Sentencing Submission on Behalf of Nishad Singh, part 5 of 6 (ECF pages 46 to 53)

[ECF p. 46]

IV. NISHAD’S REMORSE AND COOPERATION

Nishad “feel[s] overwhelmed and [his] gut clenches when [he tries] to think about the enormity of the harm [he] caused and [took] part in.” Ex. B at 2. For that, he is “so incredibly sorry.” Id. As he told the Court when he pleaded guilty, his hope then was “that in accepting responsibility, assisting the government, and forfeiting assets, [he could] begin to make it right.” Plea Hr’g Tr. at 34:24–35:1. As Peter Buckley, who was in the Bahamas during FTX’s collapse, explains, “the person who took the situation the hardest was, by far, Nishad. He was deeply devastated, and clearly not because he had lost personal wealth or the fact that he might be in legal trouble. He felt terrible that all of the effort he had put into building a company that was meant to improve the world would instead cause pain, disappointment, and devastation.” Ex. A at 145 (P. Buckley). Another former FTX employee, Willie Kaufman, writes that during the collapse Nishad “expressed [] deep remorse and concern over the harm his actions had caused without a thought for himself.” Ex. A at 12–13 (W. Kaufman). During the Presentence Investigation process, Nishad explained his feelings of remorse and regret to the Probation Department:

[I] obviously failed in character and action, I am sickened by what I did and heartbroken by the pain I caused. . . . I tried to stay and fix things when I learned of the criminal scheme . . . [Comparing himself to a frog in a boiling pot] I was in that pot, but I was turning up the temperature, I now know not to turn up the temperature, even one degree. If I was watching the news about someone else who did what I did, I would loathe them, the scale is so enormous, I will never get over this, but I don’t think I should because I can only make a dent in fixing the harm I caused, I did too little and was too late to help.

PSR ¶ 49.

Consistent with Nishad’s understanding in the final days of FTX that he had participated in something deeply wrong, he was the first of the charged defendants to step away as the collapse unfolded. As noted above, in the days before he left the Bahamas, Nishad explicitly started to remove himself from various situations, including from discussions regarding convincing customers to keep their assets on the platform. See, e.g., Trial Tr. at 1415:3–12. He then left the [ECF p. 47] Bahamas before Bankman-Fried or Wang, and before Ellison left Hong Kong, flying to the Bay Area on November 10, 2022, where he has lived since. As Nishad left the Bahamas, he started to preserve evidence that he thought might be relevant to an investigation into FTX’s collapse. This included taking screenshots of Signal messages before they were automatically deleted pursuant to company policy. These screenshots presented a unique picture into FTX’s daily affairs, even before a collapse became inevitable, and were thus crucial pieces of evidence introduced at trial.14 No other witness or co-conspirator preserved as much documentary evidence introduced at trial as Nishad, and he did so very early on, because he wanted to do what he could to start to make things right.

14 This included the “Donations Processing” Signal chat showing how political donations were facilitated, GX 475, the Signal chat between Nishad and Bankman-Fried discussing inter alia who was responsible for the customer fraud scheme, GX 480C, the Signal chat between Nishad and Michael Sadowsky in which Nishad expressed hesitation about making a particular donation, GX 477, and finally, messages between Bankman-Fried and Ellison in the final days revealing that the fraud scheme weighed heavily on her, GX 480D. Although Nishad was not in the chat between Bankman-Fried and Ellison, he was able to preserve them because Bankman-Fried sent Nishad a screenshot of the conversation between Bankman-Fried and Ellison, and then Nishad subsequently took a screenshot of his entire conversation with Bankman-Fried – which included the screenshot between Bankman-Fried and Ellison. In the relevant message, Ellison wrote to Bankman-Fried, “I think I just had an increasing dread of this day that was weighing on me for a long time, and now that it’s actually happening, it just feels great to get it over with one way or another.” Trial Tr. at 914:8–11.

