Trial Testimony of Nishad Singh, October 16 and 17, 2023: Transcript, part 9 of 13 (pages 1507 to 1532)

[1507:16] A. The exercise showed that there were specific accounts that were extremely negative, like the main account. To be in that position suggested a use of "Allow Negative" that didn't meet the spirit that I expected these privileges to be used in.

[1507:20] Q. Okay. And so prior to June of 2022 was it your view that as long as the balances were offset by sufficient assets, the borrowing was appropriate?

[1507:23] A. That was not my view.

[1507:24] Q. What was your view?

[1507:25] A. On what specifically?

[1508:1] Q. Prior to June——I understand your testimony about June, and we'll come back to that——did you have a view about whether or not Alameda could borrow provided that the borrowing was supported by assets?

[1508:5] A. There were many circumstances in which I thought that would not be appropriate.

[1508:7] Q. You didn't think——you didn't think there were circumstances in which it would be appropriate.

[1508:9] MR. ROOS: Objection, vague and asked and answered.

[1508:10] THE COURT: Sustained.

[1508:11] Q. Mr. Singh, do you recall yesterday you told us you had many meetings with the government?

[1508:13] A. Yes.

[1508:14] Q. And I think you said you had about 20 such meetings.

[1508:15] A. That sounds right.

[1508:16] Q. And in those meetings the prosecutors would ask you questions?

[1508:18] A. They would.

[1508:19] Q. And you would try to answer them the best you could?

[1508:20] A. Correct.

[1508:21] Q. Okay. Do you recall meeting with them in——well, let me do it this way. Is it fair to say that your first meeting with the prosecutors was in November of 2022?

[1508:24] A. I believe that's right.

[1508:25] Q. November 21st?

[1509:1] A. I don't remember the exact date. Sorry. But I believe that's right.

[1509:3] Q. Is it fair to say that you had meetings in November, December, and January——November and December of 2022?

[1509:5] A. Yes.

[1509:6] Q. And then you had meetings with them again in January, February, and March of the following year?

[1509:8] A. Yes.

[1509:9] Q. And then you had additional meetings in May and August?

[1509:10] A. Sorry. I forget all the exact dates.

[1509:11] Q. And you had meetings in September and October.

[1509:12] A. Yes.

[1509:13] Q. Including a meeting this past week.

[1509:14] A. Yes.

[1509:15] Q. Do you recall having a meeting with the prosecutors on January 4th of 2023?

[1509:17] A. Sorry. I don't remember the specific dates of our meetings.

[1509:19] Q. A January meeting.

[1509:20] A. I remember meeting in January.

[1509:21] Q. Okay. Do you recall telling the prosecutors that to you, the idea of borrowing from anywhere, as long as you were good for it, didn't feel wrong?

[1509:24] A. I don't remember saying that.

[1509:25] MR. COHEN: Can we call up 3501-021 just for the [1510:1] witness, please. Page 14.

[1510:2] Okay. If you can go to the last paragraph at the bottom, Brian.

[1510:4] And go to the last two sentences.

[1510:5] Q. Mr. Singh, read those to yourself and tell us whether or not they refresh your recollection that you told that to the prosecutors.

[1510:8] A. I don't——

[1510:9] MR. ROOS: Objection to the form.

[1510:10] THE COURT: What's the form objection?

[1510:11] MR. ROOS: To "telling it to the prosecutors" in the underlying question.

[1510:13] THE COURT: I'm sorry, what?

[1510:14] MR. ROOS: Just the formulation of the "do you recall telling that to the prosecutors."

[1510:16] THE COURT: Sustained as to form.

[1510:17] MR. COHEN: Let me see if we can address the Court's, counsel's issue.

[1510:19] BY MR. COHEN:

[1510:20] Q. Mr. Singh, read that to yourself, and does that refresh your recollection about what you said to the prosecutors?

[1510:22] A. Yes, but not about the exact topic we're talking about.

[1510:23] Q. So it doesn't refresh you about the topic we just discussed.

[1510:25] A. About borrowing in general? No. This refreshes me on [1511:1] something specific I thought about bank accounts.

