Sentencing Submission on Behalf of Nishad Singh, part 4 of 6 (ECF pages 36 to 45)

[This part begins partway down ECF page 36.]

6. November 2022: Nishad and the Collapse of FTX

Nishad’s naivete in thinking that collapse could be prevented was shattered within two months when the run on the exchange began. As events unfolded in November 2022, Nishad first attempted to assist in the efforts to track and locate assets, and advocated – repeatedly and unsuccessfully – to Bankman-Fried and Wang that FTX freeze further customer withdrawals. Trial Tr. at 1465:12–13. But the enormity of what was happening, and Nishad’s coming to terms with the fact that he had been complicit in perpetrating and hiding it for the past two months, proved too much to bear. Within a couple days, Nishad found himself unable to cope. He was devastated, distraught, and ultimately suicidal.

During those final days, Nishad saw Bankman-Fried and others plan to put out false and misleading statements to try to dissuade customers from withdrawing assets. Nishad refused to go along. On November 6, 2022, a group of employees were “workshopping” false and misleading tweets for Bankman-Fried to make, “discussing whether or not to characterize FTX as solvent or well capitalized.” Trial Tr. at 1464:15–23. Nishad made clear he was “not comfortable” with the “really dishonest” tweet ideas. Id at 1464:17–18, 1465:12. After acknowledging that he did not “have the power to stop them,” Nishad leaned over the couch and told the group that he was “recusing” himself from the discussion—which the group “acknowledged in a kind of annoyed way.” Id. at 1464:8–22. What proceeded was the now-infamous “FTX is fine; assets are fine” tweet. Two days later, Nishad also asked that Bankman-Fried tell others to refrain from saying anything misleading and urged Bankman-Fried to accept responsibility in a direct Signal chat. Id. at 1472:8–21; see GX 480C.

Deeply ashamed about his own role in the customer fraud scheme, Nishad spent much of his time apologizing to those of his friends and colleagues who had not known of the hole, though he did not have the words or mental state to do so coherently. Adam Yedidia, a trial witness, describes how “[i]n the final week, as FTX was collapsing, [Nishad] came to my room and apologized, sobbing on the floor, completely inconsolable.” In Yedidia’s mind, “there is no doubt [ECF p. 37] whatsoever that Nishad was deeply contrite and felt enormously guilty for what happened.” Ex. A at 7 (A. Yedidia). Can Sun testified at trial about a scene in the final days: “Nishad was sitting there. His entire face was pale, grey. It looked like his soul had been plucked away from him.” Trial Tr. at 1958:10–16. And in private moments, Nishad’s fiancée Claire attempted to “convince him hourly why he shouldn’t kill himself,” “frantically reach[ing] out to psychiatrists.” Ex. A at 39 (C. Watanabe). “His teammates, not even fully aware of his mental state, sent [Claire] a constant stream of messages asking how they could help him, and telling me they loved him.” Id. The night of Tuesday, November 8th, “about ten of the people he worked closest with, mostly customer support and engineers, came to him. They formed a line to give him a hug, one-by-one. He couldn’t stop apologizing to every one of them.” Id. Gabe Bankman-Fried, who has not spoken to Nishad in two years but “think[s] about him most days,” shares the following story:

In November of 2022, I learned as the world did about FTX’s crash. As it was happening, Sam called me, and told me that Nishad needed me, so I flew to Nassau to comfort Nishad. What I found was a broken man. He was unable to speak. Unable to cry. He was shocked by the weight of what was happening. For a man that had lived a life of kindness, both to friends and strangers, he never could have imagined he would play a role, however small, in something that hurt people. I never could have imagined that either. As we held each other in his room in Nassau, he told me that the only thing keeping him from killing himself was that he couldn’t do that to his family and friends.

Ex. A at 143 (G. Bankman-Fried).

