[Letter from Murli Thirumale (Uncle)]
Dear Judge Kaplan,
I am Nishad’s uncle and have seen his outsized conscience, his ownership of issues and intense desire to fix things from a young age. His desire to prevent cruelty to animals and inclination to treat everyone exceedingly well are examples I am sure you will hear about from others. I thought I would share a few other examples that shed light on his character:
In middle school, Nishad participated in Model United Nations (MUN) for many years. He started at first as a way to be with his friends, but the activity itself quickly grew on him. I would drop him off or pick him up for many sessions and would ask about his day. I was surprised to see that he viewed these issues as a real discourse versus just an intellectual debate game like most other students. Solving the problem of getting fresh water to India and Africa, revitalizing Laos which was not strategically important to any wealthy country, transitioning third world economies that depended on low cost exploitation labor to a different economic solution; these were not just toy problems to him. I listened transfixed as he passionately talked about these topics, having researched them but still aware of how little he knew. Our conversations didn’t involve him preaching some select facts, but instead they followed both of our curiosities. This was not just some resume item for him, he had grown to really find some meaning in it.. Nishad, even then, was one of the few “real and genuine” people in a “fake and pretentious” world around us. Made of saintly dust.
Around that same time, Nishad suffered from severe asthma attacks. He later dramatically improved his asthma through a disciplined regimen of training, going on to finish a 100 mile ultra-marathon. I remember going on an overnight stay as a large family group for Christmas. The weather was smoggy and an asthma attack hit Nishad. Much as he tried to prevent the attack, he could not and it got bad very quickly. While we rushed him to [ECF p. 118] the hospital, and though he was breathing raggedly, he was more distressed at disrupting the evening and ruining the vacation for others than about his own condition. Nishad has always been fixated on others rather than himself. He has continued this intense focus on others rather than on his own needs ever since and it has had a big effect on me in putting others’ ahead of myself and a focus away from self-centeredness.
In 2019, we were on a family vacation, when Nishad was working for FTX. At first, it looked like he could not go because of work but he ended up joining the group. It turned out that Nishad was constantly on his computer remotely logging in fixing technical issues when the exchange had problems and getting on calls to help solve problems. I talked to him about why he was working so hard when his cousins and friends were enjoying their time off. He told me that FTX had no moat over other exchanges and that its success depended on hard work. He wanted FTX to succeed because he viewed this success as a vehicle to helping others in various causes that he cared deeply about. This was a distinctly different attitude than what I had heard from the rest of FTX and cemented my view that he truly believed that FTX depended on his own personal effort and his support for his technical team. He viewed it as his moral obligation.
Finally in 2023, during the months before the trial, he was racked by remorse.. I traveled with him in those early days to New York, dropping him off to meetings with his lawyers, and observing his reactions to the unfolding catastrophe. He was distraught at having impacted the savings of so many customers, and at how the country of the Bahamas was suffering materially and in reputation due to no fault of its own. His remorse is genuine and authentic like everything else about him.
From his childhood to this day, Nishad has had great moral sensitivity and the courage to act on his morals. I watched his intense dejection and anguish as the FTX moments were replayed [ECF p. 119] during his deposition and the FTX trial. I am proud of my nephew and know that he will always be a positive force in society and to the people around him like me.
If you would like to contact me for more information, please feel free to call me at [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number] or email me at [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address].
Sincerely,
Murli Thirumale
[Letter from Vandana Thirumale (Aunt)]
September 19, 2024
Dear Judge Kaplan,
My name is Vandana Thirumale and I am Nishad Singh’s maternal aunt. I have known him since he was born, and he spent nearly every evening and several weekends for the first 13 years of his life with me. Our families are very close and we have always made it a point to spend time together.
Nishu demonstrated his loving and caring nature from an extremely young age. He suffered from asthma and severe allergies from infancy and was always excluded from group games in his preschool. Whenever this happened to him, he would tell me how sad he was, and I think this made him very empathetic towards other kids who might be similarly excluded. Our families had very large gatherings almost every week which included lots of young children. All the cousins would gather together and play board games while other children who were new to the group would hover nervously nearby. Nishad was the only child who always made sure that these children were included and welcomed. He would spend time talking to these children, finding out what they liked, and then making sure that everyone played those games as well. His nature is such that he wants everyone to get a chance to do well and shine.
