Sentencing Letters Submitted on Behalf of Nishad Singh (Exhibit A to the Sentencing Submission), part 1 of 19 (ECF pages 1 to 13)

[ECF p. 1]

Exhibit A

Sentencing Letters Submitted On Behalf of Nishad Singh
Case No. 22-cr-673 (LAK)

[ECF p. 2]

[Pages 2 and 3 of the PDF are images of a table. The table was typed out from the images. Its last rows, on page 4, are text in the PDF. In the lines below, “|” stands between the three columns, and the lines in italics are the headings of the table’s sections, which stand on a coloured band in the original. Under “Friends”, the lines “Childhood Friends”, “College Friends”, “Other Friends” and “Family Friends” are sub-headings, on white rows in the original.]

Index of Letters

Author | Title/Relationship | Page Number
Former Alameda and FTX Employees
Adam Yedidia | Former FTX Engineer | 6
Ceri Howells | Former FTX Operations | 8
Andrea Lincoln | Former FTX Engineer | 9
Rey Jose Ramirez Suero | Former FTX Customer Support | 11
Willie Kaufman | Former FTX Engineer | 12
Linchuan Zhang | Former Alameda Engineer | 14
Jack Zhang | Former FTX Office Chef | 16
Adam Kalinich | Former FTX Engineer | 17
Ashish Suvarna | Former FTX Customer Support | 19
Philippe Maes | Former FTX Engineer | 21
Adam Jin | Former FTX Business Development | 23
Christian Drappi | Former Alameda Engineer | 25
Can Sun | Former FTX General Counsel | 26
Shuang (Claire) Zhang | Former FTX Colleague | 27
Anonymous | Former FTX Colleague | 28
Anonymous | Former FTX Colleague | 30
Anonymous | Former FTX Engineer | 32
Anonymous | Former FTX Colleague | 33
Immediate Family
Claire Watanabe | Fiancé | 35
Anu Singh | Mother | 41
Raj Singh | Father | 45
Rajeev Patel | Stepfather | 49
Malhar Singh | Brother | 52
Teachers & Professionals
Alan Waters | Accountant | 57
Norm Epstein | Wealth Management Advisor | 58
FTX MDL Plaintiffs | Counsel for FTX MDL Plaintiffs | 59
Katie DeVaul | Psychiatrist | 61
Jeff Nichols | Teacher | 65
Simon Olavarria | Teacher | 67
Gerlicelda Rudas Benag | Former Cleaner and Dogsitter | 68
Charles Dunford | Physical Trainer | 69
Volunteering Community
Andy McCabe | Manager, Gubbio Project | 71
Brendan Taliaferro | Founder, Homeward Initiative | 74
Marie O’Connor | Volunteer, Gubbio Project | 76
Extended Family
Pam Watanabe | Future Mother-in-law | 79
Keith Watanabe | Future Father-in-law | 82
Bridgette & Evan Schroader | Fiancé’s Cousin | 84
Ellie Schroader | Fiancé’s Cousin | 86
Jacob Whitsitt | Fiancé’s Cousin | 88
Debi Binford | Fiancé’s Aunt | 90
Erick Watanabe | Future Brother-In-Law | 92

[ECF p. 3]

Erica Djen | Fiancé’s Sister-In-Law | 94
Brian Moyer | Fiancé’s Extended Family | 95
Dennis Whitsitt | Fiancé’s Uncle | 97
Gina Djen | Fiancé’s Extended Family | 98
Lynette Neu (Whitsitt) | Fiancé’s Cousin | 99
Chad Songer | Fiancé’s Extended Family | 101
Julie Songer | Fiancé’s Extended Family | 102
Janice Guevara | Fiancé’s Family Friend | 103
Vivian Djen | Fiancé’s Extended Family | 104
Suchitra Vaidya | “Aunt” | 105
Seth Redmore | “Uncle” | 107
Vasudha Redmore | “Aunt” | 110
Antara Rao | Cousin | 113
Meghana Rao | Cousin | 115
Murli Thirumale | Uncle | 117
Vandana Thirumale | Aunt | 120
Samir Vaidya | “Cousin” | 121
Ahir Redmore | “Cousin” | 124
Shaunak Vaidya | “Cousin” | 126
Alamelu Iyengar | Great Aunt | 129
Anil Vaidya | “Uncle” | 130
Amrit Singh | Cousin | 131
Friends
Childhood Friends
Connor Hegarty | Elementary School Friend | 134
Phillip Korolog | Elementary School Friend | 136
Colin Smith | Elementary School Friend | 139
Gabe Bankman-Fried | High School Friend | 143
Peter Buckley | High School Friend | 145
Baylor Odabashian | Middle School Friend | 147
Greg Etzbach | Elementary School Friend | 150
College Friends
Corey Zumar | College Friend | 152
Isabel Yang | College Friend | 154
Rohit Mukherjee | College Friend | 156
Sahil Chinoy | College Friend | 159
Roshan Varadarajan | College Friend | 160
Varun Tolani | College Friend | 162
Darren Zhao | College Friend | 164
Stevie Kobori | College Friend | 167
Rahul Joshi | College Friend | 169
Caley Zheng | College Friend | 171
Other Friends
Briana Reynolds | Partner of “Cousin” | 173
Myles Baumann | Post-College Friend | 175
Liza Babin | Partner of Brother | 177
Kermit Cuff | Ultramarathon Friend | 178
Ruhi Christie | Partner of “Cousin” | 179
Anonymous | Post-FTX Friend | 181

