[Letter from Anonymous (Post-FTX Friend)]
29th September 2024
Dear Judge Kaplan,
I am writing to request compassion and leniency in the sentencing of Nishad Singh. I apologize for writing my letter anonymously. I am concerned about the impact publicly disclosing the severity of my partner’s mental health struggles may have on their career. Thank you so much for your understanding. I have been friends with Nishad’s fiance Claire for four years. Over the last two years, I have become increasingly close with Nishad to the point where he is one of my best friends.
Nishad is truly one of the kindest people I have ever met. Despite being in a period of absolute crisis himself, Nishad has been profoundly supportive of me as I navigated the depression and suicidality of my husband. Of all of my friends and family, he has been one of the most consistent forms of support. Unprompted, he checked in on us, bought us home-cooked food, looked after our dogs, and cheered us along with pictures of his dogs Gopher and Moose. Over a tough holiday season, Nishad dropped by unannounced with food, dressed his dog up as a tiger for Halloween, and helped me hand sweets to the children in our neighborhood.
Nishad is an integral part of the lives of so many people around him and brings so much joy and support to their lives. There are so many small examples of this that seem silly but capture how amazing he is to the people around him; him helping me run my first ultramarathon, him abandoning the brunch he’d talked about constantly looking forward to the morning after the run to take a call from his mum who was upset, him staying at my house when my husband had a period of suicidality and insisting it would be “so great for him to get to spend time with us and get some work done!” We call this “doing a Nishad” where he wants to help but doesn’t want you to feel bad so pretends it’s actually you doing him a favor.
Nishad is in the unusual and very lucky position of having a family and community of peers who love him but will hold him accountable. He has a wonderful fiance, two dogs who he adores, a family who loves him, and a huge amount of potential to learn from his mistakes and positively contribute to the world. Nishad has started doing the hard work of forging a life he can be proud of that serves others. One of the first things Nishad did was to start volunteering at a San Francisco homeless shelter. For the last year, he has handed out warm drinks and directed people to support services.
I deeply understand, myself not coming from the background that Nishad has, that some people are immensely angry at him for having opportunities that we didn’t, throwing them away, and hurting others in the process. It would be easy to treat him like a caricature – reckless and unapologetic – but it just wouldn’t be accurate. He’s wracked with remorse, knows how badly he messed up and desperately wants to make amends. He has already started and I am certain that there is a possible outcome that sees Nishad learn from his mistakes, become an upstanding leader in his community, and use his potential for good. Sincerely thank you for considering affording him with that chance.
Warmest Regards,
Letters from Family Friends
[Letter from Rattan Gujadhur (Family Friend)]
Quatre Bornes
Republic of Mauritius
Date: 3/18/24
Character Letter in Support of Nishad Singh
Dear Judge Kaplan
I am writing to say a few words in support of Nishad Singh. Let me please briefly introduce myself to explain my relationship with Nishad. I am an executive in the biotechnology industry in the USA where I have worked for over 25 years. I have published many well cited publications and have a commercial patent under my name for the discovery of a copper (i) soluble organic catalyst. This catalyst is commonly used in industry to manufacture early-stage raw materials. I am also the CEO of a government run institute of biotechnology in Mauritius wherein we are trying to spearhead the sector regionally in Africa for the wellbeing of the country and region.
I have been married since 1995 and have two sons, aged 24 and 27. In 2015/2016, I went through a brief episode of massive depression, chronic anxiety, and mental health instability. My marriage quickly fell apart, and I literally became a homeless person overnight, not because of dire financial consequences, but mainly because of this temporary unexplained mental state event. I was unable to interact in any social setting and had to be on multiple anti-depression drugs to get back a sense of normality.
By chance in early 2018, I applied for and ended up renting a room at the home of Nishad`s mother. Living at Nishad’s house was that oasis which I was yearning for all through these difficult years. I recalled being very surprised at the early onset the Singh family instantly considered me as a family member. I would be invited to partake of food together, and invited to social gatherings, as if I was this long-lost family member. This set up gave me confidence in myself, and slowly I seem, to be regaining my mental balance and composure. Since then, I have progressed professionally and am actively helping my family, whom I put through such unnecessary difficult times.
