[1582:2] MR. COHEN: I will certainly finish today, and probably about an hour, hour and a half.
[1582:4] THE COURT: We will take the lunch break, members of the jury. The lawyers and I have a little business to do, so we will make it a little longer today. I'll see you back at let's say five to 2.
[1582:8] (Jury not present)
[1582:9] THE COURT: Mr. Roos, what's on your mind?
[1582:10] MR. ROOS: Thank you, your Honor. If it's OK, I'll approach and give you a binder that has the witness materials for tomorrow.
[1582:13] THE COURT: Thank you.
[1582:14] MR. ROOS: Your Honor, I have just handed up to you the government exhibits that we intend to use tomorrow with Professor Peter Easton, who is the government's expert witness relating to accounting and financial calculations and tracing. We conferred with defense, and they helpfully identified their areas of objections so we could work this out before we are in front of the jury. I will just go sort of in order of the issues as I understand them.
[1582:22] THE COURT: We will try.
[1582:23] MR. ROOS: The first issue, as I understand it, is that one of the exhibits, which compares the balance of customer funds on the FTX database to the balance of funds [1583:1] within FTX's wallets, hot wallets we have heard about in the case, it compares those two lines and it's Government Exhibit 1051, if your Honor wants to take a look.
[1583:4] As I understand the objection, your Honor, it's a Rule 16 objection, which is that, in the defense view, it's outside the scope of the --
[1583:7] THE COURT: I'm sorry. Back up.
[1583:8] It's a Rule 16 objection, and then I lost you because you looked down.
[1583:10] MR. ROOS: My apologies.
[1583:11] It's a Rule 16 objection, as I understand it, to the timing of the disclosure relating to the opinion that's reflected in the exhibit.
[1583:14] THE COURT: What's the objection, Mr. Cohen?
[1583:15] MR. LISNER: Your Honor, I'll address on behalf of the defense, David Lisner.
[1583:17] This graph purports to show it's not just assets, crypto assets, between what's shown in the site and what's shown in wallets.
[1583:20] Professor Easton's expert disclosure, as far as I could tell, and me and Mr. Roos have not yet had a chance to compare language, but I don't see any place where an opinion about the balance of crypto assets between wallets and the database is reflected in his disclosure, and he is not offered as a crypto expert. As I understand, tallying up the amount of [1584:1] crypto assets in a wallet is not necessarily as simple as a bank account.
[1584:3] For that reason, we think this is outside of the disclosure.
[1584:5] THE COURT: I thought it was about timing.
[1584:6] MR. LISNER: That's the words Mr. Roos used.
[1584:7] The words I would have used is, Professor Easton's Rule 16 disclosure does not provide an opinion or describe an opinion regarding the balance of crypto assets. The closest I could find is opinion 9, which describes Alameda's balances, but this exhibit expressly excludes Alameda's balances and that's in a footnote.
[1584:13] MR. ROOS: Few things, your Honor.
[1584:14] THE COURT: It would have been helpful if somebody had told me that we were going to discuss this, because I have not looked at that Rule 16 disclosure in at least two months. I have no idea what it says today.
[1584:18] MR. LISNER: Apologies, your Honor. We received this and all other exhibits and backup for Professor Easton Saturday night at 11 p.m. This is the quickest we are able to address this.
[1584:22] MR. ROOS: Just to be clear on that, we produced the initial draft of this slide, and I think this is the answer to the disclosure question, we produced it on September 8, when we produced our exhibits.
[1585:1] And the question under Rule 16(g), in analyzing whether or not there is an appropriate disclosure, is whether or not there is a prejudice to the defense.
[1585:4] I would direct your Honor to two cases as you are considering this issue. The first is the Second Circuit's decision in Tin Yat Chin. I have a copy. I don't have a copy for everyone, but I can hand up my copy to the Court. I will give the cite. It's 476 F.3d 144. There the circuit, Judge Rakoff writing for the circuit, considered whether the government's disclosure of an expert, not just a slide, but an expert, one day before his testimony was unduly late and prejudicial, and the Court concluded that the district court's decision to give an extra day, so a one-day continuance, was sufficient. Here they have had this exhibit for about six weeks now, so that's more than enough time to prepare. There is no evidence of prejudice.
