[1606:9] Q. What's your memory, sir?
[1606:10] A. That I did tell prosecutors I thought FTX might last for years, not that it would.
[1606:12] Q. Let's move forward, sir.
[1606:13] Let's now go to November 2022.
[1606:14] MR. COHEN: Pull up GX-480A, please.
[1606:15] Q. This is a chat between you and Mr. Bankman-Fried that you reviewed yesterday.
[1606:17] Do you recall that, sir?
[1606:18] A. I do.
[1606:19] Q. And it's from November 6 of 2022.
[1606:20] A. Yes.
[1606:21] Q. The blue is you and the gray is Mr. Bankman-Fried?
[1606:22] A. Yes.
[1606:23] Q. In the first entry you say that one thing that seriously helped me is if I didn't have debts. I think most of them are loans, 500 million for me exercising, more for U.S. [1607:1] investments. I hope we can unwind these but not sure.
[1607:2] Sir, this refers to the loans you have told us about earlier in your testimony, correct, that you took from FTX?
[1607:4] A. This refers to the 477 million on paper loan used for exercising and other loans made through me, Sam, and Gary to capitalize FTX US for it to make investments.
[1607:7] Q. And here you're seeking to have them unwound, correct?
[1607:8] A. I am hoping they could be unwound. I am not sure.
[1607:9] Q. Now, you are telling Mr. Bankman-Fried that it would help you not to have any debts, correct?
[1607:11] A. Right.
[1607:12] Q. By having the loans unwound.
[1607:13] A. Right.
[1607:14] Q. Then going to the third paragraph up here: Maybe 80 million extra or so are donations, personal, etc., that went through my bank account and are in my name, so 120 million pretax or something. I'm not sure that's the exact number.
[1607:18] Is that a reference to the political donations we talked about before the break?
[1607:20] A. It's a reference to that and more.
[1607:21] Q. What's the more?
[1607:22] A. Borrows from my FTX account against my FTT collateral.
[1607:23] Q. Anything else?
[1607:24] A. The 10 million that Sam gave me a few years earlier.
[1607:25] Q. You are telling Mr. Bankman-Fried here that you don't want [1608:1] to be responsible for that, correct?
[1608:2] A. Right.
[1608:3] MR. COHEN: Can we continue down, Brian, to the gray.
[1608:4] Q. Mr. Bankman-Fried says: Will think about this. What does trade mean? Excuse me. I think about this. You say thanks. What does trade mean? And you explain. Sell FTT or SRM earlier in 2022. Is that correct?
[1608:8] A. Yes.
[1608:9] Q. SRM, we covered, is Serum?
[1608:10] A. Serum tokens.
[1608:11] Q. Your idea here was to set up a backdated trade so that you would not be responsible for these amounts you had borrowed, correct?
[1608:14] A. Correct.
[1608:15] Q. And that ended up not happening, correct?
[1608:16] A. Correct. I didn't go through with it.
[1608:17] MR. COHEN: We can take that down.
[1608:18] Q. Mr. Roos asked you a series of questions about your cooperation with the government.
[1608:20] Do you recall that, sir?
[1608:21] A. I do.
[1608:22] Q. I think we have established that you had at least 20 meetings with the prosecutors, correct?
[1608:24] A. I can't remember if we said at least.
[1608:25] THE COURT: I think we have covered that two or three [1609:1] times today.
[1609:2] Q. Just to put this in sequence, you entered into a cooperation agreement with the government, correct?
[1609:4] A. I did.
[1609:5] Q. That was on February 28?
[1609:6] A. I don't remember the exact date. That sounds about right.
[1609:7] Q. Prior to that, you had a number of meetings with the government.
[1609:9] A. Yes.
[1609:10] Q. So you had meetings in November, December, and January with the government?
[1609:12] THE COURT: Mr. Cohen, we did all that before lunch.
[1609:13] MR. COHEN: There is a piece we have not done yet, your Honor.