On the morning of November 10th, while the efforts to track assets and stave off collapse were still ongoing, Nishad, Claire, and their dog Gopher got on a plane to return to the United States. Nishad did not remain around for the final couple of days, so he did not participate in Bankman-Fried’s efforts, aided by Wang, to transfer assets to the custody of Bahamas regulators. Instead, Nishad retreated into the care of his family in California. When he arrived home, his mother writes, “I held him as tightly as I could, rocking him back and forth as he wept . . . He was [ECF p. 38] riddled with guilt and consumed by shame.” Ex. A at 43–44 (A. Singh). His fiancée Claire writes of that time:

It’s hard to convey just how deeply Nishad’s soul was broken. His mind could only think of the suffering and pain: of his family, his girlfriend, his team, the public and the tens of thousands of customers who trusted them . . . The cognitive dissonance between who he believed he was and the person staring back at him in the mirror was more than he could handle.

Two days after we arrived in the U.S., Nishad asked me about suicide and forgiveness again. I’m not sure where I found the composure but I responded something along the lines of ‘If we truly believe your future holds nothing but sadness and shame, then yes, I’ll find a way to forgive you. But we’re not certain of that yet so let’s wait to confirm before deciding anything.’ Nishad listened. I still remember his dark, sunken eyes. After a long moment of silence, he agreed.

Ex. A at 39 (C. Watanabe).

As the Government stated in its closing argument in describing Nishad’s mental state upon learning of the fraud: “He was shocked, he was blindsided, and eventually he was suicidal. That is not somebody who didn’t think he was doing anything wrong.” Trial Tr. at 3126:11–24. For someone who set out on the Alameda and then FTX journey because he believed it to be a force for good – a way for him and others to use earnings generated by both entities to donate to important causes – the realization that not only had it been a force for evil, but that he had participated in it, was nearly too much to bear. Nishad’s reaction – the utter and pure guilt that wracked him in the final days and beyond – stands out among his co-defendants, even though they had been living with the truth for much longer. He understood what he had done, and what was so devastating was how his actions had been inconsistent with how he saw himself and what he had spent his whole life standing up for. And he has spent every day since then trying to make things right – including, as described below, by beginning to cooperate within days of the collapse.

B. Investor Fraud (Count Four)

Nishad pled guilty to one count of securities fraud for defrauding FTX’s investors. The [ECF p. 39] basis for this plea was principally two-fold: first, in the final two months after learning about the hole in customer funds, Nishad “understood [] implicitly that [Bankman-Fried] would not share FTX’s full financial condition” with investors from whom the company was attempting to raise money to plug the hole. Plea Hr’g Tr. at 29:22–30:18. Nishad played no affirmative role in those fundraising efforts, but he effectively assented to them.

Second, Nishad participated in an effort to artificially create and then shift earnings from EcoSerum, an entity controlled by Bankman-Fried, to FTX in an effort to make FTX’s 2021 revenue exceed $1 billion. As Nishad informed the Government and testified to at trial, on December 30th or 31st, 2021, he was looped into a conversation between Bankman-Fried, Wang, and possibly others, about ways to have FTX’s revenue exceed $1 billion, given that it was likely to fall just short. Trial Tr. at 1446:9–12, 1447:14–16. Bankman-Fried decided to retroactively have EcoSerum pay FTX for “staking fees” (or interest payments for tokens that are held by FTX for a set period) for the Serum token, thereby increasing FTX’s revenue. Id. at 1446:15–1447:13. Although Serum was technically promoted by an entirely separate entity (Eco Serum), that entity too was controlled by Bankman-Fried. Id. at 1445:24–1446:1.

To effectuate his plan, Bankman-Fried instructed Nishad “to make it appear as though [Eco Serum] had been getting charged throughout the year,” even though it had not been, and, in the FTX code, “to backdate the transactions associated with paying this fee.” Trial Tr. at 1447:21–25. Nishad did so at Bankman-Fried’s direction. He was not involved in other aspects of the plan, which apparently involved creating a false contract between FTX and Eco Serum to support these backdated transactions. Id. at 1455:1–3. But Nishad knew it was wrong to backdate the transactions, did so at Bankman-Fried’s direction, and is deeply sorry for his actions.

