Letters from Other Friends
[Letter from Briana Reynolds (Partner of “Cousin”)]
Dear Judge Kaplan,
I’ve had the joy of knowing Nishad for over four years. He is like an older brother—not by blood, but by choice—to my boyfriend of five years, Samir. Nishad and Samir’s family is a wonderfully loving and vibrant group, built on deep friendships and cherished moments together. Nishad is immensely warm and thoughtful, surrounded by a strong support system of friends and family who deeply care about him.
Through shared holidays, birthday celebrations, and frequent dinners, I’ve seen how Nishad embodies emotional intelligence and kindness. At family gatherings, he loves nothing more than playing games with his younger cousins, patiently explaining the rules so everyone can join in. He engages everyone around him with a smile and always has a kind word to share. As someone who is naturally shy and self-conscious, I often feel a bit overwhelmed at these gatherings. But Nishad has always made me feel welcomed and at ease. He quickly invites me into games and conversations, shares funny stories from his childhood with Samir, and offers encouragement in small and meaningful ways.
Nishad’s relationships with each family member are truly heartwarming. To Samir and his brother Shaunak, he is a supportive older sibling, always invested in their interests and encouraging them to explore their passions. Samir, who has a love for the natural world, credits Nishad for nurturing this passion by tutoring him in biology. This support has played a significant role in Samir’s successful career in bioinformatics. I fondly remember a family vacation where Nishad helped his fiancée, Claire, out of the car with a gentle, outstretched hand, then did the same for his mother and aunts. It’s a small detail that speaks volumes about his character.
When Nishad moved to the Bahamas from Hong Kong, Samir and I were thrilled at the thought of seeing him more often, especially after the challenges of work demands and COVID restrictions had made his visits to California so rare. We traveled to the Bahamas to spend time with him, and even as a newer addition to the family, he went out of his way to support me during my visit. At that time, I had just graduated college and was uncertain about my career path. I had been working as a substitute teacher and searching for a greater sense of purpose. I confided in Nishad about my struggle to find work that could make a positive impact on the world while also nurturing my love for writing.
Where others offered encouragement, Nishad went above and beyond, engaging in deep conversations and long walks. He listened intently as I shared my aspirations and, after thoughtful questions, offered his insights. He introduced me to the need for dedicated individuals in the animal welfare space—a cause we both care about as vegetarians. Not only did he offer to connect me with people in that field, but during his busy workdays, he created a detailed document listing over ten organizations making a difference. He even highlighted specific [ECF p. 174] individuals and projects that might resonate with me.
Looking back, I’m struck by how, even in early 2022, when Nishad had every reason to feel on top of the world, he made it clear that I was just as important. He never spoke from a place of condescension; instead, he celebrated my excitement and helped me believe in myself. When I met other FTX employees on that trip and shared my journey, they nodded knowingly, recounting their own experiences with Nishad’s support. Many mentioned that he was personally mentoring Bahamian employees in coding. They frequently remarked that he was the best employer they had ever had, emphasizing his extraordinary kindness and generosity. They all adored him. To this day, Nishad continues to encourage me in pursuing my goals, and I consider him a compassionate mentor. He is truly a remarkable individual. If you would like more context about Nishad’s character, please don’t hesitate to reach out.
Briana Reynolds
Ph: [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number]
Email: [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]
[Letter from Myles Baumann (Post-College Friend)]
September 5, 2024
The Honorable Judge Lewis A. Kaplan
United States District Judge
Southern District of New York
Dear Judge Kaplan,
I write to you today to provide insight into my experiences and friendship with Nishad, and who I've come to know him to be.
Nishad and I first met in August of 2022 when I was visiting a mutual friend at FTX with whom I had been close friends in college. Going into the trip I was nervous for several reasons, ranging from the fact that I hadn't seen this friend since I'd graduated, it was my first time out of the country since the pandemic, and felt a certain degree of intimidation by this interesting and formidable group of people.
