UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
vs.
NISHAD SINGH,
Defendant.
Case No. 22-CR-00673
SENTENCING SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF NISHAD SINGH
REDACTED PUBLIC FILING
I. PRELIMINARY STATEMENT
Nishad Singh is a unique criminal defendant, and his sentence should reflect who he is and his role in this case. He is situated differently not only from Sam Bankman-Fried and Ryan Salame, but also from the other cooperators who pled guilty in the wake of the collapse of FTX. Indeed, his circumstances are extraordinary in every way that matters to sentencing: his personal history and characteristics, his role in the charged offenses, the speed with which he cooperated, his response to the collapse of FTX, and how he has rebuilt his life since then.
First, the person Nishad is. He is an uncommonly selfless individual who, at barely 29 years old, has lived a life of remarkably good works. More than 100 people from all aspects of Nishad’s life – including before, during, and after his time at FTX – have submitted letters on his behalf, an outpouring of support from those who truly know him. The letters detail example after example of Nishad’s consideration of and help for others, from waking up at 5am to run and train with a socially isolated young girl who had developmental challenges, to quietly donating the proceeds from a college internship for the purchase of bed nets in Africa, to personally taking a young unhoused individual suffering from severe cellulitis to the hospital and staying by his side until he received care. At Alameda and then FTX, Nishad began as a novice programmer and was later promoted to manage junior members of the engineering team precisely because others recognized his unparalleled work ethic, his sense of empathy for others, and his commitment to supporting his team. Eighteen former FTX and Alameda employees – all of whom are aware of Nishad’s criminal conduct – nonetheless steadfastly support him and have provided letters demonstrating what a truly special colleague he was.
Second, Nishad’s role in the charged offenses. Put simply, his role was far more limited than any other defendant. He does not minimize his conduct; he pled guilty to serious crimes at the outset of this case and will regret his actions for the rest of his life. But his sentence should recognize that Nishad did not join the conspiracy at the heart of this case – the theft of FTX customer funds – until September 2022, just two months before the collapse of FTX, and after the core decisions were made by Sam Bankman-Fried and Caroline Ellison to use billions of dollars [ECF p. 3] in customer funds to shore up Alameda’s finances and pay back its lenders. Nishad was not part of that conduct. And even as Nishad became complicit in the fraud in its final two months, hiding the awful truth from customers and fellow employees, he simultaneously tried in multiple ways to get Bankman-Fried to cut back on expenditures and conserve funds. With respect to the campaign finance conspiracy, Nishad allowed himself to be used as a straw at other people’s direction and for other people’s benefit. His role was almost entirely passive.
Third, Nishad’s cooperation. It was immediate and exemplary. As customers started trying to pull their money out of FTX, Nishad separated himself from Bankman-Fried and other employees as they put out misleading public statements trying to persuade customers not to make withdrawals. Nishad then left the Bahamas before FTX declared bankruptcy and immediately began taking screenshots of Signal messages that became critical to the government’s prosecution. He had his counsel reach out to the government on November 14 – within three days of FTX’s announcement that it would declare bankruptcy – and he flew to New York for the first of more than 20 proffer sessions one week later, on November 21. The evidence Nishad provided in those early meetings was critical to helping the government bring both Sam Bankman-Fried and Ryan Salame to justice.
Fourth, the way Nishad has responded to the events of this case. At the time of FTX’s collapse, Nishad was shattered and on the brink of suicide as he came to terms with how he and FTX had hurt so many people. His reaction reflected his moral compass: he knew he had become part of something that was so contrary to his values that he could no longer function. Since then he has done everything he can to try to make things right and turn his life around. In addition to cooperating with SDNY, multiple other government agencies, the bankruptcy estate, and the plaintiffs in the MDL class action, Nishad has found full time employment as a software engineer and has become an “invaluable” employee who is “beloved” by his colleagues; he volunteers regularly at a daytime sanctuary for the unhoused in San Francisco; he became engaged to his now-fiancée and has started running ultramarathons again; in his extra time he is building software for an affordable housing project; and with the support of his family and a commitment to therapy, [ECF p. 4] his mental health has steadily improved. The Court’s sentence should recognize the progress Nishad has made and the exemplary life he is committed to leading.
