Sentencing Letters Submitted on Behalf of Nishad Singh (Exhibit A to the Sentencing Submission), part 2 of 19 (ECF pages 14 to 26)

[ECF p. 14]

[Letter from Linchuan Zhang (Former Alameda Engineer)]

The Honorable Judge Lewis A. Kaplan
United States District Judge
Southern District of New York

Dear Judge Kaplan,

I worked at Alameda Research in Berkeley between September and December of 2019 as a software engineer. Nishad was my direct manager. During that time, I found Nishad to be kind, helpful, and extremely hardworking, if a little naive.

I applied to work at Alameda Research because I was excited by their mission and thought it’d be good for my career capital and donation plans. I was taken in by the messaging about the company a) having prosocial goals and b) was unusually competent relative to the rest of the crypto industry, allowing them to get outsized returns. I ended up giving up a significant chunk of unvested Google stock and annual bonus to join.

When I joined, most of the team (including senior people like Bankman-Fried and Gary Wang) had already left to work on launching FTX in Hong Kong. Nishad and I were among about 8 people still in Berkeley (not all of whom were full-time).

I mostly didn’t like working at Alameda. However, Nishad was very helpful throughout the process. I was nervous about wasting people’s time, but Nishad repeatedly encouraged me to speak up more and ask more questions. He patiently explained details of the codebase that I didn’t understand to me, as well as more high-level questions like the company’s stated philanthropic values, philosophy and culture. Even when I disagreed with him, I found Nishad to be careful and nuanced. It was clear he consistently looked for the good in other people. For example, he never said a bad word about the people who left Alameda in the 2018 exodus, and even strongly complimented one of them (“one of the best traders I know”), despite my understanding that the split was anything but amicable.

I respected Nishad significantly as my manager. He was clearly technically competent, much more hardworking than I am, and also performed admirably when he was thrust into a management position at a young age (he was the first manager I’ve had who was younger than me, and I was 26). That said, occasionally I found him a little naive, though not unusually so for his age or vocation. For example, I remember discussing charity with him, and he remarked how there’s approximately no diminishing returns to charitable giving, a claim that might make sense theoretically but to me seemed implausible considering the relative magnitudes of Alameda and the charities in question.

While Nishad was competent and hardworking, he sometimes seemed to struggle with asserting his own views, particularly when they might conflict with those of more dominant personalities in the company. I don’t recall him ever openly disagreeing with Bankman-Fried about software choices, despite Nishad being more of a domain expert. At one point, he told me that he initially had severe doubts about launching FTX and thought Alameda should focus on trading rather [ECF p. 15] than consumer-facing software, a decision that he in retrospect endorsed as FTX looked like it was going to do well. He shared that the experience of him seemingly being proven wrong about decisions made him less willing to question others’ product judgment.

I ended up leaving Alameda because it was not a good cultural fit. Everybody was overworked, I personally found the work environment rather stressful and I didn’t agree with, and had trouble adapting to, the coding practices the company followed that were very different from Google’s, such as the lack of unit tests. However, Nishad was extremely supportive throughout the process. Even though our professional interests were clearly at odds, he was very helpful and genuine as I navigated leaving the company, and I still remember his kind words and offers to help on my last day.

While I found Nishad to be intelligent, fundamentally kind and well-intentioned, I can see in retrospect how his inexperience, trusting nature, and difficulty in standing firm against stronger personalities could have led him into compromising situations.

Sincerely,
Linchuan Zhang

[ECF p. 16]

[Letter from Jack Zhang (Former FTX Office Chef)]

Honorable Judge Kaplan,

My name is Jack Zhang, and I was a former chef at FTX, working for the company from July to November 2022. I was responsible for preparing lunch and dinner for all employees.

Nishad Singh was a manager, and when I joined the company, he gave me a lot of help. I have always been grateful to him. During my four months of work at FTX, I found that Nishad Singh was not only friendly but also very frugal. He is a vegetarian, and since most of the food I prepared was meat-based, it might not have been fully suitable for him. However, his only request was to ensure that the dietary needs of the majority of employees were met, and he did not ask for any special treatment.

When my family moved to the Bahamas, Nishad also helped find school for my daughter in the Bahamas. I have always been very grateful for this. Later, I found out that he had been treating all employees this nice, which made me respect him even more.

Therefore, I humbly ask you, Honorable Judge, to not be too harsh on Nishad Singh. He is a very kind person and an excellent supervisor. His respect and generosity towards every employee will be remembered deeply by all of us.