[ECF p. 4]

Anonymous | Post-FTX Friend | 183
Family Friends
Rattan Gujadhur | Family Friend | 187
Wynn Anderson | Family Friend | 188
Rajeev Char | Family Friend | 190
Arun Simha | Family Friend | 191
Indira Almedia | Family Friend | 193
Shishir Ramam | Family Friend | 195
Renuka Char | Family Friend | 197
Lily Patel | Family Friend | 198
Jayshree Ullal | Family Friend | 199
Meenakshi Kaul | Family Friend | 200
Esateys Stuchiner | Family Friend | 201
Sowmya Simha | Family Friend | 202
Sriram Viswanathan | Family Friend | 203
Anu Mahal | Family Friend | 204
Deepa Shenoy | Family Friend | 205
Ganesh Pattabiraman | Family Friend | 206
Subbalakshmi Subramaniam | Family Friend | 208
Aditya Guleri | Family Friend | 209

[ECF p. 5]

Letters from Former FTX/Alameda Employees

[ECF p. 6]

[Letter from Adam Yedidia (Former FTX Engineer)]

Adam Yedidia

July 8, 2024

Lewis A. Kaplan
Judge
Daniel Patrick Moynihan
United States Courthouse
New York, NY 10007-1312

Dear Judge Kaplan,

My name is Adam Yedidia; I was a software engineer at FTX. You may remember me as one of the first witnesses for the prosecution in the criminal trial of Sam Bankman-Fried.

I became friends with Nishad Singh when I started working for FTX in January 2021. Prior to that date, he was a few-time acquaintance of mine; I knew him as a friend of a friend. When I started at FTX, though, he was my boss. When I began working, he and I both spent three weeks in Hong Kong's quarantine, staying in different hotel rooms. We spent many hours on video calls together, as he patiently taught me the basics of writing code at FTX. Through that experience, we very quickly became close friends.

Through those weeks and almost the two years that followed, Nishad was my manager. He was, and remains, the best boss I've ever had. He was warm and patient, extremely kind and hardworking. When I made a mistake while writing code, he made sure I knew, but simultaneously never made me feel bad about it—a difficult task for any manager. He never asked me to do a task that he couldn't have done himself. While I was at FTX, Nishad spent between 70 and 80 hours a week in the office, and was the primary engineer on call. He was on average woken up in the middle of the night 3-4 times per week to deal with issues. There was a company Slack channel, #urgent-dev, which was a graveyard of people reporting urgent bugs at all hours and Nishad fixing them and thanking the people reporting them.

Despite the intense demands of his job, he was unfailingly cheerful and nice. His style was more like that of a friend than a superior, not just with me but with others as well. He was the best kind of technical manager: the kind who writes more and better code than you do, while simultaneously managing over a dozen other engineers. I learned an enormous amount of software engineering from Nishad; I left FTX a far better engineer than when I joined, and most of that is due to him. As his report, I admired him deeply, and I still do.

In addition to being an amazing mentor and manager, Nishad was also my close friend. In Hong Kong, I slipped down a flight of stairs, dislocating my left shoulder. Nishad followed me in the ambulance to the hospital, and stayed by my bedside for hours, reassuring me, while they put me on painkillers and popped my shoulder back in.

