Sentencing Letters Submitted on Behalf of Nishad Singh (Exhibit A to the Sentencing Submission), part 15 of 19 (ECF pages 151 to 161)

[ECF p. 151]

Letters from College Friends

[ECF p. 152]

[Letter from Corey Zumar (College Friend)]

Corey Zumar
August 10th, 2024

Dear Judge Kaplan,

I am writing on behalf of my very close friend and former university classmate, Nishad Singh, for the purpose of detailing the immensely positive impact that Nishad has had on my life and the lives of those around him.

Nishad and I met as college freshmen on our first day of calculus class, and we shared several courses together during our first semester. While many of my peers quickly adapted to the academic rigor of UC Berkeley’s computer science department, I struggled significantly in my first several months of university. Fortunately, Nishad was an unwavering voice of encouragement and, as a study partner, was profoundly generous with his time. On multiple occasions, Nishad spent many hours helping me and several other students grasp unfamiliar concepts, such as recursive programming, that came to him quite naturally. It was very clear to me that the vast majority of Nishad’s study time was spent for the benefit of his classmates, despite a highly competitive environment with hundreds of students vying for a limited number of spots in the computer science major. Nishad always exuded an understated and humble brilliance, downplaying his impact and emphasizing the intellect and abilities of those around him. Nishad’s selfless guidance and time investment in my success were instrumental to my acceptance into the major and to my career as a software engineer today.

Beyond helping to ensure my academic success, Nishad has always been a role model for immense kindness and inclusivity. After Nishad joined UC Berkeley’s triathlon and consulting groups during his freshman year, he invited me to almost all of their social events, despite my lack of involvement in either of these activities. This gracious pattern continued through all four years of university, with Nishad routinely organizing gatherings of his diverse community of friends. Thanks to Nishad, I met several of my closest friends who I continue to cherish to this day. Nishad also demonstrated a level of commitment and empathy in his relationships that was remarkable for a 20-year-old college student. When Nishad first met his fiancee, Claire, during our junior year, I was struck by how Nishad described her foremost as a caring, compassionate person. This is emblematic of Nishad’s value system, which emphasizes good character above all else. For nearly a decade, Nishad has always displayed unwavering commitment, affection, and support for Claire. Nishad’s early demonstration of what it means to be a dedicated partner contributed significantly to the success of my relationship with my future wife, which began several months after Nishad met Claire.

After more than 11 years of friendship, Nishad remains as charitably brilliant, socially magnanimous, and deeply invested in the prosperity of others as he was the day I met him.

Nishad regularly invites me to movie nights with his extensive friend group, and he always [ECF p. 153] makes himself available for a meal or phone call. After one of the most enjoyable evenings in my recent memory, during which Nishad enthusiastically introduced me to Gödel’s incompleteness theorems before playing Qwirkle (a board game for ages 6+) with me and my wife, Nishad expressed how happy he was that I had found my soulmate and built a future with her. I am extremely grateful to have Nishad in my life, as is everyone who is fortunate enough to have met him. Thanks to Nishad, I am a more curious learner, a better partner, and a more generous friend.

Thank you for your consideration,

Corey Zumar

[ECF p. 154]

[Letter from Isabel Yang (College Friend)]

September 1, 2024

Dear Judge Kaplan,

I have had the honor of having Nishad Singh in my life for almost eleven years, since we were freshmen in college at UC Berkeley. Since then, he’s served many roles in my life, from friend, to roommate, to exercise companion, and numerous others. In our over one decade of friendship, there are some key memories I have that really show the kindness, generosity, and dedication Nishad has toward his friends and the people around him.

As college freshmen, we were lucky to find each other in a group of friends that were all studying engineering. This group of floormates became fast friends because everyone was able to not only study together, but also play boardgames and socialize together. During one particularly frustrating problem set, one of our classmates made a poorly-timed joke about how much I was struggling, which caused me to burst into tears and leave the room. Despite there being many other people around, and not being involved in the conversation, Nishad was the only one kind enough and conscientious enough to follow me out of the room and comfort me. He stayed with me to make sure I was feeling better, and apologized profusely about the situation, though it wasn’t his fault at all. It was through that experience that I first realized what a generous and caring person Nishad was, cementing our friendship.