Importantly, the Government did not know about this conduct – including both Bankman-Fried’s fraudulent plan and Nishad’s role in it – until Nishad affirmatively brought it to the prosecutors’ attention during proffer sessions. It was not part of the main investor fraud under investigation, but Nishad nonetheless volunteered this set of facts to the Government as part of his effort to disclose any and all wrongful conduct. He then took responsibility and pleaded guilty to [ECF p. 40] his role, even though it is not clear that he would or could otherwise have been charged with any crime related to it, and it is unlikely that the Government would have discovered the issue without Nishad bringing it to the Government’s attention. In addition, because of Nishad’s proffer of information, the Government was able to locate a copy of the doctored contract Bankman-Fried made to support these backdated transactions, and used that contract during trial to corroborate Nishad’s testimony and offer further proof against Bankman-Fried. See GX 323.

C. Campaign Finance Violations and Money Laundering (Counts Five and Six)

1. Nishad’s Donations Begin With an Altruistic Focus

Nishad has always been determined to live a life of giving. He joined Alameda to be able to donate more substantially, and after getting there he donated much of his bonuses to initiatives he cared about such as Proposition 12 (the Prevention of Cruelty to Farm Animals Act) in California. Trial Tr. at 1571:1–6. Around the same time, Nishad watched with admiration as his friend Gabe Bankman-Fried left a lucrative career at Jane Street to work in Washington, DC with a goal of eventually lobbying for legislation about their shared goals: principally, animal welfare and pandemic preparedness.

In 2020, as he began to earn more money, Nishad began to solicit both Gabe’s advice and the advice of Barbara Fried – Gabe and Sam’s mother and herself the co-founder of a political fundraising organization – about where to donate. Nishad originally donated from his personal Wells Fargo account; that account ultimately did not have high enough withdrawal limits for these larger donations, so a member of FTX’s financial operations team opened a Prime Trust bank account (with higher limits) for Nishad. Though recommended by Gabe and Barbara, these early donations were targeted toward organizations that Nishad believed in and were consistent with his values. For most of those early donations, the funding came both from Nishad himself and from funds that Nishad genuinely believed (as his documented repayment attempts demonstrate) he was borrowing from Sam Bankman-Fried. Bankman-Fried would delay fulfilling Nishad’s requests to sell Nishad’s FTT tokens in order to make donations, telling Nishad that he would prefer to work out the details at a later time (which he would not do) and that in the interim, he would lend Nishad [ECF p. 41] the money.

In addition, throughout his time at Alameda and then FTX, Nishad was in frequent touch with an established charitable grantmaking foundation about giving, and solicited its advice about where to donate. Nishad sought to donate larger amounts, but his time grew more scarce as his work at FTX became all-consuming. In a communication in 2021 with this grantmaking organization, Nishad wrote:

It’s one of my regrets that I haven’t been searching hard enough for giving opportunities in the last few years… I can’t provide too much of my own time… I’m happy to do away with any formalities and just make the most of that dynamic. I’m pretty happy to receive advice / don’t take offense easily if the advice implies I’m making a mistake in how I give or spend my time / etc. I’d much rather get this right.

Ex. A at 36 (C. Watanabe).

In ensuing conversations, the grantmaking foundation suggested that what would be most useful from its perspective would be funds that they could disburse with little red tape. Nishad enthusiastically agreed, opening and funding a new Prime Trust bank account with several million dollars of his own money, and giving the grantmaking team access and authority to make grants on his behalf. When the grantmaking group wanted to make a disbursement with these funds, they would log into Nishad’s bank account and input the wire details, triggering a confirmation email to Nishad. Nishad would then be prompted by text message to click an ‘Approve’ button on the corresponding email, which Nishad would do. These donations were truly charitable, and Nishad neither sought nor obtained any recognition for them.

