[1465:18] MR. ROOS: And could we zoom in on the date and time of the first tweet.
[1465:20] Q. Mr. Singh, when is this in relation to the conversation you were just describing?
[1465:22] A. The following morning.
[1465:23] Q. Let's look at the first tweet. The defendant says, "FTX is fine. Assets are fine." Was that accurate as of November 7, 2022?
[1466:1] A. No.
[1466:2] Q. Why not?
[1466:3] A. We had determined definitively that FTX had a hole. That was clear to everybody involved in the discussion I just mentioned.
[1466:6] Q. Did those discussions include the defendant?
[1466:7] A. Yes.
[1466:8] MR. ROOS: Okay. Zoom out from here. And let's look at the one below it.
[1466:10] Q. That tweet includes a statement, "FTX has enough to cover all client holdings." Was that true at the time?
[1466:12] A. This is an even narrower statement that is even——and therefore even more false.
[1466:14] Q. Why?
[1466:15] A. FTX did not have enough to cover client holdings. That was the sense in which it was not fine.
[1466:17] Q. At or before the time the defendant tweeted this, had you discussed the state of FTX assets with him?
[1466:19] A. Yes.
[1466:20] Q. Had you discussed the issues that you've testified about relating to customer funds?
[1466:22] A. By that——I discussed with him the existence of a hole, and he——he quantified it by putting together these balance sheets.
[1466:24] Q. What, if anything, did you understand the purpose of the tweets were based on your involvement in the conversation you [1467:1] testified about?
[1467:2] A. I'd overheard in the conversation opinions that these tweets should be really strong, which I understood to be a euphemism for particularly misleading in such a way that will quell fears definitively.
[1467:6] MR. COHEN: Objection.
[1467:7] THE COURT: Mr. Roos.
[1467:8] MR. ROOS: His understanding is relevant as a co-conspirator.
[1467:10] THE COURT: Yes. Overruled.
[1467:11] A. I understood "strong" to mean making a very confident and therefore misleading statement, or false statement, about FTX's financial condition.
[1467:14] Q. Was the defendant in that conversation?
[1467:15] A. Yes.
[1467:16] MR. ROOS: We can take this down.
[1467:17] So Judge, I'm very close to the end, but I don't think I'm going to make it by 8:30——by 4:30.
[1467:19] THE COURT: I was worried about 8:30.
[1467:20] MR. ROOS: Certainly we'll make it by 8:30.
[1467:21] Would you like me to continue——I think I've got about two minutes left——or I can stop here. I'm about to switch topics.
[1467:24] THE COURT: Well, you've got two minutes left.
[1467:25] MR. ROOS: Okay. Thank you.
[1468:1] BY MR. ROOS:
[1468:2] Q. During the next week in November, the week in November that we've been discussing, did you have any conversations with the defendant about possible explanations for Alameda's borrowing?
[1468:5] A. Yes.
[1468:6] Q. What did you discuss?
[1468:7] A. He asked me to determine the total amounts that had flown through the spot margin system historically, the largest amounts that had ever been lent and borrowed.
[1468:10] Q. What is the spot margin system?
[1468:11] A. FTX supported a peer-to-peer borrowing system such that customers could explicitly lend their funds for others to borrow.
[1468:14] Q. And are customers automatically involved in the spot margin system?
[1468:16] A. No. They have to opt in.
[1468:17] Q. What specifically did the defendant ask you when he raised the possibility of the spot margin system?
[1468:19] A. He asked me to run a database query to fetch the largest——the most that had been borrowed or lent at any point in time for each coin through the spot margin system.
[1468:22] Q. And was it the case that the hole that you've testified about was the result of borrowing through the spot margin system?
[1468:25] A. No.
[1469:1] Q. Why do you say no?
[1469:2] A. Funds were taken from bank accounts, which had nothing to do with the spot margin system, and negative amounts in the main Alameda account did not have spot margin enabled. It borrowed——and were able to because of the "Allow Negative" flag.
[1469:7] Q. What do you mean that the main account didn't have spot margin enabled?