[1511:2] MR. COHEN: Okay. Then let's take that down.

[1511:3] Q. When you considered the assets that would be posted as security for the loans, did the nature——did you take into account the nature of the assets?

[1511:6] MR. ROOS: Objection, vague and foundation.

[1511:7] THE COURT: Sustained.

[1511:8] MR. COHEN: Sure.

[1511:9] Q. Coming back to——we were talking about what your thinking was prior to June of 2022. Do you recall that, sir?

[1511:11] A. I do.

[1511:12] Q. Okay. In the period prior to 2022 did you take——in thinking about what was going on at Alameda and whether anything was wrong, did you take into account the nature of the assets that Alameda was posting as collateral?

[1511:16] MR. ROOS: Objection, foundation.

[1511:17] THE COURT: Sustained.

[1511:18] Q. Now your view changed at some point? Or let me ask you a better question. When did you first believe you had done anything wrong?

[1511:21] A. I knew that I'd done something wrong when I helped doctor the Serum staking fees revenue.

[1511:23] Q. When was that, sir?

[1511:24] A. That was December 30th or 31st of 2021.

[1511:25] Q. Okay. And coming into the period prior to June, other than [1512:1] the staking fees you just talked about, is there anything else you thought you had done wrong?

[1512:3] A. I'm not sure.

[1512:4] Q. And then you told us yesterday your view changed in September 2022; is that correct?

[1512:6] A. Sorry. On what specifically?

[1512:7] Q. About what you had done wrong.

[1512:8] MR. ROOS: Objection, vague.

[1512:9] THE COURT: Yes. I don't understand, Mr. Cohen. I thought the witness just said that he first believed that he did something wrong in December——I'm mistaken. Excuse me. You go ahead.

[1512:13] You can re-put the question.

[1512:14] MR. COHEN: Okay.

[1512:15] BY MR. COHEN:

[1512:16] Q. I want to understand, to the Court's comment, what you thought in September 2022 was wrong with your conduct.

[1512:18] A. My conduct before that point or after that point?

[1512:19] Q. Take it in steps. Let's do before first.

[1512:20] A. Before that point, I knew that in June, I had observed Alameda borrowing in large amounts in a way that didn't meet the expectations I had and what I'd been told about how Alameda would use things like "Allow Negative." Even in June, when I suspected there was wrongdoing there, I took cues from the people around me and didn't pursue it further.

[1513:1] In September, I understood not only had there been an enormous amount of borrowing but that the money wasn't there at all.

[1513:4] Q. Okay. So, all right. We're going to come back to June, we're going to come back to September. I don't want to do them in bits and pieces. Just let me cover another topic quickly.

[1513:7] Do you recall that yesterday counsel asked you questions about your compensation while you worked for FTX?

[1513:9] A. Yes.

[1513:10] Q. And I believe you told us that you made a salary of about 200,000?

[1513:12] A. Yes.

[1513:13] Q. And that you'd receive cash bonuses around 1 to 2 million; is that correct?

[1513:15] A. I think that's right.

[1513:16] Q. Now you also received loans from FTX, correct?

[1513:17] A. Many.

[1513:18] Q. And you touched on a loan yesterday, but I'd like to go over it with you in a bit more detail, sir. Let me just give you the foundation.

[1513:21] Is it fair to say that at a certain point you borrowed 477 million from FTX?

[1513:23] A. In a sense.

[1513:24] Q. In a sense. And this was to purchase options?

[1513:25] A. Yes.

[1514:1] Q. Shares in FTX?

[1514:2] A. Yes.

[1514:3] Q. Okay. And it was to buy more equity in FTX, correct?

[1514:4] A. To buy my first equity in FTX.

[1514:5] Q. Okay. And you said that one of the reasons you were looking to do this was you wanted to donate the money to charity.

[1514:8] A. Right.

[1514:9] Q. Did you end up doing that?

[1514:10] A. No.

[1514:11] Q. Okay. And you said that there were taxes used with regard to how it was to be structured, correct?

[1514:13] A. The reason I believe——

[1514:14] Q. I'm sorry. Let me ask a better question, sir. The "this" being how the loans would be structured.

