[Letter from Amrit Singh (Cousin)]
15/06/2024
Dear Judge Kaplan,
My name is Amrit Singh Rana, and I am writing to you regarding my cousin, Nishad Singh.
I know Nishad as someone who has always demonstrated tremendous kindness towards the people around him. He goes out of his way to make people feel welcomed and supported. I experienced this when I moved to the United States for college. I was living with my uncle, Nishad’s father during the winter break. During that time, Nishad visited us and took me around the town. We went bouldering and had lunch with his friends from college who were also incredibly warm and welcoming. These gestures made me feel at home in a new country and eased my homesickness. He consistently extends this warmth to everyone he meets.
I respectfully ask that you take into account Nishad’s longstanding history of positive contributions and strong moral character. I believe he will continue being a valuable member of the community.
Thank you for taking the time to read my letter.
Sincerely,
Amrit Singh Rana
Letters from Friends
Letters from Childhood Friends
[Letter from Connor Hegarty (Elementary School Friend)]
May 3, 2024
Judge Kaplan,
It's been my pleasure to have known Nishad for over two decades now. We met on the first day of second grade, when he arrived as a new student at our school. I would like to say that he was immediately accepted among his peers, but unfortunately, kids are not always so kind and accepting. Nishad was a bit awkward, a bit of an outsider to our insular group of 37 students that had been together for 3 years already, and it wasn’t until we were 10 or 11 that I began to see him as a real friend, a peer amongst us.
He integrated himself into our group of friends by demonstrating persistence, showing kindness, and meeting us where we were. I think of the first time I went over to his house, and how even at a young age, he played the role of host with grace. While we all played video games and ate snacks, I remember him attending to everyone, making sure they were comfortable, making sure they ate before he did, taking the worst sleeping bag for himself. We played a James Bond game on his GameCube, and I vividly remember him volunteering to sit out, as we had 5 people and only 4 spots to play. I thought he had lost his mind. In his own house, a perfect environment to put himself first, he instead put himself last. Madness, I thought.
As I age, I realize in hindsight what his “madness” was, the first demonstrations of Nishad’s defining traits; his lack of self-aggrandizement, constant consideration for the needs of others, and willingness to sacrifice his own wants for what he thought others wanted, or needed. I think, in my childhood ignorance, I viewed him as perhaps a bit weak, a bit of a pushover. It was my shame to realize with age that his behavior wasn’t indicative of weakness, but rather his desire to put others first. It was strength.
In high school, he ran his first ultra-marathon, and he asked myself and some other friends to run along with him to help motivate him to continue. At the end, when he successfully completed his 100 miles almost a full day after he started, I remember him shooing away our praise for his frankly incredible achievement, and heaping praise upon us for our own commitment and fortitude in pacing him. Ignoring the fact that I followed along on roller skates. I’m not much of a [ECF p. 135] runner. Our meal became a celebration of all of us, of our shared achievement, our shared experience, despite the fact that he was the clear star of the show.
When Nishad was working at Alameda, we and two other friends went on a backpacking trip. I came in unprepared, to say the least, missing gear with no insoles in my shoes! It was only a few days after the trip that I pieced together all the ways Nishad had silently lightened my load, literally and figuratively. Without drawing any attention or keeping score, Nishad carried my share of the heavy shared equipment, like our bear box, to ease my suffering feet, shouldered the majority of the driving both there and back, and injected some much-needed levity and sense of adventure into our trip.
This letter has taken me some time to write, since I have found it difficult to encapsulate in short form what makes Nishad such an unusual person. I wish I had some single moment in time that illustrates the depth of his compassion, some time when he threw himself in front of a bus for me, or pulled me from a burning building, but that’s simply not how his compassion manifests. My perception of his kindness is not the result of any one event, but an accumulation of decades of consistent behavior. Years and years of consistent small actions and words that have resulted in my tremendous respect for his character. He’s not kind in performative ways, or generous only when convenient. His consideration for others permeates his thinking and his actions, and I’m honored to consider him one of my best friends to this day.