At the sentencing of Caroline Ellison, the Court distinguished her conduct from that of Bankman-Fried and recognized her extensive cooperation, but imposed a term of incarceration in part to show that cooperation cannot be a “get out of jail free card” given the seriousness of her actions. That message is unnecessary in fashioning an appropriate sentence for Nishad. Nishad’s situation is different first and foremost because of his far more limited role in the charged offenses. It is critical to encourage people in Nishad’s position, with lesser levels of culpability, to cooperate with the government – and to do so in the immediate and exemplary way Nishad did here. The Court also should consider Nishad’s exceptional character and record of charitable works as evidenced by the unprecedented support accompanying this submission, and the way he has rebuilt his life since the collapse of FTX, dedicating his energies to helping others and demonstrating genuine rehabilitation. We respectfully submit that the only appropriate sentence for Nishad, given all of these circumstances, is time served and a period of supervised release.
II. PERSONAL HISTORY
A. Family Background
Nishad was born in 1995 and raised in the Bay Area of California. Pre-Sentence Report, ECF No. 513 (“PSR”) ¶ 74. He is the first person in his family born in America. Nishad’s younger brother Malhar was born two years later; the two remain the closest of friends to this day.
Nishad’s parents grew up in India with modest means. Nishad’s mother was raised in a single-room home, sharing an outdoor bathroom with three other families. Ex. A at 41 (A. Singh). She followed her brother to the United States, where she earned a doctorate in psychology. Nishad’s father was able to immigrate to the U.S. by virtue of a scholarship to study electrical engineering, and arrived with “only a suitcase and $600.” Ex. A at 45 (G. Singh). They worked hard to provide a community-centric life for Nishad and Malhar, raising them at first “in a shared home with [their] cousins, aunt, uncle, and two other family friends.” Ex. A at 52 (M. Singh); see Ex. A at 41 (A. Singh) (explaining that Nishad grew up calling everyone in the home “aunt,” “uncle,” or “cousin,” even though not all were related by blood, because they were family “in the only ways that matter”). As Nishad’s parents found professional success in the U.S., in many ways achieving the American dream, they took great care to impart the values of hard work, selflessness, and compassion to their children.
Even as a child, Nishad had an extraordinary capacity for kindness, empathy, and generosity. Appended to this submission are letter after letter recounting Nishad’s uniquely compassionate nature from a young age and continuing through every stage of his life. He was the six year-old who connected with a young autistic boy being bullied by others and chose to play with the boy, often in silence; the eight year-old who comforted his distraught and panicking aunt on the way to the hospital while he was having a severe asthma attack; and the 10 year-old who approached his close friend’s mother after seeing her crying to give her a hug and tell her everything would be okay. Ex. A at 193 (I. Almeia), 110 (V. Redmore), 198 (L. Patil).
At the age of seven, Nishad visited India with his parents for a wedding. His mother described the impact it had on Nishad, and on her: “At the edge of the party, mothers and their children were begging for food, arms reaching through the gates.” Ex. A at 41 (A. Singh). Nishad’s mother, despite having grown up around such poverty, was “ashamed to admit that [she] barely registered” the women and children. Id. But “Nishu tugged at my sari and asked if they were okay. Through his young eyes, I saw clearly again. We discreetly took food over and handed it through the gate.” Id. Throughout the evening, Nishad peppered his mother with questions about why everyone was ignoring the families in need. Nishad “couldn’t bear it,” and “[o]ver the rest of the trip, he gave away every toy he brought to children as we passed on the street.” Id. at 41–42.