[1585:17] The second case I would point to is a district court decision by Judge Caproni. The case is Rosario. It has a Westlaw cite of 2014 WL 6076364. There she held that the production of the slides in that case for the witness provided sufficient disclosure to meet Rule 16's requirements.
[1585:22] THE COURT: Is there an opinion he is going to give about this?
[1585:24] MR. ROOS: His opinion is going to be that the amount in FTX's cryptocurrency wallets, there was a difference between [1586:1] what was in there and what was reflected in FTX's database for customer deposits, so the black line meaning this is what the database said they had in customer deposits. What FTX was actually keeping in cryptocurrency balances was considerably smaller.
[1586:6] THE COURT: Mr. Lisner, where is the prejudice to the defense?
[1586:8] MR. LISNER: The prejudice is, your Honor, while we may have had a version of this slide, it's based on tens of thousands, maybe hundreds of thousands of database entries that we received Saturday night. But, more importantly --
[1586:12] THE COURT: Did they or did they not produce this to you on or about September 8?
[1586:14] MR. LISNER: I don't currently have a recollection of this particular slide. We may have, but we did not receive the data.
[1586:17] May I add one other point, your Honor?
[1586:18] THE COURT: I'm sorry. I don't understand the distinction you're drawing.
[1586:20] MR. ROOS: Here is the version.
[1586:21] THE COURT: Please hand it up.
[1586:22] I am asking Mr. Lisner what the distinction is between the graph and the data.
[1586:24] MR. LISNER: The distinction, your Honor, is that the graph is driven by an enormous amount of numbers, and we just [1587:1] received the numbers the other day. So what this graph was based on we didn't previously have.
[1587:3] The other point I would add, and I'll rest after this, your Honor, is I believe from Mr. Roos jumping to case law about late disclosure, I take that as an admission that it was not fairly captured by Professor Easton's expert disclosure.
[1587:7] THE COURT: You will take it as an admission, and I will think about it.
[1587:9] MR. LISNER: Understood.
[1587:10] THE COURT: This graph, Mr. Roos, that you handed me, which is marked Government Exhibit 1051, does not actually look to me like the one in the book.
[1587:13] MR. ROOS: The difference, your Honor, is the temporal period. If your Honor sees the black-and-white version I printed out for you, which is draft, it goes back to 2019, the ultimate exhibit is just 2021, 2022, so it sort of elongates it, but it's otherwise the same analysis.
[1587:18] THE COURT: Same data?
[1587:19] MR. ROOS: Same data.
[1587:20] THE COURT: For the overlap period.
[1587:21] MR. ROOS: Correct.
[1587:22] THE COURT: I will consider that.
[1587:23] Next issue.
[1587:24] MR. ROOS: The second issue, as I understand it, is that the defense is objecting to admitting certain of the [1588:1] government's exhibits, a majority of them, I think. No objection to using them as demonstratives.
[1588:3] I'll tell you that the government's plan is that there are exhibits in the binder before your Honor that are the results of the financial analysis. They come in two forms: Balance data over time, either bank accounts or data from the FTX transaction database, and the other form of analysis is financial tracing, so money flowing through accounts.
[1588:9] Those exhibits the government is offering into evidence, and they are all within the 1000 series. The government also intends to use certain demonstratives, such as, you know, a portion of a document to ask the witness whether or not he has analyzed the source of the funds for the investment that is reflected on the document, and for those we are not proposing to offer those demonstratives, which are in the 3000 series, into evidence.
[1588:17] I think the dispute, just to narrow it for the Court, is whether or not the 1000 series exhibits can be offered into evidence, and the government's view, informed, I think, again by the case law, is that both under the rules relating to experts, so a 703 chart, and the rules relating to summary charts, under 1006, that these are admissible into evidence.