As new college graduates, Nishad moved in with a group of us in San Francisco, including me and my partner. Despite being a recent college grad, Nishad was very passionate about the work he was doing at Alameda Research and worked long hours, leaving little time to relax. He would only be home about three nights a week, sleeping in the office for the rest. Even though his time was limited, he made sure to make it to the important things – birthday celebrations or “family dinner” with the whole house – ensuring he spent quality time with his friends. Though I didn’t realize it at the time, Nishad must have made a concerted effort to spend time with us and continue to foster our friendships. The time he put in all those years ago helped us all stay close even as folks moved to different states and countries, and helped build the foundation of our relationship today.

Eleven years later, Nishad is still one of the most kind-hearted people I’ve ever met. Every Sunday, we go on a group run together in Golden Gate Park, and he happily listens to everyone’s stories and complaints of the week, always an expert at knowing when to give advice, or just be a person to rant to. He’s the one to alert the group to slow down if he notices one person is struggling at that pace. He’s also the one to either speed up or slow down to a walk to keep anyone who’s running alone company. Nishad does these kinds of things without a second thought. It’s his nature to constantly think of and care for the people around him.

Most recently, I and some other friends paced Nishad for his 50-kilometer race this past August. Fifteen miles in, Nishad was still cracking jokes and telling stories as we ran through the night. With Nishad’s stepfather as one of the race directors, there was a large group of friends and family there to cheer him on. This was Nishad’s first ultramarathon race since high school, and [ECF p. 155] everyone was so excited to be there for him. Since the track was a 2-mile loop, we got to see Nishad come into the aid station to be greeted by his people - with his mom and his dogs always first to reach him. Despite the challenge of running 50km, Nishad had a huge smile on his face the whole time, clearly happy to be back home, doing what he loves, surrounded by the people who love him.

I am so grateful for Nishad’s friendship, and so thankful that he is such a big part of my life.

Please reach out if you have any questions, or if any additional information can be provided.

Best,

Isabel Yang
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number]

[ECF p. 156]

[Letter from Rohit Mukherjee (College Friend)]

May 23, 2024
Dear Judge Kaplan,

My name is Rohit Mukherjee - I've known Nishad since our freshman year at Berkeley together, nearly 10 years ago.

The first real message I sent to Nishad when I learned the news of FTX's financial collapse in November 2022 was this (11/16/2022, verbatim):

I'm sure you're getting flooded with messages so I don't expect a response

Whatever twitter or reddit say about you or your character, I don't give a shit. I have absolute faith in your character and ethics despite whatever monumental errors in judgment you may have made. You are a good person. Don't stop believing that for a second.

I know who you are and what you stand for and you can consider me your friend no matter what man. We are behind you.

By the time I sent that message, Nishad had shut down his online presence, so he didn't see it or respond. Knowing now what his mental state and view of himself was at the time, I find that truly regrettable. That aside, I stand by what I said then and I'd say it again now.

My first impression of Nishad was a super bright guy with a penchant for asking questions, without any trepidation over looking stupid or exhausting his interlocutor until he was satisfied that he truly understood the subject at hand. We bonded immediately over our shared interests in philosophy, physics, and the board game Avalon, which we'd play till dawn most Saturdays in our first semester.

Nishad is emblematic of "put your money where your mouth is". I have an extensive background in values debate (Lincoln Douglas), so I'm very familiar with moralistic navel gazing. The difference between people like me and Nishad is that Nishad didn't stop at moralizing - he actually made tangible, real-world and (often) inconvenient changes to his life to align with his values.

Nishad was always willing to talk through problems with extreme candor. I struggled a lot in college with my identity, feelings of intellectual inadequacy, social exclusion, and garden-variety ennui. Nishad had infinite patience in these conversations, willing to get to the true bottom of things, and was absolutely unflinching from the truth, even when it was extremely harsh for me (or him) to hear. I valued his opinion highly because I knew it was what he truly thought - albeit expressed invariably in the kindest and most empathetic terms.