Nishad’s middle school teacher, Jeffrey Nichols, “first met Nishad as a brilliant, compassionate, and empathetic 11-year-old student.” Ex. A at 65 (J. Nichols). “Nishad always stood out . . . you immediately recognize that he radiates goodness and compassion[.]” Id. During a field trip to San Francisco in the eighth grade, in “a moment he likely thought nobody noticed, he hung behind the class and gave [an unhoused] individual his lunch money for that day.” Id. Despite teaching hundreds of students over the years, Nichols specifically remembers Nishad’s acts of kindness, writing that “[i]t is not hyperbole to say that Nishad is one of the nicest people on the planet.” Id.
Nishad’s childhood classmate and lifelong friend, Connor Hegarty, reflects on their friendship. As children, Hegarty viewed Nishad as a “bit of a pushover” due to his “willingness to sacrifice his own wants” and “put others first.” Ex. A at 134 (C. Hegarty). With age, he came to see Nishad’s generosity instead as a “strength.” Id. Hegarty explains:
My perception of [Nishad’s] kindness is not the result of any one event, but an accumulation of decades of consistent behavior. Years and years of consistent small actions and words that have resulted in my tremendous respect for his character. He’s not kind in performative ways, or generous only when convenient. His consideration for others permeates his thinking and his actions, and I’m honored to consider him one of my best friends to this day.
Id. at 135 (emphasis added).
B. High School & College
For high school, Nishad attended Crystal Springs Upland School in the Bay Area, where he became close friends with Gabe Bankman-Fried. PSR ¶ 90; Trial Tr. 1301:20–1302:1, 2310:21–24; see Ex. A at 143 (G. Bankman-Fried). During this time, Nishad met Sam Bankman-Fried, though Sam was older and Nishad largely only saw him in passing. Trial Tr. at 2310:20–24. Gabe, who has not seen or spoken to Nishad in the two years since FTX’s collapse, submitted a letter in which he describes Nishad as “one of the kindest people [he has] ever known,” writing:
Nishad had his struggles, but he handled them with grace. When Nishad felt insecure, instead of bragging to compensate, he would apologize for the tiniest of missteps – and when his friends would tell him to stop apologizing so much, he would apologize for that too. When Nishad felt stressed, he would bottle it up to avoid burdening his friends. When Nishad felt tension with someone, he would often blame himself, working tirelessly to get along with him even when others could see they didn’t deserve the effort.
Ex. A at 143 (G. Bankman-Fried).
When Nishad started high school, he was eager to pursue athletics, something that his asthma had made difficult throughout most of his childhood. He joined but struggled to perform well on the high school cross country team, still limited by his breathing. Nishad’s family friend Samir Vaidya (whom he calls his “cousin”) explains how Nishad responded: “like he always does, he figured out a way to solve his problems: by running longer but slower.” Ex. A at 122 (S. Vaidya). Inspired by his mother’s own long-distance running, Nishad went on to run marathons and eventually ultramarathons (i.e., races longer than 26.2 miles). At the age of fifteen, Nishad completed his first 100-mile run—a distance regarded by many as the pinnacle accomplishment of ultramarathoning—while raising money for the Allergy and Asthma Foundation of America. Ex. A at 191 (A. Simha).
The same compassion he showed as a child continued in his approach to sport. For instance, Nishad would stay with struggling runners until medical attention arrived, sacrificing his [ECF p. 8] own race times. Ex. A at 49 (R. Patel). He encouraged and supported Vaidya, who struggled with his weight at the time, to run with him. Vaidya recalls training with Nishad as “one of the most important health choices [he] ever made and it is all thanks to Nishad.” Ex. A at 122 (S. Vaidya). Nishad’s then-coach, now stepfather, shares how Nishad volunteered to help a “socially isolated, young girl with developmental challenges” train to become a runner. Ex. A at 50 (R. Patel). Nishad “would wake up very early at 5:00am and take her out for a run around the neighborhood. . . . His kindness and patience with her were so beautiful to watch.” Id. Both Vaidya and the young girl would go on to complete ultramarathons of their own. Id.