[1588:23] THE COURT: Thank you.
[1588:24] Mr. Lisner, first of all, is it correct that we don't have an issue about the 3000 series?
[1589:1] MR. LISNER: No. We do have one issue. I think we have two categories of issues. I can describe them for you.
[1589:3] THE COURT: Yes.
[1589:4] MR. LISNER: In the 3000 series these are slides that, as Mr. Roos pointed out, the government intends to use as demonstratives. We have no problem with that, but a number of them include call-outs or pictures of documents not in evidence. If the government purports to publish excerpts of documents not in evidence, that's our concern.
[1589:10] For a lot of the documents I think we could work something out with the government, and I'm happy to speak with Mr. Roos over the lunch break, but the principle is, they shouldn't be allowed to publish documents not in evidence under the guise of demonstrative.
[1589:15] THE COURT: The expert is entitled, if memory serves, under Rule 703, to explain the basis for his opinions, and the opinion need not be based entirely on material in evidence, as long as the non-evidentiary material is evidence of a sort that experts in the field rely upon.
[1589:20] Now, obviously, there is a potential there at an extreme for abuse, and I appreciate that, but I'm not understanding why I should assume, as a categorical matter, that anything that's non-evidentiary that the expert refers to in justifying the opinion shouldn't be placed in front of the jury.
[1590:1] MR. LISNER: I think in 703, for material that is inadmissible for which the expert relies, there is a balancing test of whether it's sufficiently probative, which we take your point. It could be published, but not all of these documents appear to be relevant to the analysis. There are news articles which are hearsay.
[1590:7] And, again, I'm happy to speak with Mr. Roos over the break --
[1590:9] THE COURT: They are not hearsay to the extent that they are offered to illustrate the basis for the expert's opinion, but I certainly welcome your working on this further with Mr. Roos, because the problem I'm having with your argument about the 3000 series right now is that you are taking the categorical position, implicitly anyway, that anything that's not evidentiary that's called out in one of these demonstratives is inherently, simply by virtue of being non-evidentiary, unduly prejudicial and so forth, and that's not the way that analysis works.
[1590:19] MR. LISNER: I understand, your Honor. I take the point. Why don't we work out what we can and maybe whatever is left, an appropriate limiting instruction perhaps.
[1590:22] THE COURT: That's fine.
[1590:23] MR. ROOS: For what it's worth, I think besides the news articles, we intend to offer the exhibits that are cited in there, which may just sort of moot the issue.
[1591:1] THE COURT: Don't eat up my lunch with that. You eat up your lunches.
[1591:3] What about the 1000 series, Mr. Lisner?
[1591:4] MR. LISNER: The 1000 series is for only part of them. We are fine with admitting them as summary Exhibits 1000 up through 1017. But from 1017 to 1050, these are a series of, I guess I'll call them flow charts that purport to show or describe the flow of funds became bank accounts for certain transactions. For example, 1039 is the one I happen to have open in my book. This appears to be expert conclusion and not a 1006 summary or include expert conclusions and not be based solely on the underlying bank records, and I think maybe with more foundation we can get there.
[1591:14] The issue that we see is, Professor Easton is, according to his Rule 16 disclosure, is going to tell us everything was commingled between bank accounts, customer funds and FTX Alameda funds. And then these slides purport to separate it out, which funds are which. I don't know how Professor Easton continued to do that, but it sounds like an accounting conclusion and not a fair 1006 summary.
[1591:21] THE COURT: You invited my attention to 1039. You start off at the left side of the flow chart with $11 million in customer funds from customer bank accounts, and the only other inflow reflected is a $200,000 inflow over a couple-day period both going into North Dimension.
[1592:1] I can understand conceptually what you are talking about, but if 99 percent of it is from one source and 1 percent of it from the other, what difference does it make? It's immaterial. Isn't it?