[1469:9] A. Customers had to opt in to borrowing and participating in the borrow/lending system. This would, you know——opting in was a——is tantamount to enabling spot margin. Alameda's main account, though it was really negative at times and was borrowing, wasn't doing so through this system.
[1469:14] Q. Now changing dates and directing your attention to November 8, 2022, did you speak to an attorney on that day named Dan Friedberg?
[1469:17] A. I did.
[1469:18] Q. And did you tell the defendant about that conversation?
[1469:19] A. I did.
[1469:20] MR. ROOS: Your Honor, the government offers Exhibit 480C, which is a message exchange between the defendant and the witness on November 8th, pursuant to stipulation S2003.
[1469:23] THE COURT: 480C is received.
[1469:24] (Government's Exhibit 480C received in evidence)
[1469:25] MR. ROOS: May we publish it?
[1470:1] THE COURT: You may.
[1470:2] BY MR. ROOS:
[1470:3] Q. Who is this Signal chat between?
[1470:4] A. Also between me and Sam.
[1470:5] Q. What's the date on it?
[1470:6] A. Tuesday, November 8th.
[1470:7] Q. You write to the defendant, "when you briefly called Dan he was very upset with us and blamed basically the three of us and said it was super [f'd] up, etc." Who is the Dan in this sentence?
[1470:11] A. Dan Friedberg.
[1470:12] Q. You wrote that when he called, he blamed the three of you. What were you referring to? Who were you referring to?
[1470:14] A. In the call, Dan blamed me, Sam, and Gary. That's what I meant, although I don't know that my meaning was clear in the message.
[1470:17] MR. ROOS: Now can we zoom out of this.
[1470:18] Q. And how did the defendant respond?
[1470:19] A. He said that that matched his understanding, that Dan was really upset at us, and that it lined up with what Joe——Joe Bankman——had told him.
[1470:22] Q. Just to be clear, who is Dan F?
[1470:23] A. Dan Friedberg.
[1470:24] Q. And so to close the loop on this, you say that Dan F was very upset, and his message in response to that is, "yup, makes [1471:1] sense"?
[1471:2] A. I said a few things. I said Dan is upset and that Ryan is likely to resign if we don't proceed correctly. Sam is saying, "yup, makes sense" maybe to part or all of that.
[1471:5] Q. Okay. And then do you see where the defendant says, "fwiw"? What is that?
[1471:7] A. "For what it's worth."
[1471:8] Q. "For what it's worth, I don't hate the idea of them being pissed at me—–I don't know, there are pros and cons, and probably mostly cons, but it might help them."
[1471:11] And so do you see that there?
[1471:12] A. Yes.
[1471:13] Q. And you wrote——can we zoom out of this—–"this is wildly selfish of me, but they may need to know that it wasn't a ton of people orchestrating it. I think it makes them more likely to want to be here to help save the situation and the others at least."
[1471:18] What were you referring to here?
[1471:19] A. I really wanted Sam to clarify what everyone's role in this fraud was, that it's selfish, my request, because I wanted him to clarify that I wasn't orchestrating it and that I learned about it really late. I wanted Sam to clarify that he was orchestrating it.
[1471:24] MR. ROOS: Judge, do you want me to keep going or stop here?
[1472:1] THE COURT: Well, you told me you'd be done in two minutes.
[1472:3] MR. ROOS: Sorry. I did say I have two minutes. I have probably three more minutes of testimony.
[1472:5] THE COURT: This time I'm holding you to it.
[1472:6] MR. ROOS: Thank you, your Honor.
[1472:7] BY MR. ROOS:
[1472:8] Q. So why were you asking for him to clarify that he was orchestrating it?
[1472:10] A. Two reasons. I was under severe emotional distress from people like Dan Friedberg calling me and blaming me for the entirety of this, and I was certainly guilty for participating in it since September, but I don't feel that I made the hole. And secondly——and I sort of wanted my——the state of my relationship with these people I loved and tried to do right by to remain intact and for them not to hate me.
[1472:17] Secondly, there was a crazy blame game going on and people weren't being productive. Now more than ever, to salvage whatever we could, FTX employees needed to be productive, and resolving the blame game quickly and definitively seemed like it would be a path towards that.
[1472:22] Q. What do you mean resolving the blame game?