About a year later, he and his girlfriend were driving down the street in the Bahamas at night, when they saw the car in front of theirs hit a dog and drive off. They pulled over and rushed out of the car to help, but when Nishad approached the dog, it bit him hard, breaking the skin and drawing blood. He called a mobile veterinarian to help with the situation. The bite turned out not to be serious, and the dog died anyway, but Nishad's actions that night have stayed with me. As much as we can all agree that it is good to pull over to help a dying stray animal on a dark street, I believe that most of us would simply keep driving. Nishad's reflexive decision to get out and help, I think, reveals a lot about his character.

[ECF p. 7]

At one point in early 2022, Nishad fell sick with COVID, and FTX simultaneously had a serious problem with an increasing number of cases of scams against certain users, particularly the elderly: the victim would be coached by the scammer to open an account on FTX and give their credentials to the scammer, who would later withdraw their money to their own account. Nishad, from his sickbed, worked through his illness to develop a system for preventing this species of scam—and also successfully agitated for FTX to reimburse the users who had been scammed, at the company's expense. His instinctual response was to help the victims of the scam; as part of the work he did to figure out what was happening, he called and gently talked to them to figure out what was wrong and reassure them.

This episode is noteworthy not because it is remarkable, but because it was par for the course for Nishad. My experience of him at the company was that of him trying his best to do the right thing in so many difficult circumstances, even when there wasn't a clear playbook for doing so.

In late 2022, before the company collapsed, I know that Nishad worked hard to reduce FTX's expenses—agitating to have an expensive expansion of FTX's office canceled, for instance, and arguing against further acquisitions. In the final week, as FTX was collapsing, he came to my room and apologized repeatedly, sobbing on the floor, completely inconsolable. His reaction took me off-guard. Part of that is I hadn’t yet learned all the details of the situation. But also, I didn't blame him then, and still don't today, for what happened. He worked very hard and sacrificed for the company; I understand him to have been a strong advocate of moderation and thrift. But regardless of how I personally see him, there is no doubt whatsoever that Nishad was deeply contrite and felt enormously guilty for what happened.

I am extremely grateful to have known Nishad. He is a kind, warm and compassionate person, and he was one of my closest friends. I have sorely missed spending time with him since FTX declared bankruptcy. I feel terribly for him. He is incredibly kind and generous; the herculean effort of building FTX, of which he took on a huge portion, would have been a credit to him in a better world but is instead a stain.

I loved working with him. Many if not most of my fondest memories of FTX are of being his coworker. I truly hope to one day have the opportunity to work with him again. I hope that you will give Nishad a lenient sentence.

Thank you,

Adam Yedidia

[ECF p. 8]

[Letter from Ceri Howells (Former FTX Operations)]

To Whom It May Concern,

I had the pleasure of working with Nishad Singh at FTX Digital Markets for over a year, and I can confidently say that he is one of the most genuine, kind-hearted individuals I have ever met. Nishad's humility and compassion were evident from the moment I met him, and his positive impact on both my team and the entire company cannot be overstated.

Nishad was always friendly and approachable, not just to me but to everyone on our team. He made it a point to learn our names, check in on how we were doing, and genuinely cared about our well-being. His kindness extended beyond simple pleasantries—he would go out of his way to be helpful, whether it was assisting with a task or just offering a listening ear. This level of attentiveness and empathy is rare, and it left a lasting impression on all of us.

One of the most admirable qualities Nishad demonstrated was his deep concern for people. He was particularly passionate about ensuring that everyone was treated fairly and with respect. I recall how he advocated for higher salaries for the Bahamian staff when he realized the discrepancies that existed. He didn’t just talk about making changes; he took action to ensure that everyone, regardless of their background, was compensated fairly. Furthermore, he took the time to help some of our local logistics staff learn coding, offering them skills that would open up new opportunities. These actions clearly showed that Nishad wasn’t in it for wealth, power, or fame—he was motivated by a genuine desire to make a difference in the lives of those around him.

In fact, Nishad seemed to actively avoid the trappings of power and prestige. Despite his significant role, he always shied away from the spotlight. He had no interest in mingling with the famous personalities who often visited the company or being interviewed. Nishad was content with focusing on his work and the well-being of his team, rather than seeking recognition or accolades.