Our next door neighbors had two daughters who were around his age. He and the younger one just didn’t get along and throughout elementary school. Years later when they were in high school, he met her at our place during dinner. He apologized to her for being such a brat when they were younger, taking the time to sit and have a very meaningful conversation with her. At the end of it, they had resolved much of the angst from their younger days and started a new friendship. When I asked him about it, he said that he was actively trying to build new friendships from childhood relationships he might have overlooked at the time.
He and I spent a lot of time alone together while I prepared dinner or gardened. He was always curious about my life, what I enjoyed doing, what things made me sad or angry, and how I went about dealing with conflict. I could talk to [ECF p. 121] him about anything and he would respond in a surprisingly mature and caring manner. He was a very earnest and serious child who wanted to make this world a better place by being a better human being. He would read and try to learn how to be responsible towards people, animals, and the planet.
Nishad has a way about him that makes everyone love him. His innate kindness and extremely loving nature means everyone has a good word to say about him. No one who has met him and spent any length of time with him can doubt his kindness and his genuine desire to make the world a better place. I also know how incredibly devastated he was after all that went down with FTX. His deep sadness for all the people whose trust had been violated still remains. He has reevaluated his life choices and is moving forward with much more care and choosing to contribute in more concrete and practical ways rather than focus on being intensely idealistic.
I, for one, cannot tell you enough how much I love and respect this young man. If you would like to contact me for more information, please feel free to call me at [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number] or email me at [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]. Thank you for your time.
Sincerely,
Vandana Thirumale
[Letter from Samir Vaidya (“Cousin”)]
July 1, 2024
Dear Judge Kaplan,
My name is Samir Vaidya and I have known Nishad Singh since my first day on this earth. He is like a brother to me in every sense except blood. Trying to distill down all the good Nishad has done for me and others into a few stories is an impossible task, but hopefully you come to see the wonderful person he is.
Both of us have asthma and used to relish any opportunity to use it as an excuse for our total ineptitude at anything physical. When he was going into high school Nishad decided he wanted a change. He was set on running cross-country, but his asthma was making it difficult to stay competitive. So like he always does, he figured out a different way to solve his problems: by running longer but slower. Nishad not only went on to be extremely successful at this, running hundred mile races despite his pulmonary challenges, but also found the time to call his chubby friend Samir to get some direly needed exercise with him. Nishad’s gentle but constant encouragement for me to get active transformed me from an overweight preteen into a highschooler who ran half-marathons in his freetime. It is no exaggeration to say this was one of the most important health choices I have ever made and it is all thanks to Nishad who showed me the way.
After I went away to college I became very focused in my biology studies (a subject that Nishad tutored me in during high school). We did not have as much time to speak once he joined FTX--he was busier than ever before. The time we did spend with each other during holidays was cherished but even then, with so many people relying on him at the company, there were often Christmas mornings where Nishad had to work on his laptop to help solve a problem.
When I had the opportunity to visit Nishad in the Bahamas I did not know what to expect. Would he even find time to see me in his busy schedule? When I landed and saw him waiting at the airport, I knew that Nishad had not let the immense workload change his character. Normally when people are working 100 hour weeks they don't have the time nor the energy for pleasantries. Every single person who I saw interacting with Nishad from co-workers to store clerks were treated with the highest level of respect. Those who knew him personally told me in private that they held him in the highest regard. To say I was impressed would be a gross understatement.
One interaction which stuck out to me in particular was when I was talking with an FTX colleague who had just moved to the Bahamas and was feeling homesick for the USA. These feelings of isolation were compounded by the rapid pace of the company. That next day Nishad took the time out of his extremely busy schedule to set up a pizza party where we all played the game RockBand, belting out classic American tunes. I could see the expression of the isolated [ECF p. 123] coworker softened with every slice and musical note; it really showed me once again that Nishads caring and inclusive personality was strong enough to show even in an ultra focused environment.
When FTX collapsed; I would not get the chance to see Nishad again for quite a long time. When I was finally able to reconnect with him, all that was left was a remorseful shell of the person I once knew as Nishad. That light and ambition that drove him to accomplish incredible physical and mental feats was snuffed out. Only the gloom of regret and deep despair remained in its shadow. After convincing him to talk about it, I saw his pain stemmed not from fear of punishment, but from anguish at the idea of hurting others.
