Sentencing Letters Submitted on Behalf of Nishad Singh (Exhibit A to the Sentencing Submission), part 10 of 19 (ECF pages 90 to 104)

[ECF p. 90]

[Letter from Debi Binford (Fiancé’s Aunt)]

June 13, 2024

Dear Judge Kaplan,

I am writing to give you my opinion of Nishad Singh.

I am a retired school counselor and at 70 years old, a mother to a young one once again as I raise my five-year-old grandson.

Claire Watanabe, Nishad’s fiancé, is my niece. We see them maybe 2-3 times per year as we are in Kentucky, and they are in California. In all these visits, Nishad has been an exceptionally kind and unassuming young man. He is always very respectful and willing to pitch in for whatever needs to be done.

The second time I saw Nishad was the summer of 2017 at our family’s farm in Indiana. We all stayed at my mother’s small farmhouse that my family built in 1966. As my mom was getting older and less mobile, we’d help with larger home maintenance projects when we’d visit. That year, we decided to tackle cleaning out the nasty, neglected cellar – rot, heaps of dead bugs, you name it, it was there. It was not a pleasant job. We all put on our rubber gloves. Nishad was right there with us. I was rather embarrassed for this to be his impression of us. I said, “You really don’t have to help with this.” His reply was, “Of-course I do” and dove in.

In 2019, my 30 year old daughter, Elizabeth, was diagnosed with incurable brain cancer. It was another farm trip at my mom’s house, one that happened to be my daughter’s last. As the disease progressed it became more difficult for her to do things for herself. At the time of this trip, she was having trouble eating something on her own. The rest of the family was likely playing with my grandson, Elizabeth’s son, in the other room. I came to check on her, and I found Nishad spoon feeding her. No one else was around. No one asked him. He saw the need and stepped up to help. It almost brought me to tears.

This unassuming helpful attitude has remained consistent through the seven years I’ve known him. When he was working for FTX, we knew he were working hard. I didn’t fully understand what they did, but I saw his dedication to making the world a better place. It wasn’t until after the collapse of FTX that we discovered that Nishad had made more money [ECF p. 91] than any of us could imagine. But of course, he wasn’t planning on keeping the vast majority for himself. Either way, I would never have known. From my eyes, Nishad remained the same before, during, and after.

This is a guy who wanted to use his God given intellect and skills to help others. It was heartbreaking to see him after the collapse. The weight he still carries with him almost two years after is immense.

Thank you for your time.

Respectfully,
Debi Binford

[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]

[ECF p. 92]

[Letter from Erick Watanabe (Future Brother-In-Law)]

Erick Watanabe
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number]

8/24/24

Dear Judge Kaplan,

I’m Erick Watanabe, and I’ve known Nishad for over 9 years as my sister’s partner. I want to share some stories about Nishad, or Nishu to me and my family, which I hope demonstrates his caring, hardworking nature, and overall stand up character.

Claire is my sole sibling and baby sister. We’ve always been close, and I’ve been opinionated about whoever Claire chose to date. I gladly took up the protective, no-one-could-ever-be-good-enough-for-her, big brother role. While there were one or two people who passed as acceptable, Nishu has earned my glowing endorsement. There’s not one specific time that made me think this, but it’s all the little interactions that I’ve seen over the years. From being Claire’s dedicated assistant in the kitchen, holding her hand as they walk down an icy road, or just gently checking in with her when she seems a little off. Even as I list these, each individual act does not convey the significance that comes from the consistency of these acts over the course of 9+ years.. Potentially even more notable is that he doesn’t just do this with Claire, but everyone he’s around.

For New Year’s in 2022, my wife Erica, my sisters-in-law, and their partners visited Nishu and Claire in the Bahamas. When we asked what to do on the island, they had no idea—they were always working. The luxury apartment, as nice as it was, didn’t really feel like a home. It felt more like a shared community space with other employees freely coming and going, desks set up in the living room, and board games sprawled across the dining table. Despite its use, Nishu was clearly ashamed of the place. When we marveled at how beautiful it was, he said that it was all too much and felt incongruent with their mission.

We met many of Nishu's colleagues during our visit. They all loved him, praising his work ethic and readiness to help with any problem. It was not uncommon to see him working at 2am or leaving dinner to handle work emergencies. This is just the kind of person he is.