As a member of the operations team, I often interacted with Nishad while handling logistical requests for employees. Unlike some others, Nishad never made extraordinary or unreasonable demands. He was always incredibly grateful for our efforts and made sure we knew it. He didn’t expect special treatment and would even feel embarrassed if we tried to offer it. To him, we weren’t just colleagues—we were friends and peers, and he treated us with a sibling-like respect and warmth.

In conclusion, Nishad Singh is a person of exceptional character. His humility, kindness, and commitment to fairness make him stand out as one of the most remarkable individuals I’ve had the privilege to work with. I wholeheartedly vouch for his integrity and the positive influence he has on those around him.

___________________________
Ceri Howells

[ECF p. 9]

[Letter from Andrea Lincoln (Former FTX Engineer)]

Andrea Lincoln

July 8, 2024

Lewis A. Kaplan
Judge
Daniel Patrick Moynihan
United States Courthouse
New York, NY 10007-1312

Dear Judge Kaplan,

I am a professor of computer science. I worked at FTX between my postdoc and my current professorship. Nishad was my boss while I was employed at FTX. Over the course of my time there I became friends with him and his girlfriend Claire. Nishad was gentle and kind to me. He treated me well as a boss and a friend.

Late one night, Nishad was bitten by a wild dog. I later learned what happened from another employee who was in the car with Nishad and Claire. The employee told me that she needed a ride home and Nishad and Claire offered to drive her. As they drove home the car in front of them hit a dog and kept driving. Nishad insisted that they pull over and check on the dog. Nishad wanted to make sure the dog was okay and came up close. The injured dog panicked and bit him and limped off into the woods. Nishad waited for animal control to come take care of the dog, despite just being bitten. Then they drove the employee home before he got treated for the bite, literally putting the dog and employee before himself.

When I was working at FTX, I got rear-ended by a car whose brakes gave out. I was fine but had some frightening back pain the next day. I was going to get checked out by a doctor when Nishad and Claire found me. When they asked if I was okay I tried to tell them I was fine but burst into tears. Nishad rearranged his day so he could drive me to get seen by the doctor. He stayed waiting for me for the whole appointment, working the whole time of course, so he could also drive me home. Nishad and Claire checked up on me and made sure I was getting treatment until I got better.

Nishad worked very hard. He worked long hours in the office, continued working while at home, and even worked through illness. When something needed to get done he would do it. He took on boring and unglamorous tasks like preforming code-reviews, fixing bugs, and doing maintenance work. Continuing to engage with the unglamorous but necessary tasks made him a much better boss. When someone needed to be on call and no one else would do it, he would be on call. When someone pushed a bug and it needed to be fixed he would wake up in the middle of the night to fix it, and he wouldn’t complain or make the bug’s author feel bad. I remember showing up to the office at 3am with Nishad already there (I think he had never left the office that day), he was working to fix a bug created by another employee. The other employee was upset at themselves and Nishad comforted them while simultaneously working to manage the fix. That isn’t the kind of work that is [ECF p. 10] splashy or fun. But being in a nearly empty office at 3am debugging an issue while comforting the person who caused is necessary to keep projects running and to keep employees happy. It was one of his strengths as a manager: he actually did the work. He is smart, quick, and cares about his employees.

Judge Kaplan, I know your job is hard and you must weigh many aspects of a case. But I ask you to consider the Nishad I saw: a gentle, kind, and hardworking man. I cannot imagine that he would re-offend. I hope that Nishad receives no jail time. I hope he can play with his dog, spend time with Claire, build new software products, and manage teams of developers. A world with Nishad in it is a warmer and safer world.

Sincerely,
Andrea Lincoln

[ECF p. 11]

[Letter from Rey Jose Ramirez Suero (Former FTX Customer Support)]

Dear Judge Kaplan,

Address: [REDACTED], Bella Vista, Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic

Date: 27 June 2024
Reynaldo Jose Ramirez Suero

Nishad and I met in 2019 over telegram. FTX staff at the time was mostly in Hong Kong so they offered me a job while I was simply helping on telegram. In 2020 January I traveled to Hong Kong to meet the team but I did not have the honor, yet, of meeting Nishad.

Meeting Nishad initially happened online. Nishad was constantly on top of the bugs I reported about the platform and always happy to take the feedback. The reality is Nishad always was ready to help and work at FTX. Due to me workring in America’s time I had to constantly call Nishad if the FTX platform went down or if we had any particular issue that required developer intervention. It didn’t matter if other developers caused the issue, were more knowledgeable, or were supposed to be “on call”, Nishad was the one who actually responded to us and our customers. Over time, Nishad became the person that the customer support team knew they could count on.