- Connor Hegarty
[Letter from Phillip Korolog (Elementary School Friend)]
September 2, 2024
Dear Judge Kaplan,
The task of attempting to distill my feelings and opinions about Nishad down to a short letter feels impossible. I’ve known Nishad since the second grade, and he has remained one of my closest friends throughout my life. He is endlessly kind, the first to self-sacrifice for others, fiercely loyal, and is somebody I’ve always loved and admired. I’ve thought for an uncomfortably long time about what to include in this letter. I have no doubt that other letters you receive will describe, in detail, Nishad’s lifelong generosity, empathy, and strong moral bearing. Qualities that, because of my proximity to him, I have had the opportunity to learn from firsthand. Instead of drowning the page with the endless stories I could include detailing all of these traits, I will include a few shorter personal anecdotes that I hope will assist you in building a more complete picture of Nishad’s character.
When I met Nishad in elementary school, he was a shy but kind boy, who was attempting to navigate the process of acclimating to a new school. At every sleepover he was the first to volunteer his bed to another and sleep on the floor, or the first to give up his spot in a game to let somebody else who was sitting out play. One day after school we had a group of friends roughhousing on a trampoline, and one boy launched Nishad into me and we collided in a painful tangle. Despite the contact being very little fault of his own, he immediately attempted to comfort me. I, being a headstrong 10 year old in pain, wouldn’t listen to him and was resolved to remain furious. Nishad stood in the middle of the trampoline and told me to do anything in retribution so I wouldn’t be the only one in pain. While melodramatic, I think that moment goes beyond a few kids being kids. Even then, Nishad’s instinct was to find a way to mitigate somebody’s pain and distress, and was willing to put his 10 year old body on the line to make it happen.
During my last year of college I sustained a traumatic brain injury. It was by far the darkest period of my life. For almost three years, I fought a long, slow, battle back to a place where I could live my life again. During the recovery, I was hugely depressed, had lost much of my sense of self, and had very little hope for the future. Nishad was one of the most important of my short array of personal anchors I used to avoid being swept away. For years when I was at my lowest I would call Nishad, regardless of the time. Despite the fact Nishad was regularly working 16 hour days at Alameda and then FTX, he would pick up,listen without judgment, and comfort me. I recall a time somewhere around 3am when I was particularly low, when I woke him up with a call. I struggle to describe, lost and fragile, how special it was to have somebody [ECF p. 137] whom it was always safe to bear my unfiltered fears and doubts. He talked to me as long as I needed, absorbing my hardship onto himself until he had built me back up to a place where I could take my next step down the road of recovery. Without his unfaltering support, I don’t know where I would be today. Even on the other side of the planet, his ardent loyalty was on full display, and his first thought was almost always for his friend, and how he could help. I would later learn of how, through this period, he would worriedly check in with friends and family about how I was doing, and ask how he could help. While this is no surprise to me given the lifelong context I’m lucky enough to have, I felt it was an apt and beautiful example of Nishad’s instinctual willingness to do whatever he can for the people he loves.
When Nishad and I were kids our friend group used to talk about having a place off in nature where we could eventually take our future families in the summer, creating the time and space for our partners and our children to become as close as we were. This dream stayed with our group throughout high school and college.
In 2021, he told a group of us friends that he’d been advised to get some real estate, and the only version of that he actually liked was making our ages-old idea a reality. It seemed too generous to accept, but he assured us he wanted this. His two requests were that it be driving-distance from one of us that was afraid of flying, and that we help him by finding the location because he had no time. I remember he once worried he was asking too much of us, which was laughably ridiculous given the magnitude of the offer. Even if he wasn’t busy, we knew how much he hates logistics and wanted to spare him the work. Over the next year we searched, and as expected, Nishad was checked out. We needed to prod him just to look at the photos of options online. We found a home in the summer of 2022 and Nishad closed on it but the owners ended up backing out. Later he finally signed for a different home in August, paying for it in October. Nishad learned about “the hole” in September. I cannot count the number of times Nishad has apologized to us and wondered what he was even thinking. He regrets it immensely.
I also want to share my perspective on Nishad’s mental state following the FTX collapse. I was so worried about him because I knew, even before understanding the facts, that if he shared even partial responsibility for the loss that so many people suffered, he would be internally assuming almost all of the responsibility and guilt regardless of how much belonged on his shoulders. Given the magnitude of the disaster, I remember thinking how impossible it would be for anyone to take on such a huge emotional burden. In the initial weeks I was unable to contact him, and I was so scared that he would choose to commit suicide. When we finally did talk, he was a shell of his former self. He was beyond distraught; barely able to go through the motions on a daily basis. Everyone close to him that I spoke to shared the same opinion:
Inwardly he was putting all of the guilt onto himself, and it was too much to bear. It drove him to write a suicide note, and he came incredibly close to ending his own life. The only reason I would share this story is because I think the pain and anguish he endured, along with the fact that it was borderline unmanageable, colors in the moral standard of Nishad’s character.