[1609:15] THE COURT: Let's get to it, please.
[1609:16] MR. COHEN: OK.
[1609:17] Q. In the meetings before you had the cooperation agreement, you entered into a different agreement called a proffer agreement, correct?
[1609:20] A. I did.
[1609:21] MR. COHEN: We would like to offer 3501-11.
[1609:22] MR. ROOS: No objection.
[1609:23] THE COURT: Received.
[1609:24] (Defendant's Exhibit 3501-11 received in evidence)
[1609:25] MR. COHEN: Go to the second page, Brian.
[1610:1] Q. This was signed by you and your attorneys and the lawyers for the government?
[1610:3] A. I can't remember if all the signatures here are exclusively -- are within that group, but at least I know that some of them are.
[1610:6] Q. Do you recognize your own signature?
[1610:7] A. I do.
[1610:8] MR. COHEN: Let's go back to the first page. If we could call out the second paragraph, number 1.
[1610:10] Q. It says in bold: This is not a cooperation agreement.
[1610:11] Do you see that, sir?
[1610:12] A. I do.
[1610:13] Q. The government had not yet decided whether they would offer you a cooperation agreement at this point, correct?
[1610:15] A. I don't know what was in their heads. I had not yet been offered a cooperation agreement.
[1610:17] MR. COHEN: You can pull that back down, Brian.
[1610:18] If we can pull out paragraph 3.
[1610:19] Q. These proffer agreements would cover your interviews during this period with the government before a cooperation agreement was reached.
[1610:22] A. Correct.
[1610:23] Q. Maybe we don't have to go through line by line.
[1610:24] Is it your understanding, sir, that the government could use the information it received in these interviews to [1611:1] pursue leads against you?
[1611:2] A. Yes.
[1611:3] Q. Even if you never got a cooperation agreement?
[1611:4] A. That's my understanding.
[1611:5] Q. Is it your understanding that if you made false statements in these interviews, you could be separately prosecuted for them?
[1611:8] A. Yes.
[1611:9] Q. Regardless of whether you got a cooperation agreement?
[1611:10] A. That's my understanding.
[1611:11] Q. Now, is it fair to say, Mr. Singh, that you were interviewed by the government on January 19 of this year?
[1611:13] A. I don't remember the exact dates, sorry.
[1611:14] Q. That's OK.
[1611:15] Do you recall the government asking you about the purchase of the Orcas Island house?
[1611:17] A. I remember discussing it with them.
[1611:18] Q. Isn't it true that you told them that you thought that there were points along the way when you had a pit in your stomach and felt things were wrong, but the purchase of the house was not one of those times?
[1611:22] A. I don't remember if those were my exact words.
[1611:23] Q. Words to that effect?
[1611:24] A. I don't remember.
[1611:25] MR. COHEN: Why don't we pull up 3501-28 at page 9.
[1612:1] If we can go to page 9 just for the witness, bottom of 9. Go back. I think we might have to go to page 10.
[1612:3] Go back to 9. I'm sorry, Brian. Top of 9. I got it.
[1612:4] Pull out the paragraph at the top of 9.
[1612:5] Q. Read the first paragraph to yourself. My question is simply whether it refreshes your recollection of you telling the prosecutors there are points along the way when you had a pit in your stomach and felt things were wrong, but the purchase of the home was not one of those times.
[1612:10] A. Sorry. I don't see an exhibit in front of me.
[1612:11] THE COURT: We are now getting into the area of essentially reading a document that's not in evidence. I know what you are trying to do, but it's not working, so try a different way.
[1612:15] A. My screen is blank.
[1612:16] Q. Your screen is blank.
[1612:17] MR. COHEN: Can we put his screen back up and then we will move on. Top of page 9.
[1613:1] THE COURT: Please put a question.
[1613:2] MR. COHEN: Okay. Is it back up? I'm sorry.
[1613:3] THE COURT: Yes.