2. The Offense Conduct

Near the end of 2021, through conversations with Gabe Bankman-Fried, Nishad was persuaded to increase his political donating, while still of the view that these donations would go toward candidates and organizations that aligned with his priorities. After agreeing, Nishad was invited to a Signal channel called “Donations Processing.” At that point, including through the Signal channel, a large number of individuals – from Sam Bankman-Fried, to political consultants [ECF p. 42] working with Gabe, to Ryan Salame, to eventually former CFTC commissioner and then-FTX executive Mark Wetjen, among others – became involved in recommending, selecting and coordinating donations by numerous individuals at FTX, including Nishad. As 2022 progressed, this effort coincided – not coincidentally – with the 2022 midterm elections, and the resulting donations grew not only more frequent, but more crassly political and for the benefit of Sam Bankman-Fried and the FTX enterprise.

Nishad was typically delayed or forgetful in making recommended donations, and Sam Bankman-Fried suggested that Nishad offload the operational legwork by giving his Prime Trust bank account credentials (which had been set up by the company in the first place) directly to Salame, who Bankman-Fried explained was already doing the same for him. This was analogous to the setup Nishad had already arranged with the grantmaking foundation, and Nishad readily agreed to give Salame his credentials, especially as the Prime Trust Account was not his regular bank account. Nishad similarly signed blank checks from his bank account to be used for donations that did not accept wires. After this point, others – principally Salame – would handle all the donation logistics, including for Nishad’s donations, and Nishad’s involvement was typically limited, again, to clicking an “Approve” button on an email that would be sent to him to confirm the bank transfer. Even there, Nishad – distracted by his engineering responsibilities – almost always had to be prompted multiple times to click the button. See, e.g., GX 475 (Salame messages Nishad, “got about 30 small dollar ones rolling in if you can confirm in your email” and then “bumping” his previous message three hours later). Nishad almost never engaged in the Donations Processing Signal thread.

In one instance shared at trial, Nishad was confused about why he was being asked to donate to a particular PAC and asked Michael Sadowsky, one of Gabe’s associates, what the purpose was. Trial Tr. at 1434:22–1436:21; GX 477. Sadowsky attempted to persuade Nishad that the donation was ultimately for a candidate who was “good on pandemics,” a cause he knew Nishad cared about, but also conceded that the group was using Nishad as the “center left face of our spending,” which would require Nishad to give to a variety of causes, including “woke” ones. [ECF p. 43] Id. Nishad was uncomfortable, and said that he needed to think about it, but ultimately made the donation and continued to donate at the behest of the group – not for personal benefit but out a misguided sense that he should be a “team player”.

More problematically, Nishad also realized, as 2022 progressed, that Salame – or others on Salame’s team – must have been wiring Alameda money into Nishad’s Prime Trust account, in order for that money to be used for donations. Salame was generally responsible for the banking setup of both Alameda and FTX, and as such, had access not only to Nishad’s bank account, but also to Alameda’s and FTX’s. Some incoming money continued to be Nishad’s own – for example, Gabe Bankman-Fried would sometimes directly ask Nishad to make a political donation, and Nishad would transfer money from his personal FTX account to Prime Trust to do it. On other occasions, however, Salame would transfer Alameda money to Nishad’s Prime Trust account to facilitate donations being recommended by the larger group.

Because Nishad had ceded his account credentials, and was paying little attention to the process, he did not realize Alameda funds were being sent into his account for some time. But when he learned of it, he did not put a stop to it. At first, Nishad convinced himself to think of the incoming Alameda money as a loan; as noted above, he had been loaned funds in the past when Bankman-Fried told him not to sell FTT, and he could well have afforded to make these donations with his own funds. But Nishad also knew that if these were loans, they were so in the loosest sense. He thus came to understand that Alameda was funding donations made in his name, and by the fall of 2022 he knew that money from Alameda was effectively coming from FTX customer funds. As he stated in his plea allocution, while Nishad did not know whether any campaign finance laws were being violated, he understood that there was something duplicitous and misleading about his role in the process, including allowing his name to be used in this manner, and he chose not to investigate further.

