Sentencing Letters Submitted on Behalf of Nishad Singh (Exhibit A to the Sentencing Submission), part 16 of 19 (ECF pages 162 to 171)

[ECF p. 162]

[Letter from Varun Tolani (College Friend)]

May 4, 2024

Dear Judge Kaplan,

My name is Varun Tolani and I’m a friend of Nishad Singh. We first met in the dorms during our freshman year of college at UC Berkeley. We both studied electrical engineering and computer science (EECS) and spent a lot of quality time together in and out of the classroom during our 4 years at UC Berkeley. While I cannot comment on the details of the case, I can comment on the Nishad Singh that I know.

Nishad is a champion of the people. He has an inspiring capacity to serve others with humbleness and grace. He truly “walks the walk”, serving both his local community and the world at large.

I first experienced Nishad’s commitment to his community in college. We spent a lot of time bonding over problem sets for our engineering courses. I have countless memories of late night “homework parties” in the kitchen of my small apartment on Benvenue Ave, Berkeley with Nishad patiently walking a group or 5 or 6 of us through his big “aha” moment, the key to solving the problem we’d all been stuck for 3-4 hours on. There is no question that he is exceptionally bright, however what stood out to me most was the grace with which he helped the rest of us. There was never a hint of ego or superiority in these moments, simply a desire to help his community. In the past year and a half since he and FTX have been in the spotlight, every single member of our group of “homework buddies” has reached out to me to express how shocked they were. The Nishad Singh they remembered is so clearly a champion of his people and does not at all match the character portrayed in the news.

I saw Nishad’s commitment to others play out at a larger scale in his career decisions. As we finished our college years together, Nishad moved on to work in machine learning at Facebook. In our field, this is one of the most sought-after jobs one can secure- a surefire launching pad to a successful career and a testament to his brilliance. However he quit only 6 months in. On paper this seemed like career suicide, but his decision made sense to me. He’d long expressed a desire to dedicate his career to serving the broader global community. For him, the journey with Alameda Research began as a way to explore the viability of cryptocurrency as a way to fund his “earn to give” philosophy and make a serious impact on global humanitarian and animal problems.

Throughout his time at FTX/Alameda I saw him really “walk the walk”. He’d regularly work 80+ hour weeks, pouring his heart and soul into his mission of building the business as a way to serve the world around him. I remember discussing the sad state of the couch in the office which has become his “primary residence”. I remember deep discussions on improving conditions for factory-farmed animals. Slowly, I began to realize that the dreams of his early twenties that he’d shared in that cramped apartment on Benvenue Ave were becoming a reality.

[ECF p. 163]

In the last few months I’ve been reminded of Nishad’s empathy, care, and grace at a very personal level. We recently reconnected after a long lawyer-recommended silence post FTX collapse. Life has dramatically changed for both of us in the past few years. On my side I’ve found myself dealing with chronic, mostly-untreatable illness. On reconnecting with Nishad I felt so much care, empathy, and a deep understanding. It was more meaningful than he could have known. He reflected on how the life of most of my peers must “feel like living on another planet” and inquired deeply into the details of how I felt rather than shying away from the uncomfortable conversation. He supported me by holding a beautiful space and silence for me-helping me feel heard and understood when it can be so easy to feel alone and isolated in my condition. Though we were reconnecting after a few years, I was reminded of the beautiful supportive presence he brings to my life and this world.

I thank you for reading my words as you consider his sentencing. Please don’t hesitate to reach out for any additional details.

Best,

Varun Tolani
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number]

[ECF p. 164]

[Letter from Darren Zhao (College Friend)]

The Honorable Judge Lewis A. Kaplan
United States District Judge
Southern District of New York

August 28, 2024

Dear Judge Kaplan,

I’m writing a character letter for Nishad Singh, my good friend for the past 11 years. I’m hoping the court will offer him leniency.