[1613:4] BY MR. COHEN:
[1613:5] Q. Again, Mr. Singh, yes or no: Does the passage at the top of that page, page 9, refresh your recollection about whether you told the prosecutors there were points along the way when you had a pit in your stomach and felt things were wrong but the purchase of the home was not one of those times?
[1613:10] A. Not really.
[1613:11] Q. Okay. Do you recall in that same meeting being asked about the political donations——
[1613:13] MR. ROOS: Can we take down the document.
[1613:14] MR. COHEN: Yes, please.
[1613:15] Q. Do you recall being asked in the same meeting about whether or not the political donations you made were loans to you?
[1613:17] MR. ROOS: Objection to what meeting.
[1613:18] Q. The meeting with the government on January 19th.
[1613:19] A. I don't remember what was discussed at each meeting exactly.
[1613:21] Q. Do you remember telling the government in January, whether you remember the date, that you did not feel like you——let me back up——there were points along the way when you had a pit in your stomach and felt things were wrong but you did not feel like that when you treated the transfers from Alameda as loans [1614:1] without questioning further?
[1614:2] A. Still not sure I said that.
[1614:3] Q. You're not sure whether you ever told the government that the transfers from Alameda were not loans to you?
[1614:5] A. Sorry. Do you mind repeating the question.
[1614:6] Q. Yeah. Did you ever deny to the government that the transfers from Alameda were loans to you?
[1614:8] A. I don't know if I——I characterized them and described how I viewed them. I don't know that I——I can't remember what exactly I said.
[1614:11] Q. Did there come a time in January where you understood the government was frustrated with your proffer?
[1614:13] MR. ROOS: Objection.
[1614:14] THE COURT: Sustained.
[1614:15] Q. Did there come a time when you met with the government and you went over the topic of the Orcas Island house again?
[1614:17] A. I can't remember if we went over it multiple times or not.
[1614:18] Q. Okay. After the time we've just been discussing.
[1614:19] MR. ROOS: Objection.
[1614:20] THE COURT: What's the objection?
[1614:21] MR. ROOS: Vague.
[1614:22] THE COURT: Rephrase.
[1614:23] Q. You just told us about a meeting in January with the prosecutors——you didn't remember the date——where you talked about the Orcas Island house, correct?
[1615:1] MR. ROOS: Objection. I think he said he couldn't recall that, could not recall that.
[1615:3] THE COURT: Answer the question, Mr. Singh. if you can.
[1615:5] A. I recall speaking with the prosecutors at some point, at least one point, about my purchase of the Orcas Island home, even after I knew that it was drawing on customer funds.
[1615:8] Q. Do you recall telling the prosecutors, as of January 24th, that you viewed the spending as egregious and unnecessary?
[1615:10] A. Which spending?
[1615:11] MR. ROOS: Objection.
[1615:12] Q. On the Orcas Island house.
[1615:13] THE COURT: Well, rephrase the question, please.
[1615:14] Q. After the——do you recall having a meeting with the prosecutors in January, on January 24th, on or about January 24th, in which you told them that the spending on the Orcas Island house was egregious and unnecessary?
[1615:18] A. My spending on it was egregious, unnecessary, and selfish.
[1615:19] Q. Okay. Did you tell them that your spending on the political donations was egregious and unnecessary?
[1615:21] A. I don't recall what I said, but I agree with those descriptions.
[1615:23] Q. And you previously denied that that was the case.
[1615:24] A. Not that I recall.
[1615:25] Q. Okay. Now Mr. Roos showed you your plea agreement——excuse [1616:1] me——your cooperation agreement.
[1616:2] MR. COHEN: Let's call that back up, 3501-002.
[1616:3] Q. If you start at the——right here, that lists out the counts you pled guilty to, correct?
[1616:5] A. Right. That's——that describes the first count and——
[1616:6] Q. We don't need to go through them all.
[1616:7] MR. COHEN: If we can go to the next page.
[1616:8] And pull out Count Six, Brian.