[1472:23] A. Sam making clear that he was responsible, that I was responsible in another capacity, that everyone responsible was responsible, and then moving past it so we could just maybe [1473:1] sell to Binance or do whatever we could to save what we could.
[1473:2] Q. You mentioned Dan Friedberg a few times now. What was his role at FTX?
[1473:4] A. He was the——he went by a couple titles, but fundamentally he was the lead——lead lawyer. He was sort of chief legal decision-maker on everything.
[1473:7] Q. And just for context, what was your mental state at this point when you were asking the defendant to do these things?
[1473:9] A. I'd been suicidal for some days.
[1473:10] Q. And why did you want him to come clean?
[1473:11] THE COURT: Hasn't that been asked and answered?
[1473:12] Q. Well, let me ask you this question this way.
[1473:13] MR. ROOS: Well, actually, let's just zoom out.
[1473:14] And can we go further down.
[1473:15] Last message, can we zoom in on it.
[1473:16] Q. Can you just read what he wrote in response to you.
[1473:17] A. Sam said, "yup, for what it's worth, I don't think that's super selfish. I think that's probably correct."
[1473:19] MR. ROOS: No further questions.
[1473:20] THE COURT: All right. Thank you.
[1473:21] Ladies and gentlemen, 9:30 tomorrow morning.
[1473:22] Counsel remain.
[The rest of the transcript for October 16 is not reproduced. Pages 1474 to 1478 record a discussion between the judge and the lawyers after the jury had left for the day, about scheduling and about matters concerning the defendant. Pages 1479 to 1484 are sealed by order of the court.]
Tuesday, October 17, 2023
[Page 1487 is the cover page of the transcript for October 17. Pages 1488 to 1490 are sealed by order of the court. Page 1491, a short exchange between the judge and the lawyers before the jury came in, about exhibits for a later witness, is not reproduced.]
[1492:1] (Jury present)
[1492:2] THE COURT: Good morning, folks. I hope you had a nice evening.
[1492:4] Mr. Singh, you're still under oath.
[1492:5] The record will reflect the jurors and the defendant all are present, as they have been throughout.
[1492:7] Cross-examination, Mr. Cohen.
[1492:8] MR. COHEN: Thank you, your Honor.
[1492:9] NISHAD SINGH, resumed.
[1492:10] CROSS EXAMINATION
[1492:11] BY MR. COHEN:
[1492:12] Q. Good morning, Mr. Singh.
[1492:13] A. Good morning.
[1492:14] Q. I'd like to ask you, if I ask you a question that you can answer yes or no, please do so.
[1492:16] A. Sounds good.
[1492:17] Q. Do you recall yesterday you testified about FTX's business spending?
[1492:19] A. Yes.
[1492:20] Q. Things like sponsorships and venture investments, correct?
[1492:21] A. Yes.
[1492:22] Q. And I believe you testified at page 1313 that you thought the spend was too large or didn't make sense. Do you recall that, sir?
[1492:25] A. I don't recall exactly what I said. In many instances I [1493:1] thought it was too large or didn't make sense, not in all.
[1493:2] Q. Okay. Fair to say that in certain instances you disagreed with the business rationale for the spend?
[1493:4] A. Right.
[1493:5] Q. You thought that spending on such items was too large.
[1493:6] A. Right.
[1493:7] Q. And is it fair to say that at certain times Sam had a different business judgment as to that spend?
[1493:9] A. Frequently.
[1493:10] Q. And Sam ran the business side of FTX, correct?
[1493:11] A. Yes.
[1493:12] Q. Now did FTX have a marketing group?
[1493:13] A. It had a lot of employees that worked on marketing in some capacity.
[1493:15] Q. And from time to time those employees would make recommendations to Sam about marketing initiatives, correct?
[1493:17] MR. ROOS: Objection, hearsay.
[1493:18] MR. COHEN: I'll rephrase, your Honor.
[1493:19] THE COURT: Yes, please.
[1493:20] Q. Do you know if from time to time the marketing group would make recommendations to Sam?
[1493:22] MR. ROOS: Objection. Hearsay.
[1493:23] THE COURT: Overruled.
