuing the story of what happened in response to ADLs. [1559:3] **Q.** Go ahead. [1559:4] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1559:5] **THE COURT:** What's the objection? [1559:6] **MR. ROOS:** Calls for a narrative. [1559:7] **THE COURT:** Yes. We have to take a very short break in any case. [1559:9] **MR. COHEN:** Oh, okay. [1559:10] **THE COURT:** I think ten minutes ought to be enough. [1559:11] **THE DEPUTY CLERK:** Would the jury please come this way. [1560:1] (Jury not present) [1560:2] **THE COURT:** Be seated, folks. [1560:3] So you have something to take care of that was discussed earlier today. This is the time. [1560:5] **MR. COHEN:** Okay. Thank you, your Honor. [1560:6] (Recess) [1560:7] (In open court; jury not present) [1560:8] **THE COURT:** Mr. Roos, the point you wanted to take up at some point, the evidence issues, how long do we need for that? [1560:11] **MR. ROOS:** Ten minutes. [1560:12] **THE COURT:** All right. We'll do it after we send the jury to lunch. [1560:14] **MR. ROOS:** Okay. [1560:15] **THE COURT:** Okay. Let's go. [1561:1] (Jury present) [1561:2] **THE COURT:** The record will reflect that the defendant and the jurors all are present, as they have been throughout. [1561:4] You may continue, Mr. Cohen. [1561:5] **MR. COHEN:** Thank you, your Honor. [1561:6] If we could bring up the exhibit we were just looking at. [1561:8] BY MR. COHEN: [1561:9] **Q.** And these are more general questions, Mr. Singh. [1561:10] As a general matter, who at FTX was able to access these codes, these codes we were looking at? The code commits. Excuse me. [1561:13] **MR. ROOS:** Objection, foundation. [1561:14] **THE COURT:** Yes. You need one. [1561:15] **MR. COHEN:** Hmm? [1561:16] **THE COURT:** Foundation. [1561:17] **MR. COHEN:** Sure. [1561:18] **Q.** Based on your experience as head of engineering at FTX, did you have an understanding of who might access the code commits we were just looking at? [1561:21] **A.** They were available to the whole company in Slack, if nothing else. There were Slack logs of all the messages. [1561:23] **Q.** Okay. Let me ask you another general question. From the FTX side, based on your experience as the head of engineering, who could have access; who could observe Alameda's accounts on [1562:1] FTX? [1562:2] **MR. ROOS:** Objection, same foundation. [1562:3] **THE COURT:** Yes, sustained. [1562:4] **Q.** Mr. Singh, based on your experience as the head of engineering, did you have an understanding about accessing customer accounts on the exchange, viewing customer accounts on the exchange? [1562:8] **MR. ROOS:** Same objection. [1562:9] **THE COURT:** Yes. Look, this isn't a matter of opinion. He either knows or he doesn't know. [1562:11] **MR. COHEN:** Yeah. [1562:12] **Q.** Did you know, Mr. Singh, whether you could see the Alameda accounts on the FTX exchange? [1562:14] **A.** Whether I personally could? [1562:15] **Q.** Yes. [1562:16] **A.** Yes, I could. [1562:17] **Q.** How were you able to do that? [1562:18] **A.** The way any other FTX staff member could, using the admin portal. [1562:20] **Q.** Okay. And the admin portal was a portal on FTX? [1562:21] **A.** Yes. [1562:22] **Q.** So for an FTX person to look at customer accounts and balances, so forth. [1562:24] **A.** That was not the purpose. [1562:25] **Q.** What was the purpose? [1563:1] **A.** Customer support reasons might require looking at a customer's—— [1563:3] **Q.** Understood, understood, understood. But in addition to that, it allowed the FTX side to look at the customer accounts. [1563:5] **A.** Yes. [1563:6] **Q.** Okay. Let's move to another topic, Mr. Singh. [1563:7] Did you ever hear of an entity called FTX US Derivatives? [1563:9] **A.** Yes. [1563:10] **Q.** What was that? [1563:11] **A.** A company that used to be named LedgerX, I believe. [1563:12] **Q.** And what business was LedgerX in? [1563:13] **A.** It operated crypto options. [1563:14] **Q.** And let me back up. Do you know who ran LedgerX? [1563:15] **A.** Zach Dexter in the period that I was aware of. [1563:16] **Q.** And just to set a foundation, what period was that? [1563:17] **A.** 2021 and 2022. [1563:18] **Q.** Did there come a time that FTX acquired LedgerX, if you know? [1563:20] **A.** Yes. [1563:21] **Q.** About when was that? [1563:22] **A.** Also sometime in '21 or '22. [1563:23] **THE COURT:** Before or after Zach Dexter was running it? [1563:25] **THE WITNESS:** I believe after. [1564:1] **Q.** And did Mr. Dexter continue to run the company even after it was acquired, or run what used to be LedgerX? [1564:3] **A.** That's my belief, but I have no firsthand knowledge. [1564:4] **Q.** Okay. Now Mr. Dexter, he was not a founder of FTX, correct? [1564:6] **A.** He wasn't. [1564:7] **Q.** He was not a founder of Alameda, correct? [1564:8] **A.** Correct. [1564:9] **Q.** Okay. What did FTX US Derivatives's trading platform deal in, if you know? [1564:11] **A.** Forgive me. Are you referencing the potential integration into FTX.US or what Zach Dexter's existing company did? [1564:13] **Q.** Integration. [1564:14] **A.** The integration would support futures to be offered to US customers, pending approval. [1564:16] **Q.** And you said pending approval. What did you mean by that, sir? [1564:18] **A.** There was some regulatory process they were engaging in to get approval to list these futures. [1564:20] **Q.** Do you know what entity they were seeking to get approval from? [1564:22] **A.** At least the CFTC and maybe others. [1564:23] **Q.** And I believe you told us yesterday that the CFTC was the commodities trading commission, I think was how you put it. [1564:25] **A.** Yeah. Forgive me. I don't remember——I don't know exactly [1565:1] what it is, but—— [1565:2] **Q.** Did you, Mr. Singh, have any involvement with this process of trying to get approval? [1565:4] **A.** I believe I described yesterday the only part that I participated in. [1565:6] **Q.** What was that? [1565:7] **A.** It was Zach Dexter——it was me fulfilling Zach Dexter's request to show Alameda's historical collateral and collateral needs in their main account. [1565:10] **Q.** And for this application for approval, did the topic of how liquidations were handled at FTX come up? [1565:12] **MR. ROOS:** Objection, foundation. [1565:13] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1565:14] **Q.** Did you know, sir, based on your interactions with Mr. Dexter, what topics came up in connection with the application for approval? [1565:17] **MR. ROOS:** Same, and calls for hearsay answer. [1565:18] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1565:19] **Q.** Did you have occasion, Mr. Singh, to review any materials in connection with the application? [1565:21] **A.** There was at least one point in September of 2022 when Zach Dexter sent me an excerpt from the application. [1565:23] **Q.** What did that excerpt refer to? [1565:24] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1565:25] **THE COURT:** Ground. [1566:1] **MR. ROOS:** Hearsay. [1566:2] **Q.** What was the topic of the—— [1566:3] **A.** Special privileges for Alameda. [1566:4] **Q.** And did you review that, sir? [1566:5] **A.** I responded to it, yes. [1566:6] **Q.** And you responded to Mr. Dexter. [1566:7] **A.** Yes. [1566:8] **Q.** What was the nature of the response? [1566:9] **MR. ROOS:** Objection, hearsay. [1566:10] **THE COURT:** Why not, Mr. Cohen? [1566:11] **MR. COHEN:** It's for the effect on the listener, your Honor. [1566:13] **THE COURT:** On Mr. Dexter? [1566:14] **MR. COHEN:** No. Excuse me. It's for Mr. Singh's state of mind. [1566:16] **MR. ROOS:** Relevance. [1566:17] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1566:18] **MR. COHEN:** Hmm? [1566:19] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1566:20] **MR. COHEN:** I'm sorry. Okay. [1566:21] **THE COURT:** 401 and 403. [1566:22] BY MR. COHEN: [1566:23] **Q.** Oh, let me go back. I meant to ask you: You testified yesterday about Alameda's line of credit. Do you recall that, sir? [1567:1] **A.** Yes. [1567:2] **Q.** And I think you told us that the line of credit at some point was set to $65 billion, correct? [1567:4] **A.** I believe that was its value at the time of the collapse. [1567:5] **Q.** Did you have any experience in understanding the amount of——amount that was actually drawn down on the letter of credit? [1567:8] **A.** I calculated how much the main account was drawing on. [1567:9] **Q.** When did you do that, sir? [1567:10] **A.** I believe it was early September. [1567:11] **Q.** Okay. That was my question. Prior to that point, prior to September, were you involved with any calculations of the actual drawdowns on the letter of credit? [1567:14] **A.** In a way. [1567:15] **Q.** What do you mean by that? [1567:16] **A.** There was an exercise I believe sometime in 2021 to write code that would charge Alameda on one definition of its used line of credit. I made modifications to it after Gary wrote it. [1567:20] **Q.** What modifications did you make? [1567:21] **A.** I can't remember all of them. One of them was including more forms of collateral that Sam had proposed. [1567:23] **Q.** Okay. Yes or no: In connection with that modification you worked on, did you come to learn about the usage of the line of credit prior to September 2022? [1568:1] **A.** In the sense that it matched the definition used by this line of interest processor. [1568:3] **Q.** Did you come to learn the number, the value, the balances used? [1568:5] **A.** I remember——I remember one of the——indirectly. [1568:6] **Q.** What do you mean by that? [1568:7] **A.** I remember the revenue associated with this, with these fees, and I knew the rate that Alameda was charged on its used line of credit. Dividing one by the other suggests what the used line of credit was. [1568:11] **Q.** And what was it? [1568:12] **A.** I recall at some point it being $2 billion because they were charged one basis point. [1568:14] **Q.** Okay. [1568:15] **A.** And the daily revenue from them was $200,000. [1568:16] **Q.** And approximately when did you do that analysis? [1568:17] **A.** Would have been mid or late '21. [1568:18] **Q.** New topic, Mr. Singh. You testified about an adjustment involving something called EcoSerum. Do you recall that, sir? [1568:20] **A.** Are you referring to the Serum staking fees? [1568:21] **Q.