[1514:16] A. The reason it was structured this way was so that there was a smaller outlay of cash from Alameda, with the tradeoff being that I took on a large debt.

[1514:19] Q. Okay. And you just answer this yes or no, sir. You consulted with attorneys about how to structure this loan, correct?

[1514:22] A. Yes.

[1514:23] Q. Okay. I believe you mentioned Dan Friedberg; is that correct?

[1514:25] THE COURT: Well, Mr. Cohen, it's not clear whether [1515:1] you're asking whether he did that in connection with this or whether he ever consulted Dan Friedberg about anything.

[1515:3] MR. COHEN: I meant in this, your Honor.

[1515:4] MR. ROOS: Objection. Misstates testimony then.

[1515:5] Q. Who were the lawyers you consulted with about this $477 million loan?

[1515:7] A. Can Sun; Joe Bankman; two of Sam's personal tax lawyers, David Forst, Sean McElroy, and others.

[1515:9] Q. Where did David Forst and Sean McElroy work, if you know?

[1515:10] A. I don't know. I think Fenwick & West but I'm not sure.

[1515:11] Q. Fenwick & West was an outside law firm?

[1515:12] A. Yes.

[1515:13] Q. And Can, C-A-N, Sun was the general counsel of FTX, correct?

[1515:15] A. Yes.

[1515:16] Q. Now documentation was prepared for that loan, correct?

[1515:17] A. Yes.

[1515:18] Q. And you signed that documentation.

[1515:19] A. Yes.

[1515:20] Q. Now you also——did you also receive a loan for $10 million?

[1515:21] A. I did.

[1515:22] Q. And that was for funds you wanted to provide to your parents, correct?

[1515:24] A. Family and friends.

[1515:25] Q. Okay. Family and friends. And that loan was in 2021, [1516:1] correct?

[1516:2] A. Yes, I believe early 2021.

[1516:3] Q. And that was money you borrowed from FTX in order to pay to family members.

[1516:5] A. Not quite.

[1516:6] Q. Was it money you borrowed from FTX?

[1516:7] A. No.

[1516:8] Q. You didn't borrow it.

[1516:9] A. I did borrow it.

[1516:10] Q. Okay. So——

[1516:11] A. Sorry. To be clear——

[1516:12] Q. Let me try, Mr. Singh. Did you borrow $10 million from FTX?

[1516:14] A. No.

[1516:15] Q. No. How did it get to you?

[1516:16] A. Sam gave it to me.

[1516:17] Q. Sam gave it to you from——through FTX?

[1516:18] A. I don't think so.

[1516:19] Q. Okay. And those were funds that were used to pay for your family-related expenses.

[1516:21] A. They were gifts to family and friends, and some amount was donated.

[1516:23] Q. Okay. Why don't we now move to another topic, Mr. Singh. And let's talk about June, June of 2022.

[1516:25] Well, I think we have to go back a little bit. Do you [1517:1] recall giving testimony yesterday about a bug in the fiat@ account system?

[1517:3] A. I do.

[1517:4] Q. And without getting too technical, the effect of this bug was to make it look like Alameda's balances were more negative than they really were, or that——let me rephrase——that Alameda owed more money to FTX than it really did?

[1517:8] A. The effect of the bug was that the fiat@ftx.com's stated balance was more negative than the——than what it should have actually been, and Alameda was consuming this balance and treating it as something that they were on the hook for, as I understood, and so Alameda overestimated how much they should have had in bank accounts to back customer deposits.

[1517:14] Q. So the net of it was Alameda overestimated the amount it owed to——back to FTX.

[1517:16] A. Yes.

[1517:17] Q. And I believe you told us yesterday that you first became aware of the bug in 2021.

[1517:19] A. I think either November or December of '21.

[1517:20] Q. And tell us again how you first learned of it.

[1517:21] A. It was in the Bahamas office. It was late at night. Gary and Adam sat a few desks away from me, and I overheard them talking about the bug.

[1517:24] Q. Okay. And what did you overhear?