[1493:24] The question is whether you know one way or the other.
[1493:25] A. Yes, I read in Slack——
[1494:1] THE COURT: No, no, no. The answer was yes. Just stop there.
[1494:3] Q. Let's talk for a moment about sponsorships. Was it your view, Mr. Singh, that FTX shouldn't have any corporate sponsorships?
[1494:6] A. I'm not sure that I had a view that extreme. I don't think I had a very precise view on what should happen.
[1494:8] MR. COHEN: If we could pull up Government Exhibit 343 in evidence, please.
[1494:10] Q. This is a document entitled List of Sponsorships. Do you recall going over this with us yesterday, Mr. Singh?
[1494:12] A. Yes.
[1494:13] Q. Okay. And counsel directed you to line 3.
[1494:14] MR. COHEN: Brian, could we have line 3.
[1494:15] Q. And that was the sponsorship for the Miami-Dade FTX Arena. Do you see that, Mr. Singh?
[1494:17] A. Yes.
[1494:18] Q. And you told us yesterday about the spend of 135 million on that sponsorship, correct?
[1494:20] A. Yes.
[1494:21] MR. COHEN: Okay. Now why don't we——Brian, if we might expand this and cover some things that weren't covered yesterday.
[1494:24] Let's take a look at the——Brian, move it a little bit more to my right.
[1495:1] Okay. Other way. Other way. Okay. That's good.
[1495:2] BY MR. COHEN:
[1495:3] Q. All right. If you can look at the heading that I'm circling, Mr. Singh, Deal Start Date and Duration, do you see that, sir?
[1495:6] A. I do.
[1495:7] Q. Is it fair to say that for the Miami-Dade FTX Arena, the duration of the sponsorship was 19 years?
[1495:9] A. Yes, that's what this suggests.
[1495:10] Q. Okay. With a start date of March 22, 2021.
[1495:11] A. That's what the spreadsheet says.
[1495:12] MR. COHEN: Okay. If we could continue, Brian, moving along on that same row, to the right.
[1495:14] If you go to the column entitled Outlay, and Brian, bring that all the way over, please.
[1495:16] Q. And that shows, Mr. Singh, the outlay per year of this $135 million commitment, correct?
[1495:18] MR. ROOS: Objection, foundation.
[1495:19] Q. Do you see that, sir?
[1495:20] THE COURT: Well, just a minute. We're not performing eye examinations here.
[1495:22] MR. COHEN: Sorry, Judge.
[1495:23] THE COURT: I mean, it says what it says.
[1495:24] MR. COHEN: Okay.
[1495:25] Q. Now, Mr. Singh, this sponsorship of the FTX Arena was aimed [1496:1] at promoting FTX's brand and awareness, correct?
[1496:2] MR. ROOS: Objection, foundation.
[1496:3] THE COURT: Sustained.
[1496:4] Q. Did you have a view about whether or not it was a useful thing to promote FTX's brand?
[1496:6] MR. ROOS: Objection.
[1496:7] THE COURT: Ground?
[1496:8] MR. ROOS: Relevance.
[1496:9] MR. COHEN: This was——
[1496:10] THE COURT: Pardon me?
[1496:11] MR. COHEN: I'm sorry. I didn't mean to interrupt your Honor.
[1496:13] THE COURT: Go ahead. I'm looking to you for a response.
[1496:15] MR. COHEN: Oh. This was covered yesterday, and this is relevant because yesterday we were told that this was excessive spend with no purpose.
[1496:18] THE COURT: Overruled.
[1496:19] BY MR. COHEN:
[1496:20] Q. You can answer my question, Mr. Singh.
[1496:21] A. Do you mind repeating it.
[1496:22] MR. COHEN: Let's read it back.
[1496:23] THE COURT: The question was: "Did you have a view about whether or not it was a useful thing to promote FTX's brand?" That's the question. Please answer it.
[1497:1] A. I understood that it had business benefits and costs. The specific, you know——if I specifically thought any given transaction was useful depended on the details of that transaction.
[1497:5] Q. And the business benefits and costs were for Sam to weigh, correct?
[1497:7] A. Yes.
[1497:8] MR. COHEN: All right. We can take that down, Brian.