I am proud to be a friend and family to Nishad in his time of need like I have seen him be to so many others during their lowest moments, including me. I know that I and hundreds of others are so lucky to call him a friend and mentor. If given the opportunity I know that he will continue to positively impact the lives of the people around him just like he has in my life.
Please feel free to reach out to me if you’d like any additional details.
Samir Vaidya
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number]
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]
[Letter from Ahir Redmore (“Cousin”)]
August 12, 2024
Dear Honorable Judge Kaplan,
I am reaching out to you today to share my insights and personal experiences regarding Nishad, whom I have had the privilege of knowing from the very moment I entered this world. Nishad and I share a deep bond, rooted in a long-standing family friendship that has always made me see him as an elder brother, especially since I grew up as an only child. My childhood was enriched with numerous gatherings at his family’s home, where we celebrated various holidays and special events such as Christmas and Thanksgiving. These occasions were filled with amazing conversations, engaging games, collaborative cooking sessions, and a shared joy that knit our lives closely together. A lot of time I look back at the best times of my childhood, and there aren’t a whole lot of memories without Nishad in them.
In our circle of family friends, particularly among the children, there was always an extremely vibrant culture of intellectual curiosity. All of the kids were and are exceptionally well-read and keen on exploring complex subjects and new topics. Despite my occasional struggles to keep up with such discussions, Nishad never hesitated to include me. He always took the time to explain concepts and share his knowledge. His approach was never patronizing; rather, it was filled with humility and an eagerness to nurture a love of learning in others. This aspect of his personality is not just admirable but profoundly inspirational.
One fantastic example of this is when we went on a family beach trip together. After a day of rafting, Nishad encouraged me to write an essay about the experience. Initially, this task frustrated me, as writing was not my forte. At the time, I absolutely hated the experience. “Writing an essay? While I’m on vacation? Why would anyone ever do this?” is what I was thinking at the time. I hated every second of holding that pencil and writing that paper. However, looking back, I realize that his intention was to open my mind to new expressions and experiences, which was a typical manifestation of his caring nature, even if I didn’t recognize that at the time.
Capturing the essence of Nishad’s impact on me and others through mere words on a document is a formidable challenge. His actions and character have left quite the mark on my life. During our childhood, I often felt slightly out of place within our group, perhaps because of my status as an only child or because of my age. Yet, Nishad consistently went out of his way to ensure I was included in every group activity. Further illustrating his character, there was an incident during the same trip when I found myself in trouble for talking back to my parents, a rather common occurrence for me as a kid. As a result, I had been excluded from group activities for the whole day and I was sitting there, on the sand, all alone. While all the other children immediately rushed to jump into the water play, Nishad chose to stay back and advocate on my behalf. His [ECF p. 125] successful persuasion of my father not only allowed me to join my friends but also highlighted his innate sense of fairness and his propensity to always stand up for what is right, irrespective of the personal cost.
Beyond these personal anecdotes, Nishad has demonstrated an extraordinary resilience and drive. He completed a grueling 100-mile run despite battling asthma, a condition that would deter many people, including me. His unwavering determination in the face of such physical challenges is nothing short of inspiring. I remember that day. I initially didn’t want to come as I was not going to be participating, but my mom convinced me to anyway. Now, I absolutely detest running, or really any sort of cardio, but Nishad’s friendly suggestion that I join for just a small portion of it (just one lap), turned into me joining them for a whole 16 miles. I look back on it as some of the most fun I have ever had in my life, despite my initial hesitancy. Nishad didn’t just push himself to take on something new that day, but he also persuaded me into joining him.
Several years ago, during a tumultuous period in my family life, Nishad's support was invaluable. He took the time to take me out for lunch on several occasions, providing a respite from my struggles. We talked about nothing related to anything, we simply enjoyed each other's company. I bet he didn’t know it at the time and still probably doesn’t know it, but those short and temporary escapes from reality really helped me. It was a simple gesture, yet it helped me in ways that he couldn’t have imagined. His ability to offer solace and distraction through genuine conversation exemplifies his compassionate nature.
