Letters from Extended Family
[Letter from Pam Watanabe (Future Mother-in-law)]
August 9, 2024
Dear Judge Kaplan,
I am writing to offer my wholehearted and heartfelt support regarding the character of Nishad Singh, my daughter’s fiance.
As a mother, my daughter Claire and her brother hold the most sacred place in my heart. Her father and I have strived to instill in them the values of integrity, kindness, and trustworthiness. Fred Rogers' words, "It’s not the honors and prizes of life which ultimately nourish our souls, it’s the knowing that we can be trusted," resonate deeply with me, and I have watched my children grow guided by these principles.
Since 2015, I have had the pleasure of getting to know Nishad. He has consistently demonstrated not only intelligence and capability but also kindness, gentleness, and pure goodness. I have always seen Nishad treat everyone and anyone with respect and warmth, whether they are his co-workers, my friends at church, or a checkout clerk at a grocery store. There are so many instances of Nishad’s caring nature that it’s hard to distill his essence, but one recent instance sticks in my mind. This past summer, Claire and Nishad were visiting when a friend of ours came over, very animated, wanting to share some exciting news. She/he had just finally recognized and accepted that they were nonbinary. This was a newer concept for me, but after celebrating what was so obviously a joyous moment for her, I needed to go upstairs to get dressed for a dinner that evening. When I came down 30 minutes later, I found Nishad on the couch with our friend in a meaningful discussion about finding our true identity and our place in the world. A few days later, our friend told me how helpful the time with Nishad was and how genuinely inquisitive and supportive he is. Our friend was in a vulnerable space, and Nishad showed up for them in such a powerful way.
In November of 2019, Nisahd and Claire met us in Kentucky to attend the funeral of Claire’s thirty-year old cousin. After the funeral, the group of cousins decided to go grab some fast-food and come back to the apartment to eat. As they went out the door I noticed Nishad was taking his backpack. Puzzled, I said: “You are only going to be gone for 30 minutes, you surely don’t need to do any work!” He mentioned something about being available if his team needed help fixing a bug or problem in the system. I never saw him without his backpack over the next three years.
[REDACTED], I found a renewed sense of hope and determination to find a solution before my son’s wedding in the fall of 2020. [REDACTED] After three prior attempts though, our finances were strained. That's when Nishad stepped in. He reached out and told me that he wanted to help pay for whichever program I thought I’d [ECF p. 80] receive the best care. He said how he was just happy to support me in some way. Claire didn’t even know he reached out until the following day.
[REDACTED] extended far beyond my son’s wedding. It means that I have enough energy and strength to travel to see my family. I no longer worry about embarrassing my kids. Most importantly, I’ve been present and fully available for my loved ones – especially Claire, who calls me multiple times a week. I’m grateful beyond belief that she has her mother’s support during this trying time. Without Nishad’s gift, who knows what would have happened, but I continue to give thanks for his support – not just in words, but in action – as I found my way.
In February of 2022, I was excited to visit Claire and Nishad in the Bahamas. I noticed that his normal easy-going and light-hearted personality was replaced with a respectful but exhausted shell. I asked him what was going on. It took some coaxing. It seemed that for every aspect of the company he was proud of, there was another he was frustrated or ashamed by.
He lit up when he talked about the coding team, and he was clearly proud of how the team had grown while remaining familial. But he also talked earnestly about how embarrassed and alone he felt over the amount and kind of spending at the company. He disagreed completely with the choice of buying residences for tens of employees to live in the Albany resort, especially theirs, for example. But he also spoke about how proud he was of the company foundation and its grants to help prevent diseases like COVID19 through policy and new types of vaccines. He shared that some of his philanthropic heroes had recently joined the team and was grateful that seasoned professionals in the space would be thinking about the company’s donation strategy full time now. He was so relieved they were finally getting to what this was all about: donating to great causes (or at least what it was all about for Nishad).
Over the course of the trip, I saw what Claire had described over our phone calls. Nishad left for the office early and came back late, every day. He seemed overwhelmed by the enormity of the job, but still felt resolute because of the good he believed they could achieve. I was torn between feeling proud of him and worried for him. It was clear he was exhausted and lonely.