To me it was obvious the dedication of Nishad to the company, someone who was always online and barely slept, I constantly recommended him to take care of his health. I met Nishad in Bahamas and had time to talk to him. Nishad felt as a young humble man and never saw me as someone below him but rather as an equal which made me feel very appreciated. I had some personal issues and commented them to Nishad and he took these issues as if they were his own and tried to help me.

Nishad had an incredible ability to empathize, he truly made me feel like I was part of the FTX team and that what I had to share and say was important, he went beyond what was considered politeness to connect with me and to understand the things I explained.

Nishad always had the ability to make you feel like his family and not his co-worker. To this day I still consider Nishad one of the person with the purest heart out there and would always consider working with him. Nishad never let the money get to his head, always kept a cool head, a smile while working on the things he loved and never said anything that would hurt anybody.

People in the company looked up to Nishad as a leader despite his young age and only Director title, and because of how hard he worked and how well he treated others.

I heartily believe that Nishad deserves a chance at redemption as to me he’s not only an incredible programmer but one the best humans and coworkers that I have ever interacted with.

[ECF p. 12]

[Letter from Willie Kaufman (Former FTX Engineer)]

William Kaufman

September 15, 2024

Honorable Lewis A. Kaplan
United States District Court Judge
Southern District of New York
Daniel Patrick Moynihan Courthouse
500 Pearl Street
New York, New York, 10007-1312

Dear Judge Kaplan,

I am writing to share with you whatever insight into the character of Nishad Singh that I can. He and I have been friends for close to ten years at this point. We met when we were both in college through mutual friends, and though we did not attend the same school, we quickly became friends and remain so to this day. Nishad’s wit, kindness, and intelligence were immediately clear to me - I will always have fond memories of hanging out, playing video games together and talking about anything and everything.

Nishad is one of the most unabashedly supportive people I know. He has an infectious excitement for the achievements of others - I will share with him what feels like a mundane accomplishment and he will somehow convince me that I have overcome a great challenge. As far as I can tell, the only person’s achievements he has ever undersold are his own. He would tell stories emphasizing some extremely embarrassing mistake he made, but when I asked others who were there, their memory of the event is much more flattering to him. He often matter-of-factly spoke of how he didn’t belong in charge of anything and had just lucked into his position at FTX. I have to wonder if his feeling that his contributions were minimal and he was among people smarter than him were part of what stopped him from speaking up against what he knew was wrong.

I briefly worked with Nishad at FTX. During that month or so, he was a mentor to me. It was clear that, despite his nominal managerial role at the company, he took much more pride in his individual contributions as a programmer. The one part of his role as a manager he clearly did enjoy, however, was finding ways to make others happy. Figuring out which kinds of projects I enjoyed, who I liked working with, and finding time to answer my questions were clearly the parts of his job that he enjoyed. I know he’ll find other ways to put his intelligence and compassion to work.

One thing I can strongly attest to is how obvious it was that Nishad was never interested in personal enrichment. Well after FTX had reached valuations in the billions of dollars, he told me about his plan to someday buy a house with his partner near where he grew up and I was struck by how modest of a plan it was. He didn’t spend money on luxurious travel accommodations, fancy meals or expensive clothes, and it was obvious that they weren’t even of interest to him.

I saw Nishad very briefly during the collapse of FTX. He was distraught to such a level that I was worried about his safety. He was barely able to put a sentence together, but what he [ECF p. 13] expressed was deep remorse and concern over the harm his actions had caused without a thought for himself. I have to imagine those feelings have left an impression on him, carrying a viscerally felt lesson about right and wrong that will lead him well as he moves forward.

It hardly makes sense to talk about Nishad without also mentioning his partner, Claire. They make a wonderful couple, and I have seen them be good for each other through ups and downs of all kinds. Nishad has a lot of work ahead of him to get his life back on the track that it should always have been, but knowing they’ll be doing it together, along with their dogs and their supportive families, gives me the utmost confidence.

Thank you for reading what I have to say about the character of Nishad. I only hope that my testimony can help you see Nishad as I see him. I know he has much left to offer the world.

Sincerely,

[The signature that follows in the original is a picture of the name “William Kaufman” in a script typeface. No typed name follows it.]