Consistent with his remorse and the steps he had already taken to preserve evidence, Nishad immediately began a dialogue with the Government regarding his desire to assist. He had no hesitation in cooperating, and within days of arriving back to the Bay Area, Nishad flew to New York and had his initial meeting with the Government on November 21, 2022.15

15 By contrast, Ellison began cooperating in December following the search of her family home and the seizure of her electronic devices and personal journal. Trial Tr. at 926:25–927:11.

As we anticipate will be described in the Government’s submission, Nishad’s cooperation has been timely, extensive, and significant. Prior to trial, he made seven cross-country trips to New York (paid for by family or Nishad’s salary from his new job, as Nishad has preserved all of his FTX-related assets for forfeiture) and had over 25 days of meetings with the Government and regulatory agencies. In addition, Nishad had multiple virtual meetings, including “coding” sessions in which he created primers for the CFTC’s software engineers explaining how FTX’s [ECF p. 48] code and database worked. Finally, as noted above, Nishad produced key internal messages shedding light on FTX’s affairs that the Government relied upon during trial.

As this Court knows, Nishad was the final cooperator to testify at trial. Over two days, he provided helpful, and emotional, trial testimony – including explaining the instances where he sought to curb Bankman-Fried’s excessive spending at FTX even in the face of public humiliation by Bankman-Fried, the tense moments when he confronted Bankman-Fried about the hole and the visible anger displayed by Bankman-Fried in response, and his shame and suicidality as he reckoned with the tremendous harm he caused to countless people through his own complicity – all before this Court, the jury, and the public.

Given the weight of Nishad’s direct examination, he unsurprisingly faced one of the toughest cross-examinations. Unlike the strategy taken for the other co-conspirators, Bankman-Fried’s counsel attempted to paint Nishad as a forgetful witness willing to say anything to please the Government. But painting Nishad as forgetful and willing to please did not work because Nishad’s testimony was credible and corroborated by other evidence. The Government relied on Nishad’s truthfulness and his candid and damaging testimony in both its main summation and in its rebuttal. Trial Tr. at 2918:5–6 (“Because to believe the defendant’s story . . . [y]ou would have to ignore the testimony of . . . Nishad Singh . . .”); 2962:3–5 (“Remember it was the defendant who really wanted to invest in K5. Nishad Singh told you about how he told the defendant it was an awful idea . . .”); 3124:3 (“. . . if you believe Nishad, the defendant is guilty.”).

In addition to his substantial cooperation, Nishad preserved all of his assets for forfeiture in this matter, including shares of an artificial intelligence company obtained in 2021 that have since increased in value by millions of dollars, as well as the home he purchased in Washington state. The vast majority of whatever funds Nishad has left will be provided to the Government or to the debtors’ estate in the FTX bankruptcy, including the full value of his own accounts on FTX worth tens of millions of dollars, even though nearly all of those funds were received before [ECF p. 49] Nishad’s knowledge of and participation in the fraud.16 Nishad will be left with virtually nothing after forfeiture and civil settlements.

16 In April 2021, before Nishad knew about the fraud and before his involvement in any of the charged conspiracies, he sought to sell $10 million of his FTT holdings to pay for various expenses of, and provide assistance to, a number of family members and friends, including expenses that arose out of a family emergency. Bankman-Fried directed Nishad not to sell any FTT and instead provided Nishad with $10 million as a loan, which Nishad then provided to family members and friends. He also used some of the money to pay taxes and make a large donation to a charitable organization. Nishad documented the fact that he owed this money back and continued to follow up with Bankman-Fried about it. In the wake of the FTX bankruptcy, counsel for Nishad and counsel for the bankruptcy estate have been discussing the possibility of recovering funds that may remain with Nishad’s family and friends, even though the transfers reflect no misconduct on Nishad’s part and occurred well before any of his criminal activity.