[1592:5] MR. LISNER: It may be, but sitting here, I don't know that. So that's why I have to --
[1592:7] THE COURT: All you have to do is ask yourself what 200,000, as a percentage of 11.2 million, is, and then you know the answer.
[1592:10] MR. LISNER: That may be true, but the backup data for this, again, is a spreadsheet that drives this. We received it in 3500 material. And that spreadsheet says, in the absence of time stamps and similar sized inflows, we performed a conservative LIFO analysis. It sounds like there was an analysis applied to the numbers to get to this chart, and that's what the issue is for us.
[1592:17] THE COURT: We all know what a LIFO analysis is, don't we. So does the witness. Last in, first out.
[1592:19] MR. LISNER: Yes, your Honor.
[1592:20] THE COURT: Standard accounting, right?
[1592:21] MR. LISNER: Yes.
[1592:22] Professor Easton is being offered as an accounting expert.
[1592:24] THE COURT: Does that take care of that group?
[1592:25] MR. LISNER: That's everything on that group. That's [1593:1] all of our objections.
[1593:2] THE COURT: We did make some progress here. I hope you can get to the goal line in time for your dessert.
[1593:4] See you later.
[1593:5] (Luncheon recess)
[1594:1] AFTERNOON SESSION
[1594:2] 2:00 p.m.
[1594:3] THE COURT: Let's get the witness and the jury.
[1594:4] (Jury present)
[1594:5] THE COURT: The record will reflect that the jurors and the defendant all are present, as they have been throughout.
[1594:8] I hope everybody had a pleasant lunch break.
[1594:9] The witness is still under oath.
[1594:10] You may proceed, Mr. Cohen.
[1594:11] MR. COHEN: Thank you, your Honor.
[1594:12] BY MR. COHEN:
[1594:13] Q. Mr. Singh, let me call your attention to September of 2022, OK, sir?
[1594:15] A. OK.
[1594:16] Q. We talked about it briefly this morning. I want to come back to it.
[1594:18] I believe you told us that, in or about September, you received a message from Mr. Bankman-Fried about whether or not to close Alameda?
[1594:21] A. I received a message that had a link to a Google Doc that described arguments for doing so.
[1594:23] Q. And this was the Google Doc you described as being headed we came, we saw, we researched?
[1594:25] A. I think that was the title.
[1595:1] Q. And this was to you and to Gary, is that correct?
[1595:2] A. I know for certain it was to the two of us. I don't know if it was also shared with others.
[1595:4] Q. And I believe you testified yesterday that one of the topics it addressed was public relations about the relationship between Alameda and FTX.
[1595:7] Do you recall that, sir?
[1595:8] A. I do.
[1595:9] Q. And another topic was I think what you described as the leadership of Alameda, correct?
[1595:11] A. Yes.
[1595:12] Q. Do you recall whether any other topics were discussed in that document?
[1595:14] A. Give me a moment.
[1595:15] Q. Sure.
[1595:16] THE COURT: Isn't the document in evidence?
[1595:17] MR. ROOS: Yes.
[1595:18] MR. COHEN: Why don't we just call it up then.
[1595:19] GX-18.
[1595:20] Thank you, your Honor.
[1595:21] Q. This is much easier. Why don't we take a look at GX-18. Yesterday you went through it for us in the middle of the page, the reasons. You see that, sir?
[1595:24] A. Yes.
[1595:25] Q. And we talked just a moment ago about the PR hit relating [1596:1] to Alameda and FTX and then current Alameda leadership.
[1596:2] Do you see that, sir?
[1596:3] A. Yes.
[1596:4] MR. COHEN: Brian, if you could reduce that, please. Go to the next page.
[1596:6] Come back to the first page.
[1596:7] I found it.
[1596:8] If you could call out the box, the reasons again. Look at entry number 2.
[1596:10] Q. The current leadership of Alameda is good, but not good enough to be able to trust with such a big operation. Then continuing to A. The fact that we didn't --
[1596:13] MR. COHEN: Can you highlight A, please, Brian.
