Sentencing Letters Submitted on Behalf of Nishad Singh (Exhibit A to the Sentencing Submission), part 7 of 19 (ECF pages 56 to 69)

[ECF p. 56]

Letters from Teachers and Professionals

[ECF p. 57]

[Letter from Alan Waters (Accountant)]

July 18, 2024

Dear Judge Kaplan:

My name is Alan Watters. I'm a CPA specializing in tax planning for high-net-income and high-net-worth individuals and families. Based in San Francisco, I have had the opportunity to work with many successful technology start-up founders over my twenty-three years in practice. I first met Nishad over a Zoom call in 2020 during the COVID-19 pandemic. In many ways, he resembled other successful tech founders I have worked with young, smart, energetic, and idealistic. However, what immediately stood out to me about Nishad was his remarkable generosity.

Typically, founders I work with initially focus on securing their personal needs by selling enough founder stock to buy a house, an expensive car, or to have cash reserves in case of market downturns. Only after fulfilling these needs do they consider charitable planning. Nishad was different. Our discussions centered around charitable donations from the start, and I helped him make a sizable contribution to a local community foundation. Nishad has a kind heart, and his core is inherently generous.

I am writing to request leniency for Nishad. He is a very intelligent engineer who, I believe, naively fell in with the wrong crowd at a young age. Given the opportunity, I am confident Nishad can positively contribute to society.

Thank you for considering my perspective. If you have any questions, please feel free to call or email me at [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address].

Sincerely,

Alan Watters, CPA

[ECF p. 58]

[Letter from Norm Epstein (Wealth Management Advisor)]

September 6, 2024

Dear Judge Kaplan,

I am a wealth management advisor who had my first opportunity to meet with Nishad one-on-one about 7 years ago. He was just beginning his professional career. We met at the request of his dad. The purpose of our meeting was to educate him about savings and investing so that he could become financially independent. What struck me early on our conversation was his preference to help others financially almost to the detriment of his own financial well-being. Whenever I would encourage him to understand the benefits of fully funding his 401k and setting aside more money for taxable investing, he would counter with how it was more important to give away that same money. His only motive was to benefit others. Enriching himself was not his goal nor desire.

This same desire to benefit others was made clear in a subsequent email that he sent me in October ’21. He wanted to set up a call to learn about how he can give away his wealth and Donor Advised Funds (DAF). His objective was stated as follows…”In the end, I want to donate ~all of what I have; I don’t care too much about the distinction between 95, 99, 99.5%, etc, but definitely don’t want the suggested approaches to assume I mean only 50%.”

He stated that he wasn’t seeking the limelight or public praise. The ability to give anonymously through a DAF was therefore a feature to him. He only wanted to talk about giving and went as far to state the following in that email in advance of the call:

“Topics I don’t want to discuss:

Preserving long-term wealth

Making sure enough is set aside for relevant milestones in my life

Remaining hedged against bad outcomes for crypto/etc / having a balanced portfolio.

Most of all, I want to communicate that I don’t care about wealth management in the standard sense.”

I hope these insights give you a solid view into Nishad’s heart.

Sincerely,

Norman A. Epstein

[REDACTED]

Hillsborough, CA 94010

[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number]

[ECF p. 59]

[Letter from FTX MDL Plaintiffs (Counsel for FTX MDL Plaintiffs)]

October 14, 2024

Honorable Lewis A. Kaplan
United States District Judge
Daniel Patrick Moynihan
United States Courthouse
500 Pearl Street
New York, NY 10007-1312

Re: United States v. Samuel Bankman Fried, Nishad Singh

Dear Judge Kaplan,

We represent the putative class of FTX customers who filed suit against FTX Insiders, including Ms. Caroline Ellison, Mr. Gary Wang, and Mr. Nishad Singh, as well as the venture capital firms, law firms, accounting firms, banks, and other third parties alleged to have aided and abetted the FTX fraud in In re FTX Cryptocurrency Exchange Collapse Litigation, 1:23-md-03076, a multidistrict litigation pending in the Southern District of Florida (the “MDL”).

Mr. Singh has provided valuable assistance to the MDL Plaintiffs, and we write to inform you of his cooperation. To date, he has met with MDL Counsel for several hours, and has agreed to as many as ten additional meetings with MDL Counsel, to answer questions and to provide information helpful to MDL Plaintiffs’ cases against alleged third-party aider-abettors. In those meetings, Mr. Singh has expressed sincere remorse for the role that he played in the FTX fraud and for the harm that he may have inflicted on MDL Plaintiffs.