After FTX collapsed and even as Sam Bankman-Fried’s trial was approaching—when Nishu was incredibly busy and emotionally taxed—Nishu still made time to help me transition from academia into software engineering. I’d been teaching physics at Loyola Marymount University, but I was burning out. With Claire’s encouragement, I decided to switch careers, but after months of applying with few interviews, I turned to Nishu for help. Despite everything on his plate, he met with me weekly for over a year, creating a personalized list of practice problems and running mock interviews. His attention to detail and commitment, even in such a difficult time for him, was extraordinary.

[ECF p. 93]

A few months ago, Nishu was volunteering at his regular spot when someone needed help finding medical care. Nishu personally took the man to the hospital. Despite the timing—this was just hours before we were scheduled to meet—he reached out to reschedule, making sure we had a new time set up. I can easily see why Nishad’s former colleagues held him in such high esteem. Yes, his work ethic is incredible, but he really does care about the person he’s helping and remains incredibly considerate of anyone he crosses paths with.

Nishu is honestly one of the best people that I know—caring, intelligent, and dedicated to helping others.

Sincerely,

Erick Watanabe

[ECF p. 94]

[Letter from Erica Djen (Fiancé’s Sister-In-Law)]

August 18, 2024

Dear Judge Kaplan,

I have known Nishad Singh for nine years now. My sister-in-law, Claire Watanabe, is his partner. Since I’ve known him, we’ve been able to go on family trips together, attend music festivals and ski trips, and just sit and talk. He always has thoughtful points to contribute and questions to ask on any topic, but especially about my job as a nurse. He has always been interested in learning about me, my hobbies, and my life. I feel lucky that Nishad has always made me feel like a big sister that he looks up to, even when he was accomplishing so much.

When I first met Nishad, he was an adorably nerdy, idealistic, college student. He was so kind and thoughtful; he was vegan because was anti-factory farming and how it harmed the environment while also treating animals poorly; he did little things to make people happy, like surprising Claire with a flower crown for something like their 5-month anniversary. He also had incredible willpower and was able to race 100-miles multiple times. He spoke about wanting to make a difference, and I remember thinking that he would, and being glad that someone so kind and compassionate had his level of ability.

Throughout the time that Nishad worked at FTX, he was tied to his work and his laptop. On family vacations, he would regularly be up at 4am doing work, in an attempt to be present with us during the day, but he never complained about it. We were able to visit Claire and Nishad in the Bahamas in 2022, and on that trip, we barely saw him because he was working so much. When we asked what to do and where we should go on the island, he had no idea, because in the months that he had been there, he had really only gone to and from the office.

The job was extremely stressful, but that wasn’t the only thing that was starting to make him unhappy. He mentioned several times that he was uncomfortable with the opulence of it all, and that he thought that living in a luxury condo set the wrong tone for the company, and went against their ideals. He also slept on the couch while we were there, which we learned was not out of the ordinary, and was actually out of consideration for Claire, since he would often have to take late-night calls, and didn’t want to disrupt her sleep.

After everything came to light about FTX, Nishad became a shell of himself. The guilt that he felt was so profound, that it was crippling. He didn’t want to go outside, he lost his previously sunny disposition, and all he wanted to do was sleep. He had always said that the goal of working at FTX was to help people, and he was absolutely mortified that the company that he worked so hard for had hurt so many people.

Nishad is still that kind and thoughtful person that I met years ago. I see it in his everyday interactions with the people around him. From taking the time to help my husband with his job search, even when Nishad has been so busy dealing with his own life, to always making sure to always clear the table and wash the dishes after family dinners, to volunteering to run whatever errand anyone asks, Nishad always wants to help.

Nishad is incredibly remorseful about the events that happened at FTX. I truly believe that he is a genuinely good person. I hope this letter can give some positive insights into his character, and that you’ll take this into consideration upon his sentencing.

Sincerely,
Erica Djen
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number]

[ECF p. 95]

[Letter from Brian Moyer (Fiancé’s Extended Family)]

[This page of the PDF is an image. Its text was typed out from the image.]

Brian Moyer
[REDACTED]
Washington, DC 20009
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number]
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]

10th May 2024

Hon. Lewis A. Kaplan
Daniel Patrick Moyniham
United States CourtHouse
500 Pearl Street
New York, New York 10007

Dear Judge Kaplan,

I’m writing to you on behalf of Nishad “Nishu” Singh and his sentence related to his involvement with the collapse of FTX in 2022. I was introduced to him in 2015 and although he’s connected to me through a meandering list of extended family members, I’ve promoted him to brother in-law status.