Jack Zhang
10/10/2024

If any further testimony is required, please feel free to contact me: [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number]

[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]

[ECF p. 17]

[Letter from Adam Kalinich (Former FTX Engineer)]

[Pages 17 and 18 of the PDF are images. Their text was typed out from the images.]

October 1, 2024

Hon. Lewis A. Kaplan
United States District Court
Southern District of New York
Daniel Patrick Moynihan Courthouse
500 Pearl Street
New York, New York 10007-1312

Re: United States of America v. Nishad Singh (22 Cr. 673 (LAK))

Dear Judge Kaplan,

I write in support of my former colleague, Nishad Singh. I can say, without qualification, that Nishad was the most hardworking and kindest manager I have ever worked for.

I first met Nishad in the fall of 2021, after I had joined FTX US, and was assigned to work as a developer in the FTX US Chicago office. I was initially sent to the Bahamas office for training, where Nishad was the Head of Engineering. Over the course of the next fourteen months, I was assigned to work in various locations, including Chicago and, for most of 2022, in Nassau, Bahamas with the majority of the FTX developers.

For a newly-created exchange growing at the rate FTX did in 2020-22, with the rapidly-increasing number of customers and transactions, we had a relatively small group of developers. Comparable operations employ hundreds of developers, so the round-the-clock workload demanded from our small developer team was often overwhelming, with Nishad shouldering the bulk of the day to day workload. Without question, Nishad worked longer hours than any other developer in the company and carried an astounding burden.

Nishad is truly one of the most selfless individuals I have ever known. While he held a position that would have entitled him to delegate almost any task to a subordinate, Nishad would always take on the most unpleasant tasks himself, and if a complicated or extremely urgent situation arose, Nishad was always the guy who would jump on it, and would stick around to be as helpful as possible even when he needed to call in more experienced developers. On the rare occasions when he could find time to attend a company social gathering, Nishad would invariably bring his work laptop along to respond immediately to issues that required urgent attention. I recall one morning in which Nishad told us he had been awakened six different times the prior night for various emergencies. Nishad worked this hard, frequently on little sleep, day in and day out, to the apparent detriment of his own [ECF p. 18] health. Our employees learned they could rely on Nishad and he did not want to let anyone down.

Of all the FTX leadership, Nishad stood out as the one who consistently showed the most empathy and compassion toward his employees. He provided honest, constructive feedback with genuine respect and always encouraged us to excel in our work while supporting us through personal and family challenges. When I was relocated far from home, Nishad went above and beyond to ensure that we received help in finding housing, making friends, accessing medical care, and meeting other personal needs. No matter how many hours into the workday, he was always patient enough to listen when employees sought his advice and to provide them with the guidance to solve their problems. It was clear that he sincerely wanted us to be happy and feel supported, in addition to sharing in the company's success.

I will never forget how Nishad responded when I opened up to him about the suicide of my best friend, which happened while I was working long hours for FTX. I was struggling with grief, and Nishad didn't hesitate to offer his time and a listening ear. He was there as both a manager and a friend, checking in on me regularly. His empathy during that difficult period meant more to me than words can express. Through his example, I learned invaluable lessons about treating colleagues with kindness and respect, and I remain deeply grateful for the compassion he showed me and others.

I respectfully ask Your Honor to extend as much mercy as possible when determining Nishad's sentence. I acknowledge the extent of financial losses experienced by many, including me, but I believe that a lengthy sentence for someone of Nishad's exceptional character would only compound the tragedy. I respectfully urge you to consider the shortest sentence permissible under the circumstances, and I would be profoundly grateful for your compassion towards him.

Sincerely,

Adam O. Kalinich

[ECF p. 19]

[Letter from Ashish Suvarna (Former FTX Customer Support)]

2nd September 2024

Dear Judge Kaplan,

I started working for FTX as a part of the Customer Support team in March 2020, right when the covid lockdown began. The Customer Support and engineering teams worked closely to identify bugs or resolve technical issues customers brought to our attention. In my role, I was fortunate to get to know Nishad, and ended up working with him almost on a daily basis for two years.

Right from the start, one thing that stood out about him was he was very welcoming, responsive and open to thoughts / suggestions. Hierarchically he was the head of engineering at FTX but it always felt like I was talking to a peer or a friend that was willing to listen carefully what we had to say and respond with courteous and actionable insights. I would say this was true for all of Nishad’s interactions with most if not all people in the team.