Nishad’s cooperation also extended well beyond this case, as he assisted a variety of agencies and representatives over the past two years, and continues to do so. First, Nishad sat for virtual interviews with the SEC regarding separate inquiries (nor directly related to FTX’s downfall) on three separate occasions, and produced documents in his possession relevant to those inquiries. Second, just this month, Nishad sat for a virtual interview with the CFTC to assist them with a separate, nonpublic investigation. Third, Nishad has cooperated with three investigations being conducted at the state level, including sitting for interviews with two state investigatory authorities to assist in their own investigations,17 and producing documents in connection with a third state investigation. Fourth, Nishad has reached a settlement with the civil multi-district litigation plaintiffs that asserted various causes of action against the co-conspirators for their respective roles in FTX’s downfall, agreeing to cooperate with the plaintiffs in their ongoing litigations. Ex. A at 59 (D. Boies). As part of his assistance, Nishad has already sat for an interview and submitted a declaration in support of the MDL plaintiffs’ amended complaint, and will sit for additional interviews upon request. See id.; Declaration of Nishad Singh in Support of Amended Complaint, In re FTX Cryptocurrency Exch. Collapse MDL Litig., Case No. 1:23-md-03076 (S.D. Fla. Feb. 17, 2024), ECF No. 493-1 at 210. Fifth, Nishad has engaged with the FTX debtors in the bankruptcy proceeding and offered any assistance he can provide, and, as of this filing, has agreed [ECF p. 50] to surrender property nominally in his name for the purpose of recovering customer assets.18 Nishad also offered assistance to the FTX debtors well before he became a formal Government cooperator, shortly after FTX declared bankruptcy in November 2022, by providing information and guidance on how to reboot the exchange, and real-time assistance with triaging the hack on November 10, 2022. Sixth, Nishad has assisted the examiner appointed by the bankruptcy court to investigate various aspects of FTX.US, including by providing information during a virtual interview and attorney proffers.

17 Singh-DPO Donation Investigation Finds Insufficient Evidence to Support Criminal Charges, OREGON DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE (July 17, 2024), available at: https://www.doj.state.or.us/media-home/news-media-releases/singh-dpo-donation-investigation-finds-insufficient-evidence-to-support-criminal-charges/.

18 This includes a property purchased by FTX in the Bahamas under Nishad’s name, as well certain equity in FTX-related companies.

[REDACTED]19

19 [REDACTED]

[Note on this text version: page 50 of the filed PDF is an image of the page, so its text, from “to surrender property” to this point and including footnotes 18 and 19, was typed out from the image. The second paragraph on that page and footnote 19 are blacked out in the original. The number of footnote 19 is itself covered and is inferred from the footnotes around it.]

[ECF p. 51]

V. NISHAD’S LIFE SINCE FTX’S COLLAPSE

As described above, Nishad began cooperating with the Government within days of leaving the Bahamas, at a time when his mental health had cratered: [REDACTED] Ex. A at 62 (K. DeVaul).

For the next several months, Nishad lived with his father, who along with his fiancée and other family members helped take care of Nishad and accompanied him on his many trips to New York to assist the government. Cooperation with the government gave Nishad “a renewed sense of purpose,” offering him a path to remedy some of the wrongs he perpetrated at FTX. Ex. A at 55 (M. Singh). With the support network of his brother, fiancée, parents, aunts and uncles, and friends, among others, and a commitment to therapy, Nishad’s mental health has slowly improved. Ex. A at 63 (K. DeVaul).

As a result of this support and therapy, while Nishad will always carry tremendous regret and remorse about his role at FTX, he has used the past 20 months to rebuild his life. He now lives in San Francisco with his fiancée, Claire, and they are looking forward to getting married in the future. For the past 14 months, Nishad has been employed as a software engineer at a private company (not in the cryptocurrency, financial services, or investment sectors). See PSR ¶ 92. The company founder writes that Nishad has already become “invaluable” and “sticks out as a huge innovator at the company.” Id. The company recently presented three new products at a leading artificial intelligence conference in San Francisco, two of which were built by Nishad and were considered a “hit” at the event. Id. Likewise, Nishad has become “a beloved staple” of the company’s Bay Area office by chatting with coworkers during lunch, joining an informal workout group, and closely mentoring an intern who is currently attending Berkeley. Id. Nishad’s “track record at the company and friendly disposition have made him a highly requested resource,” and as a result, the company founder writes “it would be a major blow for Nishad’s team and the broader company to lose him for any amount of time.” Id.