** Yes. [1568:22] **A.** I recall that. [1568:23] **Q.** Okay. And rather than me trying to summarize it, why don't you tell us what you testified to about that. [1568:25] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1569:1] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1569:2] **Q.** Okay. Mr. Singh, didn't you tell us yesterday that you were asked to look at the staking fees, for Serum? [1569:4] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. Misstates his testimony. [1569:5] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1569:6] **Q.** Okay. Mr. Singh, let me back up. [1569:7] What are staking services, Mr. Singh? [1569:8] **A.** I can describe what Serum staking was in the context of FTX. [1569:10] **Q.** That would be fine. [1569:11] **A.** Serum was a token. It was available on FTX in both locked and unlocked forms. FTX supported staking facility in which customers could designate their Serum balances as staked, which would make them unsellable but would, on an hourly or daily cadence——that changed over time——reward them with some interest, also paid out in either Serum or locked Serum. This mirrored a lot of staking behaviors of other coins on——in various other contexts. [1569:19] **Q.** Did FTX charge a——receive any payment for these services? [1569:20] **A.** Only in the sense that I doctored them. [1569:21] **Q.** Well, in your experience you said this was——this took place on other exchanges as well. In your experience did other exchanges receive payment for providing staking services? [1569:24] **MR. ROOS:** Objection, foundation. [1569:25] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1570:1] **MR. COHEN:** He just said it. [1570:2] **Q.** Okay. Mr. Singh, did you have experience with other exchanges and their——whether or not they charged for staking services? [1570:5] **A.** I had experience with some elements of other exchanges. I do not have experience with other exchanges' staking services. [1570:7] **Q.** Now I believe you testified that Mr. Bankman-Fried directed you to backdate the Serum staking services document, correct? [1570:9] **A.** No. [1570:10] **Q.** Okay. Tell us. [1570:11] **A.** Forgive me. Tell us what? [1570:12] **Q.** You said no, so I don't want to get your testimony incorrect. What was your testimony, Mr. Singh? [1570:14] **A.** Sam instructed me to backdate the payments. I didn't know anything about the document. [1570:16] **Q.** But that ultimately did not take place, correct? [1570:17] **A.** Sorry. What didn't take place? [1570:18] **Q.** You ended up not doing the backdated transaction, correct? [1570:19] **A.** No, I did. I backdated them. [1570:20] **Q.** Okay. But you said you're not aware of the document, correct? [1570:22] **A.** I'm not a——there was a document shown yesterday relating to an agreement between EcoSerum and FTX. That was not a document that I had seen until after the collapse of FTX. [1570:25] **Q.** Let's turn to a new topic, Mr. Singh. [1571:1] I believe you testified yesterday that there came a time that you got involved in political spending, correct? [1571:3] **A.** Yes. [1571:4] **Q.** Okay. About when was that? [1571:5] **A.** In 2018, I became really excited about Prop 12 in California. [1571:7] **Q.** And as a result of that, did you make any donations? [1571:8] **A.** I did in that I believe I deducted from my floating balance at Alameda so Alameda would pay——like, would donate it. [1571:10] **Q.** Okay. And turning to later in time, 2021 or so, did there come a time that you started to make donations in much larger amounts? [1571:13] **A.** Yes. [1571:14] **Q.** Okay. And I believe you told us that the process was that——well, is it fair to say that you wanted to make donations but you didn't want to be in the weeds with respect to the process? [1571:18] **A.** For some of them. [1571:19] **Q.** Okay. Which ones? [1571:20] **A.** I——it's hard for me to enumerate them all. [1571:21] **Q.** Okay. Is it fair to say that in terms of your political donations, you worked with various political consultants? [1571:23] **A.** Sam and Gabe and Barbara. [1571:24] **Q.** Did you also work with someone named Michael Sadowsky? [1571:25] **A.** Yes. [1572:1] **Q.** And Keenan Lantz? [1572:2] **A.** Yes. [1572:3] **Q.** Okay. And Gabe was Mr. Bankman-Fried's brother? [1572:4] **A.** Yes. [1572:5] **Q.** And he was a friend of yours from high school. [1572:6] **A.** Dear friend. [1572:7] **Q.** Right. And you worked with him in terms of political——political spending, correct? [1572:9] **A.** Yes. [1572:10] **Q.** You said you engaged him as a consultant, correct? [1572:11] **A.** I don't think I said that, but I did. [1572:12] **Q.** You did. In fact, you signed a——or you entered into a written consulting agreement with him, correct? [1572:14] **A.** Yes. [1572:15] **Q.** And Mr. Sadowsky was also an experienced political consultant, correct? [1572:17] **A.** I don't know his experience. [1572:18] **Q.** Okay. Well, did you believe he was in that field? [1572:19] **A.** Yes. [1572:20] **Q.** Okay. What about Mr. Lantz? [1572:21] **A.** I don't——I don't know if I knew anything about Keenan Lantz's background. [1572:23] **Q.** Okay. And the process was, at least with respect where the consultants were involved, that they would make recommendations to you about where to make donations and you would decide [1573:1] whether you wanted to make them, correct? [1573:2] **A.** There were many different processes. [1573:3] **Q.** All right. Well, why don't you go through each one if there was more than one. [1573:5] **A.** It will take some time. [1573:6] **Q.** Why don't you just go through them by topic. [1573:7] **THE COURT:** I'm sorry. By topic? [1573:8] **MR. COHEN:** Yeah. I don't want to have to have the witness give a long narrative. [1573:10] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1573:11] **THE COURT:** Ask a question. [1573:12] **MR. COHEN:** I will. Okay. [1573:13] BY MR. COHEN: [1573:14] **Q.** Were there times, sir, when you would receive a communication from Mr. Sadowsky about a contribution he suggested you make? [1573:17] **A.** I can't remember if it was Sadowsky or Gabe, but there were times when I did receive communications from them about donations they'd want me to make. [1573:20] **Q.** And then you would tell them whether you wanted to make them or not, correct? [1573:22] **A.** In some cases. [1573:23] **Q.** Okay. Well, why don't we take a look at——one moment. [1573:24] Why don't we take a look at GX 477, please, in evidence. [1574:1] Do you recall this document, sir? [1574:2] **A.** I do. [1574:3] **Q.** Okay. This is a chain between you and Mr. Sadowsky, correct? [1574:5] **A.** It is. [1574:6] **Q.** And the blue section at the top is your writing, correct, or your comment? [1574:8] **A.** Yes. [1574:9] **Q.** So you were saying to Mr. Sadowsky that you were averse to "explicitly woke stuff." What did you mean by that? [1574:11] **A.** I preferred not to be giving to causes that were explicitly far on the left. [1574:13] **Q.** Okay. But then you go on to say, "but if it's especially good or if it's hard to interact productively with Democrats without that, I understand." Do you see that, sir? [1574:16] **A.** I do. [1574:17] **Q.** Okay. And if we could scroll down to the next page. [1574:18] And in the gray is Mr. Sadowsky's responses, right? [1574:19] **A.** Right. [1574:20] **Q.** Okay. And the bottom of the page, he says, so——at the bottom, second from the bottom here, "So if you're not comfortable about it, you should think about that a lot." "You should think about how comfortable you're going to be with it." Do you see that, sir? [1574:25] **A.** I do. [1575:1] **Q.** Mr. Sadowsky was telling you that if you weren't comfortable with that donation, you didn't have to make it. [1575:3] **A.** I'm not sure if that's what he was saying. [1575:4] **Q.** Are you saying that Mr. Sadowsky was telling you to make donations you didn't want to make? [1575:6] **A.** I think when he says it here, it may be in reference to me being the centralized face of their spending and not specifically this donation. [1575:9] **Q.** Okay. And in reference to that, if you didn't want to be the central face of the spending, you didn't have to, correct? [1575:11] **A.** Not clear to me he's saying I didn't have to. [1575:12] **Q.** Okay. In your view, did you feel that you were required to be the face of the political spending? [1575:14] **A.** Not required. [1575:15] **Q.** Okay. All right. So you told us also about a chat you were on called Donation Processing. Do you recall that, sir? [1575:17] **A.** I do. [1575:18] **Q.** And that was a chat involving someone named Ryan Salame? [1575:19] **A.** Yes. [1575:20] **Q.** And again, who was he? [1575:21] **A.** He went by many titles, among them CEO of FTX digital markets. [1575:23] **Q.** Okay. And prior to that he had been at Alameda, correct? [1575:24] **A.** Maybe concurrent with that. [1575:25] **Q.** And I believe you said that this was a Signal chat called [1576:1] Donation Processing, correct? [1576:2] **A.** Correct. [1576:3] **Q.** And the way it would work is Mr. Salame would prepare a wire transfer, correct, to a political candidate? [1576:5] **A.** That was part of what was coordinated in that thread, yes. [1576:6] **Q.** And in that thread it would be presented to you for you to approve or not, correct? [1576:8] **A.** I would be pinged to click OK in my email. [1576:9] **Q.** And if you didn't click OK, it wouldn't be sent. [1576:10] **A.** In some sense. [1576:11] **Q.** In some sense. So you're saying that donations were made without you clicking yes. [1576:13] **A.** Many of them were. [1576:14] **Q.** Okay. And the ones in the queue, in the donation processing queue. [1576:16] **A.** Yes. [1576:17] **Q.** Okay. So you're saying that when Mr. Salame pinged you to okay the donation, that was unnecessary? [1576:19] **THE COURT:** That's not what he said. They pinged him with wire transfers. [1576:21] **THE WITNESS:** Right. [1576:22] **Q.** So are you saying that wire transfers would go out of your account without you responding to the pings you received from Mr. Salame? [1576:25] **A.** I think ones of some sizes would, and not all donations [1577:1] using my name were done in this manner anyway. [1577:2] **Q.