The information that Mr. Singh has provided to MDL Counsel thus far has proven very helpful to MDL Plaintiffs’ cases, in that the information not only substantiates, and supplements, the allegations set forth in MDL Plaintiffs’ complaints, but also should assist in defeating certain MDL Defendants’ jurisdictional defenses. For example, Mr. Singh shared with MDL Plaintiffs testimony supporting MDL Plaintiffs’ allegations that the FTX fraud emanated from Florida, including that:

• Several members of FTX’s payments team were based in the greater Miami area.

• After FTX US acquired Miami-based Blockfolio in mid- to late-2020, many of FTX’s publicity campaigns, including its many celebrity partnerships, generated from Miami.

• Later, in mid- to late-2021, FTX acquired Ledger X, which was also based in Miami, offered advantages such as licenses and technology that allowed FTX US to engage in futures trading, which, in turn, would have made the investment in FTX more attractive to investors.

[ECF p. 60]

MDL Counsel hopes that this Court will consider Mr. Singh’s expressed remorse and significant assistance to MDL Plaintiffs in rendering his sentence.

Respectfully submitted,

By: /s/ Adam Moskowitz
Adam M. Moskowitz
Florida Bar No. 984280
Joseph M. Kaye
Florida Bar No. 117520
THE MOSKOWITZ LAW FIRM, PLLC
Continental Plaza
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: street address]
Coconut Grove, FL 33133
Office: [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number]
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]
MDL Co-Lead Counsel

By: /s/ David Boies
David Boies
Alex Boies
Brooke Alexander
BOIES SCHILLER FLEXNER LLP
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: street address]
Armonk, NY 10504
Office: [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number]
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: email address]
MDL Co-Lead Counsel

[ECF p. 61]

[Letter from Katie DeVaul (Psychiatrist)]

KATHERINE DEVAUL, M.D.
CHILD, ADOLESCENT, AND ADULT PSYCHIATRY
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: street address]
LOS ALTOS, CA 94022
TELEPHONE: [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number] FAX: [WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: fax number]

July 13th, 2024

Judge Kaplan,

I am submitting a character reference for Nishad Singh. [REDACTED]

[REDACTED]

[ECF p. 62]

[REDACTED]

[ECF p. 63]

[REDACTED]

[ECF p. 64]

[REDACTED]

Sincerely,

Dr. Katherine DeVaul
Private Practice
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: street address]
Los Altos CA 94022

[ECF p. 65]

[Letter from Jeff Nichols (Teacher)]

August 28, 2024

Dear Judge Kaplan,

I am writing this letter on behalf of Nishad Singh who stands before you for sentencing. The German poet Johannes Von Goethe once wrote, “You can easily judge the character of a man by how he treats those who can do nothing for him.” Based on Goethe’s assessment, Nishad Singh’s character is beyond reproach.

I first met Nishad as a brilliant, compassionate, and empathetic 11-year-old student in my 6th-grade Humanities class. Among his peers, Nishad always stood out with his measured comments during class discussions, and accommodating nature during projects and field trips. It is not hyperbole to say that Nishad is one of the nicest people on the planet. To know him, you immediately recognize that he radiates goodness and compassion in a world where many of us are battling not to succumb to the bleakness and cynicism that surround us daily. In short, Nishad cares deeply about animals, and those less fortunate than himself. Nishad has from a young age recognized his privilege and to try to help those less fortunate than himself. As an 8th grader, Nishad was on a field trip with his class in San Francisco when he encountered an unhoused individual., In a moment he likely thought nobody noticed, he hung behind the class and gave the individual his lunch money for that day. This act is representative of Nishad’s generous nature and true character.

We lost touch during his high school years and when he was an undergraduate student at U C Berkeley. Luckily, Facebook allowed us to reconnect around the time he got his first job, ironically working as an Engineer at Facebook. At this time, I had asked Nishad to present to my class during our Computer Science week. Unfortunately, he was not able to do the presentation because he did not want to let down his team. Not surprisingly, this is another example of Nishad putting the needs of others above his own. After several conversations with Nishad who had metamorphosed into an accomplished adult, we were forced to switch our modes of communication to WhatsApp once he became an expat in Hong Kong. During WhatsApp phone conversations, I felt an enormous amount of warmth and curiosity from him, as he asked about my experiences teaching and humanitarian trips to Rwanda. He had retained all the intellectual humility he showed in his early years.

Nishad always sees the good in mankind. During the eighteen years I have known Nishad, I have never heard him say anything dismissive, insulting, rude, or condescending to or about anyone. Nishad is bright, and to his credit, he does not use his intellect as a weapon against the vulnerable in society. I am honored and proud to say that in my 31 years of teaching at independent schools, Nishad is one of the very few students who have welcomed me into their lives as adults. This is a privilege that I do not take for granted. I humbly request that you provide Nishad with as much leniency and compassion as possible. Regardless of his ultimate fate, I feel proud to call him a former student, mentee, and friend.