[1517:25] A. I think Gary was explaining that it existed. Adam was [1518:1] worried. Gary assured that the direction of the bug was safe, that Alameda overestimated, not underestimated how much it should keep in banks.

[1518:4] Q. Okay. Did they discuss——did they go over how big the bug was at that time?

[1518:6] A. I can't remember if they did. I remember asking for details, and at some point I had an understanding of the size——

[1518:8] Q. I'm just asking about the conversation with Gary and Adam. We'll get to the rest in a bit. Can you try——can we try again, Mr. Singh.

[1518:11] A. I can't remember if they said the size of the bug.

[1518:12] Q. Okay. And you mentioned that Gary said it was in a safe direction. What did you understand that to mean?

[1518:14] A. That Alameda believed because of the bug that they should be custodying more, not less cash than they actually needed to for customers.

[1518:17] Q. So it was safe from the FTX point of view.

[1518:18] A. Yes.

[1518:19] Q. Okay. Do you remember how, if at all, Mr. Wang and Mr. Yedidia reacted to this?

[1518:21] A. Adam was worried.

[1518:22] Q. I'm sorry?

[1518:23] A. Adam Yedidia was worried about it. After Gary gave his explanation, he seemed relaxed.

[1518:25] Q. Isn't it true that Gary joked about the bug?

[1519:1] A. Yes. I think that's right.

[1519:2] Q. He thought it was funny, correct?

[1519:3] MR. ROOS: Objection.

[1519:4] THE COURT: Sustained.

[1519:5] Q. He seemed relaxed about it, you said.

[1519:6] MR. ROOS: Objection.

[1519:7] THE COURT: Sustained.

[1519:8] He said Adam seemed relaxed.

[1519:9] MR. COHEN: I don't think that was the testimony, your Honor, but I'll ask again.

[1519:11] Q. What was Gary's reaction?

[1519:12] MR. ROOS: Objection. It was either asked and answered or it's speculation.

[1519:14] THE COURT: Sustained.

[1519:15] And you're right, Mr. Cohen, he did say Gary.

[1519:16] MR. COHEN: So then I don't need to go back since it's already in the record.

[1519:18] THE COURT: You don't need to go back.

[1519:19] MR. COHEN: Then I won't. Okay.

[1520:1] Q. Did you have any reaction at the time, Mr. Singh, of this conversation?

[1520:3] A. I did.

[1520:4] Q. What was your reaction?

[1520:5] A. I shared Adam's worry. After Gary explained that it was safe, I asked Gary if Alameda is in fact tracking this number. Gary said he's pretty sure but that it wouldn't hurt for me to confirm. I asked Caroline if they were. Caroline said they were.

[1520:10] Q. Let's move forward then to June of 2022 now, sir.

[1520:11] I believe you told us you had a communication with Caroline Ellison about Alameda's net asset value being close to zero.

[1520:14] Do you recall telling us about that yesterday?

[1520:15] A. Sorry. I don't.

[1520:16] Q. Do you recall speaking with Caroline Ellison at all in June of 2022?

[1520:18] A. Yes.

[1520:19] Q. By speak, just to be clear, I mean either orally or over Signal or Slack or so forth.

[1520:21] A. That's how I interpreted it, yes.

[1520:22] Q. What was the gist of the conversation about the state of Alameda's net asset value?

[1520:24] MR. ROOS: Objection. Hearsay.

[1520:25] THE COURT: Why isn't it, Mr. Cohen?

[1521:1] MR. COHEN: It goes to the effect on the listener, your Honor.

[1521:3] THE COURT: That's relevant why?

[1521:4] MR. COHEN: Because we are talking about the state of mind of one of the coconspirators or the alleged coconspirators.

[1521:7] THE COURT: Mr. Roos.

[1521:8] MR. ROOS: Maybe I guess we will see where the answer takes us.

[1521:10] THE COURT: Overruled.

[1521:11] MR. COHEN: Can we have the question read back?

[1521:12] THE COURT: Sure.

[1521:13] (Record read)

[1521:14] A. The conversation I remember was the one in which Caroline sent the spreadsheet that we talked about yesterday. I don't recall parts of this conversation referencing that Alameda's NAV was zero.