** Well, on the ones in the donation——in the Donation Processing chat, that's what I'm asking about now. [1577:4] **A.** There were ones discussed in that chat that did not go through my PrimePlus bank account and did not require me to click OK. [1577:7] **Q.** Now the funds that you received to make political donations, they were loans to you, correct? [1577:9] **A.** In a loose sense, some of them were loans. [1577:10] **Q.** Well, didn't you feel that you were obligated to pay them back, sir? [1577:12] **A.** That is a loose sense in which I felt that they were——might have been loans. [1577:14] **Q.** Well, you were either obligated to pay them back or you weren't, right? [1577:16] **A.** I don't think it's that simple. [1577:17] **Q.** Okay. So when you saw transfers into your account for political donations, didn't you view them as loans to you that you were on the hook for? [1577:20] **A.** I viewed them as things I was on the hook for. [1577:21] **Q.** And to take it out of colloquialism, "on the hook for" means you had to pay them back. [1577:23] **A.** I expected and wanted to pay them back. "Had to" relies on affirmative mutual understanding that may not have existed in some cases. [1578:1] **Q.** So you did have to pay them back or you didn't have to pay them back? [1578:3] **A.** I am not sure what the donor, or what, like, the loanee thought, or what the person lending to me, the lender, thought. [1578:5] **Q.** So if I'm understanding you correctly, you didn't think you were on the hook for the loans. [1578:7] **A.** I expect——I wanted to pay them back. That is distinct from there being any understanding or discussion about that. [1578:9] **MR. COHEN:** Okay. Can we call up 3501-28, please. [1578:10] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1578:11] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1578:12] **Q.** Mr. Singh, during the time you worked for FTX did you file tax returns? [1578:14] **A.** Yes. [1578:15] **Q.** And did you have an accountant who prepared them for you? [1578:16] **A.** Robert Lee. [1578:17] **Q.** And did you provide your accountant with information about the political donations you made? [1578:19] **A.** Some of them, yes. [1578:20] **Q.** Because you wanted to take account of them in payment of your taxes, correct? [1578:22] **A.** Or make them just known to the people thinking about my finances, yes. [1578:24] **Q.** Okay. Now let me back up and ask a foundation question. [1578:25] You mentioned yesterday a person named Jayesh Peswani. [1579:1] Do you recall that? [1579:2] **A.** Yes. [1579:3] **Q.** And just to remind the jury, who was he? [1579:4] **A.** The head of finance at FTX. [1579:5] **Q.** Okay. And I think you mentioned yesterday that you asked——sometime in 2021 you asked Mr. Peswani for a list of Alameda's loans to you. [1579:8] **A.** I think I asked for that in October of 2022. [1579:9] **Q.** And what was your reason for asking? [1579:10] **A.** I expected it to list a lot of transfers to me. [1579:11] **Q.** Okay. You expected it to list transfers to you because you wanted to understand what you were responsible for, correct? [1579:13] **A.** I wanted to confirm it matched what had flown through my bank account. [1579:15] **Q.** So you just wanted to know what was going through your bank account; you didn't really think you were responsible for it. [1579:17] **A.** It was my desire and expectation to repay some of the transfers that had gone through my account. I didn't know if there was separate accounting of it, and I never talked about those expectations, or asked for something that could document that. [1580:1] **Q.** So you were unclear, you're telling us, about whether or not you had a responsibility to pay the loans back? [1580:3] **A.** Yes. To clarify, I am not sure they were loans, the transfers. [1580:5] **Q.** Isn't it true, Mr. Singh, that you thought that the money going into your account were donations that you were obligated to repay? [1580:8] **A.** Obligated is complicated and might rely on mutual understanding. [1580:10] **Q.** That you were on the hook for those funds? [1580:11] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. Asked and answered. [1580:12] **THE COURT:** We have done this already, Mr. Cohen. [1580:13] **MR. COHEN:** Let's call up 3501-103, please. [1580:14] **MR. ROOS:** Objection, foundation. 611/612. [1580:15] **Q.** Do you recall in one of your many interviews being interviewed by the government attorneys on February 24 of this year? [1580:18] **A.** I don't remember exact dates. [1580:19] **Q.** You recall being interviewed in February? [1580:20] **A.** Yes. [1580:21] **Q.** And you recall telling the prosecutors that you thought of the money going to you to make donations as money that you were obligated to pay and that you were on the hook for those funds? [1580:24] **A.** I don't remember the exact words I used. [1580:25] **Q.** Was that the substance of what you told them? [1581:1] **A.** That's similar. [1581:2] **Q.** That you were on the hook for them? [1581:3] **A.** That I believed that I was on the hook and I wanted to repay them. [1581:5] **Q.** Now, didn't you also believe, sir, that when you received these transfers that you wanted to have them booked as loans? [1581:7] **A.** Sorry. Could you repeat the question? [1581:8] **Q.** Sure. When you received what you called -- I'm trying to use your language -- transfers to make political donations, you thought of them as loans and tried to get them booked as loans. [1581:11] **A.** I expected that they would be booked as loans. [1581:12] **Q.** And you tried to get them booked as loans, correct? [1581:13] **A.** In a sense. [1581:14] **Q.** Do you recall speaking with the government in January? [1581:15] **A.** Yes. [1581:16] **Q.** January 19? [1581:17] **A.** Um-hum. [1581:18] **Q.** You recall telling the prosecutors that when you did see the transfers into your account, you thought of them as loans and tried to get the transfers booked as loans. [1581:21] **A.** I don't remember exactly what I said. It seems believable. [1581:22] **Q.** Sorry? [1581:23] **A.** Seems believable. [1581:24] **MR. COHEN:** Your Honor, this might be a good time to take our lunch break. [1582:1] **THE COURT:** Give me an idea of how much more you have. [1582:2] **MR. COHEN:** I will certainly finish today, and probably about an hour, hour and a half. [1582:4] **THE COURT:** We will take the lunch break, members of the jury. The lawyers and I have a little business to do, so we will make it a little longer today. I'll see you back at let's say five to 2. [1582:8] (Jury not present) [1582:9] **THE COURT:** Mr. Roos, what's on your mind? [1582:10] **MR. ROOS:** Thank you, your Honor. If it's OK, I'll approach and give you a binder that has the witness materials for tomorrow. [1582:13] **THE COURT:** Thank you. [1582:14] **MR. ROOS:** Your Honor, I have just handed up to you the government exhibits that we intend to use tomorrow with Professor Peter Easton, who is the government's expert witness relating to accounting and financial calculations and tracing. We conferred with defense, and they helpfully identified their areas of objections so we could work this out before we are in front of the jury. I will just go sort of in order of the issues as I understand them. [1582:22] **THE COURT:** We will try. [1582:23] **MR. ROOS:** The first issue, as I understand it, is that one of the exhibits, which compares the balance of customer funds on the FTX database to the balance of funds [1583:1] within FTX's wallets, hot wallets we have heard about in the case, it compares those two lines and it's Government Exhibit 1051, if your Honor wants to take a look. [1583:4] As I understand the objection, your Honor, it's a Rule 16 objection, which is that, in the defense view, it's outside the scope of the -- [1583:7] **THE COURT:** I'm sorry. Back up. [1583:8] It's a Rule 16 objection, and then I lost you because you looked down. [1583:10] **MR. ROOS:** My apologies. [1583:11] It's a Rule 16 objection, as I understand it, to the timing of the disclosure relating to the opinion that's reflected in the exhibit. [1583:14] **THE COURT:** What's the objection, Mr. Cohen? [1583:15] **MR. LISNER:** Your Honor, I'll address on behalf of the defense, David Lisner. [1583:17] This graph purports to show it's not just assets, crypto assets, between what's shown in the site and what's shown in wallets. [1583:20] Professor Easton's expert disclosure, as far as I could tell, and me and Mr. Roos have not yet had a chance to compare language, but I don't see any place where an opinion about the balance of crypto assets between wallets and the database is reflected in his disclosure, and he is not offered as a crypto expert. As I understand, tallying up the amount of [1584:1] crypto assets in a wallet is not necessarily as simple as a bank account. [1584:3] For that reason, we think this is outside of the disclosure. [1584:5] **THE COURT:** I thought it was about timing. [1584:6] **MR. LISNER:** That's the words Mr. Roos used. [1584:7] The words I would have used is, Professor Easton's Rule 16 disclosure does not provide an opinion or describe an opinion regarding the balance of crypto assets. The closest I could find is opinion 9, which describes Alameda's balances, but this exhibit expressly excludes Alameda's balances and that's in a footnote. [1584:13] **MR. ROOS:** Few things, your Honor. [1584:14] **THE COURT:** It would have been helpful if somebody had told me that we were going to discuss this, because I have not looked at that Rule 16 disclosure in at least two months. I have no idea what it says today. [1584:18] **MR. LISNER:** Apologies, your Honor. We received this and all other exhibits and backup for Professor Easton Saturday night at 11 p.m. This is the quickest we are able to address this. [1584:22] **MR. ROOS:** Just to be clear on that, we produced the initial draft of this slide, and I think this is the answer to the disclosure question, we produced it on September 8, when we produced our exhibits. [1585:1] And the question under Rule 16(g), in analyzing whether or not there is an appropriate disclosure, is whether or not there is a prejudice to the defense. [1585:4] I would direct your Honor to two cases as you are considering this issue. The first is the Second Circuit's decision in Tin Yat Chin. I have a copy. I don't have a