I remember the phone call when I received my full-time job offer in our senior year, studying together with a few others during finals week. At the time, I didn't know whether I was going to be accepted or rejected - the recruiter had told me that she had "an update", so my friends knew I was awaiting a call. Everyone else was concentrating on some technical problem and barely noticed my absence or [ECF p. 157] return - except Nishad, who immediately asked whether that was the recruiter, and how the call went. He was almost more excited than I was upon hearing the result.

Nishad is also one of the most self-perceptive and humble people I know. We'd often have discussions over whether "true" altruism was possible, or whether we always have some subliminal, self-serving motive for charitable acts, even anonymous ones. Whether doing was actually about performing for one's own superego. Nishad would jokingly lambaste himself in these discussions. The point here is that even when he was unquestionably the best person in the room (by a country mile) at actually making the world a better place, Nishad would find a way to downplay his own actions.

In an environment when everyone was competing for clout and differentiation, Nishad never once mentioned that he set a world record for the 100-mile run at 16. I only learned of it in our junior year when I googled his name and came across his TED X talk. I remember our friend group doing extremely well, collectively, on the final exam in our Computer Science Networks class. I remember conceitedly announcing getting the 4th highest score in the class, with others in our group having taken 6th or 9th place out of a few hundred students.

Nishad, who had scored 1st, hardly said a word until we asked him directly.

Nishad and I share a tendency to put utter faith in our friends, trusting them to have intentions as good as ours, and believing in those we perceive as smarter than us to make the correct choices. I've been wrong in this (often naive) tendency, and have learned to be more doubting. I've never made a mistake as expensive as Nishad's, but they've been of the same flavor.

It's maybe this level of shared loyalty that pushed Nishad to ask me to join Alameda research in July of 2018 (FTX was not yet in existence). At the time, the engineering team was Nishad, Nishad’s boss, Gary Wang, and a few others. I was not the smartest in our friend circle, nor the best coder. I think there were two reasons he asked me over others - one was that he knew we had rock-solid mutual trust, and the other was that he thought I could be persuaded to give away 80% or more of my income, which was the cultural norm that Nishad was hoping to cement at Alameda, at least at the time.

He didn't just want someone who could code - he wanted someone who would be aligned with making a functional difference in the world, whether that meant tuberculosis vaccines or investing in green energy and AI. Over time he would tell me that he had concerns about the company experiencing “value drift” away from its charitably-minded origins, and I could see just how much it pained him.

I interviewed to be engineer #4 over the course of a few weekends, which involved waking at 5 AM, driving to Berkeley, working through 6PM, ordering vegan takeout, and driving back home to fall asleep by 10, exhausted. I got a picture of what my life could look like for the next few years.

I ultimately declined the offer. I'd like to say it was because of some penetrative foresight, a [ECF p. 158] premonition of what would happen with Alameda and FTX. But once again, it was because I didn't have the moral injunctive to do what Nishad did - to leave behind a guaranteed, safe ride to a successful and lucrative career at a FAANG company. To trade leisurely 6-hour workdays and multicolored bikes for frenetic weekend on-call shifts, years-long stints in Hong Kong, and a threadbare social life. Nishad did all of these things - without complaints, bragging, self-importance, or even much awareness - in order to make a meaningful difference by giving back. I don't doubt for one instant that this mission was the driving force behind Nishad’s insane work ethic and self-sacrifice. If he'd simply wanted to get rich, all he had to do was stay at Facebook and wait, or cash out of FTX much earlier.

A friend of mine from Berkeley recently called me to inquire about how Nishad is doing. despite only having met him a handful of times, she was adamant that he was fundamentally a good person, and not the evil mastermind or even complicit henchman behind the financial crime of decade.That's the kind of impression Nishad left, and it wasn't unwarranted.