It was during my time living at the Singh household, that I developed a close friendship with Nishad. I recalled being instantly drawn to his natural compassionate sense of self and loving kindness. Having been attracted to Buddhism all my life and knowing well of the Buddha`s edicts that ‘humanity’, ‘kindness’ and ‘compassion’ are the ultimate values to seek, being the very hallmarks of well-developed beings on their way to liberation, I was instantly drawn to Nishad. This feeling that Nishad exuded drew me to him. In family gatherings, or on walks I would unabashedly talk to him (and often bore him too) about my countless life troubles, and in these moments, it felt like, he was the 50-year-old and I was the 25 year old. He was a graceful listener, and always lent his support to me one way or the other, but mostly it was his constant kind words that entered my heart.
At large family gatherings, he would take instant notice of me, and since he knew I was shy, and he would purposely come and talk to me. We bonded over our shared curiosity in public health science. He’d ask me for my thoughts on interventions that might be as promising as deworming and about details of early pathogen detection systems in airplanes. His interest was in equal parts scientific and spiritual.
One day, when I was walking out of their house, to drive to Davis, I realized I had left my car engine on all through the night. Of course, the battery had died, and as Nishad was walking out behind me, he noticed the situation and instead of saying ‘let me help you charge your battery’, he said unhesitatingly, ‘ here take my car if you need to drive to Davis’. I was stunned by this incredible instantaneous kindness. I did not take his car but insisted that he help me charge mine, as I was going to be gone for a few days. In the car I tried to understand this sort of natural kindness that flowed out of him.
Being an amateur spiritual aspirant, I recalled telling myself, ‘wow I can bloody meditate all I want for years on end, but beauty and divinity is actually present in simple humanity and kindness’. Some seem to be born with it, and to me Nishad is one of those chaps. This is the true picture of this young man that I hold dear to my heart. What I wanted to end with, about Nishad, is a verse we Hindus recite everyday, from the Bhagavad-Gita, a very old Hindu scripture. To me Nishad`s behavior, and demeanor is very much as described in this 5000 year old verse, first penned in Sanskrit.
The karm yogis, who are of purified intellect, and who control the mind and senses, see the Soul of all souls in every living being. Though performing all kinds of actions, they are never entangled. BG 5.7
Your honor, thank you for your kind attention
Rattan Gujadhur
VP, Head of CMC
BlueJay Therapeutics, Inc.
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: street address]
San Mateo, CA 94404
Cell: [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number]
[Letter from Wynn Anderson (Family Friend)]
September 9, 2024
Dear Judge Kaplan,
Let me begin by giving some context. I met Nishad Singh when he joined our elementary school as the youngest child in the third grade and he was assigned to be our buddy family. Over the past 20 years, he has been the best of friends to my youngest son, and a cherished staple of my life. I have found him to be one of the kindest, most thoughtful and compassionate individuals I've ever met. This opinion is widely shared by countless people in our community. He has earned this reputation by his gentle heart, generous spirit, kind acts, and devotion to fairness. He is invariably the one to volunteer to take the worst seat in a car or to sleep on the floor when there are not enough beds or to hop up to help. This characteristic hasn't changed from elementary school to high school, college, and when he spent time with us during his years at FTX.
There have been many times that I have seen him reach out to someone who is struggling, to support them emotionally with a willingness to listen, a word of encouragement or in more concrete ways in acts of service. When my son had a major surgery, Nishad visited him in the ICU and then for many days after, he came just to sit quietly to keep him company as he recovered. Or, the times that he worked into the wee hours helping a friend of a friend to prepare for an interview. I recall his dedication about helping other young people with asthma. His heart is big and he has tremendous empathy for others. Giving and making a difference has been important to him from an early age. This is really who he is and what he believes in.
Nishad has always been humble and doesn't seek attention. Even with our frequent contact during these few post-college years, I didn't know how successful he was at that time. He would come to visit me, bring tea, give a long hug, and ask only about how we were doing, etc. He was not into power, accolades or prestige. As busy as those days were for him, he would find time to call to see how things were going in my life. This is not unusual for him, he has shared the same care and compassion for so many others that he has crossed paths with. He has always been willing to go the extra mile.
As is so often true in human nature, our best individual attributes cause problems if taken too far. I believe Nishad's sincere drive to help and be of service contributed to the serious choices and mistakes that he made at FTX. He is trusting, earnest and motivated to please, which I believe can make him vulnerable to manipulation by others. This observation is no way meant to excuse him from his actions, it only helps to understand how someone so caring could have gone so awry. His young age, naivety, and trusting nature also played a part. I know that understanding does not change the fact that he was and is accountable for his actions.