I first met Nishad as my freshman year college roommate on move-in day in 2013, both of our first experiences navigating independence and freedom. Our families helped us unpack and settle in; then it was time for us to quickly turn our acquaintanceship into friendship, a charge led by Nishad. My first impression of Nishad during our first time alone was that he had a warmth and a desire to connect, one that remains true even past the mold of our young adulthood. I remember my phone rang, and out of performative coolness I had set the ringtone to Muse’s Supermassive Black Hole. “Oh, I love that song!” said Nishad. “Are you a big Muse fan?” I said not really, which was only partly true, but in those days I was too awkward to pretend to bond over shared fandom. “Oh,” responded Nishad, “oh well,” and with that he gave a sort of easy smile and noncommittal chuckle, casually letting me off the hook. Over that year living together, he’d find many other ways to draw me out of my shyness with mutual interests, but at the time I had no real evidence he actually cared all that much for Muse, even though it turns out he did love the band. Only now do I realize that perhaps discussing Muse was only a secondary motivation, and that his main aim was to find something, anything that I liked. He noted and nurtured our mutual interests, and made me feel seen; he built the foundation of a relationship where I felt safe and at ease.

Over the course of our friendship, I’ve come to understand that Nishad’s easy warmth was innate to him, but his social wherewithal was not. He would often joke about his childhood awkwardness, and the canonical anecdote ended with a cousin explaining to him why he got teased in some earlier scenario that left him confused. But I never interpreted that as a closed story with a resolution - to me Nishad was a constantly progressing image of self improvement. Many figures would feature as behavioral models for Nishad, including his current girlfriend Claire and other upperclassmen, and he was always excited to sing their praises to me. In turn, Nishad would offer a path out of my own shyness as I looked to him as an unwitting mentor.

What was also innate and constant to Nishad was an instinct for kindness, which he demonstrated in acts of earnest and casual altruism. Berkeley the city was well-known for its cast of unhoused characters. One afternoon Nishad and I planned to grab a snack after lecture hall when we passed by a homeless wheelchaired woman. Just as I was about to skirt by her and continue along, Nishad said hello to her by name - they must have had previously met - and pushed her up the ramp and walked around to face her. With a single pleading glance at me, Nishad offered to buy her next meal. “We’re about to grab lunch - can I get you a burrito? Or a [ECF p. 165] coffee?” “McDonald’s,” she replied, tersely. He wheeled her around the corner to the local McDonald’s, and as he struggled to push the chair over the small hump in the doorway, the woman smacked his hand and told him to stop fussing. After the cashier listed the order total, Nishad settled up and asked if there was anything else he could provide, and she responded with empty silence.

I felt shocked on his behalf and vicariously betrayed, as if it were kindness that had been dismissed. I could only compel acts of public service in me if I was praised a commensurate amount. As we walked home, I realized Nishad thought about it entirely differently, and reflected, “She’s having an especially bad day, I hope she’ll be okay.” Among our friends Nishad became well-known for his compassion toward the homeless”. Among our friends Nishad became well-known for his generosity for the homeless.

After graduation, I moved out east to New York. Inspired by Nishad’s childhood glow up, I saw a chance to effect my own metamorphosis, or at least to shed my nerdiness. A new grad job across the country was an opportunity to don an exciting new identity, and my new life perhaps began to supersede the old Bay Area one. Nishad and I gradually lost touch. By mid 2019, our correspondence had taken on a biannual cadence. I had of course been following his rapid career growth, but we hadn’t had a chance to talk about it before he was swallowed by the workload. After FTX’s collapse in 2022, I messaged Nishad to check in but didn’t receive a response.

I saw Nishad again at a wedding in September of 2023. It was easy for us to fall back into old habits; Nishad had always made me feel at ease, and I was intent on reciprocating his warmth despite the recent distance. Countless other college friends that hadn’t heard from him since the collapse tearily hugged him, grateful that he was safe and okay. Nishad slowly came out of his shell, and ended up serving as the social glue between old college friend groups he had historically bridged. Afterwards, I remember one other friend vocalizing what I had been thinking: “It’s been impossible to reconcile the Nishad I know and the one portrayed in the media, but being with him again today made it so clear to me which one is real. He’s the same loving soul I remember.”