Since FTX's shutdown, I've seen much more of Nishad than in the years before. In some ways, it's like nothing has changed - we have the same nerdy conversations about science fiction and physics. At the same time, nearly a decade has passed since we first met, and we're both very different people. Nishad's hair has grown out; he's happily engaged and a proud dad to two energetic dogs. He's as apt to talk about children and marriage as he is World of Warcraft or number theory. Despite putting so much effort into an endeavor that turned out terribly, and despite the awful anxiety of the consequences (both for those who were hurt and for himself), he's still optimistic about the world and about people. He's attended a few social events and the phrase "so nice" is ubiquitous in people's recollections of him.

Throughout the FTX saga, people have asked me all sorts of questions upon learning how close I was to being involved, and how close I was to one of the players at the center of the story. And what I concluded with, again and again, was something to the effect of: "I don't know the details, but Nishad has a heart of gold and I'd trust him with my life savings".

There aren't all that many people I would say that about.

-Rohit Mukherjee
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number]

[ECF p. 159]

[Letter from Sahil Chinoy (College Friend)]

September 7, 2024
Dear Judge Kaplan,

I met Nishad in our first week of college and was his roommate during our sophomore year at Berkeley. My best memory of Nishad comes from the following summer, when I was working in LA and drove to the Bay Area to meet with him. I was a little lost, and a little lonely – the end of a relationship and living for months alone in a new city had unmoored me.

We went for a drive and sat on a ledge in the hills, talking for hours. Nishad is a curious mix of wise beyond his years and a little naive, and the advice he offered seesawed between impossibly idealistic and serene – almost grandfatherly – support. He is one of the most patient listeners I have met, and he listened to me drone on about my new job and my barely-livable apartment without a hint that he wanted to direct the conversation to himself. I think that some who are good at listening and giving advice can sometimes be cynical or cautious, but Nishad is the opposite: he is just boundlessly optimistic, especially about people, especially about his friends. Not sure about my career choices? Give it some time, he said – you aren’t supposed to figure it out right away, and besides, any job would be lucky to have you. Feeling lonely in the big city? That’s normal, he said, but there’s a whole community back at school rooting for you. Ended your relationship? Surely they’ll come around – how could they not? He was gentle with me then, and he’s always shown that same gentle encouragement to his friends, family, and to strangers.

Nishad once told me that he wasn’t interested in traveling the world or living in a different city, and I struggled to understand that. He told me that he had everything that he needed at home in the Bay Area – friends, relationships, family, meaningful work, nature, vegan food. Why seek experiences that would surely fail to check at least one of those boxes? I couldn’t relate at all – I wanted novelty more than I wanted comfort, and I just couldn’t imagine the contentment he said he would feel from driving the same stretch of freeway every day.

I suspect he was exaggerating a bit – we were 19, after all – but I’ve reflected on what he said, and I think it does capture something important about Nishad’s personality. I think that if Nishad knew that everyone was safe and happy, and that things were going to be okay, he wouldn’t want anything else, and he would be content to drive on the I-280 back and forth from San Francisco for the rest of his life. In my decade of knowing Nishad, whatever he wanted to accomplish was always for the sake of others; he isn’t naturally a striver, or an adventurer, or someone with something to prove. He didn’t even really want to leave the state.

My visit to him in the Bahamas in April 2022 confirmed that. He was still the same thoughtful and patient listener, taking care of me and my friends – but he lacked the ease, contentment, and assurance that I had witnessed when he was in his element at Berkeley, surrounded by the people and places he loves. I just don’t think he was happy there.

Nishad recently visited me, spending more time on the train to Boston than we had time together, all because he wanted to take part in my life here for an evening. We took two walks that night: to the ice cream store, as he animatedly explained to me and my roommate a concept from theoretical computer science, and later, around the block, as he asked me about my plans for the future and gently offered his encouragement. Listening to him, I was so relieved to see that some of that old optimism and ease was back.

Please contact me at [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address] if I can provide any more information about Nishad and my relationship with him.

Sincerely,

Sahil Chinoy

[ECF p. 160]

[Letter from Roshan Varadarajan (College Friend)]

June 2024

Regarding: Nishad Singh

From: Roshan Varadarajan

Dear Judge Kaplan,

I am writing to share my personal experience that highlights the exceptional kindness and humility that I have seen from Nishad Singh over the past 10 years. In my years of knowing him, I have found him to be caring, family oriented, and community-minded. I am sure he is deeply regretful of his recent actions, and I do not believe them to be representative of his broader character.