[1596:14] Q. The fact that we didn't hedge as much as we should have alone cost more in EV than all the money Alameda has ever made or will ever make. That's the kind of critical mistake we're likely to make if I'm not actually running the show there.
[1596:18] Mr. Singh did you have an understanding of what EV was?
[1596:20] A. Expected value.
[1596:21] Q. Do you recall anything else that was discussed about hedging in this chat or around this chat?
[1596:23] MR. ROOS: Objection. Hearsay.
[1596:24] THE COURT: Sustained.
[1596:25] Q. Continuing down to 5 the topic was: Alameda is making some [1597:1] money trading, but not enough to justify its existence.
[1597:2] Do you recall discussing that, sir?
[1597:3] A. I remember a comment from Gary giving his thoughts on this point in the chat.
[1597:5] Q. What do you remember?
[1597:6] MR. ROOS: Objection. Hearsay.
[1597:7] MR. COHEN: It goes to state of mind, your Honor.
[1597:8] THE COURT: Whose state of mind?
[1597:9] MR. COHEN: The coconspirators.
[1597:10] THE COURT: Mr. Roos, what do you say to that?
[1597:11] MR. ROOS: I'll withdraw this objection for now.
[1597:12] THE COURT: All right.
[1597:13] MR. COHEN: Could we have the question read back?
[1597:14] THE COURT: What do you remember was the question.
[1597:15] A. I remember Gary saying in the chat something to the effect of, I think Alameda is making 300 or $400 million a year. Sam, are you sure that the PR hit is worth more than that.
[1597:18] MR. COHEN: We can take this down.
[1597:19] Q. I believe you testified that after this was sent -- this GX-18 was sent across, you came to your own view about whether Alameda should be shut down, correct?
[1597:22] A. I had an idea. I don't think I had an overall view on whether it should or shouldn't happen.
[1597:24] Q. I believe you testified that your idea was that Alameda ought to be taken down off the FTX exchange, is that correct?
[1598:1] A. Not necessarily that it ought to. It just struck me as sort of like a less costly solution that maintained many of the same advantages.
[1598:4] Q. Then you had a number of chats with various people about the issue about whether or not Alameda should be -- should be -- go out of business, correct?
[1598:7] A. There was one Signal chat after this in hashtag organization in which some of that was discussed.
[1598:9] Q. Who was on that chat, sir?
[1598:10] A. Myself, Sam, Caroline, Gary.
[1598:11] Q. Were there separate chats just between you, Gary, and Caroline?
[1598:13] A. Those existed in Signal. I don't remember if we used them to talk about this.
[1598:15] Q. So you don't remember one way or the other?
[1598:16] A. I don't remember one way or the other.
[1598:17] Q. I think you also told us that there was some in-person meetings about the topic of closing down Alameda.
[1598:19] Do you recall that?
[1598:20] A. Yes.
[1598:21] Q. Who was at those meetings?
[1598:22] A. There was one meeting that I called immediately after posting in hashtag organization and getting some responses. Myself, Gary, Caroline attended.
[1598:25] Q. Mr. Bankman-Fried did not attend?
[1599:1] A. He did not attend.
[1599:2] Q. Whether it was at that meeting or otherwise, you told us about an exchange where you inquired about whether the borrows could be paid back.
[1599:5] Do you recall that, sir?
[1599:6] A. It didn't come up in that meeting. It was the elephant in the room in that meeting.
[1599:8] Q. Did it come up afterwards?
[1599:9] A. With Sam.
[1599:10] Q. Did it come up in your conversation with Ms. Ellison and Mr. Wang?
[1599:12] A. No, not the in-person one.
[1599:13] Q. What about on the chats?
[1599:14] A. Not that I recall, except for the chat with the four of us.
[1599:15] Q. What do you remember from that?
[1599:16] A. From the chat with the four of us, you mean?
[1599:17] Q. Yes.