I offered to keep Nishad and Claire company while he prepared for the trial in October. It’s a month I look back fondly on, where dinners cast a hazy nostalgia back to our Berkeley days. Over the weeks they happily spent hours gardening and manicuring my flat’s previously overgrown, small back patio. When Nishad was feeling afraid about the future, I reminded him that we would always be there for him. When I think back on our friendship, there’s almost a cyclical poeticism in our dual roles as recluse and extrovert. Just as Nishad had taught me that social awkwardness was not intrinsic, I realized that I was showing Nishad that the world had not turned its back on him.

I hope that this letter and the collective voices of friends close to Nishad can paint the picture of a man who is pure and guileless in spirit. I can certainly testify that he’s been an inspiring [ECF p. 166] influence in the formative years of my life. Please keep this in consideration as you weigh the severity of your judgment.

Thank you,
Darren Zhao

[ECF p. 167]

[Letter from Stevie Kobori (College Friend)]

April 2, 2024
Dear Judge Kaplan,

I first met Nishad our freshman year of college. We had just moved into the dorms. I was in a room on the sixth floor, right next to the stairwell, and he was in the room on the fifth floor right below me. Due to the convenient placement of our rooms, our shared major, and the fact that his roommate was a high school classmate of mine, Nishad and I quickly became friends. There was a group of us in the dorm taking a number of computer science courses together, and would all do homework in the shared common room. Just as frequently, we would play social deduction games or video games late into the night.

I think Nishad’s core values are rooted in his thoughtfulness towards others. During our study sessions, he would always offer to pick up drinks or snacks as he was coming back from campus to join us. Then and now he’s always quick to compliment others. On how put-together someone is for always starting studying for midterms weeks before, or how smart so-and-so is, able to explain concepts clearly to others. I remember he’d always compliment the precision of my study “cheat sheets” that we used to prepare for finals.

I don’t think I’ve ever heard him say anything close to a boast about his accomplishments, academic or otherwise. That first year, someone came across a video of his TedX talk about completing a hundred mile ultramarathon at age 16. We were amazed. A hundred miles is a decent-length drive, but Nishad seemed more embarrassed that we found the video than anything else. Even when we were interviewing in the fall of our senior year for jobs after college, I remember he received an offer from Facebook that came with a “rockstar” signing bonus. He waved it off as probably just luck with interview questions. I always got the sense that, while incredibly smart himself, Nishad felt lucky to have been friends with a group of fairly academically-minded peers. Years later, I learned that Nishad had the highest GPA out of all of us. I was surprised because Nishad never exhibited anything but gratefulness to be studying with us. He always made everyone feel respected and admired. In hindsight, I shouldn’t have been surprised. It’s classic Nishad - I think he really was grateful, really did admire us, and really did outperform us, all at the same time.

After college, Nishad and I lived together in various configurations in San Francisco for roughly three years. My partner, now wife, Isabel, would stay over some nights, and Nishad’s partner, Claire, later moved into the apartment. Nishad was always busy with work, frequently not coming home until late in the evening, but the four of us always found time to hang out on the weekends. Now that they’re back in San Francisco, we frequently spend time at each other’s respective homes, reminiscent of that period right after college.

One recent night, the four of us were hanging out at Isabel’s and my home in the Mission district of San Francisco. There was a loud crashing sound outside, and Nishad and I went out to investigate. There was a man standing outside a car, and after talking to him, we surmised that he was involved in a hit-and-run accident. The man could only speak broken English. He was obviously distressed, and we helped him out as best we could. I remember afterward, Nishad [ECF p. 168] expressed his concern for the man. We were given the impression that he may have been driving a friend or family member’s car, and that was a major source of worry. “I feel so bad for him. He must be so scared.” I was also concerned, but I don’t think I felt the same degree of empathy as Nishad, who seemed much more subdued the rest of the night.

Nishad has always been one of the most humble, compassionate people I know. I’m glad that we ended up living so close together our freshman year of college, and I count myself lucky to call him my friend.

Stevie Kobori
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number]
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]

[ECF p. 169]

[Letter from Rahul Joshi (College Friend)]

July 28, 2024

Judge Kaplan,

My name is Rahul Joshi. I’m writing this letter, as a friend of Nishad Singh, to share a few examples that I feel highlight Nishad’s character.