3. Nishad’s Conduct, Relative Participation, and Government Assistance

We note all of the above because it provides relevant context for Nishad’s role in what was concededly a large campaign finance offense. That role was wholly unlike the role played by [ECF p. 44] Bankman-Fried or Salame. Fundamentally, Nishad started giving in sincere and legal ways, but eventually let himself be used as a straw. He began donating because he wanted to make it his life’s mission, and he took advice from many in the FTX and Effective Altruism orbits regarding where to donate. As time went on and especially in 2022, that advice was co-opted and diverted to a more plainly political purpose – and one Nishad was increasingly uncomfortable with. But he went along with it, and assented to the use of his bank account so that donations originating from Alameda could be registered as his own. That is exactly what a straw does, and that is why Nishad pleaded guilty. But it is also why he is far from similarly situated to the other implicated individuals. Indeed, it is not uncommon for individuals who play the role of straw to not be prosecuted federally, whereas the true source of funds (in this case, fundamentally Bankman-Fried) is prosecuted. Nishad pled guilty because he is guilty, felt ashamed by his participation in the offense, and wished to accept full responsibility as part of his cooperation. But it is important – even before his significant cooperation is factored in – to place his role in context.

What perhaps brings the distinction between Nishad and the other defendants into starkest relief is their motives, and the manner by which the others, unlike Nishad, used the scheme to accumulate political influence and reputational gain. Sam Bankman-Fried’s goal was to use the donations, including Nishad’s, to amass political power for FTX but also for himself. He regularly met with politicians and government officials (including Bill Clinton, Hillary Clinton, Ron Desantis, Kathy Hochul and others) and became a very public darling of certain politicians and political sectors. As Ellison testified, Bankman-Fried was “very interested in politics and talked about wanting to use his money to have influence in politics.” Trial Tr. at 650:15–19. Bankman-Fried even alluded to running for President of the United States at some point in the future. Id.

For his part, Salame acknowledged to this Court that he “coupled [his] donations with substantial and sustained political activity and engagement.” ECF No. 433 at 11. Salame’s donations similarly allowed him to meet with powerful politicians in Congress, including former leaders of both chambers, former Congressman Kevin McCarthy and Senator Mitch McConnell. Id. at 10–11. And still to this day, Salame boasts on his online social media profile that he was [ECF p. 45] formerly a “US Republican Mega-donor.”13

13 Ryan Salame (@rsalame7926), X (F/K/A TWITTER), https://x.com/rsalame7926.

Unlike Bankman-Fried or Salame, Nishad had no interest – whatsoever – in developing a political profile or exploiting his donations for personal influence or gain. With the exception of one local politician who was a friend of Nishad’s girlfriend before his involvement in politics, Nishad never once met or communicated with the recipients of his donations or any other political figures. He affirmatively did not want to be affiliated with or publicly noted for his giving or political activism. As noted above, he actively sought to stay off of any Forbes’ lists. And consistent with his general discomfort, he expressed outward disdain for Bankman-Fried’s efforts to spend time and money on meeting with high-profile political figures. And he is ashamed that what he wanted to be his life’s mission – donating for good – ended in precisely the opposite fashion.

Nishad’s relative culpability, in itself, is highly relevant to determining the appropriate measure of punishment – but of course it must also be coupled with his significant cooperation in the Government’s campaign finance investigation. Without Nishad’s cooperation, the Government may not have been able to charge Bankman-Fried, or to charge and convict Salame, for their respective roles. Nishad proffered on multiple occasions about the donations scheme, testified about it at Bankman-Fried’s trial, and stood ready to testify at any trial of Ryan Salame had he not pleaded guilty. And beyond his information and testimony, Nishad provided critical documents, including email communications, financial records, and – perhaps most importantly – the Donations Processing Signal chat (GX 475) showing how the scheme operated in real time. Nishad preserved this chat immediately upon leaving the Bahamas, and then turned it over to prosecutors. This evidence allowed the Government to bolster significantly its investigation into both Bankman-Fried and Salame – an investigation into conduct that may not have fully come to light without Nishad’s cooperation.