Over the last two years Nishad has been consumed by guilt and shame by his actions. I met with him during a particularly dark time in early 2023 and he had no thought or [ECF p. 189] conversation about the impact this would have on him or his life, instead he spoke of the pain and loss experienced by the many people that placed their trust in him and FTX.
As we spoke I came to understand and feel his deep disappointment in himself for what he failed to do in those final two months after he became aware of the theft of funds. The current situation and memory of it all was almost too much for him to bear, that he had a hand in causing that suffering. Although I met with him as a friend, as an experienced psychotherapist, there was no doubt that Nishad's devastation by the harm he caused to others was authentic. It was not that he "got caught", he was sincerely horrified and ashamed at his role. He did not see a way forward to live with himself, it was so at odds with his values and intentions. I was very concerned that he would end his life and I appealed to his deep drive to make amends....he couldn't try to make it up in some way if he wasn't here.
Although it may sound odd considering the seriousness of the charges, Nishad’s mistakes are not reflective of who he is as a person, and with the lessons learned from this tragedy, are certainly not reflective of how he’ll behave going forward. Nishad is kind and cares deeply about others and doing the right thing for others. I know that he is truly remorseful and deeply regrets his actions. I have no doubt that he will use this experience to refocus his service to others and live a life with integrity.
W. D. Anderson
[Letter from Rajeev Char (Family Friend)]
Dear Judge Kaplan,
I have known Nishad since 2005 (he was around 8-9 years old). He has always been a caring, bright, funny and wonderful person.
A couple of anecdotes come to mind. Once - sometime around 2005/2006 my wife and I were looking after Nishad and his brother one evening as his parents had an event to attend. As we settled into their home that evening, Nishad came up to my wife and asked her if we needed anything and if she was comfortable! He said he could bring us blankets if we were cold or could point us to where the snacks were. We both could not stop smiling at this kid (he was all of 9 years old).
Another time, this was a few years later. Nishad used to play the drums and I remember that I wanted to sing a song during one of the many get-togethers (adults and their kids) we had at his place.
To preface; A) I'm a bad singer and, B) I have no sense of musical timing. For almost an hour Nishad humored me as I messed up his rhythm and started on the wrong beat! All the while he said, 'you almost got it this time, Rajeev uncle!' Hilarious! But it is a testament to his patience and being kind. I wish I had that kind of patience even now!
He has always been a bright kid and always persevered and put in 100% into everything he did. We have kept in touch with him as he blossomed into an adult. He kept and even enhanced the attributes he had as a kid; kind, generous, giving, sensitive, funny, extremely focused and hardworking. We've been out camping together - taking hikes in the wilderness and we've laughed as he bantered and traded jokes with us. He is a joy to be around, quick witted and easy to talk to on just about any subject.
When the news about FTX broke, my wife and I were on holiday. Our first reaction was shock and an immediate concern for Nishad. Knowing how sensitive he is and his overarching endeavor to do good, we were really worried about how he would cope with rectifying his mistakes. We did finally meet him when he was back home and, immediately, we could see a change in his demeanor. The weight of the situation had taken a serious toll on him. Knowing him as we do, our hearts went out to him. We love and deeply care about Nishad and it is our fervent hope that this compassionate, unassuming, funny and sensitive young man is able to harness his full potential in life.
Best regards,
Rajeev Char
July 2, 2024
[Letter from Arun Simha (Family Friend)]
March 26, 2024
Dear Judge Kaplan,
As a family friend of Nishad’s parents since 2002, I have seen him grow up from being an elementary school kid to becoming a young man. Through this journey, I have observed that his inherent empathetic nature has remained consistent.
This was highlighted in an email he sent me on March 28, 2013. He wrote that he was accepted into the College of Engineering (EECS) at U.C. Berkeley, and was also granted the Regents Scholarship. He also added in the last paragraph of the email, “I'd appreciate it if you could keep this information to yourselves - there is a large amount of angst among families and students hearing back from colleges.”
This was classic Nishad, always thinking about his friends and their well being. Despite this stellar achievement, he ensured that his parents and family friends never made any social media posts to understandably brag about the news.
He has always been a very soft, caring, tender-hearted person. Intellectually curious and humane at the same time, quite a rare quality. While participating in the model UN, he was curious about the elections in Kenya and their effect on future public policy outcomes. During the model UN conference at Harvard in 2011, The organizer commented that while other delegates were frustrated at the competitive nature of the event and how their allotted speaking times were so short, “Nishad in the 123rd Olympic committee is a natural and a very experienced delegate. He seems right at home.”
