Court documents in my case: United States v. Nishad Singh, No. 22-cr-673 (S.D.N.Y.)

It’s hard for cooperating witnesses to say much of substance about their case. It’s strictly precluded before sentencing. Even after sentencing, settlement agreements (with federal agencies) can limit what cooperating witnesses are allowed to honestly say about their case.1

Often when someone asks me a question about FTX, and especially when it's a question about me, the best I can do is gesture at the existing public court documents and encourage careful reading. I know I’m asking for a lot of labor in these cases, so it needn’t also be so logistically painful to find and read those documents.

So I’ve collected the public court docs relevant to my case here. Each PDF has a text transcription (with all differences noted below) to make consuming and searching them easy for AIs and people who use screen readers.

With the exception of the following few paragraphs, everything published on this site is part of the pre-existing public record.

I feel awful about the catastrophic harm FTX caused, and I accept full responsibility for my contributions to it. I pled guilty to six criminal counts, and I am in no way putting up this site to minimize my failings. To the contrary, all the docs describe my guilt. Some are in my words, some the prosecutors’, some my legal team’s, and some the judge’s. None set out my reasoning for my conduct, let alone aim to serve as a defense. Their job was to describe my actions, not justify them.

Still, the official court docs diverge meaningfully from much of the early public reporting on me.

For the year following FTX’s collapse in Nov ’22, reporting was based on allegations and lawsuits to which, as a cooperating witness with SDNY, I could not respond.

The evidence and testimony at trial in October ’23 contradicted much of the early reporting about me. One claim that still circulates is that I wrote the “allow negative” feature so Alameda could steal FTX customer funds. Gary Wang and I both testified that the original version of "allow negative" I wrote was to allow FTX staff to transfer locked FTT tokens. In that original version, an account could go negative in one currency only if it held enough in other currencies to cover that balance, and then some. Gary later changed the code, without my involvement, so Alameda could withdraw funds beyond that limit.2

The trial testimony also clarified that I learned of the shortfall in customer funds only two months before FTX’s collapse. It touched briefly on what I did after choosing to stay.3 Still, most claims about my conduct weren’t addressed: the trial was Sam’s, not mine.

Two years after the collapse, in October ’24, the first materials offering a more detailed account of my conduct were released: the sentencing memo from the prosecution, the memo from my legal team, and the court transcript of the sentencing proceeding itself. The judge sentenced me to time served (i.e. no jail time) and three years of supervised release.

After the collapse, I voluntarily forfeited assets I still had access to, in the hopes that their proceeds would be quickly disbursed to victims. This included all my shares in Anthropic that I purchased before I participated in any criminal conspiracy. Around the time of my sentencing in October ’24, I accepted financial liability for the entirety of the scheme’s forfeiture judgment, around $11 billion, and turned over effectively all of the rest of what I had earned in my life. (ECF No. 531 at 16)

Documents

The case is United States v. Nishad Singh, No. 22-cr-673 (LAK), in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York, before Judge Lewis A. Kaplan. “ECF No.” is the number of a filing on the court’s docket. The table is a selection, not the whole docket.

Date Document Read it here PDF
October 16 and 17, 2023 Trial testimony (ECF Nos. 366 and 368).

Note: Direct examination by the government begins at page 1298 (ECF No. 366), cross-examination by Bankman-Fried’s counsel at page 1492 (ECF No. 368), and redirect at page 1618. My account of when and how I learned of the hole in customer funds, my choice to stay and become complicit in the conspiracy, and my actions in the short period before the collapse is mainly at pages 1388 to 1417 and 1456 to 1473.
Web page · plain text Copies here: October 16 · October 17. The docket’s copies: ECF No. 366 · ECF No. 368 (CourtListener)
October 16, 2024 Sentencing submission on behalf of Nishad Singh (ECF No. 523), written by my lawyers. The public filing is redacted in places.

Note: preliminary statement (pages 2 to 4), Singh’s personal history (pages 5 to 24), role in the offense conduct (pages 25 to 45), remorse and cooperation (pages 46 to 50), life since FTX’s collapse (pages 51 to 53), sentencing guidelines and statutory factors (pages 54 to 62).
Web page · plain text Copy here · CourtListener · The New York Times, with the exhibits
October 16, 2024 Exhibit A to that submission (ECF No. 523-1): “Sentencing Letters Submitted On Behalf of Nishad Singh”, 105 letters to the Court with an index of letters. 210 pages. The public filing is redacted in places.

Note: Letters to the judge from family, friends, former colleagues and others, among them eighteen former employees of FTX and Alameda (ECF No. 523 at 2).
Web page · plain text The New York Times’s PDF of the submission and its exhibits · the court’s docket (PACER)
October 16, 2024 Exhibit B to that submission (ECF No. 523-2): My letter to Judge Kaplan, dated October 14, 2024. Web page · plain text CourtListener
October 23, 2024 Government’s sentencing letter (ECF No. 526), from the United States Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York to Judge Kaplan.

Note: The prosecutors’ own account of what I did (pages 2 to 9) and of my cooperation (pages 11 to 16), dated October 23, 2024.
Web page · plain text Copy here · CourtListener
October 30, 2024 Sentencing hearing transcript (ECF No. 531).

Note: Judge Kaplan, who presided over Bankman-Fried’s trial, sentenced me to time served (ECF No. 531 at 30). His remarks on my role are at pages 28 to 30. My counsel answered select press reports about me at page 17, and the prosecutor spoke at pages 23 to 27.
Web page · plain text Copy here. The transcript is ECF No. 531 on the court’s docket, which is available through PACER.

About the text versions

I used software to turn the PDFs into text, except for the trial testimony, for which the court report's transcript was already in text form. All the original documents are also available on this site. All of the changes made in the process of these conversions was described below:

I added a table of contents to some long files and and markers indicating original page boundaries in the PDF. E.g. [ECF p. 10] in a transcript corresponds to its PDF version's page 10, and [30:8] in a transcript refers to its PDF's contents on page 30, line 8. Footnotes in transcripts and filings are inlined after the paragraph that cites them. I left out the line breaks inside paragraphs and some things that repeat on every page: stamps, page and line numbers, some headers and footers.

There are some other markers in the text.[REDACTED] indicates that the passage was already redacted in the public filing. In the letters to the judge (Exhibit A), I also removed contact information (email addresses, phone numbers, fax numbers, street addresses) where they weren't already redacted. Each of those omissions is indicated by [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: …]. Any other omissions are listed in the document’s end note.

2 At trial, Gary said “allow negative” was created when Sam asked us to enable payments for FTX expenses, including FTT-related expenses (Trial Tr. 352:22–353:12). I likewise testified that I built the feature and an associated page for staff to transfer locked FTT (Trial Tr. 1365:17–1366:10, ECF No. 523 at 26–27 & n. 10). My original version of the feature enforced a collateral limit that would have prevented theft. I testified that changes in 2020 removed that limit and exempted Alameda from automatic liquidation (Trial Tr. 1362:25–1363:24). In their sentencing letter, the prosecutors corroborated my understanding of the feature’s original purpose and attributed to Gary the later changes that enabled the theft by letting Alameda withdraw funds it did not have and avoid automatic liquidation (Government’s sentencing letter, ECF No. 526 at 2–3). At sentencing, my counsel described how Sam and Gary later changed the behavior of the code I wrote to enable theft of customer funds without my knowledge (Sentencing hearing, ECF No. 531 at 17). ↩

3 Trial Tr. 1403–1405 (learning of the shortfall), 1409:15–20 (choosing to stay), and 1413:20–1414:13 (efforts to cut spending). ↩