In addition to working, Nishad volunteers at The Gubbio Project, a daytime sanctuary for [ECF p. 52] the unhoused in San Francisco. PSR ¶ 79. Andy McCabe, the program manager and formerly unhoused himself, writes that “[m]eeting someone as kind as Nishad has been a blessing.” Ex. A at 73 (A. McCabe). McCabe describes how Nishad has “enabled [the organization] to secure grants and attract new donors,” by creating a mobile application for the team that tracks key metrics, such as the number of visitors and time spent at the shelter. Id. at 71–72. Nishad’s contributions, however, extend well beyond his technical expertise.

McCabe writes that a regular visitor of the shelter had “a severe case of cellulitis in both legs” and a “high fever of 102 degrees.” Ex. A at 72 (A. McCabe). This visitor was “afraid to take the step himself” in getting treatment at the hospital, Ex. A at 76 (M. O’Connor), and McCabe was “worried that when he got to the hospital, he wouldn’t get the treatment he needed and deserved,” Ex. A at 72 (A. McCabe). Nishad, who had taken the time to connect with this young man over many weeks, “went out of his way not only to take him to the hospital himself but also to stay by his side for several hours as an advocate.” Id. As McCabe notes, “this isn’t something we had asked Nishad to do (or would ever ask a volunteer to do).” Id. at 72–73 (explaining the visitor, following his recovery, was able to get “off the streets” and into “semi-permanent supportive housing”). Over the last year, McCabe has “really grown to care about Nishad, not just as someone who volunteers at [his] program, but as a truly, genuinely kind human being.” Id. at 73. As another volunteer writes, seeing firsthand how Nishad interacts with the guests, generous with his time and empathetic in his conversations, gives her “hope that our young adults really do care about our basic human needs for food, shelter, health care, and respect.” Ex. A at 77 (M. O’Connor).

In addition to his volunteer work with the Gubbio Project, Nishad also became involved in a separate initiative led by Brendan Tailaferro, a friend of Nishad’s brother. Tailaferro reached out to Nishad for help building software for an affordable housing project. Ex. A at 74–75 (B. Tailaferro). Despite his full-time job, Nishad responded not only by providing advice and guidance, but also volunteered hundreds of hours to help build the software for the project. Tailaferro writes, “[a]midst an extremely difficult and stressful time in his life, [Nishad] has proven [ECF p. 53] to be single-handedly the kindest, most supportive, and most capable person I have ever had the privilege to collaborate with.” Id. at 74.

In more recent visits to Claire’s extended family’s farm in rural Indiana, Nishad can be found “cement[ing] his tradition of doing crosswords projected on the TV as a family” or playing with the toddlers. Ex. A at 85 (E. Schroader). Jake Whitsitt, Claire’s cousin, shares, “[t]hey tug at him to play,” and he can be found “pretending to be a shark or train conductor” or “braid[ing] their hair (and let them braid his hair).” Id.; Ex. A at 88 (J. Whitsitt). Brian Moyer, another family relative, writes that while he tries to set the best example as a role model for his toddler, “there are a select few out there that can offer him even more,” and looks to Nishad in particular—despite Nishad’s role in FTX—because he “is everything I want my son [] to be.” Ex. A at 95 (B. Moyer).

Nishad has also resumed running, something he had not done regularly in nearly eight years. Recently, he recently completed his first ultramarathon since his teenage years, on the same path that he had once run his 100-mile ultramarathons years ago. PSR ¶ 82; Ex. A at 51 (R. Patel). As his stepfather and former running coach writes, he “hoped and prayed that [Nishad] would return home in every sense of the word, and [he] feel[s] that he has.” Ex. A at 51 (R. Patel). And as his younger brother writes, Nishad “has found the spirit to live instead of simply crumpling into a ball or worse.” Ex. A at 55 (M. Singh). It was unclear if Nishad “[would] ever get to this place,” but seeing how far Nishad has come, his younger brother is “so proud of him.” Id.