[ECF p. 66]

Sincerely,

Jeffrey Nichols
7th-grade Global Perspectives Teacher
Latin School of Chicago

[ECF p. 67]

[Letter from Simon Olavarria (Teacher)]

Character Letter for Nishad Singh from Simon Olavarria

Dear Judge Kaplan,

I’ve known Nishad since he was 12 years old. From his middle school years until his high school graduation, I was Nishad’s teacher in ethics, debate, international relations, and current events. I also had the opportunity to hire Nishad as an intern for our summer debate programs. Additionally, I have known Nishad as an adult.

Nishad has always been characterized by his kindness, hard work, and concern for the common good. For our end-of-year culmination event in 2013, Nishad was chosen to deliver a speech on a topic of his choosing to our students and parents. I distinctly remember how Nishad chose to elaborate on a metric seldom used in international relations: the Gross National Happiness index developed by the nation of Bhutan. Throughout the development, practice, and delivery of his speech, I was reaffirmed in something I already knew about Nishad: that he cared deeply about the common good and that he would likely devote his life to it. His speech selection was not a random choice; it was an expression of the life he lived and the heart he was endowed with.

Unsurprisingly, Nishad fostered his vocation toward the common good throughout his college years and into his professional life, becoming a well-known exponent of Effective Altruism. For those who met him later, this might have seemed like the idealism fashionable among many young people in technology; for those who knew him since he was a pre-teen, it was clear that this was a continuation of who Nishad always was.

I have also had the opportunity to witness how Nishad treats people. As an older brother to Malhar (also a student of mine), Nishad was kind, generous, and a wise mentor. He was a responsible and caring son to his parents, Anu and Raj. As a high school teacher-intern, he was responsible, patient, enthusiastic about people’s progress, and the kind of guide who does not lose hope in others. He has also been a faithful friend to those close to him, and an example of achievement and social glue for his extended peers. Finally, his determination to achieve something great for others is inspiring, such as when he ran ultramarathons to benefit causes.

In the near decade and a half that I have known Nishad, I have nothing but good things to say about his character, and I hold high hopes for his future.

With love for Nishad,

Simon Olavarria

September 8, 2024

[ECF p. 68]

[Letter from Gerlicelda Rudas Benag (Former Cleaner and Dogsitter)]

Good Day Judge Lewis Kaplan,

I am writing this letter on behalf of my former employer Nishad Thirumale Singh. This gentleman I work for him and his family as family house cleaner and to take care of his gentle giant dog name Gopher in the year of 2021 and 2022 in Hong Kong.

I move away from my family in Philippines to Hong Kong for work 11 year ago. I work for 3 other employer before Nishad Thirumale Singh and his family.

When Nishad Thirumale Singh left for Bahamas, I felt heartbroken I lost my very good employer who treat me like family. He very kind very generous and have a good heart. Also very hardworking man who work long hours but still have time to say hi! and ask if im ok?

Nishad Thirumale Singh is the best of all the employers I work for in Hong Kong. After he move he even have time to message and update me about gopher. He promise me that he always keep in touch with me. After his busy day he still have time to do his promise. That I never experience with any employer I ever had. Nishad is very good with all of the positive characteristic as human he have.

I ask if there was anything I do to help. I hope this short letter will help to know him and that he is a good person. I see Nishad heart and always pray for him. I pray for you too Judge Lewis Kaplan.

Regards,
Gerlicelda Rudas Benag
JULY 7 2024

[ECF p. 69]

[Letter from Charles Dunford (Physical Trainer)]

Dear Judge Kaplan,

My name is Charles Dunford and formerly a personal trainer to Nishad during the time that he worked in Hong Kong. I came to know Nishad during the early days of Covid 2020 when I started to provide personal training services to him, on average I would see him one on one for around 3 hours per week.

Nishad and I became friends and he in particular was fundamental in helping me build a client base to get me through the difficult covid experience that the Hong Kong Government had created for the fitness industry. This was more than kindness on his part; it was a concrete effort to introduce his friends and coworkers to me.

Nishad had shown a genuine interest in me and why I was still working at an age when most men would have retired. I formerly was a private banker, but after that I went into business with a friend and ended up in debt. He could have looked down on me but he did the opposite and I am very grateful for the friendship and support he gave.

As you consider Nishad's situation, I hope you will consider the aspect of his character that I have personally experienced.

Thank you for considering my testimony on Nishad's behalf. I am sure that he will continue to make a positive contribution to society, and I am honoured to stand by him.

Yours respectfully,
Charles Dunford
[WITHHELD BY THIS SITE: telephone number]

6 MAY 2024