[1616:9] Q. Is it fair to say that one of the counts you pled guilty to, Mr. Singh, was a conspiracy to violate the Federal Election Campaign Act?
[1616:12] A. Yes.
[1616:13] MR. COHEN: I have nothing further, your Honor.
[1616:14] THE COURT: Thank you.
[1616:15] Redirect.
[1616:16] MR. ROOS: I'm sorry, your Honor. Could we have one moment with your Honor at the sidebar.
[1616:18] THE COURT: You may.
[1617:1] (At the sidebar)
[1617:2] MR. ROOS: The last question was: "Did you conspire to violate the Federal Campaign Election Act?" "A. Yes." I intend to ask: "Who did you conspire with?" I just want to put that out there, in light of the prior rulings. I think they've opened the door. With any limiting instruction——
[1617:7] MR. COHEN: We would ask for a limiting instruction.
[1617:8] THE COURT: I'll give a limiting instruction.
[1617:9] MR. ROOS: Okay.
[1618:1] (In open court)
[1618:2] REDIRECT EXAMINATION
[1618:3] BY MR. ROOS:
[1618:4] Q. Mr. Singh, the last question Mr. Cohen asked you was whether you pleaded guilty to conspiring to violate the Federal Campaign Election Act. Do you recall that question?
[1618:7] A. I do.
[1618:8] Q. Who did you conspire with?
[1618:9] THE COURT: Excuse me. Members of the jury, you're about to hear the answer to that question, and I remind you that regardless of the answer to that question, Mr. Bankman-Fried, for reasons that do not concern you, is not charged in this case with any violation or conspiracy to violate the federal election campaign laws.
[1618:15] Now you may answer the question.
[1618:16] A. Sam Bankman-Fried and Ryan Salame.
[1618:17] Q. You were asked earlier today if some notes——a few times today——if some notes refreshed your recollection. Do you remember those questions?
[1618:20] A. Some of them, yes.
[1618:21] Q. Did you take those notes that you were shown?
[1618:22] A. No.
[1618:23] Q. At your meetings with prosecutors, did you observe anyone taking notes?
[1618:25] A. Yes, sometimes.
[1619:1] Q. Did anyone ever ask you to review the notes?
[1619:2] A. Never.
[1619:3] Q. Prior to today had you ever seen them?
[1619:4] A. I've never seen those notes until today.
[1619:5] Q. Were you ever asked to review them for accuracy?
[1619:6] A. No.
[1619:7] Q. And have you ever read the entirety of the notes?
[1619:8] A. I don't think, except for today, I've ever read any amount of the notes.
[1619:10] Q. You were asked at the end there about a property you bought, a home. What happened to that property?
[1619:12] A. I forfeited it.
[1619:13] Q. What do you mean?
[1619:14] A. It was totally——
[1619:15] MR. COHEN: Objection.
[1619:16] THE COURT: What's the objection?
[1619:17] MR. COHEN: Beyond the scope.
[1619:18] MR. ROOS: He opened the door.
[1619:19] THE COURT: Overruled.
[1619:20] Q. Go ahead.
[1619:21] A. I bought it at a time when I understood that I was putting myself ahead of customers by doing so. I was embarrassed and ashamed. Forfeiting it seemed like one of the ways to right that one small wrong, at least a little. So the wrong wasn't small but the righting was small.
[1620:1] Q. You were asked some questions about auto-deleveraging event. Do you remember those questions this morning?
[1620:3] A. I do.
[1620:4] Q. And you were shown some computer code. Do you remember that?
[1620:6] A. I was shown code——commit snippets.
[1620:7] Q. Thank you. You were shown a code commit.
[1620:8] A. Yes.
[1620:9] Q. When was that from?
[1620:10] A. When was which part from?
[1620:11] Q. The code commit about auto-deleveraging.
[1620:12] A. August 2020.
[1620:13] Q. Now do you recall testifying yesterday about Alameda having a negative balance in September 2022?