[1497:9] Q. Now you also mentioned yesterday——you covered a topic of venture spending. Do you recall that, Mr. Singh?
[1497:11] A. Yes.
[1497:12] Q. And one of the topics you covered was a company called K5. Do you recall that?
[1497:14] A. I do.
[1497:15] Q. And that was a company run by, among others, Michael Kives, correct?
[1497:17] A. Oh, forgive my pronunciation yesterday. Yes.
[1497:18] MR. COHEN: Can we pull up Government Exhibit 42, please.
[1497:20] Q. Do you recall going over this with counsel yesterday?
[1497:21] A. Yes.
[1497:22] Q. And if you look at the second line from the top, Mr. Bankman-Fried stated that "Mr. Kives is probably the most connected person I've ever met. In attendance at the dinner at his house were:" and then it lists a number of people who you [1498:1] identified. Do you recall that?
[1498:2] A. I do.
[1498:3] Q. Okay. Did you——based on your working at FTX, did you have a view about whether there was a value in having connection with celebrities and entrepreneurs?
[1498:6] A. Yes, I believed that it could be valuable for the business.
[1498:7] Q. Depending on the circumstances, correct?
[1498:8] A. Right. Depending on the circumstances.
[1498:9] Q. And I believe you testified that you discussed with Mr. Bankman-Fried that someone like Mr. Kives could be a one-stop shop for such relationships, correct?
[1498:12] A. I discussed that in that Sam told me that, that it could be a one-stop shop for relationships.
[1498:14] Q. And this would eliminate the need to have multiple brokers trying to develop such relationships, correct?
[1498:16] A. I don't remember exactly what words Sam used, but he, in this document, says something to that effect, and I recall something to that effect being said in person to me.
[1498:19] Q. Did you agree with that, sir?
[1498:20] A. I didn't know. I didn't know who the other brokers were or the quality of the relationships Michael Kives had with these people.
[1498:23] Q. So you had no view on whether it was better to have one person or multiple brokers.
[1498:25] A. There was a cost of juggling multiple, but all else equal, [1499:1] having more connections is better.
[1499:2] MR. COHEN: Now we can take that down, Brian.
[1499:3] Q. Based on your interaction with Mr. Bankman-Fried, did you have any understanding about whether or not the relationship with K5 involved something more than being in a broker relationship?
[1499:7] MR. ROOS: Objection, foundation.
[1499:8] THE COURT: Mr. Cohen, what do you say to that?
[1499:9] MR. COHEN: I asked his understanding, your Honor.
[1499:10] THE COURT: Yes, I understand. Why is his understanding on that appropriate?
[1499:12] MR. COHEN: Because, your Honor, again, yesterday we were told these were all reckless and frivolous investments, and I'm entitled to show that there was way more to it than we were told yesterday, so that's the relevance.
[1499:16] THE COURT: I'll allow it for a moment, anyway.
[1499:17] MR. COHEN: Okay. All I need is a moment, your Honor.
[1499:18] Can we read the question back, please.
[1499:19] THE COURT: Please read it back.
[1499:20] (Record read)
[1499:21] A. I know at least one other project that did not itself seem like it was just exercising K5's ability as a broker.
[1499:23] Q. What was that project, Mr. Singh?
[1499:24] A. Sam investing in a tequila brand run by a famous celebrity.
[1499:25] Q. Okay. You also mentioned that in addition to the Kives [1500:1] relationship there were other venture investments that FTX spent on. Do you recall that, sir?
[1500:3] A. Yes.
[1500:4] Q. Okay. And you mentioned I believe a mining company, correct?
[1500:6] A. Bitcoin mining company.
[1500:7] Q. Bitcoin mining. And the judge explained to all of us that wasn't an in-the-ground mining company, correct?
[1500:9] A. And I tried my best and likely failed to clarify further.
[1500:10] Q. Now did you participate, Mr. Singh——let me back up.
[1500:11] Have you ever heard the term "due diligence"?
[1500:12] A. Yes.
[1500:13] Q. What does it mean to you?
[1500:14] A. The process of analyzing the internals of a company to understand how it functions.
[1500:16] Q. And is that done prior to investing in a company?