At the age of sixteen, Nishad ran a 100-mile race again, setting the world record for his age group while raising money for his high school. The same year, he helped train a boy named Miguel, who completed his own 100-miler the following year at the age of thirteen, breaking Nishad’s record. Ex. A at 50–51 (R. Patel). “Where others might have felt a pang of jealousy at being overtaken, Nishad’s heart swelled with pride. He celebrated Miguel’s achievement as if it were his own.” Id. at 51. “Nishad’s inner fire did not manifest itself as a zero-sum, competitive drive. . . . He took joy in his victories, but also took real pride in those of others.” Id. at 50.
Nishad was accepted into UC Berkeley with the same Regents Scholarship his father had received to come to the U.S., a merit-based full scholarship offered to a small number of students each year. See PSR ¶¶ 90–91. He ultimately graduated with a degree in electrical engineering and computer science with highest honors. Id. ¶ 91. As in childhood, Nishad continued to be characterized by his “dedication . . . toward[s] his friends and the people around him,” and would “often take just as much time helping [his friends] as he would completing his own project[s].” Ex. A at 154 (I. Yang), 160 (R. Varadarajan); see, e.g., Ex. A at 152 (C. Zumar). One classmate recalls “Nishad patiently walking a group or 5 or 6 of us through . . . the key to solving the problem we’d all been stuck for 3-4 hours on . . . without a hint of ego, . . . simply a desire to help.” Ex. A at 162 (V. Tolani). Another classmate remembers not learning until years after they graduated that Nishad had excelled academically, writing:
I was surprised because Nishad never exhibited anything but gratefulness to be studying with us and always made the rest of us feel respected and admired. In hindsight I shouldn’t have been, this was quintessential Nishad: I think he really was grateful, really did admire us, and really did outperform us, all at the same time.
Ex. A at 167 (S. Kobori).
In keeping with his character for selflessness, Nishad started practicing effective altruism on a small scale while in college. As one classmate recalls, Nishad “was never boastful of it, and it was only in circles of his closest friends where he would open up about raising awareness for animal rights” or donating “internship proceeds to buying bed nets to prevent Malaria in Africa.” Ex. A at 160 (R. Varadarajan). Another friend shares that in such discussions, Nishad was “self-perceptive and humble” and “would jokingly lambaste himself. . . . Nishad would find a way to downplay his own actions.” Ex. A at 157 (R. Mukherjee).
At Berkeley, Nishad met Claire Watanabe, his now fiancée. PSR ¶ 78. Claire’s initial impression was that she “hadn’t met anyone with a bigger heart or a greater willingness to act on it.” Ex. A at 35 (C. Watanabe). She shares several moments that stand out. Once, during a flight, Nishad sat next to an “older gentleman named Stan, who had recently lost his wife and was heartbroken.” Id. at 38. “They spoke for hours” about Stan’s life and his upcoming move to be closer to his adult children. Id. After they exited the flight, Nishad stopped midway through the terminal and ran back to Stan, and offered him his phone number, stating, “If you need help with the move or anything else, please let me know—it would make my day.” Id. Another deeply personal act of kindness came when [REDACTED] Claire describes: “While this is my mom’s story of strength and courage, [ECF p. 10] Nishad’s proactive, thoughtful, and gentle support played a key role in making it possible. Having my mom healthy today is one of the greatest gifts I’ve ever and will likely ever receive.” Id.