[1521:18] Q. Do you recall anything with Ms. Ellison about what the state of Alameda was in terms of its solvency?

[1521:20] A. In June?

[1521:21] Q. Um-hum.

[1521:22] A. No.

[1521:23] Q. Let's move forward because I think you covered a number of different sequences with respect to June and I want to make sure I understand them, sir.

[1522:1] Can you please tell us, as best you can, who you spoke with about this bug in June.

[1522:3] A. You would like me to list the people?

[1522:4] Q. I would like you to list the sequence, to the extent you can.

[1522:6] A. Sure. Tell me if I'm -- if my answer --

[1522:7] Q. Do your best, sir.

[1522:8] A. Caroline sent a spreadsheet, I think a Google Sheet, that contained a list of accounts labeled as if they were from Alameda's pointer system, so Alameda's nomenclature and the total value held in each. These were accounts that Alameda owned on FTX, things like the fiat account and their trading account. They showed some extremely large negative number when considered together.

[1522:15] Q. If I could stop you for a moment, sir. Who did she send that to, the Google Sheet that you referred to?

[1522:17] A. I know that she sent it to me, Sam, and Gary. I don't know if she also sent it to other people.

[1522:19] Q. Was this on one Signal communication?

[1522:20] A. I don't remember.

[1522:21] Q. Are you sure she sent it to you, Sam, and Gary?

[1522:22] MR. ROOS: Objection.

[1522:23] THE COURT: Overruled.

[1522:24] A. I am sure that the four of us got on a Google Meet and worked on like investigating it. I am not sure that she only [1523:1] sent it to the four of us.

[1523:2] Q. Let's continue with the sequence, sir.

[1523:3] A. Sure. Sam sees the spreadsheet and said something to the effect of, this can't be right. There has got to be a bug. Let's look into it.

[1523:6] Q. This was in a different Signal or the same Signal?

[1523:7] A. I can't recall. Sorry.

[1523:8] Q. Keep going.

[1523:9] A. I asked Gary how I could help. Gary told me that I could try my best to identify the accounts in the FTX database that either belonged to Alameda explicitly or morally, morally meaning that in the end there were things that Sam was responsible for.

[1523:14] I took a stab. My stab was ignored. Gary took a stab. I added a column to add notes for which elements of Gary's list -- which items Gary had pulled that I thought weren't actually belonging to Alameda. And then I recall Gary pointed out the bug. He calculated the bug.

[1523:19] Q. If I can stop you for a moment, sir.

[1523:20] These conversations you have just been going through for us, were they all over Signal or Slack, or any of them in person?

[1523:23] A. A number of it was over Google Meet, like done orally.

[1523:24] Q. Were there any that were in person?

[1523:25] A. I think Gary was next to me in the office, but I don't [1524:1] recall for sure. Sam may have been. I don't think Caroline was next to me.

[1524:3] Q. So you don't recall Caroline being there in person?

[1524:4] A. Not for this.

[1524:5] Q. You are not sure if Sam was there in person?

[1524:6] A. Correct.

[1524:7] Q. Keep going.

[1524:8] A. Gary identified the bug and calculated its effect size, which was around $8 billion. Caroline posted a screenshot of the graph that she had created that showed two things. One was Alameda's unexpected balance breaks over time or unexplained balance breaks, which I understood to mean something like unexplained changes in the balances that they were fetching, things that they couldn't reconcile against records of trades or withdrawals.

[1524:16] And then she posted the effect size, I think, that either Gary or I had given her of the bug over time. These charts showed two lines that were largely parallel, implying that this bug explained at least a large portion of what was unexplained in Alameda's observed balance breaks.

[1524:21] Q. If I could stop you there for a moment, Mr. Singh.

[1524:22] You used a couple of phrases I just want to go over. You used a phrase called balance break. What did you mean by that?

[1524:25] A. Balances in a trading system change over time. There are [1525:1] also transactions that can explain those changes. If you infer just from the transactions that you received what balances would result from them and you compare them against the actual balances that you are retrieving and fetching live, sometimes there is a difference because you might be missing records or you might be misinterpreting records. That difference is a break.