Six months later, Nishad would learn of the missing customer funds. Eight months later, FTX fell apart. The day after Claire & Nishad came back to the US, they were advised to go to an undisclosed location. Claire relayed that until it was publically understood that Nishad didn’t have access to FTX’s funds, that the two of them could be in danger. They both had already received death threats. When I got to speak with Nishad on the phone, he could only apologize for putting Claire and our family through this. His sense of horror [ECF p. 81] made me fear he might harm himself. I still have trouble thinking of that time. I was terrified. The only thing I knew to do was to keep praying for their safety and wellbeing.
Most thankfully, those prayers were answered, and they made it through those particularly dark times. We spent long periods with them in the months after. Nishad continued to wrestle with himself, and I think always will, but we never doubted his character.
I know he deeply regrets his actions and will never make the same mistakes. It’s been a long road, but I’m so proud of how he found and committed to the things he could do: help the government, find much less demanding work with good people, and rebuild his life with Claire, his family, and home community. I am delighted to officially call him my son soon.
I hope this letter has helped to describe the Nishad I know, a person of exceptional character. Thank you very much for your consideration.
Warm regards,
Pam Watanabe
[Letter from Keith Watanabe (Future Father-in-law)]
September 6, 2024
Judge Kaplan,
My name is Keith Watanabe. My daughter, Claire Watanabe, is currently engaged to Nishad. I’ll share my perspective of Nishad, as my daughter’s chosen person, and much that I’ve observed, over 9 years now.
I worked at Eastman Kodak for 25 years – starting my career in Rochester, NY before moving to Los Angeles, CA where we started our family. One aspect of my work was developing decades-long business relationships. I like to think that I developed the skill of reading people quickly and understanding their true character, which I hope lends some weight to my perspective.
Claire and Nishad’s story begins at University of California, Berkeley. Every University has its own DNA that it injects into their students. For Cal, academic excellence is at its core. Another is ‘changing the world for the better’, rooted in the 1960s counterculture movement. My observation is that both these ideas were woven deeply into both Claire and Nishad’s education, amplifying these already present values.
My first impression of Nishad was: young, very bright, polite, idealistic, capable, and hungry-to-help-the-world – so much of what we want to see in our young people. Most importantly though, he was selected by my daughter whose judgment I trusted. He fully embraced the idea of earning a lot to then give it away. To me, it sounded like an overly grand plan but maybe I was just seeing it through older eyes.
In the days of FTX, I recall Nishad saying, “I’m not the best coder or smartest person but I am a very good employee”. Everywhere Nishad went, there was the ever present backpack. I witnessed his workload evolve from challenging to difficult to near impossible as the FTX ever-growing demands of the 24/7 global marketplace also loomed larger, dominating his life - like a marathon with no end.
Reflecting back on all of this now, the horse in the book Animal Farm comes to mind: “Boxer’s incredible strength, dedication, and loyalty play a key role in the early prosperity of the Animal Farm. Quick to help and devoted to Animal Farm’s ideals. He naïvely trusts the pigs to make all his decisions for him. His two mottoes are ‘I will work harder’ and ‘Napoleon is always right.’”
After the collapse, I could feel the pain and remorse Nishad carried. His regret for what he was complicit in – like the passion that got him into FTX. This seemed extra sad because it was not his nature to be self-serving.
Today, I see Nishad consciously putting his life back together pointed in a dramatically different direction than before. He and Claire live a simpler, more balanced life with consistent work and volunteering. They are blessed with family and lifelong friends who are around to support and guide them along the way. My wife and I are grateful to be spending much more time with Nishad and Claire these days. Some of my favorite moments are the quiet early mornings with Nishad, sipping coffee and chatting with just us two – sometimes for hours – before the day begins. Nishad is returning back to an earlier version of himself but holding those who truly care even closer.