Unsurprisingly, Claire’s relatives have come to consider Nishad “a cherished” and “integral part” of their family. Ex. A at 89 (J. Whitsitt), 86 (E. Schroader). Claire’s only sibling, Erick Watanabe, considers Nishad “one of the best people that [he] know[s],” sharing how after FTX’s collapse, Nishad helped him transition into a career in software engineering: “Despite everything on his plate, he met with me weekly for over a year, creating a personalized list of practice problems and running mock interviews. His thoughtfulness and commitment, even in such a difficult time for him, was extraordinary.” Ex. A at 92 (E. Watanabe). On trips to Claire’s family’s farm in rural Indiana, including while Nishad was at the height of his wealth at FTX, he always volunteered for the least desirable tasks, like “cleaning out the nasty, neglected cellar,” sleeping in an “RV travel trailer behind the house,” or being the “designated dish do-er.” Ex. A at 90 (D. Binford), 88 (J. Whitsitt), 84 (B. E. Schroader). On one such trip, Nishad spent time with Elizabeth, a cousin of Claire’s who had been diagnosed with incurable brain cancer in 2019 at the age of 30. Ex. A at 90 (D. Binford). The trip wound up being Elizabeth’s last; her mother recalls, “I came to check on her, and I found Nishad spoon feeding her. No one else was around. No one asked him. He just saw the need and stepped up to help. It almost brought me to tears.” Id.
C. Nishad’s First Job
After graduating from Berkeley, Nishad started his professional career as a software engineer at Facebook, finally being able to work towards his desire to “earn to give.” Nishad’s father, concerned that he might not save enough for his own future, connected him with a financial advisor. The advisor writes that “[w]hat struck” him about his conversations with Nishad seven years ago – from when Nishad was first entering the professional workforce – was his “preference to help others financially almost to the detriment of his own financial well-being.” Ex. A at 58 (N. Epstein). When advised about the benefits of fully funding his 401(k), Nishad “would counter with how it was more important to give away that same money.” Id. “Enriching himself was not his goal nor desire.” Id. His accountant, Alan Watters, explains that Nishad resembled his other [ECF p. 11] tech clients in some ways, but differed in his “remarkable generosity”; their “discussions centered around charitable donations from the start.” Ex. A at 57 (A. Watters).
After joining Facebook, Nishad began the team-matching process, where he explored different teams. He earned a spot with his top choice: the team building the Donations product, a feature that allows Facebook users to raise money for charities. Before accepting the spot, Nishad talked with Gabe Bankman-Fried, his high school friend, about an idea Nishad had to prioritize effective charities within the product. Gabe connected him to his brother, Sam, to help refine the idea. Nishad “barely knew Sam but he looked up to him as he had a reputation for being a genius” and for his then-stated devotion to charitable causes. Ex. A at 42 (A. Singh). Nishad pitched his idea to the Donations team, but did not succeed, and left feeling discouraged. Id. Although Nishad eventually joined a separate, prestigious machine learning team at Facebook, he remained unfulfilled. Claire writes, “Nishad felt disconnected from his values and what he actually wanted to contribute to the world.” Ex. A at 35 (C. Watanabe).
Shortly after, Sam Bankman-Fried called Nishad and told him about his venture, Alameda Research. Nishad visited Alameda’s offices in late 2017. “[E]veryone he chatted with seemed at the time to share Nishad’s values . . . The group had pledged to donate 50% of Alameda’s profits to charity and were willing to work long, hard hours.” Ex. A at 35 (C. Watanabe). “Nishad was blown away . . . Here was an opportunity where Nishad could more directly affect positive change, and at a scale way beyond what he thought was individually possible.” Id.
Because Nishad was still relatively unknown to Bankman-Fried and a novice engineer only six months out of college, Bankman-Fried requested Nishad complete an informal trial period before he would offer a full-time job. Nishad spent multiple weeks volunteering his nights and evenings “on a trial basis at Alameda.” Ex. A at 45 (G. Singh). After receiving a formal job offer, Nishad was on the fence about leaving his secure job at Facebook. Nishad invited his father to visit the Alameda office to get his advice about moving forward with the potential job switch. Id. Eventually, one of Alameda’s senior employees said they would personally donate $50,000 to [ECF p. 12] charity if Nishad accepted the job offer that week. Ex. A at 36 (C. Watanabe). The magnitude and unhesitating commitment behind that donation was enough for Nishad to agree to say yes.