[1525:8] Q. In this situation was the break the size of the bug, the effect of the bug?

[1525:10] A. I don't think it was exactly. I recall that this chart Caroline showed suggested that a large fraction of it was explained by the bug.

[1525:13] Q. Do you recall, when you first spoke -- you overheard Gary and Adam Yedidia at the end of 2021 talk about the bug, whether the topic of a break came up?

[1525:16] A. I don't recall.

[1525:17] Q. Now, when you learned that the break was $8 billion, were you surprised?

[1525:19] A. Yes.

[1525:20] Q. Were you surprised that it had not been tracked?

[1525:21] A. I was surprised -- no, not exactly.

[1525:22] Q. Didn't you just tell us that Gary assured you it was being tracked by Ms. Ellison and others?

[1525:24] A. Gary believed that it was being tracked. Caroline assured me that it was being tracked.

[1526:1] Q. So Gary's belief was incorrect?

[1526:2] MR. ROOS: Objection.

[1526:3] THE COURT: I think the witness can handle that question.

[1526:5] A. No. Gary wasn't incorrect.

[1526:6] Q. What about Caroline?

[1526:7] A. Caroline wasn't incorrect.

[1526:8] Q. So it hadn't been tracked?

[1526:9] MR. ROOS: Objection. Vague.

[1526:10] THE COURT: Sustained.

[1526:11] Q. Let me go back to your answer because I want to make it a little more focused. When you answered about what was being tracked, were you referring to the balances in the fiat@ account or the effect of the bug or, I guess, both?

[1526:15] A. Just the balances in the fiat account.

[1526:16] Q. Based on your interaction with the work you did in June, did you have a view about whether those balances had been tracked prior to June?

[1526:19] MR. ROOS: Objection.

[1526:20] THE COURT: Sustained. Form at least.

[1526:21] Q. The topic of the break come up?

[1526:22] A. Sorry. When?

[1526:23] Q. About whether the break had been tracked since the end of the prior year that had come on.

[1526:25] MR. ROOS: Objection. When?

[1527:1] MR. COHEN: Since 2021.

[1527:2] THE COURT: I don't understand what counsel means by the break at this point.

[1527:4] MR. COHEN: The bug. The size of the bug.

[1527:5] A. Sorry. Your question -- could you repeat the question?

[1527:6] Q. Sure.

[1527:7] Let me ask it this way. Mr. Singh, did you ever track the bug, size of the bug or its effect, prior to June 2022?

[1527:9] A. Not prior to June 2022 that I recall.

[1527:10] Q. Based on your interactions with others at Alameda and FTX, do you think anyone else did?

[1527:12] MR. ROOS: Objection.

[1527:13] THE COURT: Sustained.

[1527:14] If I understand what you said, Mr. Singh, Gary told you that he thought the size of the overstatement was being tracked. Caroline subsequently assured you that that was so. Is that right so far?

[1527:18] THE WITNESS: That's not quite right.

[1527:19] THE COURT: Then correct me, please.

[1527:20] THE WITNESS: Gary assured me that the full balance, not separately the size of the error, was being tracked. Gary assured me that the fiat@FTX.com balance, which included the bug, was being tracked. Caroline assured me it was. I don't think anybody told me that the size of the bug was being tracked over time.

[1528:1] THE COURT: I said the size of the overstatement, not the size of the bug, Mr. Singh.

[1528:3] The bug was an error in the computer code, right?

[1528:4] THE WITNESS: Correct.

[1528:5] THE COURT: And it had an effect, right?

[1528:6] THE WITNESS: Correct.

[1528:7] THE COURT: The effect was to overstate the amount owed by Alameda to FTX, correct?

[1528:9] THE WITNESS: Correct.

[1528:10] THE COURT: Please, Mr. Cohen, take it from there.

[1528:11] MR. COHEN: Can we have just the last exchange with his Honor read back, please?

[1528:13] THE COURT: Yup. I think his Honor may have asked that question. I just want to hear it again.

[1528:15] (Record read)

[1528:16] MR. COHEN: I think his Honor has covered it.