When we were able to get in contact with him, some friends and I quickly traveled to be with him for a week. If he sat or lay down, he would sometimes lose himself to his emotions and have trouble even standing back up. We tried to show him that there was hope in his world, and that we would be there for him through whatever would come. This was so important to both me and our friends, because despite the limited information we had about the FTX collapse, we shared an unshakable belief in Nishad’s “goodness”.
I wish there was a way for the countless memories I have of Nishad could be transferred to you, so you could see him the same way I do. Because that’s impossible, I hope that you will believe me when I say that Nishad was a kind, caring child who was always extremely mindful about doing “right”, who grew into a kind, caring man who continued to have a deep connection to his morals. For whatever it’s worth, I can honestly say I have never known anyone who is genuinely kinder to friends and strangers alike. And I hope you will take this letter into consideration in respect to your judgment.
Phillip Korolog
[Letter from Colin Smith (Elementary School Friend)]
Dear Judge Kaplan,
My name is Colin Smith, and I am writing on behalf of my dear friend Nishad Singh. Nishad and I have been close since childhood, attending the same schools until college. I now live in Tennessee, but though we live far apart Nishad and I speak on the phone regularly about our lives and jobs, often for hours at a time, and we did so before, during, and after the years Nishad was at FTX. Nishad is like family to me.
It is impossible to express how strange it is to write this letter. Nishad is, simply, kind; he doesn’t have obvious character flaws or any hidden motives. The better you know him, the more evident this is. Among my lifelong friends, he is perhaps who I’d least expect to write this letter for.
Because he is such a kind person, a character reference focusing on this quality might be redundant with other letters. Instead, I want to focus on the parts of Nishad that only those closer to him may have seen. Nishad has an unyielding selflessness that was evident throughout the life and death of FTX. Observing the case from afar, this selflessness came to influence my understanding of events.
Finally, an apology. I am a research scientist by both profession and temperament, and I feel much more comfortable writing about facts and data than I do writing about character. This letter has been a challenge to write; I hope my perspective is useful.
Self-Esteem and Sam
Nishad is brilliant, well-spoken, and extremely likable, but he doesn't always see himself that way. He reflexively views others more positively, especially compared to himself, and has a dim view of his importance and talents.
Nishad testified during the trial that he was intimidated by Sam, which made headlines. Honestly, I thought this understated their dynamic, based on the conversations I had with Nishad while he was at FTX. Maybe in the beginning, when Sam was simply Gabe s genius older brother, it was sufficient to say Sam intimidated Nishad. Over time, I felt this relationship evolved into something different.
Nishad saw Sam as immeasurably smarter than himself. Nishad assumed he was usually wrong, his wants unimportant, and that he had to live with these differences. It seemed to me that Sam cultivated a relationship where dissent was not tolerated and that Nishad was by nature inclined to accept this dynamic.
I told Nishad multiple times that I thought Sam must be mistaken to be so dismissive of him, but Nishad, sadly, insisted otherwise. There seemed to be a culture at Alameda and later FTX that prized mental quickness over all other traits, including strength of character or effective deliberation. Nishad told me there was a running joke among early employees about how he was the only member of their cadre who wasn t able to get a job at the hedge fund Jane Street, a firm famous for difficult interview puzzles. My impression was that Nishad also thought this joke was funny. It wasn t just that Nishad s colleagues didn t seem to appreciate what makes Nishad so special, he didn t either.
As time went on, Nishad would frequently complain about Sam's actions, such as FTX s excessive advertising spending or extravagant living arrangements. Nishad didn’t seem to win many arguments over these disagreements, at least in the stories I recall.
I once asked Nishad directly why Sam didn't listen when he pushed back on his questionable decisions. Given his position as the manager of FTX s engineering team, Sam must respect his opinions, right? Nishad replied, "I think he tolerates me because I'm useful."
Caring by Nature
A unique aspect of the FTX saga was the company's charitable mission. A particular oddity was the mathematical, unemotional way some of the leaders approached charity. It seemed they didn't care about people, rather they thought in terms of dehumanized numerical abstractions of their well-being. Understandably, this perspective is hard for many people to relate to or even believe.