During the days of FTX, it was difficult to predict Nishad and Claire’s future – we didn’t know what country they’d be living in or when they’d start a family. While their immediate future remains in your hands, I see their path afterwards much more clearly now. I envision a tear-filled wedding attended by the dozens of loved ones whose words you’ll read today. I foresee my wife holding Nishad and Claire’s future child in the hospital as I embrace the two of them as new parents. I picture Christmas’ 20 years from now where we continue to fly up to spend it with Nishad’s family, a tradition that was started this past year. I imagine a bright future for them, firmly grounded in their family, closest friendships, and local community—where the seeds they are planting and nurturing today will blossom into things they treasure most in life.
Nishad remains one of the most deeply caring, bright, and gracious people I know. He has long been considered a part of our family, and I truly believe that every day he is able to invest in his new life is a benefit to all those around him. While I fully recognize the gravity of this moment and the seriousness of your decision at hand, I humbly ask that you take this perspective into account as you consider Nishad’s sentencing.
With sincere respect,
Keith Watanabe
[Letter from Bridgette & Evan Schroader (Fiancé’s Cousin)]
Tuesday, September 3, 2024
Dear Judge Kaplan,
I am writing today on behalf of myself and my husband to provide a character witness for Nishad Singh. We first met Nishad approximately 8 years ago at our wedding. Nishad was the “plus one” for my husband’s cousin, Claire. Since then, Nishad has become part of our family, and we consider him a friend as well as cousin. We’d like to share a few stories about Nishad that exemplify his commitment to family as an extension of the compassion and kindness we believe defines Nishad as a person.
In my husband’s family, there are 8 total cousins. As someone who grew up with 35 cousins, the size of his family felt more like the size of an immediate family. And similarly, they act like one. Entering such a close-knit set of cousins (ie, best friends) is an intimidating experience. When we invited Nishad to our wedding as the first time he would meet “the family”, I truly did not expect him to come. The wedding was well across the country and not a small financial commitment for then college students. However, Nishad understood the importance of family and the unique bond between the cousins, and he leaned in and showed up. We had a great time getting to know Nishad that weekend, bringing him into the fold, and celebrating.
After that, Nishad became a staple at family gatherings. Between outings at the family farm in southern Indiana and making sure to see Nishad and Claire whenever we were in California, we became closer with Nishad over time. Some memories that stick out distinctly are Nishad’s early trips to the family farm and his willingness to join in on farm or house work, no matter how unglamorous. Despite the fact that Nishad was a guest of Claire, his devotion to her and his kindness for others frequently found him as the resident late night snack chef or the designated dish do-er. No one ever asked Nishad to do these things, but he volunteered because he wanted to contribute to the group and enjoyed caring for others.
I specifically remember when one of my sisters had moved to San Francisco, where Nishad was currently living. First, Nishad and Claire made sure I knew they were around to take care of my little sister if anything came up – a huge relief for a big sister living in Kentucky. When my other sisters, my dad, and my husband and I were planning a trip, we reached out to Nishad and Claire to see if they wanted to meet up with my husband and me. Of course they did, but more than that, they invited my entire family out to share a meal. Truly, as my husband’s blood cousin, Claire had little responsibility to see my side of the family and even less so Nishad. But again, their core values include prioritizing family, showing up, and building relationships. Nishad went out of his way to make sure to choose a restaurant that had a wide variety of pescatarian options, as I had casually mentioned my dad’s dietary habits and Nishad made sure to accommodate as part of his planning.
Over the years, we certainly felt like Nishad and Claire were great life partners and were anxiously awaiting the phone call that they were taking the next steps to get engaged. True to form, Nishad made sure that Claire’s family was included in the engagement. He wrote a beautiful letter to friends and family explaining his love for Claire, reflecting on their relationship and how he came to decide to propose, as well as outline his plan for the proposal. When the day arrived, he kept us all in the loop by sending out heartwarming updates and calling upon us to shower Claire with text messages right after she said ‘yes!’. We loved the way he included us in their momentous occasion. It was a perfect reflection of how he not only understands Claire and her relationship with family, but also fits so naturally into it.