Nishad and I have been friends for about 11 years now – we met as freshmen in college. As we shared the same major, we became friends while studying together for our various classes. Even outside of class, we had many shared interests and common friends, so we often hung out over food or board games. Our friendship continued past college, to when we both lived in San Francisco after graduation, and continues to today.

I have always known Nishad to be a kind and thoughtful person. He is friendly and welcoming, even with people he has just met. He is all-in-all a genuine, unpretentious person.

There are a couple memories I have of Nishad that I would like to share:

I remember we had a discussion back in college about veganism, and I asked him about his choice to be vegan. Nishad talked through the well-known arguments around environmental impact and the harsh reality of factory farming. Ultimately, he said the point that resonated most with him was that even if we tried to treat animals well as they are raised for consumption, we can never be sure what suffering they feel throughout the process. For him, the choice was largely based on ensuring his actions didn’t cause additional pain to the livestock animals. What stood out for me was how fundamentally emotional his rationale was – it came from a place of real empathy.

I remember in 2021, during the Pandemic, a few friends set up a call for my birthday. At the time Nishad was in Hong Kong and had been for a while. It had been over a year since we’d talked, due to our busy schedules (on top of the geographic separation). It was rather early in the morning for him when the call was scheduled but he still dialed in to wish me a happy birthday. I was pleasantly surprised to see him on the call. It was a small gesture, but it meant a lot to have a friend take the time to chat, even despite the distance.

Another anecdote that comes to mind, was from a while back when Nishad, a few friends, and I met for dinner. After dinner, we grabbed some boba tea as dessert and started walking back to a friend’s apartment. On the way, Nishad was stopped by a man who asked for something to eat. Nishad offered the man his drink, which the man accepted. I remember this incident, because of how immediately open Nishad was to speak with the man. There wasn’t much hesitation, he spontaneously said ok and asked if the man wanted his drink.

Nishad is among the few friends I have, who embodies an attitude of deliberate introspection of his actions and those actions’ impact on others. I can honestly say that his example has encouraged me to do the same in my life.

I hope these few accounts provide more insight into who I believe Nishad to be.

[ECF p. 170]

Sincerely,

Rahul Joshi

[ECF p. 171]

[Letter from Caley Zheng (College Friend)]

May 15th, 2024

Dear Judge Kaplan,

I am writing this letter to share a little about Nishad, who I have had the privilege of knowing and working closely with in various capacities. We became friends in our college days at Berkeley and have been friends for over 10 years now! Over the years, I have come to admire Nishad's exceptional character, kindness, and unwavering commitment to the well-being of others.

One notable instance that exemplifies Nishad's considerate and caring nature occurred when we were both members of a club, and I was responsible for hosting a significant event. That particular week was incredibly challenging for me, as I was overwhelmed with schoolwork and midterm exams, leaving me flustered and exhausted. Without any prompting, Nishad arrived early at the event to help with the setup, understanding the pressure I was under. He also brought me coffee and food, a gesture that went a long way in lifting my spirits. Nishad stayed through the entire event, ensuring everything ran smoothly, and even assisted with the cleanup afterward. His thoughtful actions and willingness to go above and beyond without being asked highlight his considerate and selfless nature.

In addition to his caring demeanor, Nishad embodies a deep belief in the goodness of humanity and a genuine desire to improve society. This belief is something I have always admired in him. There was a time when I was particularly frustrated with a mutual friend, Nate, who had failed to show up for a meeting and was not contributing to our group project. Venting my frustrations to Nishad, I found not only a sympathetic listener but also someone who encouraged me to see things from a different perspective. Nishad gently reminded me of the other times Nate had been reliable and suggested that there might be underlying reasons for his current behavior. His ability to foster understanding and compassion in situations of conflict is a testament to his belief in the goodness of people and his desire to foster positive relationships.

Nishad's actions and beliefs consistently reflect his character as a considerate, empathetic, and altruistic individual. He not only supports his friends and peers but also inspires them to be more understanding and compassionate. I am confident that Nishad will continue to positively impact those around him and contribute meaningfully to any community he is a part of.

Thank you for considering my perspective on Nishad's character. I wholeheartedly endorse him and his admirable qualities.

Sincerely,
Caley Zheng