copy for everyone, but I can hand up my copy to the Court. I will give the cite. It's 476 F.3d 144. There the circuit, Judge Rakoff writing for the circuit, considered whether the government's disclosure of an expert, not just a slide, but an expert, one day before his testimony was unduly late and prejudicial, and the Court concluded that the district court's decision to give an extra day, so a one-day continuance, was sufficient. Here they have had this exhibit for about six weeks now, so that's more than enough time to prepare. There is no evidence of prejudice. [1585:17] The second case I would point to is a district court decision by Judge Caproni. The case is Rosario. It has a Westlaw cite of 2014 WL 6076364. There she held that the production of the slides in that case for the witness provided sufficient disclosure to meet Rule 16's requirements. [1585:22] **THE COURT:** Is there an opinion he is going to give about this? [1585:24] **MR. ROOS:** His opinion is going to be that the amount in FTX's cryptocurrency wallets, there was a difference between [1586:1] what was in there and what was reflected in FTX's database for customer deposits, so the black line meaning this is what the database said they had in customer deposits. What FTX was actually keeping in cryptocurrency balances was considerably smaller. [1586:6] **THE COURT:** Mr. Lisner, where is the prejudice to the defense? [1586:8] **MR. LISNER:** The prejudice is, your Honor, while we may have had a version of this slide, it's based on tens of thousands, maybe hundreds of thousands of database entries that we received Saturday night. But, more importantly -- [1586:12] **THE COURT:** Did they or did they not produce this to you on or about September 8? [1586:14] **MR. LISNER:** I don't currently have a recollection of this particular slide. We may have, but we did not receive the data. [1586:17] May I add one other point, your Honor? [1586:18] **THE COURT:** I'm sorry. I don't understand the distinction you're drawing. [1586:20] **MR. ROOS:** Here is the version. [1586:21] **THE COURT:** Please hand it up. [1586:22] I am asking Mr. Lisner what the distinction is between the graph and the data. [1586:24] **MR. LISNER:** The distinction, your Honor, is that the graph is driven by an enormous amount of numbers, and we just [1587:1] received the numbers the other day. So what this graph was based on we didn't previously have. [1587:3] The other point I would add, and I'll rest after this, your Honor, is I believe from Mr. Roos jumping to case law about late disclosure, I take that as an admission that it was not fairly captured by Professor Easton's expert disclosure. [1587:7] **THE COURT:** You will take it as an admission, and I will think about it. [1587:9] **MR. LISNER:** Understood. [1587:10] **THE COURT:** This graph, Mr. Roos, that you handed me, which is marked Government Exhibit 1051, does not actually look to me like the one in the book. [1587:13] **MR. ROOS:** The difference, your Honor, is the temporal period. If your Honor sees the black-and-white version I printed out for you, which is draft, it goes back to 2019, the ultimate exhibit is just 2021, 2022, so it sort of elongates it, but it's otherwise the same analysis. [1587:18] **THE COURT:** Same data? [1587:19] **MR. ROOS:** Same data. [1587:20] **THE COURT:** For the overlap period. [1587:21] **MR. ROOS:** Correct. [1587:22] **THE COURT:** I will consider that. [1587:23] Next issue. [1587:24] **MR. ROOS:** The second issue, as I understand it, is that the defense is objecting to admitting certain of the [1588:1] government's exhibits, a majority of them, I think. No objection to using them as demonstratives. [1588:3] I'll tell you that the government's plan is that there are exhibits in the binder before your Honor that are the results of the financial analysis. They come in two forms: Balance data over time, either bank accounts or data from the FTX transaction database, and the other form of analysis is financial tracing, so money flowing through accounts. [1588:9] Those exhibits the government is offering into evidence, and they are all within the 1000 series. The government also intends to use certain demonstratives, such as, you know, a portion of a document to ask the witness whether or not he has analyzed the source of the funds for the investment that is reflected on the document, and for those we are not proposing to offer those demonstratives, which are in the 3000 series, into evidence. [1588:17] I think the dispute, just to narrow it for the Court, is whether or not the 1000 series exhibits can be offered into evidence, and the government's view, informed, I think, again by the case law, is that both under the rules relating to experts, so a 703 chart, and the rules relating to summary charts, under 1006, that these are admissible into evidence. [1588:23] **THE COURT:** Thank you. [1588:24] Mr. Lisner, first of all, is it correct that we don't have an issue about the 3000 series? [1589:1] **MR. LISNER:** No. We do have one issue. I think we have two categories of issues. I can describe them for you. [1589:3] **THE COURT:** Yes. [1589:4] **MR. LISNER:** In the 3000 series these are slides that, as Mr. Roos pointed out, the government intends to use as demonstratives. We have no problem with that, but a number of them include call-outs or pictures of documents not in evidence. If the government purports to publish excerpts of documents not in evidence, that's our concern. [1589:10] For a lot of the documents I think we could work something out with the government, and I'm happy to speak with Mr. Roos over the lunch break, but the principle is, they shouldn't be allowed to publish documents not in evidence under the guise of demonstrative. [1589:15] **THE COURT:** The expert is entitled, if memory serves, under Rule 703, to explain the basis for his opinions, and the opinion need not be based entirely on material in evidence, as long as the non-evidentiary material is evidence of a sort that experts in the field rely upon. [1589:20] Now, obviously, there is a potential there at an extreme for abuse, and I appreciate that, but I'm not understanding why I should assume, as a categorical matter, that anything that's non-evidentiary that the expert refers to in justifying the opinion shouldn't be placed in front of the jury. [1590:1] **MR. LISNER:** I think in 703, for material that is inadmissible for which the expert relies, there is a balancing test of whether it's sufficiently probative, which we take your point. It could be published, but not all of these documents appear to be relevant to the analysis. There are news articles which are hearsay. [1590:7] And, again, I'm happy to speak with Mr. Roos over the break -- [1590:9] **THE COURT:** They are not hearsay to the extent that they are offered to illustrate the basis for the expert's opinion, but I certainly welcome your working on this further with Mr. Roos, because the problem I'm having with your argument about the 3000 series right now is that you are taking the categorical position, implicitly anyway, that anything that's not evidentiary that's called out in one of these demonstratives is inherently, simply by virtue of being non-evidentiary, unduly prejudicial and so forth, and that's not the way that analysis works. [1590:19] **MR. LISNER:** I understand, your Honor. I take the point. Why don't we work out what we can and maybe whatever is left, an appropriate limiting instruction perhaps. [1590:22] **THE COURT:** That's fine. [1590:23] **MR. ROOS:** For what it's worth, I think besides the news articles, we intend to offer the exhibits that are cited in there, which may just sort of moot the issue. [1591:1] **THE COURT:** Don't eat up my lunch with that. You eat up your lunches. [1591:3] What about the 1000 series, Mr. Lisner? [1591:4] **MR. LISNER:** The 1000 series is for only part of them. We are fine with admitting them as summary Exhibits 1000 up through 1017. But from 1017 to 1050, these are a series of, I guess I'll call them flow charts that purport to show or describe the flow of funds became bank accounts for certain transactions. For example, 1039 is the one I happen to have open in my book. This appears to be expert conclusion and not a 1006 summary or include expert conclusions and not be based solely on the underlying bank records, and I think maybe with more foundation we can get there. [1591:14] The issue that we see is, Professor Easton is, according to his Rule 16 disclosure, is going to tell us everything was commingled between bank accounts, customer funds and FTX Alameda funds. And then these slides purport to separate it out, which funds are which. I don't know how Professor Easton continued to do that, but it sounds like an accounting conclusion and not a fair 1006 summary. [1591:21] **THE COURT:** You invited my attention to 1039. You start off at the left side of the flow chart with $11 million in customer funds from customer bank accounts, and the only other inflow reflected is a $200,000 inflow over a couple-day period both going into North Dimension. [1592:1] I can understand conceptually what you are talking about, but if 99 percent of it is from one source and 1 percent of it from the other, what difference does it make? It's immaterial. Isn't it? [1592:5] **MR. LISNER:** It may be, but sitting here, I don't know that. So that's why I have to -- [1592:7] **THE COURT:** All you have to do is ask yourself what 200,000, as a percentage of 11.2 million, is, and then you know the answer. [1592:10] **MR. LISNER:** That may be true, but the backup data for this, again, is a spreadsheet that drives this. We received it in 3500 material. And that spreadsheet says, in the absence of time stamps and similar sized inflows, we performed a conservative LIFO analysis. It sounds like there was an analysis applied to the numbers to get to this chart, and that's what the issue is for us. [1592:17] **THE COURT:** We all know what a LIFO analysis is, don't we. So does the witness. Last in, first out. [1592:19] **MR. LISNER:** Yes, your Honor. [1592:20] **THE COURT:** Standard accounting, right? [1592:21] **MR. LISNER:** Yes. [1592:22] Professor Easton is being offered as an accounting expert. [1592:24] **THE COURT:** Does that take care of that group? [1592:25] **MR. LISNER:** That's everything on that group. That's [1593:1] all of our objections. [1593:2] **THE COURT:** We did make some progress here. I hope you can get to the goal line in time for your dessert. [1593:4] See you later. [1593:5] (Luncheon recess) [1594:1] AFTERNOON SESSION [1594:2] 2:00 p.m. [1594:3] **THE COURT:** Let's get the witness and the jury. [1594:4] (Jury present) [1594:5] **THE COURT:** The record will reflect that the jurors and the defendant all are present, as they have been throughout. [1594:8] I hope everybody had a pleasant lunch break. [1594:9] The witness is still under oath. [1594:10] You may proceed, Mr. Cohen. [1594:11] **MR. COHEN:** Thank you, your Honor. [1594:12] BY MR. COHEN: [1594:13] **Q.