He ran many ultra distances on his way to completing the 100 mile race in 2011 to raise funds for the Allergy and Asthma Foundation since he was himself suffering from the ailment. While doing so, he also raised funds for Asha for Education (for his 50 mile run).
Last month, during a brief conversation about books that we had read recently, he mentioned that he loved Brian Greene’s ‘Fabric of the Cosmos’. I mentioned that I had not read it. A day or two later, I found in my email that ebook gifted from him!
He has always been a people person, conversing smoothly with adults and talking to young kids at their level. Always respectful towards his elders and compassionate towards young people, [ECF p. 192] including my children. He has very kindly indulged in conversations with them while kids his age would ignore them!
He is a very sensitive man and I do hope and pray that he comes out of this challenging time and continues to contribute positively to society as he has done since a very young age.
My background: Arun Simha, Senior Manager, Product Management at a tech company in the Bay Area. I met Nishad’s parents while volunteering for a non-profit in 2002 and have been friends since.
Please feel free to contact me should you need any clarifications at
Arun K. Simha
[REDACTED]
Los Gatos, CA - 95032
Phone: [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number]
Email: [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]
Yours sincerely,
Arun Simha
[Letter from Indira Almedia (Family Friend)]
Date: March 30, 2024
Re: Our journey together with Nishad
Dear Judge Kaplan,
I am writing to you to share my cherished life experience with Nishad Singh who is my beloved nephew. I have known Nishad throughout his life, watching him grow from early childhood to an adult at various memorable life stages and moments.
Even at an early age Nishad showed uncharacteristic compassion for his friends, even strangers and animals. He fought for, often cried, and made a case with his parents and aunts, whenever he perceived unfairness and pain in others. He looked out for one of my nephews, Suraj, who was autistic and who was often bullied by other kids by choosing to play with him separately, often in silence. He was especially attentive to one of his pet dog, Simba who tended to be extremely ill with seizures, making sure that he never missed out on walks and play. He mirrored the pain of his playmates and was often so distraught in his experience for another’s pain that we would wonder about how a child at such a tender age could feel so much—was it even normal?
When Nishad was five, we moved back to India from our home in the Bay Area due to our job responsibilities. Nishad was devastated at the thought of being so far away from us, especially his cousin. He channeled his pain by sitting for days on a project to make a small wooden table that he hand assembled, painted and dedicated to his cousin. We still carry that table as a memento of his innocent love and the vast emotional intelligence that a child potentially holds.
He came home from school sharing his joys of music and art. Sometimes he would from an incident he witnessed wanting a discussion with family adults to understand how he/we can help. Some of his friends were kids that no one wanted to hang out with-he brought them home for sleepovers and I would watch them play together in close communion. He recognized his own vulnerability and pain sometimes and reached out from that place— silent and present in beingness.
Even as a young adult he held the same values and character traits, never afraid to reach out to his friends or even strangers. I was out on a college tour with him and a few kids from our family. During the weeklong trip, Nishad made us stop whenever we saw an unhoused person asking for help. We would donate money or buy food for them upon his insistence. He used to be so distressed seeing this that he would sob when he felt he couldn’t do more. He made an unwavering commitment to veganism during his adolescent years despite relishing chicken made by his uncle (my husband Eddy). These were never [ECF p. 194] one-off acts of compassion but his characteristically deep and sustained commitment to living a compassionate life in myriad ways. He carries these experiences deep within himself and this was the basis of all that he strove to do through his work and community engagements.
Thank you for your attention and this opportunity to share my life experience of my beloved Nishad. These are challenging times for him, but we are confident in his goodness, strength and ability to accept life as it unfolds—we stand by him in love and faith.
Sincerely,
Indira Iyer Almeida
Aunt/mother/Engineering Consultant- Chip design
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number]
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]
[Letter from Shishir Ramam (Family Friend)]
June 24, 2024
Dear Judge Kaplan,
I have known Nishad since he was about 7 years old.
Over the years watching him grow up, on multiple occasions, I found myself awestruck with the kindness, humility and determination he exhibited. I’d like to share a couple of these memories which I believe are indicative of his character in an unalienable manner.