My first night upon arriving, our mutual friend had invited me, Nishad, and others to his place to have some drinks and play Rock Band, a video game. Immediately Nishad began asking everyone if they needed anything to eat or to drink and fussing about in the kitchen, bringing out an array of drinks and snacks. Our friend began to playfully chastise him saying “Nishad, this is so you to begin mom-ing after you've had a drink, chill out so we can please play the game”. Over that evening, Nishad and I chatted and immediately got along like old friends, interrupted by a few instances of him getting a call and whipping out his laptop to deal with some work stuff. Not only was Nishad thoughtful, generous, and gracious the first time we met, but he was all of those things, all the time. Without thinking about it he was consistently caring, like it was the only way he knew how to be. Since our first meeting, my initial sense of him as fundamentally compassionate has only grown.
That experience was reinforced during my second visit to the Bahamas in October of 2022, during which I was interviewing for a position with the company. On this visit, Nishad's brother, friends from college, and additional friends whom I didn't know were in town, and Nishad was quick to invite me to join them for dinner. During what was otherwise a stressful week as I tried out for a role at the company, he was swift to offer me rides to work, invite me to cook with his friends, and otherwise made efforts to include me and make me feel at home. Though he may not know it, he provided some much needed comfort and understanding in an otherwise intimidating environment.
In thinking of other ways to interrogate my own understanding of Nishad in order to convey that perception to you, I've considered how I've discussed Nishad to others. I searched "Nishad" on my phone and found a message to my girlfriend during my second visit to the Bahamas saying "Claire and Nishad are the best hosts ever" in regards to how inclusive and loving they were towards me. In the years since I'd met him, he’s yet to meet my girlfriend, and I frequently talk about how sweet he is, and [ECF p. 176] how excited I am for her to meet him. I've also met with other of Nishad's friends from high school with whom we've invariably talked about his kindness and affability.
After that second trip to the Bahamas, I was given an offer to join FTX and was excited about the prospect. As the events of November 2022 unfolded, I was able to retain my previous position, but grew concerned for my friends at FTX, particularly Nishad. I knew that his compassion would manifest with a sense of ownership, and I worried he would take the entire situation upon himself. This was affirmed in my immediate reaction not to reach out to him, because I did not want him to take on a sense of personal responsibility as to my not being able to join. I did wind up calling Claire eventually, and she told me they were able to get back to the San Francisco Bay area to be closer to family, which I was happy to hear, as I knew his family would be able to support him.
I continued to think about Nishad over the coming months, hoping to give him space as he dealt with the fallout from FTX. For the most part I was able to stay in touch with Claire, as Nishad was too unwell to meet the times I was in San Francisco. I do remember March 3rd, 2023 in particular, however, when the Wall Street Journal article about Nishad came out. I saw it online around lunch time and read it, and was immediately brought to tears as I thought how I knew he must be internalizing the situation. I was so disturbed by the memory it called forth of a compassionate person whom those around him regarded as so remarkably kind and generous that I took the day off work, too sad thinking about how he must be handling the situation and what the impact of that on someone so singular within my life would have for me to want to deal with the world.
It wasn’t until a few months ago that we were finally able to reunite in San Francsico. We went on a hike with his dogs and went to dinner. The spunky 80-some-year-old restaurant owner must have picked up on Nishad’s welcoming nature and approached us to tell a joke. Nishad and I wordlessly nodded at each other and invited her to our table, and we proceeded to have the most memorable meal I’ve experienced in some time, laughing along to her telling all kinds of funny stories about her life.
I believe that these experiences, while innocuous, provide a sense for the kind of warmth and thoughtfulness Nishad provides effortlessly in his engagement with the world, and I am grateful for having had the opportunity to be a recipient of that kindness.
Sincerely,
Myles Baumann
[Letter from Liza Babin (Partner of Brother)]
Dear Judge Kaplan,
My name is Liza Babin, and I have had the privilege of knowing Nishad for over four years as his brother’s significant other. I am writing to share my perspective on Nishad's character and to thank you for taking the time to consider this letter.
I first met Nishad in 2020 over the phone, shortly after I began dating his younger brother, Malhar. At that time, I was an assistant in Hollywood aspiring to become a television writer. I had just conceived an idea for a scripted female-driven comedy TV show set in the world of cryptocurrency, a field I knew very little about. In my quest for understanding, I turned to Nishad.