Nishad isn t like this at all. Nishad cares deeply and is happiest when he is making others happy. It upsets me that this core trait of his wasn t more visible to the public.
Nishad sees others' unhappiness as his personal responsibility. This has been true since childhood. I remember a birthday party in elementary school where friends teased Nishad for apologizing too much; he felt responsible for things that weren't his fault. Nishad s close friends still tease him for apologizing too much.
During his time at Alameda and FTX, Nishad's care for others showed in his self-sacrifice. Once convinced that the companies’ success meant helping people, he worked harder than anyone I ve ever met. Nishad was on call every night. We joked about how when he wasn t sleeping in the office he had been relegated to the couch; Claire was tired of being woken up by calls. In early 2022, about a year before the collapse, a small group of friends convinced him to take a vacation together, Nishad s first trip with us in years. He worked every day and was on call each night.
Nishad loves coding but found managing people stressful and emotionally draining. His deep care for others made him an excellent manager but caused this work to take a heavy personal toll. He valued the happiness of others more than his own.
In his testimony, Nishad stated he stayed at FTX after learning of the hole both because he couldn't live with himself if his exit caused the company's collapse and because he felt a responsibility to attempt to avoid enormous losses, no matter how unlikely. This is entirely consistent with the Nishad I know.
Usually Billionaires Enjoy Being Rich
Most rich people I know enjoy having money, but Nishad didn’t. He only enjoyed giving it away. He became a reluctant billionaire, which would be funny to write if this letter wasn t to a judge.
Money makes Nishad uncomfortable. He loathes thinking about it and always dreaded salary discussions. He once told one of our friends he didn't know how much money he had and hated being known as wealthy to extended family and acquaintances.
Spending on others is fine for Nishad. He loves spending on charity and making his loved ones happy. Spending on himself, however, is awkward, uncomfortable, and ultimately shameful.
Nishad’s unusual aversion to money didn’t change as he grew wealthy. On the previously mentioned vacation we took in 2022, Nishad flew home economy class from the Bahamas. The ticket he bought for me was business class. On countless calls, he complained about how sickeningly unnecessary he thought fancy yachts and cars were, and how frustrated he was when other FTX employees spent excessively on such luxuries.
Nishad told me about several personal financial decisions that made absolutely no sense unless he didn’t care about wealth. As one example, one of Nishad’s favorite engineers quit because he didn’t get along with Gary. As part of the exit, Sam agreed to donate a large amount to a charity of the engineer’s choosing. When the time came, the engineer reached out to Nishad, but after Sam repeatedly ignored requests to follow through with his promise, Nishad told me he made the donation with his own money.
I can t speak for other FTX employees, but I know Nishad s stated charitable intentions were genuine. Starting in late 2021, Nishad told me he felt the company was finally delivering on its promises to make impactful donations. I could feel how proud this made him. Charity was the reason he worked so hard—giving to causes he cared for was what brought him the most joy.
The House
In 2021, Nishad was a billionaire on paper, though I did not know it at the time. He hadn’t changed at all, and he certainly wasn’t bragging about his money. But it had apparently been suggested to him to set aside a relatively small portion of his wealth in real estate. Nishad, not someone to spend solely for his own benefit, decided to purchase a house for the communal use of his close-knit childhood friends, including me, intended to be a gathering place for our families for years to come.
The search for a house began in early 2022 and was far from typical. Swamped with work, Nishad had no time to spare for house hunting, so he asked friends and family to help him find a place to purchase. The strangeness of this arrangement was not lost on us, but those of us who know Nishad well understood it was perfectly in character. Nishad cared about working hard so he could help people. He had little interest or time for the details of the house; in fact, he was genuinely grateful to avoid thinking about it.
In July 2022, Nishad contracted to buy a house, but the sellers backed out. After another search he was not involved in, Nishad purchased a different house on August 30th. He made a downpayment then, and completed the payment for the house in October. Nishad never saw either house in person.
I am now aware that Nishad paid the balance of the house after he was aware of the customer fund shortfall, and it was clearly wrong to do so. But I don’t believe the purchase was a last-ditch act of greed, it just isn’t the friend I know. My impression is that Nishad was focused on work, exhausted, and did not give enough thought to an action he now regrets.