** Mr. Singh, let me call your attention to September of 2022, OK, sir? [1594:15] **A.** OK. [1594:16] **Q.** We talked about it briefly this morning. I want to come back to it. [1594:18] I believe you told us that, in or about September, you received a message from Mr. Bankman-Fried about whether or not to close Alameda? [1594:21] **A.** I received a message that had a link to a Google Doc that described arguments for doing so. [1594:23] **Q.** And this was the Google Doc you described as being headed we came, we saw, we researched? [1594:25] **A.** I think that was the title. [1595:1] **Q.** And this was to you and to Gary, is that correct? [1595:2] **A.** I know for certain it was to the two of us. I don't know if it was also shared with others. [1595:4] **Q.** And I believe you testified yesterday that one of the topics it addressed was public relations about the relationship between Alameda and FTX. [1595:7] Do you recall that, sir? [1595:8] **A.** I do. [1595:9] **Q.** And another topic was I think what you described as the leadership of Alameda, correct? [1595:11] **A.** Yes. [1595:12] **Q.** Do you recall whether any other topics were discussed in that document? [1595:14] **A.** Give me a moment. [1595:15] **Q.** Sure. [1595:16] **THE COURT:** Isn't the document in evidence? [1595:17] **MR. ROOS:** Yes. [1595:18] **MR. COHEN:** Why don't we just call it up then. [1595:19] GX-18. [1595:20] Thank you, your Honor. [1595:21] **Q.** This is much easier. Why don't we take a look at GX-18. Yesterday you went through it for us in the middle of the page, the reasons. You see that, sir? [1595:24] **A.** Yes. [1595:25] **Q.** And we talked just a moment ago about the PR hit relating [1596:1] to Alameda and FTX and then current Alameda leadership. [1596:2] Do you see that, sir? [1596:3] **A.** Yes. [1596:4] **MR. COHEN:** Brian, if you could reduce that, please. Go to the next page. [1596:6] Come back to the first page. [1596:7] I found it. [1596:8] If you could call out the box, the reasons again. Look at entry number 2. [1596:10] **Q.** The current leadership of Alameda is good, but not good enough to be able to trust with such a big operation. Then continuing to A. The fact that we didn't -- [1596:13] **MR. COHEN:** Can you highlight A, please, Brian. [1596:14] **Q.** The fact that we didn't hedge as much as we should have alone cost more in EV than all the money Alameda has ever made or will ever make. That's the kind of critical mistake we're likely to make if I'm not actually running the show there. [1596:18] Mr. Singh did you have an understanding of what EV was? [1596:20] **A.** Expected value. [1596:21] **Q.** Do you recall anything else that was discussed about hedging in this chat or around this chat? [1596:23] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. Hearsay. [1596:24] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1596:25] **Q.** Continuing down to 5 the topic was: Alameda is making some [1597:1] money trading, but not enough to justify its existence. [1597:2] Do you recall discussing that, sir? [1597:3] **A.** I remember a comment from Gary giving his thoughts on this point in the chat. [1597:5] **Q.** What do you remember? [1597:6] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. Hearsay. [1597:7] **MR. COHEN:** It goes to state of mind, your Honor. [1597:8] **THE COURT:** Whose state of mind? [1597:9] **MR. COHEN:** The coconspirators. [1597:10] **THE COURT:** Mr. Roos, what do you say to that? [1597:11] **MR. ROOS:** I'll withdraw this objection for now. [1597:12] **THE COURT:** All right. [1597:13] **MR. COHEN:** Could we have the question read back? [1597:14] **THE COURT:** What do you remember was the question. [1597:15] **A.** I remember Gary saying in the chat something to the effect of, I think Alameda is making 300 or $400 million a year. Sam, are you sure that the PR hit is worth more than that. [1597:18] **MR. COHEN:** We can take this down. [1597:19] **Q.** I believe you testified that after this was sent -- this GX-18 was sent across, you came to your own view about whether Alameda should be shut down, correct? [1597:22] **A.** I had an idea. I don't think I had an overall view on whether it should or shouldn't happen. [1597:24] **Q.** I believe you testified that your idea was that Alameda ought to be taken down off the FTX exchange, is that correct? [1598:1] **A.** Not necessarily that it ought to. It just struck me as sort of like a less costly solution that maintained many of the same advantages. [1598:4] **Q.** Then you had a number of chats with various people about the issue about whether or not Alameda should be -- should be -- go out of business, correct? [1598:7] **A.** There was one Signal chat after this in hashtag organization in which some of that was discussed. [1598:9] **Q.** Who was on that chat, sir? [1598:10] **A.** Myself, Sam, Caroline, Gary. [1598:11] **Q.** Were there separate chats just between you, Gary, and Caroline? [1598:13] **A.** Those existed in Signal. I don't remember if we used them to talk about this. [1598:15] **Q.** So you don't remember one way or the other? [1598:16] **A.** I don't remember one way or the other. [1598:17] **Q.** I think you also told us that there was some in-person meetings about the topic of closing down Alameda. [1598:19] Do you recall that? [1598:20] **A.** Yes. [1598:21] **Q.** Who was at those meetings? [1598:22] **A.** There was one meeting that I called immediately after posting in hashtag organization and getting some responses. Myself, Gary, Caroline attended. [1598:25] **Q.** Mr. Bankman-Fried did not attend? [1599:1] **A.** He did not attend. [1599:2] **Q.** Whether it was at that meeting or otherwise, you told us about an exchange where you inquired about whether the borrows could be paid back. [1599:5] Do you recall that, sir? [1599:6] **A.** It didn't come up in that meeting. It was the elephant in the room in that meeting. [1599:8] **Q.** Did it come up afterwards? [1599:9] **A.** With Sam. [1599:10] **Q.** Did it come up in your conversation with Ms. Ellison and Mr. Wang? [1599:12] **A.** No, not the in-person one. [1599:13] **Q.** What about on the chats? [1599:14] **A.** Not that I recall, except for the chat with the four of us. [1599:15] **Q.** What do you remember from that? [1599:16] **A.** From the chat with the four of us, you mean? [1599:17] **Q.** Yes. [1599:18] **A.** I don't remember more than what's in my direct, but I could restate a lot of it. [1599:20] **Q.** No need. [1599:21] I think you told us that you asked whether or not returning Alameda's borrows was possible, and Ms. Ellison responded that it was not possible. [1599:24] Do you recall testifying to that, sir? [1599:25] **A.** I don't think those are my exact words. [1600:1] **Q.** What were your exact words? [1600:2] **A.** I enumerated the main things that I thought would be required to close Alameda down at FTX. One of them, I believe my phrasing was, close out all Alameda accounts. Caroline responded: That's impossible. I asked which part of it. She clarified the part about closing out accounts. [1600:7] **Q.** Your understanding was, it was not possible because there were not sufficient assets to pay back the borrows, correct? [1600:9] **A.** At first I was confused. That became my understanding over the course of the day. [1600:11] **Q.** And this was based on what Ms. Ellison had said? [1600:12] **A.** Ms. Ellison, Gary, and Sam. [1600:13] **Q.** Now, did you do any verification of your own about this topic, any work of your own on this? [1600:15] **A.** No. [1600:16] **Q.** Let me move forward. I believe you testified that you had a conversation with Mr. Bankman-Fried on the balcony of the Orchid penthouse. [1600:19] Do you recall that, sir? [1600:20] **A.** I do. [1600:21] **Q.** Before we get into it, let me just ask this question. [1600:22] you told us about Mr. Bankman-Fried's demeanor yesterday. What was your demeanor, your state of mind? [1600:24] **A.** I was very nervous. I was awaiting an explanation and eventually an apology. I was pacing. [1601:1] **Q.** Were you anxious? [1601:2] **A.** Yes. [1601:3] **Q.** Were you stressed? [1601:4] **A.** Yes. [1601:5] **Q.** I think you told us that later in November you regarded yourself as suicidal. [1601:7] **A.** And for a few months after. [1601:8] **Q.** At that time as well? [1601:9] **A.** Yes. [1601:10] **Q.** You testified yesterday that -- [1601:11] **MR. COHEN:** Counsel, it's page 1406, line 12. [1601:12] **Q.** First, how did the conversation begin? I said: Caroline is really freaked out about the NAV situation and so am I. [1601:14] Do you recall that, sir? [1601:15] Later on in the passage you were asked: What, if anything, did the defendant say in response? [1601:17] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1601:18] **THE COURT:** Start again, Mr. Cohen. [1601:19] **MR. COHEN:** I'm trying to short-circuit this, Judge. [1601:20] **THE COURT:** I appreciate that. But you start with a question and then you interpolate another question. [1601:22] **MR. COHEN:** Maybe I should go slower then. [1601:23] **Q.** Mr. Singh, do you recall speaking with Mr. Bankman-Fried about Caroline Ellison freaking out? [1601:25] **A.** Yes. [1602:1] **Q.** And she was freaking out over the point you had just made about the ability to pay back the borrows, correct? [1602:3] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1602:4] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1602:5] **Q.** What was she freaking out about? [1602:6] **MR. ROOS:** Same objection. [1602:7] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1602:8] **Q.