Sentencing Letters Submitted on Behalf of Nishad Singh (Exhibit A to the Sentencing Submission), part 4 of 19 (ECF pages 34 to 40)

[ECF p. 34]

Letters from Immediate Family

[ECF p. 35]

[Letter from Claire Watanabe (Fiancé)]

October 1, 2024

Dear Judge Lewis A. Kaplan,

My name is Claire Watanabe. I am Nishad Singh’s fiancé. Thank you for the opportunity to describe the Nishad I’ve come to know and love and reflect on the ways Nishad has fundamentally changed, most especially in light of his wrongdoings.

Nishad and I began dating in 2015 while we were undergraduates at UC Berkeley. I hadn’t met anyone with a bigger heart or a greater willingness to act on it than Nishad (which remains true to this day). He’d wake up early and bring me chai before our early morning computer science class. He’d leave dandelions on my pillow because he knew I loved yellow flowers. He always offered to cook me dinner, although cooking for him involved microwaving Indian dal then serving it with a side of grocery store pita bread and hummus.

Early in our relationship, we had a conversation that lasted long into the night — learning anything and everything about each other. Nishad shared his deeply held concern about suffering in our world. He introduced me to some ideas behind effective altruism, and the inspiration he felt. He spoke of charities like Against Malaria Foundation, which distributes bednets to families, primarily in Africa, that prevent malaria contraction via mosquitos. A simple solution to a pervasive problem with devastating consequences. The charity is considered effective because, on average, a couple thousand dollars of donations can translate into one life saved. An entire human life – a mother, a child – who otherwise would have passed away is saved by this size of donation. I had no idea the average person could be so impactful.

I saw the conviction in his eyes that night back in Berkeley. I was in awe of his own clarity and sense of purpose: to try to make a real dent in the world’s suffering.

In 2017, Nishad graduated from college and joined Facebook. His plan was to earn and then donate as much as possible, funding effective charities' amazing work. However, after only a handful of months, he worried if he made a mistake. He felt disconnected from his values and what he actually wanted to contribute to the world.

In October of 2017, Nishad learned of an opportunity with a company founded by Sam Bankman-Fried, the big brother of one of his best friends from high school. It was a cryptocurrency trading startup, the then nascent Alameda Research. Sam invited Nishad to visit the office and meet the team.

Sitting in a crowded room, Nishad watched as Sam traded. Sam explained the various actions he took in real time. With one trade, Sam made $40,000 in a matter of minutes. Nishad was blown away, and even more so as Sam explained that there were hundreds of these crypto-specific arbitrage opportunities out there. Nishad was also delighted by the employees – everyone he chatted with seemed, at the time, to share Nishad’s philanthropic values and ambition. The founders had pledged to donate 50% of Alameda’s profits to charity and were willing to work long, hard hours. Here was an opportunity where Nishad could more directly affect positive change, and at a scale way beyond what he thought was individually possible.

When Nishad was eventually extended an offer he was on the fence – recognizing the inherent risk [ECF p. 36] of a small startup. Eventually, one of the early business leads offered to donate $50,000 if Nishad joined the company that week. Nishad put in his resignation at Facebook the next day.

Nishad joins Alameda then FTX

On the sidelines, I watched the vortex that was Alameda (and eventually FTX) grow and grow from 2017 to 2020. It sucked up Nishad’s evenings first, then weekends, then eventually the country he called home. Everything happened so fast and with escalating intensity: half the company left; then Nishad, the most junior person in the company, became manager of the engineering team. Sam and Gary Wang (Nishad’s boss) moved to Hong Kong to build their own exchange, FTX. FTX began gaining more and more momentum, triggering most of the Berkeley office to relocate to Hong Kong. Then COVID hit. Nishad had to make the decision: either move to Hong Kong indefinitely, or stay in California and see himself become further and further out of the loop from the company’s day-to-day activities. He could already feel the impact of working apart from the team—unable to join impromptu conversations, respond to issues in real time, and often working with outdated information as things shifted by the hour.