While I understand how these events might raise suspicion that Nishad had a hidden motive for personal enrichment, I cannot recall Nishad ever intentionally acting to enrich himself at others' expense, and I don't think he started in 2022.
Why Nishad was Suicidal
Nishad testified that he was suicidal after the FTX collapse. Because it has not been extensively reported on, I think it's important to understand why Nishad was distraught, from someone who spoke to him about it.
First, Nishad told me he understood that he d been part of something that harmed people. He had spent years working crushing hours with the goal of earning to give and helping others. Realizing he spent this time helping to build a company that ultimately hurt people was unspeakably painful. Charitable causes he cared deeply about and had dedicated his working life to support were dragged through the mud, and [ECF p. 142] he felt overwhelming responsibility for his role in damaging their reputations. As he saw it, both his actions and his inactions had harmed customers, employees, and others he cared deeply about.
Second, Nishad told me he felt helpless in the days after the collapse. Coworkers were texting and calling, seeking explanations. Many were unable to leave the country, and he couldn't help them.
We had multiple conversations about this awful period. Never once has Nishad mentioned losing money or status; I could not count the number of times he has reflected on mistakes with shame.
Nishad has been in anguish. And while in some ways he is moving forward – he no longer is suicidal – it is clear to those close to him that he will never fully get over or forgive himself for his role in the damage FTX caused.
——————
As this case has unfolded, it has been difficult, if not impossible, to reconcile the Nishad portrayed in the press with who I know my lifelong friend to be. It has been humbling to reflect on how I may know less about the character of public figures than I thought I might.
I would understand if the Nishad I've described stretches believability, but this is the only Nishad I know. There are no cultural touchstones for a person like Nishad; I’ve never seen a TV show where the guilty party is a nice guy trying to help people and feels such deep, genuine remorse for his actions. I m proud to call Nishad my friend.
Thank you for your consideration,
Colin Smith
[Letter from Gabe Bankman-Fried (High School Friend)]
Hon. Lewis A. Kaplan
Daniel Patrick Moynihan United States Courthouse
500 Pearl Street
New York, NY 1007-1312
Dear Judge Lewis Kaplan,
My name is Gabe Bankman-Fried. Sam Bankman-Fried is my brother. Nishad Singh is my friend. Nishad is one of the kindest people I have ever known, and I’m writing to ask that you show him the same compassion he has shown others his entire life.
I met Nishad in high school. I immediately appreciated his sense of humor and intellect. But it took me a while to appreciate the depth of his kindness, because his kindness wasn’t performative. It was sincere. He was always quick to ask how I was doing, particularly if he could sense that I wasn’t doing well. He would cook for me when we went over to his house. He would congratulate me on my small achievements, and keep his large achievements – like running 100 miles in 24 hours – to himself. He would ask about my parents and offer to play the board game he knew I wanted to play. With every act of kindness, we grew a little closer. By the end of high school, when it came time for everyone to design their yearbook pages, Nishad and I combined ours so we had a bigger canvas to commemorate our friendship.
Nishad had his struggles, but he handled them with grace. When Nishad felt insecure, instead of bragging to compensate, he would apologize for the tiniest of missteps – and when his friends would tell him to stop apologizing so much, he would apologize for that too. When Nishad felt stressed, he would bottle it up to avoid burdening his friends. When Nishad felt tension with someone, he would often blame himself, working tirelessly to get along with him even when others could see that they didn’t deserve the effort.
Even in his lowest moments, Nishad cared about others. In November of 2022, I learned as the world did about FTX’s crash. As it was happening, Sam called me, and told me that Nishad needed me, so I flew to Nassau to comfort Nishad. What I found was a broken man. He was unable to speak. Unable to cry. He was shocked by the weight of what was happening. For a man that had lived a life of kindness, both to friends and strangers, he never could have imagined he would play a role, however small, in something that hurt people. I never could have imagined that either. As we held each other in his room in Nassau, he told me that the only thing keeping him from killing himself was that he couldn’t do that to his family and friends.
We parted ways at the airport in Nassau two years ago. We haven’t spoken since, but I think about him most days. I know Nishad has made mistakes, and I know those mistakes will haunt him for years to come. But I also know he can move beyond them if given a second chance.
I hope you see fit to give Nishad a second chance. Because if someone as kind as Nishad doesn’t deserve compassion, then what hope is there for the rest of us?
Sincerely,
Gabe Bankman-Fried