Regarding the situation at FTX, I must confess that I am not familiar with the details of the case. However, I can speak with utmost confidence about his character. Nishad has always acted with the best intentions, aiming to make a positive impact on the world. I can say with 100% confidence that at his core, Nishad is a simple person, with altruistic intentions and a big heart.
Your Honor, as you deliberate on this case, I respectfully urge you to consider these reflections of Nishad's character—his kindness, empathy, inclusiveness, resilience, and moral integrity. Thank you.
Sincerely,
Ahir Redmore
[REDACTED]
Los Gatos, CA - 95032
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number]
[Letter from Shaunak Vaidya (“Cousin”)]
July 1 2024
Dear Judge Kaplan,
My name is Shaunak Vaidya and Nishad has consistently been one of my most influential role models throughout my life. Our parents grew close many years before we were born and as such I haven’t known a birthday, holiday or other family gathering without Nishad. I consider myself extremely fortunate to have learned from him as a part of my most intimate family.
Nishad has always had a profound knack for acts of quiet kindness; he doesn’t seek applause, only wishing for confirmation that his deeds achieved positive results. There are countless instances that stick out in my head where he has created small, private, and powerful moments of connection with others, such as inviting a child whom he has never met to play with him when he sees they are feeling excluded or lonely in a large crowd. I distinctly remember one such time when I was very young, probably 6 or 7 years old, that had a profound effect on me. Nishad and I come from a large and boisterous extended family, where he found himself the “host” for numerous children visiting his home. One evening, one of the children who had come over had mannerisms that were different from the rest of the kids – unable to make eye contact, fidgeting with his hands, speaking with unexpected intonations– and I later found out that he had autism. I had never encountered someone with autism before and found myself avoiding him entirely because I didn’t know how to interact with him and, frankly, felt a bit uncomfortable. Nishad, on the other hand, walked right up to him, smiled, and started pointing out different areas of the room to ease him into a conversation. While, as a preteen boy, he may not have had much instruction with handling leadership like this, it was clear from the beginning that he had a special ability to include and uplift people. It was through Nishad’s leadership and kindness - being patient while they found their words or thought through their emotions, encouraging them and smiling - to put them at ease that I saw the person open up, smiling and [ECF p. 127] laughing with the rest of the crowd. I think about moments like this because, without Nishad, I might have stayed apprehensive about interacting with people who seemed different than me. But because I was taught that invaluable lesson, the power of inclusive compassion has stayed with me. In years to come I found myself reliving this moment in efforts to do good in small moments just like Nishad had that day. In 9th grade, an individual moved to the United States for the first time and joined our school. They appeared apprehensive and nervous about their unfamiliar environment, perhaps overwhelmed by all of the new conventions. I thought about what Nishad would do here. How easy it would be for him to be kind and help someone. I introduced myself simply as a friend, whom they could reach out to if ever they were confused or lonely. While I might not have been as adept as Nishad was, as a 14 year old I felt proud of myself for applying what I knew to be right. The new student was grateful that I reached out and eventually did contact me with a few questions. I went on to graduate with this person a few years later, at which time they approached me in thanks for that small gesture and conversation. I smiled, and in my head, thanked Nishad. His lessons to me are lasting, optimistic, and powerful. I believe Nishad would do things like this because they lead him to be the most helpful and virtuous version of himself; in this case, simply a friend.
In other instances, Nishad’s impact in improving my character was through leading by example, without judgment. I distinctly remember moments years ago when Nishad took extra time to go running with me, an overweight, exercise-averse 10-year old at the time. He was training seriously for his 100-mile race and had an intense running schedule as it was, but it was clear to me that he thought it was worth sacrificing valuable training time to share his joy of running with me. I lacked discipline early on and I hated running. But I took Nishad up on his offers to run because I loved spending time with him and admired how deeply he believed in bettering ourselves. More than a decade later, physical fitness is a core tenet in my life that I can fully attribute to his early belief in me. To this day, hearing of other folk’s struggles with [ECF p. 128] staying in shape reminds me of the empathy that Nishad had for me. I wish to recreate Nishad’s inclusion for anyone who has trouble believing in themselves the way I did. It is a true joy of mine to encourage someone who is struggling, and work with them to demonstrate that anything is possible if you are patient and committed. And that one day maybe they can do the same for someone else in their shoes. I think about Nishad in those moments. I still wish to emulate his effortless, yet intentionally uplifting spirit. Nishad’s character is unquestionably virtuous, punctuated by an aversion to acclamation and a commitment to definite good.