[1500:17] A. In general.
[1500:18] Q. Okay. Did you participate in any of the due diligence relating to the venture investments you described yesterday?
[1500:20] A. Give me a moment. I'm trying to think about if there is even a single one.
[1500:22] I did for Anthropic.
[1500:23] Q. And just to remind the jury, Anthropic was the AI company, correct?
[1500:25] A. Yes.
[1501:1] Q. And you participated in the due diligence in determining whether to make the investment, correct?
[1501:3] A. Not quite. The investment was first made, the large one, from Sam, and I was really proud of it, and I also wanted to make an investment, or view it as a donation, and so I separately went and talked with the Anthropic folks.
[1501:7] Q. So you asked to make a personal investment in the Anthropic company, correct?
[1501:9] A. No. Initially I thought it would be further investment or donation from Alameda.
[1501:11] Q. Didn't you just say you wanted to personally invest?
[1501:12] A. I wanted to be personally involved.
[1501:13] Q. Okay. Mr. Singh, can we try my question. Did you personally——did you——were you interested in personally investing in Anthropic?
[1501:16] A. Before——
[1501:17] Q. At any time.
[1501:18] A. Yeah, at any time, yes, at one point I was.
[1501:19] Q. Now you also testified yesterday about spending on Bahamas properties. Do you recall that, sir?
[1501:21] A. I do.
[1501:22] MR. COHEN: Can we call up GX 3, please.
[1501:23] Q. Do you recall providing testimony about GX 3, which was the list of the properties purchased in the Bahamas? Do you recall that, sir?
[1502:1] A. I do.
[1502:2] Q. Okay. Just quickly, before I forget, No. 2, it says Albany Lot 44, Conch Shack. Do you see that, sir?
[1502:4] A. Yes.
[1502:5] Q. What was that?
[1502:6] A. This was a house that was conveyed or——that was conveyed to Constance Wang or just one that she lived in.
[1502:8] MR. COHEN: Okay. And we can take this down.
[1502:9] Q. I believe you testified that you and Mr. Bankman-Fried and others, eight in total, wanted to live together in the Bahamas, correct?
[1502:12] A. I forget if it was exactly eight, but yes, a group of us wanted to live together.
[1502:14] Q. Fair enough. You and your girlfriend?
[1502:15] A. Yes.
[1502:16] Q. Mr. Bankman-Fried?
[1502:17] A. Yes.
[1502:18] Q. Mr. Yedidia and his girlfriend?
[1502:19] A. Yes.
[1502:20] Q. Others. Correct?
[1502:21] A. Yes.
[1502:22] Q. So you told us that you looked for——you looked for housing and you saw a place that was less expensive than the penthouse that was ultimately purchased. Do you recall that, sir?
[1502:25] A. A few places, yes.
[1503:1] Q. Few places. And when Mr. Bankman-Fried indicated he was interested in the Orchid 6 penthouse, you had a substantial disagreement. You told us that yesterday.
[1503:4] A. I had a disagreement.
[1503:5] Q. You didn't say substantial disagreement yesterday?
[1503:6] A. I forget exactly what I said yesterday.
[1503:7] Q. Didn't you tell us yesterday that you thought it was really expensive and super ostentatious?
[1503:9] A. Yes.
[1503:10] Q. Okay. But Mr. Bankman-Fried went ahead, went ahead with the purchase anyway, correct?
[1503:12] A. Right.
[1503:13] Q. And then you moved into the apartment.
[1503:14] A. I did.
[1503:15] Q. You and your girlfriend lived in one of the master bedroom suites, didn't you?
[1503:17] A. The nicest room in the house.
[1503:18] Q. And you lived there until you left the Bahamas in November of 2022, correct?
[1503:20] A. Correct.
[1503:21] Q. Okay. And prior——you told us this yesterday. Prior to November 2022, you were a billionaire.
[1503:23] A. So I believed.
[1503:24] Q. Okay. Mr. Bankman-Fried was a billionaire.
[1503:25] A. So I believed.
[1504:1] Q. The other members in the apartment were worth at least millions of dollars, correct?
[1504:3] A. So I believed.