** Do you recall in that conversation that -- according to you, Mr. Bankman-Fried said, page 1406 to 1407: I am not sure what there is to worry about. NAV is fantastic by almost any measure. It was super positive, even if you don't include FTX and FTX US equity. [1602:13] Do you recall that, sir? [1602:14] **A.** Yes. [1602:15] **Q.** And you told us you did not react positively to that, correct? [1602:17] **A.** I asked further questions. [1602:18] **Q.** Did you talk about any other topics in the meeting at the balcony? [1602:20] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1602:21] **THE COURT:** What's the objection? [1602:22] **MR. ROOS:** Hearsay. He can answer yes or no. [1602:23] **THE COURT:** Yes. You can answer yes or no and stopped when you have answered yes or no. [1602:25] **Q.** Yes or no, did you talk in the balcony meeting about the [1603:1] topic of FTX's marketing expenses? [1603:2] **A.** Talked about expenses. [1603:3] **Q.** Did you express the view that FTX going forward ought to keep expenses down? [1603:5] **A.** Something to that effect, I did. [1603:6] **Q.** Because you thought it was important going forward that FTX spend as little as possible until customers were repaid, correct? [1603:9] **A.** I specifically was concerned about frivolous spending that may not pan out to be useful. [1603:11] **Q.** So you wanted certainly frivolous spending to not be done, is that correct? [1603:13] **A.** Correct. [1603:14] **Q.** Other business spending to be as limited as possible. [1603:15] **A.** I don't think I said exactly that. [1603:16] **Q.** What did you say, sir? [1603:17] **A.** I think I just asked if Sam would now sort of take seriously the act of cutting down on the expenses and curbing future ones. [1603:20] **Q.** Now, you had mentioned yesterday that around this time you considered resigning from FTX, correct? [1603:22] **A.** Correct. [1603:23] **Q.** I meant to ask you, prior to September 2022, had you ever considered resigning? [1603:25] **A.** Yes. [1604:1] **Q.** When was that? [1604:2] **A.** Once in 2018, once before moving to Hong Kong, a few times after distressing conversations with Sam or Gary. [1604:4] **Q.** So this is over the four-year period from 2018 to 2022? [1604:5] **A.** Yes. [1604:6] **Q.** Mr. Singh, did you ever purchase an apartment in Orcas Island, Washington? [1604:8] **A.** I did. [1604:9] **Q.** When did you do that? [1604:10] **A.** I did that in October of 2022. [1604:11] **Q.** And Orcas Island is in Washington State or off Washington State? [1604:13] **A.** Right. [1604:14] **Q.** This was an apartment you purchased with friends? [1604:15] **A.** It was a house that I alone purchased, though I intended it to be used by me and friends. [1604:17] **Q.** And the purchase price was $3.7 million? [1604:18] **A.** Correct. [1604:19] **Q.** And you borrowed that purchase price from the FTX exchange, correct? [1604:21] **A.** Correct. [1604:22] **Q.** And you did this after the September meeting with Mr. Bankman-Fried you've been telling us about, correct? [1604:24] **A.** I did. [1604:25] **Q.** And in fact the closing for the apartment took place on [1605:1] November 1, didn't it, sir? [1605:2] **A.** I don't remember the exact date. [1605:3] **Q.** Isn't it fair to say that you wired the funds sometime after October 2022? [1605:5] **A.** Or late October, yes. [1605:6] **Q.** Now, coming into that meeting did you expect FTX to go forward as a company, the September meeting on the balcony? [1605:8] **A.** Would you mind clarifying what you mean by go forward? [1605:9] **Q.** Well, did you expect that FTX would last as a business going forward? [1605:11] **A.** Certainly for some amount of time, yes. [1605:12] **Q.** Didn't you expect it to last as a business for years? [1605:13] **A.** I am not sure what I expected. [1605:14] **Q.** Well, do you recall speaking with the prosecutors on January 19 of this year? [1605:16] **A.** I don't remember the specific dates in my meetings with them. [1605:18] **Q.** Do you recall saying to them that in September you believed that FTX would last for years despite the awful situation? [1605:20] **A.** I don't remember saying that. [1605:21] **MR. COHEN:** Can we call up 3501-028. [1605:22] If we can turn to page 8, third paragraph. Call that out, Brian. [1605:24] **Q.** Read this to yourself, Mr. Singh, and I ask you, yes or no, if it refreshes your recollection that you told the prosecutors [1606:1] that you believed FTX would last for years despite the awful situation. [1606:3] It's the next paragraph below, Mr. Singh. [1606:4] **THE COURT:** I'm sorry. 3501-28 what? [1606:5] **MR. COHEN:** It's the paragraph we have just pulled up. I apologize. Page 8. Same page. Just the one below, your Honor. [1606:8] **A.** This does refresh my memory. [1606:9] **Q.** What's your memory, sir? [1606:10] **A.** That I did tell prosecutors I thought FTX might last for years, not that it would. [1606:12] **Q.** Let's move forward, sir. [1606:13] Let's now go to November 2022. [1606:14] **MR. COHEN:** Pull up GX-480A, please. [1606:15] **Q.** This is a chat between you and Mr. Bankman-Fried that you reviewed yesterday. [1606:17] Do you recall that, sir? [1606:18] **A.** I do. [1606:19] **Q.** And it's from November 6 of 2022. [1606:20] **A.** Yes. [1606:21] **Q.** The blue is you and the gray is Mr. Bankman-Fried? [1606:22] **A.** Yes. [1606:23] **Q.** In the first entry you say that one thing that seriously helped me is if I didn't have debts. I think most of them are loans, 500 million for me exercising, more for U.S. [1607:1] investments. I hope we can unwind these but not sure. [1607:2] Sir, this refers to the loans you have told us about earlier in your testimony, correct, that you took from FTX? [1607:4] **A.** This refers to the 477 million on paper loan used for exercising and other loans made through me, Sam, and Gary to capitalize FTX US for it to make investments. [1607:7] **Q.** And here you're seeking to have them unwound, correct? [1607:8] **A.** I am hoping they could be unwound. I am not sure. [1607:9] **Q.** Now, you are telling Mr. Bankman-Fried that it would help you not to have any debts, correct? [1607:11] **A.** Right. [1607:12] **Q.** By having the loans unwound. [1607:13] **A.** Right. [1607:14] **Q.** Then going to the third paragraph up here: Maybe 80 million extra or so are donations, personal, etc., that went through my bank account and are in my name, so 120 million pretax or something. I'm not sure that's the exact number. [1607:18] Is that a reference to the political donations we talked about before the break? [1607:20] **A.** It's a reference to that and more. [1607:21] **Q.** What's the more? [1607:22] **A.** Borrows from my FTX account against my FTT collateral. [1607:23] **Q.** Anything else? [1607:24] **A.** The 10 million that Sam gave me a few years earlier. [1607:25] **Q.** You are telling Mr. Bankman-Fried here that you don't want [1608:1] to be responsible for that, correct? [1608:2] **A.** Right. [1608:3] **MR. COHEN:** Can we continue down, Brian, to the gray. [1608:4] **Q.** Mr. Bankman-Fried says: Will think about this. What does trade mean? Excuse me. I think about this. You say thanks. What does trade mean? And you explain. Sell FTT or SRM earlier in 2022. Is that correct? [1608:8] **A.** Yes. [1608:9] **Q.** SRM, we covered, is Serum? [1608:10] **A.** Serum tokens. [1608:11] **Q.** Your idea here was to set up a backdated trade so that you would not be responsible for these amounts you had borrowed, correct? [1608:14] **A.** Correct. [1608:15] **Q.** And that ended up not happening, correct? [1608:16] **A.** Correct. I didn't go through with it. [1608:17] **MR. COHEN:** We can take that down. [1608:18] **Q.** Mr. Roos asked you a series of questions about your cooperation with the government. [1608:20] Do you recall that, sir? [1608:21] **A.** I do. [1608:22] **Q.** I think we have established that you had at least 20 meetings with the prosecutors, correct? [1608:24] **A.** I can't remember if we said at least. [1608:25] **THE COURT:** I think we have covered that two or three [1609:1] times today. [1609:2] **Q.** Just to put this in sequence, you entered into a cooperation agreement with the government, correct? [1609:4] **A.** I did. [1609:5] **Q.** That was on February 28? [1609:6] **A.** I don't remember the exact date. That sounds about right. [1609:7] **Q.** Prior to that, you had a number of meetings with the government. [1609:9] **A.** Yes. [1609:10] **Q.** So you had meetings in November, December, and January with the government? [1609:12] **THE COURT:** Mr. Cohen, we did all that before lunch. [1609:13] **MR. COHEN:** There is a piece we have not done yet, your Honor. [1609:15] **THE COURT:** Let's get to it, please. [1609:16] **MR. COHEN:** OK. [1609:17] **Q.** In the meetings before you had the cooperation agreement, you entered into a different agreement called a proffer agreement, correct? [1609:20] **A.** I did. [1609:21] **MR. COHEN:** We would like to offer 3501-11. [1609:22] **MR. ROOS:** No objection. [1609:23] **THE COURT:** Received. [1609:24] (Defendant's Exhibit 3501-11 received in evidence) [1609:25] **MR. COHEN:** Go to the second page, Brian. [1610:1] **Q.** This was signed by you and your attorneys and the lawyers for the government? [1610:3] **A.** I can't remember if all the signatures here are exclusively -- are within that group, but at least I know that some of them are. [1610:6] **Q.** Do you recognize your own signature? [1610:7] **A.** I do. [1610:8] **MR. COHEN:** Let's go back to the first page. If we could call out the second paragraph, number 1. [1610:10] **Q.** It says in bold: This is not a cooperation agreement. [1610:11] Do you see that, sir? [1610:12] **A.** I do. [1610:13] **Q.** The government had not yet decided whether they would offer you a cooperation agreement at this point, correct? [1610:15] **A.** I don't know what was in their heads. I had not yet been offered a cooperation agreement. [1610:17] **MR. COHEN:** You can pull that back down, Brian. [1610:18] If we can pull out paragraph 3. [1610:19] **Q.** These proffer agreements would cover your interviews during this period with the government before a cooperation agreement was reached. [1610:22] **A.** Correct. [1610:23] **Q.** Maybe we don't have to go through line by line. [1610:24] Is it your understanding, sir, that the government could use the information it received in these interviews to [1611:1] pursue leads against you? [1611:2] **A.