In the first instance, Nishad was about 8-9 years old. At a family gathering, a group of kids were sitting at a table for dinner. Nishad was among the oldest. I was the only adult at the table, along with my then toddler son.
Some of the other kids at the table started to tease Shaunak, the youngest kid at the table. Shaunak was having a hard time with it. Nishad stepped up to put a stop to the teasing, comforted Shaunak. Peace was restored and dinner carried on.
Nishad exhibited a capacity for kindness and empathy at that early age. This was particularly striking for it being contrarian to how many children behave. Importantly, his peer group recognised and respected how he treated others.
A few years later, I had a chance to work briefly with Nishad when he was an undergraduate at UC Berkeley and interned with us at Shape Security. Nishad was a Regents scholar at UC Berkeley - basically, in a highly competitive environment, he was leading the pack.
Given his young age, and his credentials, I would have forgiven him any hubris. However, counter to that thought, over the summer Nishad consistently exhibited a refreshing humility and openness to learn from others. He asked insightful questions, listened respectfully and was a quick-study to boot!
Over my career, I have mentored and guided many youngsters. Nishad was the first one that I had seen grow up. It was very heartening to see that he seemed motivated by knowledge and intellectual growth, as opposed to material gain.
Additionally Nishad always struck me as one of the kindest and most generous of people I’ve met - even across generations. He was fair, thought for himself and followed through on the conclusions of that thought. I think the backstory of why he is vegan is a perfect illustration of this. He was very young - around 10 years old, if I recall correctly - and for the first time he realized that eating meat implied an animal had to be killed. He found that wrong, decided to stop eating meat and has stuck with that decision to this day. I am a generation ahead of him, but human to human, time after time, his words and deeds from a very young age have earned my respect.
I am confident that you will receive many more anecdotes and testaments of Nishad’s character, many of which I would also attest to. I picked a few that were particularly personal to me and pertinent in this instance.
Best Regards,
-Shishir Ramam
[Letter from Renuka Char (Family Friend)]
Dear Judge Kaplan,
My husband and I are friends of Nishad’s parents and it was through them that I first met Nishad in 2005. In the years since, I’ve watched him mature from a reserved & sensitive boy into the intelligent, kind, thoughtful, empathetic, and caring person he is today.
I recall a time when he was a young boy (about 11 years old). It was the start of a forecasted summer heat wave. Nishad heard my husband & I mention that it would be a rough few days as our apartment didn’t have air conditioning. Even as a child, he was immediately concerned for our wellbeing and wanted us to come and stay at his house till the heat wave had passed. He was even more concerned for the elderly relative who was visiting us at that time and wanted to ensure that she was comfortable!
Those who know him well know that this caring attitude and concern for the wellbeing of others are qualities that Nishad has hardwired within him even today.
Over the years, I have had the opportunity to observe, up close, his interactions with both adults & his peer group. Nishad was, and is, always ready with words of encouragement and support when someone undertakes a new challenge, be it training for a marathon or dabbling in a new hobby.
When he was training for his first 100 mile race, the love & admiration that he inspired could be seen in the sheer number of his friends and family that came out to run with him and support him in any capacity they could.
His ability to reach so many through his genuine concern and compassion for everyone in his orbit is, to me, what makes him who he is - a wonderful human being!
Best Regards,
Renuka Char
Phone: [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number]
Email : [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]
July 2, 2024
[Letter from Lily Patel (Family Friend)]
3/4/24
Dear Judge Kaplan,
I am Dr. Lily Patil, and I am Nishad Singh’s parents' friend. I have known Nishad since 2005.
Back in 2006, I was going through a very painful time in my life when my engagement ended. I visited Nishad‘s parents, who were advising me not to be by myself when I was feeling so low, when Nishad, listening in on our conversation. said “why shouldn’t Lily Aunty come and stay with us?” and offered his bedroom for me to stay in .
That following evening, I was overwhelmed with sadness and I was having a breakdown when Nishad came to his room to get something and saw me crying. He must’ve been all of 10 or 11 years old, and he immediately wanted to help me instead of feeling awkward and withdrawing away. He hugged me and said it’ll be okay Lily Aunty, ran downstairs, got me a glass of water to drink and pulled along his dogs in an attempt to cheer me up. He hovered around checking on me till his parents got back home.
I will never forget the kindness, compassion and emotional intelligence that a child his age showed in consoling me.
Nishad has been that person through all these years that I have known him with so many people and in so many ways.
Lily Patil