Due to the nature of crypto being 24x7, we were often working in a way such that at least >1 employee was always on shift to keep an eye out for issues on the exchange. As I was in the asia time zone and was also working weird hours, I often called Nishad, waking him up at 3am his time for critical issues. Sometimes, we were unaware if an issue was critical or not, and Nishad always encouraged us to err on the side of caution and call him anyway. If we were ever very off about that judgment, he would point out that waking him up was probably not needed in that scenario but was always very calm and composed about it and would never be annoyed at us.

I recall a time when a new joinee was asking a hilariously simple question in one of the FTX slack channels and Nishad was very calmly and patiently holding his hand through the entire process of solving the new joinee’s issue. Nishad did not have to do that and someone else that was not as busy could have solved it easily but Nishad handled it very humbly. I recall this particular instance because the new joinee only later realised that Nishad was the head of engineering at FTX. This was not the exception but the norm. He was always around for any questions and it made all of us feel more welcome to the team.

I moved to the Bahamas in April of 2022. All of my interactions until this point with Nishad were only behind a computer screen. He was genuinely very happy to see me, and me him. Nishad was easily the nicest guy in the FTX Office. Nobody could even get close to being nicer than Nishad. I am 100% sure if you ask anybody who used to work at FTX, they would say the same thing. He is very down to earth.

Nishad is a very caring teammate who takes a genuine interest in the people he works with. As I got to know Nishad better, I told him I’d like to build my skills so one day I could move from Customer Support into an engineering role on his team as I had a background in engineering . Nishad was very encouraging and personally helped ramp me up, and helped [ECF p. 20] navigate splitting my time with my manager in a way that made everyone happy. I am grateful for what I learned from him, and he also took this kind of interest in other employees within the company.

Throughout my career, I have interacted with and reported to a lot of superiors. Often when a superior does a mistake, I have observed that they try to sweep it under the rug or do not publicly apologise for it or just ignore the issue at hand. Nishad on the other hand, has been one of the select few so far I have interacted with who has publicly and often, accepted his goof ups, apologised for it humbly, and owned up to it.

Seeing Nishad work relentlessly all the time and look after others drove us further and all of us worked harder. Although Nishad was often the youngest person in the room, he led by example and earned the respect of others through his actions.

I am unsure what the future holds for Nishad, but I would like to end with a note that Nishad is a very genuine guy. It has always been a pleasure to talk to him, be it in person or online. He has very little to no ego and respects all people that he interacts with. I also think he has tremendous potential in him. He is without doubt a very talented programmer and I think it would be a shame if he isn’t given another opportunity to contribute to the world in a positive way.

2nd September 2024,
Ashish Suvarna

[ECF p. 21]

[Letter from Philippe Maes (Former FTX Engineer)]

05/27/2024

Dear Judge Kaplan,

I am Philippe Maes, an ex-coworker of Nishad. I was a contractor at FTX, responsible for the development of the mobile app. In this letter I’d like to tell you a little about Nishad Singh and the impressions he left on me.

I first met Nishad in FTX’s offices in Hong Kong. I was invited there after doing a few remote interview rounds. I was struck by how genuine and down to earth Nishad, in particular, was. He was very kind, welcoming, patient and especially non-judgemental. Even though my English wasn’t that great at the time - and I had a lot of questions - he took the time to listen and answer every one of my questions in detail. The day I did my on-site interview was the same day as the famous COVID crash. You could see and feel the stress in the office, everyone tied to their computer screens. I remember Nishad being one of the only ones in the office remaining calm and respectful.

I was offered the role, and with it, a large responsibility: building a brand new mobile app. Nishad’s management gave me a sense of responsibility and made the app almost feel like“ my” personal project. He was intensely curious about the technical details, and offered lots of help and thoughts, but was also very open-minded and grateful for my experience and effort. As the youngest member on the team, he was self-aware of his own limitations and lack of experience relating to mobile development, and managed me not by giving me orders, but by helping me be the best version of myself. He gave me the freedom to rise to the occasion myself, all while making clear he had my back. Being able to work independently like this, taught me a lot, not only as a programmer, but also being able to manage a product myself, and guide things from ideas to release. I doubt there would have been a better place to grow professionally. All of this wouldn’t have been possible without Nishad’s endless trust and patience.