** Yes. [1611:3] **Q.** Even if you never got a cooperation agreement? [1611:4] **A.** That's my understanding. [1611:5] **Q.** Is it your understanding that if you made false statements in these interviews, you could be separately prosecuted for them? [1611:8] **A.** Yes. [1611:9] **Q.** Regardless of whether you got a cooperation agreement? [1611:10] **A.** That's my understanding. [1611:11] **Q.** Now, is it fair to say, Mr. Singh, that you were interviewed by the government on January 19 of this year? [1611:13] **A.** I don't remember the exact dates, sorry. [1611:14] **Q.** That's OK. [1611:15] Do you recall the government asking you about the purchase of the Orcas Island house? [1611:17] **A.** I remember discussing it with them. [1611:18] **Q.** Isn't it true that you told them that you thought that there were points along the way when you had a pit in your stomach and felt things were wrong, but the purchase of the house was not one of those times? [1611:22] **A.** I don't remember if those were my exact words. [1611:23] **Q.** Words to that effect? [1611:24] **A.** I don't remember. [1611:25] **MR. COHEN:** Why don't we pull up 3501-28 at page 9. [1612:1] If we can go to page 9 just for the witness, bottom of 9. Go back. I think we might have to go to page 10. [1612:3] Go back to 9. I'm sorry, Brian. Top of 9. I got it. [1612:4] Pull out the paragraph at the top of 9. [1612:5] **Q.** Read the first paragraph to yourself. My question is simply whether it refreshes your recollection of you telling the prosecutors there are points along the way when you had a pit in your stomach and felt things were wrong, but the purchase of the home was not one of those times. [1612:10] **A.** Sorry. I don't see an exhibit in front of me. [1612:11] **THE COURT:** We are now getting into the area of essentially reading a document that's not in evidence. I know what you are trying to do, but it's not working, so try a different way. [1612:15] **A.** My screen is blank. [1612:16] **Q.** Your screen is blank. [1612:17] **MR. COHEN:** Can we put his screen back up and then we will move on. Top of page 9. [1613:1] **THE COURT:** Please put a question. [1613:2] **MR. COHEN:** Okay. Is it back up? I'm sorry. [1613:3] **THE COURT:** Yes. [1613:4] BY MR. COHEN: [1613:5] **Q.** Again, Mr. Singh, yes or no: Does the passage at the top of that page, page 9, refresh your recollection about whether you told the prosecutors there were points along the way when you had a pit in your stomach and felt things were wrong but the purchase of the home was not one of those times? [1613:10] **A.** Not really. [1613:11] **Q.** Okay. Do you recall in that same meeting being asked about the political donations—— [1613:13] **MR. ROOS:** Can we take down the document. [1613:14] **MR. COHEN:** Yes, please. [1613:15] **Q.** Do you recall being asked in the same meeting about whether or not the political donations you made were loans to you? [1613:17] **MR. ROOS:** Objection to what meeting. [1613:18] **Q.** The meeting with the government on January 19th. [1613:19] **A.** I don't remember what was discussed at each meeting exactly. [1613:21] **Q.** Do you remember telling the government in January, whether you remember the date, that you did not feel like you——let me back up——there were points along the way when you had a pit in your stomach and felt things were wrong but you did not feel like that when you treated the transfers from Alameda as loans [1614:1] without questioning further? [1614:2] **A.** Still not sure I said that. [1614:3] **Q.** You're not sure whether you ever told the government that the transfers from Alameda were not loans to you? [1614:5] **A.** Sorry. Do you mind repeating the question. [1614:6] **Q.** Yeah. Did you ever deny to the government that the transfers from Alameda were loans to you? [1614:8] **A.** I don't know if I——I characterized them and described how I viewed them. I don't know that I——I can't remember what exactly I said. [1614:11] **Q.** Did there come a time in January where you understood the government was frustrated with your proffer? [1614:13] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1614:14] **THE COURT:** Sustained. [1614:15] **Q.** Did there come a time when you met with the government and you went over the topic of the Orcas Island house again? [1614:17] **A.** I can't remember if we went over it multiple times or not. [1614:18] **Q.** Okay. After the time we've just been discussing. [1614:19] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1614:20] **THE COURT:** What's the objection? [1614:21] **MR. ROOS:** Vague. [1614:22] **THE COURT:** Rephrase. [1614:23] **Q.** You just told us about a meeting in January with the prosecutors——you didn't remember the date——where you talked about the Orcas Island house, correct? [1615:1] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. I think he said he couldn't recall that, could not recall that. [1615:3] **THE COURT:** Answer the question, Mr. Singh. if you can. [1615:5] **A.** I recall speaking with the prosecutors at some point, at least one point, about my purchase of the Orcas Island home, even after I knew that it was drawing on customer funds. [1615:8] **Q.** Do you recall telling the prosecutors, as of January 24th, that you viewed the spending as egregious and unnecessary? [1615:10] **A.** Which spending? [1615:11] **MR. ROOS:** Objection. [1615:12] **Q.** On the Orcas Island house. [1615:13] **THE COURT:** Well, rephrase the question, please. [1615:14] **Q.** After the——do you recall having a meeting with the prosecutors in January, on January 24th, on or about January 24th, in which you told them that the spending on the Orcas Island house was egregious and unnecessary? [1615:18] **A.** My spending on it was egregious, unnecessary, and selfish. [1615:19] **Q.** Okay. Did you tell them that your spending on the political donations was egregious and unnecessary? [1615:21] **A.** I don't recall what I said, but I agree with those descriptions. [1615:23] **Q.** And you previously denied that that was the case. [1615:24] **A.** Not that I recall. [1615:25] **Q.** Okay. Now Mr. Roos showed you your plea agreement——excuse [1616:1] me——your cooperation agreement. [1616:2] **MR. COHEN:** Let's call that back up, 3501-002. [1616:3] **Q.** If you start at the——right here, that lists out the counts you pled guilty to, correct? [1616:5] **A.** Right. That's——that describes the first count and—— [1616:6] **Q.** We don't need to go through them all. [1616:7] **MR. COHEN:** If we can go to the next page. [1616:8] And pull out Count Six, Brian. [1616:9] **Q.** Is it fair to say that one of the counts you pled guilty to, Mr. Singh, was a conspiracy to violate the Federal Election Campaign Act? [1616:12] **A.** Yes. [1616:13] **MR. COHEN:** I have nothing further, your Honor. [1616:14] **THE COURT:** Thank you. [1616:15] Redirect. [1616:16] **MR. ROOS:** I'm sorry, your Honor. Could we have one moment with your Honor at the sidebar. [1616:18] **THE COURT:** You may. [1617:1] (At the sidebar) [1617:2] **MR. ROOS:** The last question was: "Did you conspire to violate the Federal Campaign Election Act?" "A. Yes." I intend to ask: "Who did you conspire with?" I just want to put that out there, in light of the prior rulings. I think they've opened the door. With any limiting instruction—— [1617:7] **MR. COHEN:** We would ask for a limiting instruction. [1617:8] **THE COURT:** I'll give a limiting instruction. [1617:9] **MR. ROOS:** Okay. [1618:1] (In open court) ### [1618:2] REDIRECT EXAMINATION [1618:3] BY MR. ROOS: [1618:4] **Q.** Mr. Singh, the last question Mr. Cohen asked you was whether you pleaded guilty to conspiring to violate the Federal Campaign Election Act. Do you recall that question? [1618:7] **A.** I do. [1618:8] **Q.** Who did you conspire with? [1618:9] **THE COURT:** Excuse me. Members of the jury, you're about to hear the answer to that question, and I remind you that regardless of the answer to that question, Mr. Bankman-Fried, for reasons that do not concern you, is not charged in this case with any violation or conspiracy to violate the federal election campaign laws. [1618:15] Now you may answer the question. [1618:16] **A.** Sam Bankman-Fried and Ryan Salame. [1618:17] **Q.** You were asked earlier today if some notes——a few times today——if some notes refreshed your recollection. Do you remember those questions? [1618:20] **A.** Some of them, yes. [1618:21] **Q.** Did you take those notes that you were shown? [1618:22] **A.** No. [1618:23] **Q.** At your meetings with prosecutors, did you observe anyone taking notes? [1618:25] **A.** Yes, sometimes. [1619:1] **Q.** Did anyone ever ask you to review the notes? [1619:2] **A.** Never. [1619:3] **Q.** Prior to today had you ever seen them? [1619:4] **A.** I've never seen those notes until today. [1619:5] **Q.** Were you ever asked to review them for accuracy? [1619:6] **A.** No. [1619:7] **Q.** And have you ever read the entirety of the notes? [1619:8] **A.** I don't think, except for today, I've ever read any amount of the notes. [1619:10] **Q.** You were asked at the end there about a property you bought, a home. What happened to that property? [1619:12] **A.** I forfeited it. [1619:13] **Q.** What do you mean? [1619:14] **A.** It was totally—— [1619:15] **MR. COHEN:** Objection. [1619:16] **THE COURT:** What's the objection? [1619:17] **MR. COHEN:** Beyond the scope. [1619:18] **MR. ROOS:** He opened the door. [1619:19] **THE COURT:** Overruled. [1619:20] **Q.** Go ahead. [1619:21] **A.** I bought it at a time when I understood that I was putting myself ahead of customers by doing so. I was embarrassed and ashamed. Forfeiting it seemed like one of the ways to right that one small wrong, at least a little. So the wrong wasn't small but the righting was small. [1620:1] **Q.** You were asked some questions about auto-deleveraging event. Do you remember those questions this morning? [1620:3] **A.** I do. [1620:4] **Q.** And you were shown some computer code. Do you remember that? [1620:6] **A.** I was shown code——commit snippets. [1620:7] **Q.** Thank you. You were shown a code commit. [1620:8] **A.** Yes. [1620:9] **Q.** When was that from? [1620:10] **A.** When was which part from? [1620:11] **Q.