My wife and I were blessed with our first child, Paxton, in July 2022. Now that we’re past the difficult late nights and grueling feeding schedules we’re getting into the delicate parts of his spongy socialization. I set the best example I can for him, but there are a select few out there that can offer him even more. This is where I look to Nishu because Nishu is everything I want my son Paxton to be.

• Nishu takes the idea of the golden rule and reimagines it as the platinum rule; treating everyone better than he expects to be treated.

• Nishu is the last man standing at a party because he’s cleaning dishes and making sure everyone gets home safely. Nishu asks you questions about the esoteric conversation you had with him last time because he’s genuinely curious.

• Nishu is the guy that makes such a good impression with your own parents they’re constantly asking when they’ll be able to see him again.

Nishu has an ethos radiating from him morning to midnight that lifts our family, our community, and our society. Please take this into consideration during your deliberation.

[ECF p. 96]

Thank you for your time and consideration.

Sincerely,

Brian Moyer

[ECF p. 97]

[Letter from Dennis Whitsitt (Fiancé’s Uncle)]

May 6, 2024

Dear Judge Kaplan,

My name is Dennis Whitsitt. I am an Uncle to Claire and have known Nishad for about ten years. We farm in Indiana and although we have only seen them once or twice a year, I've always been struck by Nishad's curiosity and kindness.

On a visit to the farm, while on a "tour" around the farmstead Nishad had a special interest in the young calves we had in a barn. The other young people wanted to see them, but Nishad wanted to feed one out of his hand even though the mother cow was with the calf. Cattle, as with some other animals, can sense a person's demeanor and intent and they trusted him enough to lick the ground feed in his hand. To a lifelong farmer, this made an impression on me of a "city boy's" first encounter with farm animals.

On another family get together while Nishad was working at FTX we went on a walk and I was able to question him closely about his work. While we had been reading news about the great amount of money being generated by the company, Nishad showed little interest in it. His concern was in making sure that the user interface was functioning and he took that VERY seriously. Even though he was "on vacation" he always had his laptop nearby in case there were problems. He was not "making trades", his job was to make sure the worldwide site worked correctly. His concern was for his co-workers and the customers.

Nishad has never been motivated by money; his concern was always to do his job well, support customers and his team, and donate as much money as he could to charity to make the world a better place.

Sincerely,
Dennis Whitsitt

[ECF p. 98]

[Letter from Gina Djen (Fiancé’s Extended Family)]

May 12, 2024

Dear Judge Kaplan,

Thank you for giving us the opportunity to share with you what a spirited, kind, and selfless man Nishad Singh has been and more importantly still is. My name is Gina Djen and while Nishad is not directly related to me, I would still consider him extended family – my sister is married to Claire Watanabe’s brother. Most of our interactions have been during vacations and holidays, which, in a way, is where you can really get to know a person’s character.

The first time I met Nishad was spring of 2015. We had rented a house in the desert with a large group of family and close friends. Nishad came as Claire’s date and it was the first time he was meeting most of the group. We all quickly grew to love his energy and presence. It happened to be Claire and Nishad’s first anniversary and what most people will remember is the gift he bought her, but what struck me the most was the card he included with the gift. Not only did he write a heartfelt message to her, he also asked everyone in the house to include a message as well. This brought all of us closer together and proved to be a collective memory that we still bring up. It also made Claire extra happy. He really was an addition to the house that weekend that brought so much love. Spirited. Kind. Selfless.

The last time I met Nishad was in April of this year, 9 years later. This time we were at a farm in Indiana with Claire’s family to watch the solar eclipse. I was paired up with Nishad to play a group card game called Nurse. It’s pure chaos – a combination of speed and solitaire, in teams, with multiple decks of cards. Obviously, no one wanted to be paired with the new player and have to explain all the rules, and most likely lose, but he took it like a champ. Teaching is not easy, especially in a fast paced, high stress environment. Nishad was patient and encouraging at all the right moments. Spirited. Kind. Selfless.

It's no secret that it’s been a rough couple years for Nishad. What happened and his role in it has weighed on him heavily and for a while it seemed that he may have lost that spirit, but luckily, with the support of his family and friends, it’s come back. Many of these letters will have the same themes because he is genuinely a kind person. We are fully supportive of him during this difficult time because we know he means well. As long as I’ve known him, he’s also always wanted to leave a positive footprint on the world. It’s in his character to not just care about himself, but all things living. He makes everyone around him happier and wanting to do better. That’s the Nishad that we’ve all grown to love.