Despite having never met me before, Nishad patiently spent over an hour on the phone answering my numerous questions, many of which were basic due to my limited knowledge. Simply put, I knew nothing, and Nishad gave me an extremely clear and thorough understanding of not only blockchain technology, but the entire crypto space. His explanations were clear and engaging, and he painted a vivid picture of the fast-paced, multifaceted world of crypto. His kindness, patience, and encouragement during this call were deeply impactful. Nishad's belief in my idea and in me, even though I was a novice in both the entertainment and financial worlds, was invaluable. Sometimes these nods of encouragement were the only things that kept me going in an otherwise difficult and unpredictable industry.
Over the next four years, I came to see that this was not an isolated instance of kindness. Nishad consistently demonstrated a genuine interest in those around him, always taking the time to listen and offer support. On numerous occasions, he would be at his parents' house, working late into the night. Even when he was exhausted and had fallen asleep on the couch, laptop still open, he would wake up if someone needed his help, his advice or just someone to listen. His dedication to his work never overshadowed his readiness to support those around him.
As I became more integrated into his family, I continued developing my television show concept. Through the research I conducted over three years, which included attending conferences and conducting hours of interviews with various figures within the crypto space, I realized how exceptional Nishad truly is. In an industry often focused on wealth and status, Nishad stood out for his humility, dedication to positive change, and his commitment to helping others. Nishad was a character unlike any other in the space, not defined by crypto but rather by his interest in using his talents to unlock solutions to extremely complex problems in a wide variety of sectors. Over the last year alone, I’ve seen him tackle numerous new projects, such as working with Brendan Taliaferro to create a database that organizes crucial climate data. This database will help people across the country identify areas affected by climate change. Nishad constantly tackles complex problems head-on, using his engineering skills not only to understand the issues but also to provide clear and effective solutions.
I can safely say that knowing Nishad over the past four years has not only positively changed the trajectory of my life, but his efforts will continue to positively affect others for years to come. Without Nishad and his support, I may have turned my back on the one thing I loved long ago. I truly believe in Nishad’s ability to enact positive change on an interpersonal level as well as on a larger stage. His talents and character bring a light into the lives of everyone he interacts with.
Thank you for taking the time to consider my perspective.
Best,
Liza Babin
[Letter from Kermit Cuff (Ultramarathon Friend)]
August 22 2024
Dear Judge Kaplan,
Back in 2012, I read an article in the San Jose Mercury News about a local 15 year-old boy (Nishad Singh) who had run 100 miles. At the time, I was mentoring a 13 year-old boy named Miguel who was aspiring to become an ultramarathon runner himself. I just had to meet Nishad, so I was able to contact his mentor and we arranged a meeting. Despite his accomplishments, he showed no ego and wanted to help Miguel achieve his dream of running 100 miles. The three of us got to run together in the hills of Harvey Bear County Park, where Nishad shared some of his wisdom and experience with Miguel. Nishad also came out to support Miguel during an all-night training run in Campbell. He gave more advice on how to keep running throughout the night even when your body is very tired. Thanks to Nishad's support, Miguel did complete a 100 mile run.
I'm a captain of the 500 Mile American Indian Spiritual Marathon running team, and I invited Nishad to one of our training events to help coach some of our runners in running longer distances. He inspired so many people that day and made them realize that they could go way beyond their perceived limits. Even though many of the runners were much older than Nishad, he commanded their respect and admiration.
The following year I ran some laps with Nishad when he was running another 100 mile race and had time to talk more with him. I was really impressed with his intelligence, determination and compassion for others. One thing stood out to me - he related how he had read about the reality of factory farming when he was 12 years old, and decided right then that he would no longer eat meat. His parents (wonderful people!) respected his wishes. I was amazed at his courage and conviction at such a young age.
I sincerely hope that Nishad is given the opportunity to restart his life. I know he has a fiancee and a lot to offer this world. I have no doubt that he will be a positive contributor to our society going forward.