** The code commit about auto-deleveraging. [1620:12] **A.** August 2020. [1620:13] **Q.** Now do you recall testifying yesterday about Alameda having a negative balance in September 2022? [1620:15] **A.** Yes. [1620:16] **Q.** And how big was the negative balance? [1620:17] **A.** Gary told me Alameda was borrowing $13 billion in September 2022. [1620:19] **Q.** And when Alameda was borrowing $13 billion in September 2022, was that the result of auto-deleveraging? [1620:21] **A.** I fail to see the relationship between them. No. [1620:22] **Q.** You were asked about earlier today a loan for 700——for $477 million. Do you remember those questions? [1620:24] **A.** I do. [1620:25] **Q.** What was the purpose of the loan? [1621:1] **A.** The purpose of the loan was nominally for me to exercise my shares. I had money sufficient to do so otherwise. This particular loan was a part of a structure that Sam proposed with the goal of having Alameda lay out less cash than it would if I just exercised the original options I had. [1621:6] **Q.** To be clear, did $477 million ever go to you? [1621:7] **A.** No. It was really only on paper. [1621:8] **Q.** You were also asked earlier today—— [1621:9] **THE COURT:** Before you go on, you used the phrase "exercise my shares." Please explain to the jury what you meant by that. [1621:12] **THE WITNESS:** Sorry. Exercise my options. [1621:13] Before the event in which I got the large $477 million loan, I already had a large amount of options with a very low strike price. Sam's proposal was to redo them to strike them at a much higher price, such that it would cost me more to exercise them but that this way there wouldn't be tax that ultimately Alameda would have to pay by letting me sell more FTT. [1621:20] **THE COURT:** Now explain what you meant by "strike," please. [1621:22] **THE WITNESS:** Options are contracts that give you the right to get equity if you pay some amount. That amount is the strike price. So in my case, I think my original options had a strike price of $2.60 something cents, meaning that in order to [1622:1] get one share of equity, it would be $2.60 some cents to get a share of equity. They were restriked to be like some $10.86, I think, meaning that I'd have to pay more to get the equity, $10.86 I think for each share. So exercising after them being restricken would cost me more than exercising them in the state that they were granted to me. [1622:7] **THE COURT:** Proceed, counselor. [1622:8] **MR. ROOS:** Thank you, your Honor. [1622:9] BY MR. ROOS: [1622:10] **Q.** Mr. Singh, you were asked earlier today about some political donations and you said they were loans "in loose sense." What do you mean by "loose sense"? [1622:13] **A.** These were amounts that I discovered had been transferred to me often after the fact. It is the case that I intended to repay them all until September, when I realized I no longer could. That's the only sense in which they are loans. There wasn't paperwork, there wasn't a discussion of the transfers to me that I was a part of, and when I——I requested loan sheets, like lists of loans that Alameda had given, when asked from Jayesh, from Caroline, and from Can Sun, did not——they did not include many of these transfers as obligations I had to pay back. So they weren't——they weren't really loans. [1622:23] **Q.** Now you were asked a few questions a few moments ago by Mr. Cohen about times you considered resigning. Do you remember those questions? [1623:1] **A.** I do. [1623:2] **Q.** And you testified that you thought about resigning from FTX a few times; is that right? [1623:4] **A.** Yes. [1623:5] **Q.** How, if at all, was your contemplated resignation in the fall of 2022 different? [1623:7] **A.** Oh, it was extremely different. In the fall of '22, I want——the reason I wanted to resign was because I knew that I was becoming party and participating in something heinously criminal; that to keep running the business without divulging to others that there was a hole, I would be betraying customers that deposited their money into the hole, betraying my other employees. The scale of wrongdoing was enormous. In previous cases where I considered resigning, my considerations were really just focused on me——things like if working in finance and trying to make money was better than working directly at a philanthropy, things like that. [1623:18] **MR. ROOS:** No further questions. [1623:19] **THE COURT:** Thank you. [1623:20] Any recross? [1623:21] **MR. COHEN:** No, your Honor. [1623:22] **THE COURT:** All right. Thank you. You're excused, sir. [1623:24] (Witness excused) *[The transcript continues with the next witness.]* --- **About this text version** This is a text version of the court reporter’s transcript of the testimony of Nishad Singh at the trial of Samuel Bankman-Fried, *United States v. Samuel Bankman-Fried*, 22 Cr. 673 (LAK), before Judge Lewis A. Kaplan and a jury in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York. The government called Singh as a witness on October 16, 2023, and he was excused on October 17, 2023. His testimony runs from page 1298 to page 1623 of the trial transcript, which was prepared by Southern District Reporters, P.C. **Note by this site, not part of the document:** Direct examination by the government begins at trial transcript page 1298 (ECF No. 366), cross-examination by Bankman-Fried’s counsel at page 1492 (ECF No. 368), and redirect at page 1618. Singh’s account of when and how he learned of the hole in customer funds, his choice to stay and become complicit in the conspiracy, and his actions in the short period before the collapse is mainly at pages 1388 to 1417 and 1456 to 1473. - PDFs of the court reporter’s transcript for the two days, each holding the whole trial day except the pages sealed by the court, are held here: [October 16](pdf/2023-10-16-trial-transcript.pdf) and [October 17](pdf/2023-10-17-trial-transcript.pdf). The copies filed on the court’s docket are on CourtListener: [ECF No. 366](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.590940/gov.uscourts.nysd.590940.366.0.pdf) and [ECF No. 368](https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.590940/gov.uscourts.nysd.590940.368.0.pdf). This page as plain text: [trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17.txt](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17.txt). The other documents from the case: [index](index.html). - This page is long, and software that reads only the beginning of a page will miss the rest. The same text is available in 13 shorter parts: [part 1: pages 1298 to 1323 (Monday, October 16, 2023)](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-1.html); [part 2: pages 1323 to 1348 (Monday, October 16, 2023 (continued))](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-2.html); [part 3: pages 1349 to 1371 (Monday, October 16, 2023 (continued))](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-3.html); [part 4: pages 1371 to 1395 (Monday, October 16, 2023 (continued))](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-4.html); [part 5: pages 1395 to 1417 (Monday, October 16, 2023 (continued))](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-5.html); [part 6: pages 1417 to 1440 (Monday, October 16, 2023 (continued))](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-6.html); [part 7: pages 1440 to 1465 (Monday, October 16, 2023 (continued))](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-7.html); [part 8: pages 1465 to 1507 (Monday, October 16, 2023 (continued); Tuesday, October 17, 2023)](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-8.html); [part 9: pages 1507 to 1532 (Tuesday, October 17, 2023 (continued))](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-9.html); [part 10: pages 1532 to 1555 (Tuesday, October 17, 2023 (continued))](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-10.html); [part 11: pages 1555 to 1582 (Tuesday, October 17, 2023 (continued))](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-11.html); [part 12: pages 1582 to 1606 (Tuesday, October 17, 2023 (continued))](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-12.html); [part 13: pages 1606 to 1623 (Tuesday, October 17, 2023 (continued))](trial-testimony-2023-10-16-17-part-13.html). - It was made from a text extraction of the transcript for the two trial days and then compared by machine, line by line, with the PDFs of the court reporter’s transcript that are held here: each of the 7,473 lines of the testimony holds the same words at the same page and line number as in the PDF. The held PDFs do not bear the filing stamp of the court’s docket; the copies filed on the docket are ECF Nos. 366 and 368. If this text differs from the official transcript, the official transcript controls. - A marker such as `[1604:12]` gives the transcript page and line at which the text after it begins. There is a marker at the start of every paragraph and wherever a new page begins, so `[1604:1]` is the top of page 1604. Court filings cite the same page numbers: “Trial Tr. at 1604” means page 1604. - The original is typed 25 numbered lines to a page. Here each paragraph runs on as ordinary text. The line numbers, the reporter’s running header and footer, and the double spaces of the typescript are not reproduced. The line number in each marker is the number printed beside that line in the PDF. 18 pages are not full. The reporter’s note “(Continued on next page)”, which stands at the foot of 17 pages, is left out. - It covers the testimony from the moment the witness was called until he was excused, including the conferences at the bench and the discussions between the judge and the lawyers that took place in between. The places where the transcript for these two days is not reproduced, and the pages that are sealed, are noted in italics. - A paragraph begins here where the typescript labels a question, an answer or a speaker, or indents a line. The heading of each examination and the caption that names the witness are each kept as one paragraph. - The speaker labels, including Q. and A., are set in bold for readability; the original does not do that. The two headings that give the date were added. Dashes are reproduced as they appear, which differs between the court reporters who took turns: some typed `--` and some typed long dashes. - Nothing has been corrected.