Thank you for your time,

Gina Djen
Vertos Medical – Clinical Training
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number]

[ECF p. 99]

[Letter from Lynette Neu (Whitsitt) (Fiancé’s Cousin)]

April 2, 2024

Dear Judge Kaplan,

Today, I write to you in full confidence of the upstanding character of Nishad Singh.

As extended family of Claire, we are grateful to have met Nishad 10 years ago. Our family has always been close. Each Christmas and 4th of July, my grandmother’s eight grandchildren gathered from California, Indiana, and Kentucky to spend the week together on her southern Indiana farm. One family gathering, Claire brought her partner, Nishad, home to the farm. The rest is history. While I can recall a time before Nishad, I cannot recall the specifics of him joining us. Likely, this lack of recollection resulted from him blending in so seamlessly. Nishad always regards all our family members with kindness and patience.

An example of his patience was shown this last summer. In addition to romantic partners, us cousins have also welcomed the addition of multiple “great grandchildren.” In the summer of 2023, many of us were swimming in a lake by my cousin’s home in Kentucky. My eldest niece was 5 years old at the time. I had played with her for a while in the water before resigning to an afternoon of floating in the shade.

Slowly, the other members of the family joined me until only one person was left with my niece: Nishad. He spent the better part of an hour patiently and enthusiastically playing games with her. Now, I cannot recall whether they were dolphins, mermaids, or sharks, but I can still picture the smile plastered on my niece’s face. This example of Nishad’s thoughtfulness is one of many; however, if you have spent time with an energy-filled five-year-old, then you know the pricelessness of this interaction.

Sincerely,

Lynnette Neu, PhD, NCSP

[ECF p. 100]

[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number]

[ECF p. 101]

[Letter from Chad Songer (Fiancé’s Extended Family)]

[This page of the PDF is an image of a handwritten letter. The text below is a reading of the handwriting, and it may be wrong in places. Words that are crossed out are left out. Words are given in their usual spelling, also where the letter spells them differently, and where a word is written over, the likeliest word is given. Two readings are uncertain: the day in “June 1st”, which may be the 15th, and the word “talking”, which may be “talked”. A sentence written at the foot of the page, to the left of the closing and the signature, is given before them.]

July 24, 2024

Hugo C. Songer
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: street address]
Huntingburg, In. 47542

Dear Judge Kaplan:

I am writing about Nishad Singh. I understand he is to be sentenced soon, regarding his involvement in FTX.

I first met him because he is married to my niece, Claire. Since then, he has been to my home and we got acquainted better, and have gotten to know him better. I found him to be an engaging personality and we became friends.

I last saw him at a recent memorial for my wife, who died June 1st. We talking for a few minutes and he expressed sympathy and was very kind.

I’m now a retired attorney and Judge. I understand fully, because I have had to make judgment about people many times. I want to vouch for Nishad as a person and know you will give your best judgment.

If you need to know about me, please Google my name.

Very sincerely

Hugo C. Songer

[ECF p. 102]

[Letter from Julie Songer (Fiancé’s Extended Family)]

[This page of the PDF is an image. Its text was typed out from the image.]

JULIE SONGER

[REDACTED], Bloomington, IN 47401 | [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number] | [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]

July 17, 2024

Re: Nishad Singh

Dear Judge Kaplan,

I am writing regarding Nishad Singh. I am a first cousin of Pam Watanabe. I have known Pam all my life and have known Pam’s daughter, Claire Watanabe, who is engaged to Nishad, since she was born. I have known Nishad since he and Claire started dating in 2015 because they attended many family events in Indiana.

The first time I met Nishad he was playing ping pong in the basement with my kids and other cousins. Nishad was very friendly and easy to talk to. Even though he is highly intelligent and has an elite technical education, he relates well to people from many different backgrounds and educations.

My most recent interaction with Nishad was at my stepmother’s funeral, June 29, 2024, in Indiana. It was very kind of him and Claire to fly from California to Indiana to attend the service and to show their sympathy for our family’s loss. I had a long conversation with him, and he was generous and kind with our family members, young and old, ranging from 3 years old to 91 years old.

Nishad and later, Claire, got involved with FTX because of its emphasis on Effective Altruism. They were sincere in wanting to make a difference in the world with the money they made through FTX. I believe Nishad will continue to devote his talents and generous nature to altruistic causes.