Late in 2018, I remember talking with Nishad about if Alameda/FTX was worth it. He was constantly tired. The long and unpredictable hours were weighing on our relationship, and he was seeing less of his family and friends. We sat cross-legged at the foot of our bed when he said, “I’d be ashamed of myself if I walked away now.” In Nishad’s mind, walking away would mean abandoning all of the people their future donations could help – like a firefighter arriving at the scene of a burning building choosing to turn away

By the end of 2021, FTX had clearly become a success. Nishad had continuously made charitable donations since joining Alameda. His “earning-to-give” strategy seemed like it was working. But now that he was able to donate on a larger scale, he was worried he didn’t have the time to do crucial research these donations call for if you want to approach them with thought and care. He wrote as much in an email to a grantmaking group he trusted: “It’s one of my regrets that I haven’t been searching hard enough for giving opportunities in the last few years…I can’t provide too much of my own time…I’m happy to do away with any formalities and just make the most of that dynamic. I’m pretty happy to receive advice / don’t take offense easily if the advice implies I’m making a mistake in how I give or spend my time / etc. I’d much rather get this right.” Months after that email but with the same considerations in mind, Nishad and I together spoke with a different charitable giving advisory group. In the end of this evaluation process, we selected five nonprofits in-need, and Nishad donated an eight-figure amount in total. These donations funded new programs within reputable charitable organizations and funding for staff salaries for academic policy research. This moment, for Nishad, was a dream come true.

I join FTX

In January 2022, living in the Bahamas, I interviewed with Sam and other leaders for a role at FTX. My career up until that point was focused on shaping user-centric consumer technologies and leading multi-departmental teams. I was weighing the option against graduate school, having been accepted to a few technology-focused public policy programs that I could start later that Fall.

I decided to join FTX. My relationship with Nishad was my primary consideration, and after living apart during his move to Hong Kong, I wasn’t prepared to do so again. Additionally, I was fully on board with Nishad’s charitable giving mission. Since graduating, I had been donating a portion of my paycheck to global health charities like the Anti Malaria Foundation. With FTX’s success [ECF p. 37] carrying even greater stakes, I felt a similar sense of responsibility to help the company succeed and achieve Nishad’s charitable giving goals.

Joining FTX gave me a new appreciation for Nishad and the work he had been doing for years. First and foremost, Nishad was the most caring, kind and thoughtful manager across all the teams in the company. He was generous with his time and treated every team member with warmth and respect. Most other leaders and employees could be immensely stressed so it wasn’t uncommon to see people be dismissive, rude, or pull rank to conclude disagreements. I, ashamedly, fell victim to this on particularly rough days. Nishad never did. As a truly shining exception, he was the one to always remember the names of coworkers’ kids and ask how their families were doing; the one to advocate for giving the entirely Bahamian Operations team a raise when he discovered they were underpaid relative to the rest of the staff; the one who was constantly seen walking around the parking lot with engineers, as he made it a point to always say ‘yes’ when anyone on his team asked for a “walk and talk”. I cannot express how proud I was to see Nishad, one of the hardest working, to also be the kindest and most loved. Despite all of the pressures of the job, and over all those years, he stayed true to himself in this way.

Second was witnessing Nishad’s perseverance in action: A unique challenge was maintaining the FTX exchange and helping an entire team build on top of a codebase Nishad did not architect and initially build out. This was particularly difficult because Gary, the original author, was not the biggest people-person. A byproduct of this was that Gary decided to always work alone on his systems, not having anyone else double check his code, and he rarely explained his code to Nishad or anyone else, except Sam. And while the team had access to the code, it was often complex enough that it’d be over everyone else’s head.

To highlight a common type of occurrence, a memory from 2022, when we lived with Gary in the Bahamas: Nishad’s phone goes off around 3AM, waking us both up. It’s a co-worker on the customer support team calling about an issue affecting users. Nishad pulls his laptop off the bedside table and starts digging into the logs. I see on Slack, the company’s messaging platform, Nishad messaging back and forth with the customer service team in the “urgent dev” channel, asking questions, trying to diagnose what’s happening. After an hour of digging, Nishad determines that the issue is in Gary’s part of the code, and Nishad wasn’t familiar enough to handle it himself. Nishad calls Gary three times. No reply. Nishad hesitates before he gets out of bed. I peek outside moments later to find Nishad sitting on the ground in the hallway, just outside Gary’s room. Nishad asks questions into the dark room. Gary was working nights, so he was already awake. I hear Gary mumble a suggestion. Nishad takes a minute and types away, then later says, “Hmm, not that. Any other ideas?” I learned the next morning that once they identified the problem, Nishad stayed up for another two hours to fix it and talk to the customer support team so they could feel comfortable letting users know it was resolved.