I met Nishad in college – nearly 10 years ago – and have known him in various capacities, evolving from a ‘club mate’ in a business organization to a roommate, a travel companion, and a confidant.

I first met him in January 2014 when we joined a business club together. I was immediately impressed by how articulate, smart, and kind he was. We became close, taking many of the same classes together and spending our free time dreaming about our long-term aspirations. Nishad’s ambitions were always vast but never self-centered nor grounded in accolades; instead, they were grounded in wanting to ‘do the most-good possible’. It became clear to me in the first year of knowing him that Nishad was not very concerned about his own happiness – it was always about the people around him.

Nishad paired his genius and his aspirations with an unparalleled work ethic. I have never met someone who works harder than him. That reflected in his academic performance which oscillated almost exclusively between A’s and A+’s, even in the most difficult coursework. Despite his own success, he remained unbelievably humble and was always willing to help others. On every Computer Science project I did, I called Nishad for help. Nishad would spend hours coaching me through them. It is not an exaggeration to say he would often take just as much time helping me as he would completing his own project. One summer weekend in 2015 I called Nishad for help in preparation for an interview. The next morning, Nishad drove over to my house, and spent 15 hours over two days helping me prepare. Who else would devote their entire weekend to helping someone else prepare for an interview? And at the end of it – he would make you feel that you did him a favor by including him in the process.

In our second year of college, Nishad and I were selecting projects for our consulting club – each of us were project managers and both of us wanted to lead the same project. Without even an ounce of hesitation, Nishad decided he would give me my preference simply because “it seemed important to you [me]”. While this may seem trivial in hindsight, in the moment, it felt like a major decision since it would be our most significant professional experience up until then, also shaping how we spent most of our time that school year. And even then, Nishad didn’t hesitate to give up something he wanted if it meant helping a friend.

This desire to do good has been Nishad’s principal motivation for as long as I have known him. Even during his summer internships, he began donating money and time to causes that he felt could fulfill this mission. He was never boastful of it, and it was only in circles of his closest friends where he would open up about his thoughts on legislation for animal rights, his deepening concerns about AI safety, or how he donated nearly all of his internship proceeds to an organization buying bed nets to prevent Malaria in Africa. Whether it was [ECF p. 161] giving up material goods, something he wanted, or his time - Nishad never hesitated to give, because Nishad never cared about his own happiness as much as the happiness of those around him.

Nishad’s open heart shines the most through his love for Claire. I remember when Claire had graduated and was working in San Francisco, Nishad was juggling schoolwork, club commitments, research, and professional life. Yet he would find ways, at any hour, to make the trip over to San Francisco to see Claire. No matter how busy he was, Nishad would pick her up and drop her off (oftentimes enduring peak traffic), so she could travel comfortably back and forth. And while I don’t see a path to him becoming a Michelin star chef, Nishad would do his best to have a meal ready for her every time she visited.

While his philanthropy was admirable and his love for Claire heartwarming, it was through the mundane routines of daily life – in living together – that I have observed the principles by which Nishad lived his life and the evidence of his true character. No matter how busy he was, how tired he was, or what he wanted, Nishad never made things about himself. It is in his nature to care for those around him and his community: “I’m happy to do the grocery run again this week”, “I can definitely help you on the problem set”, “I can clean up the house if we are having people over”. Nishad has never been in pursuit of his own accolades or happiness, but always cared about maximizing the happiness of those around him.

Nishad has lived a very values- & principles-driven life with metronomic consistency over the 10 years I have known him. And I don’t believe this incident reflects his true character. There is every reason to believe that the kind, giving, and exceptionally brilliant version of Nishad will – and should—define him going forward. And it is on the basis of this exceptional character, his track record of exceptional care for his community, and all the potential future contributions he will make to our society that I ask for your leniency as you consider his sentencing.

Kind regards,

Roshan Varadarajan