Currently, I write about technology and cybersecurity at Indiana University. Before that, I worked in marketing communications for a defense company, Northrop Grumman, for 13 years. I have an MBA and more than 40 years of experience as a professional communicator.

Nishad has learned a painful lesson from his association with FTX, but I believe he will take that experience and use it for good going forward in his life. Thank you for the opportunity to share my thoughts about Nishad.

Sincerely,

Julie Songer

[ECF p. 103]

[Letter from Janice Guevara (Fiancé’s Family Friend)]

[This page of the PDF is an image. Its text was typed out from the image.]

Janice L. Guevara
[REDACTED]
Long Beach, CA 90807
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number]
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]

August 19, 2024

Re: Nishad Singh

Hello Judge Kaplan,

Thank you for the opportunity to provide my thoughts about Nishad Singh. I am a good friend of Keith and Pam Watanabe. Their daughter, Claire Watanabe, is engaged to Nishad Singh. It is through my friendship with the Watanabe family that I met Nishad Singh.

Nishad would often accompany Claire on her trips to visit her parents. It was on these occasions, from 2016 onwards, that I had a chance to get to know Nishad. I have always found Nishad to be incredibly respectful and humble. As the relationship between Claire and Nishad deepened, the number of times I saw Nishad each year increased. With each interaction, I have been able to get to know Nishad better and my high regard for him has intensified. It has been a pleasure getting to know this bright, kind young man. Nishad’s open and sincere nature enables everyone around him to feel included and relaxed.

In the early stages of FTX’s development, I observed Nishad openly embracing the significant positive attributes of FTX’s Effective Altruism philosophies. Nishad seemed genuinely grateful for the opportunity to make significant positive contributions throughout the world. After the collapse of FTX, the extreme pain and remorse that Nishad felt was evident to everyone around him. It was truly heartbreaking to observe Nishad experience such intense grief and remorse.

I cannot claim to understand the complexities of cryptofinance, but I consider myself to be an excellent judge of character. Prior to my retirement in 2019, I worked for 32 years for the City of Los Angeles, primarily for Los Angeles World Airports, Airport Police Division. As the Commanding Officer for the LAX Security Credential Section, I was entrusted to administer and enforce complex security mandates. At times the process was linear and straightforward but often I was required to apply careful analytical judgement and discernment. I am applying these same skills as I share my thoughts about the personal character of Nishad.

With all that I know and have observed, I continue to consider Nishad Singh to be a person of outstanding character. If I may provide further information, please do not hesitate to contact me. Thank you for this opportunity to share my thoughts about Nishad Singh.

Sincerely,

Janice Guevara

[ECF p. 104]

[Letter from Vivian Djen (Fiancé’s Extended Family)]

April 29, 2024

Dear Judge Kaplan,

I’m lucky to call Nishu Singh part of my family. (I was introduced to him as Nishu, the nickname of his family and friends, so he will always be Nishu to me). I met Nishu through Claire Watanabe, who is my sister’s sister-in-law.

Though we have only seen each other in person a handful of times—as we have lived on different coasts, then in different countries—I know that Nishu is a good, kind, caring person. I recently had a great trip with Nishu to Claire’s family’s farm in Indiana to see the eclipse with her extended family. And during the trip, I couldn’t help by notice all the times Nishu was being Nishu---while everyone else was chatting by the TV, Nishu was washing the dishes and tidying up after almost every meal; when we took a walk outside, he stayed behind to help an older relative down the stairs; when we would see relatives or friends he had not seen for a while, he would ask them what they’ve been up to and get into deep conversations about their lives and interests. I work at a small art museum—a world very different than the one Nishu was in—but he was genuinely interested in my work, showing his curiosity and compassion. He was also so kind and thoughtful about playing with my 18-month old, not complaining one bit that his crying kept him and everyone else up at night.

Nishu is kind and humble. I am certain of this because I know the Watanabe family well, and the Watanabe family is extremely welcoming and warm. The way that they treat him like a family member and deeply care about him, to have helped him through the past few challenging years, is very telling of his character. Even when he could have, he did not buy lavish gifts or extravagant vacations, but focused on doing a good job for his company and helping his family in practical ways. I hope that you will also see Nishu as a smart, creative, and hard-working person who has much to offer society.

Please feel free to reach out to me for further information.

Sincerely,
Vivian Djen
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]