Before I joined FTX, I assumed that Nishad was an engineering wiz who was woken up the most because he could solve anything. Only until after I joined did I realize how incomplete the picture was. Nishad was the one who simply always responded to support calls and wouldn’t rest until the problem was resolved.

Third, I saw a new side of Nishad’s selflessness, giving everything he had for his team and FTX as a whole: There’s a trope in the tech industry that the “business side” always over promises for engineering. The dynamic at FTX was far beyond anything I’ve heard of. Oftentimes, Nishad would [ECF p. 38] learn about projects after the fact and most of these projects were large in scope and high-profile: The Miami Heat deal meant that a new ticketing system needed to be built. The decision to quickly launch an FTX credit card meant that a new system was necessary to correctly handle chargeback fraud. Acquiring the Japanese company, Liquid, meant that the current exchange needed to be copied and dramatically changed in order to comply with Japanese regulation.

Once a new investment or partnership was made and a check was signed, Nishad could either try to challenge the decision after the fact and see if it could be reversed so it wouldn’t derail existing engineering projects. Or, alternatively, he could figure out how to build the necessary engineering systems so that the money wouldn’t be wasted. He often tried both approaches, but it was frustrating to him that he didn’t have any insights into the strategy discussions until after the fact. Inevitably when he lost the argument with Sam, he would stretch himself by assuming another engineer's workload so they were free to focus on the new project or by taking the project on himself.

Witnessing Nishad day-in, day-out, navigate these challenges while maintaining his respect and kindness towards others only deepened my respect for him.

Nishad’s Continued Acts of Compassion

Even in the midst of his growing and eventually overwhelming responsibilities at FTX, Nishad never let go of his instinct to help those around him. Whether it was through big gestures or small, everyday acts of kindness, his compassion remained at his core.

I remember one flight where Nishad took the middle seat and sat next to an older gentleman named Stan, who had recently lost his wife and was heartbroken. He was preparing to leave the home where he and his wife had raised their family, moving to be closer to one of his adult children. They spoke for hours during the flight. As we exited the plane, they exchanged polite goodbyes. Partway down the terminal, Nishad suddenly stopped, ran back to Stan, and gave him his phone number. He told him, “If you need help with the move or anything else, please let me know—it would make my day.” When Nishad came back and filled me in, my heart filled with love.

One of the most personal acts of kindness was Nishad’s support during my mom’s [REDACTED]. For years, I watched her battle this disease. [REDACTED]. My mom had ups and downs, but during the darkest times, I felt like I had lost her. [REDACTED]. In early 2021, I told Nishad about the happy news, but not about the financial strain my parents were under. Unbeknownst to me, he called my mom and offered to pay for whichever program she thought would provide the best care. He recognized the immense strength it took for her to reach this point and wanted to support her any way he could. His offer took a huge weight off my parents, [REDACTED]. It was not the only time Nishad had financially supported a loved one through medical burdens, but up close, I saw just how pure an act of love it was. [REDACTED]. While this is my mom’s story of strength and courage, Nishad’s proactive, thoughtful support played a key role in making it possible. Having my mom healthy today is one of the greatest gifts I’ve ever and likely will ever receive.

[ECF p. 39]

Fall 2022

Come September 2022, I remember Nishad’s mood shifted. He was markedly more stressed and distracted. That same month, I had suffered injuries from a car accident that confined me to bed for two weeks. Nishad was by my side, taking me to all my doctor’s appointments. I assumed his mood change was due in part to that. I wouldn’t know until later that it was because Nishad had just learned about the shortfall in customer funds.