Shaunak Vaidya
[Letter from Alamelu Iyengar (Great Aunt)]
Character Reference Letter for Nishad Singh
To the Honorable Judge Kaplan,
I am writing this letter to vouch for the character of my grand nephew, Nishad Singh, who will sit in front of you. I have known Nishad since his birth, and I can attest to his kindness, generosity, and compassion that has been present day one.
Nishad was an adorable, ever-smiling child who grew up to be a bright teenager with the kindest heart I have ever seen. He always makes sure I have a chair to sit on in any of the parties we are together. He never lets me carry any heavy things whenever we are. He is respectful, polite, and helpful to everyone he meets.
One example of his kindness that I will never forget is from a Thanksgiving party that my niece, his mother, hosted. Every year, we all, including the children and pets, go for a long walk after the meal. My niece has a couple of dogs that also walk with us. One year, one of the dogs could not walk because he was getting old. We thought of leaving him at home. But Nishad could not bear the thought of him being left out and carried him all the way there and back. He is so kind and generous that he always puts others ahead of himself and helps them in any way he can.
I hope you will consider Nishad's character and his positive impact on the people around him. He is a good person who I very much believe deserves a second chance. I sincerely request you to show him leniency and mercy.
Thank you for your time and attention.
Sincerely,
Alamelu Iyengar
10 May 2024
[Letter from Anil Vaidya (“Uncle”)]
April 3, 2024
Dear Judge Kaplan,
I have known Nishad Singh very well since his birth in 1995. My wife, Suchitra Vaidya, and I are close friends of Nishad and his parents for the past 30 years.
I personally know Nishad to be an extremely bright, principled, and generous person; this aspect of Nishad's character has not changed in the 25+ years I have known him. Nishad, his brother and my two sons are separated in age by 4 years, my sons are 3 and 4 years younger than Nishad. Over the years, I have taken Nishad and the three boys on hundreds of weekend trips, from skiing in the Sierra Nevada to day trips to the beaches in Santa Cruz. As the oldest of the boys, I relied on Nishad to lead the boys and he showed his outstanding character every time.
To illustrate the strength of his character and humility, here are two anecdotal memories of Nishad; I hope these demonstrate Nishad's true, humble, nature.
* Natural Bridges - as mentioned, we made dozens of day trips to Natural Bridges state park in Santa Cruz. I would make these trips by myself with 4 young boys with me and Nishad was always my reliable helper, organizing and making sure the other 3 boys were safe. To get to the far end of the beach, we would hop across an open spot on a cliffside trail where erosion had washed the trail away. I was trying to help my older son, Samir, across the gap when Samir slipped and Nishad, without thinking of his own safety reached across and grabbed Samir to safety from the other side from where he was watching. To save Samir, Nishad definitely put himself in significant danger, and averted a much bigger problem or injury to Samir or himself. His only thought at that moment was to save his friend. He refused to take credit for doing something heroic, the other 3 of us know how he saved the day, but he was ready to move on while deflecting our praise.
* Ski trip to Boreal Ski resort - As above, it was just the 4 boys and I on a skiing trip to Boreal resort in Tahoe. Nishad is a good skier however, it was stormy on the mountain that day and he fell on a rock. While protecting himself in the fall, he fractured his hand. I reached him quickly and got to him for care, however Nishad insisted he was well enough to go with me to get the younger boys to safety before I could get him to the Medical station. It turned out he had a severely broken hand that needed screws, a cast and painkillers to help the healing. In the 3 hours of the episode, he never admitted the pain or that he needed care. He just wanted to keep helping me! He is the most responsible, caring, and selfless young man I have ever known.
In 28 years of knowing him, I have never seen him ask for something for himself. He has always been a selfless, generous person, and honest to a fault. I hope this testimonial illustrates Nishad Singh's true character of being a humble, caring and generous person. Thank you for reading this.
Respectfully and sincerely,
-Anil Vaidya
m: [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number]
e: [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]