Although the offer was made multiple times, I chose to remain remote, working out of Belgium, instead of moving to Hong Kong (and later the Bahamas). Nishad took the time to check in with me, checking if I was doing well, if I needed something or if he could do something to make my life easier. When I visited the offices, generally once every quarter, he would always take the time to go for a walk to catch up. Our talks weren’t limited to work stuff, we would talk about our lives, travels, relationships. He would invite me over for dinner, invite me for movie nights, etc. Every time I was there, he made sure to include me in all sorts of social gatherings, which made me feel welcome and appreciated.

In short, when I think about Nishad, I think of a person who is kind and patient to everyone, even in the most stressful times. A down to earth person, not looking down on anyone and treating everyone with respect. Professionally, he allowed people to be the best version of themselves.

I hope this letter gives an idea as to what relationship me and Nishad had whilst at FTX, and how I see him as a person. I’m happy to answer any question you might have. You can reach me by email at [ECF p. 22] [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address].

Kind regards,
Philippe

[ECF p. 23]

[Letter from Adam Jin (Former FTX Business Development)]

June 12, 2024

Adam Jin
[REDACTED], Kennedy Town
Hong Kong

Honorable Lewis A. Kaplan
U.S. District Court Judge
Daniel Patrick Moynihan
United States Courthouse
500 Pearl St.
New York, NY 10007-1312

Subject: Character Reference Letter for Nishad Singh

Dear Judge Kaplan,

My name is Adam Jin, and I am writing to provide a character reference for Nishad Singh, whom I have known since 2019. Our friendship and professional relationship began at FTX. Through our shared experiences in both Hong Kong and the Bahamas, I have come to know Nishad well. I hope this letter provides you with a deeper understanding of his character.

When I joined FTX, Nishad was already a lead engineer and quickly became one of our most critical team members. His work reliability and efficiency were unparalleled. Building and maintaining a crypto exchange from scratch is incredibly challenging, and Nishad excelled in this demanding environment. During the early days, as the platform grew exponentially and experienced significant traffic, technical issues often arose unexpectedly. Nishad consistently stepped up to address these problems, regardless of the hour, often responding to urgent matters immediately after only 30 mins of sleep following an extremely long day. His tireless dedication inspired our entire team.

Nishad's contributions extended far beyond his technical abilities. He genuinely cared for his colleagues and users. We often referred to "Nishad’s time" as a precious resource, reflecting his extraordinary productivity. In our estimation, one hour of Nishad's work equaled a full day's work for five regular engineers. Despite his heavy workload, he always made time to help others, driven not just by his skill, but by a sincere commitment to helping. This was particularly evident in his approach to a common industry challenge: users deposit unsupported tokens to exchanges. Nishad developed a system to recover these assets swiftly, FTX was the only exchange that recovered users’ assets within 24 hours. His efforts in this area alone saved users millions of dollars in potentially lost funds. Nishad undertook this task out of a genuine desire to protect users and their assets. In many ways, I always saw Nishad as the moral compass of FTX, always pointing in the direction of what was right to do.

One particular day stands out vividly in my memory. We had taken a rare half-day off to go wakesurfing in Hong Kong. Nishad, a novice surfer, showed remarkable determination to learn, falling repeatedly but never giving up. Just as he began to find his balance and began to ride the wave, his phone rang. Without hesitation, he jumped off, swam back to the boat, dripping wet, pulled out the mobile phone and laptop, and immediately started working to solve an urgent technical issue. This moment encapsulated Nishad’s reliability, dedication, and always putting others before himself, even under the most unexpected situations.

[ECF p. 24]

During the COVID-19 pandemic, Nishad faced significant challenges due to Hong Kong’s stringent travel restrictions. His resilience was bolstered by the support of his long term partner, Claire, who undertook a 20-hour journey and subsequent 3-week hotel quarantine to be with him, bringing their beloved dog, Gopher. Their reunion demonstrated the strength of their bond and provided Nishad with crucial emotional support during a difficult time. The joy on Nishad’s face when he saw Claire and Gopher was heartwarming and a testament to the love and support that he has always relied on.

While Nishad has made mistakes, I have known him to take full responsibility for his actions. This instance is no exception, and I know he deeply regrets his participation in the events in question.

I hope this letter provides deeper insight into Nishad's character as a dedicated and kind individual. He is a person of dedication and kindness. I respectfully ask for your consideration of these qualities when determining the consequences of his actions. Should you require further information, please do not hesitate to contact me.