[1528:17] Q. Very quickly, Mr. Singh, the fiat account was tracked, not the amount of the bug?

[1528:19] A. Not the size of the error as a result of the bug.

[1528:20] Q. I am going to ask you to complete the sequence, but before you do that, you used a phrase called morally responsible for certain amounts. What did you mean by that?

[1528:23] A. There are some accounts in the FTX system that are explicitly under Alameda's name, things like info@AlamedaResearch.com. There are other accounts, like [1529:1] Project Serum accounts, that on their face don't belong to Alameda Research but that I understood, in the end, Sam beneficially owned. Those accounts would be morally but not explicitly owned by Alameda or Sam, so those were to be included inside of this calculation.

[1529:6] Q. Meaning in the event that they were needed, you understood that Sam would make use of those assets for Alameda?

[1529:8] A. Really just that they fell under the large umbrella of things that Sam controlled, which was not just Alameda.

[1529:10] Q. But you considered it in connection with considering the assets of Alameda?

[1529:12] A. I was told to pull those balances.

[1529:13] Q. And you pulled them?

[1529:14] A. Gary ended up pulling them.

[1529:15] Q. Why don't we complete the sequence, sir.

[1529:16] MR. ROOS: Objection.

[1529:17] THE COURT: I think it's a little hard to start in the middle of the ocean at this point. Try to pin it down.

[1529:19] Q. You told us, Mr. Singh, about communications you had with Gary, Sam, and Caroline over communications about addressing the impact of the bug. Can you tell us what happened next.

[1529:22] A. Gary identified -- I think I may have said this. Forgive me if I'm repeating myself. Gary had identified the bug. He identified its effect size as of the current date then, so as of the date we were doing the exercise. Caroline demonstrated [1530:1] that this bug explained a lot of what had been unexplained in Alameda's observed balance breaks.

[1530:3] I believe I asked -- said I thought this was fixed in November. I don't remember if I got a response, but it's a silly question. It hadn't been fixed. I don't recall everything that happened after that.

[1530:7] The next thing I do recall is sensing from others a palpable sense of relief and even celebration. Sam made a joke or sort of like comment on how it was amazing that such a large balance break could be explained just by a single thing, a single bug.

[1530:12] Q. We have now talked -- everything you just told us about the bug took place in June and July of 2022.

[1530:14] A. I think everything I just described now was on a single day, like a single -- in a single hour over Google Meet or something.

[1530:17] Q. It's a series of communications over Google Meet?

[1530:18] A. One Google Meet, one long discussion over Google Meet.

[1530:19] Q. With potentially some in-person communications as well?

[1530:20] A. Yeah.

[1530:21] Q. Do you believe you are clear on the sequence of what happened?

[1530:23] A. I don't think I remember everything about it.

[1530:24] Q. But on what you just told us, you believe you are clear on that, correct?

[1531:1] A. I'm stating the sequence the best to the best of my ability.

[1531:3] Q. Now, we talked about the 20 interviews you've had with the prosecutors, correct, sir?

[1531:5] A. Correct.

[1531:6] Q. Do you recall speaking with them in January of this past year, January 4?

[1531:8] A. I don't recall the specific date, but I do think I met with them in January.

[1531:10] Q. And at that point you had already had many meetings with them, correct?

[1531:12] A. Yeah. I had had more than one.

[1531:13] Q. Does it refresh you that you had more than five?

[1531:14] A. I would believe it.

[1531:15] Q. Fair enough. And you had gone over the topic of what happened in June with them, correct?

[1531:17] A. I think so.

[1531:18] Q. Isn't it fair to say that you told the prosecutors that you had a surprising amount of haziness when trying to recall events in June and July of 2022?

[1531:21] A. I don't remember saying those exact words, but I did acknowledge that there was a lot that I -- there was a lot that I didn't remember the details around from that time.

[1531:24] Q. In particular as to June and July of 2022.

[1531:25] A. I don't know if I said specifically those dates or months.

[1532:1] MR. COHEN: Why don't we call up for the witness only 3501-021, page 17.

[1532:3] Brian, if you could go to the second-to-last paragraph and call it out, pull it up.