Two months later, the world I knew fell apart in a week. On Sunday, November 6th, Nishad told me that something was really really wrong and that this was probably the end for the company. Frankly, I didn’t believe him – how could that be the case? But his suicidal state scared me tremendously and made me pay attention. That week my main priority was Nishad. I’d wake up in a panic if he wasn’t next to me, worried about what he might have done. I’d convince him hourly why he shouldn’t kill himself. I frantically reached out to psychiatrists. His teammates, not even fully aware of his mental state, sent me a constant stream of messages asking how they could help him, and telling me they loved him.

I remember the evening of Tuesday, November 8th. We thought that FTX was being bought by Binance. A lot of the employees had gathered that night as a kind of funeral for FTX. No other company leaders attended. Nishad, torn apart, felt too ashamed to see anyone. When I finally convinced him to step out, about ten of the people he worked closest with, mostly customer support and engineers, came to him. They formed a line to give him a hug, one-by-one. He couldn’t stop apologizing to every one of them.

By Thursday, November 10th, FTX had filed bankruptcy, we were back in the US, and I was only beginning to piece everything together.

It’s hard to convey how deeply Nishad’s soul was broken after the collapse. He asked me repeatedly if I would forgive him if he took his own life. He could only think of the suffering and pain: of his family, his girlfriend, his team, the public and the customers who he let down. His entire adult life had been dedicated to alleviating suffering, yet now he saw himself as complicit in causing it for so many people. The cognitive dissonance between who he believed he was and the person staring back at him in the mirror was more than he could handle.

Two days after we arrived in the US, Nishad asked me again about suicide and forgiveness. Despite being an emotional wreck myself, barely hanging on, I somehow found a moment of clarity and said something like, ‘If we truly believe your future only holds shame and sadness, then yes, I’ll find a way to forgive you. But we don’t know that for certain yet, so let’s hold off on deciding anything.” Nishad listened. I still remember his dark, sunken eyes. After a long moment of silence, he agreed. While I think the suicidal thoughts continued, even well after he got psychiatric help, that was the last time he asked me that question.

Today

Now, nearly two years later, I’m immensely grateful that Nishad is far from the suicidal headspace he was in that fall. The Nishad of today reminds me of the guy I met nine years ago – though wiser and more grounded. I see him carry remorse for his actions daily, but I’m relieved he has found a way to live with himself and recognize he has something special to give to his family, friends, and community.

[ECF p. 40]

Many customers and others have suffered far more than me, but forgiveness has been necessary for my own healing over these past two years. My heart continues to break when I think about what the other employees, customers, and their families had to endure throughout this.

It took me many conversations to fully understand what Nishad was thinking in the two months he was aware of the missing customer funds. I know he will never again allow his compassion and sense of duty to be hijacked, agreeing to actions that would otherwise run counter to his values. Over these past years, I’ve seen he’s learned necessary life lessons about who to trust, a more mature view of responsibility and obligation, and how to maintain perspective on what’s right. I know he’s fundamentally changed in such a way that he’ll never put us anywhere close to a situation even remotely similar.

Nishad today invests in his relationships with family and friends instead of pushing himself to accomplish “one more thing” at work. He trusts his gut about new people – gravitating to those who are warm, caring, and genuine – rather than marveling at someone’s intelligence and drive. His ambitions around “maximizing impact” have been replaced with a much more measured approach: to volunteer his time to good causes, but not sacrifice his whole life to do something at an extraordinary scale. He kisses our dogs on the nose every morning. He insists on driving our friends home if it's after dark, even if it’s only a few blocks away. He wakes me up with a warm cup of tea on days he knows I have early meetings, just like he used to.

Taking full responsibility for his role in the FTX collapse and cooperating with authorities has been a fundamental part of Nishad’s effort to make amends. Above all, I respect the dedication he has brought to every request from the government, especially in those early months. It amazes me that he managed to pull himself together, let alone apply the same determined work ethic I saw from him at FTX.

I know that Nishad will continue to answer for his wrongdoings and that his future remains uncertain. But whatever lies ahead, I continue to look forward to the day where we can say our vows to one in front of our loved ones. My decision to stand by Nishad’s side remains unshaken. I am confident in who he is and what he’s learned, and I’m deeply grateful for his love and presence in my life.

I sincerely thank you for this opportunity and for your attention. I am available to answer any questions or provide additional details at [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address] or [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number].

Most Respectfully,

Claire Watanabe