Sincerely,

Adam Jin
June 12, 2024

[ECF p. 25]

[Letter from Christian Drappi (Former Alameda Engineer)]

Dear Judge Kaplan,

My name is Christian Drappi. I came to know Nishad Singh during my work at Alameda Research, and like him I was a witness at Mr. Bankman-Fried’s trial. I'd first like to state that the last time Nishad and I communicated was before I learned about what had happened at the company. He has no idea I am writing this, and this is entirely my own decision. In fact, I never considered Nishad a close friend. It was hard to consider most of my colleagues as friends: we were all just there and got along. On the other hand, when I met Nishad, I immediately liked him – it was hard not to. As we spent more time in the Bahamas, my positive view of him was strengthened, and I came to trust Nishad quite a bit.

On November 7, I learned about how FTX defrauded its customers. And on November 8, 2022, I learned that Nishad was involved in the conspiracy. I felt betrayed. I always had trouble understanding the inner-minds of Sam, Caroline and Gary. But Nishad was someone I could relate to. As a result, I thought that he would keep the other three on the right path. I was wrong.

Nishad testified the week after my testimony, and I attended most of it in the overflow room. After hearing him speak, I feel less betrayed than I did on November 8th. This comment isn't meant to excuse his actions in any way. Rather, I say this because today I have a much different picture in my mind about how Nishad conducted himself. I now believe his issue is not knowing right from wrong. It's that he needs to find the courage to stand up for what he believes is right, rather than following orders when he knows they are wrong. I hope that the Court’s sentence in this case will develop that courage in him while taking into account both what Nishad has to offer in the future and the victims in this case.

During the time I got to know Nishad, there were several other things that struck me about his character. These are why I came to trust him so much, and why I'm now writing this letter. Firstly, Nishad's eagerness to please extended far beyond committing financial crimes with his superiors. He was generally eager to please. The best of this is when he would go out of his way to welcome new people into his world, either socially or professionally. He was warm to everyone he came across, no matter who they were. This was particularly true when it came to FTX's local employees in the Bahamas. Unfortunately it was all too common for higher-ranking FTX employees to treat the Bahamas staff with much less than the respect they deserved. I'm proud to say that Nishad was the opposite. This is part of why he was so beloved by everyone at the company.

Professionally, Nishad was probably the most effective software engineer I have ever met. He would work at all hours of the day. We would be playing padel at midnight and he would stop in the middle of a game because he had to fix a bug in the code. Often times the bugs wouldn't even be his doing, but he took responsibility for the whole team. Not only was his volume of work remarkable, but also his efficiency was world-class. I saw this first-hand, from the code itself to the products that it powered. In a few days he could build features that it would take weeks for an entire team to complete.

I believe that Nishad has a bright future in front of him, and I am extremely confident in that belief. A year and a half ago, I'd have told you that he is the colleague that you'd dream of working with. If he's able to muster the courage to always do the right thing, then I am sure that I'll be saying that in the future too. Your Honor, thank you for reading this letter.

Sincerely,
Christian

[ECF p. 26]

[Letter from Can Sun (Former FTX General Counsel)]

[This page of the PDF is an image. Its text was typed out from the image.]

Honorable Lewis A. Kaplan
U.S. District Court Judge
Daniel Patrick Moynihan
United States Courthouse
500 Pearl St.
New York, NY 10007-1312

October 9, 2024

Dear Judge Lewis A. Kaplan,

I am writing to provide a letter of support for Mr. Nishad Singh, whom I came to know during my time as General Counsel at FTX. Recognizing the seriousness of his crimes, I hope my insights into Nishad’s character will offer a more complete understanding for the Court.

Nishad was a pivotal member of the engineering team at FTX, and his technical expertise was integral to the development and growth of the platform. Throughout our working relationship, I witnessed Nishad’s dedication and hard work firsthand. My observation was that he always approached his work with a high level of professionalism, focus, and commitment to quality.

Beyond his technical abilities, he consistently demonstrated kindness and consideration for others, both in and out of the workplace. He was always responsive, approachable and warm to others. He was someone his colleagues could rely on, not only for his professional contributions but also for his empathy and willingness to support those around him.

That being said, I am also now aware of the gravity of the crimes committed by certain individuals within FTX that led to its collapse, and Nishad's involvement in those activities. I do not wish to diminish the harm caused by these events. However, from my interactions with him, I believe that Nishad was never motivated by personal greed. I believe that he deeply regrets the role he played, and he has expressed sincere remorse to me for the consequences that have impacted so many people.

Thank you for your time and consideration.

Sincerely,

Can Sun
Former General Counsel, FTX