Kermit Cuff
[REDACTED]
Mountain View, CA 94041
[Letter from Ruhi Christie (Partner of “Cousin”)]
July 1, 2024
Dear Judge Kaplan,
I am Shaunak Vaidya’s girlfriend, which automatically inserts me into the middle of Nishad Singh’s family dynamics, since Shaunaks family is part of a large family friend circle. When I’m with Shaunak’s family, I self-identify as a wall-flower. I find myself most comfortable sitting back and observing, rather than speaking up and interacting nonstop. Things like family barbecues or holiday parties are wonderful events, but, with all due respect, for an outsider they can be quite overwhelming.
As I made my way through these gatherings, I eventually met Nishad. He had grown up fully integrated in the beautiful chaos, yet still held a remarkable poise and sensitivity to quieter folks. He approached me with the clear intent of wanting to make me comfortable, which I could feel immediately. It’s as if he understood my discomfort. From asking me about my life to random questions about anything, I felt at ease around Nishad. It feels rare to have someone always take a genuine interest in what I have to say and likewise, make an effort to hear me. He is someone I can walk up to at any time and be comfortable around.
Despite Nishad’s seemingly constant bombardment of work, it was always apparent that he wanted to spend all his time with his family. Nishad always found a way to make his loved ones the main event, even if that meant joining a game night hours after it had begun. This is especially true when it comes to a family member in need of help. When Shaunak and I visited Nishad in the Bahamas, Shaunak fell very ill. It came to a point where over-the-counter drugs were not helping. I felt so scared and worried because we were far away from home and I had very little medical knowledge. In a panic, I called Nishad for help. After explaining the situation, Nishad showed up within a few minutes. He immediately drove us to a doctor to get Shaunak the care he needed. Despite him getting work calls while we were at the doctor’s, Nishad stayed with us the whole time. I am someone who takes pride in being strong for others and putting on [ECF p. 180] a brave face, especially for someone I love. But at this moment, I felt helpless. Nishad’s presence alone gave me the strength I was lacking. It is something I am grateful for to this day.
The rest of our time in the Bahamas visiting Nishad felt like a strange dream. We were shocked by the luxury that we were surrounded by, supplemented constantly by Nishad’s assurance that he had no desire to live like this. When giving us a tour of his place, his little comments made us realize he was not very fond of the luxury. When we went out to dinner, the waiters would call him “sir”. He would smile awkwardly and insist that they “keep it casual” with them. The waiters gave a laugh and it seemed as though they were relieved for not having to be so uptight around him. Sure, the luxury and being treated like royalty was “nice”, but Nishad truly did not want any of that. He just wanted to be a regular guy. The first night we arrived, we spent hours playing Guitar Hero and Code Names with Nishad and his work colleagues. It quickly became evident that his colleagues enjoyed his company outside of work, and situations like this were welcome respites from the formality of his unwanted environment. Nishad’s humility was challenged while we were there, and to me he was quite uncomfortable reckoning with this. Conversely, it is no question where Nishad seemed most in his element: helping those in need.
Ruhi Christie
[Letter from Anonymous (Post-FTX Friend)]
To Judge Lewis Kaplan,
I have known Nishad's fiancée Claire for years. I met her through our involvement with a charity. For years I only knew her partner, Nishad Singh, as an extreme workaholic trying to earn money to give away. I'd met him briefly over Skype during Covid. He was working from home because he was sick. With his dog on his lap, he said a warm but sickly "hi" while the camera was pointed at him.
I have a long history of recurrent depression. Between these bouts, I like to help others who struggle and often sit on suicide watches with people in crisis. When FTX exploded I contacted Claire to see if she was okay. She was not. But Nishad really was not. Claire was terrified he would kill himself imminently, she asked if I could talk to him. Nishad's mental state was different than I have ever encountered. It wasn't depression. It was horror. Deep, deep horror. He was like a person torn inside out.