[1504:4] Q. Would you regard it as really expensive for a group of billionaires and millionaires to live in a $30 million apartment?
[1504:7] A. The expense would be the same no matter the wealth of the people living in it.
[1504:9] Q. So your view is it was really expensive.
[1504:10] A. In absolute terms, yes.
[1504:11] Q. What about relative to the wealth of the people living in the apartment?
[1504:13] A. I don't really know what's reasonable for billionaires to do. I don't know other billionaires.
[1504:15] Q. So you have no view.
[1504:16] A. I felt confused about it.
[1504:17] Q. Okay. But not confused enough to move out.
[1504:18] A. Oh, I considered moving out many times.
[1504:19] Q. But you didn't.
[1504:20] A. I didn't.
[1504:21] Q. Okay. Now I want to move to a different topic, Mr. Singh. Bear with me a moment.
[1504:23] Do you recall yesterday that you told us that you were asked what your role was in the fraud against FTX's customers that you committed with the defendant? Do you recall being [1505:1] asked that question, sir?
[1505:2] A. Or something to its effect, yes.
[1505:3] Q. Okay. Fair enough.
[1505:4] And you told us that "In September of 2022, I learned of the hole and even after that, implicitly and explicitly, I greenlit transactions that I knew must have been digging the hole deeper and therefore coming from customer funds." Do you recall giving that testimony yesterday?
[1505:9] A. Or something to that effect, yes.
[1505:10] Q. Okay. So you also testified yesterday that you first learned that customer funds were being deposited, FTX customer funds were being deposited in Alameda bank accounts as early as 2019. Do you recall that, sir?
[1505:14] A. Yes.
[1505:15] Q. And you gave us an example from 2019 and 2020, correct?
[1505:16] A. Sorry. I don't remember which examples I gave, but——
[1505:17] Q. That's fine. So I take it you didn't think that was wrong.
[1505:18] A. Not at the time.
[1505:19] Q. Okay. And then you told us yesterday that——and we'll get to this more in a bit——you told us about a sequence in June, beginning in June 2022, where you were asked to look into certain balances of Alameda. Do you recall that, sir?
[1505:23] A. I do.
[1505:24] Q. Okay. We'll get to that in a minute.
[1505:25] But you also told us that when you first learned about [1506:1] the situation in June, "I thought Alameda had positive balances on FTX, that it was borrowing in lots in some places but that overall they had the money." Do you recall giving us that testimony?
[1506:5] MR. ROOS: Objection. I think Mr. Cohen is just rereading his testimony from yesterday.
[1506:7] MR. COHEN: I'm setting up the question, your Honor. This is cross-examination.
[1506:9] THE COURT: Mr. Cohen, I understand what's happening in this courtroom, and I don't need that. If you're reading from the transcript, read from the transcript and identify by page and line what you're reading from.
[1506:13] MR. COHEN: I thought I was. Okay. I will, your Honor.
[1506:15] THE COURT: Well, let's proceed that way.
[1506:16] MR. COHEN: Let's go to the transcript. For counsel and the Court's benefit, this is page 1404. You don't have to show it to the witness, but for counsel and the Court, lines 5 through 11.
[1506:20] BY MR. COHEN:
[1506:21] Q. "Q. What do you mean?"
[1506:22] "The June exercise, I thought Alameda had positive balances on FTX, that it was borrowing lots in some places but that overall, they had more money than they didn't. This suggested an entirely different reality. I was hoping that I [1507:1] didn't really understand what Gary——what Gary meant by borrowing, but if I did, this was absolutely devastating."
[1507:3] Do you see that, sir? Did you hear that, sir? I'm sorry.
[1507:5] A. I hear that.
[1507:6] Q. And you gave that testimony yesterday.
[1507:7] A. I believe so.
[1507:8] Q. All right. So as of June——this is the date that you gave the testimony in——your concern was whether or not Alameda had assets to cover the borrowing.
[1507:11] A. I had other concerns as well.
[1507:12] Q. In the passage I just read, that was what you told us.
[1507:13] MR. ROOS: Speaks for itself.
[1507:14] THE COURT: Sustained.
[1507:15] Q. Now what were your other concerns in June?