What I personally enjoy most about Nishad is his calming presence and passion for the pursuit of knowledge. As an introvert prone to panic attacks, Nishad is one of the few people I am never worried about spending time with because he is quiet, calm, empathetic, and asks insightful questions. I’ve enjoyed competing for best time in the daily NYT Mini crosswords from across the country as well as in person discussions about his thoughts on a huge variety of topics. It was during these discussions that I came to understand Nishad’s drive to consciously guide his career towards doing good…and no, I don’t mean doing well – I truly mean doing good. This was a clear reflection of the open-minded, dedicated, and mildly naïve spirit that guides Nishad in all aspects of his life. From the time we first had these conversations while he was in college through his time at FTX, his spirit and purpose had remained unchanged.
There are no words to express the sadness and devastation we have all experienced during this time. Seeing Nishad after the collapse was heart breaking because he was the same caring soul we had known all along, but now plagued by shame. There was never a doubt in our mind that we would be there for him and Claire as they reckoned and rebuilt. In their most recent visit with us this summer, we were all able to breathe a small sigh of relief as we began to see Nishad’s spirit re-emerging. He rolled around with the kindergarteners and braided their hair (and let them braid his hair), coded (and updated in real time!) a collaborative word game we played for hours, and cemented his tradition of doing crosswords projected on the TV as a family. It’s important to note he started this tradition because he noticed one of the matriarchs of the family didn’t have a lot of activities tailored to her interests, but Nishad knew she loved crosswords and made sure to incorporate them so she would have a family activity to participate in and look forward to.
While the examples above are certainly small examples and perhaps may be considered insignificant by some, I think the little things add up to the big things and it is in someone’s everyday actions where their character can truly be found. As a board-certified oncology pharmacist, I have spent much of my career with patients at the end of their life or facing the uncertainty of a prognosis and have truly seen the best and worst of humanity. I believe that Nishad is firmly in the “best” category – he is kind, compassionate, and dedicated to his family.
To know him is to love him.
We would be happy to provide any additional details or answer any questions you may have. Thank you in advance for your time and consideration of our character witness.
Best,
Bridgette Schroader, PharmD, MPA, BCOP ([WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address])
Evan Schroader, PE ([WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address])
[Letter from Ellie Schroader (Fiancé’s Cousin)]
September 18, 2024
Dear Judge Kaplan,
I am writing to attest to the resounding character of my friend and future family member, Nishad Singh. My name is Ellory Schroader, and I am a Registered Nurse residing in Lexington, Kentucky. Nurses have been consistently recognized as the most compassionate and trusting of people, yet, everyday over the past eight years, I have been inspired by the generosity, authenticity, and humility of Nishu. In every capacity, Nishu exudes a strong sense of morals and displays tremendous amounts of love for those around him.
For some background, I first met Nishu through my cousin Claire. Nishu and Claire are now engaged, and, although we are not officially family, I have considered him as an integral part of mine for years.
Some of my favorite times with Nishu have been at our biannual family reunions. My memories always include him toting his work backpack around everywhere. For years! It wasn’t uncommon to see him coding away at the most ungodly hours in the middle of the night. Despite the demands of his job, he always strived to be present for important family activities. This dedication to his work and family is a testament to his discipline and commitment to making a true difference in the world, big and small. I recall asking Claire how she felt about his work/life balance in the earlier years of FTX, and she was often torn. She wanted to spend more of him, but she knew he felt a strong sense of responsibility to do everything he could to leave the world a better place than how he found it. Claire, myself, and most everyone around him saw his potential to do exactly that.
When I first met Nishu, my impression was, “Wow, this guy is really interested in my thoughts and opinions and seems genuinely engaged.” He’s always been curious about my job and consistently expresses deep respect for my career choice. He’ll ask, “Gosh, this probably isn’t even the right way to phrase this question, but do you know how (insert something about neurology) works?” I respond with what I know, and we’d dive into a 10-15 minute discussion, eventually huddled over a phone looking up articles because we’ve reached the depths of our understanding. This interaction, spanning various medical topics, happens every time I see him. He’s the only non-medical professional with whom I can “nerd out” over modern medicine—fueled by his inquisitive mind and genuine interest in me and my work. Nishu has a knack for making others feel welcome and valued, always eager to understand the passions that drive those around him.