I’ve been in desperate mental places myself, and have tried to help many other people who were suffering terribly–including one who eventually committed suicide–but I’ve never known anyone who seemed as imminently at risk of killing themselves as Nishad. I remember thinking–quietly and to myself– that it seemed more likely than not that he would not survive. Nishad is a very unusual person. His personality is extreme, but in almost the exact opposite way anyone could expect given his complicity in FTX. I have worked and volunteered with charities for decades and know some incredibly good people, but even so, and without hyperbole, Nishad is one of the most interpersonally kind, thoughtful, people-pleasing individuals I have ever met. Not in a "slick" way like a salesman, but in an almost childlike, naive way. He is warm, friendly, and self-effacing, but it goes even deeper, he also tries to solicit and follow the preferences of others, expresses few of his own opinions, and persistently “goes along to get along.”
As Nishad slowly recovered from his psychological crisis, his work ethic and devotion to others returned. This recovery came at a very fortunate time for me. Within about 6 months, our roles flipped. Around this time I had a flare up of recurrent major depression–the worst I’ve ever had in my 30-year on-and-off struggle with the condition. I became unable to work and within a short period almost completely stopped being able to leave the house or speak with almost anyone. When my world collapsed, Nishad was one of the only people I could bring myself to turn to.
It wasn’t that I could not have theoretically called on others, and it was not just that Nishad kept showing up–though he did. With my depression, it was as though my battery was drained to nearly zero. I have to constantly triage between energy-demanding activities like calling my psychiatrist, crawling out of bed to shower at least every few days, or facing the shame of reaching out to a friend or family member. Even trying to text or email my family, or closest, oldest friends could exceed all the power I had. But not Nishad. Nishad was “no batteries required.” I went weeks at a time where literally the only people I talked to were my wife, mental health professionals, and Nishad. Not my family. Not my friends of decades. Nishad, who I had met less than a year before during the worst period of his life, and who was just now barely getting to his feet–yet he became a cornerstone of my life support. In the past 18 months–the worst of my life–I’ve spoken with Nishad more than anyone except my wife. During this time, he also provided me with more support than all of the rest of my [ECF p. 182] family combined. This period was, naturally, also nightmarish for my wife. So, of course, she has also spoken with Nishad more than with anyone else but me. This who he is at his core–if Nishad finds he can help you, he is all in. He has become, according to my wife, “probably my best friend.” I think this is an understatement: Nishad is our family.
Nishad provided vital emotional support, but he was also relentless in finding practical things he could do for my wife and me to create more slack in our lives and less stress. This included smaller things like dog-sitting, doing chores when he visited, bringing and making food, and “co-working” to provide company. When my wife needed relief from months of continuous suicide watch, Nishad took over, staying with me so she could spend a few days away from home and finally rest. This meant doing even more housework–as I did not move much those days, driving me to outpatient treatment as I was not safe to operate a car myself, and sleeping on my couch (apparently, several times sharing the small space with my dogs who have come to love him almost as much as my wife and I do). And he did this all without making it seem like a burden. And because of Nishad’s extreme and abnormal personality, I don’t think it was a burden. He just sincerely wanted to help.
Your Honor will almost certainly have received dozens of character letters saying how Nishad is incredibly warm, caring, emotionally attentive, self-sacrificing, understanding, accommodating, and not at all demanding. These are all true and obvious to anyone who knows him. Something that is only known to those of us who have ever leaned on him very heavily, as I have, is that when Nishad feels he is doing something good or providing care, it is clear that that is all he wants to be doing.
With the openness that comes from shared vulnerability, I have had many tearful conversations with Nishad in private. The sincerity of his guilt, regret, and remorse is beyond question–as is the pain it still causes him. When we talk about his situation he always focuses on how he can “undo the damage” or “make it up to others” as much as possible. He truly believes he owes a broad debt to the world. When discussing the future, Nishad mostly sticks to talking about possible career directions or voluntary projects he can take on that would be good for the world and pay back some of his “debt.”
He has a lot of debt to repay and has made a strong start. Nishad's friends, family, and community all hugely benefit from his presence. And with us around to keep him devoted to the right things, he, and everyone, will benefit from him being with us.
Thank you for your consideration.
(I apologize that I feel it is necessary to submit this letter anonymously. I have suffered substantial career consequences in the past because of the stigma surrounding my struggles with depression.)