[1599:18] A. I don't remember more than what's in my direct, but I could restate a lot of it.
[1599:20] Q. No need.
[1599:21] I think you told us that you asked whether or not returning Alameda's borrows was possible, and Ms. Ellison responded that it was not possible.
[1599:24] Do you recall testifying to that, sir?
[1599:25] A. I don't think those are my exact words.
[1600:1] Q. What were your exact words?
[1600:2] A. I enumerated the main things that I thought would be required to close Alameda down at FTX. One of them, I believe my phrasing was, close out all Alameda accounts. Caroline responded: That's impossible. I asked which part of it. She clarified the part about closing out accounts.
[1600:7] Q. Your understanding was, it was not possible because there were not sufficient assets to pay back the borrows, correct?
[1600:9] A. At first I was confused. That became my understanding over the course of the day.
[1600:11] Q. And this was based on what Ms. Ellison had said?
[1600:12] A. Ms. Ellison, Gary, and Sam.
[1600:13] Q. Now, did you do any verification of your own about this topic, any work of your own on this?
[1600:15] A. No.
[1600:16] Q. Let me move forward. I believe you testified that you had a conversation with Mr. Bankman-Fried on the balcony of the Orchid penthouse.
[1600:19] Do you recall that, sir?
[1600:20] A. I do.
[1600:21] Q. Before we get into it, let me just ask this question.
[1600:22] you told us about Mr. Bankman-Fried's demeanor yesterday. What was your demeanor, your state of mind?
[1600:24] A. I was very nervous. I was awaiting an explanation and eventually an apology. I was pacing.
[1601:1] Q. Were you anxious?
[1601:2] A. Yes.
[1601:3] Q. Were you stressed?
[1601:4] A. Yes.
[1601:5] Q. I think you told us that later in November you regarded yourself as suicidal.
[1601:7] A. And for a few months after.
[1601:8] Q. At that time as well?
[1601:9] A. Yes.
[1601:10] Q. You testified yesterday that --
[1601:11] MR. COHEN: Counsel, it's page 1406, line 12.
[1601:12] Q. First, how did the conversation begin? I said: Caroline is really freaked out about the NAV situation and so am I.
[1601:14] Do you recall that, sir?
[1601:15] Later on in the passage you were asked: What, if anything, did the defendant say in response?
[1601:17] MR. ROOS: Objection.
[1601:18] THE COURT: Start again, Mr. Cohen.
[1601:19] MR. COHEN: I'm trying to short-circuit this, Judge.
[1601:20] THE COURT: I appreciate that. But you start with a question and then you interpolate another question.
[1601:22] MR. COHEN: Maybe I should go slower then.
[1601:23] Q. Mr. Singh, do you recall speaking with Mr. Bankman-Fried about Caroline Ellison freaking out?
[1601:25] A. Yes.
[1602:1] Q. And she was freaking out over the point you had just made about the ability to pay back the borrows, correct?
[1602:3] MR. ROOS: Objection.
[1602:4] THE COURT: Sustained.
[1602:5] Q. What was she freaking out about?
[1602:6] MR. ROOS: Same objection.
[1602:7] THE COURT: Sustained.
[1602:8] Q. Do you recall in that conversation that -- according to you, Mr. Bankman-Fried said, page 1406 to 1407: I am not sure what there is to worry about. NAV is fantastic by almost any measure. It was super positive, even if you don't include FTX and FTX US equity.
[1602:13] Do you recall that, sir?
[1602:14] A. Yes.
[1602:15] Q. And you told us you did not react positively to that, correct?
[1602:17] A. I asked further questions.
[1602:18] Q. Did you talk about any other topics in the meeting at the balcony?
[1602:20] MR. ROOS: Objection.
[1602:21] THE COURT: What's the objection?
[1602:22] MR. ROOS: Hearsay. He can answer yes or no.
[1602:23] THE COURT: Yes. You can answer yes or no and stopped when you have answered yes or no.