In 2022, I visited the Bahamas to advise Claire and her operations team on an emergency medical protocol for FTX’s employees. I was excited for the opportunity to see Nishu and Claire and meet their community. I assumed they were close friends with their six other housemates, including Sam and others, but I was surprised to find that Nishu wasn’t particularly close, nor felt totally comfortable, with anyone except two of the engineers (Adam and Andrea). When I joined them for a meal at the penthouse apartment, I felt like a fish out of water amidst the highly rational, heady conversations and fast-paced logic games. The group there mostly ignored me, the new person. The environment didn’t match what I knew of Nishu and Claire, who are deeply caring, warm, and easygoing souls. Nishu, in particular, [ECF p. 87] ensures everyone feels part of the conversation, often taking the time to bring others up to speed in social settings.
I remember worrying about whether Nishu and Claire could be themselves in that environment. Later in the trip, I saw Nishu with some of his engineering team—it was then I felt relieved. With them, he was clearly at home: he was relaxed, cracking jokes, and smiling. I was glad to see there was a place where he felt comfortable.
As someone who loves both Nishu and Claire deeply, witnessing the fallout of FTX’s collapse has been heartbreaking. I know in my core that Nishu was never in it for self-enrichment; his genuine intention was always to help people and make a positive impact. He carries with him every day the knowledge that the exact opposite happened. Through our family gatherings and my visits, I can tell Nishu continues to harbor a deep sense of remorse for his role in what happened.
In conclusion, Nishu’s presence enriches all of our lives. I sincerely hope this letter conveys the depth of my respect and admiration for him. He inspires me to strive for goodness in the world, and I am beyond grateful to have him in my life.
Thank you for considering my perspective.
Sincerely,
Ellory Schroader
[Letter from Jacob Whitsitt (Fiancé’s Cousin)]
4/4/2024
Dear Judge Kaplan,
I am a family friend of Nishad and I am the first cousin to his fiancé, Claire. As such I have had the pleasure of knowing Nishad since before he joined FTX. Through all of this Nishad has been an extremely kind and caring individual.
Since 2020, our extended family has held a family reunion at another cousin’s house in Kentucky. Nishad joined us for most of these events despite his demanding FTX workload. During these gatherings Nishad has always been unassuming and Kind. Then and to this day, he’s the first to sleep in the least desirable area. One year it was on an air mattress in an unfinished room, and others it was a RV travel trailer behind the house; he never requested or indicated interest in having one of the 3 private bedrooms or the 4th private converted room. He’s consistently the first person to offer his seat at the overcrowded breakfast table and can always be found doing the dishes after a meal. His only request was for access to the internet to support the FTX site in case of emergency.
Spending time with Nishad each summer has highlighted one thing over and over; his overwhelming kindness. He’s engaging and gentle with the children, who are now between ages two and six. They tug at him to play, and he happily obliges, pretending to be a shark or train conductor or whatever else the moment calls. One of the most common places to find Nishad is sitting on the ground playing with the 5 children (all 6 or younger). One of the favorite family videos of Nishad was him playing Rock Paper Scissors with my oldest daughter, 5 at the time.
He’s not just great with the kids. Nishad engages our parents in discussion in a way I think they’re often not used to: he’s curious about their lives in a playful and encouraging way. Discussions with Nishad reliably get to the heart of something meaningful or interesting. Normally I’d be worried that my dad would bore people half to death with stories about the farm, but Nishad has an endless appetite for hearing about it. In the mornings, my dad seizes on the first chance to talk and hang out with Nishad before anyone else can.
In addition to his unassuming and kind nature, it is necessary that I highlight the utmost remorse Nishad demonstrated this past summer. July was the first time that our extended family had connected directly with Nishad since he left the Bahamas. During this family gathering Nishad requested a time to address the adults in the family. He apologized profusely about the ordeal, and accepted full responsibility for what he had done. He said that he would have understood if we’d advised Claire to leave him, but was so grateful for the love and support he’s felt from us instead. Because of whom we know him to be, advising Claire to leave was something none of us had even considered.
Nishad has been and will always continue to be a cherished member for our extended family. This is due to the wonderful person that Nishad is; kind, thoughtful, selfless, and engaging; if one was able to see the way my two young daughters look at him when playing there would be no doubt of Nishad’s character.
Thank you for your time.
Sincerely,
Jacob Whitsitt
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number]