[1620:15] A. Yes.
[1620:16] Q. And how big was the negative balance?
[1620:17] A. Gary told me Alameda was borrowing $13 billion in September 2022.
[1620:19] Q. And when Alameda was borrowing $13 billion in September 2022, was that the result of auto-deleveraging?
[1620:21] A. I fail to see the relationship between them. No.
[1620:22] Q. You were asked about earlier today a loan for 700——for $477 million. Do you remember those questions?
[1620:24] A. I do.
[1620:25] Q. What was the purpose of the loan?
[1621:1] A. The purpose of the loan was nominally for me to exercise my shares. I had money sufficient to do so otherwise. This particular loan was a part of a structure that Sam proposed with the goal of having Alameda lay out less cash than it would if I just exercised the original options I had.
[1621:6] Q. To be clear, did $477 million ever go to you?
[1621:7] A. No. It was really only on paper.
[1621:8] Q. You were also asked earlier today——
[1621:9] THE COURT: Before you go on, you used the phrase "exercise my shares." Please explain to the jury what you meant by that.
[1621:12] THE WITNESS: Sorry. Exercise my options.
[1621:13] Before the event in which I got the large $477 million loan, I already had a large amount of options with a very low strike price. Sam's proposal was to redo them to strike them at a much higher price, such that it would cost me more to exercise them but that this way there wouldn't be tax that ultimately Alameda would have to pay by letting me sell more FTT.
[1621:20] THE COURT: Now explain what you meant by "strike," please.
[1621:22] THE WITNESS: Options are contracts that give you the right to get equity if you pay some amount. That amount is the strike price. So in my case, I think my original options had a strike price of $2.60 something cents, meaning that in order to [1622:1] get one share of equity, it would be $2.60 some cents to get a share of equity. They were restriked to be like some $10.86, I think, meaning that I'd have to pay more to get the equity, $10.86 I think for each share. So exercising after them being restricken would cost me more than exercising them in the state that they were granted to me.
[1622:7] THE COURT: Proceed, counselor.
[1622:8] MR. ROOS: Thank you, your Honor.
[1622:9] BY MR. ROOS:
[1622:10] Q. Mr. Singh, you were asked earlier today about some political donations and you said they were loans "in loose sense." What do you mean by "loose sense"?
[1622:13] A. These were amounts that I discovered had been transferred to me often after the fact. It is the case that I intended to repay them all until September, when I realized I no longer could. That's the only sense in which they are loans. There wasn't paperwork, there wasn't a discussion of the transfers to me that I was a part of, and when I——I requested loan sheets, like lists of loans that Alameda had given, when asked from Jayesh, from Caroline, and from Can Sun, did not——they did not include many of these transfers as obligations I had to pay back. So they weren't——they weren't really loans.
[1622:23] Q. Now you were asked a few questions a few moments ago by Mr. Cohen about times you considered resigning. Do you remember those questions?
[1623:1] A. I do.
[1623:2] Q. And you testified that you thought about resigning from FTX a few times; is that right?
[1623:4] A. Yes.
[1623:5] Q. How, if at all, was your contemplated resignation in the fall of 2022 different?
[1623:7] A. Oh, it was extremely different. In the fall of '22, I want——the reason I wanted to resign was because I knew that I was becoming party and participating in something heinously criminal; that to keep running the business without divulging to others that there was a hole, I would be betraying customers that deposited their money into the hole, betraying my other employees. The scale of wrongdoing was enormous. In previous cases where I considered resigning, my considerations were really just focused on me——things like if working in finance and trying to make money was better than working directly at a philanthropy, things like that.
[1623:18] MR. ROOS: No further questions.
[1623:19] THE COURT: Thank you.
[1623:20] Any recross?
[1623:21] MR. COHEN: No, your Honor.
[1623:22] THE COURT: All right. Thank you. You're excused, sir.
[1623:24] (Witness excused)
[The transcript continues with the next witness.]