[1602:25] Q. Yes or no, did you talk in the balcony meeting about the [1603:1] topic of FTX's marketing expenses?
[1603:2] A. Talked about expenses.
[1603:3] Q. Did you express the view that FTX going forward ought to keep expenses down?
[1603:5] A. Something to that effect, I did.
[1603:6] Q. Because you thought it was important going forward that FTX spend as little as possible until customers were repaid, correct?
[1603:9] A. I specifically was concerned about frivolous spending that may not pan out to be useful.
[1603:11] Q. So you wanted certainly frivolous spending to not be done, is that correct?
[1603:13] A. Correct.
[1603:14] Q. Other business spending to be as limited as possible.
[1603:15] A. I don't think I said exactly that.
[1603:16] Q. What did you say, sir?
[1603:17] A. I think I just asked if Sam would now sort of take seriously the act of cutting down on the expenses and curbing future ones.
[1603:20] Q. Now, you had mentioned yesterday that around this time you considered resigning from FTX, correct?
[1603:22] A. Correct.
[1603:23] Q. I meant to ask you, prior to September 2022, had you ever considered resigning?
[1603:25] A. Yes.
[1604:1] Q. When was that?
[1604:2] A. Once in 2018, once before moving to Hong Kong, a few times after distressing conversations with Sam or Gary.
[1604:4] Q. So this is over the four-year period from 2018 to 2022?
[1604:5] A. Yes.
[1604:6] Q. Mr. Singh, did you ever purchase an apartment in Orcas Island, Washington?
[1604:8] A. I did.
[1604:9] Q. When did you do that?
[1604:10] A. I did that in October of 2022.
[1604:11] Q. And Orcas Island is in Washington State or off Washington State?
[1604:13] A. Right.
[1604:14] Q. This was an apartment you purchased with friends?
[1604:15] A. It was a house that I alone purchased, though I intended it to be used by me and friends.
[1604:17] Q. And the purchase price was $3.7 million?
[1604:18] A. Correct.
[1604:19] Q. And you borrowed that purchase price from the FTX exchange, correct?
[1604:21] A. Correct.
[1604:22] Q. And you did this after the September meeting with Mr. Bankman-Fried you've been telling us about, correct?
[1604:24] A. I did.
[1604:25] Q. And in fact the closing for the apartment took place on [1605:1] November 1, didn't it, sir?
[1605:2] A. I don't remember the exact date.
[1605:3] Q. Isn't it fair to say that you wired the funds sometime after October 2022?
[1605:5] A. Or late October, yes.
[1605:6] Q. Now, coming into that meeting did you expect FTX to go forward as a company, the September meeting on the balcony?
[1605:8] A. Would you mind clarifying what you mean by go forward?
[1605:9] Q. Well, did you expect that FTX would last as a business going forward?
[1605:11] A. Certainly for some amount of time, yes.
[1605:12] Q. Didn't you expect it to last as a business for years?
[1605:13] A. I am not sure what I expected.
[1605:14] Q. Well, do you recall speaking with the prosecutors on January 19 of this year?
[1605:16] A. I don't remember the specific dates in my meetings with them.
[1605:18] Q. Do you recall saying to them that in September you believed that FTX would last for years despite the awful situation?
[1605:20] A. I don't remember saying that.
[1605:21] MR. COHEN: Can we call up 3501-028.
[1605:22] If we can turn to page 8, third paragraph. Call that out, Brian.
[1605:24] Q. Read this to yourself, Mr. Singh, and I ask you, yes or no, if it refreshes your recollection that you told the prosecutors [1606:1] that you believed FTX would last for years despite the awful situation.
[1606:3] It's the next paragraph below, Mr. Singh.
[1606:4] THE COURT: I'm sorry. 3501-28 what?
[1606:5] MR. COHEN: It's the paragraph we have just pulled up. I apologize. Page 8. Same page. Just the one below, your Honor.
[1606:8] A. This does refresh my memory.